expanded gambling in georgia: social and economic impacts to consider public hearing comments...
TRANSCRIPT
Expanded Gambling in Georgia: Social and Economic Impacts to Consider
Public Hearing CommentsAtlanta, GA10 December 2015
Douglas M. Walker, Ph.D.Professor of Economics
College of CharlestonCharleston, SC, USA
About me• Professional Background• College of Charleston (2007-present)• Georgia College (1998-2007)
• Research on socio-economic impacts of gambling• 2 books• More than 50 journal articles and book chapters
• Consultant for state government agencies, including• Florida Legislature• Maryland State Lottery and Gaming Control Agency• Massachusetts Gaming Commission• Missouri Office of the Attorney General• …and various research agencies and industry groups 2
Interest in Georgia• Georgia resident for 9 years• GA casino expansion would represent large expansion in SE,
and could affect politics in South Carolina• Interesting perspectives, outdated research cited during
Savannah meeting in Nov.
3
1 Economic perspective on gambling
• Everyone has a perspective, or bias… • Economics focuses on voluntary, mutually beneficial
transactions• Consumers are sovereign and rational
• ‘Gambling’ is putting something of value at risk on the outcome of an uncertain event• Enjoyable and entertaining to some people, not to others
• Since the expected value of all casino bets, lotteries, etc., is negative, gambling must provide entertainment value
• Psychologists generally view the issues from the perspective of minimizing potential harms from expanded gambling…
4
Disordered gambling• Research suggests that 0.4 – 2.0% of the adult population has
a gambling disorder• Not ‘rational’ – inability to control behavior• Suffer financial stress, problems with family, friends, career• ‘Social costs’ are attributed to pathological gamblers• Common view that ‘vice’ goods with potential for addiction
should be regulated• Gov’t role to protect vulnerable populations• Gambling is viewed differently from ice cream, shoes, etc.
5
2 Economic benefits
• Measurable benefits include:• Tax revenues • Employment & wages• Economic growth/development
• Less-measurable benefits:• Consumer benefits
• More entertainment firms competing => lower prices• Higher quality ‘entertainment’ options• Increased variety
• ‘Counterfactual’ is important • What industry might have otherwise expanded?
6
Tax revenues• Taxes are technically transfers of wealth• Tax revenues are the primary reason for legalization in the U.S.• Tax rates on GGR range from 6% to over 60%
• CT tribal casinos pay 25% slot revenues to state• DE tax on VLT revenue 62%• ME taxes 16% table games, 39-46% on slots• MD slots taxed at 67%; 20% on table games• PA slots taxed at 55%
• Then casinos pay income taxes…• Lower tax rates are likely to encourage larger capital
investment
7
Tax revenues, cont.• 2011 study showed slightly negative effect of casino revenues
on state tax revenues• But effect is positive when tourism and economic growth effects
are considered – indirect tax revenues attributable to casinos• States tax GGR at much higher rates (25-30% avg) than sales
taxes (6% avg)• 1-to-1 substitution in spending => casinos increase tax revenues• Lottery ‘tax’ is about 30%
• Lottery and casinos will raise more tax revenue than either alone
8
Market saturation?• Is the NE market ‘saturated’?• Closure of 4 of 12 Atlantic City casinos• Should a particular state care about regional saturation?
• Are casino companies willing to build more?• A great market test of a saturated market
• Regulations may need to consider potential future competition • Discussion of lower tax rates in DE, IN• Other regulatory changes to help stabilize industry
9
Casino revenues in NE states
102001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
5,000
6,000
DelawareMaineMarylandNew JerseyNew YorkPennsylvaniaRhode Island
Year
Rev
enue
(mill
ions
$)
Casino taxes paid in NE states
111998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
DelawareMaineMarylandNew JerseyNew YorkPennsylvaniaRhode Island
Year
Taxe
s pa
id (m
illio
ns $
)
12
Casino taxes & politics• Taxes from gambling (casinos + lotteries) represent < 5% of
revenue in most states• Gov’t allows industry to exist, enforces monopoly• ‘Defensive legalization’• Why not keep $ at home?
• Gambling taxes are ‘voluntary’• ‘regressivity’ question is interesting
• Fiscal stress relief• Avoid cutting spending or raising other taxes
13
Employment & wages• Do casinos create new jobs or ‘cannibalize’ jobs in other
industries?• County-level analysis shows a positive employment effect and
minor wage effect from casinos• Positive impacts concentrated in entertainment & hospitality
sectors• Effect size depends on county size
14
Casinos and economic growth• Some markets clearly see significant economic growth due to
casinos• Las Vegas• Macao• Mississippi Gulf Coast
• Intuition: increased economic activity is the source of economic growth
• Impacts in other markets not as obvious
15
Consumer benefits• Rarely discussed in political debate over casinos• Benefits mentioned earlier• Lower prices • More variety • Higher quality
• Tourism: new option for potential tourists• Entertainment isn’t tangible, but it benefits consumers• Baseball game tickets• Critics: gambling is a ‘sterile transfer of money’
16
3 Economic costs• ‘Industry cannibalization’• Evidence that casinos harm lottery sales
• Relationship to other industries: ‘market competition’• Little evidence of an overall negative impact on other industries• Results could be market-specific
• Additional infrastructure requirements• Regulations/taxes typically require casinos to pay for
17
Net (measurable) economic impact• Considering just the economic benefits• Tax revenues• Employment & wage effects• Consumer benefits
• And economic costs• Inter-industry competition
• Gambling industries• Non-gambling industries
• Infrastructure costs• Very likely to be positive
18
4 Social costs of gambling• Social costs are mostly attributed to pathological gamblers• Income lost from missed work• Crime • Corruption of public officials • Divorce caused by gambling• Bankruptcy
• Most ‘costs’ defy monetary measurement• But they’ve been estimated at $10,000• Critics claim: Cost:Benefit ratio is 3:1
• But policymakers need data to help inform decisions…
19
Comorbidity• Most pathological gamblers have other disorders• Petry, Stinson, and Grant (2005, p. 569) find:• 74.2% have alcohol use disorders• 38.1% have drug use disorders• 41.3% have anxiety disorders• 28.5% have obsessive-compulsive personality disorder
• How can ‘social costs of gambling’ be measured when most pathological gamblers have multiple disorders?• Most social cost studies ignore this issue• Result is an exaggeration of the social costs attributable to
gambling.
20
5 Casinos and crime• Key concern about casinos is the potential link to crime• Pathological gamblers are more likely to commit crimes• Casinos attract potential victims with cash and potential
criminals• Evidence is mixed, and appears to be dependent upon how
‘crime rate’ is measured• Include or exclude ‘visitors’?• Reno studies showed areas near casinos are safer
21
6 Other concerns• Other important concerns defy measurement in cost-benefit
analyses• Citizens may have concerns about gambling changing the culture
• NIMBY• Moral concerns about gambling
• Should the state condone casino gambling?• What about lottery gambling?• Beer with > 5% ?
• Individual freedom and the role of government in restricting industry?
• These are real considerations that often get ignored in the face of seemingly precise and authoritative data
22
Summary of research• Good data, ability to measure economic benefits• Employment • Wages • Tax revenues
• Difficult to measure consumer benefits• Economic costs (e.g., industry cannibalization) are more
difficult, but still measurable• Social costs are very difficult to measure • Research should focus on types of harms and their prevalence –
not estimating social costs in $
23
Contact InformationDoug WalkerProfessor of EconomicsCollege of Charleston5 Liberty St., Rm. 427Charleston, SC 29401
Tel: (843) 953-8192Email: [email protected]: walkerd.people.cofc.edu
casinonomics.net
Casinonomics (2013)
24