final report prepared for: prepared by - barrie hall/planning-and-development/proposed... ·...

25
Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited, 681- 685 Yonge Street, Barrie, Ontario – Noise Impact Feasibility Study FINAL REPORT Prepared for: Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited 206 - 4370 Steeles Avenue West, Vaughan, ON L4L 4Y4 Prepared by: Stantec Consulting Ltd. 300W-675 Cochrane Dr Markham, ON L3R 0B8 FILE 160950989 August 4, 2017

Upload: dinhlien

Post on 30-Jul-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited, 681-685 Yonge Street, Barrie, Ontario – Noise Impact Feasibility Study

FINAL REPORT

Prepared for: Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited 206 - 4370 Steeles Avenue West, Vaughan, ON L4L 4Y4

Prepared by: Stantec Consulting Ltd. 300W-675 Cochrane Dr Markham, ON L3R 0B8

FILE 160950989

August 4, 2017

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Table of Contents

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................... I

1.0 INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................1.1

2.0 OBJECTIVE LIMITS ........................................................................................................2.1

3.0 SOURCES AND METHODS ............................................................................................3.1 3.1 TRANSPORTATION .......................................................................................................... 3.1

4.0 TRANSPORTATION ASSESSMENT RESULTS ....................................................................4.1

5.0 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS ...................................................................5.1 5.1 RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................................................... 5.2

5.1.1 Exterior Wall .................................................................................................. 5.2 5.1.2 Window Assembly ....................................................................................... 5.2 5.1.3 Ventilation .................................................................................................... 5.2 5.1.4 Noise Warning Clause ................................................................................. 5.3

6.0 CONCLUSIONS AND CLOSURE ...................................................................................6.1

7.0 REFERENCES .................................................................................................................7.1

LIST OF TABLES Table 2-1: NPC-300 Sound Level Criteria for Transportation Sources ..................... 2.2 Table 3-1: Point of Reception Locations ..................................................................... 3.1 Table 3-2: Road Traffic Data ........................................................................................ 3.2 Table 4-1: Road Traffic Model Results (Dwelling Unit) ............................................... 4.1 Table 4-2: Road Traffic Model OLA Results ................................................................. 4.2 Table 5-1: Recommended MOECC Dwelling Unit Mitigation Matrix ...................... 5.1 Table 5-2: Recommended MOECC OLA Mitigation Matrix ..................................... 5.2

LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Site Plan Showing Receptor Locations ................................................................... 3.3

LIST OF APPENDICES

SITE PLAN

ZONING MAP

SAMPLE STAMSON CALCULATIONS

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

i

Executive Summary

Stantec Consulting Ltd. (Stantec) was retained by Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited to prepare a noise impact study for submission to the City of Barrie (the City) as part of a site plan application as required for new proposed residential developments. The study focuses on the traffic noise impact from Yonge Street on the proposed development (the Development) as required by the City’s Engineering Department. The purpose of the study is to determine whether the Development can be feasibly constructed in compliance with the Ministry of Environment and Climate Change’s (MOECC) noise objectives. The Development is located at 681-685 Yonge Street in Barrie, Ontario. The Development is immediately surrounded by Yonge Street to the south, Ashford Drive to the east, and existing residential to the north and west.

The traffic noise impact on the Development, Finally, warning clauses are recommended to be included in pertinent Offers of Purchase or Sales and Lease or Rental Agreements. Recommendations for the exterior wall assembly, ventilation system and window are also provided.

Based on the assessment it is concluded that it is feasible to achieve the MOECC’s noise objectives for the proposed development with the implementation of recommended noise controls. Warning clauses are also recommended to be included in pertinent Offers of Purchase or Sales and Lease or Rental Agreements. Recommendations to meet the noise objectives are provided in Section 5.0 of this report.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Introduction August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 1.1

1.0 INTRODUCTION

Stantec was retained by Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited to conduct a noise impact study for a proposed residential development located at 681-685 Yonge Street in Barrie, Ontario. A site plan and site location is provided in Appendix A. The study assesses the future noise contribution from nearby road traffic (i.e., Yonge Street and Ashford Road) on the Development. This report is prepared in support of the site plan application required for the by the City’s Engineering Department.

The development is located on a plot of land with Yonge Street to the south, Ashford Drive to the east, and residential dwellings adjacent to the north and west. The development consists of 33 townhouse units which are 3 storeys high. The townhouses are separated into 6 blocks along 3 rows.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Objective Limits August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 2.1

2.0 OBJECTIVE LIMITS

Noise is recognized as a pollutant in the Environmental Protection Act, as it can affect many human activities. Municipal and provincial noise control guidelines in Ontario require that noise concerns be considered in the planning of any new development, preferably at the earliest stages.

In land use planning, although elimination or control of the pollution source is usually a primary objective, there are general limits as to what is practical and technically possible. This is particularly applicable to noise impacts. The City, under transfer from the Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change (MOECC), has authority to assess noise impacts from road sources adjacent to new residential developments.

The City of Barrie noise by-law 2006-140 (City of Barrie 2012) outlines several technical MOECC publications that form part of this recommended noise control by-law. This by-law does not specifically provide quantitative limits for assessing noise for urban planning and therefore was not used.

Noise criteria for transportation sources is addressed and outlined in the MOECC publication NPC-300 Environmental Noise Guideline – Stationary and Transportation Sources – Approval and Planning” (MOECC 2013), and therefore was used to assess the impact due to noise. A summary of the sound level objectives contained NPC-300 are listed in Table 2-1 for road traffic.

The criteria in Table 2-1 is the maximum noise objectives (sound level limits) beyond which mitigation or control measures are recommended in accordance with NPC-300. These measures can take the form of ventilation requirements, architectural design, warning clauses, building component construction, or noise barriers. Sound from surface transportation sources (i.e., road) are to be assessed to consider ventilation and warning clause requirements.

As detailed in NPC-300, road traffic sound level limits are 55 dBA during the daytime in Outdoor Living Areas and 50 dBA during the nighttime at the plane of window of the applicable living space. These limits are used to assess the need to specify building components beyond the OBC minimum requirements to ensure that indoor sound levels will be met.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Objective Limits August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 2.2

Table 2-1: NPC-300 Sound Level Criteria for Transportation Sources

Assessment Location

Daytime Sound Level Limit (07:00 h - 23:00 h)

Leq 16-hr1 (dBA)

Nighttime Sound Level Limit (23:00 h - 07:00 h)

Leq 8-hr2 (dBA)

Outdoor Living Area (OLA)3 55 N/A

Indoor Living Area4 45 40

Notes: 1 Daytime transportation noise averaged over 16 hour daytime period (07:00 to 23:00). 2 Daytime transportation noise averaged over 8 hour nighttime period (23:00 to 07:00). 3 OLA sound levels are predicted at a height of 1.5 m. It is defined as the common outdoor area allocated for recreational uses (e.g. an apartment or balcony with a depth of greater than 4m). 4 Indoor criteria are applied in a living room or similar during the daytime period and in sleeping quarter/bedrooms during the nighttime.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Sources and Methods August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 3.1

3.0 SOURCES AND METHODS

Yonge Street is a four lane arterial road running east and west to the south of the Development. Ashford Road is a primary access road from Yonge Street to St. Peter’s Catholic Secondary School, Saint John Paul II Separate School, and the surrounding residential area. Ashford Road runs north of Yonge Street and is to the east of the development. Residential side roads Kenneth Avenue and Montgomery Drive are located to the north and west of the Development. The land to the south of the Development, across the street from Yonge Street, is zoned for a commercial shopping centre. A zoning map of the Development location is provided in Appendix B.

3.1 TRANSPORTATION

Sound propagation calculations for the study were conducted in accordance with the methods defined in Ontario Road Noise Analysis Method for Environment and Transportation (ORNAMENT) (MOECC 1989). The analysis was performed using STAMSON V5.04, a computerized implementation of the methods contained in ORNAMENT. The model was created with site-specific parameters determined from the site plan in Appendix A and traffic volume data provided by the City.

Representative receptor locations for the buildings and the outdoor living area (OLA) between rows 2 and 3 were chosen based on their exposure to the roads discussed previously (i.e. locations most impacted by traffic noise). The indoor sound level limit was assessed at the third storey, 7.5 m above grade, for both daytime and nighttime. The OLA sound level limit was assessed during the daytime period, 3 m away from the midpoint of the applicable façade and 1.5 m above grade (as outlined in NPC-300). Points of reception (POR), along with their associated building block and unit numbers, based on the site plan included in the study, are summarized in Table 3-1 and shown in Figure 1.

Table 3-1: Point of Reception Locations

Point of Reception

ID

Building Block

Unit Number

Building Façade

UTM Coordinates (NAD 83, Zone 17 T)

Easting (m) Northing (m)

POR01 A 1 North 608280 4912225

POR02 A 1 East 608279 4912217

POR03 D 22 East 608274 4912203

POR04 D 22 South 608271 4912202

POR05 E 23 East 608254 4912191

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Sources and Methods August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 3.2

Point of Reception

ID

Building Block

Unit Number

Building Façade

UTM Coordinates (NAD 83, Zone 17 T)

Easting (m) Northing (m)

POR06 E 23 South 608252 4912190

POR07 F 33 South 608188 4912221

POR08 F 33 West 608187 4912224

POR09 C 12 West 608209 4912241

POR10 B 11 West 608212 4912250

POR111 A N/A South1 608275 4912215 Note: 1 OLA receptor location selected as 3 m from mid-point of façade of the building to the south, 1.5 m above

grade (as required in NPC-300).

Noise impacts on the development due to road traffic on Yonge Street and Ashford Drive were assessed. Traffic data for the year 2017 was provided by the City. This information included average annual daily traffic (AADT) counts and a traffic breakdown of 4% commercial and heavy trucks. A typical Ministry of Transportation of Ontario (MTO) day/night traffic split of 90%/10% was assumed. Traffic volume growth rates of 3.5% and 1% were used for Yonge Street and Ashford Drive, respectively. These growth rates were used to determine the projected AADT for the year 2027 (10-year projection as recommended in NPC-300).

Table 3-2 displays the AADTs for the roads, truck breakdown information, forecasted traffic counts, and posted speed limits.

Table 3-2: Road Traffic Data

Road

Traffic Volume Medium Trucks1

Heavy Trucks1

Posted Speed Limit (km/h) Current

(2017)

Mature Sate of Development

(2027)

Yonge St. 15,000 21,158 0.8% 3.2% 50

Ashford Dr. 5,000 5,523 0.8% 3.2% 50 Note: 1 Medium/heavy truck split of 25 %/75 % was assumed from the overall 4% of commercial truck traffic, resulting in

0.8% medium truck and 3.2% heavy truck.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Sources and Methods August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 3.3

Figure 1: Site Plan Showing Receptor Locations

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Transportation Assessment Results August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 4.1

4.0 TRANSPORTATION ASSESSMENT RESULTS

The predicted noise levels from transportation sources were assessed per MOECC NPC-300. Each noise source was assessed at the most impacted points of reception as shown in Figure 1.

Prediction results for the outdoor plane of window during the daytime and nighttime periods are presented in Table 4-1. The most basic building construction allowed under the Ontario Building Code (OBC) is expected to achieve a noise reduction of 20 dB between outdoor and indoor sound levels. However, to be conservative, the indoor sound level was assumed to be 10 dB less than that predicted at the outdoor plane of window. These prediction results are provided in Table 4-1 for PORs representing dwelling units (POR01 to POR10) and Table 4-2 for the OLA (POR11) during the daytime period.

Sound level predictions for the representative point of reception locations are provided in Appendix C as an output of STAMSON.

Table 4-1: Road Traffic Model Results (Dwelling Unit)

Receptor ID

Predicted Future (2027) Noise Levels due to Road Traffic Indoor

Sound Level (Day)

Leq 16-hr (dBA)1

Indoor Sound Level

(Night) Leq 8-hr (dBA)1

Meets Sound Level Limit? (Yes or No)

Outdoor Plane of Living Room

Window (Day) Leq 16-hr (dBA)

Outdoor Plane of Bedroom Window

(Night) Leq 8-hr (dBA)

Day (45 dBA)

Night (40 dBA)

POR01 (north façade of unit 1)

59 52 49 42 No No

POR02 (east façade of unit 1)

64 57 54 47 No No

POR03 (east façade of unit 22)

64 58 54 48 No No

POR04 (south façade of unit 22)

64 57 54 47 No No

POR05 (east façade of unit 23)

65 58 55 48 No No

POR06 (south façade of unit 23)

68 61 58 51 No No

POR07 (south façade of unit 33)

67 61 57 51 No No

POR08 (west façade of unit 33)

64 57 54 47 No No

POR09 (west façade of unit 12)

57 51 47 41 No No

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Transportation Assessment Results August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 4.2

Receptor ID

Predicted Future (2027) Noise Levels due to Road Traffic Indoor

Sound Level (Day)

Leq 16-hr (dBA)1

Indoor Sound Level

(Night) Leq 8-hr (dBA)1

Meets Sound Level Limit? (Yes or No)

Outdoor Plane of Living Room

Window (Day) Leq 16-hr (dBA)

Outdoor Plane of Bedroom Window

(Night) Leq 8-hr (dBA)

Day (45 dBA)

Night (40 dBA)

POR10 (west façade of unit 11)

58 51 48 41 No No

Note: 1 Indoor sound level taken as 10 dB less than the calculated value at outdoor plane of window.

Table 4-2: Road Traffic Model OLA Results

Receptor ID Predicted 2027 Noise Level OLA (day) Leq 16-hr (dBA)

Meets Daytime Sound Level Limit (55 dBA)? (Yes or No)

POR11 (OLA of unit 1) 60 No

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Discussion and Recommendations August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 5.1

5.0 DISCUSSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Based on MOECC’s criteria, dwelling unit mitigation measures are not recommended for daytime levels less than 55 dBA. However, sound levels greater than 55 dBA and less than 65 dBA, the guideline recommends providing forced air ventilation with provisions for central air conditioning, warning clauses, and building material meeting minimum Ontario building code requirements (OBC). For sound levels greater than 65 dBA, central air-conditioning and warnings clauses along with building material selected to meet the indoor levels are recommended.

Table 5-1 indicates whether warning clauses, forced air heating, central air conditioning, or building components in excess of the OBC minimum are recommended.

Table 5-1: Recommended MOECC Dwelling Unit Mitigation Matrix

Receptor ID

Predicted Future (2027) Noise Levels due to Road Traffic Indoor Ventilation

Building Component

Outdoor Plane of Living Room Window (Day)

Leq 16-hr (dBA)

Outdoor Plane of Bedroom

Window (Night) Leq 8-hr (dBA)

NWC and including forced

air heating 56-65 dBA (day) 51-60 dBA (night)

NWC and including central air

conditioning >65 dBA (day) >60 dBA (night)

Greater than OBC minimum

construction to meet indoor

sound level limit >65 dBA (day) >60 dBA (night)

POR01 (north façade of unit 1)

59 52 Yes No No

POR02 (east façade of unit 1)

64 57 Yes No No

POR03 (east façade of unit 22)

64 58 Yes No No

POR04 (south façade of unit 22)

64 57 Yes No No

POR05 (east façade of unit 23)

65 58 Yes No No

POR06 (south façade of unit 23)

68 61 Yes Yes Yes

POR07 (south façade of unit 33)

67 61 Yes Yes Yes

POR08 (west façade of unit 33)

64 57 Yes No No

POR09 (west façade of unit 12)

57 51 Yes No No

POR10 (west façade of unit 11)

58 51 Yes No No

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Discussion and Recommendations August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 5.2

Based on MOECC’s criteria, OLA mitigation measures are not recommended for daytime sound levels less than 55 dBA. However, for sound levels greater than 55 dBA and less than or equal to 60 dBA, the guideline recommends either prospective buyers be notified of potential the noise through warning clauses, or noise control measure be implemented to reduce the sound level to 55 dBA. For sound levels greater than 60 dBA, noise control measures should be implemented to reduce the level to 55 dBA. In cases where noise control measures are not feasible due to technical, economic or administrative reasons, the sound level may exceed 55 dBA. However, in such cases, a sound level in excess of 60 dBA would not be acceptable. Table 5-2 indicates whether noise warning clauses and/or mitigation measures are recommended.

Table 5-2: Recommended MOECC OLA Mitigation Matrix

Receptor Predicted 2027 Noise Level OLA (day) Leq 16-hr (dBA)

Mitigation Action

POR11 (OLA of unit 1) 60 Noise Warning Clause, or Reduce sound level to 55 dBA

5.1 RECOMMENDATIONS

Recommendations to control the impact road traffic has on the Development are discussed below.

5.1.1 Exterior Wall

For the development, exterior walls exceeding the OBC’s minimum requirements are required for the east and south walls of units in Block E and the west and south walls for units in Block F. This is due to the elevated sound levels from Yonge Street. It is recommended an exterior assembly providing a STC 40 rating or better should be included for all buildings.

5.1.2 Window Assembly

It is recommended that window glazing assembly providing a STC 30 rating or better should be included for all buildings. Typically, window assemblies include a small operable portion within the window assembly. Good weather seals should be included for this operable portion to minimize the noise flanking.

5.1.3 Ventilation

It is recommended that all units within the Development are provided with central air conditioning to allow windows and exterior door to remain closed.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Discussion and Recommendations August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 5.3

5.1.4 Noise Warning Clause

Based on the study results for the PORs representing dwelling units (POR01 to POR10), it is recommended that the warning clauses be included in all offers of purchase and sale, and lease or rental agreements to comply with NPC-300. The study results for the OLA (POR11) affords the option of either mitigation or providing notice to prospective purchasers or tenants using a noise warning clause to comply with NPC-300. It is recommended that a noise warning clause be selected to be included in all offers of purchase and sale, and lease or rental agreements.

Appropriate wording for the noise warning clauses is provided below and can be altered as required by the City.

Noise Warning Clause for All Blocks (Type A):

“Purchasers/tenants are advised that sound levels due to increasing road traffic may occasionally interfere with some activities of the dwelling occupants as the sound levels exceed the sound level limits of the City of Barrie and the Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change.”

Noise Warning Clause for All Blocks (Type D):

“This dwelling unit has been supplied with a central air conditioning system which will allow windows and exterior doors to remain closed, thereby ensuring that the indoor sound levels are within the sound level limits of the City of Barrie and the Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change.”

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Conclusions And Closure August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 6.1

6.0 CONCLUSIONS AND CLOSURE

Based on the result of this noise impact study it is concluded that Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited’s proposed development can be constructed in compliance with the MOECC’s noise objectives with the implementation of the following recommendations:

• Incorporate central air conditioning. Noise Warning clauses as described in Section 5.0 should be included in pertinent Offers of Purchase or Sale and Lease or Rental Agreements.

• Detailed plans should be reviewed to confirm that no balcony (outdoor living area) greater than 4 m in depth or additional amenity areas are provided within the development

• Preliminary exterior wall and window assembly is discussed within this report and should be confirmed based on final layout plans.

• An acoustical engineer registered to practice in the Province of Ontario or approved professional from the City’s building department must certify that the building plan includes all required noise controls.

Once the site plan is finalized, including building floor plan and suites layout plans, this noise impact feasibility study should be updated with a detailed noise impact study.

This report has been prepared on behalf of Ashford and Yonge Developments Limited (the Client). The analysis and conclusions highlighted in this report are based on information obtained from the Client and their representatives. This assessment represents the information available and provided at the time of assessment and the conclusions are the best judgment of the assessor based on current environmental standards. Stantec Consulting Ltd. attests that to the best of our knowledge, the information presented in this report is accurate.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

References August 4, 2017

as \\cd1215-f01\work_group\01609\active\160950989\planning\report\final\rpt_160950989_681-685-yonge-st_20170804_fin.docx 7.1

7.0 REFERENCES

City of Barrie. By-Law No. 2006-140. February, 2012. Available at: http://www.barrie.ca/City%20Hall/ByLaws/BylawDocs/Noise%20By-law.pdf. Accessed June 2017.

Ontario Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change. 1989. Ontario Road Noise Analysis Method for Environment and Transportation, ORNAMENT. October, 1989.

Ontario Ministry of the Environment and Climate Change. 2013. Environmental Noise Guideline – Stationary and Transportation Sources – Approval and Planning Publication NPC-300. August, 2013.

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Appendix A Site Plan August 4, 2017

SITE PLAN

F I R E R O U T E

BLOCK A7 UNITS

BLOCK D7 UNITS

BLOCK F7 UNITS

BLOCK C7 UNITS

BLOCK B7 UNITS

BLOCK E7 UNITS

BELOW GRADE'ENVIROWIRX'

GARBAGE STOR.

2.0m FENCE

Y O N G E S T R E E T

A S

H F

O R

D

D R

I V

E

VISITOR PARKINGSIGN

V VMICHAEL & JAMES BOSEOUSKI

681-685 YONGE STREET,BARRIE, ON

ARCHITECTS

2853

OF

LICENCEIAN S. MALCOLM

05.05.2017

PROJECT

PROJECT INFORMATION

DRAWING

DRAWING No.

CLIENT

ORIENTATION

STAMP

No. ISSUE/ REVISION DATE

PROJECT No.:DRAWN BY:CHECKED BY:DATE:SCALE:

173934MMISM

AS NOTED

DO

NO

T SC

ALE

DR

AWIN

GS.

THE

CO

NTR

ACTO

R S

HAL

L C

HEC

K AN

D V

ERIF

Y AL

L D

IMEN

SIO

NS

AND

REP

OR

T AL

L ER

RO

RS

AND

OM

ISSI

ON

S TO

TH

E A

RC

HIT

ECT

BEFO

RE

PRO

CEE

DIN

G W

ITH

TH

E W

OR

K.

AD

ETAI

L N

o.B

SHEE

T N

o. W

HER

E D

ETAI

LED

A B

33 TOWNHOMES

ISM

AR

CH

ITEC

TS17

4 Ba

yfie

ld S

treet

Barri

e, O

N

L4M

3B5

T: 7

05.7

26.2

342

E: i

an@

ism

arch

itect

s.ca

1 CLIENT REVIEW MAY 01/17

SITE PLAN

A100

DRAWING PROVIDED FOR ILLUSTRATIVE PURPOSES

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Appendix B Zoning Map August 4, 2017

ZONING MAP

Proposed Development Location

Huronia R

d

Central Area Commercial (C1, C1-1, C1-2)

Transation Centre Commercial (C2, C2-1, C2-2)

Shopping Centre Commercial (C3)

General Commercial (C4)

Convenience Commercial (C5)

Residential Single Detached Dwelling First Density (R1)

Residential Single Detached Dwelling Second Density (R2, R2-WS)

Residential Single Detached Dwelling Third Density (R3, R3-WS)

Residential Single Detached Dwelling Four Density (R4, R4-WS)

Residential Apartment Dwelling First Density (RA1, RA1-1, RA1-2, RA1-3)

Residential Apartment Dwelling Second Density(RA2, RA2-1, RA2-2)

Residential Hold (RH)

Residential Multiple Dwelling First Density (RM1; RM1-SS, RM1-WS)

Residential Multiple Dwelling Second Density (RM2)

Residential Multiple Dwelling Second Density (RM2-TH, RM2-TH WS)

Institutional (I)

Educational Institutional (I-E)

Major Institutional (I-M, I-M-1)

Environmental Protection Area (EP)

Open Space (OS)

Agriculture (A)

Business Park (BP)

Highway Industrial (HI)

Light Industrial (LI)

General Industrial (GI)

Restrictive Industrial (RI)

Municipal Services and Utilities (MSU)

City Centre Revitalization Area

Application Currently Before the Ontario Municipal Board

City Boundary

Parcels

Water

ASHFORD AND YONGE DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED, 681-685 YONGE STREET, BARRIE, ONTARIO – NOISE IMPACT FEASIBILITY STUDY

Appendix C Sample Stamson Calculations August 4, 2017

SAMPLE STAMSON CALCULATIONS

POR06.txtSTAMSON 5.0 NORMAL REPORT Date: 25-07-2017 11:20:50MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY / NOISE ASSESSMENT

Filename: POR06.te Time Period: Day/Night 16/8 hoursDescription: POR06 Block E Unit 23 South Side

Road data, segment # 1: Ashford Dr (day/night)----------------------------------------------Car traffic volume : 4772/530 veh/TimePeriod *Medium truck volume : 40/4 veh/TimePeriod *Heavy truck volume : 159/18 veh/TimePeriod *Posted speed limit : 50 km/hRoad gradient : 1 %Road pavement : 1 (Typical asphalt or concrete)

* Refers to calculated road volumes based on the following input:

24 hr Traffic Volume (AADT or SADT): 5000 Percentage of Annual Growth : 1.00 Number of Years of Growth : 10.00 Medium Truck % of Total Volume : 0.80 Heavy Truck % of Total Volume : 3.20 Day (16 hrs) % of Total Volume : 90.00

Data for Segment # 1: Ashford Dr (day/night)--------------------------------------------Angle1 Angle2 : 0.00 deg 90.00 degWood depth : 0 (No woods.)No of house rows : 0 / 0 Surface : 2 (Reflective ground surface)Receiver source distance : 29.50 / 29.50 mReceiver height : 7.50 / 7.50 mTopography : 1 (Flat/gentle slope; no barrier)Reference angle : 0.00

�Road data, segment # 2: Yonge St (day/night)--------------------------------------------Car traffic volume : 18281/2031 veh/TimePeriod *Medium truck volume : 152/17 veh/TimePeriod *Heavy truck volume : 609/68 veh/TimePeriod *Posted speed limit : 50 km/hRoad gradient : 1 %Road pavement : 1 (Typical asphalt or concrete)

* Refers to calculated road volumes based on the following input:

24 hr Traffic Volume (AADT or SADT): 15000 Percentage of Annual Growth : 3.50 Number of Years of Growth : 10.00 Medium Truck % of Total Volume : 0.80 Heavy Truck % of Total Volume : 3.20 Day (16 hrs) % of Total Volume : 90.00

Data for Segment # 2: Yonge St (day/night)------------------------------------------Angle1 Angle2 : -90.00 deg 90.00 degWood depth : 0 (No woods.)No of house rows : 0 / 0 Surface : 2 (Reflective ground surface)Receiver source distance : 16.60 / 16.60 mReceiver height : 7.50 / 7.50 m

Page 1

POR06.txtTopography : 1 (Flat/gentle slope; no barrier)Reference angle : 0.00

�Results segment # 1: Ashford Dr (day)-------------------------------------

Source height = 1.34 m

ROAD (0.00 + 55.96 + 0.00) = 55.96 dBAAngle1 Angle2 Alpha RefLeq P.Adj D.Adj F.Adj W.Adj H.Adj B.Adj SubLeq---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 0 90 0.00 61.91 0.00 -2.94 -3.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 55.96----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Segment Leq : 55.96 dBA

�Results segment # 2: Yonge St (day)-----------------------------------

Source height = 1.34 m

ROAD (0.00 + 67.30 + 0.00) = 67.30 dBAAngle1 Angle2 Alpha RefLeq P.Adj D.Adj F.Adj W.Adj H.Adj B.Adj SubLeq---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -90 90 0.00 67.74 0.00 -0.44 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 67.30----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Segment Leq : 67.30 dBA

Total Leq All Segments: 67.61 dBA

�Results segment # 1: Ashford Dr (night)---------------------------------------

Source height = 1.34 m

ROAD (0.00 + 49.47 + 0.00) = 49.47 dBAAngle1 Angle2 Alpha RefLeq P.Adj D.Adj F.Adj W.Adj H.Adj B.Adj SubLeq---------------------------------------------------------------------------- 0 90 0.00 55.41 0.00 -2.94 -3.01 0.00 0.00 0.00 49.47----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Segment Leq : 49.47 dBA

�Results segment # 2: Yonge St (night)-------------------------------------

Source height = 1.34 m

ROAD (0.00 + 60.78 + 0.00) = 60.78 dBAAngle1 Angle2 Alpha RefLeq P.Adj D.Adj F.Adj W.Adj H.Adj B.Adj SubLeq---------------------------------------------------------------------------- -90 90 0.00 61.22 0.00 -0.44 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 60.78----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Segment Leq : 60.78 dBA

Total Leq All Segments: 61.09 dBA

Page 2

POR06.txt�

TOTAL Leq FROM ALL SOURCES (DAY): 67.61 (NIGHT): 61.09��

Page 3