examining and evaluating potential blockchain applications...
TRANSCRIPT
TVE-MILI 19001
Examensarbete 15 hpFebruari 2019
Examining and Evaluating Potential Blockchain Applications in Manu- facturing and R&D
Peter Soldner
Masterprogram i industriell ledning och innovationMaster Programme in Industrial Management and Innovation
Teknisk- naturvetenskaplig fakultet UTH-enheten Besöksadress: Ångströmlaboratoriet Lägerhyddsvägen 1 Hus 4, Plan 0 Postadress: Box 536 751 21 Uppsala Telefon: 018 – 471 30 03 Telefax: 018 – 471 30 00 Hemsida: http://www.teknat.uu.se/student
Abstract
Examining and Evaluating Potential BlockchainApplications in Manufacturing and R&D
Peter Soldner
Blockchain – the technology behind virtual currencies such as Bitcoin – is being promoted by many as one of the most promising emerging technologies. At its core the blockchain is a distributed, immutable data base, able to pinpoint exactly when and by whom a given transaction has been made. Similar to the internet in its early days, blockchain (often referred to as Distributed Ledger Technology) must be seen as a foundational technology, enabling a great variety of potential applications. The blockchain’s greatest potential lies in its ability to disintermediate and optimize very specific processes, companies should first evaluate exactly where and how they could benefit from it and whether blockchain-based solutions could provide an advantage compared to traditional ones. Some of the blockchain’s key advantages include disintermediation, improved traceability of products, increased transparency of transaction histories, as well as enhanced security of records regarding fraud and unauthorized activities. Within manufacturing industries, some of the most promising applications of the technology lie in the field of supply chain management and logistics, distributed manufacturing (e.g. 3D-printing), as well as the Internet of Things (IoT). R&D departments might be able to use the technology as a way to defend intellectual property, similar to how they could use a notary service. Blockchain enabled 3D-printing might also be of interest in the case of low production volume samples and prototypes.
TVE-MILI 19001Examinator: Enrico BaraldiÄmnesgranskare: Sofia WagrellHandledare: Marc Fritzen
TableofContent
I
Table of Content TableofContent..................................................................................................................I
ListofFigures....................................................................................................................IV
ListofAbbreviation............................................................................................................V
1. Introduction................................................................................................................1
1.1 ProblemDiscussionandResearchObjectives...................................................................1
1.2 Content............................................................................................................................1
2. Background.................................................................................................................3
3. Methodology...............................................................................................................4
3.1 ResearchPhilosophy........................................................................................................4
3.2 ResearchApproach..........................................................................................................4
3.3 ResearchStrategy.............................................................................................................4
3.4 TheoreticalChoices..........................................................................................................4
3.5 Validity.............................................................................................................................5
3.6 Reliability.........................................................................................................................5
3.7 Bias..................................................................................................................................53.7.1 Biasindatainterpretation.................................................................................................................53.7.2 Samplebias........................................................................................................................................5
3.8 Ethics...............................................................................................................................6
3.9 SourcesandDataCollection.............................................................................................63.9.1 Literaturesources..............................................................................................................................63.9.2 Non-writtensecondarysources:.......................................................................................................63.9.3 Primarydatacollection......................................................................................................................7
4. TheUnderlyingTechnology.........................................................................................8
Definition.............................................................................................................................8
4.1...............................................................................................................................................8
4.2 HowBlockchainTechnologyWorks..................................................................................84.2.1 Fivebasicprinciplesofblockchain....................................................................................................94.2.2 Blockchain’sarchitectureexplained................................................................................................10
4.3 TheCurrentStateofBlockchainTechnology...................................................................114.3.1 Firstgenerationblockchains............................................................................................................124.3.2 Secondgenerationblockchains.......................................................................................................12
4.4 LimitationsofBlockchainTechnology.............................................................................124.4.1 Currenttechnicalchallenges...........................................................................................................124.4.2 Nontechnicallimitations.................................................................................................................13
5. TheoreticalAnalysis...................................................................................................14
5.1 DefiningInnovation........................................................................................................14
5.2 TechnologyAdoption.....................................................................................................14
TableofContent
II
5.2.1 Thediffusionofinnovationtheory..................................................................................................145.2.2 Thecurrentstateofblockchaintechnologyadoption....................................................................155.2.3 Thes-curveprofileoftechnologyadoption....................................................................................165.2.4 Critique............................................................................................................................................16
5.3 TechnologyImprovement...............................................................................................165.3.1 Thes-curveoftechnologyimprovement........................................................................................165.3.2 Discontinuity....................................................................................................................................175.3.3 Critique............................................................................................................................................18
5.4 AnalyzingthePaceofTechnologySubstitution...............................................................18
5.5 AssessmentAlongtheGartnerHypeCycle......................................................................20
6. Blockchain–AFoundationalTechnology...................................................................21
6.1 AdoptionStatusofFoundationalTechnologies...............................................................21
6.2 AdoptionMatrixforFoundationalTechnologies.............................................................21
7. DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology.......................................................23
7.1 EnvironmentsinwhichBlockchainisUseful...................................................................237.1.1 Advantagesofblockchaintechnology.............................................................................................237.1.2 Environmentsinwhichblockchaintechnologycouldbebeneficial................................................247.1.3 Genericblockchainapplications......................................................................................................24
7.2 OverviewofBlockchainUseCasesacrossdifferentIndustries........................................257.2.1 Banking............................................................................................................................................257.2.2 Insurance.........................................................................................................................................257.2.3 Energymarkets................................................................................................................................267.2.4 Retail&consumergoods................................................................................................................267.2.5 Publicsector....................................................................................................................................267.2.6 Healthcare.......................................................................................................................................277.2.7 Automotive......................................................................................................................................277.2.8 Entertainment.................................................................................................................................28
8. BlockchaininManufacturing.....................................................................................29
8.1 Supplychainandlogistics...............................................................................................29
8.2 InternetofThings(IoT)...................................................................................................308.2.1 Improvedsecurity............................................................................................................................308.2.2 IdentifyingIoTdevices.....................................................................................................................308.2.3 Networkscalability..........................................................................................................................308.2.4 Dataintegrity...................................................................................................................................308.2.5 Grantingaccess...............................................................................................................................30
8.3 3DPrinting.....................................................................................................................31
9. BlockchainApplicationsinResearch&Development.................................................32
9.1 DefensivePublishing......................................................................................................329.1.1 Idea..................................................................................................................................................329.1.2 Example...........................................................................................................................................329.1.3 Benefit.............................................................................................................................................33
9.2 SecuringSpecifications&ChangeRequestsontheBlockchain........................................339.2.1 Example...........................................................................................................................................339.2.2 Benefit.............................................................................................................................................34
TableofContent
III
9.3 3DPrinting.....................................................................................................................349.3.1 SAMPL..............................................................................................................................................35
9.4 DigitalProductBackbone...............................................................................................359.4.1 Idea..................................................................................................................................................36
10. Analysis.................................................................................................................37
10.1 AssessingtheStateofBlockchaininManufacturingandR&D.........................................3710.1.1 Technologyadoption..................................................................................................................3710.1.2 Technologyimprovement...........................................................................................................3710.1.3 Thepaceoftechnologysubstitution...........................................................................................3710.1.4 Gartnerhypecycle......................................................................................................................38
10.2 DefensivePublishing......................................................................................................3810.2.1 Interviewresponses&interpretation.........................................................................................3810.2.2 Adoptionmatrix..........................................................................................................................38
10.3 SecuringSpecifications&ChangeRequestsontheBlockchain........................................3910.3.1 Interviewresponses&interpretation.........................................................................................3910.3.2 Adoptionmatrix..........................................................................................................................39
10.4 3DPrinting.....................................................................................................................3910.4.1 Interviewresponses&interpretation.........................................................................................3910.4.2 Adoptionmatrix..........................................................................................................................39
11. Conclusion..............................................................................................................41
Bibliography..................................................................................................................XLIV
ListofFigures
IV
List of Figures Figure1.Blockchain’sunderlyingtechnologies(source:ownrepresentationbasedonVoshmgir,2016,p.13)....8Figure2.Basicblockchainstructure(source:ownrepresentation).........................................................................9Figure3.Client/ServerandPeertoPeernetworks(source:ownrepresentationbasedonPhillips,2014)...........10Figure4.DiffusionofinnovationaccordingtoEverettM.Rogers(source:publiccontent)..................................15Figure5.Technolgys-curveaccordingtoRichardFoster(source:Mignogna,2015)............................................17Figure6.Technologydiscontinuity(source:Hinks,Alexander,&Dunlop,2007,p.3)...........................................17Figure7.TechnologycompetitionbetweenanoldtechnologywithconsiderationoftheirrespectiveecosystemsaccordingtoAdner&Kapoor(source:Adner&Kapoor,2015,p.5).....................................................................18Figure8.Resultingmatrixwhenconsideringthenewtechnology’semergencechallengeandtheoldtechnology’sextensionopportunity(source:ownrepresentationbasedonAdner&Kapoor,2016)...................19Figure9.Garnerhypecycle(source:GartnerResearch,2013,p.15)....................................................................20Figure10.Surveyresults(source:ownrepresentation)........................................................................................20Figure11.Adoptionoffoundationaltechnologies(source:ownrepresentationbasedonIansiti&Lakhani,2017)...............................................................................................................................................................................22Figure12.Defensivepublishingonblockchain(source:ownrepresentationbasedonBernsteinTech.,2017)....33Figure13.Storingcontractsorotherdocumentsontheblockchain(source:ownrepresentation)......................34
ListofAbbreviation
V
List of Abbreviation CARS Credibility,Accuracy,Reasonableness,Support
GDP GrossDomesticProduct
IIot IndustrialInternetofThings
IoT InternetofThings
IT InformationTechnology
MB Megabyte
R&D ResearchandDevelopment
SAMPL SecureAdditiveManufacturingPlatform
tps Transactionspersecond
US UnitedStates
1.Introduction
1
1. Introduction Blockchain,thetechnologybehindBitcoin,hasbeenacontroversialtopicinrecentyears.Manyexpertsseegreatpotentialwithinvariousindustries,andapplicationsofthetechnologyarenotonlyfoundinthefinanceindustry.Whileopinionsonthetechnologyoftenvary,interesthascertainlyspiked,andgiventheWorldEconomicForum’s2015estimatethat10%oftheglobalgrossdomesticproduct(GDP)willbestoredonblockchaintechnologyby2027, it is likelythatthetechnologywillaffectbusinessprocessesinonewayoranother(WorldEconomicForum,2015).
1.1 Problem Discussion and Research Objectives Duetotheongoingpublicinterest,aswellasthefoundationalnatureofthetechnology,manypoten-tialusecasesforblockchaintechnologieshavebeenproposedinrecentyears.Whilethefinancialin-dustryalreadyhasaselectionoffunctioningblockchainapplications,mainlyintheformofcryptocur-rencies,manyoftheusecaseswithinothersectorsaremerelyideasorinitialconceptsatthispoint,whichmakesitdifficulttodistinguishbetweenfactandhype.
The same is true for blockchain applications within manufacturing industries, an area that isstarting to receivemoreandmoreattention.Therefore, thepurposeof this thesis is toa) identifyand describe potential blockchain applications within manufacturing industries on anoperationallevel(Objective1).
A subject that so far has only received little attention, however, is the blockchain’s relevance inregards to product development activitieswithinmanufacturing industries. Thus, the secondmainobjective of the thesis is to b) examine how the technology can be used within manufacturingR&Ddepartments(Objective2).
Forboth,objective1&2,potentialusecaseswereeitherfoundinexistingliteratureorideatedbytheauthor.
Oncethestudyhasbeenabletoidentifydifferentscenariosinwhichblockchaintechnologycouldbeusedinamanufacturer’sR&Dsetting,themainresearchquestionofthisthesis,aspresentedbelow,canbeaddressed.
“Whichpotentialapplicationofblockchaintechnologycouldgeneratethegreat-estimpactonR&Dactivitieswithinmanufacturingindustries,andhowlikelyare
establishedmanufacturingcompaniestoadopttheusecase?”
1.2 Content Inordertocreateabettergeneralunderstandingforthesubject,chapters4,0and6willprovidethereaderwithnecessarybackgroundinformationaboutblockchaintechnology,aswellasexaminethenatureofthetechnologyfromatheoreticalperspective.
Chapter7aimstogivethereaderanideaofhowthetechnologycangenerallybeusedbyexplaininginwhichenvironmentsandunderwhichfactorstheuseofblockchaintechnologycanbebeneficial.Italsoprovidesvariousexamplesofapplicationsacrossdifferentindustries.
Thelatterhalfofthethesisshiftsthefocustowardsthemanufacturingindustry.Whilechapter8de-scribeshowthetechnologycangeneratevalueformanufacturingcompanies(Objective1),chapter9triestoidentifypotentialblockchainapplicationsinResearch&Development(Objective2).
1.Introduction
2
InordertobetterunderstandhowthetechnologycouldbeappliedtoanR&Dsettingdifferentindustryexpertshavebeeninterviewed,andboththeresultsaswellasaninterpretationoftheseresultsarepresentedinananalysis(chapter10).Thischapteralsoevaluateshowthenewlygatheredresultscom-parewiththetheoreticalbackgroundprovidedinchapter5and6.
Atlast,afinalconclusionispresentedinchapter11,whichalsocontainsapersonalopinionandrec-ommendations.
2.Background
3
2. Background Asindicatedinchapter1.1,thetermblockchainhasbeenusedquite loosely inrecenttimes.Manyprojects,companies,orresearchgroupsarepromisingblockchain-basedproductsthattheyclaimwillsolveavarietyofproblems.Likeformostotherindustries,therehavealsobeenmanyproposalsonhowblockchaincouldbeusedinamanufacturingandR&Dsetting.
Inordertobetterevaluatetheiractualpotential,theideawastopresentindustryexpertsfromman-ufacturingandR&Dwithpotentialuse-cases,andhavethoseexpertsevaluatethembasedontheirexperience,insight,andknowledge.Apartnershipwith3DSEManagementConsultantsGmbH,aMu-nichbasedconsultancywithexpertise inproductdevelopment, systemsengineering,agileproductdevelopmentandotherR&Drelatedtopics,wouldnotonlyallowaccesstovariousexpertsfromclient-companies,butalsoadaytodayinteractionwithexperiencedconsultantswithinthecompany.
3.Methodology
4
3. Methodology 3.1 Research Philosophy Forthepurposeofthestudy,interpretivismwaschosenasthefavoredresearchphilosophy.Asopposetopositivism,whichtriestocompressinsightsintouniversal,law-likegeneralizations,interpretivismpromotestheexplorationandinterpretationofsituationaldetails(Saundersetal.,2009).
3.2 Research Approach Byitsnature,deductivereasoningrequiresapredeterminedhypothesiswhichwillthenbetestedandevaluatedthroughoutthestudy.Duetothenatureofthetopic,aswellastheresearchquestion,adetailedhypothesiswouldhavebeendifficult formulate. Therefore, amore inductive researchap-proachwaschosen.Inductivereasoningrequirestheresearchertotakeanactiveroleintheresearchprocess,aswellasanoverallmoreflexiblestructurethatallowsforagilitythroughouttheresearchproject.Suchanapproachfurtherrequiresagoodunderstandingabouttheresearchcontextwhich,consideringthenoveltyandnatureofblockchain-technology,wouldbealargepartoftheoverallpro-ject.Asolidunderstandingofthetechnologywasalsorequiredas,forresearchobjective2inparticu-lar,usecasesfromdifferentindustriesweretransferredintoanR&Dsetting.Havinganindustrypart-nerwouldmakeitpossibletosetupin-depth,personalinterviewswithvariousindustryexperts(qual-itativedata).Therefore,anotherreasonforchoosinganinductiveresearchapproachwasthatinduc-tive reasoning favorsqualitative-overquantitativedata collection,aswell asbeing less concernedabouthavingtoconcludegeneralizationsfromthedataobtained(Saundersetal.,2009).
3.3 Research Strategy Sinceansweringtheresearchquestionsrequiresadeepunderstandingofthecontextinwhichblock-chain-technologywillbeapplied,acasestudyapproachwaschosen.Ascase-studiesallowforavarietyofdifferentdatacollectiontechniquestobeused,theycanbringflexibilitytotheresearchprocess.Triangulation–validatingdatabyusingdifferentdatacollectiontechniqueswithinthecasestudy–wasachievedbyusing interviews,aswellasaquestionnaireattheendofeach interview.Sinceallinterviewpartnerscomefromadifferentcompanyandhaveuniquebackgrounds,theresearchstrat-egyconsistsofmultiplecases,aseachinterviewcouldbeconsidereditsindividualcasestudy(Saundersetal.,2009).
3.4 Theoretical Choices Inorder togive the readerabetterunderstandingofhownewtechnologiesgenerallybehave inamarket,chapter5willexplaindifferenttheoreticalconcepts.Apartfromdefiningtheterminnovation,thischapterwillalsoexplaintheprocessofhownewtechnologiesareadoptedovertime(technologyadoption),aswellashowtechnologiesimproveovertime(technologyimprovement).Furthermore,differentfactorsthatcaneitherprolongorshortenatechnologieslifecyclewillbedescribed(chapter5.4).Topresentthereaderwithanideaabouthownewtechnologiesareoftenperceivedbythepublic,the theorybehind the famousGartnerHypeCyclewillbeexplained (chapter5.5). Inchapter6 thedifferencebetweendisruptive-andfoundationaltechnologieswillbeexplained,andhowthisdistinc-tionaffectsthetechnologiesadoptionprocess.
3.Methodology
5
3.5 Validity Validitydescribestheaccuracy–thedegreetowhichananswersrelatestothequestion–ofastudy(Mohajan,2017).Thus,wheninterpretingtheresultsoftheexpertinterviews,itiscrucialtorealizethatanswerscanbesubjective.Forexample,whenaskingaboutthebusiness-implicationsofagiventechnologyuse-case,onemustkeepinmindthattheinterviewpartnermightunconsciouslyanswerthequestionwithhisorherpersonalbackgroundorcompany-roleinmind.Thethesistriestoimprovevaliditybyconductingatotalofsevenin-depthinterviews,thusdecreasingtheeffectofeachinterviewpartner’spersonalbackgroundontheoverallscore.However,anevengreatersamplesizewouldfur-therincreasethestudy’svalidity.
3.6 Reliability Duetotheinductiveresearchapproach,aswellasthetechnologieshighdegreeofnovelty,itmustbenotedthatinter-raterreliability,whichessentiallydescribestheconsistencyofstudyresultswhenper-formedbydifferentresearchers,isdifficulttofullyensure(Mohajan,2017).Notonlywouldanotherresearchermaybecomeupwithdifferentuse-cases,thewayinwhichadifferentresearcherwouldexplaintheuse-casestotheinterviewpartnerscouldalsohaveaneffectontheirrespectiveopinions.
Intra-raterreliability,ortheconsistencyofrepeatedtestsbythesameresearcher,ismorelikelytobeestablished since the interview-process,especiallywhenexplaining theuse-cases,waspracticed inadvanceandfollowedaconsistentstructure(Mohajan,2017).
3.7 Bias Biascanbedescribedas“anytrendordeviationfromthetruthindatacollection,dataanalysis,inter-pretationandpublicationwhichcancausefalseconclusions”(Šimundić,2013,p.1).Both,interviewpartnersandresearcherscanbesubjecttobias.Inordertominimizethedeviationfromthetruthitisnotonlycrucialtoacknowledgethatbiasdoesexist,butalsototryidentifyingitssourcesandwhereitmightbemostprominent.
3.7.1 Biasindatainterpretation
Whenresearchingagiventechnologyoveranextendedperiodoftime,researchesoftendeveloptheirownopinionsonwhereandhowthetechnologycanbeused.Whileasolidunderstandingaboutthetechnologyiscrucialforinductiveresearch,researchesmustensuretonotinterpretfindingsinfavoroftheiralreadyexistingbeliefs(Šimundić,2013).
3.7.2 Samplebias
Sinceitisimpossibletointerviewanentirepopulation(e.g.everypersonworkinginR&D),asampleneedstobeselected.However,thissampleshouldbeselectedinawaythatbestrepresentsthepop-ulation(Šimundić,2013).Inthiscaseitwasamaingoaltofindinterviewpartnersfromdifferentin-dustriesandwithdifferentroles.
3.Methodology
6
3.8 Ethics Researchethicsistryingtoanswerhowaresearchtopicshouldbeformulated,howdatashouldbecollected,stored,processed,andanalyzed,aswellashowfindingsshouldbeformulatedinamoralandresponsiblemanner(Saundersetal.,2009).TheRespectProjecthasbroughtforwardawell-de-finedcodeofpracticeforethicalresearchconsistingofthreemainprinciples,eachexplainedingreatdetailandwithvarioussub-categories.Whilethefirstprincipledescribeshowscientificstandardscanbeensured,thesecondprincipleexplainshowcompliancewithregulationsandlawscanbeensured.Thelastprincipletouchesonhowtoavoidsocialandpersonalharminresearch(TheRESPECTProject,2004).
3.9 Sources and Data Collection The informationgatheredthroughouttheresearchprojectcanbecategorized in literaturesources,oralsources,andprimarydata.
3.9.1 Literaturesources
Duetotheinductiveresearchapproach,thefirstmaintaskwastodevelopagoodunderstandingaboutblockchain-technology.Themostconsistentlyusedapproachtoacquirein-depthknowledgewasex-tensiveliteratureresearch.Literaturecamefromboth,primary-andsecondarysources.
Primaryliteraturesources:
Primary literaturesourcesareoftendescribedas the firstoccurrenceofaparticularpieceof infor-mation(Saundersetal.,2009).Inthiscase,primaryliteraturemostlycameintheformofcompanywhite-papers(e.g.white-papersonaparticularblockchain-protocol),andothercompanypublicationssuchaswebsite-content,orcompanyreports.Sinceprimaryliteraturesourcesusuallyarenotsubjecttoreview-processes,contentneedstobetakenskeptical.
Secondaryliteraturesources:
Onceaprimary literaturesourcehasbeenpublished it isoftencategorizedassecondary literature(Saundersetal.,2009).Thus,secondaryliteratureoftencamefromsourceslikepublishedbooks,sci-entific-/industryjournals,newspapers,magazines,andotherdigitalsourcessuchaswebsites.Thistypeofliteraturewouldaccountformostoftheoverallliteratureanalyzedthroughouttheresearchproject.Duetothegeneralhypesurroundingthetopic itwas importanttoevaluatethecreditabilityofthevarioussources.InordertoensurequalityofsourcestheCARS(Credibility,Accuracy,Reasonableness,Support) Checklist for Information Quality as introduced by Harris (2010)was applied. During thisphase,literatureresearchwascomplementedbytwoinformalphoneinterviewswithIT-expertswithknowledgeinblockchaintechnology.
3.9.2 Non-writtensecondarysources:
Apartfromprimary-andsecondaryliteraturesources,informationwasalsogatheredfromaudio-andvideomaterialfoundontheinternet.Especiallyduringtheearlystagesofthethesis,wherethemainfocuswasonunderstandingthetechnologyitself,animatedYouTubevideosandrecordedexpertin-terviewswereavaluablesourceofinformation.ItmustbenotedthatinformationtakenfromYouTubeorsimilarplatformsisnotveryreliableandshouldthereforealwaysbeconfirmedbypublishedlitera-ture.However,theyweremostlyusedasastartingpointforfurtherliteratureresearch,astheyoftenhelpedclarifyingwhattosearchfor.
3.Methodology
7
3.9.3 Primarydatacollection
Duringthirdphaseofthethesis,thedifferentconceptsofblockchaininR&D,whosebasicfeasibilityhas already been proven at this point,were further examined. Informationwas gathered throughsevenone-hourinterviewswithR&Dexpertsfromvariouscompanies,whichwerefollowedbyaques-tionnaire.
Semi-structuredinterview:
Thereasonforchoosingsemi-structuredinterviewswasthatbyeliminatingtightboundaries,aratheropendiscussionabout theapplicability,usefulness,and futureof thedifferentuse-caseswouldbeencouraged.Thisinterviewformwouldalsoallowtovarythequestionsthemselves,aswellastheirparticularorderdependingontheparticipant’sindividualbackground.Furthermore,questionswouldmostlyhaveanopencharacter(Saundersetal.,2009).Assuggestedin(Blandford,2013),interviewsweregivenstructurebyhavingtheinterviewseparatedindifferentsections,aswellashavingvariouskeyquestionsalreadyprepared.Afterabriefpersonalintroduction,intervieweeswereaskedabouttheiralreadyexistingknowledgeonblockchaintechnologies.Thisexistingknowledgewasthensup-plementedbyadditionalexplanationsaboutthetechnology.Onceabasicunderstandingwasensured,participantswereintroducedtothedifferentuse-cases.Inordertoallowforabetterconversationalflow, the entire interview was audio-recorded and only important written comments were made(Saundersetal.,2009).Permissionforaudio-recordingtheinterviewwasobtainedbyhavingpartici-pantssignaconsentform.
Questionnaire:
Withthehelpofafinalquestionnaire,participantswereaskedtoquantifytheirbeliefsaboutthepo-tential,likelihood,andimplementationtimeframesofeachuse-case.Whilepotentialandlikelihoodweretoberatedonascalefrom0to10,implementationtimeframeswereassessedinyears.Giventhethreepresenteduse-casesandthethreedimensionsexplainedabove,atotalofninevalueswereneededtocompletethequestionnaire.Afteraninitialexplanationoftheprocess,interactionbetweenparticipants and the interviewerwas kept at aminimum inorder to ensure anunbiased response(Saundersetal.,2009).
4.TheUnderlyingTechnology
8
4. The Underlying Technology Accordingtoa2016surveyconductedbyDeloitte,blockchaintechnologyisbecomingakeybusinessfocusforUScompaniesinvariousindustries.However,thesamesurveyalsofoundthatknowledgeaboutthetechnologyisoftenratherlimited(Schatsky&Piscini,2016).ThefollowingwillthereforetrytogiveabasicunderstandingofBitcoin’sunderlyingtechnology.
4.1 Definition Thetermblockchainwasfirstintroducedinawhitepaperaboutthevirtualcurrencybitcoin.Thenine-pagepaper,whichdescribesBitcoin’sunderlyingtechnology,includingfunctionsandalgorithms,waspublishedin2008bytheanonymousauthor(s)behindthepseudonymSatoshiNakamoto(Nakamoto,2008).Sincethen,manyexpertshavebroughtforwarddifferentdefinitionsonwhattheblockchainreallyis.Thefollowingtwohavebeenselectedbytheauthor.
DonandAlexTabscott,authorsofBlockchainRevolution,definedtheblockchainasfollows:
“Theblockchainisanincorruptibledigitalledgerofeconomictransactionsthatcanbeprogrammedtorecordnotjustfinancialtransactionsbutvirtuallyevery-thingofvalue.” (Tabscott&Tabscott,2016,p.48)
JenniferRideoutexplainedblockchainas
“acontinuouslygrowinglistofrecordsortransactionbetweenpeersthatarelinkedtogethersequentiallyinblocks.Eachblockinthelink(orchain)containsacryptographichashforthepreviousblock,atimestampandtransactiondata.
Blocksincludearecordofeverytransactionthatoccurredonthenetworkduringthatperiod,andeverytransactionisvalidatedtoguaranteeaccuracy.” (Rideout,2018,p.1)
4.2 How Blockchain Technology Works Atitscore,blockchaintechnologyusespeer-to-peernetworking,cryptographyandgametheory,allofwhichhavebeenaroundforyears.Blockchain,however,presentsanewconceptofcombiningthethree(Figure1).
Figure 1. Blockchain’s underlying technologies (source: own representation based on Voshmgir, 2016, p. 13)
Astheblockchainexistsacrossanentirenetworkofcomputers,thereisnoneedforcentralizedservers(Lord,2016).Theblockchainallowsforinformationtoberecordedandsharedbyacommunity,withallmembershavingacopyoftheinformationandcollectivelyvalidatingnewinformation(Trouton,
4.TheUnderlyingTechnology
9
Vitale&Killmeyer,2016).Newinformationisaddedintheformofblocks,whicharechainedtogetherusingcomplexcomputationalalgorithms.Thisprocessiswhatgivestheblockchainitsname.Further-more,eachindividualcomputer(called‘node’)withinthenetworkhasacompletehistoryoftransac-tions,startingwiththeveryfirstblock(Woodside,Augustine&Giberson,2017).
Inotherwords, theblockchain isanetworkofnodesall runningthesameprotocolandholdinganidenticalcopyoftheledgeroftransactions.Throughtheconceptofmachineconsensus,transactionscanbecarriedoutwithoutthehelpofintermediaries(Voshmgir&Kalinov,2017).
Figure 2. Basic blockchain structure (source: own representation)
4.2.1 Fivebasicprinciplesofblockchain
Inordertobetterunderstandthetechnology,itcanbehelpfultoexploretheblockchain’smostfun-damentalattributes.Iansity&Lakhani(2017),forexample,concludedthatblockchainisbestdescribedbythefollowingfiveprinciples:
1. Distributeddatabase:Everynodewithintheblockchainisgrantedaccesstotheentiredatabase,canseeitscompletehistory,andcandirectlyverifyitspartner’stransactionrecordswithouttheneedofaninter-mediary.Therealsoisnosinglypartythathascontroloverthedataortheinformation.
2. Peer-to-peertransmission:Communication between peers occurs directly, thereby eliminating the need for a centralnodetostoreandforwardinformation.
3. Transparencywith‘pseudonymity’:Everyuserwithintheblockchaininrepresentedbya30-plus-characteralphanumericaddress.Everytransactionanditsassociatedvalueislinkedtotheuser’saddressandclearlyvisibletoallothernodesontheblockchain.However,sinceauser’salphanumericaddressalonedoesnotrevealanypersonalinformationbyitself,itisuptotheuserstodecidewhethertoprooftheiridentitytootherusersorremainanonymous.
4. Irreversibilityofrecords:Differentcomputationalalgorithms(furtherexplainedin4.2.2)ensurethatatransactionthathasbeenenteredontheblockchainstaystherepermanent.Thisisduetothefactthatthenewtransactionisnowlinkedtoeveryothertransactionrecordbefore.
4.TheUnderlyingTechnology
10
5. Computationallogic:Duetothedigitalnatureoftheblockchainandtheindependenceonintermediariestovalidatetransactions,theseverysametransactionscanbetiedtocomputationallogicandessentiallybeautomatedandprogrammed.
Figure 3. Client/Server and Peer to Peer networks (source: own representation based on Phillips, 2014)
4.2.2 Blockchain’sarchitectureexplained
Thefollowingsub-chapterwilltrytoexplaintheblockchainsbasicarchitecture,itsworkingmechanism,aswellasitsmostfundamentalcomponents.
Blocks:
Asalreadyindicatedbythename,ablockchainismadeupofaseriesofblocks,witheveryblockcon-tainingaspecificsetofinformation.Thetypeandamountofinformationperblockisdefinedbytheblockchain’sindividualprotocol.Onthebitcoinblockchain,forexample,blockscontainasetoftrans-actionswithalimitof1MB.IfaddressAwastosendx-amountofbitcointoaddressB,thisandmanyother transactions would be stored within a block and subsequently added to the blockchain(Drescher,2017).Apartfromtheactualdata,eachblockalsocontainsatimestamp,thepreviousblockshashvalue,aswellasitsownhashvalue(explainedbelow).
Hashvalues:
Ahashvaluecouldessentiallybedescribedasthedigitalfingerprintfordata.Withthehelpofahashfunction,anykindofdata(input)canbeturnedintoauniquehashvalue(output).Hashvaluesarenumericnumberswithafixedlength,whichdoesnotdependonthesizeortypeoftheinput-data.
Hashfunctionsareone-wayfunctions,meaningthatthesameinput-datawillalwaysresultinthesamehashvalue,butthereisnowayofrecreatingtheinput-datafromthehashvaluealone.Theycanfurtherberegardedascollisionresistant,sincetheycanbedesignedinawaythatmakesitvirtuallyimpossibletoreceivethesamehashvalueasanoutput,unlesstheinput-dataisidentical(Drescher,2017).
Timestamp:
Aseveryblock,aswellaseverytransaction,containsatimestamp,itallowstoeffectivelyidentifytheexacttimeanddataagiventransactionwasconducted(Drescher,2017).
4.TheUnderlyingTechnology
11
Linkingblocks:
Asthetermblockchainsuggests,blocksarepermanentlylinkedtogethersimilartolinksinachain.Thisisachievedbyusingthehashvalueofthepreviousblockasoneoftheinput-dataforthehashfunctionofthecurrentblock.Thismeansthatthehashvalueofanygivenblockdirectlydependsonthehashvalueofthepreviousblock.
Ifwetakeintoconsiderationthatthispreviousblockagaindependsonthehashvalueofitsrespectivepredecessor,itbecomesevidentthateachgivenblockdirectlydependsonthehashvaluesofeveryotherblockbefore.
Tamperproof:
Theconceptexplainedintheparagraphabovealsoimpliesthatoncedataisstoredontheblockchainitbecomespermanentandtamperproof,asanychangeinablocksdatawouldalteritshashvalue,thusalteringthehashvaluesofeverysubsequentblock(includingthemostcurrent).
Consensusmechanism:
Whenevernewinformationisadded,theblockchain’salgorithmtriestoensurethatonlyvalidblockscontainingvalidtransactionsandvalidblockheadersareaddedtotheblockchain.Thecomputersthatverifytransactionsarecalledminers.Toensurethattheinformationtobeaddedtotheblockchainiscorrect,thealgorithmrequiresamajorityofminerstoagreeoninformation.Thisprocessiscalledtheconsensusmechanism.Ofcourse,noonewouldwillinglyverifyinformationwithouthavingsomein-centive,thusminersareusuallyrewardedwithtokens.Incaseofthebitcoinblockchain,theincentivecomesintheformofbitcoins(Drescher,2017).
Proofofwork:
Asmentionedbefore,ifablockistobeaddedtotheblockchain,allnodesmustagreeonitsvalidity(consensusmechanism).Thisprocessiscalledmining,andtheparticipatingnodesarecalledminers.Butwhatpreventsaminerfromproposingthousandsofinaccuratetransactions,hopingthateventu-allythenetworkwillvalidateoneofhisorherinaccuratetransactions.Proofofworkpurposelymakestheprocessofproposingnewblockstothenetworkexpensive.Onlytheminerto firstsuccessfullysolveanextremelydifficultcalculationcanproposeanewblock.Sinceitismorethanlikelythatablockcontainingfalseinformationwillberejectedbythenetworkanyway,theminerwouldonlywastecom-putingpowerwhentryingtoaddfalsetransactionstotheblockchain(BitFuryGroup,2015).
Proofofstake:
Inadditiontoproofofwork,proofofstakeisanotherapproachtoensuretheblockchain’sintegrity.Nodesparticipatingintheproofofworkmechanismarecalledvalidatorsandcanberegardedastheequivalenttominerswithinaproofofworkmechanism.Here,thevalidatorthatgetstoaddtheblocktotheblockchainischosenrandomlyoutofapoolofvalidatorsthatallhavetokensfromthespecificblockchain.Ifavalidatorischosentoaddthenewblock,thesystemwillfreezesomeofthevalidatorstokensbeforetheblockisadded.Thesetokenswillonlybereturnedoncethenetworkhasagreedthattheblockisvalid.Thedepositsystemthuscreatesanincentiveforvalidatorstoonlyaddvalidblocks(BitFuryGroup,2015).
4.3 The Current State of Blockchain Technology Likewithmostothertechnologies, theblockchain’scapabilitiesareconstantlybeing improved.Alt-houghthereisnocommonconsensusinliterature,mostexpertstypicallycategorizeblockchainsintotwogenerations:
4.TheUnderlyingTechnology
12
4.3.1 Firstgenerationblockchains
Theappearanceofbitcoin in2008marked the inventionof theblockchain,andbitcoinasadigitalcurrencywasthefirstusecaseofthetechnology.Bymakingbitcoin’scodeopensource,thecreatorsbehindbitcoinalloweddevelopmentteamsallovertheworldtocreateavarietyofnewblockchains,allmimickingandexpandingonthebitcoinblockchain’sunderlyingideaandcode.Thus,allfirstgen-erationblockchainsweredecentralizedvirtualcurrencies,whichessentiallymeanstheyrecordtrans-actionsandkeepapublicledgerofthem.SomeexamplesincludeLitecoin,Monero,Dashandmanymore(“BlockchainGenerations:Cryptocurrencies,BlockchainPlatforms,DecentralizedWorld,”2018).
4.3.2 Secondgenerationblockchains
ThesuccessoffirstgenerationblockchainsinformofvirtualcurrenciesmadeITexpertsthinkaboutthegreaterpotentialofthedistributedledgertechnology.In2013,RussianprogrammerVitalikButerinproposedtheideaofnotonlyrecordingtransactionsonablockchain,butalsoincorporatingprogram-ming languageontotheblockchain.Heproposedthe ideaofsmartcontracts,whichat itscorearesmall,self-executingcomputerprogramsrunonablockchain.SmartcontractsbecamethebasisforButerin’sblockchainplatformEthereum.
4.4 Limitations of Blockchain Technology Thefollowingchapteraimstodescribewhereandwhyblockchaintechnologieshavetheirlimitations.
4.4.1 Currenttechnicalchallenges
Belowaspectshavebeenidentifiedassomeofthemostimportanttechnicallimitationsoftheblock-chaintechnology:
Security:
Althoughthecryptography itselfused intheblockchain isconsideredextremelysecure, itdoesnotprotecttheownersfromaccidentallyrevealingtheirprivatekeysorhavingthemstolen.Thisprivatekeyistheonlysecurityinstrumentauthorizingthelawfulowner.Onceanotherpersonhasgottenac-cesstotheprivatekey,thesecurityisbroken(Drescher,2017).
Anothersecurityissueisthepossibilityofa51-percentattack.Inthisscenario,asingleminingpoolprovidesmorethanhalfofthesystem’scomputationalpower.Thissingleminingpoolwouldthenbeable to record false informationon theblockchain.However, in reality this isonly relevant tonewblockchains,asonceagivenblockchainhasreachedalargernumberofparticipants(criticalmass),a51-percentattackbecomesvirtuallyimpossible(Drescher,2017).
Limitedscalability:
BlockchainssuchasBitcoinorEthereumrelyonaconsensusmechanismamongstnodeswhenevernewblocksareadded.Thisensuresthatthehistoryoftransactiondataisprotectedfrombeingma-nipulatedorforged.However,thisisalsowhatlimitstheblockchain’sthroughput,ortotalnumberoftransactionspersecond(tps)theblockchaincanprocess(Drescher,2017).Incaseofthebitcoinblock-chain,thetransactionspeedislimitedtoaround7tps.Toputthisnumberintoperspective,theVISAnetworkcanreachupto10,000tps,andTwitterevenhasamaximumofaround15,000tps(Swan,2015).
4.TheUnderlyingTechnology
13
Highcosts:
Most blockchains use a proof ofwork consensusmechanism (chapter 4.2.2) to ensures theblock-chain’s integrity.Thismechanismreliesonsolvingcomputationalhashpuzzleswhichrequires largeamountsofcomputerpower,whichinreturnleadstohighcostsinformelectricity(Drescher,2017).
Hiddencentrality:
Althoughanycomputercould,intheory,useitscomputationalpowertobecomeaminer,therealitylooksdifferent.Ashashpuzzlesarerequiredto increase indifficulty,mostofthemining inmatureblockchainsisdonebyafew,highlyspecializedentitieswithvastamountsofcomputationalpower,andareusuallylocatedinareaswithaccesstocheapelectricity.Thesegroupscouldeventuallyformanoligopoly,thusunderminingthedistributednatureoftheblockchain(Drescher,2017).
4.4.2 Nontechnicallimitations
Lackoflegalframework:
Aswithmostinnovations,thesupportinglegalandregulatoryframeworksoftenlackbehindthetech-nology.Incaseoftheblockchain,manyquestionsregardingthelegalimplicationsandacceptanceoftransactionsareyettobediscussed.Manycomparetheblockchain’slegalstatustodaytothelackinglegalacceptanceofinternetcommerceinthe1990s(Drescher,2017).
Intermediariesfeelingthreatened:
Oneoftheblockchain’smainadvantagesisitsabilitytodisintermediateprocessesthatwouldnormallyrequireathirdpartytobecomeinvolved(furtherexplainedinchapter7.1.1).Anexamplecouldbetheentireprocessofpatent registration,wheremany intermediaries (e.g.notaries, lawyers,patentof-fices)areinvolved,makingtheentireprocessextremelybureaucratic.Storingpatentsonablockchaincouldpotentiallymakesomeofthem,orat leastpartoftheirworkobsolete.Those intermediariescouldbecomethreatenedintheirexistenceandmighttrytheirbesttoretainthestatusquo.Anotherprimeexamplecouldbethebankingindustry,whichmakessubstantialpartsofitsincomebychargingtransactionsfees.Especiallywhensendingmoneytoanothercountry,thesefeescouldbeveryhigh.Cryptocurrenciesallowtheexchangeofvaluedirectlybetweenpeersandwithouttheneedofinter-mediariesintheformofbanks.This,ofcourse,posesathreattotheirexistingbusinessmodel.
Lackofuseracceptance:
Thestillverymuchopenlegalstatusoftheblockchaincancauseuncertaintyamongstusers,whichinreturncanreducetheirinterestinthetechnology.Theuncertaintyonwherethedevelopmentoftheblockchaintechnology isheadedcausesfurtheruncertaintyamongstusers, thusfurtherdecreasingtheirinterest(Drescher,2017).
Pricespeculations:
Mostblockchainsareusingsomesortoftoken-systemtoincentivizeandrewardminers(chapter4.2.2“consensusmechanism”).However,manyofthesetokensaresubjecttopricespeculationsandoftenseedailypricefluctuationsofupto10%ormore.Thus,projectsbasedonpublicblockchainsarepre-sentedwithgreatlevelsofuncertainty(Fauvel,2017).
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
14
5. Theoretical Analysis Thefollowingchapterwillpresenttheoreticalbackgroundinformation,aswellasatheoreticalanalysisonhowtheblockchaintechnologyfitsintoinnovationtheory.
5.1 Defining Innovation AustrianeconomistJosephSchumpeter,seenbymanyasthemostimportanteconomicthinkerofthefirsthalfofthe20thcentury,wasamongstthefirsttodefinetheterm‘innovation’.Inhis1939bookBusinessCycleshedescribesinnovationasthecreationofanewproductionfunction.Heexplainsthatanewproductionfunctioncouldbetheresultofanewproduct,theexplorationofnewmarkets,aswellaschangeswithintheorganizationalstructure(Schumpeter,1939).
5.2 Technology Adoption Thefollowingwillexplainhownewtechnologiesareadoptedintheirrespectivemarkets,aswellasanalyzethedegreetowhichblockchain-technologyhasbeenadapted.
5.2.1 Thediffusionofinnovationtheory
AccordingtoEverettM.Rogers’diffusionofinnovationtheory(1962),theadoptionofagiveninnova-tionwithinasocialsystemoccursatdifferenttimes.Rogersdescribesasocialsystemas“asetofin-terrelatedunitsthatareengagedinjointproblemsolvingtoaccomplishacommongoal”(Rogers,1962,p.24).Membersofthissocialsystemcouldbeindividuals,informalgroups,orinthiscaseorganiza-tions.Hewentontodividethepopulationwithinthesocialsystemintofivedifferentgroups,consistingofinnovators,earlyadopters,earlymajority,latemajority,andlaggards.
Innovators,whichaccountforaround2.5%ofthetotalpopulation,aretheveryfirsttoadoptanewtechnology.Theyarewillingtotakerisks,havesufficientfinancialbacking,andusuallyknowalotaboutthetechnology.
Thesecondgroupthatadoptsthetechnologyaretheearlyadopters(13.5%).Theyarepeoplethatusenewtechnologiessignificantlyearlierthanthemajority.Earlyadopterscanactasambassadorsofthenewtechnologyandformopinionsamongstthemajorityofusers.
Thenext34%arecalledtheearlymajority.Theyconsistofeveryonewhoadoptsthetechnologyaftertheearlyadopters,butbeforethehalf-waypointofadoptionisreached.
Liketheearlymajority,thelatemajorityaccountsfor34%ofthepopulation.However,thelatema-jorityconsistsofpeoplethatadoptatechnologyaftertheaverageconsumerdoes.Comparedwiththeearlymajoritythosepeopleoftenaremoreskepticaland/orhavealowerincome.Often,theymustfirstbeconvincedorpressuredtoadopt.
Thelastgrouptoadoptatechnologyarecalledlaggards.Theyaccountfor16%oftheoverallpopula-tion,andarethelasttoadopt.Laggardsareoftenaversetochangeandfocusedontraditions.Bythetimetheyadoptatechnology,innovatorsmighthaveoftenalreadymovedontoanewtechnology.
Whenvisualized,thediffusionofinnovationcurveoftentakestheshapeofabellcurve(Figure4).
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
15
Figure 4. Diffusion of innovation according to Everett M. Rogers (source: public content)
5.2.2 Thecurrentstateofblockchaintechnologyadoption
Inordertoassesstheblockchaintechnologyalongthediffusionofinnovationadoptioncurve,Wood-sideetal. (2017) tooka triangulationapproach.They tried toassess the technologiesadoptionbycomparingtheresultofthreedifferentanalysis(anenvironmentalanalysis,atextanalysis,andafi-nancialanalysis).
Environmentalanalysis:
Theenvironmentalanalysis,wheretheyevaluatedthetechnologiespolitical-,economic-,social-,andtechnicalenvironment,determinedthatthatblockchaintechnologyisonitswaytotheearlyadopterscategory.Whatcurrentlypreventstheblockchainfromadvancingtotheearlyadopterscategoryisanongoing competitionbetweendifferentblockchain technologies, aswell as theuncertaintyaroundglobalgovernmentalregulation.Asaresult,thestudyfoundthatblockchainstillresidesintheinnova-torscategory,orthefirst2.5%oftotaladoption.
Textanalysis:
Thetextanalysis,whereannualreportswerescannedfortheword‘blockchain’andotherblockchain-relatedkeywords,foundthatbythetimeofthestudyin2017,onlyonecompanyoutof50(IBM)hadspecificallymentionedtheblockchainintheirannualreport.Comparedwithothermega-trends,suchasartificialintelligence,internetofthings,cloudcomputing,oraugmentedreality,blockchainrankedlast in the textanalysis.Thus, the textanalysisalsoplacesblockchain technology in the innovatorscategory.
Financialanalysis:
Thefinancialanalysis,whichexaminedfinancialinvestmentsinthetechnology,statedthat$1.4billionwereinvestedinblockchainstartupsin2016.Itwasalsomentionedthatthebigfouraccountingfirms(EY,PwC,Deloitte,KPMG)areheavilyresearchingandinvestinginthetechnology.Atthetimeofthestudy,theUSDollarvalueofallcryptocurrenciescombinedhadavalueof$91.073billion,whichwouldbeequalaround5.8%ofthetotalUSDollarcurrencyincirculation.Duetosubstantialpriceincreases
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
16
onthecryptocurrencymarket,thefinancialanalysisfindsblockchaintohavepartlymovedtoearlyadoptercategory.
Resultsandconclusion:
Asaresult,thestudyfoundthattheblockchaintechnologyismostlyseenwithintheinnovatorscate-gory,orthefist2.5%ofmarketshare.However,thestudyalsoacknowledgesthatblockchainisnotfarfromreachingtheearlyadopterscategory,withfinancialapplicationshavingpartlyreachedtheearlyadopterscategoryalready.
Theauthorsconcludethatblockchaintechnologybringsthepotentialtodisruptandinnovatemanykeyareasofbusiness.However,theystatethattheaccountingindustrywillbeimpactedthemostastheblockchaincouldautomatemanyofitsmanualprocesses,suchasthelaborintensivedoubleentrybookkeepingprocess.
5.2.3 Thes-curveprofileoftechnologyadoption
Therateinwhichdiffusiontakesplacecanbedescribedbyans-curve.Itshowsthattherateofadop-tionovertimeisratherslowatthebeginningofthediffusionprocess(innovatorsandearlyadopters),acceleratestowardsthemiddle(early-andlatemajority),andagainslowsdowntowardstheendofadoption(laggards).Thiss-curveisthederivativeofthediffusionbell-curve(Figure4).
5.2.4 Critique
Rogers’diffusionofinnovationtheorycanplayakeyroleinunderstandinghowatechnologyisbeingadopted.However,thetheoryalsohasitslimitations.
Firstofall,Rogers’diffusiontheoryassumesthatthetechnologyitselfisstaticanddoesnotchangewithinitslifecycle(Adner&Kapoor,2015).Astechnologiesundergoconstantprogress,itcanbear-guedthatRogers’staticviewontechnologyisnotentirelycorrect.Forexample,rapidorunexpectedimprovementscouldspeeduptheadoptionprocess.Furthermore,notonlydoesthenewtechnologyundergochange,butalsotheoldtechnologywhichisbeingreplaced.
Thediffusionof innovation theory furtherdoesnot take the technology’secosystem intoaccount.However, both new- and old technology depend on their respective ecosystems. Emergence chal-lengesforthenewtechnologycouldariseduetoproblemswithinthetechnology’secosystem,whiletheoldtechnology’secosystemcouldprovideextensionopportunities(Adner&Kapoor,2015).
5.3 Technology Improvement Inthe1980’s,RichardFosterexaminedthenatureoftechnologyimprovementsandhelpedtoexplainhowtechnologyissubstituted.Amongstothers,hecameupwiththefollowingprinciples.
5.3.1 Thes-curveoftechnologyimprovement
Thes-curveoftechnologyimprovementdescribesthebasicpatternoftechnologicalchangeinthreephases.
Itshowshowperformanceimprovementsachievedthroughagivenamountofeffortortimearerela-tivelysmallintheearlydevelopmentstagesofthetechnology,hencemakingthecurveappearrela-tivelyflat.Thisphaseiscalledinfancy(Figure5–I)
However,asthetechnologybecomesbetterunderstood,therateofprogressincreasesandsubstantialimprovementsinperformancecanbeachievedwithrelativelylittleeffort.Thisphaseiscalledexplo-sion(Figure5–II),andthecurveitselffollowsarelativelysteeppattern.
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
17
Asthetechnologymatures,improvingthetechnologywillbecomeincreasinglydifficultandimprove-mentsthemselvesmoreandmoreincrementalwhichresultsindecreasingreturns.Thisphase,whichiscalledgradualmaturation(Figure5–III),depictsanincreasinglyflatcurve(Foster,1986).
Figure 5. Technolgy s-curve according to Richard Foster (source: Mignogna, 2015)
5.3.2 Discontinuity
Onceagiventechnologyapproachesthetopofitss-curve,meaningithasreachedits limits,anewtechnologicalconceptneedstoemergeinordertoensurefurthertechnologicalprogress.Thistransi-tionusually isnotsmooth,andresults inaphasewherebothtechnologicalconceptscompetewithoneanother(Figure6).Thisphaseinwhichthenewtechnologicalconceptgraduallysubstitutestheoldtechnologyisreferredtoasdiscontinuity(Foster,1986).
Figure 6. Technology discontinuity (source: Hinks, Alexander, & Dunlop, 2007, p. 3)
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
18
5.3.3 Critique
Foster’sideasoftechnologyimprovementandthes-curveoftechnologyimprovementlackinthefol-lowingaspects.
Forone,Foster’stheoriesassumethatthetechnologys-curveoftheoldtechnologywilleventuallyflatten,andnofurtherprogressismade.Thishowever,oftendoesnotholdtrueandsometimesim-provements intheoldtechnologycanstillbeachieved.Adneretal. (Adner&Kapoor,2015,p.17)foundthat“attimes,thepaceofsubstitutionwassloweddueto“lastgasp”effortsbysomefirmstomaximizethevaluethattheycouldcapturefromtheoldtechnology”.
Furthermore,theroleofdemand-sideadoptionismostlyoverlooked.Therefore,thequestionwhendominanceovertheoldtechnologywillbeachievedis ignored,andthewrongassumptionismadethatthebettertechnologywillalwaystakeoverthemarket(Adner&Kapoor,2015).
5.4 Analyzing the Pace of Technology Substitution Whilethetechnologyadoptionliterature(e.g.Rogers,chapter5.2)hasexaminedtherateoftechnol-ogyadoptionbutignoredthatfactthatbothold-andnewtechnologiesaswellastheirecosystemscontinue to evolve, literature regarding technology improvement (e.g. Foster, chapter 5.3)mostlyoverlooksdemand-sideadoptionandthereforedoesnotgivemuch informationaboutwhendomi-nancewillbeachieved(Adner&Kapoor,2015).
AdnerandKapoor(2015)arguethatinordertotrulyunderstandthepaceoftechnologysubstitutionanditsdynamics,theconceptsoftechnologyadoptionandtechnologyevolutionneedtobelinked.Furthermore,theyrecognizethattechnologysubstitutiondoesnotsolelydependonthetwotechnol-ogiesinquestionbutshouldratherbeseenasacompetitionbetweenthenew-andoldtechnology’secosystems.Whiletheoldtechnology’secosystemcoulddelaysubstitutionbyofferingextensionop-portunities for the old technology, emergence challenges within the new technology’s ecosystemcouldalsodelaysubstitution(Figure7).Thisiswhatresultsinadifferencebetweenthetheoreticallypossibletechnicalperformanceofthetechnology,andtheactualrealizedperformance.
Figure 7. Technology competition between an old technology with consideration of their respective eco-systems according to Adner & Kapoor (source: Adner & Kapoor, 2015, p. 5)
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
19
Acknowledgingthis,Adner&Kapoordevelopedaframeworkforanalyzingthepaceoftechnologysub-stitution,whichtakesboth,technologyadoptionandevolution,aswellasbothtechnologies’respec-tiveecosystemsintoaccount.Theresultisamatrixthatconsiderstheemergencechallengeofthenewtechnologyontheoneaxis,andtheextensionopportunityof theoldtechnologyontheotheraxis(Figure8).
Figure 8. Resulting matrix when considering the new technology’s emergence challenge and the old tech-nology’s extension opportunity (source: own representation based on Adner & Kapoor, 2016)
Quadrant1-Creativedestruction:
Quickestsubstitutioncanbeexpectedinsituationwithlowemergencechallengesandlowextensionopportunities.Here,theoldtechnologyhaslittlepotentialrespondtothethreat,whilethenewtech-nology’spotentialisnotheldbackbybottleneckselsewhereinitsecosystem(Adner&Kapoor,2016).
Quadrant4-Robustresilience:
Slowestpaceofsubstitutioncanbeexpectedwhereverthenewtechnology’secosystemfacesgreatemergencechallengesandtheoldtechnology’secosystemhassignificantopportunitiesforimprove-ment.Heretheoldtechnologycanbeexpectedtokeepitsleadershippositionforanextendedperiod.Newtechnologiesthatfall intothiscategoryoftenseemrevolutionaryatfirstbutareoverhypedinreality(Adner&Kapoor,2016).
Quadrant2-Robustcoexistence:
Lowecosystememergencechallengesforthenewtechnology,buthighecosystemextensionoppor-tunitieswillresultinanongoingcompetitionbetweenthetechnologies.Althoughthenewtechnologywillbeabletogainaccesstothemarket,butimprovementsintheoldtechnologyecosystemwillallowittodefendsomeofitsmarketshare(Adner&Kapoor,2016).Thisresultsinaprolongedperiodofcoexistencebeforesubstitutiontakesplace,whichcanbequitebeneficialfortheconsumerasongoingcompetitioncanimprovetheperformanceofbothecosystems(Adner&Kapoor,2015).
Quadrant3-Illusionofresilience:
Highecosystememergencechallengesforthenewtechnologyandlittleecosystemextensionoppor-tunityfortheoldtechnologywillresultinaperiodofstagnationuntiltheemergencechallengescanberesolved.Thisperiodwillmostlikelyleavetheoldtechnologywitharelativelyhighmarketsharebutlittlegrowth.Theoldtechnology’shighmarketsharemustbeseenasveryfragile,becauseonce
5.TheoreticalAnalysis
20
theemergencechallengesforthenewtechnologycanberesolved,substitutionwillberapid(Adner&Kapoor,2016).
5.5 Assessment Along the Gartner Hype Cycle Inordertocorrectlyexaminepotentialapplicationsoftheblockchaintechnologyandpredictfuturedevelopments,itisimportanttofirstdetermineandunderstandthecurrentphaseofthetechnology.
Figure 9. Garner hype cycle (source: Gartner Research, 2013, p. 15)
TheGartnerHypeCycleisacom-monly used tool to determinethephaseofagiventechnology.Developed by the informationtechnology firmGartner Inc., itallows to visualize the expecta-tions in a technology over timesince it emerged. It isbasedonthe assumption that all newtechnologies follow a universalpatternandcanbedividedintodistinctphases.Afterthetechnologyisfirsttriggeredthroughatech-nologybreakthrough(InnovationTrigger)expectationstendtorisequicklyduetohypeandinitialsuc-cessstories.Thissharp increase inexpectationscontinuesuntil thePeakof InflatedExpectations isreached.Onceitbecomesevidentthatthetechnologywillnot,ornotyetliveuptotheinflatedexpec-tations, it is rapidlydiscreditedandsent intotheThroughofDisillusionment.Assecond-andthird-generationproductsarebeinglaunched,thetechnologybeginstoclimbtowardstheearlystagesofmaturity.ThisphaseiscalledtheSlopeofEnlightenment.ItbringsthetechnologyallthewaytothePlateauofProductivity,whichrepresentsthebeginningofmainstreamadoption(GartnerResearch,2013).
A2017study(Dieterichetal.,2017)foundthat,atthetime,mostexpertssawthetechnologyeitherrightontopthePeakofInflatedExpecta-tionsoronitswaytowardsit(Figure10).Thesefurtherstressestheimportanceofdistinguishing between hype and valua-blepotentialuse-casesineachindustry.Itmustbenoted,however,thattheresultsdepicted in the survey have been gath-eredpriortoNovember2017.Combinedwithenormouspricedecreasesincrypto-currencieswithinthefirsthalfof2018,itcanbeassumedthatthetechnologyhasnowalreadypassedthePeakof InflatedExpectations and is advancing towardstheThroughofDisillusionment.Figure 10. Survey results (source: own representation)
6.Blockchain–AFoundationalTechnology
21
6. Blockchain – A Foundational Technology Itisoftenheardthattheblockchaintechnologywillrevolutionizevariousareasofbusiness.Althoughmostexpertsrealizethetechnology’spotential,manydonotsharetheongoinghype.Apartfromthetechnology’smany technical-andnontechnical limitation (chapter4.4) thatareyet tobe resolved,blockchain-led transformationofbusinessandgovernmentwill take its timedue toblockchainnotbeingadisruptivetechnology,butratherafoundationaltechnology(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).Insteadofattackingtraditionalbusinessmodelsandquicklyovertakingthemthroughabetterand/orcheapersolutionasdisruptivetechnologiesdo,afoundationaltechnologyhasthepotentialtocreatenewfoun-dationsfortheentireeconomic-andsocialsystem.Andalthoughanewfoundationaltechnologyusu-allyhasanenormous impact, itoftentakesdecadesforthetechnologytounfold itspotential.Theadoptionprocess(chapter5.2)offoundationaltechnologiesthusisnotsudden,butmoregradualandsteady,slowlygainingmomentumwitheverytechnologicalimprovementorinstitutionalchange.
6.1 Adoption Status of Foundational Technologies Iansiti&Lakhanifoundthattheadoptionoffoundationaltechnologiescanbedefinedalongtwodi-mensions.Thesetwodimensionshelptodeterminehowfastafoundationaltechnology’sdifferentusecaseswillbeadopted.
Novelty,thefirstdimension,describeshownewtheusecaseistoitstargetgroup.Applicationswithahighdegreeofnoveltyarerelativelyunknowntousers.Thismeansthatgreatereffortswillberequiredtomakesurethatpeopleunderstandandappreciatethevaluetheapplicationcreates.
Theseconddimensioniscomplexity,whichisrepresentedbythelevelofecosystemcoordinationre-quiredtomakethespecificapplicationpossible.
6.2 Adoption Matrix for Foundational Technologies Evaluatingafoundationaltechnologyanditsusecasesalongthetwodimensionsdescribedinchapter6.1createsfourquadrantsorcategories.Tomaketheirideasmoretangible,Iansiti&Lakhaniappliedtheir frameworktotheTCP/IPtechnologyasanexample.Theyhavealsogivenpossibleblockchainapplicationsthatcouldrepresenteachcategory(Figure11).TCP/IP (transmissioncontrolprotocol/internetprotocol) is thetechnologybehindthe internet,andintroducedacompletelynewwayoftransmittinginformation.Itcanbeseenasaprimeexampleforafoundationaltechnology(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).Althoughthetechnologywasalreadyintroducedin1972,ittookyearsfordifferentusecasestobedevelopedandadopted.E-mail,theWorldWideWeb,orVoiceOver IPareonlya fewofmanydifferentusecases the technologymadepossible,andallemergedatdifferenttimes.
Singleuse:
Thisfirstquadrantconsistsofapplicationslowinboth,noveltyandcoordination.Theseapplicationsareusuallyrelativelysimple,butpresentabetter,cheaper,andhighlyfocusedsolution.InthecaseofTCP/IP,earlye-mailsbetweenuniversity researcherswithin theAdvancedResearchProjectAgencyNetwork(thebirthplaceoftheinternet)intheearly70’swouldfallintothiscategory(Kleinrock,2010).Fortheresearchese-mailwasasingle-useapplicationthatpresentedacheapalternativetophonecalls,faxesandmail(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).
6.Blockchain–AFoundationalTechnology
22
Localization:
Despitebeinghighinnovelty,solutionsinthissecondquadrantarerelativelylowincomplexity.Thismakespromotingtheiradoptionquitesimple.AusecasewithintheTCP/IPtechnologythatfallsintothiscategoryistheadoptionofnetworktechnologiesbyorganizationastheystartedtocreatetheirowne-mailnetworksystems(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).
Substitution:
Inthisthirdquadrant,solutionsarerelativelylowinnoveltyastheybuildonexistingsingleuseandlocalizationusecases.However,coordinationbecomescomplexassolutionswithinthiscategoryhaveabroaderandmorepublicuse.Theyaimtoreplaceentirebusinessconcepts,thusfacinghighadoptionbarriers.Amazon’searlydaysasanonlinebookstore, trying tochange theprocessofhowpeoplepurchasebooks,wouldbeaperfectexampleofausecasefromthiscategory(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).
Transformation:
Solutionswithinthisfourthquadrantarecompletelynewandveryhighincomplexity.Theyrequirecoordinatingtheactivitiesofmanyactors,aswellas institutionalagreementonstandardsandpro-cesses.Adoptionwilldependonmajorsocial,legal,andpoliticalchange.However,ifsuccessfulthesesolutionscouldchangethenatureofeconomic,social,andpoliticalsystems(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).InthecaseofTCP/IPtechnology,videoconferencetechnologies(e.g.Skype),whichcouldresultinashifttowardsvirtual-,andawayfromin-personmeetings,canbeseenasanexampleforthiscategory.
Figure 11. Adoption of foundational technologies (source: own representation based on Iansiti & Lakhani, 2017)
7.DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology
23
7. Different Applications of Blockchain Technology 7.1 Environments in which Blockchain is Useful Tobetterunderstandwhichblockchainapplicationswemightseeinthefuture,itmakessensetofirsthavealookattheadvantagesandlimitationsofthetechnology,aswellasexaminingwhichenviron-mentsthetechnologyissuitedforbest.
7.1.1 Advantagesofblockchaintechnology
Amongstothers,literaturedescribesthefollowingaspectsasthemainadvantagesofblockchaintech-nology.
Disintermediation:
Disintermediationisbeingnamedasoneofthemostimportantlong-termimpactsoftheblockchain.Drescher(2017)describestheblockchainasadigitalandstrictlyrule-followingmiddleman,whichbearsthepotentialto,atleastpartly,replacetraditionalmiddlemensuchasbanks,notaries,orlegalinstitu-tions.Thismeans thatmiddlemen in formofhumanorganizations,whichrelyonthetrustof theircustomers,couldbereplacedwithsoftwaresystemsthatensuretrustviacode.Furthermore,secureanddirecttransactionsbetweenpeerscannotonlymakeone,butpotentiallymanytraditionalmid-dlemenobsolete.
Decentralization:
Althoughtheremightbedifferentopinionsonwhethertheblockchain’sabilitytodecentralizeinfor-mationcanalwaysberegardedasanadvantageornot,itdefinitelyisoneoftheverykeyattributesofthetechnology.Withblockchainthereisnoneedforcentraldatahubs(datacenters),becausetrans-actionscannowprooftheirvaliditythemselves(Williams,2017).
Automation:
Theblockchainhasthepotentialtoreplacemanualtasks,whichhavepreviouslybeencarriedoutbyintermediaries,withautomated interactionsbetweenpeers.Therefore,theargumentcanbemadethatblockchainfostersautomation(Drescher,2017).
Increasedtransparency:
Theuseofblockchaintechnologycanmaketransactionhistoriesfarmoretransparentthantheyarerightnow.Asdiscussedpreviously,theblockchaincanbeconsideredaformofdistributedledger,withallnetworkparticipantssharingthesamedocumentationinsteadofeachhavingindividualcopies.Thisshareddocumentationcanonlybeupdatedonceallparticipantshaveagreedonit(consensus),makingdocumentationontheblockchainmoreaccurate,consistentandtransparent(Hooper,2018).
Improvedtraceability:
Greatertransparencyoftransactionsalsoresultsinbettertraceabilityofproducts.Forexample,ex-changesofgoodscanberecordedonablockchain,leavingbehindatamperproofaudittrailofhistor-icaltransactiondatawhichcanproofauthenticityoftheproductandpreventfraud(Hooper,2018).
Enhancedsecurity:
Whencomparedtocentralizedrecord-keepingmechanisms,theblockchainprovidesbettersecuritybypreventingfraudandunauthorizedactivity.Thisisduetotransactionshavingthebeagreeduponbeforerecordingthem,theirsubsequentencryption,aswellasthembeinglinkedtoallprevioustrans-actions.Furthermore,informationisnotstoredonasingleserver,butanentirenetworkofcomputers.
7.DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology
24
Thismakesitfarmoredifficultto(purposelyoraccidently)damageoraltersensitivedata(Hooper,2018).
Increasedefficiencyandspeed:
Traditionalprocessesheavilyrelyonpaperwork,arepronetohumanerror,andoftenrequirethird-partyinvolvement.Thesefactorsmakemany,especiallyinter-organizational,processesinefficientandtime-consuming.Theblockchainpromisestoaddressmanyofthesefactors,thusincreasingtheeffi-ciencyandspeedofvariousprocesses(Hooper,2018).
Reducedcosts:
Besidescostreductionsthroughautomation,blockchaincanespeciallycutcoststhroughdisinterme-diation.Theuseofblockchainallowsforfewerthirdpartyinvolvementasguaranteesandlegalpro-tectionprovidedbyvariousmiddlemancanbereplacedbyinherenttrust inthedatastoredontheblockchain (Drescher,2017).Furthermore, therewillbe lessneed to reviewdocumentationbeforetrades,astheblockchainensuresthatallpartieshaveaccesstotheverysame,immutableversionofagivendocument(Hooper,2018).
7.1.2 Environmentsinwhichblockchaintechnologycouldbebeneficial
A2016paperreleasedbyPricewaterhouseCoopers(PwC,2016)identifiedsixdistinctcharacteristicsthatwouldsupporttheuseofblockchain.Thecompanysuggestedthatforeverysituationwhereatleastfouroutofthefollowingsixexamplesapply,blockchainsolutionscouldbeavaluablesolution.
1. Multiplepartiessharedataandneedacommonviewofdata2. Multiplepartiesupdatedataandtheseactionsneedtoberecorded3. Participantsneedtotrustthattheactionsthatarerecordedareverifiedasvalid4. Intermediariesaddcostandcomplexity5. Interactionsaretimesensitive,withdelaysaddingcosts6. Transactionscreatedbyparticipantsaredependedoneachother
7.1.3 Genericblockchainapplications
Basedonthetechnology’scharacteristics,Drescher(2017)describessevendifferentgenericusecasesforblockchain.
1. Proofofexistence:Theblockchaincanhelptoprovetheexistenceofdata.Oncedataisstoredontheblock-chain,everynodewithinthenetworkcanconfirmtheveryexistenceofthedata.Thisusecasebecomesmoreobviouswhen lookingatconcreteexamples likeregistriesof itemssuchasbrandnames,patents,licensecodes,orinternetaddresses.
2. Proofofnonexistence:Contrarytotheexampleabove,thisusecaseprovidesawayofprovingthenonexistenceofspecificentriesoritemsontheblockchain.Examplescouldbeprovingthatapersonorcompanyhasnorecordofcomplaints,fines,orconvictions.
3. Proofoftime:As every block also contains a time-stamp (chapter 4.2.2), the blockchain cannot onlyproveanentry’sveryexistence/nonexistence,butalsotheexacttimeanddatetheentrywasadded.Applications thatcouldbenefitare, forexample, the trackingofpayments,deliveryornotificationtracking,themanagementofpredictions,etc.
7.DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology
25
4. Proofoforder:Apartfromstatingtheexacttimeofanevent,theblockchainalsoclearlyprovestherela-tiveorderinwhicheventsoccurred.Provingthatacertaineventtookplacebeforeanothereventcouldbeusedinexamplessuchaspatentapplicationsorcopyrightclaims.
5. Proofofidentity:Asaspecificcaseofproofofexistence,proofofidentitycanensurethatacertainidentityalreadyexists.This couldbeused in the formofdigital identitydocuments forpeople,animals,orgoods,similartoaforgery-proofpaperdocument.
6. Proofofauthorship:Theblockchaincanalsoprovideinformationonwhoaddedcertaindata.Throughthecon-ceptsof identificationandauthenticationrequireauthorstoverifytheir identitybeforemakinganentryontheblockchain.Averygoodexampleforthisusecasecouldbethetrackingofcontentchangesindocuments.
7. Proofofownership:Relyingonallpreviouslymentionedusecases,thispatternallowstomanageandclarifyownershipofrealestate,cars,companyshares,cryptographiccurrencies,andmanymore.
7.2 Overview of Blockchain Use Cases across different Industries Beingafoundationaltechnology(chapter6),theblockchaincouldpotentiallyfinduseinhundredsofdifferentusecases,manyofwhomareprobablynotevenknowntoday.Thefollowingsub-chapteraimstogivethereaderanideaofwheretheblockchaincouldbeused.Itthereforemustbenotedthatthefollowingdoesnotpresentacompletelistofpossibleapplications,butratherafewchosenexam-ples.
7.2.1 Banking
Withcryptocurrenciesbeingtheveryfirstapplicationsoftheblockchaintechnology,thebanking-andfinancialindustryhasnaturallybeenapioneeringsectorforblockchain.Accordingtoa2016surveybyIBM,91%ofbankshaveplannedtoinvestinblockchainsolutionsby2018(Bearetal.,2016).
Solvingthedoublespendingproblem:
Thedoublespendingproblemdescribestheriskthatdigitalcurrenciescouldpotentiallybespenttwice.Incontrasttophysicalcurrencies,whereinorderforonepersontoreceiveapaymenttheotherpersonhastohandoverthephysicalcoinornote,digitalcurrenciesconsistofdigitalinformation.Sincedigitalinformation caneasilybe reproduced,digital currencies require someone toensure thatwhateveramounttransferredfromoneaccounttoanotherisnotonlyaccreditedtothereceivingaccount,butalsodeductedfromthesendersaccount.Intoday’sfiatsystems,thisisensuredbyintermediariesintheformofbanks.Cryptocurrenciessuchasbitcoineffectivelysolvethedoublespendingproblembymaintaininga sharedpublic transaction ledger. Thismeans that funds canonlybe credited tooneaccountiftheyarebeingdebitedfromanotheraccountattheverysametime,similartohowforoneperson to receive a coin another person has to let go of it (“Double-Spending Definition |Investopedia,”).
7.2.2 Insurance
Withintheinsuranceindustry,theblockchaintechnologycouldpotentiallyenablenewrevenuemod-els.Forexample,Gatteschietal.(2018)describehowtheemergenceofsmartcontractsandblockchainbasedpaymentscouldenablemicro-orpay-per-useinsurances.Althoughtheoreticallypossible,thesetypesofinsurancewerenoteconomicallyfeasibleinthepastastheyusuallywerenotabletocovertheadministrativecostsassociatedwiththem.Theuseofsmartcontracts,forexample,couldallow
7.DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology
26
quickandcheappolicyundersignmentandmanagementonmobiledeviceswithclosetonowaitingtime.
7.2.3 Energymarkets
Theblockchainissaidtohelpestablishdecentralizedenergymarketsby,forexample,allowingenergysourcesandconsumerstoautomaticallytradeenergywithouthavingtorelyonintermediaries.Here,inputslikeamountofenergyproducedbyadevicecanberecordedontheblockchain’spublicledger,whilesmartcontractscansellthestoredenergytoconsumers(e.g.smarthomes)willingtopayacer-tainprice(Martyniuk,2018).
Inlate2017,SiemenshasdoubleddownonitsinvestmentinNewYorkbasedmicrogridproviderLO3Energy,whohasdevelopedablockchainbasedplatformformicrogrids.Thecompany’splatformallowssolarpanelownerstodirectlytradeunusedsolarenergywiththeirneighbors.Savingandtimestamp-ingeverytransactionontheblockchainkeepsanimmutablerecordofwhosoldwhichamountofen-ergytowho,whiletoken-basedpaymentsystemsallowforrealtimetransactionsettlements(SiemensAG,2017).
7.2.4 Retail&consumergoods
Theblockchainisalsosaidtohaveagreatimpactonretail-andconsumermarketsmostlythroughitspotentialtomakesupplychainsmorevisibleandtrustworthy.
Productorigin:
Astheblockchainmakesaproduct’ssupplychainfarmoretransparent,productinformationcanbemademoreaccessibletoconsumers.Walmart,forexample,onceconductedatracebacktestonman-goespriortousingblockchain.Ittookthemalmostsevendaystotracethemangoesbacktotheorigi-nalfarm.Withthehelpofablockchain-backedsupplychain,Walmartwasabletoprovidethesameinformationin2.2seconds(Charleboris,2017).
Foodsafety:
Integratingblockchainbasedsolutionsintofoodsupplychainsnotonlyhelpstounderstandwheretheproductiscomingfrom,itcanalsohelptoensurefoodsafetyalongtheway.ZetoChain,forexample,isaimingtoprovideanend-to-endsolutionfornotonlyrecordingtheproductsorigin,butalsomoni-toringenvironmentaldatasuchastemperaturealongtheitsjourney.Thisisachievedbyusingblock-chain-enabled IoT temperaturesensorsplacedatevery link in thecoldchain,aswellas theuseofsmartcontractsthatpreventtheacceptanceofaspecificdeliveryshouldsensorsrecordaninterrup-tionintheproductcoldchain(Zeto,2018).
7.2.5 Publicsector
Blockchainsolutionscouldplayavital role invariousgovernmentalprocesses.Manygovernments,includingtheUK,Brazil,China,SwedenandtheUSarealreadyrunningpilots,tests,andtrialsondif-ferentblockchain-basedapplications(Killmeyer,White,&Chew,2017).Someexamplesofpotentialapplicationsinthepublicsectorarepresentedinthefollowing.
Identitymanagement:
Linkingthephysical-anddigitalworldrequiresadigitalidentityandsincemoreandmoreprocessestakeplaceonlinepeoplehavetocreatemoreandmoredigitalidentities.Therearedigitalidentitiesatbanks,insurancecompanies,taxagencies,healthcareprovidersandmanymore.Asofrightnow,ourdigitaldataisstoredonavarietyofdifferentdatabasesandgeneratedatdifferenttimes,whichresultsintheproblemofnotalldigitalidentitiesbeingidenticalanduptodate.TheBlockchainallowsaperson
7.DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology
27
tocreateonesingledigitalidentitythatisstoredinasecureandincorruptiblemanner,andwhichcanbeusedforavarietyofonlineactivitiesthatrequireaperson’sidentification.ThegovernmentofEs-tonia,forexample,hasalreadyestablishedablockchain-baseddigitalIDthatcanbeusedtovote,filetaxreports,openbankaccounts,registerproperty,andmanyotheractivitiesthatinvolveaperson’sidentification(Shaan,2018).
Propertyregistration:
Today,land-andpropertyregistrationisamostlypaper-basedandfragmentedprocess,whichmakestransactionscostly,inefficient,andvulnerabletotampering.Byusingtheblockchain,adecentralized,standardized and non-corruptible record keeping system for property registration could be estab-lished.Thissystemwouldreducethenumberof intermediariesrequired(e.g.notaries),strengthenpropertyrights,anddecreaseprocesstimeandcost(Killmeyeretal.,2017).
Voting:
Similartohowpeoplecaninitiateothersecuretransactions,theblockchaincanallowcitizenstocastandvalidatevotes,aswellasverifyelectionresults.Ablockchainbasedvotingprocesspromisestogreatlyreducecosts(e.g.ballotprinting,electronicvotingmachines,maintenance,etc.),increasese-curityandauditabilityofvotes,allowallcitizenstovotefromanywhereintheworld(Killmeyeretal.,2017).
7.2.6 Healthcare
OneoffourpromisingpotentialblockchainapplicationsinhealthcareidentifiedbyBCGin2016(Closeetal.,2016),istorecordapatientsindividualmedicalrecordonablockchain.Thiswouldallowpatientstousepublicandprivatekeystolicensedataaccesstodoctors,hospitals,orotherpartieswithwhomthepatientwouldliketosharehisorhermedicalrecords.Havingmedicalrecordsstoredonablock-chainwouldnotonlygive thosewhohavebeengrantedaccessby thepatientacompletemedicalhistory of the patient, but also provide the patient with a complete audit trail of every doctor,healthcareprovider,medicaldevice,orotherentitythathashadaccesstothehisorherhealthcarerecords.Britain’sNationalHealthService(NHS)iscollaboratingwithGoogle’sDeepMindtocreateaprivateblockchainthatwouldenablepatientstotrackpersonaldataaccessanduseinrealtime.
7.2.7 Automotive
Blockchainisalsomakingitswayintotheautomotivesector.Carmanufacturers,suchasToyota,BMW,Volkswagen, or Renault have announced initiatives to bring blockchain to the automotive sector(McIntosh,2018).
Maintenance-&salehistory:
Blockchainscouldplayakeyroleinkeepingtrackofacar’smaintenanceandsalehistory,givingcardealers,partmanufacturers,andcustomersmoretransparentandreliableinformationabouttheve-hicleshistory.ThecompanyBigChainDBisworkingonthe‘CarPass’platform,whichaimstogiveeachvehicleanimmutabledigitalpassport.
Similarly, carmanufacturerscouldbeable to track individualparts,enabling themtoknowexactlywhichvehicletheywentinto.Knowingexactlywhichpartswentintoaspecificcarbecomesvaluablewhencertainpartsneedtoberecalled,asmanufacturerwouldbeabletoonlyrecallthosevehiclesthatwereactuallyfittedwiththeproblematicpart(McIntosh,2018).
7.DifferentApplicationsofBlockchainTechnology
28
Autonomousdriving:
According to German automotive supplier ZF Friedrichshafen, artificial intelligence and blockchainbasedtransactionsmustbecombinedwhenitcomestoautonomousdriving.Self-drivingvehiclesnotonlyneedtodrive,butalsoneedtobeabletoperformtransactionsandpayments. IncooperationwithIBMandUBS,thecompanyhasthereforedevelopeda‘CareWallet’basedonblockchaintechnol-ogythatwillallowcarstomakeautonomouson-the-gopaymentsthemselves.Thiscapabilitywouldallowcarstoautonomouslytransactwithpowerchargingstations,andwillbeofspecialimportanceinregardstocar-sharingandpay-per-usemodels(ZFFriedrichshafenAG,2018).
AccordingtoJimMilan,blockchaincouldalsoplayanimportantroleinmitigatingtheriskofhackingattacksonautonomousvehiclefleets.Milanstatesthatinsteadofhavingallconnectedcarsreporttoasingleserver,blockchainwoulddistributethedataamongstallnetworkparticipants.Hackingthesystemwouldnowrequirehackingallvehiclesonthenetworksimultaneously,insteadofattackingasingleserver(McIntosh,2018).
7.2.8 Entertainment
Today,platformssuchasYouTube,Spotify,Netflix,orSoundCloudactasdistributers forvideoandmusiccontent.Thismodelhasledtovariouspaymentdisputesbetweenartists(mostfamouslyTaylorSwift)andplatforms.Blockchainpromisestoenablenewbusinessmodelsintheentertainmentindus-try(Dhillon,2018).
Micropayments:
Bymakingmicropaymentseconomicallyfeasible,blockchaincouldallowartistsandcontentcreatorstosellcontentdirectlytoconsumers,potentiallyeliminatingtheneedforintermediariessuchasrecordlabelsorstreamingproviders.Intheory,artistcouldenjoyfullcontroloverhowtheyarepaidandinwhichwaytheircontentismonetized.Userscoulddirectlybuylicensestodownload,stream,remix,oruseapieceofcontent(e.g.asong)fromthecreator(Dhillon,2018).
Digitalrights:
Blockchaincanalsohelpsecuringrightsandauthorshipforanykindofdigitalcontent.DigitalrightsmanagementstartupMediachain,whichhasrecentlybeenacquiredbySpotify,isworkingonasolu-tionwheredigitalcontentisgivenauniqueIDwhichisthensecurelymanifestedontheblockchain,creating amedia library where author and story behind every piece of content can be identified(Dhillon,2018).
8.BlockchaininManufacturing
29
8. Blockchain in Manufacturing A2016surveybyDeloittefoundthatexecutiveswithinthemanufacturingindustryhadamongstthemostoptimisticoutlookonblockchain,with42%ofparticipantsstatingthatsubstantialinvestmentswerealreadybeingplanned for2017 (Schatsky&Piscini,2016).Despite itsoptimisticposition, themanufacturingindustrystillhasalongwaytogointermsofblockchainadoptionwhencomparedtothefinancialindustry(Iansiti&Lakhani,2017).
Beingafoundationaltechnology(chapter6),theblockchaincouldpotentiallyaffectthemanufacturingindustry ina varietyofways.However,experts suchasDieterichet al. (2017), identify threemaincategoriesofhowtheblockchaincouldtransformmanufacturing.
8.1 Supply chain and logistics Supplychainandlogisticsissaidtobeoneofareaswhereblockchaincouldunfolditsgreatestpoten-tial.IBMandDutchlogisticgiantMaerskwereamongstthefirsttodevelopablockchainbasedplatformtohelptrackthepapertrailsofthousandsofshippingcontainersaroundtheglobe.Insteadofhavingbitsofinformationspreadamongstdifferententitieswithinthesupplychain,theblockchaincanes-sentiallyprovideasharedvisibilityledger,everyonewithinthesupplychainreportsto.Althoughsolu-tionsusingtraditionalsoftwaredoexist,theyareusuallyownedbyoneentityandthusnotinteroper-ablealongentiresupplychains.Beingopenstandard,blockchaininitiativeswillallowdifferentsystemstobeintegratedintothesupplychain‘networkofnetworks’(IBM,2017).
Potentialbenefitsofblockchainbasedsupplychainsinclude:
Increasedtraceability:
Blockchainenablesmoretransparentandaccurateend-to-endtrackingofmaterialsalongtheentiresupplychain.Thishelpscompaniestoensurethatquality-,aswellasothercorporatestandardssuchas social responsibility aremet, especially since transaction records essentially become immutableoncerecordedontheblockchain(Deloitte,2017).
ThecompanyEverledger,forexample,hascreatedablockchainbasedplatformthatletsjewelerstrackexactlywhichmineagivendiamondcamefrom.Thishelpsthemtoensurethatminingandtransportofdiamondshasbeeninlinewithethicalstandards(“EverledgerDiamondPlatform,”n.d.).
Decreasedlossesfromcounterfeit:
Knowingexactlyhowpartsandfinishedgoodsarepassedthroughthechainofsubcontractorscouldhelppreventlossesfromcounterfeitandgraymarkettrading,aswellasincreaseconfidenceforend-marketusers(Deloitte,2017).
Improvedvisibility:
Theblockchaincouldensurethateveryauthorizedpartywithinthesupplychainwillhaveaccesstotheverysamedocumentsandinformation.Byreducingcommunicationordataerrorslesstimeneedstobespentvalidatinginformation,whichinreturnspeedsuptheprocessandsafescosts(Deloitte,2017).
Reducedadministrativecosts:
Havinginstantaccesstocompleteandauditproofsupplychaindatahelpstoreducecostsbyacceler-atingadministrativeprocessesforcomplianceorcreditpurposes(Deloitte,2017).
8.BlockchaininManufacturing
30
8.2 Internet of Things (IoT) Connectingphysicaldevisesandallowingthemtocollectandexchangedataonthenetworkissaidtobeoneofthekeydriversofindustrialgrowthsoverthecomingyears.TheInternetofThings(IoT),orIndustrial InternetofThings(IIoT)as it isreferredtoinanindustrialsetting,willhelpcompaniestocapturegrowthbyincreasingproductionratesandefficiency,creatingnewhybridbusinessmodels,foster innovationthrough intelligenttechnologies,andtransformtheirworkforce(Daughertyetal.,2015).
TheblockchaincouldplayanimportantroleinfutureIoTapplicationsandissaidtoimprovecurrentIoTsolutionsindifferentways.
8.2.1 Improvedsecurity
Asofrightnow,IoTdeviceswithinanetworkcommunicatethroughintermediariesintheformofcen-tral cloudservers.Thismakes IoT systemsprone tohackingasa ‘singlepointof failure’ couldgivehackersaccesstothenetwork.Thedistributednatureofblockchainprotectsnetworksbyeliminatesthissinglepointoffailure,whileencryptionprotectsindividualdevicesfromattacks(Deloitte,2018).
8.2.2 IdentifyingIoTdevices
AnotherproblemtheblockchaincouldsolveforIoTsystemsistheidentificationandauthenticationofindividualdevices,whichiscurrentlyachievedthroughcertificatesfromthirdpartyauthorities.Thirdpartycertification,however,comeswithcostswhichmakestheprocessunfeasibleforsmallerorlesssignificantdevices.Incontrasttotraditionalcertificates,registeringIoTdevicesonablockchaintocre-ateauniquedigitalidentityforeachdevicefurthermoreallowstheinformationaboutthedevicetobedynamicallyupdatedandcomplemented(Dieterichetal.,2017).
8.2.3 Networkscalability
BymakingcommunicationwithinIoTnetworksmoresecure(8.2.1)andreducingcostsfortheregis-trationprocess(8.2.2),blockchaincanhelpincreasethescalabilityofIoTnetworks(Dieterichetal.,2017).
8.2.4 Dataintegrity
Theblockchain’sirreversibilityandthefactthateveryblockhasatamper-prooftimestampcanhelpincreasetheintegrityofsensordata.Theblockchainthushelpstoensurethatsensordatawithintheindustrialinternetofthingshasnotbeenmanipulatedafterwards(Dieterichetal.,2017).
8.2.5 Grantingaccess
TheblockchaincouldfurtherhelpwiththeprocessofgrantingaccesstodatathatisgeneratedbyIoTdevices.OwnersofIoTdevicescouldeffectivelysellrealtimesensordatatocustomersindirectex-changeforcryptotokens(Dieterichetal.,2017).
BlockchainbasedIoTnetworkscouldessentiallyeliminatetheneedforcentralizedcloudserverstorunthenetwork.Amongstothersimilarprojects,BoschandCiscoSystemshavefoundedtheTrustedIoTAlliance.IncollaborationwiththeIOTAFoundation,BNYMellon,andavarietyofblockchainstart-ups,BoschandCiscoaredevelopingablockchainbasedIoTecosystem(TrustedIoTAlliance,2018).
8.BlockchaininManufacturing
31
8.3 3D Printing 3Dprintingislikelytoplayanimportantroleinfuturemanufacturingprocesses.Distributedmanufac-turingcouldpotentiallyincreaseflexibilityandshortenshippingroutes.Printingspecificpartsonde-mandcouldsignificantlyreducestoragecostsforspareparts.Theblockchaincouldplayinimportantroleinsecuringintellectualpropertyofprintingfiles,aswellasthetrackingandverifyingindividualpartsalongthesupplychain.
Howblockchaincouldhelpsecuringintellectualpropertyoffiles,andhowitcouldallowprintedpartstobeverifiedwillbefurtherexplainedinchapter9.3.
9.BlockchainApplicationsinResearch&Development
32
9. Blockchain Applications in Research & Development Asdescribedinchapter1.1,oneofthemainobjectivesofthisthesiswastoidentifyandevaluatehowR&Dactivitieswithinthemanufacturingindustrycouldpotentiallybenefitfromblockchaintechnolo-gies.Inordertoidentifypotentialusecases,twoapproacheswerefollowed.
Thefirstapproachwastoideatepotentialusecasesandevaluatethemfortheirtechnicalfeasibility,aswellastheirpracticalpotential.ThesecondapproachwastolookatexistingusecasesandideasfromothersectorsandtrytotranslatethemintoaR&Dsetting.
9.1 Defensive Publishing Theideaofdefensivepublishingonablockchaincombinestheconceptofhashingdata(chapter4.2.2)withtheblockchain’simmutablenatureanditsabilitytotimestampdata(chapter4.2.2).Althoughtheconceptwasfirstideatedbytheauthor,moredistinctsearchrevealedexistingprototypes.
9.1.1 Idea
Throughhashalgorithms,anytypeofdatacanbeturnedintoauniquenumericvalueoffixedlength–auniquedigitalfingerprintofthefile.Althoughthehashvaluegivesnoinformationabouttheactualfile,identicalfileswillalwaysresultinidenticalhashvalues.
Ifahashvaluewastobestoredonapublicblockchain,everyonecouldseewhenandbywhomthevaluewasputontheblockchain.Thisessentiallyallowscompaniestolaterproofthattheywereinthepossessionofacertaindocument,withouthavingtorevealtheinformationbeforehand.
9.1.2 Example
Apharmaceuticalcompanydiscoveredarevolutionarynewdrugbutisnotyetreadytofileapatentsincemoretestarestilltobedone.However,thecompanyalsohasagreatinterestinbeingabletoproofthattheywerethefirsttodiscoverthedrug.Disclosingtheirdiscoveriesisnotanoptionasthiswouldgivevaluableinformationtocompetitors.Thecompanydecidestosummarizethecurrentstateofresearchinadocumentandcreateahashvaluefromthedocument.Theynowtakethehashvalue,storeitonapublicblockchain,andrememberexactlywhichblockitwasstoredin.Asthehashvaluegivesnoinformationaboutitsunderlyingfile,noactualinformationwillbemadepublic.However,atanypoint inthefuture, thecompanycouldnowgivetheverysamedocumenttoacourt (orsomeotherkindofauthority),tellthemexactlywhichhashalgorithmtheyusedinthefirstplace,andletthecourthashthefileonceagain.Allthatislefttodoistocomparethehashvaluethatwasjustcreatedfromthefilethecourtreceivedwiththehashvaluethecompanystoredontheblockchainpreviously.Giventhattheoldandthenewhashvalueareidentical,thisprovesthatatthespecificpointinthepast,thecompanywasinpossessionoftheverysamedocument.
9.BlockchainApplicationsinResearch&Development
33
Figure 12. Defensive publishing on blockchain (source: own representation based on Bernstein Tech., 2017)
9.1.3 Benefit
Defensivepublishingonablockchainwouldallowcompaniestoconvincinglyproofthatagivenstateofknowledgeoradiscoverywaspresentwithinthecompanyataveryspecificdateinthepast.Themajorbenefitisthatnoactualinformationhastobemadepublicbeforehand.
Ananalogytothisprocesscouldbeadocumentthatwassealedandgiventoanotarywhoholdsontotheenvelope.Thenotarycouldthenlaterconfirmtheexactdateonwhichhe/shereceivedtheenve-lope,andthatthecontenthasnotbeenaltered.
However,comparedwiththenotary-analogytherearetwomajorbenefits.Firstly,hashvaluescanbecreatedfromanydataregardlessofsizeortype.Secondly,inharshcontrasttoexpensivenotaryfees,storingahashvalueonablockchaincomeswithlittletonocost.Thesefactorsresultinafargreaterscalabilityandautomatabilityoftheprocess.Forexample,itiscompletelyplausibletostorehashesofweeklyorevendailyversionsoflabnotebooksortestresultsonablockchain,whilehavingtheentireprocessfullyautomated.
9.2 Securing Specifications & Change Requests on the Blockchain SimilartotheconceptofDefensivePublishing(chapter9.1),hashvaluesofvirtuallyanyfilecouldbestoredonablockchain.InrespecttoR&D,thiscouldforexamplebeusedforproductspecificationsand/orchangerequests.Althoughnoexistingsolutionsweretobefoundatthetimeofthisstudy,theideaitselfwastransferredfromtheexistingusecasedescribedin9.1.
9.2.1 Example
ContractorAandengineeringserviceproviderBhavejustagreedonamajorchangerequestforanengineeringproject.Theybothwanttobesurethatfromthispointonforwardspecificationswillnotbechangedwithoutexplicitagreement.Theydecidethatabinding‘versionoftruth’ofthedocumentwillbehashedandstoredontheblockchain,withbothpartiesalsostoringthefileontheirprivateservers.Towardstheendoftheprojectthecontractorrealizesthattheengineeringserviceprovidermusthaveforgottenatolerancetheyagreedupon.KnowinglyorunknowinglyserviceproviderBar-guesthatthetolerancewasneverincludedinthespecifications.
However,insteadofwastingvaluabletimeandresourcesonfindingoutwhichofthetwopartiesisright,contractorAcaneffectivelyproofthattheirversionofthedocumentiscorrectbysimplycom-paringthehashvalueoftheirdocumentwiththehashvaluestoredontheblockchain.
Itshouldbenotedthatthisexamplecouldbeappliedtoanycontractordocumentwheretwoormorepartieshaveaninterestinstoringatrustable,tamperproofcopyonneutralground.
9.BlockchainApplicationsinResearch&Development
34
Figure 13. Storing contracts or other documents on the blockchain (source: own representation)
9.2.2 Benefit
Themainbenefitarisingfromthisapplicationistheabilitytostoreanimmutableandtime-stamped‘versionoftruth’ofanydocumentonneutralground.Again,thiscouldalsobeachievedbygivingacopyofthedocumenttoatrustedthirdparty(e.g.notary)whichensuresthattheversionitreceivedstaysunaltered.Aswiththepreviousexample,scalabilityandhighcostsarethemaindisadvantagescomparedtotheblockchainalternative.
Anotherbenefit is thatbyknowing that there indeedexistsanunalterableversionof truthon theblockchain,partiesmightloseinterestintryingtotricktheirbusinesspartnerssincetheyknowthattheotherpartycouldproofthemwronganyway.
9.3 3D Printing 3Dprintinghasbeeninthespotlightforawhilenow,andwithcontinuoustechnologicaladvances,thetechnologyislikelytoplayanimportantroleinfuturemanufacturingprocesses.
Despiteageneraltrendtowardscomputer-basedsimulationsthroughdigitalmock-ups,physicalsam-plesandprototypesarestillrelevantinproductdevelopmenttoday.Comparedtootherproductionmethods(e.g.injectionmolding),additivemanufacturingrequireslittleinvestmentfortoolingandisthereforeespecially adequate for small productionquantities,making3Dprinting also suitable forearlystagesampleproduction.However,apartfromtheprintingtechnologyitselftherearealsootherchallengesthatneedtoberesolved.
Securing intellectual property within the product development process becomes increasingly im-portantasmoreandmorepartiesbecomeinvolved.TheriseofR&Dcollaborations,ashifttowardsusingmoreandmoreengineeringserviceproviders,aswellasthetrendtowardssimultaneousengi-neeringrequiresindividualcompaniestoprotecttheirdata.
Althoughthisusecasewasfoundinexistingliterature,noveltyliesinitspotentialimpactonR&Dac-tivitiesinparticular.
9.BlockchainApplicationsinResearch&Development
35
9.3.1 SAMPL
SAMPL(SecureAdditiveManufacturingPlatform)–acooperationprojectbetweendifferentorgani-zationssuchasAirbus,Prostep,NXP,ortheFraunhoferInstitute,aswellasvariousuniversities–iden-tifiedthesechallengesasfollowed(SAMPL,2017).
Copyright–Intellectualpropertyintheformofprintable3D-filesneedstobeprotected.Similartotheproblemsthemusic-andmovieindustryfaced,manufacturersalsoneedtoprotectfilesfrompiracyandcounterfeitproducts.
Identifyingoriginals–Manufacturesdonotonlywant topreventcounterfeitparts frombeingpro-ducedinthefirstplace,theyalsoneedtoensurethat,ifcounterfeitpartsdoexist,theoriginalpartscanbeclearlyidentifiedassuchanddistinguishedfromunauthorizedcopies.
Liability–Inthecaseofwarrantyandproductliability,manufacturesneedtobeabletoshowexactlywhereandwhenacertainpartwasproduced.
Security–Itfurthermoreneedstobeensuredthatonlyauthorizedentitieshaveaccesstothedata.Thisfirstrequiresunequivocallyidentificationofwhoeverwantstoaccessthedata.
Safety– Itneeds tobeensured thatnounauthorizedchange toproductdataor featurescan takeplace.Thisbecomesespecially importantwhenpartshavesafetyrelevanceandneedtoholduptohighqualitystandards
TheSAMPLproject,whichispartlyfundedbytheGermangovernment,triestocreateablockchainenhanced3Dprintingplatformthatallowsdataownerstohavefullcontrolovertheirfiles.Theirap-proachseesaplatformthatcreatesa‘chainoftrust’betweentheintellectualpropertyownerandthefinalcustomer.Itincludesallintermediaries,theprintingserviceprovider,aswellasthe3Dprintersthemselves(‘trusted3Dprinters’)which’scontrolsneedtobecertified,too.Thischainoftrustiscom-plementedbyablockchainbasedlayerthatprovidesalllicenseandcopyrightinformation.Withinthechainoftrust,everyactionmustfirstbeauthorizedonthelicenselayerandwillthenberecordedonitaswell.Bymakinguseofsmartcontractswithinthelicenselayer,productownerscanaddressspe-cificquantitiestodifferentserviceproviders,knowingthatcertifiedprinterswillonlyprinttheexactquantitytheyarelicensedto.
But theprojectdoesnotonlywant toeffectively trackandsecuredataup to thepoint thepart isprinted,traceabilityofpartsshouldcontinueoncethephysicalpartexists.ByimprintingRFID-chipsontotheparts,eachpartcanbegivenauniqueidentityontheblockchainandthusbetrackedthrough-outitsentirelifecycle.
Othercompaniesaretakingsimilaractions,withGeneralElectricalreadyhavingfiledapatentforablockchainbaseddistributedmanufacturingplatformin2017(USPatent&TrademarkOffice,2018),and3DprintersupplierssuchasHPbeinginvolvedinvariousprojects(Feldman,2018)
Blockchainbased3Dprintingplatformscouldessentiallyallowdataownerstosharedatawithouthav-ingtogiveawaytheactualfile.
9.4 Digital Product Backbone Anotherconceptwhichcouldaffectdevelopmentprocessesistheideaofblockchain-baseddata-andconfigurationsmanagement,whichcouldhelpmanagecomplexityandincreasetraceabilityofproductsub-systems.Thisconceptwasideatedbytheauthorandthusverylittleinformationwastobefoundinexistingliterature.Therefore,onlythebasicideawillbedescribedinthefollowing.
9.BlockchainApplicationsinResearch&Development
36
9.4.1 Idea
Ascomplexityinelectric/electronicsystemsincreases,traceabilityofE/Ecomponentsfromearlysys-temsengineering toafter salesbecomes increasinglydifficult.Configurationsare currentlydefinedthroughtraditionallystructuredpartlists(billofmaterial).Furthermore,technicaldocumentssuchasCADfilesarealsoattachestothisbillofmaterial,thusfurtherincreasingsizeandcomplexityofthepartlist(Heber&Groll,2017).
Heber&Groll(2017)thereforedescribetheideaofcreatingablockchainbaseddigitaltwinofindivid-ual products or subsystems, acting as product backbone and including all relevant information asmetadata.Intheory,thisdigitaltwinisabletosuccessfullylinkeveryconfigurationandchangeaprod-ucthasundergonetooneanother,aswellasputthemintherightchronologicalorder.
Ifasub-systemishandedoverfromsuppliertoOEM,theOEMcanmirrorthesub-systemsblockchain.Thisallowstonotonlyreceiveallrelevantproductinformationintherightchronologicalorder,theOEMisalsoabletolinksubsequentblockstothealreadyexisting(mirrored)blockchain,ensuringcon-figurationtraceabilityalongtheproduct’sentirelifecycle.
10.Analysis
37
10. Analysis AddressingthetopicofblockchaininmanufacturingandR&Dfromamoregeneralperspective,thetechnologywillfirstbeevaluatedaccordingtothetheoriespresentedinchapter5.
Afterwardsthethreepotentialapplicationsofblockchain-technologiesinR&D(asdescribedinchapter9)willbeevaluatedin-depthbasedoninterviewresponsesandliteraturefindings.Eachuse-casewillthenbecategorizedalongtheAdoptionMatrixforFoundationalTechnologies(chapter6.2).
10.1 Assessing the State of Blockchain in Manufacturing and R&D In the following, the blockchain technology will be evaluated along the theories presentedinchapter5.
10.1.1 Technologyadoption
Itmustbestatedthattheoverallknowledgeaboutblockchain-technologiesanditspotentialapplica-tions inmanufacturingandR&Dwasrather limitedamongst interviewparticipants.This,combinedwiththescarcityofalreadyestablishedapplicationsinthemanufacturingindustrytoday,supportsthecasethatoveralladoption isnotveryadvancedat thispoint.As JosephM.Woodside’s2017study(chapter5.2.2)alreadysuggests,onlyapplicationsinthefinanceindustryarelikelytohavereachedtheearlyadoptersstageatthispoint.ItcanthereforebeconcludedthatblockchaininmanufacturingandR&Dislikelytostillresideintheinnovatorsstage.
10.1.2 Technologyimprovement
Analyzingthecurrentliteratureonblockchaintechnologyitbecomesclearthatforalargenumberofpotentialuse-casestobefeasible,thetechnologyneedsto improve inkeyareas(chapter4.4). It isthosetechnicalobstacles(especiallythelimitedscalabilityandtherelativelyhighcosts),thatpreventblockchain-technologies fromreally improving.However, if these technical challengescanbeover-come,blockchainislikelytoleavetheinfancyphase,andenteritsexplosionphasewhereperformancewillimproveexponentially.
10.1.3 Thepaceoftechnologysubstitution
ThetechnologyadoptionmatrixdevelopedbyAdner&Kapoor(chapter5.4)putsafocusonthere-spectivetechnology’secosystem.Ittakesthenewtechnology’semergencechallenges,aswellastheoldtechnology’sextensionopportunitiesintoaccount.
Ecosystemextensionopportunities(oldtechnology):
Mostpotentialblockchainuse-cases inmanufacturingandR&Dare in competitionwith traditionalsoftwaresolutions.Althoughsoftwareproductsthemselvesareconstantlybeingimproved,extensionopportunitieswithintheirecosystemhavebecomerarer.Whileinthepast,factorssuchasprocessingpowerorinternetspeedwerelimitingtraditionalsoftwaresolutions,weseemtohavereachedapointwheresoftwareisrarelylimitedbyexternalfactors.
Ecosystememergencechallenge(newtechnology):
Externalfactorssuchasthelackinglegalframeworks(asdescribedinchapter4.4.2)arelikelytofurtherdelayblockchainadoption.Itcanthereforebestatedthattheblockchain’secosystememergencechal-lengesarerelativelyhigh.
Withlowextensionopportunitieswithintraditionaltechnologies’ecosystems,butratherhighemer-gencechallengeswithin theblockchain’secosystem,quadrant3 (illusionof resilience)seemstobe
10.Analysis
38
whereblockchain-technologiesfallinto.Thismeansthatadoptionislikelytostagnateuntilemergencechallengescanberesolved.Forthisperiodmarketsharesareunlikelytoshiftandwill remainwithtraditionalsoftwaresolutions.However,oncetheblockchain’semergencechallengescanberesolved,substitutioncouldbequiterapid.
10.1.4 Gartnerhypecycle
Giventhattheinitialhypearoundblockchainseemstohavefaded,itislikelythatthePeakofInflatedExpectationshasbeensurpassed.However,therealquestioniswhetherornottheThroughofDisillu-sionmenthasbeenreachedyet.Althoughnodecisiveanswercanbegiven,itislikelythattheblock-chain-technologyasawhole iseitherat,orcloseto it. Itseemsas ifadoptersthroughoutdifferentindustrieshaveshiftedtheirfocusbacktowardsspecificapplicationswherethetechnologycanreallybringanadvantage.
10.2 Defensive Publishing Thefollowingwillpresentan in-depthanalysisoftheuse-caseDefensivePublishingasdescribedinchapter9.1.
10.2.1 Interviewresponses&interpretation
Responses varied depending on the interviewee’s individual position, aswell as the orientationofhis/herdepartment.Asageneraltrenditcouldbeobservedthatmoreresearch-baseddepartmentssawgenerallymorepotentialfortheapplication.Themostpositiveresponse(8outof10forpotential)regardingpotentialcamefromanindividualworkingforaGermanresearchinstitution.Hisargumentwasthatalthoughlabbooksdoexist,theyprovidelittleevidenceinhindsightastheycanbealteredatwill. The research institute however has great interest at being able to proof previously existingknowledgewhenneeded.
Averagedamongstallfiverespondents,theapplicationspotentialwasseenata6.8outof10,whilelikelihoodwasseenat5.1outof10.Giventhatamarketreadysolutionwasavailabletoday,partici-pantsansweredthatitwouldtakeanaverageof2.9yearsbeforetheprocesswasfullyimplemented.
ItmustbenotedthatR&Disaverybroadfield,andnoteveryoneisdirectlyinvolvedwithnewintel-lectualpropertythatmustbesecuredagainstcompetitors.Itisthuslikelythatresponsesvarygreatlydependingonindividual’spositionwithinthecompany,andthecompany’sinvolvementinscientificresearch.Itmustfurtherbenotedthatthemainobjectivemustbetofileapatent,andthattheblock-chainapplicationaspresentedshouldmerelyberegardedasanadditionaltoolingettingthere.
10.2.2 Adoptionmatrix
Novelty:Sincetheonlywayforacompanytoprotectitsintellectualpropertytodayistofileapatentassoonaspossible,beingabletoproofone’sresearchprogressbeyondanydoubtconstitutesahighdegreeofnovelty.
Complexity:Comparedtootherblockchainsolutions,technicalcomplexityranksratherlow.However,whilethetechnicalcomplexityitselfisratherlow,establishingthisuse-caseasanacceptedstandardcouldstillpresentchallengesasbothpatentofficesandcourtsneedtoagree.Thisassumptionisalsosupported by the questionnaire, where despite market ready solutions the implementation time-framewasestimatedtobealmostthreeyears.
Withahighdegreeinnovelty,butalowtomediumdegreeincomplexity,DefensivePublishingcanbeassignedtothesecondquadrant(Localization).
10.Analysis
39
10.3 Securing Specifications & Change Requests on the Blockchain Thefollowingwillprovideanin-depthanalysisoftheideaofstoringspecificationsandchangerequestsonablockchain(asdescribedinchapter9.2).
10.3.1 Interviewresponses&interpretation
Respondentsevaluatedtheconceptwithanaveragepotentialof7.1outof10,andalikelihoodof6.4outof10.Theyfurtherstatedthatifthedecisiontoadoptblockchainbasedsolutionwasmadetoday,andgiventhatamarketreadysolutionisavailable,itwouldtakethecompaniesanaverageof2.8yearsbeforetheprocesswasfullyimplemented.
Interviewrespondentsseemtohaveastrong interest inbetterandmoretransparentsolutionsformanagingchangerequestsandspecifications.Thisimpliesthatmanycompaniesinfacthaveproblemsinthisarea.Itmustbenoted,however,thattraditionalsoftwaresolutionsformanagingchangere-questsandspecificationsdoexists,andthatmostcompaniescouldimprovetransparencyandtracea-bilitybyimprovingoradoptingtraditionalsoftwaresolutions.
10.3.2 Adoptionmatrix
Novelty:Giventhattraditionaldocumentmanagementsystemshavebeeninuseforawhile,itcanbeconcludedthatthedegreeofnoveltyisfairlylow.
Complexity:While the technical complexity itself is rather low, establishing thisuse-caseas anac-ceptedstandardcouldpresentchallenges.Althoughimplementationonanorganizationallevelwouldnotbetoohard,thedifficultyliesinturningitintoastandardwhichwillbeacceptedbyvariousdevel-opmentpartners.
Witharelativelylowdegreeinnovelty,butamediumtohighdegreeincomplexity,DefensivePublish-ingcanbeassignedtothethirdquadrant(Substitution).
10.4 3D Printing Anin-depthanalysisoftheideaofblockchain-based3D-printingnetworks(asdescribedin9.3)willbepresentedinthefollowing.
10.4.1 Interviewresponses&interpretation
Blockchainenabled3D-printingwasaccreditedwithanaveragepotentialof6.2outof10amongstallsevenparticipants.Likelihoodwasseenslightlylowerwithanaveragescoreof5.6outof10.Thepos-sibleImplementationtime-framewasestimatedtobearound3.4years.
Atthetimeofthisthesis,researchonblockchain-basedProductDataManagementseemstobeinitsinfancy.Beforeamoreconclusiveevaluationonthesubjectcanbeconducted,existingideasmustbeturnedintofunctioningprototypesandcomparedwithcurrentsolutions.Itis,however,aconceptthatshouldbecloselymonitoredoverthenextmonthsandyears.
10.4.2 Adoptionmatrix
Novelty:Sincedataprotectionin3D-printingthroughablockchain-basedsolutionisacompletelynewconcept,noveltyrankshighforthisuse-case.Thisassumptionissupportedbythefactthatnoneoftheinterviewparticipantshaveheardaboutthisapproachbefore.
Complexity:Realizingablockchain-supported3D-printingnetworkrequiresnotonlyaworkingtech-nicalsolution,printingcontractorsalsoneedtobecomecertified.Thefactthatsofaronlyprototypesandconceptsexistspeaksforahighdegreeofcomplexity.
10.Analysis
40
Withahighlevelofcomplexityandnovelty,blockchain in3D-printingmustbeplacedinthefourthquadrant(Transformation).
11.Conclusion
41
11. Conclusion Blockchain–thetechnologybehindvirtualcurrenciessuchasBitcoin–isbeingpromotedbymanyasoneofthemostpromisingemergingtechnologies.Similartotheinternetinitsearlydays,blockchain(oftenreferredtoasDistributedLedgerTechnology)mustbeseenasafoundationaltechnology,ena-blingagreatvarietyofpotentialapplications.Intheory,mostsoftwareapplicationstodaycouldsome-howberealizedthrough-orcomplementedbyblockchain.However,sincetheblockchains’securityattributesdonotalwaysoutweighthespeed-andcostadvantagesofconventionalsoftwaresolutions,noteveryapplicationthatcanberealizedthroughblockchainshouldbe.
Atitscoretheblockchainisadistributed,immutabledatabase,abletopinpointexactlywhenandbywhomagiventransactionhasbeenmade.Afteracertainamountofindividualtransactionshavebeenconductedwithinthenetwork,thesetransactionsarebeingsummarizedinablockandsubsequentlyaddedtotheblockchain.Withthehelpofcryptographichashfunctions,everyblockislinkedtobothitspredeceasing-andsucceedingblock.Thisessentially results ina chain-likeconnectionwhereallblocksaresecurelyconnectedtooneanother.Thefactthatwheneveranewblockistobeaddedtothechainamajorityofthenetworkneedstofirstagreeonthecurrentstateoftheentireblockchain–consensusmechanism–makestheinformationstoredontheblockchainvirtuallytamper-proofandcreatesanirreversiblerecordoftransactions.
However,thisconsensusmechanismisalsowhatgreatly limitstransactionspeedandsubsequentlyscalabilityofblockchainapplications.Althoughtransactionspeedsandotherlimitingfactorsarecon-stantlybeingimproved,theblockchainshouldnotbeseenasthesolutiontoallofworld’sproblemsbutmuchratherasatechnologythatcanbringgreatvalueinveryspecificenvironmentsandapplica-tions.
Aspectsthatdofavortheuseofblockchainincludemultiplepartiessharingandupdatingshareddata,theneedtobeabletotrusttherecords,theexistenceofintermediariesthataddcosts,aswellasmiss-ingtrustbetweenthepartiesinvolved.
Someoftheblockchain’skeyadvantagesincludedisintermediation,improvedtraceabilityofproducts,increasedtransparencyoftransactionhistories,aswellasenhancedsecurityofrecordsregardingfraudandunauthorizedactivities.
Inrespecttoobjective1– identifyanddescribethemostrelevantpotentialblockchainapplicationswithinmanufacturingindustries–itcanbestatedthatthemanufacturingindustryislackingbehindthefinancialindustryintermsofblockchainadoption.Nonetheless,thethesisisabletoidentifythreemaincategorieswhereblockchaintechnologiesmostprobablywillaffectmanufacturingcompanies.
Withinthesupplychainand logisticssectors,manufacturingcompanieswillbenefit fromincreasedtraceabilityandvisibilityofsupplychains.Blockchaincould,forexample,helptoensurethatallpartieswithinthesupplychainaccessverysamedocumentsandinformation,thusreducingtheriskcommu-nicationordataerrorsandhelpreduceadministrativecosts.Knowingexactlyhowpartsandfinishedgoodsarebeingpassed through thechainof subcontractorscanalsohelp todecrease losses fromcounterfeitproducts,aswellasallowOEM’stoexactlypinpointwherespecificpartscamefromincaseofmalfunctions.Thiscanfurtherhelpcompaniestoproofthatmaterialsweresourcedinalignmentwithcorporatesocialresponsibilitystandards.
TheInternetofThings(IoT)–afuturekeydriverofindustrialgrowthinitself–isalsosaidtobenefitfromblockchaintechnologies.SecurityofIoTsystems(orIndustrialInternetofThingsasreferredtoinamanufacturingcontext)willbeenhancedastheblockchaincanenablenetworksystemswithouttheneedofacentralcloudserver.ThiscentralcloudserverarchitectureiswhatmakesIoTsystemsvul-nerabletohackingattacksaseverydevicewithinthenetworkcangranthackersaccesstotheentire
11.Conclusion
42
system(singlepointoffailure).Furthermore,theblockchaincanhelptoidentifyandauthenticatein-dividualIoTdevices,aprocessthatcurrentlyrequiresthirdpartycertificationwhichagainisaddingcostsandlimitsscalabilityofnetworks.ProjectssuchastheTrustedIoTAlliance,whichamongstotherconsistsofBoschandCiscoSystems,arealreadyworkingonblockchainbasedIoTecosystemsandhavealreadylaunchedtestnetworks.
Thethirdandlastcategorywhereblockchainmostprobablywilltransformmanufacturingisdistributedmanufacturing.Distributedmanufacturing,mainlyintheformof3Dprinting,willallowcompaniestoincreaseproductionflexibility,shortenshippingroutes,andsignificantlyreducetheneedforin-storagespareparts.Blockchainsolutionswill therebyhelptosecure intellectualproperty(e.g.constructionfiles)wheneverprintablefilesaresenttocontractorsorotherthirdparties.ByequippingpartswithRFID-chipsorotheridentificationmeasuresitwillfurthermorebepossibletotraceproductsfromtheverymomenttheywerecreated.ProjectssuchasSAMPL(SecureAdditiveManufacturingPlatform),acooperationbetweencompaniessuchasAirbus,Prostep,andtheFraunhoferInstitute,arealreadytry-ingtoestablishblockchain-based3D-printingplatformsthatwillhelpincreasesecurityinadditiveman-ufacturing.Theproject’sgoalsaretoprotectfilesfrompiracy,helpidentifyoriginals,ensuretraceabil-ityofprintedparts,securedatafromunauthorizedaccess,aswellasensureintegrityofindividualfiles.
Regardingmainobjective2–examineifandhowthetechnologycouldaffectR&Dprocesseswithinmanufacturingcompanies–itmustbeconcludedthat,atleastatthispointoftime,blockchain-tech-nologiesaregenerallybettersuitedforotherenvironmentssuchaslogistics,financial,orthepublicsector.Manyofthoseblockchainfavoringcaricaturistsdescribedabove(multiplepartiessharingandupdatingshareddata,theneedtobeabletotrusttherecords,existingintermediariesthataddcosts,andespeciallymissingtrustbetweenthepartiesinvolved)onlypartlyapplytoR&Denvironments,mak-ingtraditionalsoftwaresolutionsoftenfavorable.However,blockchain,asexplainedearlier,enablesavarietyofdifferentapplications,someofwhichcanalsobringvaluetoR&Ddepartments.
Blockchain-based3Dprintingsolutionsasdescribedabovecanalsobecomerelevantwithinproductdevelopment.Thesmallproductionquantitiesofprototypesorearlysamplesmake3Dprintingagoodalternativetoinvestmentheavyproductionmethodssuchasinjectionmolding,especiallyattheearlystagesofproductdevelopment.ThepreviouslymentionedSAMPLproject,aswellassimilarinitiativesshouldthereforebemonitoredclosely.
Similartohowtheblockchaincouldprotectfileswithin3Dprintingprocesses,itmighteventuallybepossibleforthetechnologytohelpsecurefileswithinvirtualsimulation-andtestenvironments.Sim-ulationsmight someday be run in a virtual black-box, providing companies the simulation resultsneededwithoutgivingaccesstotheactualconstructionfiles.However,therearenoprojectsorinitia-tivesonthetopicyet,makingitunliketoappearanytimesoon.
Anapplicationthatiscurrentlymuchmorefeasiblefromatechnicalstandpointisthestoringofhashvaluesonablockchain.Amongstothers,BernsteinTechnologieshavedevelopedaservicethatallowscompaniestoturnanyfileofunlimitedsizeintoafixednumericcode(hashvalue)whichisthenstoredontheblockchain.Byitsnature,ahashvaluedoesnotrevealanyinformationabouttheunderlyingdocument.However,everytimeanidenticalfileisinsertedintothesamehash-algorithm,itwillresultintheverysamehashvalue.Witheveryblockontheblockchaincontainingatimestamp,andcombinedwith the irreversiblenatureof theblockchain, this concept referred toasdefensivepublishing letscompanieseffectivelyproofthattheywereinpossessionofacertaindocumentatagivenpointinthepastwithouthavingtoprematurelyrevealitscontent.Aprimeexamplewherethisconceptcouldbeusedislaboratorynotebooks.Researchinstitutionshaveagreatinterestinbeingabletoprooftolegalinstitutionsorcompetitorsthatthecontentoftheirlaboratorynotebookshasnotbeenalteredafter-wards.
11.Conclusion
43
Similartotheconceptofdefensivepublishing,virtuallyanydocumentcanbeturnedintoahashvalueandstoredontheblockchain.Thiscouldproofvaluablewhereverthereisaninterestinbeingabletolaterproof that thedocument inquestionhasnotbeenaltered.ProductspecificationsandchangerequestsareanotherexamplewhereR&Ddepartmentsmighthaveaninterestinhavinganimmutable‘singleversionoftruth’ofthedocumentstoredontheblockchain.
Inbothcasestheblockchainessentiallytakesontheroleofanotary.However,blockchainsolutionscanprovidetheserviceforafractionofthecostandwithfarbetterautomatabilityandscalability.
Anatthemomentrathervaguepotentialuse-caseistheblockchain’spossibleinvolvementincreatingdigitalproductbackbonesinformofaproductsdigitaltwin.Althoughanideahasbeenpublishedthatdescribesascenariowhereamajorityofdocumentsrelatedtoagivenproductarestored(oratleastareferencedto)ontheblockchain,itwillmostlikelytakeyearsbeforethefirstprototypesareopera-tional.Nonetheless,theideaholdsgreatpotentialandshouldthereforebemonitoredoverthecomingyears.
Inconclusionitcanbestatedthattheblockchainisatechnologythatwillaffectmostifnotallareasofbusinessinsomewayoranother.However,sincetheblockchain’sgreatestpotentialliesinitsabilitytodisintermediateandoptimizeveryspecificprocesses,companiesshouldfirstevaluateexactlywhereand how they could benefit from it andwhether blockchain-based solutions could provide an ad-vantagecomparedtotraditionalones.Ratherthanquickanddisruptive,overalladoptiontothetech-nologyislikelytobemoregradual,startingwiththemostrudimentaryapplicationsandslowlygainingmomentumasthetechnologyitself,individualproducts,aswellasthelegislationsurroundingitim-prove.
Bibliography
XLIV
Bibliography Adner, R.,&Kapoor, R. (2015). Innovation ecosystems and thepaceof substitution: Re-examining
technology S-curves. Strategic Management Journal, 37(4), 625–648.https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2363
Adner, R., & Kapoor, R. (2016). Right Tech, Wrong Time. Harvard Business Review, (November).Retrievedfromhttps://hbr.org/2016/11/right-tech-wrong-time
Bear, K., Drury, N., Korsten, P., Pureswaran, V.,Wagle, L., &Wallis, J. (2016). Leading the pack inblockchain banking. IBM Research, 1–20. Retrieved from https://www.hyperledger.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Leading-the-pack-in-blockchain-banking-1.pdf
Bernstein Tech. (2017). The blockchain way to intellectual property Why the blockchain willrevolutionizeIP.
BitFury Group. (2015). Proof of Stake versus Proof of Work. Retrieved fromhttp://bitfury.com/content/downloads/pos-vs-pow-1.0.2.pdf
Blandford, A. (2013). Semi-Structured Qualitative Studies. The Encyclopedia of Human-ComputerInteraction,2ndEditio.
Blockchain Generations: Cryptocurrencies, Blockchain Platforms, Decentralized World. (2018).Retrieved May 24, 2018, from https://www.intellectsoft.net/blog/blockchain-generations-cryptocurrencies-and-blockchain-platforms
Charleboris,S.(2017).Howblockchaintechnologycouldtransformthefoodindustry.RetrievedJuly2,2018, from http://theconversation.com/how-blockchain-technology-could-transform-the-food-industry-89348
Close, K., Serazin, E., Aboshiha, A., Hurwitz, A., Lørup, L., & Hakim, N. (2016). A Prescription forBlockchaininHealthCare.
Daugherty,P.,Banerjee,P.,Negm,W.,&Alter,A.E.(2015).DrivingUnconventionalGrowththroughthe Industrial Internet of Things. Accenture, 1–20. Retrieved fromhttps://www.accenture.com/au-en/_acnmedia/Accenture/next-gen/reassembling-industry/pdf/Accenture-Driving-Unconventional-Growth-through-IIoT.pdf [Accessed 16 Aug.2016].
Deloitte. (2017). Using blockchain to drive supply chain innovation. Digitalization in Supply ChainManagement and Logistics: Proceedings of Hamburg International Conference of Logistics,1(December),2013.https://doi.org/10.15480/882.1444
Deloitte.(2018).IoTpoweredbyBlockchainHowBlockchainsfacilitatetheapplicationofdigitaltwinsin IoT, 20. Retrieved fromhttps://static1.squarespace.com/static/58f7bc39bebafb94498d25bf/t/5af42d3b0e2e728fc7dc086e/1526042306961/IoT_powered_+by_Blockchain.pdf
Dhillon, S. (2018).HowBlockchainCanTransformThe FutureOf Entertainment.Retrieved July 11,2018, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/valleyvoices/2018/02/01/how-blockchain-can-transform-the-future-of-entertainment/#558c0a6e6b6b
Dieterich,V.,Ivanovic,M.,Meier,T.,Zäpfel,S.,Utz,M.,&Sandner,P.(2017).ApplicationofBlockchainTechnology in the Manufacturing Industry, (November), 1–23. Retrieved fromwww.twitter.com/fsblockchain%0Awww.facebook.de/fsblockchain
Double-Spending Definition | Investopedia. (n.d.). Retrieved June 27, 2018, fromhttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/doublespending.asp
Drescher,D.(2017).Blockchainbasics:Anon-technicalintroductionin25steps.BlockchainBasics:ANon-TechnicalIntroductionin25Steps.https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4842-2604-9
Everledger Diamond Platform. (n.d.). Retrieved August 16, 2018, fromhttps://diamonds.everledger.io/
Fauvel, W. (2017). Blockchain Advantage and Disadvantages. Retrieved May 22, 2018, fromhttps://medium.com/nudjed/blockchain-advantage-and-disadvantages-e76dfde3bbc0
Feldman,A.(2018).HP’sCTO:BlockchainInManufacturingCouldStopTheProblemOfCopycatParts.RetrievedJuly24,2018,fromhttps://www.forbes.com/sites/amyfeldman/2018/06/18/hps-cto-blockchain-in-manufacturing-could-stop-the-problem-of-copycat-parts/#5655c4c4370e
Foster,R.N.(1986).Innovation:TheAttacker’sAdvantage(1sted.).SummitBooks.
Gartner Research. (2013). Inside Gartner Research, 1–28. Retrieved fromhttps://www.gartner.com/imagesrv/research/methodologies/inside_gartner_research.pdf
Gatteschi,V.,Lamberti,F.,Demartini,C.,Pranteda,C.,&Santamaría,V.(2018).BlockchainandSmartContracts for Insurance: Is the Technology Mature Enough? Future Internet, 10(2), 20.https://doi.org/10.3390/fi10020020
Harris, R. (2010). Evaluating Internet Research Sources. Virtual Salt. Retrieved fromhttps://www.virtualsalt.com/evalu8it.htm
Heber,D.,&Groll,M.(2017).Towardsadigitaltwin:HowtheblockchaincanfosterE/E-traceabilityinconsideration of model-based systems engineering. Proceedings of the 21st InternationalConferenceonEngineeringDesign(ICED17),Vol.3:Product,ServicesandSystemsDesign,3(DS87-3), 321–330. Retrieved from https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85029804429&partnerID=40&md5=7284deb46866017645b78f3350c41cc7
Hinks,J.,Alexander,M.,&Dunlop,G.(2007).TranslatingmilitaryexperiencesofmanaginginnovationandinnovativenessintoFM.JournalofFacilitiesManagement,5(4),226–242.
Hooper, M. (2018). Blockchain Unleashed: IBM Blockchain Blog. Retrieved May 11, 2018, fromhttps://www.ibm.com/blogs/blockchain/2018/02/top-five-blockchain-benefits-transforming-your-industry/
Iansiti,M.,&Lakhani,K.R.(2017).TheTruthAboutBlockchain.HarvardBusinessReview,(January-February2017Issue),1–2.https://doi.org/10.1080/15265161.2014.947042
IBM.(2017).TheBenefitsofBlockchaintoSupplyChainNetworks,1–4.Retrievedfromhttps://www-01.ibm.com/software/commerce/offers/pdfs/Blockchain_3-15-2017.pdf
Killmeyer,J.,White,M.,&Chew,B.(2017).Willblockchaintransformthepublicsector?TechTrends2018. Retrieved from https://dupress.deloitte.com/dup-us-en/industry/public-sector/understanding-basics-of-blockchain-in-government.html
Kleinrock,L.(2010).Anearlyhistoryoftheinternet[HistoryofCommunications].IEEECommunicationsMagazine,48(8),26–36.https://doi.org/10.1109/MCOM.2010.5534584
Lord, S. (2016). Bankchain & itBit: Settling on the blockchain.Modern Trader, 16. Retrieved fromhttp://www.futuresmag.com/2016/04/16/bankchain-itbit-settling-blockchain
Martyniuk,N.(2018).BlockchainEstablishesDecentralizedEnergyMarket.RetrievedJune29,2018,from https://medium.com/wepower/blockchain-establishes-decentralized-energy-market-ae413952f6da
McIntosh, R. (2018). From 0 to 100: The Fast and Furious Rise of Blockchain in the Auto Sector.Retrieved July 10, 2018, fromhttps://www.financemagnates.com/cryptocurrency/news/cryptocurrencynews0-100-fast-furious-rise-blockchain-auto-sector/
Mignogna,R. (2015).TechnologyForecasting&StrategicTechnologyPlanning.RetrievedAugust9,2018,fromhttp://richmignogna.blogspot.com/2015/03/technology-forecasting-strategic.html
Mohajan,H.(2017).TwoCriteriaforGoodMeasurementsinResearch:ValidityandReliability.MunichPersonalRePEcArchive.https://doi.org/10.26458/1746
Nakamoto, S. (2008). Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System. Www.Bitcoin.Org, 9.https://doi.org/10.1007/s10838-008-9062-0
Phillips,B.(2014).TheP2PWitchHunt.RetrievedAugust9,2018,fromhttps://blog.peer5.com/the-p2p-witch-hunt/
PwC. (2016). Blockchain: An Introduction. Retrieved from https://www.pwc.co.uk/financial-services/fintech/assets/blockchain-an-intro.pdf
Rideout,J.(2018).Theincorruptiblepowerofblockchain.ManufacturingAUTOMATION,1–2.
Rogers,E.M. (1962).Diffusionof Innovations.MacmillianPublishingCo. (Firstedit).NewYork:TheFreePress.https://doi.org/citeulike-article-id:126680
SAMPL.(2017).SAMPLProjektÜbersicht.
Saunders,M., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2009).Researchmethods for business students.Researchmethods for business students (5th ed.). Prentice Hall. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13398-014-0173-7.2
Schatsky,D.,&Piscini,E. (2016).Deloittesurvey:Blockchainreachesbeyondfinancialserviceswithsome industries moving faster. Deloitte, 2–5. Retrieved fromhttps://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/about-deloitte/articles/press-releases/deloitte-survey-blockchain-reaches-beyond-financial-services-with-some-industries-moving-faster.html#
Schumpeter, J. (1939). BUSINESS CYCLES - A Theoretical, Historical and Statistical Analysis of theCapitalistProcess.McGraw-HillBookCompany.
Shaan,R.(2018).BlockchainsandDigitalIdentity–TowardsDataScience.RetrievedJuly2,2018,fromhttps://towardsdatascience.com/https-medium-com-shaanray-how-blockchains-will-solve-privacy-88944f3c67f0
SiemensAG.(2017).GemeinsamePresseinformationvonSiemensundLO3Energy:SiemensinvestiertinLO3EnergyundstärktbestehendePartnerschaft,1–3.
Šimundić, A.-M. (2013). Lessons in biostatistics Bias in research. BiochemiaMedica, 23(1), 12–15.https://doi.org/10.11613/BM.2013.003
Swan,M.(2015).MelanieSwan(FirstEdit).O’ReillyMedia,Inc.
Tabscott,D.,&Tabscott,A. (2016).BlockchainRevolution:How theTechnologyBehindBitcoinandOtherCryptocurrenciesisChangingtheWorld.Portfolio.
TheRESPECTProject.(2004).RESPECTCodeofPracticeforSocio-EconomicResearch,1–4.
Trouton,S.,Vitale,M.,&Killmeyer,J.(2016).3Dopportunityforblockchain.DeloitteUniversityPress,1–22. Retrieved from https://dupress.deloitte.com/dup-us-en/focus/3d-opportunity/3d-printing-blockchain-in-manufacturing.html
TrustedIoTAlliance.(n.d.).TrustedIoTAlliance.RetrievedJuly24,2018,fromhttps://www.trusted-iot.org/
USPatent&TrademarkOffice.(2018).UnitedStatesPatentApplication:0180173203.RetrievedJuly24, 2018, from http://appft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=HITOFF&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsearch-adv.html&r=1&p=1&f=G&l=50&d=PG01&S1=20180173203.PGNR.&OS=dn/20180173203&RS=DN/20180173203
Voshmgir,S.(2016).Blockchains,SmartContractsunddasDezentraleWeb.TechnologiestiftungBerlin.Retrieved from https://www.technologiestiftung-berlin.de/fileadmin/daten/media/publikationen/170130_BlockchainStudie.pdf
Voshmgir,S.,&Kalinov,V.(2017).Blockchain:ABeginnersGuide.Retrievedfromhttps://s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/blockchainhub.media/Blockchain+Technology+Handbook.pdf
Williams,S.(2017).5BigAdvantagesofBlockchain,and1ReasontoBeVeryWorried.RetrievedMay14, 2018, from https://www.fool.com/investing/2017/12/11/5-big-advantages-of-blockchain-and-1-reason-to-be.aspx
Woodside,J.M.,Augustine,F.K.J.,&Giberson,W.(2017).BlockchainTechnologyAdaptionStatusandStrategies.JournalofInternationalTechnologyandInformationManagement,65–94.
WorldEconomicForum.(2015).DeepShift-TechnologyTippingPointsandSocietalImpact.DeepShiftTechnologyTippingPointsandSocietalImpact,(September).
Zeto. (2018). Blockchain: The future of food safety. Retrieved July 3, 2018, fromhttps://www.zeto.ie/2018/04/09/blockchain-the-future-of-food-safety/
ZFFriedrichshafenAG.(2018).ZFCareWalletSimplifiesUsageofAutonomousVehicles,1–3.