2-1

Faculty of Business and EconomicsUniversity of Hong Kong

Dr. Huiyan Qiu

MFIN6003 Derivative Securities Lecture Note Two

2-2

OutlineBasic derivatives contracts• Forward contracts; Call options; Put options

Types of positions and payoff / profit diagrams• Long / Short position

Risk management• From producer’s and buyer’s perspective

Empirical evidence on hedgingReasons to hedge or not to hedge

2-3

TodayExpiration

date

Forward ContractsForward contract: a binding agreement (obligation) to buy/sell an underlying asset in the future, at a price set today

2-4

Forward ContractsA forward contract specifies• The features and quantity of the asset to be

delivered• The delivery logistics, such as time, date, and

place• The price (forward price) the buyer will pay at

the time of deliveryTwo parties sign the contract• Long forward: agree to pay THE price to buy• Short forward: agree to sell for THE price

2-5

Payoff and ProfitPayoff for a contract is its value at expiration. Profit for a position in a contract is net value at expiration of all relevant cash flows. We can use diagrams to show the value of a position at expiration.Forward: (1) zero cash flow at initiation, (2) pay forward price at expiration, (3) get asset (value ST) at expiration For forward contract, payoff = profit

2-6

Payoff on a Forward ContractExample: S&R (special and rich) indexToday: Spot price = $1,000 6-month forward price = $1,020In six months at contract expiration: Case 1: Spot price = $1,050• Long position payoff = $1,050 – $1,020 = $30 • Short position payoff = $1,020 – $1,050 = – $30Case 2: Spot price = $1,000• Long position payoff = $1,000 – $1,020 = – $20 • Short position payoff = $1,020 – $1,000 = $20

2-7

Payoff Diagram for Forwards

X-axis: S&R index level 6-month later. Y-axis: payoff for 6-month forward

6-month forward price = $1,020Long: y = x – 1,020 Short: y = 1,020 – x

2-8

Futures ContractsFutures contracts are the same as forwards in principle except for some institutional and pricing differences.

Forward contracts are OTC products.

Futures contracts exist in exchange market.

2-9

Reading Price QuotesIndex Futures

Expiration month

The open price

High of the day

Low of the daySettlement price

Daily changeOpen interest

Hang Seng Index Futures

2-10

Hang Seng Index Futures Daily market report on August 22, 2012. Source: www.hkex.com.hk

HSI - Hang Seng Index Futures HK$50 per index point Contract *Open *Daily *Daily Settle- Chg in *Contract *Contract Volume Open Change in Month Price High Low ment Setl High Low Interest OI Price Price AUG-12 20,000 20,015 19,839 19,858 -277 20,311 18,600 59,973 93,147 +1,900 SEP-12 19,918 19,934 19,760 19,777 -275 21,238 17,750 3,359 12,135 +1,271 DEC-12 19,875 19,875 19,740 19,748 -278 20,915 17,725 195 5,842 +61 MAR-13 19,830 19,830 19,690 19,699 -277 20,124 19,248 73 120 +28 All Contracts Total 63,600 111,244 +3,260

2-11

Forward vs. Outright Purchase

Outright purchase: • Invest $1,000 in index and own the index. Forward: • Invest zero, sign the contract• Invest $1,020 at expiration and own the

index. Same outcome: own the index at expiration.Why investing $1,000 now results in the same outcome as investing $1,020 later? Price indication?

2-12

Forward payoff Bond payoff

Forward vs. Outright Purchase

Forward + bond = Spot price at expiration – $1,020 + $1,020 = Spot price at expiration

Figure Summing the value of the long forward plus the bond at each S&R Index price gives the line labeled “Forward + Bond”.

2-13

Additional ConsiderationsType of settlement• Cash settlement: less costly and more

practical• Physical delivery: often avoided due to

significant costs Credit risk of the counter party• Major issue for over-the-counter contracts

• Credit check, collateral, bank letter of credit • Less severe for exchange-traded contracts

• Exchange guarantees transactions, requires collateral

2-14

Today Expiration date

or

at buyer’s choosing

Call Option and Put OptionA call option (put option) gives the owner the right but not the obligation to buy (to sell) the underlying asset at a predetermined price during a predetermined time period The seller of a call option is obligated to sell if askedThe seller of a put option is obligated to buy if asked

2-15

TerminologyStrike (or exercise) price: predetermined price• Call: the amount paid by the option buyer for

the asset if he/she decides to exercise• Put: the amount the option buyer receives for

selling the asset if he/she decides to exerciseExercise: the act of paying the strike price to buy (for call) or selling the asset for the strike price (for put)Expiration: the date by which the option must be exercised or become worthless

2-16

Exercise StyleExercise style: specifies when the option can be exercised• European-style: can be exercised only at

expiration date• American-style: can be exercised at any

time before expiration• Bermudan-style: Can be exercised during

specified periodsFocus: European-style options.

Reading Price QuotesHang Seng Index options

2-17

Hang Seng Index Options Daily market report on top-10 traded options on August 22, 2012. Source: www.hkex.com.hk

2-18

Call Option on S&R IndexA 1000-strike call on S&R Index• Underlying asset: S&R Index with current (spot)

price of $1,000• Strike price: $1,000• Expiration date: 6 months later

Today: • call buyer acquires the right to pay $1,000 in six

months for the index, but is not obligated to do so

• call seller is obligated to sell the index for $1,000 in six months, if asked to do so

2-19

Payoff for the BuyerSix months later at contract expiration:• If the spot price ST is higher than $1,000, the call

buyer will exercise the option: pay $1,000, get ST. Payoff = spot price – 1,000

• If the spot price ST is lower than $1,000, the option buyer will walk away and do nothing. Payoff = 0.

Payoff = Max [0, spot price – strike price]

2-20

Call Option on S&R IndexCall option preserves the upside potential ( ), while at the same time eliminating the unpleasant ( ) downside (for the buyer)

Why would anyone agree to be on the seller side? • The option buyer must pay the seller an initial

premium of $93.81 (option pricing)

2-21

Payoff and Profit for the Buyer

Payoff = Max [0, spot price at expiration – strike price]Profit = Payoff – future value of option premiumSuppose effective 6-month risk-free rate is 2% • If index value in six months = $1,100

• Payoff = max [0, $1,100 – $1,000] = $100• Profit = $100 – ($93.81 x 1.02) = $4.32

• If index value in six months = $900• Payoff = max [0, $900 – $1,000] = $0• Profit = $0 – ($93.81 x 1.02) = – $95.68

2-22

Diagrams for Purchased CallPayoff at expiration Profit at expiration

y = max [0, x – 1,000] – (93.81 x 1.02)

2-23

Payoff/Profit of a Written CallCall writer: the option seller• To receive the premium for option sold• To have the obligation to sell if requested

Seller’s payoff and profit is opposite to the buyer• Payoff = - max [0, spot price at expiration – strike

price]• Profit = Payoff + future value of option premium

The payoff and profit diagram of a written call is the mirror image of a purchased call, symmetric with regard to the X-axis

2-24

Profit Diagram for a Written Call

Figure Profit for writer of 6-month S&R call with strike of $1000 versus profit for short S&R forward.

y = (93.81 x 1.02) – max [0, x – 1,000]

2-25

Put OptionsPayoff/profit of a purchased (i.e., long) put• Payoff = max [0, strike price – spot price at

expiration]• Profit = Payoff – future value of option

premiumPayoff/profit of a written (i.e., short) put• Payoff = – max [0, strike price – spot price at

expiration]• Profit = Payoff + future value of option

premium

2-26

Put Option ExamplesS&R Index 6-month Put Option• Strike price = $1,000, Premium = $74.20,

effective 6-month risk-free rate = 2%If index value in six months = $1,100• Payoff = max [0, $1,000 – $1,100] = $0• Profit = $0 – ($74.20 x 1.02) = – $75.68

If index value in six months = $900• Payoff = max [0, $1,000 – $900] = $100• Profit = $100 – ($74.20 x 1.02) = $24.32

2-27

Profit Diagram for a Long Put Position

Figure Profit on a purchased S&R index put with strike price of $1000 versus a short S&R index forward.

y = max [0, 1,000 – x] – (74.20 x 1.02)

2-28

A Few Items to NoteA call option becomes more profitable when the underlying asset appreciates in value A put option becomes more profitable when the underlying asset depreciates in value Moneyness of option:• In-the-money: positive payoff if exercised

immediately• At-the-money: zero payoff if exercised

immediately• Out-of-the money: negative payoff if exercised

immediately

2-29

Summary on Forward & OptionTable Maximum possible profit and loss at maturity for long and short forwards and purchased and written calls and puts.

2-30

Summary on Forward & Option

Figure Profit diagrams for the three basic long positions: long forward, purchased call, and written put.(Long w.r.t. the underlying asset.)

2-31

Summary on Forward & Option

Figure Profit diagrams for the three basic short positions: short forward, written call, and purchased put.(Short w.r.t. the underlying asset.)

2-32

Summary on Forward & OptionTable Forwards, calls, and puts at a glance: a summary of forward and option positions.

2-33

Basic Risk ManagementIn general, to hedge against price increase in the future:• Take derivatives positions with positive payoff

when price is high• Long forward, long call, short put

To hedge against price decrease in the future:• Take derivatives positions with positive payoff

when price is low• Short forward, short call, long put

2-34

Basic Risk ManagementFirms convert inputs into goods and services

output input commodity

producer buyer

A firm is profitable if the cost of what it produces exceeds the cost of its inputsA firm that actively uses derivatives and other techniques to alter its risk and protect its profitability is engaging in risk management

2-35

Empirical Evidence on Hedging

Half of nonfinancial firms report using derivativesAmong firms that do use derivatives, less than 25% of perceived risk is hedged, with firms more likely to hedge short-term riskFirms with more investment opportunities are more likely to hedgeFirms that use derivatives have a higher market value and more leverage

2-36

The Producer and the BuyerA producer selling a risky commodity has an inherent long position in this commodityWhen the price of the commodity , the firm’s profit (assuming other costs are fixed)

A buyer that faces price risk on an input has an inherent short position in this commodityWhen the price of the input , the firm’s profit (assuming other costs are fixed)

2-37

Producer: Hedging With ForwardsA short forward contract allows a producer to lock in a price for his outputExample: the firm enters into a short forward contract, agreeing to sell gold at a price of $420/oz. in 1 year.

2-38

Producer: Hedging With a Put Option

Buying a put option allows a producer to have higher profits at high output prices, while providing a floor on the price

Example: themining firm purchases a 420-strike put at the premium of $8.77/oz

2-39

Producer: Insuring by Selling a Call

A written call reduces losses through a premium, but limits possible profits by providing a cap on the price

Example: themining firm sells a 420-strike call and receives an $8.77 premium

2-40

Adjusting the Amount of Insurance

Insurance is not free!…in fact, it is expensiveHow to reduce the cost of insurance (at the same time, reducing the benefit of insurance)?In the case of hedging against a price decline by purchasing a put option, one can• using a put with a lower strike price instead

lower the price• in addition, sell a call reduce the total price

2-41

Gold Options

Call and put premiums for gold options with one year until expiration.

2-42

Figure Comparison of profit forGolddiggers using three different put strikes.

2-43

Figure Comparison of Golddiggers hedged with 420-strike put versus hedged with 420-strike put and written 440-strike call (420–440 collar).

2-44

Buyer: Hedging With Forwards

A long forward contract allows a buyer to lock in a price for his inputExample: a firm, which uses gold as an input, purchases a forward contract, agreeing to buy gold at a price of $420/oz.in 1 year (revenue after other cost adjusted: $460/oz)

2-45

Buyer: Hedging With a Call Option

Buying a call option allows a buyer to have higher profits at low input prices, while being protected against high pricesExample: a firm, which uses gold as an input, purchases a 420-strike call at the premium of $8.77/oz

2-46

Why Do Firms Manage Risk?Hedging changes the distribution, not the value, of cash flows. Golddiggers’ example: the hedging strategies shift dollars from more profitable states (when gold prices are high) to less profitable states (when gold prices are low).Hedging can be optimal for a firm when an extra dollar of income received in times of high profits is worth less than an extra dollar of income received in times of low profits.

2-47

An ExampleHow hedge adds value• Consider a firm with cost per unit of $10• The selling price is either $11.20 or $9, with 50%

probability• Thus, the firm has either a $1.20 profit or $1 loss• The expected profit per unit = ____$0.10__________ • If the tax rate on profit is 40%, after-tax profit is

either $0.72 or –$1• After-tax expected profit = ______-$0.14__________

2-48

An Example (cont’d)If the firm sells forward at strike $10.10• The profit is fixed at $0.10 with certainty• After-tax profit per unit is $0.06

After-tax profit

Selling priceSlope = 1

Slope = 1-tax rate

A

B

C

D-$0.14

$0.06

2-49

Why Do Firms Manage Risk?Concave profits can arise from- Taxes: differential taxation treatment on

gains or losses, capital or ordinary incomes, across countries

- Bankruptcy and distress costs: avoid huge loss

- Costly external financing: smooth cash reserves in the firm

- Preservation of debt capacity: reduce riskiness of cash flows

- Managerial risk aversion: reduce firm risk

2-50

Reasons Not to HedgeReasons why firms may elect not to hedge• Transaction costs of dealing in derivatives (such

as, commissions and the bid-ask spread)• The requirement for costly expertise• The need to monitor and control the hedging

process• Complications from tax and accounting

considerations• Potential collateral requirements

2-51

What can Go Wrong?One of the risks faced by a company that trades derivatives: an employee who has a mandate to hedge or to look for arbitrage opportunities may become a speculator.Barings Bank Case (more detail in Appendix): • One of the most infamous tales of financial

demise • The 200-year-old British bank was wiped out

in 1995 by the activities of one trader, Nick Leeson, in Singapore

2-52

End of the Notes!

2-53

Appendix:

Barings Bank Case

One of the most infamous tales of financial demise The 200-year-old British bank was wiped out in 1995 by the activities of one trader, Nick Leeson, in Singapore

2-54

In 1993, Nick Leeson was appointed general manager of the bank's Barings Futures subsidiary in Singapore. The mandate is to look for arbitrage opportunities between the Nikkei 225 futures price on the Singapore exchange and the Osaka exchange. Over time, Leeson moved from being an arbitrageur to being a speculator: bets on the future direction of the Nikkei 225 using futures and options. When incurring losses, he began to take bigger speculative positions. By the time Leeson’s activities were uncovered, the total loss was close to one billion dollars.

2-55

Barings Bank CaseOne trading strategy Leeson used: written straddle – selling put and call options on the Nikkei 225 Index. A written straddle is a bet on the volatility being low. Hence it will produce positive earnings when markets are stable but can result in large losses if markets are volatile. When an earthquake in Japan caused a steep drop in the Nikkei 225 equity index, Leeson's unauthorized trading positions suffered huge losses and his operation unraveled.

2-56

Barings Bank CaseLeeson managed both the trading and back office function as the general manager. Thus he was able to conceal his unauthorized trading activities for over a year. The senior managers at Barings came primarily from a merchant banking background and knew very little about trading. In March 1995, Dutch banking group ING bought Barings for one British pound, assumed its debts, took over operations and renamed it ING Barings.

2-57

Leeson AfterwardsLeeson pleaded guilty to fraud and was sentenced to six and a half years in prison. (He was released from prison in July 1999 for good behavior.)During his detention, he was diagnosed as suffering from colon cancer which he survived. When in prison, Leeson wrote a book “Rogue Trader”, which was made into a movie.Nick Leeson now is CEO of Galway United Football Club (Ireland)In June of 2005, Leeson released a new book “Back from the Brink: Coping with Stress”.