feature article programmable antenna systems solutions… articles/kmw.pdf · the goal is to place...
TRANSCRIPT
By Burton Calloway,KMW Communications, Inc.
The “Last Mile” in mobile communications is the wireless connection between the
Mobile Base Station Transceiver (BTS) and the individual antenna on the mobile
phone, PDA, laptop or other mobile device. The quality of this connection deter-
mines the Quality of Service (QoS) of the voice, data or multi-media communication.
To ensure the continuous quality of wireless networks, a major industry supporting
wireless carriers has been established. This support industry consists of sophisticated
optimization software, RF engineers, RF technicians, independent site companies,
tower crews and tower equipment. Optimizing wireless networks is a substantial con-
stant expense for wireless carriers.
The two main elements in deployment are the carriers desire to optimize coverage and
capacity. At the same time, the wireless carriers want to control capital and labor expens-
es. The goal is to place BTS and antenna sites in such a way to optimize expensive net-
work carriers, minimize sites and handle the call traffic to optimize capacity and coverage
There are many variables in BTS and antenna deployments such as user density;
user time of day; traffic such as commute, enterprise, residential or special events;
user traffic type of voice, data, video and internet, geography, building density, build-
ing height and road topology.
To meet requirements that may seem mutually exclusive, virtually every type of
fixed antenna possible has been developed and deployed.
Wireless Paradigm ShiftA wireless paradigm shift is now taking place in the changing applications and
technology of wireless phones and networks. Mobile voice communications was the
initial and driving application for mobile wireless. The concept was wireline quality
mobile voice communication anytime and any place. The new Paradigm is wireline
quality mobile communication anytime, anywhere and any type. Voice is now taken
for granted and the driving applications are data, email messaging, IM, video, loca-
tion services and internet. New generations of mobile phones and devices are
designed and are being deployed at an increasing rate. To meet the requirements of
these new applications and mobile phones, wireless carriers are moving to third gen-
eration (3G) Wideband Code Division Multiple Access (WCDMA) networks with
new gateway switching enters and mobile base station (BTS) technology supported
by programmable antenna and integrated Programmable Antenna System Solutions.
Antenna GenerationsFixed downtilt antennas may be thought of as the first generation of antennas. As the
name implies, these antennas are ordered, manufactured and delivered to cell sites with
fixed characteristics in frequency, electronic downtilt, beamwidth and gain expressed in
dBi and/or dBd. dBd is expressed 2.1dB lower than dBi lo. The electronic downtilt in
the USA is typically 2°, 4° or 6°. The Beamwidth normally has increments such as 33°,
45°, 65°, 90°, 120° or 360° (Omni). Typical dBi increments are 12,14,15,16,17,18,19
and 20. Most antenna Beamwidths come in various downtilt and dBi. In general the
higher the beamwidth the lower the dBi. The issue with fixed antennas is while they
offer the lowest first costs, they can have the greatest capital and expense costs. Any
change in the deployment variables will either require additional carriers, different
antennas or antenna adjustments to meet the wireless carrier quality
of service in coverage and capacity. This results in both capital and
site expense increases.
Now a new generation of Programmable Antenna System
Solutions are being deployed to minimize capital and labor expens-
es while proving real time optimization. Programmable Antenna
System Solutions consist of programmable antennas supported by
remote programmable control hardware and software. Changes can
be either made in real time, programmed on a pre-set schedule or by
traffic conditions determinate by the wireless network.
Second generation programmable antennas provide remote elec-
tronic downtilt (EDTA). These antennas can have changes pro-
grammed either at the BTS or in the operations control center - the
downtilt of the antennas. These antennas were developed to reduce
or eliminate tower climbs particularly in expense towers like high
power, water towers or limited access sites and buildings. In addi-
tion, any down-tilt requirement change can now be accomplished in
real time with no capital and minimum labor expense.
Third generation programmable antennas incorporate both remote
electronic downtilt and horizontal azimuth steering. This concept is
so new that no industry buzz word like EDTA has taken hold.
KMW Communications has trademarked DualPhase for the com-
bined antenna. As long as no changes to beamwidth are required, no
capital and either little or no expense is necessary. Also, by being
able to easily change the azimuth to optimization direction may
remove any beamwidth change. In addition, the real benefit may be
real time optimization. More balanced sectors and increased 20 to 24 percent Erlang
site usage is common. Having an optimized network by both time
of day and types of usage allows wireless carriers to offer the high-
est quality of service to increase users, minutes and applications.
Fourth generation programmable antennas incorporate remote
electronic downtilt, horizontal azimuth steering, and beamwidth
selection with corresponding dBi change. This type of antenna is in
proof of concept, and field trials. In these trials the sectors can be
equally balanced and Erlang increases to between 40 and 50 per-
cent. This type of antenna virtually eliminates any change out of
antennas and eliminates capital and site expenses. Again, this type
of programmable antenna is so new that no industry term is avail-
able. KMW Communications has trademarked TriPhase for this
antenna. The most common trial applications is two sectors of
DualPhase and one (1) TriPhase. The TriPhase is usually installed
in the most difficult or volatile sector. This approach tends to mini-
mize coast and still increase optimization.
Control ArchitectureProgrammable Antenna System Solutions architecture consist of
antenna control configuration, antenna pattern and antenna control
hardware and software technology. Programmable Antenna configu-
rations are manual, external actuator and internal built in control
options. One method of antenna pattern control is achieved by a
control sleeve that moves across the pattern to achieve pattern
changes. The other method is phase shifting that changes the pattern
electronically rather that mechanically. The Antenna control hard-
ware and software are Portable Antenna Control (PAC) and Antenna Interface Control
Module (AICM)
Manual control changes downtilt by turning control knobs on the bottom of the
antenna by hand. Manual control is an advantage over fixed antennas in that a change
in downtilt does not require a switch of antennas. However tower crews, tower equip-
ment and substantial technician labor is required.
The external actuator is at the bottom of the antenna connected by a jumper cable
to the antenna. The antenna is controlled by electrical signals. A cable runs from the
external actuator to the bottom of the tower to control the actuator. Actuator and
tower reduction is achieved by connecting a jumper cable from all three sector anten-
nas to the actuator and connecting the actuator to one of the feeder cables trough a
Smart Bias-T. This eliminates two actuators and two tower control cables. The disad-
vantage is complexity with jumper cables and external to the antenna electronics at
the top of the tower.
A control electronic is built in to the antenna radome. With this control technique
no additional cables or actuator are needed and one of the existing feeder cables is
also used as a control. The advantage of this technology is that radomes have proven
the test of time for reliability and no extra complexity of cables or external electron-
ics are on the tower.
Programmable antenna patterns control consist of two basic types. The first and
most common is a moveable sleeve that interacts with the antenna pattern to change
the pattern. In general, the outside actuator drives the movement of this sleeve. This
sleeve approach is well developed and low cost. The potential disadvantage is having
a moving part as integrated with the pattern.
The next generation approach is to use non moveable DC feedlines to change the
bias of the pattern. This approach is
similar to the same technology used
for a fixed downtilt antenna manu-
factured at the factory. The pattern
has a different electrical characteris-
tic. To generate differ DC electrical
bias electronic delay line motors are
used. These are the same type of
motors used in aerospace and auto-
motive. The reliably has been
proven over the last 20 years in con-
tinuous use and harsh environmental
conditions. Today this approach is
slightly more expensive to manufac-
ture than the sleeve method, but it
does eliminate any moving parts in
the antenna pattern.
Programmable antenna hardware
and software consist of two types,
Portable Antenna Controller (PAC)
and Antenna Interface Controller
Module (AICM). PAC units are portable and carried by wireless technicians. Usually
only one or two PAC units are required per market. Changes are made at the base of
FFEEAATTUURREE AARRTTIICCLLEE1188
AANNTTEENNNNAA SSYYSSTTEEMMSS && TTEECCHHNNOOLLOOGGYY •• JJUULLYY//AAUUGGUUSSTT 22000066
PPrrooggrraammmmaabbllee AAnntteennnnaa SSyysstteemmss SSoolluuttiioonnss:: AA TTeecchhnnoollooggyy TThhaatt’’ss TTiimmee HHaass CCoommee
Dual-Phase
Tri-Phase
PAC-I Complete Kit
Continued on page 21
EEDDOO RReecceeiivveess CCoonnttrraacctt ffoorr NNaavvyy AAnntteennnnaassEDO Corp. has been awarded a five-year contract to provide the US Navy with signal-
intelligence-gathering antennas. The $10 million indefinite-delivery/indefinite-quantity
contract is for the procurement of up to 273 antennas and related engineering services.
This receive-only CA-3138-1 antenna was developed in cooperation with the US
Navy Radio Frequency and Antenna Branch at Space and Naval Warfare Systems
Command, Calif. It is to be utilized on a number of Navy ships, including the Arleigh
Burke (DDG 51) class destroyers.
EDO continues to be a leader in developing state-of-the-art electronic self-defense
systems, said CEO James M. Smith. Our omni-directional antenna detects signals
that are then processed by the ship’s electronic surveillance and measurement system
to determine if they are from hostile sources. Such situational awareness of the
source and direction of a threat enables the commanding officer to quickly react with
an appropriate defensive response.
EDO designs and manufactures a diverse range of products for defense, intelli-
gence and commercial markets, and provides related engineering and professional
services. This includes supplying highly engineered antenna systems for communica-
tions, electronic warfare, navigation, radar and wireless Local Area Networks for
governments and commercial firms. EDO’s antenna product line includes GPS, low
RCS, spirals, horns, circular arrays and collinear arrays.
EEMMSS WWiirreelleessss CCrreeddiittss LLaarrggeesstt--EEvveerr QQ11 RReevveennuueess ooff $$1155..66MMiilllliioonn ttoo SSttrroonngg AAnntteennnnaa SSaalleess
EMS Wireless, a division of EMS Technologies, Inc. recently announced the high-
est first quarter revenue results in the division's history, with sales of $15.6 million,
which represents a 27.8 increase compared to the same quarter last year.
Gerald Hickman, senior vice president and general manager, EMS Wireless, credits
the Q1 results to continued investment in wireless networks by EMS customers,
which have fueled strong orders from EMS Wireless's antenna product lines, includ-
ing both the traditional fixed-beam antennas and the Cobra (COntrollaBle Radiating
Aperture) Series line of vertical electrical downtilt antennas.
In the first quarter our antenna shipments were fairly evenly distributed across our
entire customer base. We believe this shows that we are not solely dependent on one
large customer, he said.
EEllccootteeqq ttoo MMaannuuffaaccttuurree AAnntteennnnaass ffoorr PPCCTTEELL iinn RRuussssiiaaElcoteq SE, a provider of electronics manufacturing services (EMS) to the commu-
nications technology industry, has entered into an agreement with the American-
based PCTEL Antenna Products Group, Inc., a wholly-owned subsidiary of PCTEL,
Inc. According to the agreement Elcoteq will manufacture iVET (integrated Variable
Electrical Tilt) base station antennas along with certain land mobile radio antennas in
Elcoteq's new St. Petersburg plant in Russia. The deliveries will begin in the second
quarter of 2006.
PCTEL is a great addition to our customer list in the Communications Network
Equipment business area and our new St. Petersburg plant in Russia, said Bruno
Cathomen, vice president, Communications Network Equipment at Elcoteq.
Antennas fit extremely well within our scope, and we believe that our knowledge
and expertise combined with our flexible and
efficient manufacturing will strongly support
PCTEL's prosperous growth. The synergies
between the two companies are good in other
product areas and geographical locations as
well, which creates a good basis for expanding
the business in the future.
Elcoteq is an ideal contract manufacturer for
our Antenna Products Group, said Marty
Singer, chairman and CEO of PCTEL. With
previous experience in manufacturing sophisti-
cated base station antennas, Elcoteq will help
Antenna Products Group achieve its cost targets
across several product lines.”
RRFFIIDD TTaaggss OOffffeerr LLaatteesstt iinn AAsssseett //LLooggiissttiiccss MMaannaaggeemmeenntt
Radio Waves, Inc., a provider of microwave
antenna technology, has announced a first in the
microwave antenna industry. RFID tags are now
available as an option for Radio Waves cus-
tomers. These RFID tags can be placed on
microwave antenna boxes, giving customers the
option to track finished goods. These RFID tags
allow for the latest in asset management and
logistics management showing Radio Waves
commitment to operational excellence.
AANNTTEENNNNAA SSYYSSTTEEMMSS && TTEECCHHNNOOLLOOGGYY •• JJUULLYY//AAUUGGUUSSTT 22000066
IINNDDUUSSTTRRYY NNEEWWSS 2211
the tower eliminating tower crews or equipment. Most PAC units interact with the
antenna to know the downtilt and azimuth setting. In addition, PAC units can down-
load to standard program antenna sector information so RF engineers can have a
total market view of antenna deployment.
AICM are BTS specific and one is located in each mobile site and controls all
three sector antennas. The AICM communicates with the wireless network opera-
tions and control center (NOC). At the NOC is central software to communicate
with the AICM and download information to the NOC systems. The NOC is able to
program the antennas with no personel on site. The current concern is interoperabil-
ity, authentication and security over a network. One approach being developed by
the BTS and switch OEMs is to integrate the AICM into the BTS and NOC net-
work. Using the existing secure network eliminates security and interoperability
issues. In addition, many OEMs are deploying optimization software to allow carri-
ers to more easily optimize the wireless networks.
Control StandardsCurrently two standard organizations AISG and 3GPP are developing interoper-
ability standards for programmable antennas. Today these standards only cover
electrical downtilt function, not beam steering or beamwidth selection. These addi-
tional standards will evolve over time. The other areas of concern with these stan-
dard committees are that today they are not as universal as IEEE 802.11a, b, /g. The
effect is no plug and play like with WiFi. KMW expects its mobile devices to easily
function in hotspots like wired or wireless networks in hotels. Antenna manufac-
tures must map their antenna protocols to the AISG standards to achieve limited
interoperability. Most OEMs are working with 3GPP and the interoperability and
security will be built into the network. This should be very functional since most
carriers only deploy one OEM per major wireless market.
ConclusionMost wireless carriers have outsourced tower sites and tower crews. This means
they have lost some control and responsiveness with their networks on making
physical site changes. Fixed antenna changes require tower crews, tower equipment
rentals, RF technicians and drive time expenses. Often, antenna change-outs are
required to support new applications and traffic. With the new generation of
Programmable Antenna System Solutions, networks can be configured on a real
time basis while reducing capital and operations expenses. A by-product benefit is
reduction of energy costs and a green solution for the environment. Many state and
local governments like California are encouraging energy efficient and green solu-
tions. This may make deployment easier.
As with any new technology different stages of adoption take place. Today,
Programmable Antenna System Solution deployments are in the innovator or early
adopter stage. However, deployment is increasing rapidly because programmable
antennas have the lowest lifecycle capital and operational expenses. These program-
mable antennas will be the majority of antenna type purchased in the next few years.
For more information contact Burton Calloway at [email protected]
Continued from page 18