final shilpabank-farhad[1].doc
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
1/98
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
2/98
1.1 Background of the Study:
Industries play a pivotal role in the economic development of every country. This is
why industrialization has been adopted as a vital instrument of economic developmentin many developing countries. Realizing this, Govt. of Bangladesh has a evelopment
!inancing Institution "!I# named Bangladesh $hilpa Ban% "B$B# on &1st ecember
1'() under the president *rder +o. 1)' of1'() with a mission of accelerating the
process of industrialization of the country by providing financial assistance and
equity support.”
1.2 Probe! State!ent:
!or a developing country li%e Bangladesh a huge amount of capital investment is very
much needed both in private and public sectors. In order to get ma-imum benefits
from such capital investment the proect appraisal is very important. /ny error in
appraisal will have an adverse impact on capital structure of the country.
0roect appraisal means the e-amination of proect before the proect is underta%en. It
refers to the evaluation of proects and selection between alternatives. 0roect
appraisal report is prepared by oan *peration epartment. The proect has been
appraised by an appraisal team consisting of engineer, economist and financial
analyst. This report critically evaluates the proposed proect through technical
analysis, economic analysis and financial evaluation. 2hen the proect is found to be
technically feasible, financially rewarding and economically 3 commercially viable
only then that proect is financed by B$B. This study will ma%e an attempt to the
proect /ppraisal 0ractice of B$B "a case study of 45$ 6TT/6 0/$TI7 T.#.
1." Ob#ect$%e& to the Study
This report e-amines the proect appraisal procedure of B$B. To do this it e-amines
how B$B appraises proect what information it deeds from the entrepreneur 3 what
aspects of a proect need to scrutinize 3 evaluate of its particular proect 45$ 6ttade
0lastic imited 3 $olaiman Te-tile 4ills imited.
)
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
3/98
The obectives are summarized as follows8
To get an overall idea about the e-isting proects appraisal procedure9
6valuate the particular proect regarding the appraisal9
To determine the limitations or problems "if any# of the proect appraisal9
To recommend necessary steps to over come such limitations.
1.' Sco(e of the Study:
This report will mainly focus on the proect appraisal of Bangladesh $hilpa Ban%. The
proposed study will cover the appraisal practice, procedures and techni:ue followed
by the oan *peration department "*# in the preparation of appraisal report.
4oreover the evaluation of its procedure to a particular proect named 45$ 6TT/6
0/$TI7 I4IT6.
1.) *ethodoogy of the Study:
7orrect and smooth completion of research wor% re:uires adherence to some rules
and methodologies. Rules were followed to ease the data collection procedure.
/ccuracy of study depends on the information and data analysis.
1.).1 STUD+ ,R-,:
The area of my study has been encompassed the operation area of Bangladesh $hilpa
Ban% ;ead office and the ha%a 7ommercial Branch of $hilpa Ban%.
1.).2 T,R-T ROUP
To accumulate the re:uired data I have contacted with each departmental head along
with other concerned e-ecutive of Bangladesh $hilpa Ban%. In case of industry
diagnosis I have got in close with the responsible personnel of 0roect Implementation
epartment of B$B to collect the information.
1.)." T+P-S O/ R-S-,RC0
In this study the descriptive type of research has underta%en to gain insights and
understanding about overall operation of B$B and the sic% industry.
&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
4/98
1.).' SOURC- O/ IN/OR*,TION.
The data will be collect from both primary and secondary sources.
Source& of Pr$!ary Data
The sources of primary data are8
!ace to face interview.
*fficial records 3 documents of B$B.
7ommunication with other respective personnel of B$B.
6-pert opinion.
Secondary &ource&
The sources of secondary data are8
/nnual report 3 appraisal manual of B$B
0roect appraisal report of 45$ 6ttade 0lastic imited 3 $olaiman Te-tile 4ills
imited
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
5/98
0ractical performance in the formal stages become difficult. $o in performing this
report our lac% of proper %nowledge greatly influenced in this performance.
Besides above, have to face some other limitations are8
1. ac% of availability of data
). 4any personnel of B$B were reluctant to provide useful information.
&. Improper combination among various departments
>. They are in government employee so have no eagerness to supply more because
of e-tra hardness.
?. @pAtoAdate information were not available
. $ufficient records, publications, facts and figures are not available. These
constraints narrowed the scope of the real analysis.
(. !or the reason of confidentiality, some useful information cannot be e-pressed
in this report.
C. Time is a limitation that would mostly with stands a comprehensive study on the
topic selected.
'. !inally this is my first ob 6-perience. $o my %nowledge especially in such a
research study is limited.
?
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
6/98
CHAPTER TWO
4IT-R,TUR- R-5I-6
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
7/98
4IT-R,TUR- R-5I-6
/ proect is a proposal for an investment to create, e-pand and5or develops certain
facilities in order to increase the productions of goods and5or services in a community
during a certain period of time. !or the purpose of B$B, proect means a scheme for
capital investment to develop facilities to provide goods and services. B$BDs main
function is to e-tend financial assistance to industrial proect. It basically needs to be
satisfied about the overall viability of a proect to be financed. !or this purpose, an
obective assessment of the viability of the proect is re:uired to be e-amined by B$B
from various points of view. 0roect appraisal coyer five different aspects of a
proect8 4anagement and *rganization, Technical, 4ar%et, 6conomic, and !inancial.
/n assessment of the promoters in respect of their integrity, e-perience and
capabi1ities to implement and run the proect is of prime importance before e-tending
credit facilities to them. There are no set rules to find out if the borrowers or
promoters are the men of integrity. It is to be done by direct and indirect investigation.
The borrowerDs e-perience .and capabilities can, on the other hand, be assessed in
terms of his educational bac%ground, spatial :ualifications, practical business
e-perience, receptiveness to new ideas, or good advice, the general reputation and
above all his potentiality to learn new things and adaptability to new and changing
situation.
7losely related to the management is the type of organizational structure necessary to
carry out and operate the proect successfully. $o far as organization is concerned,
there are two basic :ueries9 hat organization is needed to bring the proect to the
operating stage and what organization will be needed thereafter. In the operating
phase, one of the most common :uestions is the e-tent to which responsibility and
(
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
8/98
authority should be centralized or delegated. The answer depends on the scale of
operation, its geographical dispersion, the degree of specialization of personnel, and
the number of persons to whom responsibility can be delegated. Internal controls
should also be reviewed.
The technical aspects of in industrial proect are appraised to determine whether the
proect is sound with regard to every engineering and technological consideration,
including product specification, process, size, internal balance, suitability and
availability of physical facilities, designs and layouts of e:uipment and buildings etc.
In a developing country li%e Bangladesh, where there is hardly and indigenous
technological base to support the industrialization process the industr1al underta%ings
have to be conceived on the basis of %now or borrowed technology until such time as
the development of local technology is sufficient. The basic aspects to be analyzed in
the course of technical appraisal are E 0roducts5 $ervice9 Raw materials9 $%ills and
technology re:uired for manufacture5 service9 Testing and analytical report9 abor9
Transporting9 2or% $chedule9 6stimation and evaluation of cost. The relative
importance of these aspects will, however, vary from proect to proect.
/n industrial proect is to bring in some goods Dor services for a community. But the
community does not need them infinitely. Their demand is of course finite and at
given prices. !or appropriate mar%eting obective, it is necessary to loo% at depth into
the A macro5micro demand5 supply situation for specific products in the mar%et9
6-isting and e-pected competition in local and foreign mar%ets9 the mar%et share, etc.2hile appraising industrial proects, the Ban% is re:uired to analyze these factors and
to bring out the obective in :uantitative termsA0roduct identification9 +ature of
emand9 Type of emand8 there are various types of demand for the product5service in
:uestion. These are direct, derived, new, replacement demand, $ize and 7omposition of
the 0resent emand etc.
C
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
9/98
In economic appraisal, the proect is loo%ed at from the national or social point of
view and the economic cash flow is constructed on the basis of Ftrue or real pricesF,
commonly %nown as accounting or shadow prices. 6conomic appraisal should cover
both :uantifiable and nonA:uantifiable benefits "where applicable#. $uch benefits are
6conomic Rate of Return "6RR#, Bruno Ration omestic Resource 7ost,
7ontribution of Gross omestic 0roduct, and 6mployment Generation and 7ost per
employment. The term nonA:uantifiable refers both "1# to effects that are %nown to
arise but which cannot be measured in physical terms and ")# to effects, which cannot
be valued. ifficulties in :uantification and valuation will often go together.
Huantification problems often are data problem a certain effect could not be
measured, but has not been.
The main purpose of financial appraisal is to assess if the proposed proect is viable in
term of its operation in the future years and its financial soundness. The financial
analyst should have a clear idea as to what is intended to be achieved through the
financial appraisal. The financial appraisal is directed to e-amine mainly the
following two aspects8 !und re:uirement to bring the proect in to e-istence and the
probable sources from which the re:uired funds will be mobilized9 and 0rospects of
ade:uate revenue generation by the proect when it goes into operation and the li%ely
position of the concern with regard to its actual cash generation "li:uidity# and its
probable impact upon the financial condition "solvency# The first aspect deals with
the estimation of total of the proect "fi-ed cost net wor%ing capital# and a suitable
financial arrangement "debtAe:uity relation#. The second aspect relates to the analysis
of productionAcost profit at different volume of production carried up to the year the
proect attains its normal capacity operation.
$ources of Information8
Bangladesh $hilpa ban%, )JJ& annual report )JJ)A)JJ&8 )A1C.
Bangladesh $hilpa ban% august 1'C>.manual of, proect appraisal
'
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
10/98
0roect 4anagementAThe managerial process
A7lifford !. Gray
A6ri% 2. arson
CHAPTER THREE
O5-R5I-6 O/ B,N4,D-S0
S0I4P, B,N7
1J
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
11/98
".1 Introduct$on
Bangladesh $hilpa Ban% "B$B#, once a leading developed financing institutional
"!I# established in 1'() with a mission of accelerating the process of
industrialization of the country by providing financial assistance and e:uity support.
/fter getting liberation a newly born country re:uired rapid financial assistance and
advisory services to industrialize the nation and B$B supposed to bolster in thisregard. It has been e-tending long and medium term loan facilities in local and
foreign currencies to industrialize proects "both new and B4R6# in the private and
public sectors. 2ith the passage of time due to mismanagement of loan distribution
and ill motive of borrower left he sector derelict.
".2 In&t$tut$ona o%er%$e8 of BSB
-&tab$&hed October "19 132
*rganization ;ead office ha%a
ivision ?
epartment )1
Konal *ffice &
Branch *ffice 1?
0ersonnel C?
"." Ca($ta &tructure and &ource& of fund
/uthorized capital 8 T% )JJJmillion
0aid up capital 8 T%1&)J million
*ther sources of ban%Ds fund are the government, Bangladesh Ban%, 7ommercialBan%, ocal5*verseas financial institutional and suppliersD credit.
11
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
12/98
O8ner&h$( of BSB
/t least ?1 percent of the /uthorized capital of B$B be subscribed by Bangladesh
government and remaining >' percent be subscribed by Bangladesh nationals or by
financial institutions local or foreign. 0resently, 1JJ percent ownership of the Ban%
belongs to the government.
".' *$&&$on
/ccelerating the process of industrialization of the country by providing financial
assistance and e:uity support.
".) *anage!ent
The overall policy formulation and the general direction of Ban%s operation vest on a
board of directors appointed by the government. The board of irectors consists of
nine "'# members including the chairman and the 4anaging director. +on government
shareholder subscribing to the capital of the Ban% shall eventually elect four ">#
irectors from amongst themselves. The 4anaging irector is the chief conducting
the overall Ban%ing business.
". /unct$on of BSB
B$B e-tends long and medium term loan facilities in local and foreign currencies to
industrial proects "both new and B4R6# in the private and public sectors Besides the
Ban% also performs the following activities.
0rovide wor%ing capital loans to industrial proect. /ssist in the form of underwriting
and bridge finance to public limited companies as e:uity support. Issues guarantees
for repayment of loan on behalf of borrowers, 6-tends commercial Ban%ing services
along with deposit mobilization. 0urchases and sells shares 5 securities for B$B and
on behalf of customers as a member of ha%a $toc% 6-change "$6# td. and
1)
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
13/98
7itation $toc% 6-change "7$6# td. for capital mar%et development and 7onduct
proect promotional activities with preparation of various subAsect oral study reports.
1&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
14/98
1>
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
15/98
".3 O(erat$ona ,ct$%$t$e& of the Bank
Bangladesh $hilpa Ban% being the prime development financing institutional
continued its effort to ma%e on effective contribution towards e-pansion of
industrialization process of the country. It emphasized on long term lending to theviable new proects having comparative advantages, e-port prospects, forward and
bac%ward lin%age and local technology as well as raw materials based proects. Top
priority has been given for realization of its loans towards augmenting and recycling
of the invertible funds and maintaining satisfactory loan portfolio for increasing
profitability. 2ith this end in view the Ban% has underta%en some realistic steps
towards replacement. Rescheduling and li:uidating of loan accounts of sic% 5 closed 5
stuc%Aup proects with waiver facilities where deemed appropriate.
".; Strength of BSB
B$ is a development finance institution. It plays significant role in the industrial
development of Bangladesh. Its untiring endeavor is remar%able. As a finance
institution it has both strength and wea%ness. /ll the contribution of B$B is the
conse:uences due to its strength. *n the other hand failure ness of B$B is for
unconsciousness and unauthorized e-ercise of power. It is indeed that the
contribution of B$B is below the e-pectation. It fails to achieve the target because
a great portion of loss is compensated against its contribution. 4any e-perts tell
B$B fails to use his resources successfully as a result it is a loosing concern. It is
true but some e-ternal interfere also responsible for unfortunate losses. /lthough
there are some drawbac%s, B$B has some strong side that may ensure future
achievements. These are the following8
B$B has some s%ill manpower such as 6ngineer, 6conomist, Business
e-ecutives, lower and so forth. Their capabilities are deteriorating for lac% of
proper wor%ing environment and une-pected political pressure. In some cases
they are not able to wor% independently. If B$B can use his personnel
sufficiently, it will be profitable in future.
B$B has greater capacity to collect money from foreign countries. It may
come through loan aid, grant etc. and B$B has many potential sectors where it
1?
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
16/98
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
17/98
CHAPTER FOUR
,CTI5ITI-S O/ B,N4,D-S0
S0I4P, B,N7
'.< ,CTI5ITI-S O/ B,N4,D-S0 S0I4P, B,N7
1(
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
18/98
Bangladesh $hilpa Ban% encompasses various department and zonal offices to
discharge its activities. To perform efficient and effectively B$B in its board meeting
has determined the schedule activities of various departments and zonal offices and
they supposed to perform the tas% accordingly and the respective employee have to
repot according to organizational hierarchy.
/ctivities of some important department are enumerated below.
'.1 4oan O(erat$on de(art!ent
Bangladesh $hilpa Ban% "B$B# grants loan on the basis of certain criteria. The first
/ctivities of loan granting are done by the loan operation department. /ny
entrepreneur who wants to borrow money, from B$B must fulfill at first ban%
standard :uestionnaire from "B$H!# terms of T% 1JJJ.These processes are as follows8
/t first an application form is supplies to the entrepreneur.
/fter filling up the application from it is submitted by the 6ntrepreneur.
/ proect appraisal letter is supplied by the entrepreneur.
/fter analyzing the proect appraisal, the board decides the loan should be
sanctioned or not.
If the loan is sanctioned it is forwarded to the proect implementation department.
'.2 Docu!entat$on and *ach$nery Procure!ent De(art!ent
/fter sanctioning loan by loan operation department, it issues a letter to
documentation department, parties and after concerned departments. The
documentation department issues a letter to the parties to produce necessary
documents. Those documents are8
4emorandum of /ssociation /rticles of /ssociation
The land upon which the proect will be established, document of this land must
be produced.
Receipts of rent
ocumentation fee
4oua 4ap
The document that reveal that the land were not sold within preceding two
years.
1C
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
19/98
Then a form is filled up. These documents are sent to lawyer. It every thing is o% it is
transferred to proect implementation department.
In the documentation process the borrowers are re:uired to submit a copy of memorandum of association and articles of association. It is returned after the
conflation that in has been submitted according to the rules the borrower company
must submit it after the authorization by direction of registration of
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
20/98
Lerification of new material process of proect ensuring the cash capital
according to the loan terms and condition and providing necessary
assistance in this matter.
Inspection and monitoring e-perimental production and e-tension of loan period.
4a%ing the final construction report "!7R# and transferring it to central
recovery department "7R# and concerned department5 authorities.
etermination of the construction period of the proect preparing loan
repayment schedule and ta%ing after necessary action regarding this.
4onitoring and inspecting the proect to see whether the proect is
implementing according to time schedule and ta%ing necessary initiatives tosolve any %ind of problem arising out there from and providing necessary
advice to the entrepreneur.
Receiving insurance letter against the predetermined ris% implementation
priest assets and ensuring its deposit to ban
'.' Centra reco%ery de(art!ent
0roect implementation department ma%es a repayment schedule and given itA to the
borrower. +ominally the interval is months. This department inspects the proect
after every months to see whether there is any lea%age. If the borrower fails to repay
the loan as the application of the borrower it is rescheduled. $ometimes a portion or
interest is e-empted. If the borrower fails to repay the loan, than it is transfer to law
department to ta%e legal action. *n the application of the borrower sometime the
proect is transferred to proect rehabilitation department to restore the proect.
'.) 4oan ,ccount$ng De(art!ent
oan accounting department is the department which centrally maintains all loan
accounts of the ban%. There are > sections which performs the activities of the
department.
1. +ot due section.
). /mount due section overdue section
&. Replacement section
>. General and policy section
)J
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
21/98
De&cr$(t$on:
I. +ot due is the installment not yet due for payment in schedule time fi-ed by the
0roect department5 Branch officer.II. The payment of installment and interest in not paid cleared in time is overdue.
The functions of this section are8
a# /ccurately list of balance preparation.
b# /dvice sending to borrower.
c# Huarter5 half year by interest charge.
Ill. 2hen the overdue is rephrased or waived then the replacement section will do the
needful activities.
IL. General and policy section do the following8
a# To prepare the monthly Trial Balance.
b# 4onthly recovery statement.
c# 4onthly disbursement schedule
d# To ma%e entry all the transaction as per daily statement received
from the branch officer.
e# /ll list of balances of not due send to the ;ead *ffice and Branch
*ffice.
f# To prepare distribution of wor% among the officers and staff as
specific guidelines of the authorities.
Not Due Sect$on:
I# Huarterly5 half yearly installment and interest charge and transferred it to
amount due section.
)# The rate of interest is fi-ed by the prevailing interest at the time of
e-ecution of loan document.
!oreign currency installment and interest will full as foreign currency loan
agreement as per contract of overseas donor agency.
'. Pro#ect Rehab$$tat$on de(art!ent =PRD>
The obective of B$B is to ma%e industrialization of the country. But many of the
proects, which are loaned by B$B, become sic% and cannot carry on their proects.
)1
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
22/98
There are many reasons, so government tries to revive the proposed proect for greater
advancement of the country.
The main activities and responsibility of 0roect Rehabilitation department are as
follows8
1> 2hen files are transferred to 0roect Rehabilitation department, it traces the
cause of sic%ness and Recommend to ta%e initiative to rehabilitate a proect . The
rehabilitation process starts after the recommendation of the advisory committee
formed by the General 4anagers.
2> The files of the proects are transferred to aw epartment to ta%e necessary
actions, which are deemed not rehabilitate. /gain if there is no opportunity to
rehabilitate any it also reected.
"> Lerification of the proposal regarding rehabilitation recommendation preparing
the implementation schedule and ta%ing necessary initiatives to ta%e care the proect
and deciding the single or oint management of the ban% over the proect if necessary.
'> Ta%ing rehabilitation program controlling proects management and monitoring
and ensuring the management system ta%en over by ban% and performing other
activities regarding these.
)> 0roduction of the rehabilitated proect, ma%ing of the products analyzing the
targeted loan recovery and actual situation and ta%ing necessary initiates regarding
these.
> Retraction of ban% participation stage by stage from the proect, which is
profitable
'.3 4a8 De(art!ent
In the $hilpa Ban% fails to recover its loan in the normal way, it must under ta%en
alternative action and file case in the court. The causes which $hilpa Ban% tiles cases
are8
I. Recovery case 8 A $ection &&
II. !inancial oan 7ase 8 A $ection ?"a#
III. 7ertificate 7ase 8 A $ection &?
IL. Ban%ruptcy 7ase 8 A $ection '"1#
L. 7ase if chec% is not cashed 8 A $ection 1'C
))
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
23/98
"0etition case#
LI. 7ase if machinery of proect
is transferred from the proect
without permission 8 A $ection &(
LII. 7ase if false properties are
mortgaged 8 A $ection >J
I. Reco%ery Ca&e:
7ase is filed with the court of istrict
'.; 0u!an Re&ource *anage!ent De(art!ent =0RD>
The department of human resource management was not same name as now.
4odernizing the structure of the administration of the ban% and evelopment the s%ill
of the human resources and reducing operating cost of the organization. The directorMs)>>th meeting was conducted on )&rd /pril 1''. In this meeting, rename of the
)&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
24/98
/dministration department as F/dministration and ;uman Resource epartmentF and
epartment of labor as Ddepartment of ;uman resources 4anagementD.
Sections of this department:
There are five sections in this department
$ection /ctivities
1. General administrative
3 policy section,
A !i-ing principles relating to human
Resource activities5position,
A !i-ing principles relating to
organization.
A!i-ing principles relating to delegation
of power,
A/ctivities relating to trade union,
A$end statements relating to delegation of
power.
). 4anagement section A0rovide employment policy,
A0rovide transfer policy,
A0rovide promotion policy,
A!i-ing pay scale.
A!i-ing annual increment policy.
&. isciplinary section A4itigates the complaint against
personnel.
>. 2elfare section A0rovide scholarship policy,
A/ssist the helpless personnel,
A0rovide retirement benefit.
?. eave 3 medical section A0rovide medical facility 3 allowances.A0rovide vacation opportunities,
A0rovide conveyance facility 3
allowances9
A0rovide house rent allowances.
A0rovide cloths benefits.
)>
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
25/98
Function of the Human Resources Manaement !epartment
1. To give medical facilities to the stuff.
). To maintain relationship with retired or dead stuffs and their families to %now
their condition.
&. To maintain and grant leaves without regular leave.
>. To coordinate and evaluate the branch and regional stuff activities.
?. To step and implement for opening new branch office.
. To maintain relationship with government and other institution
(. To prepare and implement policy about human resources and related activities.
C. To control the activities the staff of the ban%s and ta%e proper. $tep to
implement computer technology.
'. To perform the activities assigned by the departmental head.
1J. To control the administration of human resources of the ban%.
11. To give loan for house building, by cycle. 4otorcycle, and ensure their proper
utilization.
1). To assess and collect compatible personnel who will be perfect for the ban%.
1&. To ta%e program and implement for developing human resources.
1>. To ma%e appointment, promotion and appraising s%ill of officer and stuff.
1?. To ma%e service rules, correction, e-pansion, administration rules, sub rules,
orders, notice etc for controlling and stuff.
1. To give scholarship to the brilliant student of the university for appointing and
finding s%illed officer.
1(. To give general scholarship to the brilliant and daughter of stuff.
1C. To communicate with trade union scrutinizing their demands, open discuss
eveloping the relationship with administration proper implementation of labor
)?
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
26/98
law.
CHAPTER F"#E
PRO-CT ,PPR,IS,4 PROC-DUR-
)
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
27/98
PRO-CT ,PPR,IS,4
).1. INTRODUCTION
/ proect is a proposal for an investment to create, e-pand and5or develops certain
facilities in order to increase the productions of goods and5or services in a community
during a certain period of time. !or the purpose of B$B, proect means a scheme for
capital investment to develop facilities to provide goods and services. B$BDs main
function is to e-tend financial assistance to industrial proect. It basically needs to be
satisfied about the overall viability of a proect to be financed. !or this purpose, an
obective assessment of the viability of the proect is re:uired to be e-amined by B$B
from various points of view. This is what can be called proect appraisal.
The aim of proect appraisal is to e-amine the need, which a proect is designed to
meet and to DF udge whether the proect is li%ely to meet this need in an efficient way.
0roect appraisal provides a rational basis for decisionAma%ing. In case of shortAterm
lending, it is not usually necessary to ma%e e-pensive study of the customerDs future
potential 6-amination of general creditworthiness of a customer and his current
financial position is ade:uate.
There can be no fi-ed or standardized approach to proect appraisal. +umerous and
diverse elements enter into the process of appraisal. It is difficult to have a cut and
dried formula with the help of which a proposal for financial assistance can be
adusted straightway as acceptable or unacceptable. 2hile broadly the same set of
factors is ta%en into consideration in the scrutiny of individual applications, the
weight age given to the factors varies from proect to proect. In practice, proectappraisal coyer five different aspects of a proect, viz.
"1# 4anagement and *rganization
")# Technical
" 4ar%et
"># 6conomic, and
"?# !inancial.
)(
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
28/98
).2 *,N,-*-NT ,SP-CTS
/n assessment of the promoters in respect of their integrity, e-perience and
capabi1ities to implement and run the proect is of prime importance before e-tending
credit facilities to them. There are no set rules to find out if the borrowers or
promoters are the men of integrity. It is to be done by direct and indirect investigation.
The borrowerDs e-perience .and capabilities can, on the other hand, be assessed in
terms of his educational bac%ground, spatial :ualifications, practical business
e-perience, receptiveness to new ideas, or good advice, the general reputation and
above all his potentiality to learn new things and adaptability to new and changing
situation.
The e-tent to which crucial probing with regard to these aspects may be necessary
depends on the type of the proect and the bac%ground of promoters. If, for e-ample, a
proect incorporating a relatively comple- techni:ue and process is promoted by an
entrepreneur with proven abilities and e-perience, the crucial areas to be probed may
be, among others, the competence of the managerial and technical e-ecutives li%ely to
be in charge of the proect. But if such as the competence and previous e-perience of
the promoter, their collaboration tieAup arrangement, the technical and managerial
bac%ing he has already line up, their financial resource, etc. may have to be
thoroughly scrutinized.
)." OR,NI?,TION,4 ,SP-CTS
7losely related to the management is the type of organizational structure necessary to
carry out and operate the proect successfully. $o far as organization is concerned,there are two basic :ueries9 what organization is needed to bring the proect to the
operating stage and what organization will be needed thereafter. In the operating
phase, one of the most common :uestions is the e-tent to which responsibility and
authority should be centralized or delegated. The answer depends on the scale of
operation, its geographical dispersion, the degree of specialization of personnel, and
the number of persons to whom responsibility can be delegated. Internal controls
should also be reviewed. These are basic to sound organization. !or a management tofunction efficiently, the organization should be able to provide prompt reports on
)C
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
29/98
current performance that can be chec%ed against both past performance and previous
proections of future trends so as to bring problems to light as they arise. It is e:ually
important that the organization should be able to put the decisions of management
into effect without delay. Besides, sound budget and inventory control are needed
?.&.1. 7R6IT I+L6$TIG/TI*+
/ppraisal of management and organization of proect cannot be dined ade:uately
without underta%ing methodical credit investigation. The following two broad
obectives are intended to be realized through the credit investigation.
"1# 0roper identification of the application, and
")# egeneration of their ability and willingness to abide by their agreement
with the Baric In order words, whether they can and will live up to
their commitments in a nominal way. Through an organized credit
investigation answers to the following specific :uestions are sought8
"a# 2ho are the applicantsN
"b# 2hat are their present professions or vocationsN
"c# /re they persons of proven honesty and recognizedintegrityN "d# /re they persons of proven honesty and
recognized integrityN
"e# 2hat is the e-tent of their financial worthN
"f# ;ow much they can and are willing to invest from their own
resourcesN
"g# ;ow far they are capable of implementing and running the
proect.
?.&.). $*@R76 *! 7R6IT /T/
!or the purpose of evaluating the credit worthiness of the applicants, particulars and
information are necessary about their character "honesty and integrity#, capital
"properties and possessions#, capacity "entrepreneurial and managerial ability#,
li:uidity "cash and nar% cash assets#, etc. Information necessary for evaluating these
traits and :ualities can be obtained from a number of $ources. There are several methods
li%e written re:uests, telephone conversation, meeting information at social gatherings, etc.
)'
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
30/98
which may be ointly or severally adopted to obtain the re:uired information. The usual
sources of information can be broadly divided into internal sources and e-ternal
sources. The e-ternal sources can again be subAdivided into personal contacts and
indirect investigation
?.&.&. I+T6R+/ $*@R76$
In case the applicants are e-iting borrowers of the Ban%, the internal records and
behavior of respective loan accounts will reveal great deal of information about their
ban%Aability. etails of past borrowings5e:uityAsupport such as amount, date of
sanction, amount repaid, amount outstanding and overdue, together with comments on
aspects li%e replacements, moratorium, etc, if any, should be incorporated in the credit
report.
?.&.>. 6OT6R+/ $*@R76$
!or the new applicants, the credit investigator has to depend primarily on the e-ternal
source to verify the statements and declarations made in the loan application. The
main e-ternal sources are.
"a# 7redit Information Bureau "7IB# Report. If the corn report indicates that
the proposed sponsors are defaulters to any Ban%5*!I, their proposal should
be turned down as per decision of the G*B,
"b# Interview with the applicants,
"c# !inancial statements, deed and statutory documents, etc.
"d# Inspection of the apple incants, place of business and properties, and
"e# *ther sources li%e commercial ban%ers of the applicants, business firms,
trade circle, friends and associates, Registrar of oin $toc% 7ompanies5!irms,
istrict Registrar $ubAregistrar, ocal periodicals, Government 0ublications,
etc.
?.&.?. /00I7/+T$AT;6IR ;*+6$TP /+ I+T6GRITP
The main tas% of the credit investigator is to ascertain the real identity of the
applicants with regard to their honesty, integrity and their legal authority to borrow or
to raise institutional e:uity. The starting point for him is the loan application and
&J
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
31/98
specifically the declaration of the personal assets of the applicants. *n this basis, he
should have a threadbare discussion with the applications.
The credit investigator should %eep it in mind that the applicants should not only be
citizens of Bangladesh, but they must also not be minors, ban%rupts or persons of
unsound mind. ;e should also be well aware of the legal status of proprietorship
concerns, partnership firms and limited liability companies with regard to
membership, capital, obectives, borrowing capacity and ta- obligations.
?.&.. 0R*06RTI6$ /+ 0*$$6$$I*+$ *! T;6 /00I7/+T$
The financial standing of the applicants is udged by means, of direct reference to
their movable and immovable properties. The valueD of total assets minus
corresponding borrowings, if any, would indicate the net worth. /lthough the assets
free from encumbrances should from the basis of assessing the financial standing, the
details of the e-isting borrowings from different sources should be stated in the credit
report to throw light on the borrowings from different sources should be stated in the
credit report to throw light on the borrowings habits of the applicants. There are
compelling reasons for which the credit investigator has to be satisfied about the
ownership and real value of the declared assets.
?.&.(. IH@IITP $T/T@$ *! T;6 /00I7/+T$
The credit investigator must be satisfied that the applicants are financially capable of
underta%ing a proect of the contemplated size. This calls for determination of the
sources and the e-tent of funds that the applicants are capable of mobilizing and also
the e-tent they are ready to invest. The li:uid funds necessary for investment in the
proect may be mobilized by the applicants from one or more conventional sources.
?.&.C. 7/0/7ITP *! T;6 /00I7/+T$
Because of the comple-ity involved in setting up and ensuring profitable operations of
an industrial proect, the most important preAre:uisite that the Ban% e-pects the
applicants to possess is the capability to manage and supervise. The success of a
proect depends primarily on this trait of the sponsors. Its presence blooms a proect
and its absence dooms the same. @nfortunately this is most difficult to udge. /s
indicated in the proceeding paragraph, the entire credit analysis is directed to point up
&1
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
32/98
this :ualitative characteristic of the sponsors. Individual, capability is reflected in the
conglomeration of s%ill and resourcefulness, education and. e-perience, age and
personal health, etc. The first consideration for the credit investigator is to ascertain
how successful the applicants are in their present trade and profession. The second
consideration is to udge whether they are financially and managerially competent to
underta%e implementation of the proect. The thing consideration is to forecast ability
to run the proect successfully upon implementation. /nalysis of the past operations,
opinion of the commercial ban%ers, independent opinion from outside sources, etc.
would be useful in assessing the capability of the applicants. It may be mentioned
here that while Fassessing the sponsorMs capability, the following point should be
e-amined.
Q 0ast repayment performance of e-isting loans.
).'. T-C0NO4OIC,4 ,SP-CTS
The technical aspects of in industrial proect are appraised to determine whether the
proect is sound with regard to every engineering and technological consideration,
including product specification, process, size, internal balance, suitability and
availability of physical facilities, designs and layouts of e:uipment and buildings etc.
In a developing country li%e Bangladesh, where there is hardly and indigenous
technological base to support the industrialization process the industr1al underta%ings
have to be conceived on the basis of %now or borrowed technology until such time as
the development of local technology is sufficient.
The second important aspect of technical study includes evaluation of resources to be
used for setting up the proect as well as operating it subse:uently. The physical
resources to be used are to be transformed into financial tens. ;ence, the tas% of the
engineer is to evaluate :uantitatively the resources such as proect land, building
materials, machinery, e:uipment, stores and spares, raw materials, labor, power, fuel,
etc. Then he is to wor% out the cost of, these resources. In monetary tens to determine
the capital cost of the proect and also itMs operating cost after implementation. 2hile
evaluating the capital outlay and physical facilities, the engineer will have to
determine the production cycle and also the time schedule for implementing the
proect.
&)
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
33/98
In the case of a proect involving technical collaboration or borrowed technology, the
proect engineer has to e-amine various facets of technology transplant and its
adoption to suit the local conditions including the terms and conditions of technology
transfer and financial and economic implications of such transfer of technology.
/lthough basically, technology transfer ta%es place between two systems, namely, the
domestic ac:uisition system "the sponsors# and the delivery system "foreign
collaborations#, the development ban% which acts as a gateA%eeper between the two
systems has a vital role to play in determining the suitability of the borrowed
technology, the terms and conditions of technology transfer and its impact on the proect as a
whole. The ultimate aim of proect appraisal by a evelopment ban% is to determine the
profitability of the proect both from commercial and social points of view.
This cannot be underta%en unless through technical studies and cost analysis have
been made a related technical problems solved. Thus, the technical studies and cost
analysis provided the basis both for the initial estimates of the profitability of an
investment during the initial stages and for the final decision to implement the proect
or not. The technical appraisal, therefore, constitutes the foundation of the entire
superAstructure of proect appraisal.
/ development Ban% may need to consult or contact with specialized engineering
services from outside for specialized matters, particulars relating to proects to be
based on comple- technology. ;owever good an engineer of evelopment Ban% may
be in studies or specific operations, he cannot be e-pected to be e-pert in all fields of
specialization. This point is of great practical significance while dealing with a proect
in which the country has no previous e-perience. In such a situation, particularly in
the case of a proect involving large capital outlay, it is advisable to find out best
advisors "consultants# from outside. !or because any defect in the proect design and
formulation will eventually affect the enterprise adversely.
?.>.1. B/$I7 /$067T$ *! T67;+I7/ /00R/I$/
The basic aspects to be analyzed in the course of technical appraisal are E
).'.1 =,> Pre$!$nary $n%e&t$gat$on
"a# 0roducts5 $ervice9
&&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
34/98
"b# Raw materials9
"c# $%ills and technology re:uired for manufacture5 service9 and
"d# Testing and analytical report.
).'.1=B>. Seect$on of (roduct$on (roce&&"a# 7hoice of alternative and selection criteria9
"b# 2astage in manufacturing process9
"d# isposal of wastes and effluents and
"e# 6nvironment and pollution control.
I 4achinery and e:uipment for production5service
II. 0roductive capacity and efficiency. $ite selection
III. $ite selectionA
"a# Technical factors9
"b# 7ost factors of production9
"c# 4ar%eting factors9
"d# /dministrative and housing factors9 and
"e# Transportation factors.
IL. ayout planA
"a# $ite9
"b# Building9
"c# 0lant and 4achinery9 and
"d# $upplementary Installations.
L. /nalysis and evaluation of utilities and supplies
"a# Raw materials9
"b# $tores and spares9
"c# Technical nowAhow9
"d# Transfer of technology9
"e# 0ower, !uel, 2ater, $team ere9
"f# abor9 and
"g# Transporting.
LI. 2or% $chedule.
LII. 6stimation and evaluation of cost.
The relative importance of these aspects will, however, vary from proect to proect.
&>
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
35/98
).). *,R7-TIN ,PPR,IS,4
/n industrial proect is to bring in some goods Dor services for a community. But the
community does not need them infinitely. Their demand is of course finite and at
given prices.
?.?.1. 7*+760T *! 4/R6T
*rdinarily, the mar%et means a precise place where commercial transactions occur. In
a broader sense, however, it is termed as the sum of contacts between buyers and
sellers of a product or service, the price and :uantity e-changed of which are
detonated by the forces of demand and supply. 4ar%et, in this sense, may be formally
organized and geographically centered or it may, be either. The mar%et includes the
whole environment in which the enterprise is to live and to which it must adapt
itself8 consumers, suppliers, competitors and all %inds of technical, material, political,
legal and administrative restrictions. 4ar%et analysis is the first FscreeningF stage in
the proect appraisal, at which proects that cannot e-pect satisfactory mar%et
acceptance shall be reected.
?.?.). 4/R6TI+G 0/+
,: *arket$ng Ob#ect$%e:
4ar%eting plan, as inD the case of production and financial plan, should have obective
in the bac%drop9 and the obective is what is wanted to be achieved. The obective
may be more than one and :uantifiable. !or appropriate mar%eting obective, it is
necessary to loo% at depth into the E
"a# macro5micro demand5 supply situation for specific products in the mar%et.
"b# e-isting and e-pected competition in local and foreign mar%ets,
"c# mar%et share, etc.
2hile appraising industrial proects, the Ban% is re:uired to analyze these factors and
to bring out the obective in :uantitative terms.
=a> Product $dent$f$cat$on:
&?
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
36/98
The study of this environment should begin with proper identification of the goods or
services to be e-posed to the environment. *ne way of identifying them is in term of
their complementarily and 7ompetitiveness. 7omplementary goods are used together
in a single consumption activity. 7ameras, films and developing instruments and
chemicals constitute a set of such complements. 7omplementary goods may be sold
together or separately.
/nother way of distinguishing goods and services is in terms of their
consumers. These are8 !inal goods, Intermediate goods and Investment Goods.
astly, the goods and services may be either new or e-isting in the mar%et.
=b> Nature of De!and.
=c> Ty(e of De!and:"I# There are various types of demand for the product5service in :uestion. These are
direct, derived, new, replacement demand, etc. The mar%et analyst should
identify the type of demand be created for the product"s#5 services.
, "II# $ize and 7omposition of 0resent emand8 4ar%et $ize8
).).". *-T0ODO4O+:
The initial obective of demand analysis is the determination of current effectivedemand. 6ffective demand represents the total :uantity of a specific product
purchased at a given price in a particular mar%et over a given period. The base for
estimation is the actual consumption figure during the relevant period.
The e:uation of apparent consumption is as follows8
7S0 "4AO# O
2here,
7 S 7onsumption
0 S omestic production
4 S Imports
O S 6-ports
$ S 7hanges in $toc%
&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
37/98
*nce current demand has been estimated foe the entire mar%et, it becomes necessary
to segment the mar%et to ma%e future proections.
6ffective mar%et segmentation will therefore8
A help to understand better mar%et behavior and responses,
A enable the concentration of efforts on promising mar%et segments,
A enable the fine tuning of mar%eting strategy to the needs of target segments,
A increase total sales, reduce costs and step up profits.The most typical variables, by which mar%ets can by segmented are as followsF
,: Con&u!er *arket&
=1> Geographic8
A /dministrative regions
A Geographic regions
A 7limate
A 7ityAsize
A RuralAdistrict cutAsize.
=2> Soc$o@econo!$c:
A Income "level, dynamics, distribution#
A /ge
A $e-
A *ccupation A education
A !amily size
A Religion
A Income elasticity of demand
A 0rices and availability of complimentary goods
A Govt. policies A nationality
A $ocial class
A 7ulture
="> Per&ona$ty and beha%$or:
&(
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
38/98
A ife style
A eadership
A /mbition
A 7onservatism
A Buying motive A loyalty
A 6-troversion and introversion
A $ervice sensitivity and introversion A service sensitivity
A 0romotional sensitivity
B: Indu&tr$a *arket&:
=1> Nu!ber and ty(e& of $ndu&tr$a u&er&:
A $ize
A *wnership
A /ge of e:uipment
A Regional concentration
A Lertical vs. horizontal mar%etsA technological progress.=2> Buy$ng (o8er:
A +umber of employees
A +umber of employees
A LalueAadded.
The mar%et analyst should collect and analyses the following data for e-port mar%et8
=I> 6ord Trade:
A +ames of the countries to which the product will be e-ported
A ;ow these countries are at present meeting their demand. If through import,what are the countries of their originN
A Time series data regarding e-port and import.
=$$>. Character$&t$c& of S(ec$f$c Inter!ed$ar$e& =-A(orter9 I!(orter>:
A General description of types available
A 4arginsA 6ffectiveness
&C
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
39/98
A Regulation
A 7ontacts in e-port mar%et
A 4ar%eting tas%s they are able and prepare to carry.
=$$$> Tran&(ort and In&urance:A Traditional transportation means
A 7osts of freight and insurance A timing of delivery
A elivery terms, I!, !*B, etc.
=$%> *arket ,cce&&$b$$ty:
A Tariffs and fees
A +onAtariff barriers
A Huality standards
A ;ealth, medical and safety re:uirements
A 0ac%age standards
A Import :uotas
A 7ustoms regulations
A 0olitical and administrative barriers8
A Trading habit
A 7omparative advantage
=%> Ter!& and cond$t$on& of &ae& and d$&tr$but$on arrange!ent
=%$> -A(ort $ncent$%e a%a$abe
=%$$> Pa&t eA(ort trend (erfor!ance of the (roduct=&>
).).'. SUPP4+ ,N,4+SIS:
ocal producerDs past and present output, together with capacity utilization review
provides a convenient departure point for an analysis of supply situation and outloo%,which combined with combined with demand estimates, will determine the proectDs
position in the mar%et and thus e-pected.
7ompared with the variety of methods applicable for demand forecasting, proecting
the future supply position in the mar%et is a rather unassuming tas%. /vailability of the
production in the mar%et is a function of8
Adomestic producers present and proected capacities
Anew proects being under construction present and proected e-port volume
Aforeign manufacturerD capacities, mar%eting strategies and development plans,
&'
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
40/98
A Government policies.
).).). SUPP4+ ,P:
7onsidering the future demand for the product and total potential supply of the same,
the analyst should, estimate the proected supply gap. It is to be e-amined how the
supply gap ustifies the setting up of the proect under consideration.
).).. *,R7-T S0,R-:
;aving estimated the supply hap, the mar%et analyst should calculate the proectDs
contribution towards the reduction of this gap. In fact, mar%et share is the mar%eting
obective.
).).3. *,R7-TIN IN/OR*,TION
The procedure of mar%et analysis, outlined above, call for systematic collection of
information about the mar%et for the goods and services to be considered. $ome of
this information is :uantitative while other is :ualitative.
).).;. U,NTIT,TI5- IN/OR*,TION
The following :uantitative information is to be collected in physical on a national
basis8
Con&u!(t$on Data:
1. 0roduction
). Imports
&. 6-ports
!or international comparison, such data for comparable foreign countries are also to
be collected.
Indu&tr$a cen&u&:
1. +umber of productive units
). istribution of productive units by location.
&. Installed production capacity.
De!ogra(h$c Data:
>J
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
41/98
1. istribution of population by age, se-, marital status, religion, literacy,
income, occupation and region.
). /verage size of a family
&. Rate of population growth
>. Rate of organization.
The following :uantitative data, e-press in terms of value, are also be collected on a
national basis8
Pr$ce&:
1. !.G.B. price of e-ports
). 7.!. price of imports.
&. 6-Afactory price of products and services.
>. 2holesale price annual average.
?. 7onsumerDs price inde-
. 7ost of living
The re:uirement information relating to ta- e-pressed in rates5 values age8
1. 7ustoms duty.
). L / T.
&. Import license fee.
>. *thers.
The above :uantitative data should be collected for several for several years in the
past so as to constitute historical series.
).).. U,4IT,TI5- IN/OR*,TION:
The :ualitative information, which may be re:uired for mar%et analysis, is8
1. ocation informationATransport and communication facilities, water and
power facilities, nearness to the mar%et, etc.
). 0ossibilities of continued supply of inputs.
&. /ttitude of customers.
>. 7limatic characteristics.
?. 4ethods of distributionAmar%et and nonAmar%et
. Government policies8
>1
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
42/98
"a# 6conomic evelopment obectives.
"b# ;ealth and safety standards.
"c# Investment5International policy.
"d# Ta-ation policy.
"e# 6-port policy.
"f# 4onetary policy.
"g# abor policy.
"h# *thers, if any
).. -CONO*IC ,PPR,IS,4
In economic appraisal, the proect is loo%ed at from the national or social point of
view and the economic cash flow is constructed on the basis of Ftrue or real pricesF,
commonly %nown as accounting or shadow prices.
6conomic analysis of a proect aims at determining whether that proect is consistent
with overall national and sectorA wise obectives aridD whether the investment
proposed is the best means of achieving the intended obectives. It involves a
systematic evaluation of a range of options for achieving the intended obectives. It
involves a systematic evaluation of a range of options for achieving a state set of
obectives. /llocating resources to a sector or specific purposes reduce reduces the
resources available for other sectors and purposes. Therefore, it is essential that the
allocation of investment resources be efficient among sectors. 6conomic appraisal is
the primary means of determining whether a proposed investment is worthwhile. It
should determine whether a proect is acceptable and, if it is, whether it is the best
alternative.
6conomic appraisal should cover both :uantifiable and nonA:uantifiable benefits
"where applicable#. $uch benefits are described adAseriatim.
)..1. U,NTI/I,B4- B-N-/ITS:
!ollowing are the :uantifiable benefits of economic appraisal8
"a# 6conomic Rate of Return "6RR#,
"b# Bruno Ratio5 omestic Resource 7ost,"c# 7ontribution of Gross omestic 0roduct, and
>)
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
43/98
"d# 6mployment Generation and 7ost per employment.
=a> -CONO*IC R,T- O/ R-TURN =-RR>:
6RR measures the potential earning power of the social resources used in the proect
and thus help the assessment of investment proposal. It is wor%ed out at which the
present value of costs becomes e:ual to the present value of benefits. +et present
value "+0L# is the net value or net benefit of a proect when all costs have been
discounted to the present at the accounting rate of interest.
/fter wor%ing out the 6RR, it should be compared with the /ccounting Rate of
Interest "/RI#.The /RI is nothing but the opportunity cost of capital which is
supposed to ma-imize the use and productivity of investAable resources in the country.
The broad decision criterion is that, other things being e:ual, the proect whose 6RR
is les than the /RI should ordinarily be reected unless other un:uantifiable benefits
are ade:uate or the proect can be :ualitatively ustified8 etern1ining the opportunity
cost of capital for a society is difficult, but economists generally consider it to be 1?
percent in most developing countries. The planning 7ommission of Bangladesh has
estimated the /RI at *. 1? "or 1? percent#.
=b> BRUNO R,TIO DO*-STIC R-SOURC- COST =DRC>:
/n industrial proect will either be import substitute or e-port oriented or combination
of both in nature. In developing country, development of industrial proects, normally
involves substantial amount of scarce foreign e-change. *n the basis of more absolute
amount of saving and5or earning of foreign e-change of an investment proposal, the
optimal allocation of scarce resources "both domestic and e-ternal# may not be
achieved, the implicit foreign e-change. In other words it indicates the domestic
resource cost involved in foreign e-change to be saved5 earned by a proect.
The domestic resource cost "R7# involved in saving5 earning foreign e-change by a
proect is normally wor%ed out by dividing the real domestic cost in Ta%a by real net
foreign e-change to be saved5 earned. It is normally e-pressed as Ta%a cost per unit
off foreign e-change "i.e. U or# saved5 earned i.e. the amount of Ta%a re:uired to save
earn a ollar or 0ound $terling. If domestic resources are e-pressed in domestic
currency and foreign e-change is e-pressed in dollars, a R7 of less than the
"$hadow# e-change rate is considered :uite acceptable.
>&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
44/98
=c> CONTRIBUTION TO ROSS DO*-STIC PRODUCT =DP>
7ontribution to G0 of a proect is estimated from sales value and interAfirm
transactions. ata regarding sales value is ta%en from the calculation of sales estimate
of the financial appraisal. $ales value of fourth year is ta%en. $imilarly data estimate
of the financial appraisal. $ales value of fourth year is ta%en. $imilarly, data relating
to interAfirm transaction of fourth year is collected from the calculation sheet of cost
of goods sold and General /dministration and selling e-penses of the financial
appraisal
.etail calculation of contribution to G0 of a proect may be wor%ed out as per the following
format8
/. $ales ">th year#
B ess8 A InterAfirm Transaction ">th year#
A Raw and pac%ing materials
A $tores and spares
A 2ater, 0ower and !uel A Repair and maintenance
A Rent, Ta- and insurance A postage, telephone, fa- etc.A $tationery and printing
A Traveling and conveyance
A /dvertisement.
A 7ontribution to G0 "/AB#
B$ has meaningful contribution to G0. In the year 1''>A1''? G0 was C.V,
which is higher than that of previous yea. I observed that in the year 1''A'( was too
lower than last two years. But in the year 1''(A'C G0 contributions was C.1V,
which is >.V greater than that of last year. /nother depression was come in the
industrial sector in the year 1''CA''9 only contribution was ).?V, which is lower
contribution after liberation to date. /fter the year 1''' G0 contribution is more or
less e:uivalent over the years. In the year 1'''A)JJJ, )JJJAJ1 and )JJ1AJ) were
?.(V and ?.JV respectively. The growth rate of gross domestic product of Bangladesh
decreased to >.CJV in )JJ1AJ) as against ?.&JV in the previous year. The overall
growth in the sector of agriculture and forestry declined to &.JJV in )JJ1AJ) from
?.?JV during the preceding year. *n the other hand the rate of growth in the
>>
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
45/98
industrial "manufacturing# sector during the year under report declared to ?.JJV from
.(JV in the previous year. The rate of domestic savings as percentage of G0 in
)JJ1AJ) reminded at 1C percent as in financial year )JJJAJ1. The rate of total
investment to G0 increased marginally from )&.J' percent in the preceding year to
)&.1 percent during in the under report.
Tabe 1 @ DP contr$but$on of Indu&tr$a Sector on O%era DP of the econo!y
Pear G0 "V#
1''>A1''? C.J
1''?A1'' ?.&J
1''A1''( &.?J
1''(A1''C C.1J
1''CA1''' ).?J
1 '''A)JJJ ?.(J
)JJJA)JJ1 .(J
)JJ1A)JJ) ?.JJ
$o from the above discussion we could easily say that the rehabilitation department isnot successful enough.
=d> -*P4O+*-NT -N-R,TION ,ND COST P-R -*P4O+*-NT:
The number of fullAtime and partAtime obs measured in manAyears e-pected to be
created both during construction and during operation of the proect should be
estimated separately. If data are available, these estimates should be related to
Regional, sectoral and national levels of unemployment and under employment and
under employment. 2here possible, the degree of labor intensiveness "i.e. the number
of wor%ers employed per unit of investment# of the proect should also be estimated.
>?
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
46/98
)..2. Non@uant$f$abe Intang$be Benef$t& -Aterna$t$e&:
The term nonA:uantifiable refers both "1# to effects that are %nown to arise but which
cannot be measured in physical terms and ")# to effects, which cannot be valued.
ifficulties in :uantification and valuation will often go together. Huantification
problems often are data problem a certain effect could not be measured, but has not
been.
).3. /IN,NCI,4 ,PPR,IS,4
The main purpose of financial appraisal is to assess if the proposed proect is viable in
term of its operation in the future years and its financial soundness. The financial
analyst should have a clear idea as to what is intended to be achieved through the
financial appraisal. The financial appraisal is directed to e-amine mainly the
following two aspects8
"a# !und re:uirement to bring the proect in to e-istence and the probable
sources from which the re:uired funds will be mobilized9 and
"b# 0rospects of ade:uate revenue generation by the proect when it goes into
operation and the li%ely position of the concern with regard to its actual
cash generation "li:uidity# and its probable impact upon the financial
condition "solvency#.
The first aspect deals with the estimation of total of the proect "fi-ed cost net
wor%ing capital# and a suitable financial arrangement "debtAe:uity relation#. The
second aspect relates to the analysis of productionAcost profit at different volume of
production carried up to the year the proect attains its normal capacity operation.
).3.1. COST O/ T0- PRO-CT
The cost of a proect represents all capital e-penditure to be incurred for ac:uisition of
its fi-ed assets plus the nit contribution of longAterm resources in the proposed current
assents. In other words, the fi-ed cost of the proect plus the net "or permanent#
wor%ing capital re:uirement to run the proect will comprise its total cost.
).3.2. /IE-D COST O/ T0- PRO-CT
>
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
47/98
The re:uirement of physical assets for a proect is essentially an engineering estimate.
The analyst should, however, rechec% the various cost items detailed in the fi-ed cost
statement given in the technical report. The idea is to see that all costs are included
and the cost estimates are realistic. The analyst should go through item by item and
also loo% in to their ramification. Individual item of tangible assents will have a
re:uired :uantity "H# and a price "0#. The H indicates any :uantity in area, number,
volume, or any other suitable unit of measurement. The 0 indicates the price for a
specific unit of H. The fi-ed cost of a proect is the aggregate of cost of land, building
construction, plant, and machinery and e:uipments preliminary and are e-penses
"capitalized# and a margin for contingencies "any or may not be considered#.
).3.". 6OR7IN C,PIT,4
/part from investment in the fi-ed assets, li:uid funds are, necessary for investment
in current assets li%e stoc%s of ram materials, goodAinAprocess, finished goods, Dstores
and spares, debtors, etc. The portion of fund, which remains invested in current assets
of a concern, is called its wor%ing capital. $uch assets are characterized by their
tangibility and shortAliveliness. It is worthwhile to mention here that Bangladesh Ban%
issues some policy guidelines from time to time as to what will be the tied up period
while calculating wor%ing capital re:uirement pending on the nature of the proect,
which should be followed during appraisal.
).3.'. *-,NS O/ /IN,NC-
/ proect may be financed in the following two ways8
The entire finance may be provided by the sponsors9 or
0art of the finance may be provided by the sponsors and the rest by the
7reditors.
The following are the usual sources of funds8
=I> -u$ty Ca($ta
"a# 0aidAup share capital9
"b# Reserves and surplus "for an e-isting concern#9 ,
"c# Retained 6arnings "for an e-isting concern#9 and
"d# *ther sources such as loans from irectors, friends, relatives, associates,
etc.
>(
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
48/98
=II> 4oan Ca($ta:
"a# ongAterm borrowings "both secured and unsecured#9 and
"b# Interest uring 7onstruction 0eriod "I70#.
).3.). ,N,4+SIS O/ /IN,NCI,4 ST,T-*-NT
0roper interpretation of data presented by financial statements helps in9
"i# C
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
49/98
0rofitability Ratios show the managementDs overall effectiveness as revealed by the
returns generated on sales and investment.
).3.3. /IN,NCI,4 PRO-CTIONS
!inancial proections are final translation of plan for a proect in monetary terms. In
other words, proections reflect in concrete terms the anticipation of the analyst
regarding the future income and e-penditure and their probable impact upon the
assets, liabilities and e:uity of a proposed proect. Through financial proections,
answers are sought to the following :uestions8
"i# 2hat it should cost to produce and sell the productN and
"ii# 2hat it should sell forN
).3.;. PR-S-NT,TION
The third basic re:uirement of financial proections is a suitable techni:ue for
calculation and presentation. The analyst will have to utilize his %nowledge of
accounting. The financial proections are prepared and presented within the
accounting framewor%. The :uality of the proections would, therefore, depend upon
the analystDs %nowledge of accounting. The financial proections involve wor%ing out
the following three interrelated statements for a number of years in respect of a
proect8
"i# !orecast of earnings this will measure the cost of production and profitability9
"ii# !und flow statement which will indicate maor or prominent fund inflows and
outflows9
"iii# proected Balance $heets which will depict the capital structure and assets spread
at the and of periods used in "i# and "ii# above.
).3.. COST O/ PRODUCTION
*nce the computation of future sales is completed, the ne-t step .is to calculate the
relevant cost of sales. This process involves preparation of some sort of e-penses
budgets for the relevant years for which sales have been calculated. /ll the e-penses
can be broadly divided into the following three categories8
"i# 7ost of goods sold9"ii# General, /dministrative and selling e-penses9 and
>'
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
50/98
"iii# !inancial e-penses.
CHAPTAR S"$
PRO-CT *ONITORIN PR,CTIC-
O/ BSB
?J
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
51/98
Pro#ect *on$tor$ng Pract$ce of BSB
"/ 7ase $tudy#
!or illustrating the monitoring practices of B$B I choose a case named 45$ 6ttade
0lastic td. which dictates the actual performance of 0roect 4onitoring
department of B$B.
.1 N,*- O/ T0- PRO-CT:
45$ 6ttade 0lastic td.
4ocat$on8 7har Raman, 4eghnaghat, $onargaon, +arayangon.
.2C,P,CIT+ O/ T0- PRO-CT:
The annul rated capacity of the proect has been estimated on the basis of three shifts
operations of eight hours per day and three hundred wor%ing days in a year.
oan operation department issues a sanction letters pointing out the total mount of
loan, which sanctioned in favor from of the 45$ 6ttade 0lastic td.
In the sanction letter, * offers brief description about the followingA
7ost of the proect,
4eans of finance,
7apital structure,
/mount of loan,
0urpose of loan,
?1
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
52/98
period of loan,
Rate of interest and other charges,
isbursement schedule,
Repayment schedule,
$ecurity of loan,
$pecial conditions, /nd so on
." I*P4-*-NT,TION
/ sum of the 'CCJJJJJ and C&JJJ sanctioned in favor of 45$ 6ttade 0lastic td. to
be repaid )> "Twenty four# :uarterly installments, Repayment shall commence after
commence after eighteen months from the date of opening of letter of credit "57# or
si- months after the proect goes into commercial operation, whichever is earlier. The
interest is to be accrued on the outstanding loans amount after the e-piry of the grace
period shall be charged as usual on :uarterly basis.
.' 4O,N S,NCTION F -EP-NDITUR-
Tas% of the main proect Implementation department of B$B is to disburse the
sanctioned loan in accordance with oan *peration epartment .The disbursement
schedule of total loan amount is given below8A
1st
Installment S(>&.1C lac
)nd Installment S1'?.? lac
&rd Installment S?J.JJ lac
Total S'CC.C& lac
!irst installment money will allow for importing machinery and e:uipment, CJV of
machinery cost will be paid out of B$B loan, )JV machinery cost will be paid out of
sponsorMs e:uity.
?)
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
53/98
*S -ttade Pa&t$c 4td.
4$&t of I!(orted *ach$nery
Tabe@2
$ +o. +ame of 4achinery
/. 0lastic e-truding tape stretching @nit
Huantity
1 0lastic 6-truding 4achine ) set
) Tape 2inder ) set
& ;ot *ven > set
> ThreeAroller shaping unit ) set
? 0ressAroller $tretching unit ) set
$litting @nit ) set
( 2ater Tan% ) set
1
B. 7ircular oom 2or%shop
7ircular oom ?J set
) 7rane with single trac% ) set
& ;and Borrow set
7. Bag 4a%ing 2or%shop
1 aminating machine 1 set
) aminating machine "middle $ean# 1 set
& Bag mar%ing machine &J set
> $ewing machine ) set
? Bounding machine ) set
7rane with single trac%
( /ir compressor & set
?&
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
54/98
Other& $!(ort !ach$nery
aboratory e:uipment, power supplies and control system, water supply system.
)nd installment was to be disbursed for the constructions were opening of letter of
credit for import of machinery and e:uipment through B$6.
&rd installment was to be disbursed towards reimbursement of net wor%ing capital.
Third installment was allotted on basis of utilization of second installment of loans
and producing documentary evidence other than availing of re:uired wor%ing capital
from sponsorDs designated commercial ban%.
The 0roect Implementation epartment of B$B inspects the 45$ 6ttade 0lastic td .
before final production time to time. The principal obective of such types of
inspection is to avoid fraudulent activity and to maintain proper distribution of loan.
B$B provides !inal 7onstruction Report "!7R# in inspection formAII in regular
interval basis. It contains an inspection team. The report to the higher authority of
B$B on inspection formAI provide the construction and engineering timetable and
progress made.
*n )Jth /ugust )JJ&, inspection was made on reconstruction of land and building.
7ompanyDs engineers, site engineer and other e-ecutives were presented at that time.
Inspection team compared the actual activity with the master layout plan. /ccording
to s%etch construction wor% was for 7ircular loan $ection "party#. Parn ma%ing
section and raw material store. Total investment for reconstruction became T%A&(.'(
lac%.
/fter completion of inspection wor%, inspection term provided some suggestions on
basis of improvement of reconstruction wor% ayout plan of machinery.
*n )'th +ovember )JJ), another inspection was made on imported machinery. /t that
time, another construction wor% "main gate establish# was ongoing. !oreign e-porter
4r. 0eter Khou was set up machinery within three months. Result of this inspection
shows8 at total investment e T &CJ.') lac% on reconstruction proect.
?>
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
55/98
.) INSP-CTION T-,* SU-STIONS
In&(ect$on tea! &ugge&t$on&A !or reconstruction wor% TA 1??.) lac
was distributed on th
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
56/98
"?J.JJ lac# of &rd installment will be distributed on basis of fulfillment of net wor%ing
capital.
0roect implementation department disbursed the loan to 45$ 6ttade 0lastic td .
according to different installments. *n other hand it can be said that loan disbursed on
basis for wor%s completed. But some tas%s were performed 5 completed slowly by
company. It is tolerable because many hindrances came out due to the construction
period. 0ractically it is not possessive to complete 1JJV wor% according to s%etch.
0roect Implementation epartment of B$B regularly monitors the specific proect
and disburses the total loan amount through different installments.
The entrepreneurs provided its information about the re:uirement of bridge loan. The
proects maintained strictly its annual capacity of production. The authority of B$B
disbursed the total loan amount by installment, which is also precondition of
disbursing oan amount. I thin% 45$ 6ttade 0lastic td. completely fulfilled most of
the re:uirements. /s a result, they received the sanctioned amount on due date.
The company shared so for product diversification commercially by producing and
selling high :uality of bag. 4onitoring epartment has to ta%e creative actions to use
loan in full volume. B$B shared diversify its service and add new features is to
service so that it can attract new entrepreneurs how all of people. 6$B can use internet
for both local and international correspondence. 6Amail can reduce the tele- cost
substantially. Ban% should ta%e intelligent decision to create own web page in Internet
so that it can communicate with entrepreneurs a branches very :uic%ly. B$B should
increase its number of monitoring team to investigate very :uic%ly.
?
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
57/98
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
58/98
3.1 Precaut$on& about S$ck Indu&try:
$ic% situation arises in an industry in some abnormal period. But if the rate of
sic%ness is overwhelming then it becomes a matter of fact. $o before providing loan
importance must be given on evaluation. If the evaluation procedure is correct, sic%
industry situation may avoid :uite easily. $o at preAinvestment stage the following
things must be consideredA
6-amine the proect is done appropriately.
The proect cost is calculated in a proper way.
The proper place is selected.
efect machineries must not be purchased.
6nsure that s%illed and e-perienced personnel are easily found.
0roper stapes are ta%en to protect uneven brea%down of electricity.
6nsure that proper people are involved in the managing committee.
6nsure the financial capability of the initiator.
6nsure the procedure of ma%eup the preliminary cost and the doubtful loss.
6nsure the :uality of the produced product.
6nsure the proper way to mar%eting the produced products.
7onsider the change of test of customer.
0roper plan is ta%en to implement the proect.
$teps are ta%en to avoid the potential conflict
3.2 The Sy!(to!& of S$ck Indu&try:
The symptoms of sic% industry are as followsA
The initiator is unable to pay sufficient money at the implementation stage.
?C
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
59/98
The delay of implementation increases the proect cost. It also creates many
problems and the burden of loan interest is increased.
ac% of full production or fre:uent obstruction of industry.
The initiator is unable to pay the loan installment and other liability.
The failure in payment of loan installment in time increases the burden of loan.
Inability to submit the financial statement in time.
Increase the tendency of underta%ing unfair means in preparing the papers of stoc%
materials.
0rofit from investment is decrease gradually.
The proect faces loss gradually.
The production level decreases gradually.
Ta%ing loan from various sources at a high rate.
/pplied for a large amount of loan.
+onAcooperating tendency with the loan providing ban%ers.
ac%ing of perfection in the mar%et.
3." S$ck Indu&try Ca&&$f$cat$on:G
The 4inistry of !inance and the 4inistry of Industries coAoperate to provide debt
relief and other financing assistance to bail out failing firms in a specific industry that
has been identified by the government as a F$ic% IndustryF. /ssistance may include
waiver of interest, reduction in principal, repeated rescheduling of overdue loans, of
combinations of these. / F$ic% IndustryF classification may be purchased with a
suitable bribe to the appropriate ministry, 4inistries, the 04*, and the $tanding
committee of 0arliament on !inance may be lobbied and bribed to obtain such a
classification. Billions of BT of +7B loans are written down using this techni:ue.
3.' Cau&e& of S$ckne&&:
Bangladesh $hilpa Ban% underta%es various proects by providing finance, machinery
and other aids, some proects are implemented and successful and some proects are
?'
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
60/98
failed to attain the goal and these firms are called sic% firm. There are various reasons
of sic% firm. But to discuss it easily I classify it in two classes. They areA
The reasons that are beyond die control of the proect owner9 and
The reasons that arc under control of the proect owner
The above causes are further divided into seven "(# causes. The causes are discussed below according to their importance though all of the causes are important.
3.'.1/$nanc$a Probe!&Shortage of 6ork$ng Ca($ta
The shortage of wor%ing capital is the most acute problem for maority of the sic%
industries. 2or%ing capital is re:uired to finance purchase of re:uired raw materials
and other short term needs of a proect after it is implemented. / survey shows that
1(V of the proects suffered due to shortage of capital. The problems, which lead an
industry towards sic%, are as followsA
4easurement of investment outlay and cost of the proect are not appropriate.
2hen the means of financing is not available.
2hen the proect is not profitable.
2hen the production is not reached at the brea%Aeven point.
oan application with insufficient amount of money that would not meet fi-ed
and operation cost.
2hen they canDt calculate appropriate ris% level of sic%.
7ash flow of the proect is not available.
If actual cost of the proect is more than the budgeted cost.
$hortage of wor%ing capital, i.e. if they do not manage the sufficient
wor%ing capital.
If mar%et interest rate increase, cost of wor%ing capital increase as a result the
proect may become in sic%.
ac% of operating capital.
J
-
8/9/2019 Final Shilpabank-Farhad[1].doc
61/98
;igher fi-ed cost, i.e. increase fi-ed cost as a result of increasing of the price
of machinery, land or any other fi-ed items.
2hen variable cost increase.
oes not ensure sufficient mortgage.
Improper inspection of Ban% financed proect.
Insufficient insurance facility.
6conomic problem comes from the social cost benefit analyses.
3.'.2 *arket$ng Probe!:
4ar%eting problems are the ne-t serious problem. This problem occurs due to a large
number of similar industries and the availability of the products in the secondary
mar%et by unauthorized import of such products. / survey reveals that )&g