embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion...

14
/. Embryol. exp. Morph. Vol. 30, 3, pp. 573-585, 1973 573 Printed in Great Britain Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in mice that develop congenital aganglionic megacolon By WILLIAM WEBSTER 1 From the Institute of Child Health, Guilford Street, London SUMMARY Embryological studies on the mouse indicate that, contrary to the classical concept, all the enteric ganglia are from a single, vagal, neural crest source. The immature ganglion cells first enter the gut by way of the newly formed vagal outgrowth at 10 days gestation. The neuroblasts then migrate down the gut in a cranio-caudal direction, being replaced by more neuroblasts from the vagus. By 15 days 12 h the process is complete and ganglion cells are present throughout the gut. The process is continuous and there is no evidence of a lumbo- sacral origin for any of the intramural ganglia. In mice which develop aganglionic megacolon the process is basically the same except that the neuroblasts appear to migrate at a slower rate than normal. The result is that the migration of the neuroblasts and the elongation of the gut are out of phase so the migrating neuroblasts cannot reach the end of the gut, despite the fact they migrate 6-7 days longer than normal. INTRODUCTION Aganglionic megacolon, or Hirschsprung's disease, is a congenital disease of mammals occurring in man at an incidence of between 1 in 2000 and 1 in 10000 live births in England (Bodian & Carter, 1963). The disease is due primarily to an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum. The present paper compares the development of the enteric ganglia in normal mice with the development in a strain which is characterized by congenital aganglionic megacolon due to the recessive gene piebald-lethal (s l ). ORIGIN AND GENETICS The gene piebald-lethal, s l , was first detected in the Jackson Laboratories U.S.A. in 1959. It occurred in the F 2 generation of a cross between C3H/HeJ and C57BL/6J strains (Lane, 1966). Piebald-lethal, s l , segregates as a simple recessive gene (Lane, 1966; Webster, 1971), it is allelic to and nearly recessive 1 Author's address: Department of Anatomy, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, Virginia 22903, U.S.A.

Upload: others

Post on 23-Oct-2019

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

/ . Embryol. exp. Morph. Vol. 30, 3, pp. 573-585, 1973 5 7 3

Printed in Great Britain

Embryogenesis of the entericganglia in normal mice and in mice that develop

congenital aganglionic megacolon

By WILLIAM WEBSTER1

From the Institute of Child Health, Guilford Street, London

SUMMARYEmbryological studies on the mouse indicate that, contrary to the classical concept, all the

enteric ganglia are from a single, vagal, neural crest source. The immature ganglion cellsfirst enter the gut by way of the newly formed vagal outgrowth at 10 days gestation. Theneuroblasts then migrate down the gut in a cranio-caudal direction, being replaced by moreneuroblasts from the vagus. By 15 days 12 h the process is complete and ganglion cells arepresent throughout the gut. The process is continuous and there is no evidence of a lumbo-sacral origin for any of the intramural ganglia.

In mice which develop aganglionic megacolon the process is basically the same except thatthe neuroblasts appear to migrate at a slower rate than normal. The result is that the migrationof the neuroblasts and the elongation of the gut are out of phase so the migrating neuroblastscannot reach the end of the gut, despite the fact they migrate 6-7 days longer than normal.

INTRODUCTION

Aganglionic megacolon, or Hirschsprung's disease, is a congenital disease ofmammals occurring in man at an incidence of between 1 in 2000 and 1 in 10000live births in England (Bodian & Carter, 1963). The disease is due primarily toan absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuouslength of gut above the rectum. The present paper compares the developmentof the enteric ganglia in normal mice with the development in a strain which ischaracterized by congenital aganglionic megacolon due to the recessive genepiebald-lethal (sl).

ORIGIN AND GENETICS

The gene piebald-lethal, sl, was first detected in the Jackson LaboratoriesU.S.A. in 1959. It occurred in the F2 generation of a cross between C3H/HeJand C57BL/6J strains (Lane, 1966). Piebald-lethal, sl, segregates as a simplerecessive gene (Lane, 1966; Webster, 1971), it is allelic to and nearly recessive

1 Author's address: Department of Anatomy, University of Virginia, Charlottesville,Virginia 22903, U.S.A.

Page 2: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

574 W. WEBSTER

to piebald, s, and completely recessive to wild-type, (+) . All the homozygoterecessives develop megacolon with a complete lack of ganglion cells in thedistal gut.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

To study the development of the enteric ganglia in the normal and sl/sl mice;embryos from over 150 pregnant females were examined. Three main crosseswere used: sl/sl x sljs\ sl/sl x sl/ + and + / + x + / + . The mice were matedovernight and the day a plug was recorded was considered day 1 of pregnancy.Instead of using the conventional but capricious silver impregnation techniquesto identify the developing neuroblasts a histochemical method was used. In theadult mouse the mature enteric ganglia are characterized by a cholinesterasepositive reaction. A similar but weaker reaction can be obtained from theimmature ganglia in the embryo. Maximal staining was obtained by using anon-specific esterase technique; a-naphthyl acetate was used as the substrate(Gomori, 1950; Davis & Ornstein, 1959; see Bancroft, 1967). Embryos of knownage were frozen in hexane cooled to -90°C by an acetone/solid CO2 mixturethen serially sectioned in a cryostat at 16 jum. The sections were melted on toslides, air-dried, then stained for 2-30 mins at 37 °C in the incubating medium.The sections were counter-stained in 2% methyl green (chloroform extracted).

The distribution of ganglion cells in the adult mouse intestine was examinedby use of frozen sections stained with haematoxylin and eosin.

RESULTS

1. Pathology

Throughout this study the term 'colon' is used to represent all the largeintestine distal to the caecum as in the mouse the rectum is not clearly delimited.In normal mouse colon groups of myenteric ganglion cells are present approxi-mately every 50 /an between the outer longitudinal and inner circular musclelayers as seen in 10 /im sections (Fig. 1). Ganglia normally extend as far distallyas about 1 mm from the striated sphincter surrounding the anal canal. Thesubmucous plexus, although present, is very sparse in the colon.

In mice with aganglionic megacolon there are no ganglion cells in either themyenteric or submucous plexuses in the distal 25 mm of colon, there is agradual increase in the next 20 mm (transitional zone) and the proximal half ofthe colon is comparable to that of a normal mouse. In the aganglionic regionlarge abnormal nerve fibres are frequently seen in the zone normally occupiedby the ganglion cells between the longitudinal and the circular muscle layers(Fig. 2). These nerve trunks, which are considered to be part of the sacralparasympathetic outflow, will be discussed in a future paper.

Page 3: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

Embryogenesis of enteric ganglia in mice 575

Fig. 1. Longitudinal section through the wall of colon of a normal adult mouse.Note groups of ganglion cells (arrows) between the outer longitudinal and innercircular muscle layers, x 60.Fig. 2. Longitudinal section through the wall of colon from a mouse with agangli-onic megacolon. Note large nerve fibres (arrow) in place of ganglion cells seen inFig. 1. x 60.Fig. 3. Coat pigmentation of the different mouse genotypes, (a) Black, sl/+ or + / + ;(b) white, sl/sl easily recognizable coat pigmentation of animals with aganglionicmegacolon; (c) piebald, sl/s; (d) black and white, Is/Is, Is is another gene causingaganglionic megacolon; see Discussion; (e) agouti, ls/+ or + / + .Fig. 4. Colon and part of small intestine from five adult mice, (a) Normal mouse -note 4 or 5 faecal pellets in the colon; (b), (c) From well but affected sljsl mice-pellet formation is masked by faecal accumulation in the distal half of the colon;(d), (e) From sick sl/sl mice; note grossly enlarged proximal segment including thecaecum and the normal sized empty distal colon (aganglionic). x \.

2. Clinical presentation

All mice homozygous for the gene piebald-lethal are easily recognizable as sl,besides causing megacolon, also causes an almost complete absence of coatpigmentation (Fig. 3). Approximately 10 % of these homozygotes died beforepostnatal day 3 and a further 25 % before weaning. The surviving mice lived anaverage of 14 weeks.

Death in the preweaned mouse was not usually due to intestinal obstruction,but was characterized by diarrhoea and presumably enterocolitis. In older mice,

Page 4: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

576 W. WEBSTER

10 • •.

Page 5: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

Embryogenesis of enteric ganglia in mice 577

however, the sick mouse invariably showed a grossly enlarged faeces-packed,proximal colon; followed by a normal sized empty distal colon (aganglionic)(Fig. 4).

3. Embryonic development

The development of the enteric plexus in the mouse was examined by serialfrozen sections stained for esterase activity. The esterase activity was localizedin the perikaryon of the early neuroblasts (Fig. 5). The developing liver, the gutmucosa and the dorsal root ganglia also show high activity.

(a) Control ( + / + or sl/ + )

At the 10th day of gestation the normal mouse embryo has 26-28 somites andis structurally comparable to a 96 h chick embryo (Rugh, 1968) or a 28-dayhuman embryo (Otis & Brent, 1954). The gut is a simple tube with the lungs,liver and dorsal pancreas all present as small primordia. There are no ganglioncells in any portion of the alimentary tract at this stage. There are however apair of vagal downgrowths from the post-otic vagal ganglia which make contactwith the primitive oesophagus. Neuroblasts are present along the vagus pre-sumably migrating from the vagal ganglia to the gut.

By IO2—11 days there are considerable numbers of neuroblasts present in thegut. The intestine has grown rapidly and because of its great elongation a loophas formed to the left. The stomach can be clearly distinguished by its expandedlumen. Neuroblasts are present along the oesophagus in conjunction with thevagus just outside the circular muscle layer (Fig. 6). These neuroblasts can betraced on serial sections throughout the stomach and into the intestine (Fig. 7).The distal part of the alimentary canal is completely aganglionic at this stage.

By 111 days gestation further growth of the intestine has led to the formation

FIGURES 5-10

Fig. 5. Section of 16/im from the intestine of a normal 11-J-day embryo showingesterase stained neuroblasts. Note the nucleus is not stained, x 1000.Fig. 6. Transverse section through a normal 10^-day embryo. The vagal down-growths (arrows) have made contact with the upper oesophagus and neuroblasts.are present around the oesophagus. Stained for esterase activity, x 50.Fig. 7. Transverse section through a normal 11-day embryo showing esterase stainedneuroblasts (arrows) in the stomach and intestine, x 50.Fig. 8. Transverse section through a normal 11-day embryo at the level of thetracheal bifurcation. Neuroblasts are seen around the oesophagus outside thecircular muscle layer, x 100.Fig. 9. Transverse section through a normal 11-day embryo showing esterase stainedneuroblasts in the stomach and duodenum x 100.Fig. 10. Longitudinal section of a normal ll-£-day embryo showing neuroblasts asfar distally as the caecum. The distal gut is completely aganglionic at this stage. Thearrows show distal limit reached by neuroblasts. Section stained for esterase activity.Inset shows section of whole embryo, x 35.

Page 6: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

578 W. WEBSTER

11

12

Page 7: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

Embryogenesis of enteric ganglia in mice 579

of a slight umbilical hernia. The trachea has now separated from the oesophagusand the cloacal cavity has now divided into urogenital and rectal portions.Neuroblasts are now present in the oesophagus (Fig. 8), stomach and duodenum(Fig. 9), and small intestine as far distally as the caecum (Fig. 10).

By 122 days further elongation of the gut has caused a sizeable umbilicalhernia. Intramural neuroblasts are now present throughout most of the intes-tinal tract; only the distal threequarters of the colon is still aganglionic (Fig. 11).By day 13| this is reduced to the distal quarter of the colon, about 1-5 mm.However, because of the continuous rapid growth of the large intestine it is afurther 2 days, to 15-2- days gestation, before the neuroblasts reach the end of thegut (Fig. 15). When the longitudinal muscle differentiates these neuroblasts formthe myenteric plexus. The submucous or Meissner's plexus becomes apparentlater.

The time taken for the complete migratory process is about 5\ days; despitethe fact that three-quarters of the alimentary tract has ganglia after only 24 h.This emphasizes the great elongation of the gut, which increases from approxi-mately 1 mm at 10 days to 50 mm by 15̂ - days gestation.

{b) Piebald-lethal {sllsl)

The embryology of the sljsl mice was examined by comparing sections ofembryos from sl/sl x sl/sl crosses with normal embryos. Also complete littersfrom sl/sl x sl/+ crosses were examined by serial sections of each embryo.The distance the ganglia had migrated along the gut was determined for eachembryo and if possible the embryos from each litter were divided into twogroups sl/sl and sl/ +. Using this method no difference could be demonstratedbetween + / + or + /sl and sl/sl genotypes in 10^- or 11^-day embryos. By 12£days gestation, however, a definite and constant difference could be demon-strated.

In the normal 12^-day embryo, ganglia are present as far distally as one-quarter of the way down the colon, which is 4 mm long (Fig. 11). In sl/sl

embryos of the same age neuroblasts only extend as far distally as the caecum(Fig. 12). There is no evidence of any difference in size of the embryo or length

FIGURES 11, 12

an = region of anus

Fig. 11. Longitudinal section through normal 12-̂ -day embryo showing the proxi-mal half of the colon and a section of the small intestine. Neuroblasts are presentthroughout the small intestine and the proximal quarter of the colon. The arrowsmark the distal limit reached by the neuroblasts. x 40.Fig. 12. Longitudinal section through 12-̂ -day sl/sl embryo showing the proximalhalf of the colon and a section of the small intestine. Neuroblasts are presentthroughout the small intestine but have only just started to enter the colon. Thearrow marks the distal limit reached by neuroblasts. x 40.

Page 8: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

580 W. WEBSTER

Page 9: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

Embryogenesis of enteric ganglia in mice 581

of the gut. By 13-̂ days gestation the difference has increased, in the normalembryo only one quarter of the colon is still aganglionic while in the sljsl

embryos it is the distal threequarters. In the 14^-day normal embryo only 0-7mm is still aganglionic compared with 3-5 mm in the sl/sl embryos (Figs. 13, 14).When the process is normally complete at 15^ days only 50% of the colon isganglionic in sl/sl embryos (Figs. 15 and 16 show 16^-day embryos). Theprocess does not stop here, however; the ganglia continue to migrate for afurther 6-7 days, until 1-2 days after birth, so in the newborn only the distal 25 %of the colon remains aganglionic; the colon at this stage measures 25 mmcompared with 4 mm at 12£ days gestation.

DISCUSSION

The use of animal mutations to study human congenital disease has oftenbeen disappointing as superficial similarities have been shown to have quitedifferent pathogenesis. However, in the case of the piebald-lethal mutation inmice the similarity to Hirschsprung's disease in man is extensive. Histologicallythe condition is almost identical; a detailed comparison will be publishedelsewhere.

The present study shows that the intramural ganglionic plexus of the mouseintestine is formed by neuroblasts which migrate along the alimentary tract in acranio-caudal direction. The process starts on the 10th day of gestation and iscompleted by 15Y days gestation. All the neuroblasts are of vagal origin.

This system of development is in agreement with the study made by Okamoto& Ueda (1967) on the embryogenesis of the myenteric plexus in man; and theresults from Yntema & Hammond's (1954) ablation experiments on the chickembryo. However, although it is generally agreed that the enteric ganglia of theupper intestine are of vagal origin, a number of authors have reported that theganglia of the terminal gut have a separate lumbosacral origin (Abel, 1909,

FIGURES 13-16

an = region of anus

Fig. 13. Longitudinal section of a normal 14^-day embryo showing the distal colon(rectum). Neuroblasts are present almost to the end of the gut (arrows). Sectionstained for esterase activity, x 50.Fig. 14. Longitudinal section of a 14^-day sl/sl embryo showing almost the wholecolon. Neuroblasts are present only in the proximal quarter of the colon. Thearrows mark the distal limit reached by the neuroblasts. x 40.Fig. 15. Longitudinal section of a 16^-day normal embryo showing distal colon.Ganglion cells are now present throughout the whole intestine. Section stained foresterase activity, x 50.Fig. 16. Longitudinal section of a 16^-day sl/sl embryo showing the distal colon.There are no ganglion cells present in this part of the gut. Section stained for esteraseactivity, x 50.

Page 10: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

582 W. WEBSTER

1912; Kuntz, 1910fl, b, 1920, 1922, 1953; Uchida, 1927; van Campenhout, 1930,1931, 1932; Jones, 1942; Dereymaeker, 1943; Huther, 1954; Andrew, 1963,1964, 1969, 1970; Cantino, 1970). Recently Andrew (1971) reviewed the experi-mental evidence and concluded that the only work carried out early enough indevelopment to be of value was that of Yntema & Hammond (1954) and herown work (Andrew, 1963, 1964,1969,1970). The work of Yntema & Hammondsupports the hypothesis of a single vagal origin for all the enteric ganglia.Andrew's work has primarily consisted of culturing as chorio-allantoic graftspieces of chick blastoderm. She has demonstrated that both vagal and morecaudal trunk levels of neural crest can give rise to 'enteric ganglia' in thesegrafts. However, as Andrew (1971) points out, although trunk neural crest givesrise to enteric ganglia in grafts it is quite possible that this ability may not be real-ized in the intact embryo. The morphological investigations have been carriedout almost exclusively by silver impregnation techniques despite the fact thatidentification of neuroblasts is difficult at early stages by this method. However,Cantino (1970) used a cholinesterase staining method on rat and rabbit embryosand still concluded that neuroblasts travel along the pelvic nerves to the hind gut.

Although the distal intestine in the mouse grows in close proximity to thepelvic plexus there is no evidence in the present study that ganglion cells passfrom the plexus into the intestine. It is possible that in mammals at least,investigators have interpreted the adjacent pelvic plexus with its many ganglioncells as part of the distal gut. Certainly before the longitudinal muscle differen-tiates the boundary of the distal gut is difficult to determine.

The strongest evidence against a dual origin, at least in the mouse, comesfrom the embryology of mice that will develop megacolon. It has been shown inthis study that the absence of ganglia in the distal gut is not caused by a deficientpelvic supply. Instead the neuroblasts of vagal origin migrate down the gut at aslower rate than normal. This results in the migrating neuroblasts being out ofphase with the lengthening of the gut, so despite the fact they migrate 6-7 dayslonger than normal they cannot reach the end of the gut.

Theories on the origin of aganglionic megacolon in man have been suggestedby a number of authors. Huther (1954) and Svenson (1950,1955), in accordancewith the classical theory of a dual origin of enteric ganglion cells, claimed the'pelvic source' of neuroblasts was defective. Additional evidence for this camefrom the occasionally reported case of a region of aganglionic colon followedboth proximally and distally by normal ganglionic gut. However, the existenceof such 'skip segments' has now largely been discredited or at least if such alesion occurs it is very rare (Nixon, 1964).

Other suggestions include: some sort of vascular disturbance (Ehrenpreis,1966) or temporary ischaemia (Earlam 1972) to the developing gut destroyingganglion cells. As pointed out by Gray & Skandalakis (1972), such vascularobstruction would presumably result in many cases of 'skip segments'; againit is doubtful if such a condition exists.

Page 11: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

Embryogenesis of enteric ganglia in mice 583

A more plausible explanation comes from Okamoto & Ueda (1967); theypropose that the neuroblast migration from the vagal neural crest source stopsat an early stage leaving a continuous, distal, aganglionic region. None of thesetheories seem applicable to the situation seen in the piebald-lethal mouse. Inthis case, the formation and subsequent length of the aganglionic region isdependent upon the speed of migration of the progenitor ganglion cells. Whetherthis is the mechanism causing Hirschsprung's disease in man is unknown.

There is considerable evidence that the primary effect of the sl, piebald-lethalgene is on the neural crest. Lane (1966) first showed that the myenteric ganglioncells of the distal colon were absent; the enteric ganglia have been shown by anumber of authors to be of neural crest origin (Yntema & Hammond, 1954;review Andrew, 1971). Piebald-lethal mice also show extensive white spotting;as the mice have pigmented retinas there is nothing wrong with their geneticcapacity to produce melanin so the melanocytes are presumed to be absent fromthe white areas (Billingham & Silvers, 1960). Melanocytes were first shown tobe of neural crest origin by the elegant experiments of Rawles (1947,1953,1955).A third neural crest lesion was shown by Deol (1967) in the inner ear of thepiebald-lethal mouse. The neural epithelium of the inner ear was invariablyaffected, although the degree and extent of the abnormality varied. Deolreasoned that the abnormalities of the neural epithelium are reflexions of adeficiency in the acoustic ganglion.

The way in which the mutant gene may act on the neural crest is unknown,but a considerable amount of experimental work has been done on the pig-mentation aspect of the defect. Mayer & Maltby (1964), and Mayer (1965,1967 a, b) have investigated spotting in lethal-spotting (Is) mice and in piebald(s) mice. The lethal-spotting mice develop aganglionic megacolon in the samemanner as do piebald-lethal mice (Webster, 1971). Mayer concluded thatpropigment cells migrate to all skin regions of the body, but the skin is a mosaicof specific areas which differ in the level of a factor promoting melanoblastdifferentiation. The s and Is genes make the melanoblasts more sensitive thannormal to the effect of varying skin areas. Mayer (19676) claimed the presence,in piebald skin, of a factor that prevented melanoblast expression only betweenday 11 and day 12 of gestation.

An alternative to this system has been proposed by Schaible (1969). From aseries of breeding experiments in which pigment patterns were selected Schaibleproposed that the complete pigmentation of most mammals and birds developsby expansion and merger of clones of pigment cells, from the same centres thatappear as pigmented spots against a white background in piebald spottedmutants. Schaible's conclusion on the way in which white areas are formedincludes the idea introduced by Mayer that the neuroblasts must reach the skinat a certain stage and if they arrive late there is inadequate proliferation or noproliferation at all resulting in white areas. As Schaible was unable to demon-

38 E M B 30

Page 12: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

584 W. WEBSTER

strate any reduction in number of primordial melanoblasts he proposed thatpiebald, s, and other spotting genes have their effect by retarding melanoblastmigration.

In man there have been greatly conflicting reports of other neural crest lesionsassociated with Hirschsprung's disease.

REFERENCES

ABEL, W. (1909). The development of the autonomic nerve mechanism in the alimentarycanal of the chick. Proc. R. Soc. Edinb. 30, 327-347.

ABEL, W. (1912). Further observations on the development of the sympathetic nervoussystem in the chick. /. Anat. 47, 35-72.

ANDREW, A. (1963). A study of the developmental relationships between enterochromaffincells and the neural crest. / . Embryol. exp. Morph. 11, 307-324.

ANDREW, A. (1964). The origin of intramural ganglia. I. The early arrival of precursor cellsin the presumptive gut of chick embryos. / . Anat. 98, 421-428.

ANDREW, A. (1969). The origin of intramural ganglia. II. The trunk neural crest cells as asource of enteric ganglion cells. / . Anat. 105, 89-101.

ANDREW, A. (1970). The origin of intramural ganglia. III. The vagal source of entericganglion cells. /. Anat. 107, 327-336.

ANDREW, A. (1971). The origin of intramural ganglia. IV. The origin of the enteric ganglia;a critical review and discussion of the present state of the problem. / . Anat. 108, 169-184.

BANCROFT, J. D. (1967). An Introduction to Histochemical Technique, pp. 204-206. London:Butterworth.

BILLINGHAM, R. E. & SILVERS, W. K. (1960). The melanocytes of mammals. Q. Rev. Biol.35, 1-40.

BODIAN, M. & CARTER, C. O. (1963). A family study of Hirschsprung's disease. Ann. hum.Genet. 26, 261-277.

CANTINO, D. (1970). An histochemical study of the nerve supply to the developing alimentarytract. Experientia 15, 766-767.

DAVIS, B. J. & ORNSTEIN, L. (1959). High resolution enzyme localisation with a new diazoreagent, Hexazonium pararosaniline. / . Histochem. Cytochem. 7, 297-298.

DEOL, M. S. (1967). The neural crest and the acoustic ganglion. / . Embryol. exp. Morph. 17,533-541.

DEREYMAEKER, A. (1943). Recherches experimentales sur l'origine du systeme nerveuxenterique chez Fembryon de poulet. Archs Biol., Paris 54, 359-375.

EARLAM, R. J. (1972). A vascular cause for aganglionic bowel. A new hypothesis. Am. J. dig.Dis. 17, 255-261.

EHRENPREIS, T. (1966). Some newer aspects on Hirschsprung's disease and allied disorders./ . Pediat. Surg. 1, 329-337.

GOMORI, G. (1950). Sources of error in enzymatic histochemistry. / . Lab. din. Med. 35,802-809.

GRAY, S. W. & SKANDALAKIS, J. E. (1972). Embryology for Surgeons, pp. 197-202. Phila-delphia: W. B. Saunders.

HUTHER, W. (1954). Die Hirschsprung'sche Krankheit als Forge einer Entwicklungsstorungder intramuralen Ganglien. Beitr. path. Anat. 114, 161-191.

JONES, D. S. (1942). The origin of the vagi and the parasympathetic ganglion cells of theviscera of the chick. Anat. Rec. 82, 185-197.

KUNTZ, A. (1910a). The development of the sympathetic nervous system in mammals. /.comp. Neurol. 20, 211-258.

KUNTZ, A. (19106). The development of the sympathetic nervous system in birds. / . comp.Neurol. 20, 283-308.

KUNTZ, A. (1920). The development of the sympathetic nervous system in man. / . comp.Neurol. 32, 173-229.

Page 13: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum

Embryogenesis of enteric ganglia in mice 585KUNTZ, A. (1922). Experimental studies on the histogenesis of the sympathetic nervous

system. / . comp. Neurol. 32, 1-36.KUNTZ, A. (1953). The Autonomic Nervous System, pp. 117-134. London: Bailliere, Tindal

and Cox.LANE, P. W. (1966). Association of megacolon with two recessive spotting genes in the mouse.

J.Hered. 57, 29-31.MAYER, T. C. (1965). The development of piebald spotting in mice. Devi Biol. 11, 319-334.MAYER, T. C. (1967a). Pigment cell migration in piebald mice. Devi Biol. 15, 521-535.MAYER, T. C. (19676). Temporal skin factors influencing the development of melanoblasts

in piebald mice. /. exp. Zool. 166, 397-404.MAYER, T. C. & MALTBY, E. L. (1964). An experimental investigation of pattern development

in lethal-spotting and belted mouse embryos. Devi Biol. 9, 269-286.NIXON, H. H. (1964). Hirschsprung's disease. Archs Dis. Childh. 39, 109-115.OKAMOTO, E. & UEDA, T. (1967). Embryogenesis of the intramural ganglia of the gut and its

relation to Hirschsprung's disease. J. Pediat. Surg. 2, 437-443.OTIS, E. M. & BRENT, R. (1954). Equivalent ages in mouse and human embryos. Anat. Rec.

120, 33-63.RAWLES, M. E. (1947). Origin of pigment cells from the neural crest in the mouse embryo.

Physiol. Zool. 20, 248-265.RAWLES, M. E. (1953). Origin of the mammalian pigment cell and its role in the pigmentation

of hair. In Pigment Cell Growth (ed. M. Gordon), pp. 1-13. New York: Academic Press.RAWLES, M. E. (1955). Pigmentation in autoplastic and homoplastic grafts of skin from fetal

and newborn hooded rats. Am. J. Anat. 97, 79-128.RUGH, R. (1968). The Mouse; its Reproduction and Development. Minneapolis: Burgess.SCHAIBLE, R. H. (1969). Clonal distribution of melanocytes in piebald spotted and variegated

mice. / . exp. Zool. Ill, 181-199.SVENSON, O. (1950). A new surgical treatment for Hirschsprung's disease. Surgery, St Louis

28, 371-381.SVENSON, O. (1955). Congenital defects in pelvic parasympathetic system. Archs Dis. Childh.

30, 1-7.UCHIDA, S. (1927). Uber die Entwicklung des sympathischen Nervensystems. Acta Sch. med.

Univ. Kioto 10, 63-136.VAN CAMPENHOUT, E. (1930). Contribution to the problem of the development of the sym-

pathetic nervous system. / . exp. Zool. 56, 295-320.VAN CAMPENHOUT, E. (1931). Le developpement du systeme nerveux sympathique chez le

poulet. Archs Biol., Paris 42, 479-507.VAN CAMPENHOUT, E. (1932). Further experiments on the origin of the enteric nervous

system in the chick. Physiol. Zool. 5, 333-353.WEBSTER, W. S. (1971). Embryological study of the development of aganglionic megacolon in

piebald-lethal mice and lethal-spotting mice. Ph.D. Thesis, University of London.YNTEMA, C. L. & HAMMOND, W. S. (1954). The origin of intrinsic ganglia of trunk viscera

from vagal neural crest in the chick embryo. / . comp. Neurol. 101, 515-541.

{Received 14 March 1973, revised 14 June 1973)

Page 14: Embryogenesis of the enteric ganglia in normal mice and in ... · an absence of enteric ganglion cells from the rectum and a varying but continuous length of gut above the rectum