florida council of public/private partnerships lee a. weintraub, esq. becker & poliakoff, p.a....
TRANSCRIPT
FLORIDA COUNCIL OF FLORIDA COUNCIL OF PUBLIC/PRIVATE PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPSPARTNERSHIPS
Lee A. Weintraub, Esq.Lee A. Weintraub, Esq.Becker & Poliakoff, P.A.Becker & Poliakoff, P.A.
3111 Stirling Road3111 Stirling RoadFt. Lauderdale, FL 33311Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33311
954-985-4147954-985-4147lweintraub@[email protected]
Section 287.05712 applies to any facility Section 287.05712 applies to any facility or project serving a public purposeor project serving a public purpose
It applies to counties, municipalities, It applies to counties, municipalities, school boards, any other political sub-school boards, any other political sub-division of the state, and any public body, division of the state, and any public body, corporate and politiccorporate and politic
Establishes the Partnership for Public Facilities and Infrastructure Establishes the Partnership for Public Facilities and Infrastructure Act Guidelines Task ForceAct Guidelines Task Force
Task force will recommend guidelines for the legislature to consider to Task force will recommend guidelines for the legislature to consider to create a uniform process for establishing P3’screate a uniform process for establishing P3’s
Including factors public entities should consider when processing Including factors public entities should consider when processing requests requests
Task force will begin meeting by August 31, 2013 to establish Task force will begin meeting by August 31, 2013 to establish procedures for the conduct of its businessprocedures for the conduct of its business
No more than two task force meetings may be held for the purpose No more than two task force meetings may be held for the purpose of taking public testimonyof taking public testimony
Task force must submit final recommendations to governor and Task force must submit final recommendations to governor and legislature by July 1, 2014legislature by July 1, 2014
Local Government GuidelinesLocal Government Guidelines
Formal establishment or adoption of Formal establishment or adoption of guidelines by public entity is not required guidelines by public entity is not required for entity to request or receive P3 for entity to request or receive P3 proposalsproposals
Public entity may adopt its own guidelines Public entity may adopt its own guidelines provided they are consistent with this statuteprovided they are consistent with this statute
Procurement ProceduresProcurement Procedures
Public entity may receive unsolicited proposals Public entity may receive unsolicited proposals or may solicit proposals through traditional or may solicit proposals through traditional procurement methodsprocurement methods
Public entity may establish a reasonable Public entity may establish a reasonable application fee for unsolicited proposalsapplication fee for unsolicited proposals Fee must be sufficient to pay costs of evaluating the Fee must be sufficient to pay costs of evaluating the
proposalproposal Public entity may hire private consultants to assist in Public entity may hire private consultants to assist in
the evaluation, paid for by private entity the evaluation, paid for by private entity
Procurement ProceduresProcurement Procedures
If the public entity intends to enter into a If the public entity intends to enter into a comprehensive agreement, it must publish comprehensive agreement, it must publish notice in the Florida Administrative notice in the Florida Administrative Register and newspaper of general Register and newspaper of general circulation at least once a week for two circulation at least once a week for two weeksweeks
Procurement ProceduresProcurement Procedures Notice must provide that the public entity has received Notice must provide that the public entity has received
a proposal and will accept other proposals for the a proposal and will accept other proposals for the same projectsame project
Time frame for accepting other proposals shall be Time frame for accepting other proposals shall be determined by public entity on project by project basisdetermined by public entity on project by project basis
Based upon complexity of the project and the public benefit Based upon complexity of the project and the public benefit to be gained by allowing a longer or shorter period of time for to be gained by allowing a longer or shorter period of time for competing proposalscompeting proposalsTime frame must be at least 21 days, but no more than 120 Time frame must be at least 21 days, but no more than 120 days, after initial date of publicationdays, after initial date of publication
Copy of the notice must be mailed to each local Copy of the notice must be mailed to each local government in affected areagovernment in affected area
Procurement ProceduresProcurement Procedures
Public entity is authorized to approve project Public entity is authorized to approve project if:if:
Project is in public’s best interestProject is in public’s best interest Facility is owned by public entity or ownership will be conveyed Facility is owned by public entity or ownership will be conveyed
to public entityto public entity Adequate safeguards in place to ensure additional costs or Adequate safeguards in place to ensure additional costs or
service disruptions are not imposed on public if material default service disruptions are not imposed on public if material default or cancellation of agreementor cancellation of agreement
Adequate safeguards in place to ensure capacity may be added Adequate safeguards in place to ensure capacity may be added if desired if desired
Estimated cost is reasonable in relation to similar facilitiesEstimated cost is reasonable in relation to similar facilities
Project Approval RequirementsProject Approval Requirements
Unsolicited proposal must be accompanied by Unsolicited proposal must be accompanied by following items, unless waived by public entity:following items, unless waived by public entity: Conceptual design of facility and schedule for Conceptual design of facility and schedule for
constructionconstruction Description of method by which private entity Description of method by which private entity
proposes to secure necessary property interestsproposes to secure necessary property interests Description of private entity’s general plans for Description of private entity’s general plans for
financing projectfinancing projectIncludes sources of private entity’s funds and identity of any Includes sources of private entity’s funds and identity of any dedicated revenue source or proposed debt or equity dedicated revenue source or proposed debt or equity investment on behalf of private entityinvestment on behalf of private entity
CONTENTS OF UNSOLICITED CONTENTS OF UNSOLICITED PROPOSAL (CON’T)PROPOSAL (CON’T)
Proposed user fees, lease payments or other Proposed user fees, lease payments or other service payments over term of agreementservice payments over term of agreement
Including methodology for and circumstances that Including methodology for and circumstances that would allow changes to user fees would allow changes to user fees
Project Qualification and ProcessProject Qualification and Process
After competitive bidding period has expired, public entity After competitive bidding period has expired, public entity ranks proposals received in order of preferenceranks proposals received in order of preference Public entity may consider professional qualifications, general Public entity may consider professional qualifications, general
business terms, innovative design techniques, cost reduction business terms, innovative design techniques, cost reduction terms, and finance plansterms, and finance plans
Public entity may then begin negotiating with highest Public entity may then begin negotiating with highest ranked firmranked firm If pubic entity is not satisfied with results of negotiations, public If pubic entity is not satisfied with results of negotiations, public
entity may terminate negotiations and begin negotiating with entity may terminate negotiations and begin negotiating with second ranked firmsecond ranked firm
Public entity may reject all proposals at any point in processPublic entity may reject all proposals at any point in process
Notice to Affected Local Notice to Affected Local JurisdictionsJurisdictions
Public entity must furnish copy of proposal to Public entity must furnish copy of proposal to each affected local jurisdictioneach affected local jurisdictionEach affected local jurisdiction has 60 days from Each affected local jurisdiction has 60 days from receipt of notice to submit written comments receipt of notice to submit written comments indicating whether proposed facility is indicating whether proposed facility is incompatible with local jurisdiction’s plansincompatible with local jurisdiction’s plansIf affected local jurisdiction fails to respond within If affected local jurisdiction fails to respond within 60 days, non-response is deemed 60 days, non-response is deemed acknowledgement that project is compatibleacknowledgement that project is compatible
Interim AgreementInterim Agreement
May be entered into before or in connection with May be entered into before or in connection with negotiation for comprehensive agreementnegotiation for comprehensive agreement
Interim agreement does not obligate public entity Interim agreement does not obligate public entity to enter into comprehensive agreementto enter into comprehensive agreement
Interim agreement is discretionaryInterim agreement is discretionaryParties may proceed directly to comprehensive agreementParties may proceed directly to comprehensive agreement
Interim AgreementInterim Agreement
Interim Agreement must be limited to provisions Interim Agreement must be limited to provisions that authorize private entity to commence that authorize private entity to commence activities for which it may be compensated activities for which it may be compensated related to the projectrelated to the project
Including project planning and development, design, Including project planning and development, design, environmental analysis & mitigation, survey, ascertaining environmental analysis & mitigation, survey, ascertaining availability of financingavailability of financing
Establish process & timing for negotiation of comprehensive Establish process & timing for negotiation of comprehensive agreementagreement
Such other provisions the parties deem appropriateSuch other provisions the parties deem appropriate
Comprehensive AgreementComprehensive Agreement
MustMust provide for: provide for: Payment and performance bonds Payment and performance bonds Public entity’s review and approval of project designPublic entity’s review and approval of project design
Does not require private entity to complete the design before Does not require private entity to complete the design before executing comprehensive agreementexecuting comprehensive agreement
Public entity’s inspection of construction activitiesPublic entity’s inspection of construction activities Public liability insurance requirementsPublic liability insurance requirements Public entity’s monitoring of maintenance practices by Public entity’s monitoring of maintenance practices by
private entityprivate entity
Comprehensive AgreementComprehensive Agreement Periodic financial reporting by private entity pertaining Periodic financial reporting by private entity pertaining
to projectto project Fees, lease payments, or service paymentsFees, lease payments, or service payments Rights and responsibilities of parties during course of Rights and responsibilities of parties during course of
construction and operationsconstruction and operationsIncluding provisions for termination of agreement & rights Including provisions for termination of agreement & rights and responsibilities upon default by private entityand responsibilities upon default by private entity
– Must provide for circumstances whereby defaulting private Must provide for circumstances whereby defaulting private entity’s responsibilities and interests may be assumed by either entity’s responsibilities and interests may be assumed by either entity participating in funding of project or public entityentity participating in funding of project or public entity
Comprehensive AgreementComprehensive Agreement
MayMay include: include: Agreement by public entity to make grants or Agreement by public entity to make grants or
loans to private entity from amounts received loans to private entity from amounts received from federal, state or local government or from federal, state or local government or agenciesagencies
Notice of default and right to cure provisionsNotice of default and right to cure provisions
Comprehensive AgreementComprehensive Agreement
Private entity will receive revenues from Private entity will receive revenues from fee-generating uses of facility over life of fee-generating uses of facility over life of agreementagreement Pre-negotiated portion of same must be Pre-negotiated portion of same must be
returned to public entityreturned to public entity
FinancingFinancing
Private entity may enter into private source Private entity may enter into private source financing agreement with financing sourcesfinancing agreement with financing sources Financing agreement obligations and liens on Financing agreement obligations and liens on
property must be paid in full before transfer of property must be paid in full before transfer of ownership or operation of facility to public entityownership or operation of facility to public entity
Public entity may provide its own capital or Public entity may provide its own capital or operating budget to support projectoperating budget to support project Financing agreement may not require public entity to Financing agreement may not require public entity to
indemnify financing source, subject public entity’s indemnify financing source, subject public entity’s facility to liens, or pledge security interestfacility to liens, or pledge security interest
Any such provision in financing agreement is void as matter Any such provision in financing agreement is void as matter of lawof law
FinancingFinancing
Public entity shall appropriate contractual Public entity shall appropriate contractual payment obligation, if required by payment obligation, if required by comprehensive agreement, on priority comprehensive agreement, on priority basisbasis Payment obligation must be appropriated Payment obligation must be appropriated
before other non-contractual obligations before other non-contractual obligations payable from same enterprise or government payable from same enterprise or government fundfund
Expiration or Termination of Expiration or Termination of AgreementsAgreements
If private entity materially defaults, compensation If private entity materially defaults, compensation otherwise due to private entity would be payable otherwise due to private entity would be payable to investors & lenders on job as provided in any to investors & lenders on job as provided in any operative agreementoperative agreement Provided costs of operating and maintaining facility Provided costs of operating and maintaining facility
are paid in the normal courseare paid in the normal course Public entity’s assumption of development or Public entity’s assumption of development or
operation of project does not obligate it to pay any operation of project does not obligate it to pay any obligation of private entity from sources other than obligation of private entity from sources other than revenues from the project unless stated otherwise in revenues from the project unless stated otherwise in comprehensive agreementcomprehensive agreement
Sovereign immunity is not waivedSovereign immunity is not waived
This act shall take effect July 1, 2013This act shall take effect July 1, 2013