exhibit to agenda item #1c - smud
TRANSCRIPT
Powering forward. Together.
Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special SMUD Board of
Directors Meeting – Budget 2019
Wednesday, November 7, 2018 scheduled to begin at 5:00 p.m.
Customer Service Center, Rubicon Room
Exhibit to Agenda Item #1c
Energy Delivery
2019 Proposed Budget & Initiatives
Frankie McDermott
Chief Energy Delivery Officer
Chief Energy Delivery Officer Organization
Note: SMUD resources support
Business Unit processes regardless
of organization/functional affiliation.
CHIEF
WORKFORCE
OFFICER
CHIEF
LEGAL
OFFICER
Dir, Reliability
Comp & Coord
Dir, Accounting &
Controller
Director, Planning,
Pricing & Ent Perf
Director, Treasury
Director, Facilities
& Security Ops
Dir, Substn,
Telecom, & Mtrg
Director, Power
Generation
Dir, Commercial
Development
Dir, Procurement
Whse & Fleet
Dir, HR, Diversity
& Inclusion
Dir, Org Capability
& Effectiveness
Dir, Environmental
Safety & Real Est
Deputy General
Counsel
BOARD OF DIRECTORSSpecial Asst to Board of Directors
Director, Audit
Services
CHIEF GRID
STRATEGY &
OPERATIONS
OFFICER
Director,
Grid Operations
Director,
Grid Planning
Director, Energy
Strat, R&D
Dir, Distribution
System Ops
CHIEF
CUSTOMER
OFFICER
Director,
Revenue Ops
Dir, Marketing &
Corp Communic
Dir, Adv Energy
Solutions
Dir, Retail Prod
Del & Sales
CHIEF
INFORMATION
OFFICER
Dir, IT Infrastruc
& Operations
Director, Energy
Trading & Contract
Manager, Executive Department
Director, Resource
& New Bus Strat
CHIEF
FINANCIAL
OFFICER
Dir, IT
Applications
Dir, IT Strategic
Initiatives
Dir, IT Information
Security
Deputy General
Counsel
Dir, Customer
Care
Director, Strategic
Services
Director, Line
Assets
Dir, Community
Energy Svcs
CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
& GENERAL MANAGER
CHIEF ENERGY
DELIVERY
OFFICER
November 7, 2018 3 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Energy Delivery Business Unit
Power Generation Line Assets
Substation,
Telecom &
Network
Commercial
DevelopmentStrategic Services
Hydro GenerationNew Services/Local
Agency
Substation Design &
Construction
Commercial
Development
Business Process &
Solutions
License
ImplementationLine Maintenance
Substation / Network
Maintenance &
Hazardous Material
Sacramento Power
Academy
Thermal Generation
Line Design,
Construction, &
Replacement
Telecommunications
Renewable GenerationVegetation
Management
Field Metering &
Power Quality
Gas Pipeline
Civil Engineering &
Const. Management
Inspection
Regulatory Compliance
Rancho Seco Fuel
Storage
Project Development
November 7, 2018 4 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
2019 Proposed Budget by Theme
November 7, 2018 5 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
$345.0
$4.1
$40.0
$37.0
$-
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
$300
$350
$400
$450
2019 Proposed
$M
Keeping the Lights On Optimization/Operational Excellence
Risk Mitigation Embracing the Future
$426.1M
*Excludes Allocated costs
Keeping the Lights On
3,200New Residential Lots
In 2018 vs. 355 in 2012
80Commercial ProjectsIn 2018 vs. 15 in 2016
370K FeetCable Replacement
In 2018 vs. 213k Feet in 2012
1,127Poles Replaced
In 2017 vs. 453 in 2012
241Vehicle vs. Assets
Notifications
In 2017 vs 125 in 2010
92,628Trees (Veg Mgmt)
In 2017 vs. 57k in 2012
• Safety and the pursuit of
zero injuries
• Customer expectations
are increasing
• Core work continues to
grow
• Significant capital spend
on load serving
capability, aging
infrastructure and
customer driven
projects2 13
64
05
10152025
2012-2016 2017-2021
New / Upgraded Substations(Transmission and Distribution)
Dist. Substations (Non-IC) Dist. Substations (IC Related)
Transmission Substations
November 7, 2018 6 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Keeping the Lights On
▪ Safety and the Pursuit of Zero Injuries (SD-6)
▪ Grid Substation Improvements & New Capacity:
Substation E, Franklin Bulk Substation and Substation G
(SD-4)
▪ Proactive Retirement and Replacement of Circuit Breakers
and Transformers
(SD-4)
▪ Capacity and Performance Upgrades at Cosumnes Power
Plant (CPP) & Sacramento Power Authority (SPA)
(SD-4)
▪ Generation Equipment, Overhauls and Maintenance (SD-4)
Franklin Bulk Substation Transformer Cosumnes Power Plant Gas Turbine Rotor White Rock Tunnel
November 7, 2018 7 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Keeping the Lights On
▪ Cable & Pole Replacement Work (SD-4)
▪ Distribution Vegetation Management / Routine Tree Trimming (SD-4)
▪ 230kV Shunt Capacitor Installations (SD-4)
▪ Rancho Seco Switchyard Expansion (Design) (SD-4)
Cable Replacement Work Shunt Capacitors at Foothill Substation Vehicle vs. Pole Replacement
November 7, 2018 8 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Optimization and Operational Excellence
Demonstrated cost savings and examples of our continued focus on
Operational Excellence (SD-2, SD-4)
▪ Vegetation Mgmt
▪ GO-165 Corrective Maintenance
▪ Cable Replacement (including emergency)
▪ UG Fault Repairs
▪ Pole Replacement
▪ Annual Line Patrol
▪ Field Force Training Process Efficiency gains
▪ Equipment Efficiency improvements at Cosumnes Power Plant (e.g. ECOMAX, TRU-CURVE,
Combustion Hardware)
▪ Aux Boiler Operations (SCA – Procter Co-Gen, CVFA – Carson Co-Gen)
▪ Solano 2 Wind Turbine Efficiency
▪ Advanced Gas Path & DLN 2.6+ upgrades at Cosumnes Power Plant (CPP)
November 7, 2018 9 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
2017 to 2021
Forecasted
Savings of
$42.1M is
built into the
plan
Optimization and Operational
Excellence
▪ Use of objective technologies such as Light Detection and
Ranging (LiDAR) and Pole Test Resistograph data to pin-point
where investments make the most significant impact
(SD-4,10,17)
▪ White Rock Control Upgrades (SD-4)
▪ Jaybird High Pressure Lift (SD-4)
▪ Upper American River Project (UARP) Dissolved Gas
Analyzers & Bushing Monitoring
(SD-4)
Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) Pole Test Resistograph Dissolved Gas Analyzer & Bushing
Monitoring
November 7, 2018 10 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Optimization and Operational
Excellence
▪ Workforce Optimization (WFO): improvement projects in
support of Energy Delivery and Customer Service
(SD-2,4,5)
▪ SAP Enterprise Asset Management (EAM) (SD-2,4)
▪ Design Tool / Compatible Units (SD-2,5)
Workforce Optimization – ClickSoftware Scheduling ModuleSAP Enterprise Asset Management
(EAM)
November 7, 2018 11 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Risk Mitigation
Risks
• Regulatory requirements
(e.g. clearance / fire mitigation
standards) (SD-2, SD-4, SD-17)
• Robust economy is increasing our
core work (SD-2, SD-6)
• Lack of availability of vegetation
management crews nationwide (SD-2, SD-4, SD-17)
• Supply and demand issues driving
up the cost of materials and labor (SD-2)
• Leadership / experience turnover (SD-8)
• Condition based corrective
maintenance / mechanical
discovery (SD-4)
• Disruptions from process and
technology changes (SD-8)
Mitigation Strategies
• Drive to exceed clearance and fire
mitigation requirements (SD-17)
• Leverage performance based
maintenance capabilities (e.g. asset
analytics) (SD-4)
• Continued focus on safety programs,
training and processes (SD-6)
• Launch new leader development
initiatives (SD-8)
• Implementation of cost reduction
and/or cost avoidance opportunities (SD-2)
• Overall hour reduction is our focus
(e.g. unit cost reductions)
• Workforce Optimization
• Consolidation opportunities within
our Business Unit and across SMUD
• Drive efficiencies in our workforce
training
November 7, 2018 12 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Risk Mitigation
▪ UARP Road Reconstruction (SD-4,17)
▪ Hydro License Implementation Cost (SD-4,9,17)
▪ UARP Easement Widening (SD-4,17)
▪ LiDAR Vegetation Management (SD-4,17)
▪ Loon Lake Fire Protection (SD-4,17)
Hydro License Implementation workUARP Road Reconstruction SMUD Line Crews – Carr Fire Mutual Aid
November 7, 2018 13 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Risk Mitigation
▪ Re-Routing Gas Pipeline Body Cavity Vents (SD-4,6,17)
▪ Indoor Cultivation Projects (SD-4,5,9)
▪ Transmission Line Splice X-Ray (SD-4,17)
▪ Rancho Seco Nuclear Fuel Storage (SD-7,17)
Gas Pipeline Body Cavity Vents Rancho Seco Nuclear Fuel StorageIndoor Cultivation
November 7, 2018 14 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Embracing the Future
▪ Renewable project development such as Solano Wind,
South Fork Powerhouse and Rancho Seco Photovoltaic
Solar (PV2)
(SD-2,4,7,9)
▪ Removing barriers to new service connections (SD-4,5)
▪ Using analytics to predict failure (SD-2,4)
Solano WindfarmPredictive AnalyticsRancho Seco Photovoltaic Solar Project
(PV2)
November 7, 2018 15 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Embracing the Future
▪ The way we manage work will change
(Workforce Optimization)
(SD-2,4)
▪ Improved customer notification for SMUD work (SD-5)
▪ Commercial Development (SD-4,5,13)
▪ Sacramento Power Academy (External) (SD-6,19)
1430 Q Street -- an 8-story mixed-use
projectCommercial Development Workshop
focused on new and emerging
energy-related technologies
Line Instruction at the Sacramento Power
Academy
November 7, 2018 16 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Energy Delivery2019 Proposed Budget
November 7, 2018 17 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
$0
$50
$100
$150
$200
$250
$300
2018 Plan 2018Forecast
2019 Prop 2018 Plan 2018Forecast
2019 Prop
O&M Capital
$M
Keeping the Lights On Optimization/Operational Excellence
Risk Mitigation Embracing the Future
Allocated Costs
$200.4 $196.7$192.5
$283.9 $281.2$231.2
Powering forward. Together.
Exhibit to Agenda Item #2
Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special SMUD Board of
Directors Meeting – Budget 2019
Wednesday, November 7, 2018 scheduled to begin at 5:00 p.m.
Customer Service Center, Rubicon Room
Energy Delivery – Power Plant JPAs
Major Objectives
▪ Provide electrical power in accordance with SMUD’s dispatch and per the
applicable Power Purchase Agreement (PPA).
▪ Provide steam to the steam host per the applicable agreement (Commodity /
Thermal / Steam Sales).
▪ Maintain debt service payments per the applicable Bond Indenture
Agreement.
Management
▪ All four JPA’s are supported through SMUD staff and management.
▪ Operations and Maintenance (O&M) at all four JPA’s are conducted through
O&M services contracts. Ethos Energy Power Plant Services has the
contract for all plants; Carson Ice (CVFA), Procter & Gamble (SCA),
Campbell Soup (SPA), including McClellan and Cosumnes (SFA).
November 7, 2018 19 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Energy Delivery 2019 JPA Budget Summary
O&M
Interest,
Principal &
Distribution
Expenditures
O&M
Interest,
Principal &
Distribution
Expenditures
O&M
Interest,
Principal &
Distribution
Expenditures
O&M
Interest,
Principal &
Distribution
Expenditures
Total Fuel 13,655,995$ 25,558,393$ 28,494,416$ 119,365,016$
Total Plant O&M 9,752,850$ 6,862,581$ 9,804,536$ 17,483,449$
Total Administrative & General 1,526,380$ 1,578,248$ 1,560,721$ 2,243,898$
Interest on Bonds 413,938$ 829,838$ -$ 6,332,375$
Bond Principal Repayment 5,295,000$ 6,162,500$ -$ 10,207,500$
Plant Betterments / Capital
Expenditures-$ -$ 2,185,000$ 14,500,000$
Current Year Released Fund
Contribution
TOTAL 24,935,225$ 5,708,938$ 33,999,222$ 6,992,338$ 39,859,673$ 2,185,000$ 139,092,363$ 31,039,875$
Expenses
SFA
(Cosumnes)
SCA
(Procter & Gamble)
SPA
(Campbell's & McClellan)
CVFA
(Carson)
% Change
Generation
(MWh)
Total O&M
expenses
(incl. fuel)
Cost,
$/MWh
Generation
(MWh)
Total O&M
expenses
(incl. Fuel)
Cost,
$/MWh
Cost,
$/MWh
CVFA (Carson Ice) 372,996 $21,704,539 $58.19 343,863 $24,935,225 $72.51 24.6%
SCA (P&G) 842,351 $43,208,600 $51.30 760,778 $33,999,222 $44.69 -12.9%
SPA (Campbell's & McClellan) 975,475 $33,863,290 $34.71 915,647 $39,859,673 $43.53 25.4%
SFA (Cosumnes) 3,561,199 $172,564,671 $48.46 3,452,054 $139,092,363 $40.29 -16.8%
TOTAL 5,752,020 $271,341,100 $47.17 5,472,342 $237,886,483 $43.47 -7.8%
2018
JPA
2019
November 7, 2018 20 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019
Northern California Gas Authority No.1(NCGA No.1)
▪ Created in 2007 as joint powers agency for a prepaid gas
transaction in support of commodity purchases.
▪ Board Authorizes debt service and authorizes payments.
▪ Timing of payments generates net income/(loss) of ($0.2 million) in
2019. 2018 budget = ($0.8M) net loss.
November 7, 2018 21 Board Finance & Audit Committee Meeting and Special
SMUD Board of Directors Meeting - Budget 2019