energyforward fleet transition 2014 aapt summer meeting july 28, 2014 minnesota power david j....

11
EnergyForward Fleet Transition 2014 AAPT Summer Meeting July 28, 2014 Minnesota Power David J. McMillan, Executive Vice President

Upload: winfred-griffin

Post on 25-Dec-2015

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

EnergyForward Fleet Transition

2014 AAPT Summer MeetingJuly 28, 2014

Minnesota Power

David J. McMillan, Executive Vice President

•Shale Gas Supply

•Transforming Long-Term Outlooks

•Gas-Electric Market Alignment

•Technology Enablers

EPA Regulatory

Change

•Expanding Footprint

•New Products

•Renewables Expansion

•Technology Evolution

•Mercury and Air Toxics Standard Final

•Carbon Regulation Unfolding

•Ongoing uncertainty

Low regional market pricesTransmission growthMarket sophistication

Abundant natural gas Renewable accessibilityLife cycle considerations

Fuel Supplies

MISORegional Energy

Market

Power Industry in Transformation

2

3

MP’s Fleet Transition Goals

Large industrial impacts on MP:• Significantly influence MP’s

system needs• Strongly reinforce a focus on cost

in balance with stewardship and reliability

• Have led to innovative thinking and action about energy supply and partnerships for years

• Cost based rate issues for industrial customers are real

Regulated Utility MWH Sales

Industrial43%

Residential12%Commercial

13%

Other Power

Suppliers10%

Municipals7%

Other13%

4

and MP’s Customers

Coal42%

Biomass3%

Hydro4%

Wind12%

MHEB 250 MW 10%

Natural Gas and Market

29%

5

Coal65%

Biomass2%

Hydro2%

Wind11%

MHEB Short Term5%

Market Purchases

15%

Coal95%

Biomass1%

Hydro4%

2005

Current Long Term Planning Line Up

Resource Transformation

2013

• Long Term Direction:1/3 renewable, 1/3 coal, 1/3 natural gas

• This is an aspirational goal and we are well on our way to it

Manitoba Hydro is constructing:• 695MW Keeyask Hydro Project (by 2019 ~ $6.5 billion)• 1485MW Conawapa Hydro Project (as early as 2026 ~ $10.7 billion)• BiPole III HVDC Reliability Project - $3.3 B

Minnesota Power and Manitoba Hydro are constructing:• 500 kV Great Northern Transmission Line (GNTL) transmission line to

deliver hydro to upper Midwest from north of Winnipeg to the Iron Range (by 2020)

~ $0.35 billion in Manitoba ~ $0.5-$0.65 billion in Minnesota

• Will enable ~ 900MW hydro export to US• 250 MW purchased for MP retail customers

Manitoba Hydro Purchase

Winnipeg

Creative/Regional Solutions

ManitobaHydro

Minnesota Power

500MW MP Bison Wind

• High volume, reasonable cost renewables secured

• Wind to hydro storage enabled

• Regional reliability and energy markets enhanced through added transmission

250MW MP Purchase

7

• “Excess” wind energy from MP Bison system in North Dakota able to be stored in MH’s system.

• GNTL facilitates “storage of wind energy.”

• MH and MP systems operate independently; i.e., typically dollars not MWhs exchanged.

Wind / Hydro Synergy

2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 (Pro-

jected)*

-

10,000,000

20,000,000

30,000,000

40,000,000

50,000,000

60,000,000

70,000,000

80,000,000

-0.5%

0.0%

0.5%

1.0%

1.5%

2.0%

2.5%

Energy Partners - Low Income Triple E Plus PowerGrant Percent of Savings

Year

kWh

sav

ing

s (b

usb

ar)

9

Delivering Energy Savings

MN Conservation Goal of 1.5%

MP Conservation Results Exceed Goal!

10

Proposed EPA Carbon Rule Issues

• Rule appears to discount or ignore “early” actions taken between 2005-2012 (renewables, plant efficiency, conservation, etc.)

• Cross-border ownership not recognized (e.g., ND wind serving MN customers)

• As a result of the first two bullets, Minnesota is asked to do more than its share

• Forced fuel switching will affect power markets

• Forced coal to gas switch brings price volatility and reliability risk• Base NGCC capacity and energy production assumptions questionable

• Uncertainty calculating reduction goals and crediting action

Thank You!