final presentation for bangladesh annual review meeting
TRANSCRIPT
Mapping at Destination
Modicare Foundation & Anchal Charitable Trust
1
City or Intervention Map
2
5
Sub-location – Shalimar garden details
• Name of Location: Jhilmil (East Delhi/U.P Border)
• Name of sub-location: Shalimar Garden
Map of sub-location - 2
Mobility Route and Pattern
Pattern of mobility (time, means, regularity, further mobility in India)
Most of the mobile population visits their native place once in a six months or at least in a year
Mobile Population goes to Nepal seasonally esp. Deepawali,Holi,Teej(Up & Down)
They prefer to travel by road whereas a small number travels by train
Time required for the same varies. Kanchanpur and Accham required 10-12 hours by road
Mobility Routes1.Kanchanpur to Banbasa than Anand Vihar Delhi. (By road)
2.Accham to Kanchanpur than Banbasa and than Anand Vihar Delhi. (By road)
Further Mobility within Delhi & NCR has been observed (Lajpat Nagar,Sahibabad and Tahirpur)
Mostly Mobile Population visited to Mumbai, Bangalore and some goes to Gujrat (Barodara and Ahemdabad)
Overall details of mobile population
Total Single With family
% age who are in India for < 5 years
% age who are in locality for < 5 years
People from Nepal
24000-26000
9000-10000
15000-16000
70 - 75 %
60 – 65 %
People from Accham/ Kanchanpur
6000-7000
2500 - 3000
3500-4000
70 – 75 %
60 – 65 %
Overall details of mobile populationPeople from Nepal People from Accham /Kanchanpur
Location 1 Kashmiri Gate/Chandni Chowk
Sub-location (1a) Nepali park
170 - 200 30 - 35
Sub-location (1b) Guru Nanak Market
250 – 300 70 – 100
Sub-location (1c) Chavi Ganj
300 - 350 150 – 200
Sub-location (1d) Mori Gate
100 - 150 70 - 75
Sub-location (1e) Old Lajpat Rai Market
400 - 500 40 – 50
Sub-location (1f) New Lajpat Rai market
200 - 250 40 – 50
Sub-location (1g) Bhagirath Place
200 - 250 0
Total 1520 - 2000 400 – 510
People from Nepal / Bangladesh
People from Accham/Kanchanpur
Location 2 Kingsway Camp/Model Town
Sub-location (2a) Mukherji Nagar
250 - 300 100 – 150
Sub-location (2b) Nirankari Colony
300 - 400 250 – 300
Sub-location (2c) Malikpur
250 - 300 40 – 50
Sub-location (2d) Indira Vikas Colony
200 - 250 100 – 150
Sub-location (2e) Sant Nagar / Burari
1500 - 2000 150 – 200
Sub-location (2f) Outerm Lane
400 - 500 150 - 200
Total 2900 - 3750 790 - 1050
People from Nepal / Bangladesh People from Accham/Kanchanpur
Location 3 Jhilmil (East Delhi/ U.P Border)
Sub-location (3a) Chitra Vihar
125 – 150 10 – 15
Sub-location (3b) Sonia Camp
300 - 400 10 – 12
Sub-location (3c) Ambedkar Camp
100 - 200 10 – 15
Sub-location (3d) Maharajpur
275 - 300 40 – 50
Sub-location (3e) Old Seema Puri
250 - 300 50 – 60
Sub-location (3f) Karkarduma Village
250 - 300 20 – 30
Sub-location (3g) Ghondli
250 - 300 100n – 150
Sub-location (3f) Shalimar Garden
4000 - 4500 2400 - 2500
Sub-location (3f) New Seema Puri Tahirpur
1400 - 1500 300 - 350
Total 6950 - 7950 2940 – 3127
People from Nepal / Bangladesh
People from Accham/Kanchanpur
Location 4 Azadpur
Sub-location (4a) Transport center/ Mandi
700 - 1000 150 – 200
Sub-location (4b) Sanjay Gandhi TPT Nagar
250 - 300 50 – 100
Total 950 - 1300 200 – 300
Location 5 Noida
Sub-location (5a) Mamura Sector-66
250 - 300 25 – 50
Sub-location (5b) Harola Market Sector-5
3000 - 3500 250 – 300
Sub-location (5c) Noida Sector-9
100 - 150 20 – 30
Sub-location (5d) Khoda 500 - 600 50 – 60
Sub-location (5e) Mayur Vihar (1,2,3)
300 - 400 60 – 70
Total 4150 - 4950 405 - 510
People from Nepal People from Accham / Kanchanpur
Naraina (L) 787 80
Naraina Vill. (SL) 515 75
Rajeev Gandhi Camp (SL) 272 5
J.J. colony, Indrapuri (L) 420 50
AB & WZ (SL) 145 2
CDEF (SL) 275 48
Kirti Nagar (L) 240 20
Chuna Bhatti (SL) 132 20
Indra Camp (SL) 108 0
Kapas Hera (L) 800 100
Radha Krishan Mandir Side (SL)
560 70
Oberoi farm side (SL) 240 30
People from Nepal People from Accham / Kanchanpur
Gurgaon (L) 2550 450
Sarhual Vill. (SL) 1540 400
Sukhrali (SL) 348 10
Nathupur (SL) 422 20
Sikanderpur (SL) 240 20
Okhla (L) 1356 0
Janta Jeevan Camp (SL) 404 0
Mazdoor Janta Camp (SL) 356 0
Tehkand (SL) 596 0
Harkesh Nagar (L) 1337 0
G.H. (SL) 550 0
Sanjay Colony (SL) 137 0
ABCDEFI blocks (SL) 650 0
People from Nepal People from Accham / Kanchanpur
Zamdurpur (L) 405 30
Zamrudpur Vill. (SL) 171 15
Punjabi Mohalla (SL) 234 15
Garhi (L) 500 50
Shera&Kallu Mohalla (SL) 330 35
Prakash&Mumraj Mohalla (SL)
170 15
Overall mobile population details• Nature of occupation – varies among men and women. The major sectors in which
Nepali mobile population get engaged are/as restaurant worker either big or roadside ‘Dhaba’, Factory worker, Watchmen, Driver, domestic help, rikshaw-puller
Language – Nepal is a multi-linguistic nation with more than 11 regional languages. Most common languages are- Nepali, Hindi, Maithili, Tharu, Gurung, Tamang, Magar etc.
• Literacy level – among the mobile population of the all locations seems to be good. But formal schooling esp. among middle aged is very less. A good number of young generation completes their primary & secondary
• Festivals, gatherings, events- Teej, Dushera & Nepali New year are major festivals & events in which major gathering & celebration takes place at various locations which unites them as well.
• Living conditions (basic amenities) – In most of the
Work / Sex / SocietyOccupation Restaurant worker either big or roadside ‘Dhaba’, Factory
worker, Watchmen, Driver, domestic help etc
Working conditions Long working hours, less pay for same amount of work (shared at few location)
Patterns of sexual behaviour Single & unaccompanied male are more into high risk behaviour. Teen age marriage, prevalence of abortions and miscarriages
Entertainment activities and peer pressure for entertainment and sexual behaviour
Younger generation gets involves into sports and music. Gambling is more prominent among middle-aged. Alcoholism is very much prominent.
Social structure and conflict resolving mechanisms
At some location the prevalence of class & caste system was observed. Within the community or police.
15
Health profile and access to health servicesOccurrence of STIs A few cases of STIs were reported to the
team during IDIs
Condoms and other contraceptive use Quite satisfactory. Condom is more used as a mean for birth control.
Substance abuse (alcohol, drugs) Alcoholism is one of the major problem with this community.
Instances of HIV+ cases 4 cases of HIV was shared but none of them resides in the locality any more.
Access to primary health care services (public or private)
Access to govt. primary health services is very less due to the distance factor
Confidential RH services in the community
Maternity dispensaries available in 2 locations
HIV testing services (ICCTC) St. John Ambulance Post, Bijwasan, ESI okhla, many more but not accessed
16
Awareness
Awareness on STI Not familiar with the terminology but aware about signs & symptoms (both male & female).
Awareness on HIV/AIDS Basic information among male is quite satisfactory
Awareness on laws protecting mobile population
Community leaders or seniors are aware about some aspect of the Indo-Nepal treaty
Awareness on local entitlements Average
17
Stigma & discrimination
S & D in the community because of their status of being mobile population (give examples of violence or discrimination)
Yes, Stigma and discrimination is very big problem in community.Example :- In Bhagirath place there is a medical shop in market and mobile population live on roof top floor in this building. One day, theft in medical shop and medical shop owner blamed on Nepali population. shop owner complained to police and also break house of Nepali population.
Are there any local laws and rules that hinder their quality of life
They do not have Indian identity card, such as voter ID or ration card due to which they are not able to take the benefit of provisions in govt rate.
Case story of a vulnerable person who has been less than 5 years
Name- Nand Ram Joshi( Name changed)Age – 25 YearsAddress – Old Lajpat Rai MarketParmanent address – Village – Barabis 2, Distt Bajura, Nepal
He works as a helper in a shop. He is living in Delhi for just under 5 years, but in the present site been for a year. He lives with his friends in a one-room shack (jhuggi) on the roof-top of a building. He earns 4000-5000 per month. He spends 2000-2500 and saves 2000-2500. Yet at times he is in debt. So he is vulnerable.
Often he has money to spend. When he drinks alcohol then he says he cannot decide what is right or wrong. Some times he visits sex worker. Also, then he doesn’t use condoms. He lacks knowledge of safe sex. He is illiterate. He has not collected information on STI. He states that no personnel from any organization, has contacted him regarding HIV. He says there is no unity among Nepalis. He goes to Nepal once a year. He doesn’t know whether HCWs use sterilized needles. He had STI after he had visited SW.
Case story of a vulnerable person who stays single
• Name- Mangal Serala (Name Changed)• Age – 32 Years• Address – Indira Vikas Colony• Parmanent address – Village – Barabis 6,Distt Bajura,Nepal
• He has come from Nepal in search of lively hood. He is living in Delhi for 3 years. He runs a tea stall. He lives with his friends in jhuggi on rent. He earns 10,000-12,000. He spends money on alcohol , some times he goes to sex worker because peer pressure. When he goes to sex worker he doesn’t use condom. His awareness level is very low. He goes to Nepal twice a year. He is not aware which types of needles are used the doctors. Once he has been infected with STI could be from the sex worker. He is single, is having money to spent and ignorant. Thus he is vulnarable.
Case story of a vulnerable person who stays with family
• Name- Suresh ( Name changed)
• Age – 36 Years• Address – Shalimar Garden• Parmanent address – Village – Mahendra Nagar,Distt
Kanchanpur,Nepal
• He lives with his family. He is having six members in his family. He is illiterate so he doesn’t have knowledge how to do family planning. He drinks alcohol every night. He doesn’t use condom neither with his wife nor with FSW. He doesn’t have much information regarding usage of condom. Many a times he and his wife are infected with STI but they do not go to any health facility to seek service. They depend on home treatment only. He visits Nepal once or twice a year. His children does not go to school because he do not earn enough to send his kids to school.
Successes• Finalization of different locations for mapping from the
scattered geographic areas of Delhi & NCR• Established effective linkages with one of the influential
stakeholders i.e, police• Due to SALT Technique good rapport building with the impact population (at least at some locations)• Mapping tools provide a handy information of our impact
population which can further be used for evaluation
studies and research• In a very short period Ning has become an integral part of
the EMPHASIS program
Challenges
•Executing the mapping exercise was challenging as the key respondents were available only on Sundays • People from North-Eastern state of India are also being referred as Nepali by the key informants or community members• Expectations of impact population intend more towards service delivery and basic amenities• Tasks have been performed in a very tight schedule therefore time management should be given a priority by CARE while formulating the country action plan in future• How to address the people from other districts of Nepal along with Achham and Kanchanpur under EMPHASIS •Vast geographical area and less number of ORW’s•The land lords / gatekeepers / care takers are at times not very cooperative
Learnings• Working along with vulnerability (mobility) has been a
learning experience itself• Team must have their Identification proof while starting
work in their respective field areas• Sathi Nepal (a program of FHI for Nepali people) has
been still in the memory of our impact population which sets the tone for our initial rapport building task. Also it leads the comparison between the two programs
• Sharing through Ning is beneficial for the program as well as the team
• Every intervention/task gives an insight as appropriately named as Knowledge Building Phase
25