evaluation of potential methane generation in the ... · vol. 33, no. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

9
ISSN 0104-6632 Printed in Brazil www.abeq.org.br/bjche Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, October - December, 2016 dx.doi.org/10.1590/0104-6632.20160334s20150264 *To whom correspondence should be addressed This is an extended version of the work presented at the XI Latin American Symposium on Anaerobic Digestion (DAAL-2014), Havana, Cuba. Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE INVESTIGATION OF AN ABANDONED CONTAMINATED LANDFILL IN SANTIAGO, CHILE I. Cortés 1* and S. Montalvo 2 1 Centro Nacional del Medio Ambiente, Larraín 9975, La Reina, Santiago, Chile. E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected] 2 Departamento de Ingeniería Química, Universidad de Santiago de Chile. (Submitted: April 26, 2015 ; Revised: August 30, 2015 ; Accepted: August 31, 2015) Abstract - This study presents the environmental evaluation of an abandoned and potentially contaminated landfill using analyses for the presence of heavy metals and for methane generation potential. The site is located in the city of Santiago, Chile, and was used as a rural landfill for domestic, industrial and construction waste until 1978, but is now in a heavily urbanized area and surrounded by houses. Analyses performed on 24 samples taken in and around the site show Potential Methane Generation (PMG) values between 1.6% and 11.3% of maximum projected levels. These low values, compared to those of an active landfill, indicate that waste material stored in the site has a low capacity to generate methane. Concentrations of heavy metals in the surface and deep soil are similar to typical levels for these metals in normal soil, according to international USEPA standards, and do not present imminent risk to human health. The use of the PMG test technique for the study of the health risk of an abandoned landfill is a new contribution to the Chilean evaluation methodology and management program for Abandoned Sites with Potential Presence of Contaminants (SAPPC). As part of the environmental management strategy for the site, two of the five operable units studied were transformed into a park after this study. Keywords: Abandoned landfill; Methane; Solid waste; Contaminated sites. INTRODUCTION Studies related to the potential presence of con- taminants in soils at a site are varied and usually develop as a prior and fundamental step in the evalu- ation of remedial alternatives, recovery of the site for different uses, or both, depending on the characteris- tics of the location. However, there is no definitive, common methodology applied to all situations. To deal with this limitation, several comparative models have been developed to establish the presence of abnormal levels of contaminants at a specific site under study (Aslibekian and Moles, 2003; Muhlba- chova et al., 2015; Rodríguez et al., 2015; Wen et al., 2015; Khan et al., 2008). For example, since 1995 in the United Kingdom it has been known that soils within 1 to 3 km of metal smelters may contain up to 15 times the natural values of Pb in the soil and also may present high concentrations of Cd at distances as far as 40 km from the originating industrial activ- ity (Aslibekian and Moles, 2003). In polluted soils, interactions between heavy met- als, organic matter content and microorganisms have been correlated (Muhlbachova et al., 2015). Increas- ing concentrations of metals in the urban environ- ment have been studied, wherein concentrations of

Upload: others

Post on 19-Oct-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

ISSN 0104-6632 Printed in Brazil

www.abeq.org.br/bjche

Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, October - December, 2016 dx.doi.org/10.1590/0104-6632.20160334s20150264

*To whom correspondence should be addressed This is an extended version of the work presented at the XI Latin American Symposium on Anaerobic Digestion (DAAL-2014), Havana, Cuba.

Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering

EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE INVESTIGATION OF AN ABANDONED CONTAMINATED LANDFILL IN

SANTIAGO, CHILE

I. Cortés1* and S. Montalvo2

1Centro Nacional del Medio Ambiente, Larraín 9975, La Reina, Santiago, Chile. E-mail: [email protected]; [email protected]

2Departamento de Ingeniería Química, Universidad de Santiago de Chile.

(Submitted: April 26, 2015 ; Revised: August 30, 2015 ; Accepted: August 31, 2015)

Abstract - This study presents the environmental evaluation of an abandoned and potentially contaminated landfill using analyses for the presence of heavy metals and for methane generation potential. The site is located in the city of Santiago, Chile, and was used as a rural landfill for domestic, industrial and construction waste until 1978, but is now in a heavily urbanized area and surrounded by houses. Analyses performed on 24 samples taken in and around the site show Potential Methane Generation (PMG) values between 1.6% and 11.3% of maximum projected levels. These low values, compared to those of an active landfill, indicate that waste material stored in the site has a low capacity to generate methane. Concentrations of heavy metals in the surface and deep soil are similar to typical levels for these metals in normal soil, according to international USEPA standards, and do not present imminent risk to human health. The use of the PMG test technique for the study of the health risk of an abandoned landfill is a new contribution to the Chilean evaluation methodology and management program for Abandoned Sites with Potential Presence of Contaminants (SAPPC). As part of the environmental management strategy for the site, two of the five operable units studied were transformed into a park after this study. Keywords: Abandoned landfill; Methane; Solid waste; Contaminated sites.

INTRODUCTION

Studies related to the potential presence of con-taminants in soils at a site are varied and usually develop as a prior and fundamental step in the evalu-ation of remedial alternatives, recovery of the site for different uses, or both, depending on the characteris-tics of the location. However, there is no definitive, common methodology applied to all situations. To deal with this limitation, several comparative models have been developed to establish the presence of abnormal levels of contaminants at a specific site under study (Aslibekian and Moles, 2003; Muhlba-

chova et al., 2015; Rodríguez et al., 2015; Wen et al., 2015; Khan et al., 2008). For example, since 1995 in the United Kingdom it has been known that soils within 1 to 3 km of metal smelters may contain up to 15 times the natural values of Pb in the soil and also may present high concentrations of Cd at distances as far as 40 km from the originating industrial activ-ity (Aslibekian and Moles, 2003).

In polluted soils, interactions between heavy met-als, organic matter content and microorganisms have been correlated (Muhlbachova et al., 2015). Increas-ing concentrations of metals in the urban environ-ment have been studied, wherein concentrations of

Page 2: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

724 I. Cortés and S. Montalvo

Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering

Cd, Ni and Cr measured in plant leaves in 2012 ex-ceeded those reported in 1941 for the same species by factors of 10, 13 and 16, respectively (Rodríguez et al., 2015). The increase of these pollutants in the urban atmosphere was related to human activity changes during a period of more than 70 years. The anaerobic biodegradation of domestic and industrial waste in landfill sites goes through a complex pro-cess and therefore it is not easy to estimate the bio-logical conversions involved. Measurements at these sites must be performed carefully taking into account different waste sources such as pharmaceutical resi-dues, plastic products, antibiotics, and complex or-ganic compounds (Wen et al., 2015; Khan et al., 2008; Kumar et al., 2004; Aguilar-Virgen et al., 2011; Aguilar-Virgen et al., 2012; Angelidaki and Sanders, 2004; Stergar and Zagorc, 2002; ISO 11734, 2012; Kolstad et al., 2012; Gartiser et al., 2007; El-Mashad et al., 2012; Angelidaki et al., 2006).

Human activities in Chile have generated loca-tions known as Abandoned Sites with Potential Pres-ence of Contaminants (SAPPC), such as old land-fills, uncontrolled dumpsites, or industrial waste sites. When abandoned, these sites may be converted to new land uses without additional regulation. Stud-ies of contaminants in soils at these and other sites have been performed considering the type and extent of pollutants in the involved area (Romero et al., 1999; Ginocchio et al., 2004; Molina et al., 2009; Escudey et al., 2007; Badilla-Ohlbaum et al., 2001; Palma-Fleming et al., 2000). The systematic evalua-tion of SAPPC in Chile began only 5 years ago, in 2010, and has targeted defined areas that have been environmentally impacted by one or more potentially polluting activities, which ended at some point with-out a proper site closure process.

In 2012, the Chilean Government began to apply a national methodology (Chilean Government, 2012) to identify and confirm the presence of contaminants at these sites. This methodology contains an ordered sequence of activities whose first step is the applica-tion of criteria to identify and prioritize SAPPC sites within each region. Subsequently, in step two, the Preliminary Investigation collects and analyses site historical information. In step three, the Confirma-tory Investigation collects and analyses site samples. See Figure 1.

The Confirmatory Investigation of the SAPPC methodology, as shown in Figure 2, is designed to determine representative concentrations of pollutants present at the potentially contaminated site, which are then compared with reference criteria to confirm whether or not the suspected contaminant levels pose a preliminary risk to potential receptors.

Figure 1: Illustration of the Chilean SAPPC. Evaluation Methodology developed and conducted by the Ministry of Environment.

Figure 2: Flow Diagram for the SAPPC Confirma-tory Investigation.

Suitable methods of analysis for this study were selected for quantifying the presence of heavy metal contaminants. To evaluate an abandoned landfill un-der the SAPPC methodology, it is crucial to establish the levels of landfill gas (biogas, consisting of CH4,

Regional level:identification, prioritization, ranking

Specific site level:preliminary investigation

Confirmatory Investigation

Gather detailed activity and pollution history of the site

Compare with reference values

Develop concentration statistics

for each contaminant

Form hypothesis about the distribution of potential contaminants

Execute Sampling, Analysis of Water, Wastes, Soil, and Gas

Do the concentrations represent preliminary risk?

Communicate results. Execute preventative management

of environmental risks.

No

Yes Develop a risk assessment

Page 3: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

Cmes

evinlaPgm

Cd1ficitebAcethpco

taeaidpdwcoexCtoso

Evalu

CO2, H2S, N2methodology stablish these

This papevaluation ofn the Confirandfill in the

PMG as a meas levels is a

ment of the Ch

The SAPPChile, had an

ential, indus962 and 197ive municipaity and werechnique thale barriers

After the cloeled out andhe constructiected that soontain heavy

The test araking into acach sector. 3dentified throint consistieep soil zone

were collecteoncentrationxtrinsic toxi

Characteristico USEPA Teource Conse

uation of Potentia

Brazilian

). However, does not co

e levels. er presents af Potential Mrmatory Invee city of Sanethodology f

an important hilean SAPP

MET

PC known asn area of 25 strial and co78. Wastes alities locatedre placed usat did not incor other spsure of the

d used for difion of residoils in a landy metals, gas rea was diviccount the di30 representaroughout theng of a surfae. 80 soil sam

ed for later ns, pH levelsicity was mec Leaching Pest Method 1ervation and

al Methane Gener

Journal of Chem

the current Contain details

a case studyMethane Genestigation ofntiago, Chilefor determincontribution

PC Evaluation

THODS

s La Cañamehectares andonstruction deposited thd in the soutsing a rudimclude the usepecial protec

landfill, thefferent objecdential housidfill such as and other poded into six ifferent usesative samplie area, withace zone, a trmples and 24evaluation o

s and extrinseasured usin

Procedure (TC1311, establis

Recovery A

Figure 3

ration in the Inves

mical Engineering

Chilean SAPs about how

y including neration (PMf an abandone. This studyning the land

to the advann Methodolog

era in Santiad received rewaste betwe

here were frhern part of

mentary lande of impermctive measure land was ptives, including. It was this one mi

ollutants. operable un and owners

ing points wh each samrash zone an4 trash sampof PMG, meic toxicity. T

ng the ToxicCLP) accordshed in the RAct (RCRA)

3: Experimen

stigation of an Ab

g Vol. 33, No. 04,

PPC w to

the MG) ned

y of dfill nce-gy.

ago, esi-een rom the

dfill mea-

res. par-ding ex-

ight

nits, s of

were mple nd a ples etal The city

ding Re-) of

theind

genSima pthesigbiois ingdu

corbiaMamapoof catconsolwhganmibecomZnanme20

schconwininthaof ±

1.2.3.4.5.6.

7.

8.

ntal setup for

bandoned Contam

, pp. 723 - 731,

e United Stadustrial wast

Abandoned neous distribmilarly, the gproblem in te surface whgnificant capological convrelated to th

g depositionustrial and do

Potential Mrding to the pan Technicalanagement. ate anaerobi

ounds in digethe biogas p

tions for sonsists of carlid residues hich have beenisms adapteicronutrients st conditionmpounds of

nCl2, CuCl2, d Na2SeO3,ethanogenic 10; Ortner eFigure 3 sh

hematic for nditions insiith nitrogen ng of digestat might havthe reactor m0.2. Methan

Silicone tubinControlled leaRubber plug, Glass capillar500 ml anaeroBeaker (500 mcylinder; 500 ml graduCO2 from theDisplaced Namethane gene

the anaerobi

minated Landfill i

October - Decem

ates and in thes. landfills are

bution of domgeneration ofhese sites an

hile the sub-pacity for genversion. Theheir environm

of metal-coomestic sourcMethane Genprinciples desl Standard NWater qualitic biodegradested sludge.production”, olid residue rrying out thin 500 ml

en previouslyed to these re

was used ins for anaerothis solution Na2MoO4, according

archaea mict al., 2014; P

hows the expone reactor

de the reactogas for 20 mtion, therebye been presemedium wasne productio

ng; ak silicone tub

ries; obic reactor (Sml) for receivi

ated cylinder e generated gaaOH solution (erated).

c reactor.

in Santiago, Chil

mber, 2016

he Chilean r

e characterizemestic and inf methane ornd can mani-surface trashnerating gas

e presence ofmental persiontaining waces. neration was scribed in theNTC4233 “Ety. Evaluatiodability of . Method by with some

evaluation.he anaerobicbatch react

y inoculatedesidues. A son this study obic digestio

n were MnCl2CoCl2.6H2Oto the req

croorganismsPereda et al.,perimental prr. To achievor, the systemminutes befoy eliminatingent in the reas adjusted wion during d

bing;

Schott glass bing any NaOH

containing Naas; (equal to the v

e 7

regulations f

ed by a heterndustrial wastr landfill gas fest weakly h can retainvia anaerob

f heavy metastence followastes from i

evaluated ae 2009 ColumEnvironmenton of the ultorganic com

y measurememinor modif The methoc digestion tors at 35° C with microo

olution of trato ensure th

on. The ma2.4H2O, H3B

O, NiCl2.6H2uirements f

s (Milán et a 2006). rocedure setuve the anoxm was flusheore the begig any oxygeactors. The pith NaOH todigestion w

bottle); H leaving the

aOH to scrub

volume of

725

for

ro-te. is at

n a bic als w-in-

ac-m-tal ti-m-ent fi-od of C, or-ce he

ain O,

2O for al.,

up xic ed in-en

pH o 7

was

Page 4: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

72

mNmextegrethv(Pth

mEmgOb1c,th

Fst

P

sutaula1Tinantr

26

measured by NaOH duringmeasured mexpected theoermined thatenerated woeactor wouldherefore be eolume of 17PMG) resultheoretical va

The CH4 amined using Elmer GC Cmetal concenarbage samp

Optima 3000ased on offi992; US-EPA, 2007). Figuhe experimen

Figure 4: Vitatically cont

Potential MPMG(%) = (V

RE

Figures 5 ults tables foable includesse for the unayer accordin-Unconsolid

Trash, Layer nclude the pHnd range of ration range

displacemeng 35 days oethane volumoretical volumt the amountuld be 170 Ld work withexpected to g7 L. The Pott was expresalue. and H2S leve

a Gas ChroClarus 500/5ntrations in ples was perfo0 ICP accordcial methods

PA-a, 2007; Uure 4 shows ntal anaerobi

iew of anaertrolled bath (

Methane GeVg(L)·100)/1

ESULTS AND

to 9 containor the operabs a short descnit and the thng to the fo

dated solid sr 3-Deep soH range in eH2S in Layein each laye

nt of a saturaof anaerobic me was comme. In this ct of landfill-L per kg of wh 100 g of wgenerate a mtential Methssed as a per

els in the bioomatograph,

580. The deboth the so

formed using ding to stans of the US-US-EPA-b, 2the physicalic digesters

robic reactor(35 ºC).

eneration wa17 L.

D DISCUSS

n the locationble units in tcription of thhickness of

ollowing dessurface mate

oil. Other taach layer, raer 2, and theer. The resul

I. C

Brazilian Jou

ated solutiondigestion. T

mpared with case, it was -waste methawaste. Since waste, it wo

maximum bioane Generatrcentage of

gas were det, model Peretermination il samples aa Perkin Elm

ndard protoc-EPA (US-EP2007; US-EP installation

rs in a therm

as calculated

SION

n maps and the study. Eahe current laneach excava

scription: Laerial, Layer

abulated resuange of PMGe metal conclts observed

Cortés and S. Mo

urnal of Chemica

n of The the de-ane the

ould gas tion the

ter-rkin

of and mer cols PA, PA-for

mo-

d as

re-ach

and-ated ayer

2-ults

G % cen-

for

Opble(Fisul

pitnesecloc

recgarme11beoilexppe

cotrabuthaconin in Papacourectheanthe

meingfrahythetioothconcarbiothehybioThfillwhThmucen20

ontalvo

al Engineering

perable Unit e Unit Resigure 9) are lts shown forGarbage w

ts, with diffesses rangingctor. No garcated outside

In 8 of the 2corded were rbage had easured PM.3%. The mlonged to a sly black appplained by cted for this In general,

mpared to anash has achieut still maintane under apnsistent with2004, and athe study b

arcel 5, showcity to decomunt that therceived wasteere is not expaerobic degre site.

At the end ethane and hg biogas waaction variedydrogen sulfie detection lion in sanitaryher studies. ncentration orbon monoxogas was veeir study. Jaf

ydrogen sulfiogas was vhemelis and Ul biogas has hile Nikiemahe low propounicipal solintrations (Z15).

Parcels 3 anidential Witnot shown,

r the other unas found in

fering levels g between 4rbage was foe of the landf24 samples azero, indicatcompletely

MG values wmaximum PMsample with earance of inthe extendetype of garb

all observen active landeved an advatains a low ppropriate coh previous stuare relativelyy Kristman

wing that thmpose. It is e is ample ev

es more than pected to be radation rate

of each samhydrogen sulas determined between 5de volume frimit of 0.02%y landfill bioDesideri et of hydrogen

xide (0–500 ery small anffrin et al. (

fide concentrery low at Ulloa (2007)an H2S volu

a et al. (2007ortion of suld waste exphou et al.,

nd 4 (Figure ithin Aband

but are simnits.

n 24 of the of degradat

40 and 370 cound at the fill boundaryanalysed, the

ating that in tstabilized.

were betweMG value fthe characterndustrial gared stabilizat

bage. ed PMG va

dfill. This indanced state ocapacity to

onditions. Thtudies conducy similar to t

(2009) in thhe garbage h

important toevidence that

35 years agoany further i

e of the garb

mple digestiolfide contented. The me50% and 55fraction was %. The low Hogas has beeal. (2003) f

n sulfide (0–ppm) in sa

nd therefore (2003) also fration in saonly 100 p

) stated that ume fraction7) found a levlfur compounplains these

2014; Hla

7), and Operoned Landf

milar to the r

30 perforatetion, in thiccm across thsample poin

y. e biogas levethese areas thThe non-zeen 1.6% anfound (11.3%ristic odor anrbage and wtion time e

alues are lodicates that thof degradatio

generate mhese results acted at the sithose reportehe area callehad a low co take into at La Cañameo and, as sucincrease in thbage stored

on process, tht of the resuethane volum5% while thgenerally ne

H2S concentren reported found that th200 ppm) an

anitary landfnegligible ffound that th

anitary landfppm (0.01%sanitary lan

n less than 1%vel of 0–0.2%nds present low H2S coand Robert

ra-fill re-

ed ck-he nts

els he

ero nd %) nd

was ex-

ow he

on, me-are ite ed ed

ca-ac-era ch, he in

he lt-

me he

ear ra-in he nd fill for he fill

%). nd-%, %. in

on-ts,

Page 5: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

NeswuTco

Evalu

For all theNi, V, Se, As,st concentra

when comparnconsolidate

This is becauontain metal

uation of Potentia

Brazilian

e metals teste, Ba, B, Co,

ations were fred to the ced solid suruse domestic llic compone

F

al Methane Gener

Journal of Chem

ed (Cd, Zn, Mo, Mn, Fefound in theconcentrationface and deand industri

ents.

Figure 5: L

Figure 6: Lo

ration in the Inves

mical Engineering

Cr, Cu, Pb, , Hg), the hi

e garbage layns found in eep soil layeial wastes of

Location and

ocation and r

stigation of an Ab

g Vol. 33, No. 04,

Al, igh-yer, the ers. ften

layThceeeanbyin

d Results for

results for Op

bandoned Contam

, pp. 723 - 731,

The garbagyer of filler he concentrated either then soils or th

y the United Sits Superfund

Ta

Thickn(cm)pH

PMG (%H2S (%

Cd mg/Zn mg/Cr mg/As mg/Cu mg/Pb mg/Al mg/Se mg/Ni mg/V mg/

Ba mg/Co mg/Mo mg/

B mg/Fe mg/

Mn mg/Hg mg/

Operable Un

Table

Thickn(cm)pH

PMG (%H2S (%

Cd mg/Zn mg/Cr mg/As mg/Cu mg/Pb mg/Al mg/Se mg/Ni mg/V mg/

Ba mg/Co mg/Mo mg/

B mg/Fe mg/

Mn mg/Hg mg/

perable Unit

minated Landfill i

October - Decem

e layer in thsoil approx

tions of heave natural mete human heaStates Envirod Site Remed

able 1: Range of VaLayer 1

ness ) 40–70

6.57–7.53%) - %) - /kg <0.06–0.8/kg 18.1–148/kg 13.4–28/kg <2.39–22/kg 44.4–128/kg 10.9–28/kg 3159–1607/kg <1/kg <0.38–18/kg 198.9–18/kg 10–50/kg 11.8–29/kg <0.31–1.3/kg <0.46–99/kg 9288–5752/kg 232–87/kg 0.04–59

nit Parcel 5.

e 2: Range of valueLayer 1

ness )

9–10

7.65–7.99%) - %) - /kg 1.38–2.5/kg 551–71/kg 122–23/kg 5.31–19/kg 359–241/kg 301–80/kg 4610–950/kg 7.81–18/kg 25.9–43/kg 83.9–116/kg 20.3–57/kg 15.7–25/kg 9.71–16/kg 100–29/kg 25693–4656/kg 487–64/kg 0.60–2.8

Current Park

in Santiago, Chil

mber, 2016

he site was cximately onevy metals foutal concentraalth risk stanonmental Agediation progr

alues for Operable1 Layer 2

0 40–280

3 6.65–7.980–6.<0.0

85 <0.06–2.68.2 341–1158.3 10.9–420.2.8 <2.39–23.8,1 242–1088.8 102–14776 4924–1856

1.8 <1.8.0 <0.38–29.82 74.4–138.0.1 24.9–249.9 11.8–24.32 1.29–9.99.4 <0.46–144.23 8025–766271 339–99

9.7 0.41–12.

es for Operable Un1 Layer 2

0 120–190

9 7.48–7.730–5.<0.0

51 0.78–1.913 587–8336 43–46

9.9 5.06–9.811 99–23107 30.4–10801 5536–736

8.2 6.87–16.3.0 13.6–63.6.2 62.6–102.7.5 43.6–48.5.3 11.6–22.6.5 2.64–4.197 114–2469 30547–404740 567–62288 0.65–65.

k.

e 7

covered withe meter thicund did not eations in Chndards defineency (USEPA

ram.

e Unit Parcel 5 Layer 3

0 40–210

6.85–7.230 - 2 - 3 <0.06–0.646 29.6–5156 11.2–2533 <2.39–12.65 49.5–3928 15.2–243.42 4729–117648 <1.80 <0.38–21.38 95.1–198.29 26.6–59.25 12.9–30.74 <0.31–3.358 1.98–180.49 1655–414670 307–8447 0.05–1.07

nit Current Park Layer 3

0 80– 20

7.69–7.948 - 2 - 3 <0.06–1.248 87.7–2808 25.5–79.43 <2.39–5.292 66.4–2212 <0.27–1047 3610–796636 4.56–14.92 10.0–17.13 92.6–120.47 15.4–292.54 14.8–19.21 <0.31–1.631 75.5–150.47 20766–406027 413–865,84 0.12–32.0

727

h a ck. ex-il-ed A)

4 5

6 2 4 4 8

2 2 7 5 4 7 4 7

4 0 4 9

4

9

4 5 2

4 2 8 0

Page 6: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

72

5 wchmlaola

28

At presentand Actual P

while maintaihimneys ins

methane gas ayer. The lather sectors ater dates du

t, the operabPark have beining the co

stalled for mthat may b

and-use chaof the site,

ue to differin

Fig

ble units ideneen transformontained garb

monitoring thbe released ange manageis planned f

ng legal and

Figure 7

gure 8: Loca

I. C

Brazilian Jou

ntified as Parmed into a pabage, and ha

he emissionsfrom the trement, for for executiond environmen

7: Location o

ation and resu

Cortés and S. Mo

urnal of Chemica

rcel ark, ave

s of rash the

n at ntal

act

wistufortheogthe

of Operable

ults for Oper

ontalvo

al Engineering

tion requiremThe results

ith the generudy of contar Europe, 20e Potential M

gy should be e assessment

Unit Parcels

Table 3

Thickn(cm)pH

PMG (%H2S (%

Cd mg/Zn mg/Cr mg/As mg/Cu mg/Pb mg/Al mg/Se mg/Ni mg/V mg/

Ba mg/Co mg/Mo mg/

B mg/Fe mg/

Mn mg/Hg mg/

rable Unit Pr

ments. obtained in

ral principleaminated site000). TherefoMethane Genadded to the t of contamin

3 and 4.

3: Range of values Layer 1

ness ) 70–170

7.03–7.54%) - %) - /kg <0.06–0.4/kg 72.9–130/kg 21.9–32/kg <2.39–8/kg 52.3–95/kg 15.4–44/kg 7211–793/kg <1/kg <0.38–17/kg 124–13/kg 27.9–52/kg 16.4–20/kg 0.51–2.9/kg 87.6–17/kg 21199–2978/kg 265–42/kg 0.06–0.1

roperty Reser

n this study es discussed es (WHO Reore, this testineration (PMe standard menated soils in

for Operable Unit1 Layer 2

0 120–230

4 6.36–6.92.3–11.

<0.045 <0.06–9.0

0.4 264–1312.6 101,7–853.8.0 <2.39–15.5.7 199.6–1319.4.4 178.5–360.30 4961–2708

1.8 <1.7.0 <0.38–21.31 68.7–108.

2.4 46.1–166.0.1 9.5–16.92 3.9– 5.76 20–14

89 32322–413528 520–6818 0.65–1.1

rve.

are consisteby the WH

egional Offiing shows th

MG) methodoethodology fn Chile.

t Property ReserveLayer 3

0 80–130

6 6.85–8.163 - 2 - 2 <0.063 49.5–1093 19,1–34.84 <2.39–7.05 56.9–60.87 5.69–35.85 6376–117888 <1,85 <0.383 121–146.22 35–451 15.1–18.44 <0.31–1.631 25.6–146.80 19998–394905 303–4016 0.12–0.68

ent HO

ce hat ol-for

e

6 9 8 0 8 8 8 8 8 2 5 4

8

8

Page 7: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

P2vwacmap

telaanso

tilaimfocomb

A

Evalu

Study devPMG values

4 garbage saalues are lo

which indicatchieved an a

maintains a loppropriate co

Concentraerial layer thayer do not rnd do not eoils.

The usefulion (PMG) tandfill sites mportant conor evaluationompletion of

ment plan forle units studi

Aguilar-Virgezález, P. anconstants

uation of Potentia

Brazilian

Figure 9

CONCL

velopment anbetween 1.6amples takenow comparetes that the advanced staow capacity onditions.

ations of heavhat covers threpresent immexceed the n

lness of the test for riskhas been d

ntribution ton and managf this study, r the site tranied into a par

REFER

en, Q., Ojedand Quinterok and Lo of

al Methane Gener

Journal of Chem

9: Location o

LUSIONS

nd analyses 6% and 11.3n at the landed with an trash stored ate of degradto generate

vy metals in e trash and iminent risk tnormal level

Potential Mk assessmentdemonstratedo the Chileagement of SA

the environmnsformed twrk.

RENCES

a-Benítez, S.-Núñez, M.,f biogas gen

ration in the Inves

mical Engineering

of Operable

have identif% in 16 of dfill site. Thactive landfin the site h

dation, but smethane un

the surface min the deep sto human heals of metals

Methane Genet of abandond, which isn methodolo

APPC. After mental mana

wo of the ope

, Taboada-G Estimating neration rate

stigation of an Ab

g Vol. 33, No. 04,

Unit Residen

fied the

hese fill, has still

nder

ma-soil alth s in

era-ned an

ogy the

age-era-

Gon-the

e in

Ag

An

An

As

Ba

Ch

bandoned Contam

, pp. 723 - 731,

ntial Within

final disposContam. Am

guilar-VirgenOjeda-Beníbiogas gene45 (2011). (

ngelidaki, I.,coni, L., Cayuzhnui, S.dation, ActiMeeting 9 lished by: ITechnical UBuilding 11

ngelidaki, I. anaerobic Rev. Enviro

slibekian, Oassessment mines abanland. Enviro(2003).

adilla-OhlbauH., CéspedLagos, G.content andin central C2749-2757

hilean GoveMethodolog

minated Landfill i

October - Decem

Abandoned

al sites in Bamb., 28(1), 4n, Q., Taboatez, S., Mexeration. Inge(In Spanish)., Alves, M.,ampos, L., Gand van Lie

vity and Inhito 10 Octob

Institute of EUniversity of

5 DK-2800 and Sander

biodegradabon. Sci. Biote. and Molesof metals co

ndoned mineon. Geochem

um, R., Gines, A., GonzE., Relation

d copper contChile. Environ

(2001). ernment, Mgical guide

in Santiago, Chil

mber, 2016

Landfill.

aja California43-49 (2012)ada-Gonzále

xican model eniería (Méx. , Bolzonella

Guwy, A., Jeer, J., Anaeroibition (ABAber 2006, inEnvironmentf Denmark BKgs. Lyngby

rs, W., Assebility of maechnol., 3, 11s, R., Environtaminated e site, Co T

m. and Health

nocchio, R., zález, S., Allnship betweetent of selectn. Toxicol. C

Ministry of for the ma

e 7

a, México. In. (In Spanishez, P. A. anfor estimatin

xico), 15-13

a, D., Borzanícek, P., Kaobic Biodegr

AI) Task Groun Prague. Put & Resourcygningstorvey (2006). ssment of thacropollutant7-129 (2004)

ronmental risoils at SilveTipperary, Irh, 25, 247-26

Rodríguez,len, H. E. anen soil coppted crop planChem., 20(12

Environmenanagement

729

nt. h). nd ng 7-

ac-al-ra-up

ub-ces et,

he ts. ). sk er-re-66

P. nd

per nts 2),

nt, of

Page 8: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

730 I. Cortés and S. Montalvo

Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering

soils with potential contaminants (2012). (In Spanish).

Colombian Technical Standard NTC4233, Environ-mental Management. Water quality. Evaluation of the ‘ultimate’ anaerobic biodegradability of or-ganic compounds in sludge digestion. Method by measurement of biogas production. (2009). (In Spanish).

Desideri, U., Di María, F., Leonardi, D., Proietti, S., Sanitary landfill energetic potential analysis: A real case study. Energy Conversion and Manage-ment, 44, 1969-1981 (2003).

El-Mashad, H. M., Zhang, R. and Greene, J. P., An-aerobic biodegradability of selected biodegrada-ble plastics and biobased products. J. Environ. Sci. and Eng., A, 1, 108-114 (2012).

Escudey, M., Förster, J. E., Becerra, J. P., Quinteros, M., Torres, J., Arancibia, N., Galindo, G. and Chang, A. C., Disposal of domestic sludge and sludge ash on volcanic soils. J. of Haz. Mat., 139(3), 550-555 (2007).

Gartiser, S., Urich, E., Alexy, R. and Kummerer, K., Anaerobic inhibition and biodegradation of anti-biotics in ISO test schemes. Chemosphere, 66, 1839-1848 (2007).

Ginocchio, R., Carvallo, G., Toro, I., Bustamante, E., Silva, Y. and Sepúlveda, N., Micro-spatial varia-tion of soil metal pollution and plant recruitment near a copper smelter in Central Chile. Environ. Pollut., 127 (3), 343-352 (2004).

Hla, S. S., Roberts, D., Characterisation of chemical composition and energy content of green waste and municipal solid waste from Greater Brisbane, Australia. Waste Management, 41, 12-19 (2015).

ISO 11734:1995, Water quality – Evaluation of the "ultimate" anaerobic biodegradability of organic compounds in digested sludge – Method by measurement of the biogas production. (2012).

Jaffrin, A., Bentounes, N., Joan, A. M., Makhlouf, S., Landfill biogas for heating greenhouses and providing carbon dioxide supplement for plant growth. Biosystems Engineering, 86, 113-123 (2003).

Khan, S., Cao, Q., Zheng, Y. M., Huang, Y. Z. and Zhu, Y. G., Health risks of heavy metals in con-taminated soils and food crops irrigated with wastewater in Beijing, China. Environ. Pollut., 152, 686-692 (2008).

Kolstad, J. J., Vink, E. T. H., De Wilde, B. and De-beer, L., Assessment of anaerobic degradation of IngeoTM polylactides under accelerated landfill conditions. Polymer Degradation and Stability, 97, 1131-1141 (2012).

Kristmann Consultores, Study on the current situa-tion of former landfill La Cañamera. La Ca-ñamera Park Design Project, Comuna de Puente Alto, Santiago de Chile. (2009).

Kumar, S., Mondal, A. N., Gaikwad S. A., Devotta S. and Singh R. N., Qualitative assessment of me-thane emission inventory from municipal solid waste disposal sites: A case study. Atmos. Envi-ron., 38, 4921-4929 (2004).

Milán, Z., Montalvo, S., Ruiz-Tagle, N., Urrutia, H., Chamy, R., Sánchez, E. and Borja, R., Influence of heavy metal supplementation on specific meth-anogenic activity and microbial communities de-tected in batch anaerobic digesters. J. Environ. Sci. and Health, Part A, 45(11), 1307-1314 (2010).

Molina, M., Aburto, F., Calderón, R., Cazanga, M. and Escudey, M., Trace element composition of selected fertilizers used in Chile: Phosphorus fer-tilizers as a source of long-term soil contamina-tion. Soil and Sediment Contamination Journal, 18(4), 104-112 (2009).

Muhlbachova, G., Sagova-Mareckova, M., Omelka, M., Szakova, J. and Tlustos, P., The influence of soil organic carbon on interactions between mi-crobial parameters and metal concentrations at a long-term contaminated site. Sci. Total Environ., 502, 218-223 (2015).

Nikiema, J., Brzezinski, R., Heitz, M., Elimination of methane generated from landfills by biofil-tration: A review. Reviews in Environmental Sci-ence and Bio/Technology, 6, 261-284 (2007).

Ortner, M., Rachbauer, L., Somitsch, W. and Fuchs, W., Can bioavailability of trace nutrients be meas-ured in anaerobic digestion? Appl. Energy, 126(1), 190-198 (2014).

Palma-Fleming, H., Quiroz, E., Gutiérrez, E., Cristi, E., Jara, B., Keim, M. L., Pino, M., Huber, A., Jaramillo, E., Espinoza, O., Quijón, P., Contreras, H. and Ramírez, C., Chemical characterization of a municipal landfill and its influence on the sur-rounding estuarine system, South Central Chile. Bol. Soc. Chil. Quím., 45(4), 48-56 (2000).

Pereda, I., Irusta, R., Montalvo, S. and Del Valle, J. L., Solid mining residues from Ni extraction ap-plied as nutrient supplier to anaerobic process: Optimal dose approach through Taguchi's meth-odology. Water Sci. Technol., 54, 209-219 (2006).

Rodríguez, J. A., De Arana, C., Ramos-Miras, J. J., Gil, G. and Boluda, R., Impact of 70 years urban growth associated with heavy metal pollution. Environ. Pollut., 196, 156-163 (2015).

Romero, H., Ihl, M., Rivera, A., Zalazar, P. and Azocar, P., Rapid urban growth, land-use changes

Page 9: EVALUATION OF POTENTIAL METHANE GENERATION IN THE ... · Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, . ). . ),

Evaluation of Potential Methane Generation in the Investigation of an Abandoned Contaminated Landfill in Santiago, Chile 731

Brazilian Journal of Chemical Engineering Vol. 33, No. 04, pp. 723 - 731, October - December, 2016

and air pollution in Santiago, Chile. Atmos. Environ., 33(24-25), 4039-4047 (1999).

Stergar, V. and Zagorc Konèan, J., The determination of anaerobic biodegradability of pharmaceutical waste using advanced bioassay technique. Chem. Biochem. Eng. Q., 16 (1), 17-24 (2002).

Themelis, N. J., Ulloa, P. A., Methane generation in landfills. Renewable Energy, 32, 1243-1257 (2007).

US-EPA, (United States Environmental Protection Agency), Method 1311, Toxicity characteristic leaching procedure. (1992).

US-EPA-a, (United States Environmental Protection Agency), Method 7471B, Mercury in solid or semisolid wastes (manual cold-vapor technique). In: United States Environmental Protection Agency. Test methods for evaluating solid wastes. Physical/ Chemical Methods. SW-846 On-Line (2007).

US-EPA-b, (United States Environmental Protection Agency), Method 7473, Mercury in solids and so-lutions by thermal decomposition, amalgamation, and atomic absorption spectrophotometry. In: United States Environmental Protection Agency. Test methods for evaluating solid wastes. Physical/

Chemical Methods. SW-846 On-Line (2007). US-EPA-c, (United States Environmental Protection

Agency), Method 6010C, Inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry. In: United States Environmental Protection Agency. Test methods for evaluating solid wastes. Physical/ Chemical Methods. SW-846 On-Line (2007).

Wen, H., Zhang, Y., Cloquet, C., Zhu, C., Fan, H. and Luo, C., Tracing sources of pollution in soils from the Jinding Pb-Zn mining district in China using cadmium and lead isotopes. Appl. Geo-chem., 52, 147-154 (2015).

WHO, Regional Office for Europe, European Centre for Environment and Health, Methods for as-sessing health risks generated by exposure to haz-ardous substances released from sanitary land-fills. Report of a WHO Meeting, Lods, Polonia. April 10-12. EUT/00/5026441 (2000).

Zhou, H., Meng, A. H., Long, Y.Q., Li, O. H., Zhang, Y. G., An overview of characteristics of municipal solid waste fuel in China: Physical, chemical composition and heating value. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 36, 107-122 (2014).