Europaisches Patentamt

European Patent Office

Office europeen des brevets © Publication number: 0 5 5 8 8 4 7 A 1

© Application number: 92307750.7

@ Date of filing: 25.08.92

E U R O P E A N PATENT A P P L I C A T I O N

750.7 © int. Ci.5; C07C 37/14, C07C 3 9 / 0 6

© Priority: 05.03.92 US 846099 © Applicant: TEXACO CHEMICAL COMPANY 3040 Post Oak Boulevard

@ Date of publication of application: Houston, Texas 77056(US) 08.09.93 Bulletin 93/36

@ Inventor: Knifton, John Frederick © Designated Contracting States: 10900 Catskill Trail

DE FR GB Austin, Texas 78750(US) Inventor: Sheu, Yu-Hwa Edward 6210 Turtle Point Drive Austin, Texas 78746(US)

© Representative: Brock, Peter William et al URQUHART-DYKES & LORD 91 Wimpole Street London W1M 8AH (GB)

© Alkylphenol synthesis using acid-modified clay catalysts.

© Alkylphenols can be synthesized by reacting phenol with an olefin in the presence of a catalyst comprising a montmorillonite clay having the structure:

Mx/„n+ y H2 0(AI4-xMgx)(Si8 )O20 (OH)*

where M represents the interlamellar cation, and x, y and n are numbers, which has been rendered acidic by pretreatment with one or more acids selected from hydrogen fluoride, fluorosulphonic acids or anhydrides, and mineral acids. The reaction is carried out under adiabatic conditions at a temperature of 60 to 250 °C and a pressure of 0.1 to 3.55 MPa.

00 00 m

Rank Xerox (UK) Business Services (3. 10/3.6/3.3. 1)

EP 0 558 847 A1

This invention relates to a one-step method for the preparation of alkylphenols from a phenol and the corresponding olefin. More particularly it relates to a one-step method for preparation of alkyl phenols by reacting phenols and the corresponding olefins over certain acid-treated montmorillonite clays. The method is especially effective in the synthesis of the most desirable para-alkyl phenol, for example, para-

5 nonylphenol from phenol and nonene. It is known in the art to prepare higher molecular weight alkylphenols, such as p-tert-octylphenol, p-

nonylphenol and dodecylphenol, by alkylating phenol with diisobutylene, propylene trimer and propylene tetramer, respectively, under acidic conditions. Nonylphenol, in particular, is used as an intermediate for surfactants, as well as antioxidants and lubricating oil additives.

w "Bisphenol A and Alkylated Phenols", SRI PEP Report No. 192 (Dec. 1988)., page 4-4, indicates that it is known to prepare various alkyl phenols by acid catalyzed reactions of phenols with various olefins. The alkylphenols may include p-tert-butylphenol, p-isopropylphenol, p-sec-butylphenol, p-tert-octylphenol, nonyl- phenol and dodecylphenol. The alkylation reaction takes place at or near atmospheric pressure in the presence of an acidic catalyst, such as a mineral acid, a Lewis acid (e.g. boron trifluoride) or a cation

75 exchange resin (e.g. styrene-divinyl benzene resin). The acid catalysts lead to predominantly para-alkylated phenols when the para-position is available. Generally a molar ratio of phenol to olefin of 1.5:1 to 3:1 is desired, in order to minimize the yield of dialkylphenols.

US-A-41 98531 discloses a process for continuous manufacture of p-alkylphenols by reacting phenol with olefin at 70 to 140° C in a fixed bed of an organic sulphonic acid cation exchange resin.

20 A BF3 catalyst is used for the reaction of phenol and isobutene in GB-A-1 294781 , where the product is cooled to form crystals, which are crushed before ammonia is added to remove the catalyst.

US-A-3872179 discloses a two-step reaction of gaseous isobutene with liquid phenol in the presence of an acid-activated clay.

A boron trifluoride catalyst is used for the alkylation of phenol in US-A-3317612. 25 The use of clays as catalysts for selected applications is known in the art. The unusual properties of

smectite clays, which make them of interest as catalysts, are discussed in "Catalysis: Selective Develop- ments", Chem. Systems Report 84-3, 239-249, Section 3.4320. These compositions are layered and exhibit a 2:1 relationship between tetrahedral and octahedral sites. In addition the combination of cation exchange and intercalation, and the fact that the distance between the layers can be adjusted, provide interesting

30 possibilities. An article by F. Figueras, entitled "Pillared Clays as Catalysts", in Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng., 30, 457 (1988)

discusses methods of modifying clays and the effects of the modifications. At page 472, there is a discussion of the method of drying, i.e. air drying or freeze drying, which can effect the macroporosity of the resulting product and, as expected, the adsorption capacity. The author concludes that the thermal

35 stability of pillared clays can be improved to reach 800 °C using information available with respect to intercalation and drying methods.

Figueras notes (page 481) that the acid strength of montmorillonites was found to be higher than that of Y-zeolites and, in the case of the clays, Bronsted acidity appears to be weaker than Lewis acidity. The author describes three kinds of acid sites known to exist at the surface of clay, and suggests that the

40 coexistence of several types of acidity makes the localization of acid sites more difficult than in well- crystallized structures.

There is a review of the catalytic activity of pillared clays by T. Matsuda and E. Kikuchi, entitled "Acidic Properties of Pillared Clays in Relation to Their Catalytic Behaviour", in Proceedings of International Symposium on Acid-Base Catalysis, Sapporo, Nov. 28-Dec. 1, 1988. In Ch. 3.11 these authors observed

45 that Bronsted acid sites are responsible for isomerization, whereas both Bronsted and Lewis acid sites can catalyze disproportionation. Other pertinent findings were that Bronsted sites are far more active than Lewis sites, but studies would indicate an irreversible change of Bronsted acidity to Lewis acidity in the course of high temperature calcination, (page 354). The authors concluded that cracking of a compound such as cumene, depended only on the acidic properties, but disproportion activity was affected by the pore

50 structure in addition to acidity. This was thought to relate to the fact that pillared montmorillonite had regular micropores, while pillared saponite had macropores. In addition saponite is tetrahedrally charged clay with Al cations substituting for Si cations. In montmorillonite, in contrast, Mg cations are octahedrally substituted for Al cations. At page 352, it is stated that cracking acidity is satisfactorily related to Bronsted activity, while it is difficult to find any relationship between the disproportionation activity and the acidic property.

55 There is a review of the use of pillared, cation-exchanged and acid-treated montmorillonite as catalysts for certain organic reactions by J.M. Adams et al., J. Inclusion Phenomena, 5, 663 (1987), Applied Clay Science, 2, 309 (1987). These clays display Bronsted and Lewis acid activities. It is noted that while some cationic species are stable in solution over a wide concentration and pH range, others are not, particularly

2

EP 0 558 847 A1

solutions containing aluminium. It is noted that it is difficult to ensure a reproducible Al3+ clay and moreover, since workers have used slightly different exchanging and washing procedures, a comparison between related experiments is hindered. Commercial acid-treatment is carried out using concentrated hydrochloric, sulphuric or phosphoric acids. The concentration of the acid and the time of the treatment is variable.

5 Sometimes the excess acid is removed by washing, whereas in other instances this is not the case. Therefore, there is a great variety in the type and activity of acid-treated clays.

Montmorillonites have been used as catalysts for the reaction of straight chain alk-1-enes to ethers, and for reactions of alkenes plus alcohols. In the latter, primary alcohols gave high yields, secondary less and tertiary alcohols only trace amounts. The Al+3 clays have efficiencies of one third to one half of Amberlyst®

io 15 in reactions of this type without solvent or using 1,4-dioxane. The acid-treated clay K-306 can be used to convert methanol and ammonia into methylamines. Acid-

treated clays have also been used to convert cumene hydroperoxide into phenol and acetone. Of the known processes for producing alkylphenols, two stages are generally required for cooling and

recycling, and many of the catalysts are not stable at high temperatures. In addition, it is often difficult to is obtain a high para- to ortho- ratio or, in the case of nonylphenol synthesis, to obtain more monononylphenol

than dinonylphenol. From the art, it would appear that conversions of about 80% are about the most which could be expected in any process to prepare alkylphenols.

It would be a distinct advance in the art if alkylphenols, such as nonylphenols, and particularly para- nonylphenols, could be prepared in one step with nonene conversion as high as 97%. It would be

20 particularly desirable if the catalyst exhibited high thermal stability. Such a process would be especially attractive commercially if the system could be operated adiabatically, since close temperature control, cooling and recycling make many processes much more expensive.

It is an object of the present invention to provide a one-step process for the synthesis of alkylphenols in high yield and with almost complete conversion of olefin using a catalyst system which can operate under

25 adiabatic conditions and exhibits stability even at elevated temperatures. Another object is to obtain high selectivity while, at the same time, producing a high ratio of para- to ortho- alkylphenol.

This invention provides a method for the synthesis of alkylphenols by reacting phenol with an olefin in the presence of a catalyst, which is a montmorillonite clay having the structure:

so IVW+ y H2 0(AI4-xMgx)(Si8 )O20 (OH)+

where M represents the interlamellar cation, and x, y and n are numbers. The clay has been rendered acidic by pretreatment with one or more acids selected from hydrogen fluoride, fluorosulphonic acids or anhydrides, and mineral acids. The reaction is carried out under adiabatic conditions at a temperature from

35 60 to 250 ° C and a pressure of 0.1 to 3.55 MPa. The reaction provides high selectivities and yields. In the examples where the olefin is nonene, the

product is made up of a large ratio of the most desirable form of nonylphenol, para-nonylphenol, compared to ortho-nonylphenol.

The reaction can be represented by the following:

where n is 3 or more, preferably from 4 to 12. The olefins which are useful in the invention are those which are often available from petrochemical

operations. Examples include propylene, 1- and 2-butenes, isobutene, isopentene, isoheptene, 50 diisobutylene, mixed octenes, mixed nonenes, decenes and dodecenes, or mixtures thereof. In addition

higher straight chain olefins produced by ethylene oligomerization or by dehydrogenation or chlorination- dehydrochlorination of straight chain paraffins are also useful.

Preferred olefins are Cg-Ci2 olefins and particularly useful are mixed octenes and mixed nonenes, or mixtures thereof. The following Examples demonstrate the production of p-nonylphenol, which is the

55 prefered form of an important specialty chemical. Nonylphenol is in demand as an intermediate for surfactants, antioxidants and lubricating oil additives.

The molar ratio of the olefin to phenol can vary, but is generally in the range from 1:5 to 5:1. The prefered molar ration is about 1:1.

40

(Eq. 1 )

45

3

EP 0 558 847 A1

As stated the catalyst comprises an inorganic clay which is acid-activated and modified with an acid selected from hydrogen fluoride, fluorosulphonic acids and anhydrides, and mineral acids, e.g. sulphuric acid, plus combinations thereof. Suitable fluorosulphonic acids or anhydrides include fluorosulphonic acid itself, trifluoromethanesulphonic acid (triflic acid) and trifluoromethanesulphonic anhydride.

5 A general representation of the montmorillonite structure is:

Mk/„" + y H2 0(AI4-xMgx)(Si8 )O20 (OH)*

where M represents the interlamellar (balancing) cation, normally sodium or lithium, and x, y and n are io numbers.

These montmorillonite clays are used in the present application in an acidic form. Acids activate montmorillonites by attacking and solubilizing structural cations in the octahedral layers. This opens up the clay structure and increases surface area. These acid-treated clays act as strong Bronsted acids. Generally strong mineral acids are used to activate the clay, for example, sulphuric acid and phosphoric acid. As

is noted in the above mentioned Matsuda review article there is an indication that Bronsted sites are more active, but have a tendency to be converted into Lewis acid sites as temperature increases during calcination of pillared clays. The clays are effective in the form of granules, powders or extrudates.

The acid-treated montmorillonite clays used according to the present invention upon which the triflic acid or hydrofluoric acid are deposited should have acidities of at least 1.0 mg KOH/gm, and preferably 5 to

20 100 mg KOH/gm, titrated to a phenolphthalein end point. Their surface area should be at least 30 m2/g, and preferably 200 to 1000 m2/g. Their moisture content should be limited also, whereby upon heating at 105 °C, the weight loss is generally less than 20 wt%, but may be higher under certain circumstances.

Illustrative examples of suitable acidic montmorillonite clays include clays in granular form, such as Filtrol Grade 24, having a 20-60 mesh size (0.25-0.84 mm) and Grade 24 Superacid Clay. Filtrol Grade 24 is

25 manufactured by Engelhard and has an acid capacity of 25 mg KOH/g. Grade 24 Superacid Clay, also from Engelhard, has an acidity of 33 mg KOH/g.

Where the montmorillonite clay or acid-pretreated montmorillonite clay, as described above, is impreg- nated with triflic acid or hydrogen fluoride, the clay is generally treated with from 0.01 to 10% triflic acid or HF and preferably the clay is impregnated with from 0.1 to 1.0% triflic acid. The examples demonstrate that

30 0.1 to 1.0% is an effective amount. When one of the fluorine-containing acids is used for treatment of the clay, it is preferred to use a clay that has first been pre-treated with a mineral acid since better results are obtained. The mineral acid pre-treatment is not, however, necessary.

Where hydrogen fluoride is deposited on acidic montmorillonite, 0.1 to 1.0% is a preferred effective amount.

35 An effective amount of triflic acid or hydrogen fluoride would be sufficient to produce an acidity of the catalyst in the range of 1 to 100 mg KOH/g.

Preparation of alkylphenols is preferably conducted in a fixed bed, continuous flow reactor. The reaction is conducted under adiabatic conditions. The "hot spot" or maximum temperature of the

reactor is from 60 to 250 °C, preferably 80 to 140°C. The preferred temperature depends on the choice of 40 reactants. In the case of nonene and phenol an effective temperature is about 90 ° C. The pressure is from

0.1 to 3.55 MPa (atmospheric to 500 psi) and is preferably about 0.8 MPa (100 psi). Typically the alkylphenol is generated continuously in up to ca. 80+ wt% concentration in the crude

product liquid effluent. Olefin conversions are high. Nonenes conversion is almost quantitative, and can be as high as 97%.

45 Preferably the nonenes conversion is over 90% and the para-nonylphenol to ortho-nonylphenol weight ratio is over 5:1 .

These yields are achieved at a total liquid hourly space velocity (LHSV) of 1 to 10 under mild conditions.

Here LHSV is defined as follows: 50

W e i g h t of T o t a l L i q u i d Feed R u n LHSV = T h r o u g h t h e R e a c t o r P e r H o u r

Volume of C a t a l y s t in R e a c t o r 55

Conversion of define (wt%) is estimated in the following examples using the equation:

4

EP 0 558 847 A1

100 Wt% Cone , of O l e f i n in P r o d u c t x 100 Wt% Cone , of O l e f i n in F e e d

Yields of alkylphenol (mole%) are estimated from:

100 M o l e s of A l k y l p h e n o l in P r o d u c t L i q u i d 10 M o l e s of O l e f i n in F e e d

The accompanying Examples illustrate: 1. In Example 1, using the 0.5% HF-treated clay catalyst, run adiabatically

75 a) 97% nonenes conversion per pass at 100°C, LHSV 1, b) p-nonylphenol to o-nonylphenol ratio of 13.5:1 at 80 °C, with a nonylphenol to dinonylphenol ratio of 9:1 at 80 °C, and c) 79% nonenes conversion per pass at 100°C, LHSV 3.

2. In Examples 2 to 5, other acid-treated clays likewise give good performances. For example, in the 20 case of the 0.1% triflic clay catalyst (Example 3) and the sulphuric acid-treated clays (Examples 2, 4 and

5), the calculated nonene conversions, nonylphenol total concentration and para-to-ortho nonylphenol ratios, as well as the nonylphenol to dinonylphenol ratios, are summarized in Table 6. In all these cases these acid-treated clays give:

a) High nonene conversion per pass; 25 b) High total nonylphenol concentrations in the crude product effluent;

c) High p-nonylphenol to o-nonylphenol ratios; d) High total nonylphenol to dinonylphenol ratios; and e) Good performance at higher LHSV

Product analyses were primarily by gas liquid chromatography (gle) and liquid chromatography (Ic). 30

EXAMPLE 1

This Example illustrates the selective production of para-nonylphenol from phenol and mixed nonenes using a hydrofluoric acid-treated montmorillonite clay catalyst.

35 Synthesis was conducted in a 500 cm3 capacity, tubular reactor constructed of stainless steel, operated upflow and fitted with temperature, pressure and flow rate regulating devices.

The reactor was charged at the beginning of the experiments with 400 cm3 of 0.5% hydrogen fluoride on Engelhard Grade 24 clay in the granular form, that had perviously been treated with sulphuric acid, having an acid capacity of 25 mg KOH/g and a water content of 18.4%. A screen of glass wool was placed

40 at the top and bottom of the reactor to ensure the catalysts would remain in the middle portion. The catalyst bed was treated with a phenol/nonene mixture (1:1 weight ratio, 1.34:1 molar ratio) upflow,

at a rate of 400 cm3/h, while the first section of the catalyst bed was held at 80 °C. The reactor was run adiabatically and the hot spot temperature along the catalyst bed was at least 100°C; total pressure was 0.8 MPa (100 psi). Samples of crude product effluent were collected after the unit has reached steady-state

45 conditions and analyzed by gle and Ic. Typical analysis data are given in Table 1 . The experiment was repeated at a series of set-point temperatures (100°, 120°C) and flow rates (800,

1200 cm3/h) under adiabatic conditions. These run and results data are also given in Table 1.

5

EP 0 558 847 A1

10

15

20

25

co u X

30

35

40

45

50

a. o 2 E * w,2

O I P in . O Q. s o o

O «

U. EC

a. E

" S o 5 o « O 5 a.

K <g O O)

co <n *<r oj r- 5 S £ 3 8

f*3 <v V *p tt? <6 cj <b <6

OO CJ CO V3 in <6 o> v> in

O) r» «- o p k ,-' <d

0> eo o) cj in

co *n eg r- £ £ £ £ S

u- II z O- II

s O) fv f*. oi co <o o

t- Oi o a. i Z 6

8 c3 8 8 Q- 1 z o

« o o

5

"b o c •H a) 4-1

•o a)

•H

B U

E-i

55 EXAMPLES 2-5

These examples illustrate the selective production of para-nonylphenol from phenol and mixed nonenes using a variety of other acid-treated montmorillonite clay catalysts.

6

EP 0 558 847 A1

Following the procedures of Example 1, a series of acid-treated montmorillonite clays were used as catalysts with phenol/nonene feed (1.34:1 molar ratio) under adiabatic operating conditions, at a series of operating temperatures (80-1 20 °C) and feed rates (400-1200 cm3/h). The catalysts tested comprised:

5 Example

2 A Sulphuric acid-treated clay having an acidity of 33 mg KOH/g. 3 A triflic acid-(TF)-treated clay having an acidity of 11 mg KOH/g and a water content of 17.2%. 4 Another sulphuric acid-treated clay having an acidity of 93 mg KOH/g.

io 5 A further sample of sulphuric acid-treated clay having an acidity of 5 mg KOH/g and a water content of <1%. The clay was Engelhard Grade 24. Run data and results are summarized in Tables 2 to 5.

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

55

7

1 6 ~ ~ - - N 1 O *l 2 £ in <o « * - . « • ? 2 g <o <o S ^ O ^ H CO o o. o>o «? | g k- «J 5! - ° o o t- O q_ O) ro -<r CO . 3 00 Cj If) *T CO q <S f- <o <i> SS 0 « cr o> a

X . . c O ' « - C D r - ~ K Q o i o i r - ' o i o i c i c o . C ' < r . . * r . . < \ i

CO CO O CO tO "«T

z N CO "J -1 c co 2 "S. v « < Z C c O ' - O ' C O ' O ' ^ l "

si 2 Z 15 8 8 8 § § £ a: * *» <* to «

1 e § 8 8 8 8 3* . . . .

^% o „ l o ! <"? O £ 0C *" a.

<a O S- s 2 S £ o , o

o * CO o>

3

8

SP. 0. CM O) O) co p ^ 2 (D W) CD CO CO O

O f Q- <\i n- <q »q cq Q. Z eb 1 CO CO CO Z Q o o " O n . N '-. T " — ) o) o o K co q z <o t-- t- <o <o 0 2 cc t» 0.

X U3 CO O Ol CO O O oS CO CO C7> p x cm 0.

CO (J) , o co o> to

z y _l • 3 z E <* - " n " "

x co a. -j >- ~ z o 2 15 8 8 8 8 8

1 e § 8 8 8 8 o • . . . . o

X o « A- O s tr ^ 0-

CO

« £ x O £ O i- * en *- E

2-

9

1 * v iri oi iri o> a

«< ? Q_ r- CO CM CO O) ' 2 O . CD O CNi

O 1 E „v CO 1 O CL co eg co co 0. 2 cb co Z K r-' 5 0 O O — 1- O n co O CO O 10 3 = O) 0 10 c\i q in co co co O « tr o> 0.

X . «<J- CO CO o> *- 0 Q CO CO oi p oi .c 55 cm cm cnJ CO °- 55 LU X 2 . O) CO O) CM lO O >- fr 2 ° CM CO CO K

5< g X • a q. v C r- CM CO *T IO 0 z

15 8 8 8 8 8

e S 8 8 8 8 t-

>. CO 0 *: n >. £ 1 £

8 S f" f

CO o>

10

■ 1 a? q. k o w **** Z V ci co eg O t O Q. o co 10 cd g CO CO co to O o »- O q. co <o k m -r- 3 2" tQ CO CO CO q to <o to in 0 « cr o a

eg o to m Q Q in to to £ co eg eg eg in Q.

CO co to ,_ -<r o UJ • O <X <N CO i- Z

m 9 o. - < z | !* ' N n ' "

>- z 2

15 § | 8 § §

1 i" § 8 8 8 8 3* . . . .

X o « « O s oc - 0.

CO O 5. • S o O) o - 5

0 2 CO <* o> 1 E CO £■

11

EP 0 558 847 A1

10

z a a.

.i 0- z o.

15 a. , z l

20

25

CO

< D CO UJ CO 5 . < z < t- o =3 Q O cr o.

z o

30 o " CL E

35

0 o *- 01 <b 6 CM CM CO CD S 0 0)0 cb to CO

m r-; co to oi T ° co to oj oj eg in co oi to « S T- (O N CO O O CO V <b t

(o 5 S IS iS § § 2 $ 2 2 ? S 2

S < s

8 8 8 § 8 8 § 8 8 § 8 8 § 8 8

.coin . CO to .com

40

45

50

O o co

i— 4« o CO O

55 Claims

1. A method for the synthesis of alkylphenols by reacting phenol with an olefin in the presence of a catalyst, characterised in that the catalyst is a montmorillonite clay having the structure:

12

EP 0 558 847 A1

Mx/„n+ y H2 0(AI4-xMgx)(Si8 )O20 (0H)+

where M represents the interlamellar cation, and x, y and n are numbers which has been rendered acidic by pretreatment with one or more acids selected from hydrogen fluoride, fluorosulphonic acids or anhydrides, and mineral acids, and in that the reaction is carried out under adiabatic conditions at a temperature of from 60 ° C to 250 ° C and a pressure of 0.1 to 3.55 MPa.

A method according to Claim 1 characterised in that the olefin comprises mixed octenes, mixed nonenes, mixed dodecenes or a mixture thereof.

A method according to Claim 1 characterised in that the olefin comprises mixed nonenes.

A method according to any one of Claims 1 to 3 characterised in that the montmorillonite clay has been treated with sulphuric acid and has an acidity of 1.0 to 100 mg KOH/gm.

A method according to Claim 4 characterised in that 0.1% to 10% wt% of hydrogen fluoride is deposited on the sulphuric acid-treated montmorillonite clay.

A method according to any one of Claims 1 to 3 characterised in that the fluorosulphonic acid is fluorosulphonic acid or trifluoromethanesulphonic acid.

A method according to Claim 6 characterised in that 0.1 to 10% by weight of trifluoromethanesulphonic acid is deposited on the montmorillonite clay.

A method according to Claim 7 characterised in that the acidity of the acid-treated clay is from 2 to 15 mg KOH/g.

A method according to any one of Claims 1 to 3 characterised in that the fluorosulphonic anhydride is trifluoromethanesulphonic anhydride.

A method according to any one of Claims 1 to 9 characterised in that the maximum operating temperature is 80 to 140°C.

13

P 92 30 7750

)OCUMENTS CONSIDERED TO BE RELEVANT

lategory Ration of document with indication, where appropriate, of relevant passages » daim PPUCATION gut. CL5 )

S-A-3 211 670 (H KAPLAN ET AL) column 1, line 15 - column 2, line 27;

xamples *

S-A-4 055 605 (C L JARREAU) column 1, line 48 - line 66; claims *

B-A-877 356 (ESS0 RESEARCH AND NGINEERING)

claims; examples *

E-B-l 252 692 (UNIVERSAL OIL PRODUCTS) the whole document *

-10

-10

-10

07C39/06

IEARCHED (Int. CI. 5 )

The present search report has been drawn up tor au cuius Place of taarca

THE HAGUE 15 JUNE 1993 HtTWUUU l . U .

category of ui tu uutumtrv 10 X : particularly relevant if taken alone Y : particularly relevant if combined with another

document of the same category A : technological background O : non-written disclosure P : intermediate document

1 : incory or pnnapiv lumnjiny «w E : earlier patent document, but published on, or

after the filing date D : document cited in the application L : document cited for other reasons * "member of the same patent family, corresponding

document