eng gtp2012 ar 06 improving student outcomes

Upload: james-tai-wai-jin

Post on 04-Jun-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    1/24

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six90

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    2/24

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six91

    ImprovingStudentOutcomes

    SECURING THENATIONS FUTURE

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    3/24

    Moreover, as Malaysia transforms into a high- income nation, there will be greater demand forskilled knowledge workers and we must do allthat we can to ensure that our children acquireproper foundational skills to be lifelong learners.To this end, the Ministry of Education haslaunched the Preliminary Report of the MalaysianEducation Blueprint (MEB), a 12-year programmethat provides exhaustive detail about how wewant to see the education system transformedby 2025.

    TAN SRI DATO HAJI MUHYIDDINHAJI MOHD YASSIN

    Deputy Prime Minister of Malaysia

    MINISTERS FOREWORD

    A quality education remainsone of the best guarantees ofsuccess later in life and theMalaysian Government iscommitted to transforming theMalaysian education systemto be among the best in theregion. Studies have shownthat a quality education earlyon in life leads to higher

    salaries, and enhances socio- economic mobility with ourambitions of Vision 2020to create a high-income nation.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six92

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    4/24

    Together, with the help of all Malaysians,we can ensure a brighter future for thegenerations to come.

    to our initiatives in GTP 2.0, which will build on

    the foundations established over the last threeyears while expanding our scope to include otherrelated areas.

    As the minister in charge of the EducationNKRA, I am personally convinced that we areheading in the right direction with the reformsthat we have introduced for this sector, and I ampersonally committed to see that we continuedown this path over the next three years. Together,with the help of all Malaysians, we can ensurea brighter future for the generations to come.

    The initiatives of GTP, a holistic programme

    of change that aims at targets with a three-foothorizon, will form the rst wave of change thatworks towards the overall goals of the MEB.The Education NKRA, should thus be seen asa working subset under the overarching rubricof the MEB, providing immediate and impactfulresults that can be felt by the rakyat.

    As for the results by the NKRA team, anyonewho has been following our achievements shouldbe excited by of shown so far now that the rsthorizon of the GTP has drawn to a close. Pre- school enrolment numbers are up, primary schoolstudents have been screened for basic literacyand numeracy skills, and schools have improved.These are but some of our accomplishments, andthey are signi cant by any account, especiallygiven the short turnaround time of three years.

    But we cant pat ourselves on the back justyet. There is still a long way to go before wecan justly say that our education system is onpar with the best in the world. We are therefore

    going forward with a number of enhancements

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six93

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    5/24

    Primary 94%

    Lower Secondary 87%

    Upper Secondary* 77%

    Sources: Perangkaan Pendidikan Malaysia, Quick Facts

    MALAYSIA HAS MADE GREAT PROGRESS IN PROVIDING

    ACCESS TO EDUCATION

    Enrolment rates at public primary and secondary schools

    * Upper secondary schools includevocational and technical schools

    ImprovingStudentOutcomesNKRA

    OVERVIEW

    CHAPTER

    6

    An educated Malaysian workforce is essential to attaining thedevelopment goals of Vision 2020, and all efforts in this area mustbegin from the ground up. The adult literacy rate in Malaysia is inthe 92nd percentile, 1 there is evidence to suggest that Malaysianyouths are slipping when compared with regional peers. 2

    1UNDP Human Development Index, Malaysia, 2008.

    2PISA 2009 result and TIMSS 2011 result.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six94

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    6/24

    The EDU NKRA is focused onimmediate goals in line with theoverall philosophy of the GTP.

    The EDU NKRA makes special e ort to beinclusive because access to quality educationis a right for every Malaysian regardless of race,income-levels or other background. It thus hasfocused on speci c education areas identi edin the GTP Lab as those that will have themost signi cant impact on as wide an audienceas possible.

    Over the last three years, the EDU NKRA

    has reported signi cant improvements inall areas, thereby laying the foundation forthe transformation of Malaysian educationin line with the Preliminary Report of theMalaysian Education Blueprint which waslaunched in September 2012. But while theBlueprint provides the overarching vision forthe education sector, the EDU NKRA is focusedon immediate goals in line with the overallphilosophy of the GTP.

    The work of the EDU NKRA is thereforea subset of the Blueprint that works towardssimilar goals.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six95

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    7/24

    GTP 1.0 ACHIEVEMENTS

    The work of GTP 1.0 in improving student outcomes was directed by fourkey imperatives identi ed in the GTP Labs session held in 2009: Ensuring every child succeeds

    Setting similar expectations for all students regardless of backgroundand providing targeted help for students who fall behind.

    Holding schools accountable for changes in student performance Empowering schools to take greater ownership of accountability for the

    performance of their students.

    Investing in great leaders for every school Investing in principals and head teachers as primary drivers of

    change via a rigorous selection process, and implementing a robustprofessional development programme.

    Attracting and developing top teachers Increasing the attractiveness of the profession to hire greater talent,

    as well as providing measures to ensure that teachers have the rightsupport to further hone their skills.

    These imperatives were translated into four key initiatives under GTP 1.0:

    Improving access to quality early childhood education. Screening for basic literacy (Bahasa Malaysia) and numeracy skills

    (the Literacy and Numeracy Screening Programme or LINUS). Implementing high-performing schools and school improvement

    programmes.Implementing new deals for principals and head teachers.

    These initiatives are designedto accomplish two goals: toimmediately arrest the declinein student outcomes and toestablish a foundation for futureimprovements within theeducation sector.

    In pursuing these initiatives,the EDU NKRA has put greaterfocus on the formative years of astudents life via the pre-schooland LINUS programmes, whichare tailored to establish learningfoundations. These programmesingrain skills required for lifelonglearning while implementingtargeted initiatives focused onimproving schools and schoolleadership to arrest the slide in

    student performance.The EDU NKRA has reported

    progressive success in eachof the three years of GTP 1.0,and the lessons learnt in theimplementation of the initiativeswill be invaluable for the next threeyears. Therefore, a strong threadof continuity links the NKRAsinitiatives in GTP 1.0 and GTP 2.0although initiatives willbe geared to emphasise qualityover the next three years.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six96

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    8/24

    A strong thread of continuity linksthe NKRAs initiatives in GTP 1.0and GTP 2.0 although initiativeswill be geared to emphasise

    quality over the next three years.

    2012 OVERVIEW

    The last 12 months have been challengingfor the EDU NKRA, which stretched its targetsowing to the signi cant success experienced

    in the previous years. Moreover, being the nalyear of GTP 1.0, the NKRA decided to appointan external reviewer to verify the results of theLINUS initiative, which showed a signi cantimprovement in student outcomes.

    As part of the EDU NKRAs commitment totransparency and accountability, the results ofthe reviewer were taken into consideration inthe implementation of the LINUS programmein 2012. The subsequent results of the LINUSspecial screening showed a drop in performancefrom reported numbers, but still above theachievement threshold of 90%.

    The EDU NKRA has taken additional steps to ensurethat the impact of its initiatives are in accordance withthe GTPs demand for transparency and accountability.

    For instance, the EDU NKRA commissioned an external

    review of the results of its LINUS (Literacy and Numer -acy Screening) initiative in 2011 after implementersreported a 98% to 99% success rate among Year 2students.

    The reviewers concluded that the LINUS programmecould be enhanced in a number of ways. For example,they suggested that a more accurate report could beobtained by screening students under test conditionsand that the LINUS syllabus should be more closelyaligned with the existing syllabi of schools.

    Moreover, the reviewers found that the implementa -

    tion of the screenings did not completely adhere to thebenchmarks of the screening process, at times makingit easier for students to screen positively.

    The EDU NKRA has taken the results of this report seri -ously and has started implementing the reforms sug -

    gested by the report. In 2012, the EDU NKRA screenedthe rst two cohorts of the LINUS programme undertest conditions and found that the achievement ratefell from 98% - 99% to 93% - 94%.

    The EDU NKRA takes the view that there can be nocompromises when it comes to education. Further -

    more, it is committed to vigorous monitoring standardsfor its initiatives and welcomes any and all criticismfrom all quarters.

    COMMITMENT TO TRANSPARENCY

    I am happy with the transformation programmes

    to increase the quality of education. As a teacher,

    I feel that it is timely as kids nowadays are getting

    smarter thanks to technology. So, the programmes

    are in line with the changing times. It also helps the

    rural children as well, which increase the level of

    education they receive.

    Zalinah Jamal, 47

    Teacher

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six97

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    9/24

    In terms of quanti able targets, the EDU NKRAhas managed to reach or exceed almost all of itstargets. Speci cally, it delivered the followingoutcomes:

    The EDU NKRA saw the opening of 2,054 pre-school classes last year, and sawtotal enrolment increase to 80.5% or 768,145 pre-school aged children. In total,the NKRA oversaw the opening of 6,643 pre-school classes and the training ofsome 21,000 pre-school teachers. It also implemented the pilot for the NationalPre-School Quality Standards programme.

    The EDU NKRA realised that principals and head teachers at large schools were at adisadvantage when it came to the New Deal programme, which are awarded basedupon on the successful performance of their schools. The New Deal is an incentiveprogramme to motivate principals and head teachers to improve their schoolperformance. A new category was introduced in 2012 to ensure that all principalsand head teachers had a fair chance of winning a New Deal regardless of the size oftheir schools.

    The screening of the third cohort for the LINUS programme showed a pro ciencyrate of 90% for numeracy and 82% for literacy, which is a still signi cantachievement under this programme. The numbers have come down slightly fromthe previous years because the programme implementers had decided to raisethe standards of the programme.

    As a result, the LINUS programme was modi ed to screen every student annually.For the rst cohort of the LINUS programme, students were only successivelyscreened if they failed to meet pro ciency requirements during the rst roundof testing.

    In 2012, each student is tested in every screening regardless of pro ciency level,and must pass all 12 constructs to be deemed literate or numerate. The previousconstruct requirements were eight (8) for literacy and ten (10) for numeracy.These changes ensure a more accurate re ection of the levels of literacy andnumeracy of Malaysian school children.

    LINUS will be continued in GTP 2.0 and will incorporate English literacy screeningas part of its programme. A baseline screening for English literacy will beimplemented in 2013.

    OUTCOME 1

    Improving Pre-School Enrolment

    OUTCOME 3

    Introducing new New Deal categories for principals

    OUTCOME 2

    Continued screening of school children under LINUS

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six98

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    10/24

    OUTCOME 4Paving the ground for upskillingEnglish teachers

    When the principal of SMK Seri Kembangan,Tay Keng Lee, rst learnt about the New Dealprogramme, he immediately saw it as an oppor -

    tunity for his secondary school. SMK Seri Kem -bangan was then languishing near the bottom asone of the worst performing secondary schoolsin the country ranking 1,930th out of 2,248.

    When I initially shared the New Deal ideas withthe teachers, even my secretary was sceptical:will it work? says Tay. Well, straight away, theschools operational procedures were stream -

    lined. I was able to o er o er encouragementand advice. The students began to be inspired

    by our teachers.

    They treated school as a home away fromhome, not as a threat. Their attitudes changedas they grew in their respect for their teachers.From Tays personal drive and the introductionof his New Deal ideas, SMK Seri Kembangansaw its ranking jump 1,369 positions to 561during a 2012 School Inspectorate inspection.Tay says the achievement would not have beenpossible without a group of dedicated teachersand administrators.

    By renewing our efforts, our students im -

    proved, Tay says. We had created history. Itwas as if we had created a miracle for SMK SeriKembangan. Make the impossible, possible.

    MAKING THE IMPOSSIBLE, POSSIBLE

    About 61,000 English teachers were tested under theCambridge Placement Test (CPT) in advance of a newinitiative to be introduced in GTP 2.0 that will rapidlyupskill the pro ciency levels of all English teachers inthe country. The results of the screening showed that27.8% of screened teachers met the minimum CPTstandards, which is the international minimum pro ciency

    level for English language teachers, or C1 in the CommonEuropean Framework of Reference. The results were muchbetter among lecturers of whom met that standard.

    (*) Pre-A A A B B C C

    (*) Technical error

    Overall result of CPTshows that 27.8% of61,035 in-service Englishteachers & lecturers metminimum internationalstandard (C1)

    27.8%

    M i n i m u m

    S t a n d a r d

    ProficientRequire upskillingBasic user

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six99

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    11/24

    OUTCOME 5

    Better numbers under the SchoolImprovement Programme

    OUTCOME 6

    Closing the gap in special education

    There was a 43.6% drop in the number of schools, or 164 schools, categorised

    under Band 6 and Band 7, which are the two lowest bands in accordance withMinistry school standards. Meanwhile, there was a corresponding 27.1% increasein Band 1 and Band 2 schools. These numbers surpassed targets, which were set at20% and 8% respectively.

    Preliminary ndings in the MEB revealed a signi cant gap in Malaysias delivery ofspecial education,and thus the NKRA conducted a special education lab to identifyand provide solutions to the problem in 2012. The lab was jointly participated byboth public and private sector stakeholders including special-needs NGOs. Theinitiatives identi ed in the lab are based on four main workstreams:

    Assessment and early interventionIncrease awareness and networkPublic-private partnerships in schools for special-needsTeacher training and certi cation

    After syndication with stakeholders, including from the Deputy Prime Minister,the lab output is included as a to a chapter in the MEB speci cally for specialeducation. Meanwhile, EDU NKRA has also started training 300 remedial teachersto enhance their pedagogical skills in supporting mainstream students withlearning di erences. This encourages integration of students with learningdi erences in mainstream schools.

    40% drop in Band 6 & 743%

    27% increase in Band 1 & 227%

    2012 Target & Achievement

    BANDBANDBANDBANDBANDBANDBAND

    2009 2011 SCHOOL BANDING TREND

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 0

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    12/24

    NKPIs

    No. NKPIs 2012 Target Actual Result Remarks Trafc Lights

    1 Pre-school enrolment rate 768,145 children (age4+ and 5+) enrolled inpre-schools

    2 LINUS Cohort 12.1 Literacy rate

    2.2 Numeracy rate

    3 LINUS Cohort 23.1 Literacy rate

    3.2 Numeracy rate

    4 LINUS Cohort 34.1 Literacy rate

    4.2 Numeracy rate

    5 High Performing Schools 39 schools awarded theHPS status in 2012

    6 New Deals Principalsexceeding target6.1 Primary School

    6.2 Secondary School

    NA* 125 principals awarded NA

    7 New Deals Principalsperforming below target7.1 Primary School

    7.2 Secondary School

    NA* NA

    8 SIP Reduce Band 6 & 7

    9 SIP Increase Band 1 and 2

    AND ABOVE TO * The achievements for primary schools will only beavailable in March 2013. Therefore, these NKPIs will betracked in the year 2013.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 1

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    13/24

    INITIATIVES

    6.1

    1 Improving Pre-School Enrolment Rate

    2 Literacy and Numeracy Screening (LINUS)

    Programme

    3 Recognition of High Performing Schools (HPS)

    4 New Deals for Principals

    5 School Improvement Programme (SIP)

    1

    IMPROVING PRE SCHOOL

    ENROLMENT RATE

    Early childhood education is a critical componentof a young students foundational development,and gives him/her a good start once in primary

    school. The impact of pre-school is well-documented and reported in other publications, 3 but the general conclusion of these ndingsagree that Malaysia needs to accelerate itspre-school enrolment rate.

    At the start of the GTP programme, a nationalsurvey showed that only 67% of children agedfour to ve were enrolled in pre-schools. Thisnumber has since improved to 80.5% in 2012,and the results of this higher enrolment shouldbecome more apparent now that the pre-schoolers are entering the primaryeducation system.

    In terms of speci c actions, the EDU NKRA hasincreased the number of Government operatedpre-school classes nationwide, particularly inremote locations. Through this initiative, some1,493 public pre-schools were opened in remoteareas in 2012, bringing total number to 4,271over the course of GTP 1.0.

    There has also been greater collaborationwith private sector partners to deliver pre-schools in collaboration with the Government.The last year saw 561 private pre-schoolsestablished under the programme, bringing theGTP 1.0 total to 2,370.

    To help promote the development ofprivate pre-schools, the Government has madeRM10,000 grants available to help setup small to medium centres, especially inrural and urban poor areas. Some 356 private

    operators received the grant in 2012.Finally, the Ministry of Education (MoE) has

    taken additional steps to support enrolmentby providing nancial assistance to low-incomegroups to help o set the cost of early education.This initiative will be continued and enhancedin GTP 2.0.

    3For more information, please consult the GTP Roadmappp153-155.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 2

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    14/24

    The Ministry of Education (MoE) hastaken additional steps to supportenrolment by providing nancialassistance to low-income groups tohelp o set the cost of early education.

    80.5% PRE-SCHOOL ENROLMENT RATE &

    2,054 NEW CLASSES LAUNCHED

    561 new pre-school built byprivate operators 561

    1,493 new public pre-school

    built in 2012, by state 1,493

    KelantanKedah

    Perak

    Selangor

    Johor

    Sarawak

    Sabah

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 3

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    15/24

    2

    LITERACY AND NUMERACY SCREENING

    LINUS PROGRAMME

    Basic literacy and numeracy pro ciency are foundational skills, which

    prepare and shape students for lifelong learning. However, formal testingalone is insu cient to ensure pro ciency as results come too late for anyremedial work to be done which results in lost opportunities. LINUS wasintroduced as a targeted e ort to detect weaknesses in these two areas atan early stage.

    LINUS RESULTS 2010 2012 (LITERACY)

    SEPJU NMA RSEPJU NMA RSEPJU NMAR

    Cohort 1

    SEPJU NMA RSEPJU NMA R

    Cohort 2

    SEPJU NMA R

    Cohort 3

    Special Screening Special screening is conducted under test conditions Students must pass all 12 constructs

    Normal Screening

    2010 2011 2012

    Starting 2012,students must passall 12 constructs to beconsidered literate

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 4

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    16/24

    The ultimate aim of the LINUS screening programme is to ensure that allMalaysian students, excluding those with learning di culties, possess basicpro ciency in numeracy and Bahasa Malaysia literacy by the time theycomplete Primary Three. This programme screens students as they enterPrimary One to determine their pro ciency levels, and those who do notmeet the standard are placed into remedial programmes.

    The success of LINUS in GTP 1.0 has encouraged its enhancement andexpansion in GTP 2.0 to include English literacy screening as well as greatermonitoring of student development as they move from Primary One toPrimary Three.

    INTERNATIONAL AVERAGE

    Shanghai, China Singapore Hong Kong Korea Taiwan

    Croatia

    Israel

    Thailand Malaysia Indonesia

    INTERNATIONAL AVERAGE

    Shanghai, China Finland Hong Kong Singapore Japan

    Greece

    Malta

    Thailand Malaysia Indonesia

    Reading

    INTERNATIONAL AVERAGE

    Shanghai, China Korea Finland Hong Kong Singapore

    Russian Fed.

    Chile

    Thailand Malaysia Indonesia

    Regional peers

    MEAN SCORECOUNTRYRANK

    MathMEAN SCORECOUNTRYRANK

    Science MEAN SCORECOUNTRYRANK

    MALAYSIA RANKS AMONG THE BOTTOM THIRD OF 74 PARTICIPATING

    COUNTRIES ACROSS ALL SUBJECTS IN PISA 2009

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 5

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    17/24

    39 NEW HPS IDENTIFIED IN 2012

    KEDAH

    SK Ibrahim SJKC Keat Hwa SM Sains Sultan Mohamad Jiwa SM Sains Pokok Sena SK Sultanah Asma

    MELAKA SBPI Selandar SJKC Yok Bin SK Convent Infant Jesus (2) SK (P) Methodist 2

    PULAU PINANG

    SK Minden Height SJKC Kwang Hwa SM Sains Kepala Batas SK Bertam Indah SJKC Union

    KELANTAN

    SK Zainab 1

    SK Seri InderaPERLIS

    SM Sains LabuanWP LABUAN

    SK Sri GayaSABAH

    PERLIS

    SK Seri Indera

    SELANGOR

    SM Sains Hulu Selangor

    NEGERI SEMBILAN

    SM Sains Tuanku Jaafar

    PERAK

    SJKC Ave Maria Convent

    TERENGGANU SK Sultan Sulaiman 1 SK Tengku Mahmud SK Sains Sultan Mahmud SBPI Batu Rakit Kolej Sains Islam Pendidikan Negeri Terengganu SK Tengku Ampuan Intan

    JOHOR

    SK Perempuan Sultan Ibrahim SK Infant Jesus Convent SJKC Foon Yew 2 SM Sains Kota Tinggi

    SM Sains Johor

    SM Sultan Ismail SK Bandar Ismail SK Bandar Penawar 2 SMK Infant Jesus Convent

    SK Bandar Maharani

    3

    RECOGNITION OF HIGH PERFORMING

    SCHOOLS HPS

    The goal of the HPS programme is to recognise and incentivise schools

    that have demonstrated outstanding performance records by assigningthem HPS status. Because of their successful track records, HPS will begiven greater autonomy to adapt curriculum and instructional methodson the assumption that the school, as a high performer, knows whatworks best.

    HPS receive a special allocation of RM700,000 and RM500,000respectively in the rst two years after they have been designated as such.They subsequently receive RM300,000 annually. Principals, head teachersand teachers of HPS also receive a one-time bonus when a school isreceives HPS designation.

    These nancial incentives further serve to motivate schools to

    challenge one another to be recognised as an HPS. The EDU NKRA willestablish and maintain a minimum number of 100 HPS and schools mustmeet speci c criteria to be deemed as one. By the end of 2012, 91 HPShad been identi ed.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 6

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    18/24

    5

    SCHOOL IMPROVEMENT PROGRAMME SIP

    The School Improvement Programme (SIP) is aconcerted initiative aimed at closing the gapbetween the highest and lowest performingschools. The programme aims to narrow the gapby focusing improvement e orts on schoolsfalling into the MoEs two lowest rankingcategories Band 6 and Band 7 and byproviding support to help schools attain Band 1and Band 2 status.

    There is a danger that wildly uctuatinglevels of school standards will see theachievements of the best performing students

    eclipsed by poor performing ones, and hencethe SIP aims to level school standards acrossthe board. SIP works by assessing the needs ofBand 6 and Band 7 schools through a rigorousmonitoring process that looks at a variety of dataincluding test results reported to the SchoolExamination Analysis System ( Sistem AnalisisPeperiksaan Sekolah or SAPS ).

    Remedial help is given to schools that needit the most as well as support in other waysto bring the school up to speed. The goal is toensure that no school falls under Band 6 andBand 7 categories by 2015.

    The programme is tailoredto encourage principals andhead teachers to improve theirperformance by providingthem with nancial and careerincentives.

    4

    NEW DEALS FOR PRINCIPALS

    School leadership has been identi ed as one of the keyfactors with direct in uence over the performance of a school.

    As part of its rst phase of initiatives designed to improvestudent outcomes, the EDU NKRA has put in place a New Dealpackage for high performing principals and head teachers.

    The programme is tailored to encourage principals andhead teachers to improve their performance by providingthem with nancial and career incentives. This is e ectivelythe rst step in transforming the culture of the countryseducation system from one that is tenure-driven to one that isperformance-driven.

    The programme looked at several criteria before decidingon whether to award a New Deal. These criteria are: A target composite score of above 84% for primary

    schools and above 88% for secondary schools, or a year-on-year improvement of 2,050 places for primary schoolsand 300 places for secondary schools, or for schools withlarge enrolments a year-on-year improvement of 1,250places for primary schools and 300 places for secondaryschools.

    An Annual Appraisal Report (LNPT) score of higher than 90

    A clean (unquali ed) nancial audit report from the stateeducation department

    A history of no disciplinary action

    Achievement of school literacy and numeracy targets (forprimary schools)

    This programme also gauges how well principals performin comparison to the target composite score, and is themeasurable outcome for this initiatives KPI. The program will

    be enhanced in GTP 2.0 by reworking the appraisal processas by providing greater detail on fast-tracking principaldevelopment.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 7

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    19/24

    One of the key goals of the Education NKRA, and indeedfor the rst horizon of the GTP 1.0, was to instil a funda -

    mental change in the way civil servants deliver servicesto the rakyat. As with most other NKRAs, the EducationNKRA experienced a similar reluctance with its personnelwith respect to the theme of change.

    The biggest challenges were the human factor, said DrNoorliza bt Haji Zakuan, the head of the NKRAs DeliveryManagement O ce (DMO). The need for a change inmindsets among the top and middle managers who havebecome complacent owing to the routine way of doingthings was an obstacle we had to overcome.

    The prevailing belief why x when its not broken? isstill strong among them and we needed to make extrae ort to convince the Ministry of Educations popula -

    tion why there was a need to change. The watered downinformation and messages, and lack of understandingcontributed to this resistance.

    Not all the challenges were fully overcome, she ad -

    mitted, but they have reduced with time. Regular roadshows, engagement sessions and performance dialogueswith the various stakeholders have helped them under -

    stand the objectives of the NKRA.

    In this regard, the rst two years of the GTP 1.0 proved to

    be the most challenging as the DMO team was faced witha resistant civil service. In contrast, 2012, Dr Noorliza said,was an easier year for her team.

    For some, the EDU NKRA was merely an acronym aone-o project and not the transformational changewe were trying to achieve, she said. Many were angryand resistant, but by 2012, they began to realise thatthere were other way to do things.

    It is important for all, especially the rakyat, to note thatthe GTP is not merely lip service by the Government butteaches how things need to be done to achieve resultsand outcomes in a faster way.

    Despite the obstacles, the EDU NKRA would report three

    consecutive years of success, with particularly sparklingresults with respect to its Literacy and Numeracy Screen -

    ing Programme and its e orts to move schools out fromthe two lowest bands in the nation.

    Dr Noorliza, who was brie y a teacher herself before she joined the ranks of policy makers, says, in true teacherfashion, that her greatest pleasure was in seeing theNKRAs targets met and when the people started believ -

    ing in the GTP.

    Now everyone in the MoE is talking about KPIs and

    target-setting, and the discipline of action is being em -ulated by the National Education Blueprint team, shesays. This is the DMOs and PEMANDUs and also mypersonal achievement.

    VIEWS FROM THE DELIVERY MANAGEMENT OFFICE DMO

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 8

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    20/24

    LOOKINGFORWARD TOGTP 2.0

    6.2

    The success of the NKRAs initiatives implementedunder GTP 1.0 has made a strong case for theirenhancement in GTP 2.0. Almost all the initiatives

    in GTP 2.0 have a clear link to the initiatives of GTP1.0, but new ones will be introduced that expand thescope of the EDU NKRAs work. Two new emphasesfor GTP 2.0 include focusing on improving Englisheducation and improving the teaching profession byproviding increased progression and developmentopportunities.

    THE EDU NKRA WILL IMPLEMENT

    SEVEN KEY INITIATIVES IN GTP 2.0:

    GTP 2.0 Initiatives Description

    Pre-school and EarlyChildcare

    The success of the Pre-school initiative in GTP 1.0 has led the NKRAto expand its coverage to encompass early child-care as well. This willensure that children are exposed to formal education environmentsat a formative age. Moreover, international benchmarks for EarlyChildhood Education (ECCE) cover both pre-school and childcare, andthe inclusion of ECCE will allow the NKRA to benchmark Malaysianprogrammes against international standards. Meanwhile, the qualityof pre-schools will be formalised under a new benchmarking regime.

    LINUS 2.0 GTP 1.0s LINUS programme has been one of the main highlights ofthe EDU NKRAs transformation story, and will be further enhanced inGTP 2.0 by the addition of English pro ciency screening. The screening

    process has also been improved to track students annually regardlessof whether or not they demonstrate pro ciency.

    High PerformingSchools

    While GTP 2.0 will focus on maintaining the quality of the existing HPS,the programme also aims to identify more HPS. In particular, eight moreschools will be added to the roster to complete the initial targetednumber of 100, and 10 more will be subsequently added annually.

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six10 9

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    21/24

    School ImprovementProgramme

    To further enhance the performance of schools, GTP 2.0 willempower District Education O ces with the authority to providerelevant support and aid for underperforming schools. The objectivehere is to create central hubs that have the resources and powers

    to support and improve schools within their jurisdictions.

    New Deals and NewPrincipal CareerPackage

    In addition to the New Deal opportunities o ered to principalsand head teachers, this enhanced initiative will also streamline theappointment process transforming it into a performance-based system.It will also create a comprehensive succession plan to ensure that everyschool will be sta ed by a principal or head teacher at all times.

    New Teacher Career

    Package

    This new initiative shares its roots with the Principal Career

    Package. The EDU NKRA recognises that teachers are at the very frontlines of the education system, and this initiative will transformteacher compensation from a tenure-based system to a performance-based one.

    Upskilling EnglishTeachers

    The results from the CPT show that there is a need to further enhancepro ciency and pedagogical competencies of English languageteachers in the system. This initiative aims to bring teachers Englishpro ciency up to the international standards through a series offocused and e ective professional development programmes.

    The EDU NKRA is also cognisant of the fact that PreliminaryReport of the Malaysia Education Blueprint (MEB) waslaunched in Spetember 2012, and hence there is a need toharmonise the initiatives of GTP 2.0 with the objectives of theMEB. Both the GTP and MEB are working towards the samegoals in this regard, and the latter functions to provide a

    clearer long-term focus to the direction of transformation.GTP 2.0 builds on the foundation established by GTP 1.0

    through the introduction of new, speci c initiatives such asthe New Principal and Teacher Career Package, which is anextension of the New Deal programme implemented in GTP1.0. The next three years will also see greater emphasis placedon further strengthening foundations by focusing e orts onimproving basic English literacy.

    The NKRAs e orts in GTP 2.0 will also respond toconcerns voiced by the rakyat that insu cient attention isbeing paid to establishing basic education foundations, whichis a key action item in the MEB.

    I think changes like these take time. For me, the

    governments initiatives to improve the quality

    of teachers and education standards are good.

    Its the starting point for changes in the nation

    to take place.

    Mohd Khairul Azim, 24

    Lawyer

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six11 0

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    22/24

    HARMONISATION WITH THE

    MALAYSIA EDUCATION BLUEPRINT MEB

    The Malaysian Education Blueprint (MEB) represents theambitions of the Government to create an education systemin Malaysia that is on par with the best in the world by 2025.

    The MEB is the result of an extensive review of the existingeducation system conducted in October 2011, which polleda number of sources including local teachers and parentsand international organisations such as UNESCO and theWorld Bank.

    NationalEducationBlueprint 2013 2025

    ACCESS QUALITY EQUITY

    Universal enrolmentacross all levels frompre-school to uppersecondary by 2020

    From stagnant enrolmenttoday to developed nationlevels

    98% Primary90% Lower Secondary85% Upper Secondary

    Top third of countries ininternational assessmentssuch as Programme forInternational StudentAssessment (PISA) andTrends in InternationalMathematics and ScienceStudy (TIMMS) in 15 years(improving from thebottom-third today).

    Malaysia as one of thefastest improving systemsever in the world, in

    15 years

    50% reduction inachievement gaps(urban -rural,socio-economic,gender) by 2020

    Malaysia as one of theworlds most equitableschool systems

    GTP 2.0 2013 2015

    92% pre-school At international average ininternational assessmentssuch as PISA, TIMSS*

    25% reduction inurban-rural achievementgaps across Malaysia*

    THREE ASPIRATIONS IDENTIFIED FOR THE MALAYSIAN EDUCATION SYSTEM

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six11 1

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    23/24

    There are overlaps between the goals of the MEBand the EDU NKRAs GTP initiatives due to thefact that the EDU NKRA represents a subset ofspeci c initiatives within the overall rubric of theMEB. The initiatives under GTP 1.0 are already

    working towards the ve policy shifts outlined/indicated above, and GTP 2.0 initiatives willfurther build on the foundation they establish,which will help the overall development of theeducation sector towards the vision presentedby the MEB. To better co-ordinate the delivery ofthese shifts, a new o ce will be set up under thepurview of the MoE to monitor the deliverablesof all initiatives targeting the education sector.

    The Malaysian Education Blueprint (MEB)represents the ambitions of the Governmentto create an education system in Malaysia thatis on par with the best in the world by 2025.

    4For more information on the Malaysia Education Blueprint please refer tothe document which has been published by t he Ministry of Education andis available on its website at: http://www.myedureview.com.

    The result of the research is a set of 11 policyshifts documented in the MEB that work towardsrealising the countrys education ambitions:1 Provide equal access to quality

    education of an international standard *2 Ensure universal pro ciency in Bahasa

    Malaysia and the English Language *3 Develop values-driven Malaysians4 Transform teaching into a profession of

    choice *5 Ensure high performing school leaders are

    in every school *6 Empower education o ces and schools

    to develop solutions based on local need *7 Leverage Information Communications

    Technology (ICT) to scale up the qualityof learning across Malaysia

    8 Transform the delivery capabilities andcapacities of the Ministry of Education

    9 Create partnerships with parents,communities and the private sector ona larger scale

    10 Maximise student outcomes for everyringgit spent

    11 Increase transparency for direct publicaccountability

    * Indicates areas presently being worked onby EDU NKRAs GTP initiatives.4

    Government Transformation Programme Annual Report Chapter Six11 2

  • 8/13/2019 Eng GTP2012 AR 06 Improving Student Outcomes

    24/24

    KEY LESSONSThe execution of the NKRAs initiatives inGTP 1.0 has revealed a number of lessons thatwill be invaluable in the implementation of GTP 2.0,

    including the need to constantly monitor theimplementation of initiatives and shifting groundconditions.

    6.3

    These monitoring processes have already resulted in changesto the delivery of 2012 initiatives, such as the need for regularLINUS screening for all students and creating di erentiatedcategories for the New Deal awards. These changes to theinitiatives help provide a more accurate picture of existingeducation standards across the country, which in turn will helptailor future initiatives in order to address issues better.