dynamic of supply chain management of shree cement ltd
TRANSCRIPT
THE INDIAN INSTITUTE OF PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT
NEW DELHI
THESIS ON
DYNAMIC OF SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT OF SHREE CEMENT LTD
SUBMITTED TO:
PROF. SUMANTA SHARMA
PROF. VIJAY BODDU
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF:
MR. VARUN MUDGAL
SUBMITTED BY:
POONAM JAIN
ALUMNI ID NUMBER: DF/08/10-M-523
BATCH: FW 08-10
ii
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
ABSTRACT
This project cover the brief understanding about the Cement sector, I
have collected the primary data from the Cement Industry as the
growing demand of real estate also to understand whether the Shree
Cement has targeted the market right or not, I have concluded this
project with the proper recommendation has been made to that, which
help other research to do some research on the basis of that.
Transportation is the movement of products from one node in the distribution
channel to another. By providing for the swift and uninterrupted flow of
products back and forward through the distribution channel, transportation
provides companies distinct markets on an equal footing. Transportation also
permits wider and deeper penetration of new markets far from the point of
production. In addition, by maximizing vehicle and materials handling
capacities and cargo requirements, effective transportation permits
distributors to leverage economies of scale by lowering the per unit cost of
transporting the product. Efficient transportation enables distributors to reduce
the selling price by holding costs down, thereby providing for more
competitive product positioning. Finally, transportation provides other
business function with essential information concerning products, market
place and time utilities and transit costs, and capabilities necessary for
effective enterprise planning and operational execution. The first step in the
management process is to establish the cost effectiveness of private
transportation fleets and the search for and selection of public carriers. The
goal is to ensure the highest level of customer service at the lowest possible
price. The selection of a carrier is normally a combination of the price of
service, carrier financial stability, reliability and mode availability and
subjective elements. The second step involves the ongoing choice of
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
ii
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
selected transport mode to meet daily shipment requirements. Modes should
be chosen that will perform the service for the cost, satisfy any special
shipping needs required by the customer, exceed the rates and services
offered by competing carriers and minimize the likelihood of loss, damage or
delivery delay. Once the mode and carrier has been selected, shippers as a
third step must work with carriers to establish an effective schedule and the
proper vehicle routing to ensure timely customer delivery. The fourth step of
the process is the preparation and completion of the necessary shipping
documentation. Finally, managers must be diligent in developing
transportation performance measurements that will provide them with
quantifiable data necessary for increased productivity and competitive
advantage.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
i
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
SIGNATORY PAGE
TO WHOMESOEVER IT MAY CONCERN
This is to confirm that Poonam Jain, student of IIPM, NEW DELHI, is doing a
live project(Thesis) on the topic “Dynamic of supply chain
management of Shree Cement Ltd” under my guidance and that the
work being done by the candidate is original and is of the standard expected
by an MBA student.
May god bless her with all success in her career.
Warm regards
Varun mudgal
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
v
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
It is well-established fact that behind every achievement lays an unfathomable
sea of gratitude to those who have extended their support and without whom
the project would never have come into existence.
I express my gratitude to IIPM, New Delhi for providing me an opportunity to
work on this thesis as a part of the curriculum.
Also, I express my gratitude to Prof. Sumanta Sharma and Prof.Vijay Boddu
on the completion of my project.
Yours Sincerely
Poonam Jain
F-9
FW 08-10
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
v
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
TOPIC APPROVAL LETTER
Dear Poonam Jain, This is to inform that your thesis proposal on “Supply Chain Management of Shree Cement Ltd.”, to be conducted under the guidance of Mr. Varun Mudgal is hereby approved and the topic registration id number is DF/08/10-M-523 Make it a comprehensive thesis by ensuring that all the objectives as stated by you in your synopsis are met using appropriate research design; a thesis should aim at adding value to the existing knowledge base. You are required to correspond with your internal guide Prof. Vijay Kr. Boddu at [email protected] Ph.-0124-3350714 by sending at least four response sheets (attached along with this mail) at regular intervals before the last date of thesis submission. NB: 1) A thesis would be rejected if there is any variation in the topic/title from the one approved and registered with us.2) The candidate needs to handwrite at least 1200 to 1500 words on the summary of thesis at the time of viva.
Regards,Prof .Sumanta Sharma Dean (Projects) [email protected]: +91 0124 3350701 (D)+91 0124 3350715 (Board)
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
v
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
CONTENT
ABSTRACT...................................................................................... ii
SIGNATORY PAGE.........................................................................iii
TOPIC APPROVAL LETTER.......................................................... iv
ACKNOWLEDGMENT.....................................................................v
CONTENTS……………………………………………………………...vi
THESIS SYNOPSIS......................................................................vii
1. INTRODUCTION ………………………………………………………….1
2. COMPANY PROFILE……………………………………………………..11
3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY…………………………………………..24
4. LITERATURE REVIEW…………………………………………………...26
5. FINDING AND ANALYSIS………………………………………………..51
6. RECOMMENDATION……………………………………………………..61
7. CONCLUSION……………………………………………………………..63
8. BIBLIOGRAPHY…………………………………………………………...66
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
v
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
THESIS SYNOPSIS
INTRODUCTION
A supply chain is a system of organizations, people, technology, activities,
information and resources involved in moving a product or service from supplier to
customer. Supply chain activities transform natural resources, raw materials and
components into a finished product that is delivered to the end customer. In
sophisticated supply chain systems, used products may re-enter the supply chain at
any point where residual value is recyclable. Supply chains link value chains, Over
the last three years, Shree considerably strengthened its marketing presence. Since the
company is based in Rajasthan, the state is the company’s principal market. Rajasthan
is India’s largest cement producing state and Shree’s is the largest single location
plant in northern India. The company’s northern-most positioning within Rajasthan
makes it the closest among all Rajasthan manufacturers to Delhi, Haryana and some
parts of Punjab, a significant cost edge. The company enjoys a market share of about
11 per cent in north India.
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
To study Supply chain management concepts and practices in industrial
scenarios.
To carry out supply chain opportunity analysis with particular reference to
Shree cement
To Benchmark the Implementation Of Supply Chain Management Techniques
In Shree Cement
To study how company work out for its lead time, utilization of the transport
effectively and efficiently.
Do the factor analysis through the primary data analysis
i) Cement is extremely heavy, so that transportation must be optimized
through network
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
i
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
ii) Demand is normally stable, with seasonal trends but very few spikes
iii) Multiple parties in the supply chain make a simple flow more difficult
HYPOTHESIS
H1: Supply chain became more efficient if the product available to the store.
H2: How to develop channel to create more store to sell the product.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
PRIMARY DATA: I will collect the primary data though the questionnaire which is
close and open ended both.
SECONDARY DATA: Internet, Book and Journal.
Tool Used: Bar Graph, Pie Diagram
Sampling Method: Random Sampling chosen by the gathering of data
Sample Size:
1. 100 Dealers + customer
SCOPE OF THE WORK
Shree Cement Ltd. is an energy conscious & environment friendly business
organization. Having Nine Directors on its board under the chairmanship of Shri.B.G.
Bangur, the policy decisions are taken under the guidance of Shri. H.M. Bangur,
Managing Director. Shri. M.K.Singhi, Executive Director of the Company, is looking
after all day-to-day affairs. The company is managed by well qualified professionals
with broad vision who are committed to maintain high standards of quality &
leadership to serve the customers to their fullest satisfaction. The board consists of
eminent persons with considerable professional expertise in industry and field such as
banking, law, marketing & finance & general management.
JUSTIFICATION OF THE CHOOSING TOPIC
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
x
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
It is one way in which I would be able to understand the supply chain wherein the
goods are being delivered from the company to the end consumers, also I would be
able to help the company with my project report, which could become a milestone in
my career path.
DETAILS OF EXTERNAL GUIDE
Name : Mr. Varun Mudgal
Company : Shree Cement ltd, Beawar
SUMMER INTERNSHIP
Company : Dalmia Cement, Ariyalur
Position : Management Trainee
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
x
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
1
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
INTRODUCTION
I have divided the problem area basically in two parts first part will cover the
Industrial analysis and followed by this I have done research on the company
specific problem. The objective to doing so is to prove the objective of the
project.
Problem with the Industry consist the competition level that has with retail
channel management cement sector with low entrance risk in last 10 years
almost 20 to 30 new companies came in to this space and trying to earn profit
but it is really the hard for everybody to actually save their cost. The growing
need and demand of the Real estate would also be the factors for increasing
demand of the Cement, and for every good organization has to have the good
distribution network.
BACKGROUND TO THE PROBLEM
CEMENT INDUSTRY
Sector structure/Market size
India is the world's second largest producer of cement with total capacity of
219 million tonnes (MT) at the end of FY 2009, according to the Cement
Manufactuer’s Association. According to the Cement Manufacturer’s
Association, cement despatches during 2009-10 were 159.43 million tonnes
(MT) increasing by 12 per cent over 142.23 in 2008-09. Cement production
during 2009-10 was 160.31 MT an increase of 12.37 per cent over 142.65 MT
in 2008-09. Moreover, the government’s continued thrust on infrastructure will
help the key building material to maintain an annual growth of 9-10 per cent in
2010, according to India’s largest cement company, Shree Cement. In
January 2010, rating agency Fitch predicted that the country will add about 50
million tonne cement capacity in 2010, taking the total to around 300 million
tonne.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
2
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
New Investments
Cement and gypsum products have received cumulative foreign direct
investment (FDI) of US$ 1.71 billion between April 2000 and February 2010,
according to the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion
In January 2010, Swiss cement company Holcim announced plans to
invest US$ 1 billion for setting up 2-3 greenfield manufacturing plants in
India in the next five years. The expansion will take the company’s total
cement-making capacity to 60 mtpa (million tonnes per annum) from 50
mtpa currently.
Jaiprakash Associates Ltd will invest US$ 984.1 million to take its
cement manufacturing capacity from 20 mtpa to 33 mtpa by 2012.
Madras Cements Ltd is planning to invest US$ 178.4 million to
increase the manufacturing capacity of its Ariyalur plant in Tamil Nadu
to 4.5 MT from 2 MT by April 2011.
Monnet Ispat & Energy (MIEL) will set up cement plants in
Chhattisgarh and Gujarat with an investment of about US$ 527.9
million. Work on the two plants will begin in the October-December
quarter under a new division of the company to be christened Monnet
Cement.
Ambuja Cements, the country’s third-largest cement maker, plans to
spend around US$ 756.3 million to expand its capacity to 24 mtpa from
the current 19 mtpa by year-end to meet strong demand from the
infrastructure sector.
Mergers and Acquistions (M&As)
Dalmia Cement has increased its stake in OCL India to 45.4 per cent
from 21.7 per cent at an investment of US$ 38.24 million as part of its
plan to expand its footprint in eastern India.
In April 2010, French cement maker Vicat bought 51 per cent in
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
3
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Bharathi Cement.
Ultratech Cement, the country’s second-largest cement maker and a
part of Aditya Birla group is acquiring Dubai-based ETA Star Cement
for an enterprise value of US$ 382.1 million.
Government Initiatives
Government initiatives in the infrastructure sector, coupled with the housing
sector boom and urban development, continue being the main drivers of
growth for the Indian cement industry.
Increased infrastructure spending has been a key focus area. In the
Union Budget 2010-11, US$ 37.4 billion has been provided for
infrastructure development.
The government has also increased budgetary allocation for roads by
13 per cent to US$ 4.3 billion.
India, being the second largest cement producer in the world after China with
a total capacity of 151.2 Million Tones (MT), has got a huge cement industry.
With the government of India giving boost to various infrastructure projects,
housing facilities and road networks, the cement industry in India is currently
growing at an enviable pace. More growth in the Indian cement industry is
expected in the coming years. It is also predicted that the cement production
in India would rise to 236.16 MT in FY11. It's also expected to rise to 262.61
MT in FY12. The cement industry in India is dominated by around 20
companies, which account for almost 70% of the total cement production in
India. In the present year, the Indian cement companies have produced 11
MT cement during April-September 2009. It took the total cement production
in FY09 to 231 MT.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
4
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Industry Background
The history of the cement industry in India dates back to the 1889 when a
Kolkata-based company started manufacturing cement from Argillaceous. But
the industry started getting the organized shape in the early 1900s. In 1914,
India Cement Company Ltd was established in Porbandar with a capacity of
10,000 tons and production of 1000 installed. The World War I gave the first
initial thrust to the cement industry in India and the industry started growing at
a fast rate in terms of production, manufacturing units, and installed capacity.
This stage was referred to as the Nascent Stage of Indian Cement Industry. In
1927, Concrete Association of India was set up to create public awareness on
the utility of cement as well as to propagate cement consumption. The cement
industry in India saw the price and distribution control system in the year
1956, established to ensure fair price model for consumers as well as
manufacturers. Later in 1977, government authorized new manufacturing
units (as well as existing units going for capacity enhancement) to put a
higher price tag for their products. A couple of years later, government
introduced a three-tier pricing system with different pricing on cement
produced in high, medium and low cost plants.
Cement industry, in any country, plays a major role in the growth of the nation.
Cement industry in India was under full control and supervision of the
government. However, it got relief at a large extent after the economic reform.
But government interference, especially in the pricing, is still evident in India.
In spite of being the second largest cement producer in the world, India falls in
the list of lowest per capita consumption of cement with 125 kg. The reason
behind this is the poor rural people who mostly live in mud huts and cannot
afford to have the commodity. Despite the fact, the demand and supply of
cement in India has grown up. In a fast developing economy like India, there
is always large possibility of expansion of cement industry.
CEMENT PRODUCTION AND GROWTH
Domestic demand plays a major role in the fast growth of cement industry in
India. In fact the domestic demand of cement has surpassed the economic
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
5
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
growth rate of India. The cement consumption is expected to rise more than
22% by 2009-10 from 2007-08. In cement consumption, the state of
Maharashtra leads the table with 12.18% consumption, followed by Uttar
Pradesh. In terms of cement production, Andhra Pradesh leads the list with
14.72% of production, while Rajasthan remains at second position.
The production of cement in India grew at a rate of 9.1% during 2006-07
against the total production of 147.8 MT in the previous fiscal year. During
April to October 2008-09, the production of cement in India was 101.04 MT
comparing to 95.05 MT during the same period in the previous year. During
October 2009, the total cement production in India was 12.37 MT compared to
a production of 11.61 MT in the same month in the previous year. The cement
companies are also increasing their productions due to the high market
demand. The cement companies have seen a net profit growth rate of 85%.
With this huge success, the cement industry in India has contributed almost
8% to India's economic development.
TECHNOLOGY UP-GRADATION
Cement industry in India is currently going through a technological change as
a lot of upgradation and assimilation is taking place. Currently, almost 93% of
the total capacity is based entirely on the modern dry process, which is
considered as more environment-friendly. Only the rest 7% uses old wet and
semi-dry process technology. There is also a huge scope of waste heat
recovery in the cement plants, which lead to reduction in the emission level
and hence improves the environment.
CEMENT DESPATCHES
Cement industry in India has successfully maintained almost total capacity
utilization levels, which resulted in maintaining a 10% growth rate. In 2006-07,
the total despatch was 155 MT, which rose up to 170 MT in 2007-08. The
month of October 2009 saw a cement despatch of 12.22 MT, which was
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
6
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
almost 9% higher than the total cement despatch of 11.21 MT in the same
month in the previous year.
2008-09 (Apr-Oct) (in
MT)
2007-08 (Apr-Oct) in
MT
Production 101.04 95.05
Despatches (Excluding
Export)100.24 94.33
Export 1.46 2.16
Capacity Utilization (%) 85 93
Major Players in Indian Cement Industry
There are a number of players prevailing in the cement industry in India.
However, there are around 20 big names that account for more than 70%
of the total cement production in India. The total installed capacity is
distributed over around 129 plants, owned by 54 major companies across
the nation.
Following are some of the major names in the Indian cement industry:
Company Production Installed Capacity
Shree Cement 17,902 18,640
Gujarat Ambuja 15,094 14,860
Ultratech 13,707 17,000
Grasim 14,649 14,115
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
7
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
India Cements 8,434 8,810
JK Group 6,174 6,680
Jaypee Group 6,316 6,531
Century 6,636 6,300
Madras Cements 4,550 5,470
Birla Corp. 5,150 5,113
Mergers and Acquisitions in Cement Industry in India
UltraTech Cement is going to absorb its sister concern Samruddhi
Cement to become biggest cement company in India.
World's leading foreign funds like HSBC, ABN Amro, Fidelity, Emerging
Market Fund and Asset Management Fund have together bought 7.5%
of India Cements (ICL) at a cost of US$ 124.91 million.
Cimpor, a Cement company of Portugal, has bought 53.63% stake that
Grasim Industries had in Shree Digvijay Cement.
French cement company Vicat SA bought 6.67% share of Sagar
Cement at a cost of US$ 14.35 million.
Holcim now holds 56% stake of Ambuja Cement. Previously it held
22% of stake. The company utilized various open market transactions
to increase its stakes. It invested US$ 1.8 billion for that.
Recent Investments in the Indian Cement Industry
In a recent announcement, the second largest cement company in
South India, Dalmia Cement declared that it's going to invest more than
US$ 652.6 million in the next 2-3 years to add 10 MT capacity.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
8
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Anil Ambani-led Reliance Infrastructure is going to build up cement
plants with a total capacity of yearly 20 MT in the next 5 years. For this,
the company will invest US$ 2.1 billion.
India Cements is going to set up 2 thermal power plants in Andhra
Pradesh and Tamil Nadu at a cost of US$ 104 billion.
Anil Ambani-led Reliance Cementation is also going to set up a 5 MT
integrated cement plant in Maharashtra. It will invest US$ 463.2 million
for that.
Jaiprakash Associates Ltd has signed a MoU with Assam Mineral
Development Corporation Limited to set up a 2 MT cement plant. The
estimated project cost is US$ 221.36 million.
Rungta Mines (RML) is also planning to invest US$ 123 million for
setting up a 1 MT cement plant in Orissa.
CEMENT INDUSTRY
The cement industry is one of the vital industries for economic development in
a country. The total utilization of cement in a year is used as an indicator of
economic growth. Cement is a necessary constituent of infrastructure
development and a key raw material for the construction industry, especially
in the government’s infrastructure development plans in the context of the
nation’s socioeconomic development. Cement Industry In India Prior To
Independence The first endeavor to manufacture cement dates back to 1889
when a Calcutta based company endeavored to manufacture cement from
Argillaceous (kankar). But the first endeavor to manufacture cement in an
organized way commenced in Madras. South India Industries Limited began
manufacture of Portland cement in 1904.But the effort did not succeed and
the company had to halt production. Finally it was in 1914 that the first
licensed cement manufacturing unit was set up by India Cement Company Ltd
at Porbandar, Gujarat with an available capacity of 10,000 tons and
production of 1000 installed. The First World War gave the impetus to the
cement industry still in its initial stages. The following decade saw tremendous
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
9
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
progress in terms of manufacturing units, installed capacity and production.
This phase is also referred to as the Nascent Stage of Indian Cement
Industry. During the earlier years, production of cement exceeded the
demand. Society had a biased opinion against the cement manufactured in
India, which further led to reduction in demand. The government intervened
by giving protection to the Industry and by encouraging cooperation among
the manufacturers. In 1927, the Concrete Association of India was formed
with the twin goals of creating a positive awareness among the public of the
utility of cement and to propagate cement consumption.
After Independence
The growth rate of cement was slow around the period after independence
due to various factors like low prices, slow growth in additional capacity and
rising cost. The government intervened several times to boost the industry, by
increasing prices and providing financial incentives. But it had little impact on
the industry. In 1956, the price and distribution control system was set up to
ensure fair prices for both the manufacturers and consumers across the
country and to reduce regional imbalances and reach self sufficiency.
Period Of Restriction (1969-1982)
The cement industry in India was severely restrained by the government
during this period. Government hold over the industry was through both direct
and indirect means. Government intervened directly by exercising authority
over production, capacity and distribution of cement and it intervened
indirectly through price control. In 1977 the government authorized higher
prices for cement manufactured by new units or through capacity increase in
existing units. But still the growth rate was below par. In 1979 the government
introduced a three tier price system. Prices were different for cement
produced in low, medium and high cost plants.
However the price control did not have the desired effect. Rise in input cost,
reduced profit margins meant the manufacturers could not allocate funds for
increase in capacity. Partial Control (1982-1989) To give impetus to the
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
10
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
cement industry, the Government of India introduced a quota system in
1982.A quota of 66.60% was imposed for sales to Government and small real
estate developers. For new units and sick units a lower quota at 50% was
effected. The remaining 33.40% was allowed to be sold in the open market.
These changes had a desired effect on the industry. Profitability of the
manufacturers increased substantially, but the rising input cost was a cause
for concern.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
11
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
COMPANY PROFILE
Shree Cement is the largest cement manufacturer in North India and among
the top five cement manufacturing groups in the country. The company is
being professionally managed by its promoters Shri B. G. Bangur, Chairman
and Shri H. M. Bangur, Managing Director. Turnover of the company for 2009-
10 was Rs. 3632 Crores and Net profit was Rs. 676 Crores, while in 2008-09
the company posted a turnover of Rs. 2715 crore and generated operating
profit of nearly Rs. 1034 crore . It has more than quadrupled its capacity in the
last 5 years to reach present cement capacity of 12 million tons p.a. with
manufacturing plants at Beawar, Ras, Khushkhera and Suratgarh in
Rajasthan and Laksar (Roorkee) in Uttarakhand. The Company follows a
multi-brand strategy and sells cement under the highly recognized brands of
Shree Ultra, Bangur and Rockstrong. which together enjoy largest market
share in high value markets of Rajasthan, Delhi & Haryana.
Operational excellence and efficiency of the Company gets reflected in one of
the highest operating profit margins in the Industry. High-calibre project
management and execution capabilities have seen the Company compress
project timelines and push rapid capacity expansions. A striking case in point
is the commissioning of Unit VII in a world record of 367 days. Shree is also
into the power sector with a Power generation capacity of 210 MW which is
set to go up to 560 MW by December 2011. It is known to be an energy
efficient and environment friendly company and has received various awards
and accolades at national and international level for excellence in energy
efficiency and environment management. Shree has set up waste heat
recovery projects of 46 MW capacity which is the largest waste heat power
generation capacity in world cement industry excluding China.Shree follows
the triple bottom-line approach of measuring performance against thethree
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
12
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
benchmarks of Economical, Social and Environmental. Shree is an active
participant at Climate change forums andis the first Indian cement company
to join the Cement Sustainability Initiative of the World Business Council for
Sustainable Development, Switzerland. We differentiate ourselves in a highly
competitive market with continual changes in our marketing & branding
strategy and by aligning our offerings to the customer's needs instead of
forcefully pushing products. This is to
say we do not create customers, we create what customers want.
We believe that our sustained success is because of our highly satisfied
customers and that continuous learning
about their psyche and behavior is the only path ahead. Today, by creating
depth in dealer networks, extensive
brand promotion and opening up new strategic markets, we are able to
absorb a larger sales quantum, ensure
better realizations and increase our competitiveness.
Shree Ultra
Shree Ultra is our flagship brand, contributing to more than half of our sales
volume and is
the first manifestation of our strategic move from commodity to brand
marketing. Its two variants, Shree Ultra OPC and Shree Ultra Jung Rodhak
Cement are distinctly positioned in
the market. Shree Ultra Jung Rodhak Cement through its unique rust
prevention properties, has high acceptance amongst brand influencers
(masons etc.) and high brand recall value.
The brand, while enhancing its presence in highly educated markets of Delhi
has increased
its reach in the interior markets of Madhya Pradesh, Uttrakhand, Uttar
Pradesh and Punjab.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
13
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Bangur Cement
Bangur Cement, launched as a premium brand in the market,is designd to
meet the high end market segment. Its unique brand tagline "Sasta Nahin,
Sabse Achcha", gives it the status of 'top of the market' value brand.
Rockstrong Cement
Rockstrong Cement is the youngest brand from the Shree stable. It has
recorded the highest year on year growth amongst the three brands of Shree
in 2009-10. Its holds a position in the market on the promise of high
performance and ability to withstand exceptionally harsh environment
conditions. Rockstrong promotions are carried out through a series of witty
hoardings on current topics,
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
14
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
DISTRIBUTION SYSTEM OF SHREE CEMENT LTD
The- company whose operations are concentrated in and around Delhi. It
Franchisees and 15 Distributors- They also have 'instant access personal
care kit counters- Each franchises or distributor can have any number of
dealers under him as long as the person is approved by the Shree cement ltd
authority. Each franchises has to invest Rupees Ten Lakhs. to obtain a
franchise and should employ an officer recruited by ITC. This person acts as
an liaison between the company and the franchises. The franchises can it
any number of dealers as long as their territories do not overlap. But
unfortunately Shree cement ltd has not been very successful in controlling
territorial overlaps of dealers. The franchises can carry out his 1 her own
promotional strategy. For this the. company contributes 75% of the money
and the franchises contributes 25% of the money. The dealers under the
franchisee receive the same commission. The franchises and the dealer
obtain the feedback from the customers and they are sent through the liaison
officer on a day-to-day basis to ITC. The dealer has to invest Rupees. One
Lakh as an initial investment. The dealer of Shree cement ltd are not allowed
to provide any other operators' service.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
Company
Distributor Franchisee
Dealers Dealer
Customer Customer
15
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Target set for distributors and the dealers is 100 -150 activations per month.
Hence the dealers can also go for their own promotions like banners and
discounts on festivals etc. The dealer provides service promptly. The
consumer on providing the bill of purchase for the handset and proof of
residence has only to wait an hour before getting connected. The staff of the
dealers and the franchisees are provided training by the Shree cement ltd
personnel.
Retail Distribution channel for SHREE CEMENT LTD
Markets all over the world have been on a roll in 2003 and the Indian bourses
are no exception having gained almost 60% in 2003. During this period, while
there are sectors that have outperformed this benchmark index, there are also
sectors that have underperformed. Shree cement ltd registered gains of just
33% on the BSE Shree cement ltd Index last year.
At the macro level, Indian economy is poised to remained buoyant and grow
at more than 7%. The economic growth would impact large proportions of the
population thus leading to more money in the hands of the consumer.
Changes in demographic composition of the population and thus the market
would also continue to impact the ITC.
Recent survey conducted by a leading business weekly, approximately 47 per
cent of India's 1 + billion people were under the age of 20, and teenagers
among them numbered about 160 million. Together, they wielded INR 14000
Cr worth of discretionary income, and their families spent an additional INR
18500 Cr on them every year. By 2015, Indians under 20 are estimated to
make up 55% of the population - and wield proportionately higher spending
power. Means, companies that are able to influence and excite such
consumers would be those that win in the market place.
Shree cement ltd market has been divided for a long time between the
organized sector and the unorganized sector. While the latter has been
crowded by a large number of local players, competing on margins, the former
has varied between a two-player-scenario to a multi-player one.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
16
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Unlike the U.S. market for fast moving consumer goods , which is dominated
by a handful of global players, India's Rs.460 billion FMCG market remains
highly fragmented with roughly half the market going to unbranded,
unpackaged home made products. This presents a tremendous opportunity
for makers of branded products who can convert consumers to branded
products. However, successfully launching and growing market share around
a branded product in India presents tremendous challenges. Take distribution
as an example. India is home to six million retail outlets and super markets
virtually do not exist. This makes logistics particularly for new players
extremely difficult. Other challenges of similar magnitude exist across the
Shree cement ltd supply chain. The fact is that Shree cement ltd is a
structurally unattractive industry in which to participate. Even so, the
opportunity keeps Shree cement ltd makers trying.
At the macro-level, over the long term, the efforts on the infrastructure front
(roads, rails, power, river linking) are likely to enhance the living standards
across India. Till date, India's per capita consumption of most Shree cement
ltd products is much below world averages. This is the latent potential that
most Shree cement ltd companies are looking at. Even in the much-
penetrated categories like soaps/detergents companies are focusing on
getting the consumer up the value chain. Going forward, much of the battle
will be fought on sophisticated distribution strengths.
Structural Analysis Of SHREE CEMENT LTD
Typically, a consumer buys these goods at least once a month. The sector
covers a wide gamut of products such as detergents, toilet soaps, toothpaste,
shampoos, creams, powders, food products, confectioneries, beverages, and
cigarettes. Typical characteristics of Shree Cement products are: -
The products often cater to vary distinct but usually wanted for aspects -
necessity, comfort, luxury. They meet the demands of the entire cross section
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
17
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
of population. Price and income elasticity of demand varies across products
and consumers.
Individual items are of small value (small SKU's) although all Shree cement ltd
products put together account for a significant part of the consumer's budget.
The consumer spends little time on the purchase decision. He seldom ever
looks at the technical specifications. Brand loyalties or recommendations of
reliable retailer/ dealer drive purchase decisions.
Limited inventory of these products (many of which are perishable) are kept
by consumer and prefers to purchase them frequently, as and when required.
Brand switching is often induced by heavy advertisement, recommendation of
the retailer or word of mouth. Distinguishing features of Indian Shree cement
ltd Business
Retail industries involve the sale of new or used goods to end consumers for
personal or household consumption. Cut-throat competition is becoming
tougher in retail space with growing supply and demand.
Hyper-markets and Super-stores are battling each other on every major
corner while direct marketers (including catalogs and online sites) are stealing
customers from stores. Online selling at deep discounts is even making
immense inroads into consumer purchases of automobiles and travel. Direct
selling through online retailers, catalog companies and home-shopping
television channels continues to increase. Sales via the Internet rose
dramatically in 2005 globally.
To continuously improve on the process and leverage on the core
competencies, there is a need for a foundation that provides accurate
information wherever and whenever required. This calls for a need for
strategic management of supplies and inventory as far as retail industry in
concerned. To change an in-store paper based environment of registering
sales in retail shops to an online shopping environment, there needs an
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
18
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
integration of the data to increase customer satisfaction, increase productivity
and liberate sales people from registering chores and extend market beyond
traditional bounds.
Enriching category, item planning, streamlining product introductions and
other business strategies alone are not sufficient to sustain and over-grow in
the market place. Real-time visibility to sales and order status, in-store kiosks,
and service desk enhancements and strategic technologies to track inventory
have become the call of the hour to improve the customer experience and
further differentiate the brand. New efficiencies in managing stock and
collaborative forecasting and replenishment help ensure that the products
customers want are readily available on store shelves.
Strategic methods and tools like Vendor Managed Inventory, ERP and SCM
are recognized very much these days. Several Indian companies have
already come up with either a home-grown ERP or SCM model or they use
packages from well-established firms. There is a need for a strategic
collaboration of the internal process with the business process of the suppliers
and customers. Hence, this paper would aim at answering the question, "How
retailers need to organize their supply chain strategically to compete in
consumer market?"
Our team has, therefore, tried to analyze the present scenario of retail
industry and has come up with some suggestions as possible strategies in
Supply Chain Management for Retail industry. We are proposing the following
model for information integration in a retail industry: -
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
19
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
The strategic innovation should ideally start from identifying important supply
chain member with whom it is critical to link, thus, making way for a spatial
convenience. Focusing on providing dynamic visibility to the supplier about
the status of the inventory, and using techniques to gather the consumption
pattern of products, and thereby forecasting to a number nearer to accuracy,
would form part of our suggestions.
Delivering right product at the right time for the right price with the least
possible cost through strategic planning of demand and supply and effective
utilization of inventory, distribution, warehousing and transportation seems like
a complex scenario of unattainable level.
Well, this statement is nothing but the idealistic state. Nearing what is known
as perfection needs continual improvement and timely innovations.
Timely innovations and strategic moves can become disruptive many a times.
Take the case of Shree cement ltd effect. What seemed way back in 1962 as
a small outlet in the remote part of Indian rural area through e choupal, is now
the legend of American retail business. Excellent inventory tracking system
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
20
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
and efficient distribution coupled with reduced price for consumers is what
made Shree cement ltd the hallmark of FMCG sector. In this paper, the urge
for a retail industry to go for ways to improvise and maintain its supply chain
along with suggested ways for the same are discussed.
Challenges in Retail
The following are the key areas that may pose a threat to those retail
companies that ignore the impacts of giving less importance to manage their
demand and supply: -
Forecasting and Inventory Management for JIT replenishments of
products.
Peak Season Demand Handling.
Order Management in case of retailers with multiple outlets.
Warehouse Management in case of multiple outlets.
Introducing new products.
Handling variety of items.
Need for Managing Supply Chain
A Supply Chain can be considered as the set of entities that collectively
manufactures a product and sells it to an end-point. (Stern et al, 2001, p.513).
To enhance service through time based delivery and make-to-order a retail
industry should look at ways of building a relationship with suppliers through
enhanced Supply Chain Management. Leveraging information as a service
can enable staff to respond quickly to market opportunities and gain new
insight from existing data.
This calls for a system that efficiently tracks information and which is put to
use strategically. "There is tremendous competition in the retail space,"
explains Ken Dschankilic, Enterprise Architect, Canadian Tire Corporation.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
21
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
"To keep our edge, we must continuously improve our processes and
leverage our core capabilities in new ways. To do this, we need a solid
foundation that provides accurate information wherever and whenever it’s
neede.
The area that has been highlighted would form part of our interest and the
information that need to flow between the whole-saler and the retailer, and the
information between the consumer and the retailer are of importance. The
strategies proposed mainly will deal with how to effectively handle the
available information and utilize them for the enhanced service at customer
level specific to retail industry.
There are three broad categories of distribution channel that are generally
used by cosmetic companies.
1. Distributor or Dealer network.
2. Franchisee.
3. Stand alone stores.
A diagrammatic representation of the distribution channel is as shown below: -
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
22
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Dealer or distributor network channel is the most widely used distribution
channel used by the cosmetic companies. In this distribution channel, the
manufacturer appoints a distributor who is given a certain area in which he will
operate. The distributor purchases goods from the manufacturer. He then
dispatches his salesmen to various retail outlets like malls, departmental
stores, groceries, etc to take order and supply the goods to the outlets.
Companies like Philips , Energetic and Surya use this distribution channel.
The common trends used in the industry regarding the setup of a distribution
channel are as follows: -
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
23
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Trends of the industry
Shree Cement BIRLA CEMENT
Distributor Margin 6% 8%
Retailer Margin 15% 20%
Cash Discount 1-2% NO
Credit Period 15 Days 15 Days
Franchisee Status Performance based Performance based
Replacement 100% replacement is done 100% replacement is done
Standalone stores are another type of distribution channel that is used by
various organizations. In this type, companies open up a retail space where
the entire store is dedicated to their own products. Birla, Lafarge and Shree
Cement.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
24
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH OBJECTIVE
To study Supply chain management concepts and practices in
industrial scenarios.
To carry out supply chain opportunity analysis with particular reference
to Shree cement
To Benchmark the Implementation Of Supply Chain Management
Techniques In Shree Cement
To study how company work out for its lead time, utilization of the
transport effectively and efficiently.
Do the factor analysis through the primary data analysis
iv) Cement is extremely heavy, so that transportation must be
optimized through network
v) Demand is normally stable, with seasonal trends but very few
spikes
vi) Multiple parties in the supply chain make a simple flow more difficult
HYPOTHESIS
H1: Supply chain became more efficient if the product available to the store.
H2: How to develop channel to create more store to sell the product.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
PRIMARY DATA: I will collect the primary data though the questionnaire which is close and open ended both.
SECONDARY DATA: Internet, Book and Journal.
Tool Used: Bar Graph, Pie Diagram
Sampling Method: Random Sampling chosen by the gathering of data
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
25
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Sample Size: 100 Dealers + customer
SCOPE OF THE WORK
Shree Cement Ltd. is an energy conscious & environment friendly business
organization. Having Nine Directors on its board under the chairmanship
Shri.B.G. Bangur, the policy decisions are taken under the guidance of Shri.
H.M. Bangur, Managing Director. Shri. M.K.Singhi, Executive Director of the
Company, is looking after all day-to-day affairs. The company is managed by
well qualified professionals with broad vision who are committed to maintain
high standards of quality & leadership to serve the customers to their fullest
satisfaction. The board consists of eminent persons with considerable
professional expertise in industry and field such as banking, law, marketing &
finance & general management.
JUSTIFICATION OF THE CHOOSING TOPIC
It is one way in which I would be able to understand the supply chain wherein
the goods are being delivered from the company to the end consumers, also I
would be able to help the company with my project report, which could
become a milestone in my career path.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
26
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
LITERATURE REVIEW
Logistics is about moving materials, information and funds from one business
to another or from a business to the consumer. It is a vital part of the business
economic system and is a major global economic activity. In fact 10-15 per
cent of product costs are logistics related. Worldwide, logistics constitutes
about $2 trillion a year. For any country, the logistics cost is estimated
between 9 and 20 per cent of its GDP. Every company dreams of achieving
the seven R's - delivering the right product in the right quantity and the right
condition, at the right place, at the right time, for the right customer at the right
cost. Effective logistics management alone can make this possible.
Logistics is one of the oldest and also the newest activities of business
management. It involves combining diverse functions and service providers
who may be culturally and objectively different. In the past, quality of products
and services was the key differentiating factor for companies operating in the
same market. In due course, quality and low cost became the winning
combination. Today, responsiveness to the customers' needs is the
determining factor. An enterprise that caters instantly to the needs of the
customer is the winner. Integrated logistics can serve as a potent tool for
success in today's competitive business environment.
Logistics is an organized process of managing the flow of merchandise from
the source of supply - the vendor, wholesaler or distributor - through internal
processing functions like warehousing and transportation, until the
merchandise is sold and delivered to the end customer. Logistics
management aims to reduce inventory-holding costs and improve profits,
while enhancing customer satisfaction. Anything can be ordered online, but
receiving a tangible product is impossible. The difference between e-business
success and failure lies in a company's ability to manage the logistics.
History of Logistics
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
27
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
The Greeks defined logistics as "the science of correct reasoning by means of
mathematics". The first modern use of the term was in the military to identify
the process of planning and coordinating the movement of army and weapon
support systems. Good logistics brings out the ability to move faster and
accurately to the battlefront. “If one applies the same to the business
organisation, it is one's ability to reach the product to the consumer at the right
time, right place, right quantity and at the lowest cost.” On similar lines, supply
chain management will mean the network of organisations involved in the
process by which goods are moved from producer to consumer and the
counter flow of information, to manage the supply chain as a single entity.
A prominent application of logistics was in World War II where weapon
movements were coordinated to ensure success. A recent instance of
massive logistics initiatives is in the Gulf war. With increasing competition in
the market place, managements started focusing on customer services in the
early 1950s in developed markets such as Europe and the U.S. In late 1960s
some of the logistics concepts were tested. Following the oil crisis of the
1970s and the concept of just in time in manufacturing customer-servicing
standards were given more importance and new integrated logistics models
and solutions were born. The emergence of organized distribution system by
department stores and super fast courier service organisations gave a boost
to logistics concepts and strategies. Today all businesses are looking for
seamless transaction systems to co-ordinate their information and material
requirements along the value chain. At the micro level any manufacturing and
marketing company spends 5 - 35 per cent of sales on logistics. The major
cost components are transportation, warehousing and inventory carrying cost.
Improvements in logistics get reflected in a reduction in inventory levels,
shorter delivery schedules, and improved servicing standards with significant
savings in total costs.
Logistics Management Process
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
28
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Michael Porter in his famous book "Competitive Advantage'' has spoken of the
value chain approach and emphasized logistics as one of the most important
tools for competitive advantage.
The various processes and elements that are part of logistics as a discipline
are:
Inbound logistics: Purchasing, Inbound transportation, Inventory
Management.
Manufacturing: Production planning systems, Machine scheduling system.
Outbound logistics: Order booking process, Distribution management,
outbound transportation, and Warehouse management systems.
As customers started demanding improved servicing standards, fast cycle
time has become the key factor for business success, whether it is custom
made tailoring service in Hong Kong or development of a new car in Detroit.
Before delving deep into logistics, a look at the current business scene will be
great help.
Scenario of Logistics in India
At present, companies specialising in logistics operations in India use
traditional technologies and cater to stand alone services like transportation,
warehousing, clearing and forwarding. There is tremendous scope to upgrade
the technology, integrate the entire supply chain, improve productivity levels
and bring down operating costs. Any technology that can improve productivity
in transportation operations will be a great boom to the economy both directly
and indirectly with opportunities for 10-12 per cent reduction in costs. Besides
the savings on downstream users of transport will be much higher and the
cost multiplier effect on the economy will be reduced to that extent.
Given the emerging business and technological trends there are possibilities
for adoption of logistics solutions specifically designed for India. In addition,
there is a requirement for an integrated strategy towards developing logistics
and its related IT infrastructure and also enhancing its industry base.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
29
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
In recognition of the growing need for technology-enabled solutions in
logistics in India and abroad, many companies such as eLogistics are taking
shape. In fact, there are a dozen multinational logistics companies such as
Exel, Bax Global and Menlo which have started operations in India during the
last few years.
Today logistics management in India has become complex with about ten
million related outlets to cater to the needs of 1000 million people.
The logistics market in India is estimated to be Rs. 260,000 crores and
constitutes 13 per cent of the GDP. It is much higher than for the U.S. but
lower when compared to countries like China and Korea.
A reduction in logistics costs by one percentage point will mean a saving of
$4.8 billion or Rs. 21,600 crores annually. Besides significant benefits can be
reaped through the multiplier effect of better logistics on all economic sectors.
About Customer Service
According to LaLonde and Zinszer have researched various ways that
customer service can be viewed: 1) as an activity, 2) in terms of performance
levels, and 3) as a philosophy of management. Viewing customer service in
terms of performance levels has relevancy providing it can accurately
measured. The notion of customer service as a philosophy of management
exemplifies the importance of customer-focused marketing. All three
dimensions are important to understand what is involved in successful
customer service.
A broad definition of customer service should embody elements from all three
perspectives. LaLonde and his associates offer the following definition:
“Customer services are a process for providing significant value-added
benefits to the supply chain in cost-effective way.” This definition illustrates
the trend to think of customer service as a process-focused orientation that
includes supply chain management concepts.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
30
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
It is clear that excellent customer service performance seems to add value for
all members of the supply chain. Thus, a customer service program must
identify and prioritize all activities important to accomplish operating
objectives. A customer service program also needs to incorporate measures
for evaluating performance. Performance needs to be measured in terms of
goal attainment and relevancy. The critical question in planning a customer
service strategy remains, does the cost associated with achieving the
specified service goals represent a sound investment and, if so, for what
customers? Finally, it is possible to offer key customers something more than
high-levels basic service. Extra service beyond the basics is typically referred
to as value- added. Value-added services, by definition, are unique to specific
customers and represent extensions over and above a firm’s basic service
program.
The three fundamental dimensions of customer service were: -
Availability.
Performance.
Reliability.
About Logistics & Customer Service
Logistics contributes to an organization’s success by providing customers with
timely and accurate product delivery. The key question is who is the
customer? For logistics, the customer is any delivery destination. Typical
destination range from consumers’ homes to retail and wholesale businesses
to the receiving docks of a firm’s manufacturing plants and warehouses. In
some cases the customer is a different organization or individual who is taking
ownership of the product or service being delivered. In many other situations
the customer is different facility of the same firm or a business partner at
some other location in the supply chain. Regardless of the motivation and
delivery purpose, the customer being serviced is the focal point and driving
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
31
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
force in establishing logistical performance requirements. It is important to
fully understand customer service deliverables when establishing logistical
strategies.
Whereas logistics is not capability that contributes to overall success, it is
fundamental to servicing customers. In a typical marketing situation, the
desired customer service performance changes over time. To plan marketing
strategy in a dynamic will serve to illustrate how logistical customer service
requirement related to a specific product/segment situation will change over
time. The product life cycle structure offers a useful framework for viewing the
dynamics associated with customer service requirements planning.
In terms of overall logistical performance, the basic customer service platform
or program should be the level of support provided to all customers.
Transportation is the most visible of all functions of logistics and high
contributor to logistics cost. We can see trucks, containers and
wagonloads of material being moved from place to place as an activity
directly associated with trade and business. We should also appreciate
that this is an activity that adds highest amount of cost to the activity of
making inputs and outputs available to consumers. Transportation
function moves the products to meet customer expectations at
minimum cost.
Functions of Transportation
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
32
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Product movement:-
What is moved?
Raw Material, Semi Finished items, WIP, Finished goods, packaging material,
rejected material - movement is required up or down the supply chain. How is
this done? What Resources are used?
Resources used by transportation:
A. Temporal - product is locked up during transit, hence inaccessible. We
have to spend a positive amount of time in transporting the material. Time is a
resource [temporal resource] that is expended in transportation. During the
time the product is locked up costs are incurred in proportion to the time
B. Financial - several cost elements like administration costs, salaries,
maintenance costs are expended. Loss on account of product loss and
damage also needs to be accounted for. Fuel consumed is a big cost in
transportation
C. Environmental – this activity is a fuel guzzler, eats up natural fuels like oil,
directly and indirectly. - 67% of all domestic fuel usage in the US is by
transportation activity.
Creates congestion, air pollution and noise pollution. Environmental cost is
tangible and substantially intangible. As transportation utilizes temporal,
financial and environmental resources items must be moved only when
product value is enhanced
Product Storage:-
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
33
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Temporary storage in stationary vehicles or Vehicles kept moving on a
circuitous route - Product storage is expensive in a transport vehicle. But
some times keeping overall cost in mind this is adopted.
A. When unloading and loading is more expensive than storage
B. When storage space is limited. [Situation when inventory levels are very
high]
Principles of Transportation
There are two fundamental principles guiding transportation management and
operations. They are economy of scale and economy of distance.
Economy of scale:-
It refers to the characteristic that transportation cost per unit of weight
decreases when the size of the shipment increases. It is common knowledge
that larger the capacity of the transport vehicle more goods can be
transported at a time which will decrease the cost per unit of transport. If
smaller is the capacity of the transport vehicle then to transport a large
amount of goods, more trips will have to be made which will increase the cost
per unit of transport.
Example: Rail or water transport is less expensive in case of bulk transport
than smaller capacity vehicles like motor or air. A transportation economy of
scale exists because fixed expenses such as administrative costs, invoicing
costs, equipment costs associated with moving goods and materials get
spread over the entire weight of the load. This will help to decrease cost per
unit of the goods transported.
Example: Suppose the cost to administer a shipment is Rs. 10.00. Then for a
10 kgs. shipment the cost of transporting per unit of the product becomes
Re.1.00, while for a 1,000 Kgs shipment the cost of transporting per unit of the
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
34
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
product Re.0.01. Thus it can be said that an economy of scale exists for the
1000 kgs shipment.
Economy of distance:-
It refers to the characteristic that transportation cost per unit of distance
decreases as distance increases. Transportation economy of distance is also
referred to as a tapering principle since rates or charges taper (decrease) with
distance. The rationale of economies of distance is similar to that for
economies of scale. Longer distances allow the fixed expenses to be spread
over more miles, resulting in lower overall per mile charge. These principles
are important considerations when evaluating alternative transportation
strategies or operating practices. The objective is to maximize the size of the
load and the distance that is shipped while still meeting customer service
expectations.
Example: local trains in Mumbai are of three types’ fast locals, semi-fast
locals and slow locals. Traveling through fast local saves times as it does not
halt at every station, but in case of slow trains it halts at every station which
consumes time more than the fast trains or the semi-fast trains.
Participants in Transportation Decisions
Normal commercial transaction has limited number of parties to the business
decision. They are seller, buyer and directly or indirectly government. But a
transportation decision has number of parties to the decision. These parties
have very important roles to play in transportation environment. Parties to a
transportation decision are those who have a stake in the transportation. They
are
1. Shipper: shipper is a party who wants to transport the goods to his
customer in a business transaction
2. Consignee is the party to whom the goods are sent
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
35
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
3. Carrier is the service provider who carries the consignment from shipper to
consignee.
4. Government has a role to play as they are keenly interested in
transportation and have a stake in it. Transportation makes business
happen which is fundamental to the economy of any society. Economic
prosperity to the society is the objective of the government of the day.
Government also collects tax on the transaction. Government represents
general public whose interest they have to protect.
5. General public is another party who has a large stake in the transaction
involving transportation. Public want goods produced at different parts of
not only country but also world. Their demand cannot be met without
transportation.
Roles and perspective of each party
Shipper and consignee:-
Predictable and minimum transit time, minimum cost, minimum taxation,
specified pick up and delivery times, zero loss and damage, timely exchange
of information and invoicing. These are the needs of the above parties. They
look at transportation from this angle. They are the basic elements of
transportation. Business between them initiates the need for transportation
Carrier:-
What do carrier wants? Revenue maximization and cost [labor, fuel and
vehicle costs, taxation] minimization. Flexibility in pick up and delivery times to
consolidate movement. Carrier facilitates the business between shipper and
consignee. He gets paid for his service. He adds value to the supply chain by
moving the material from supplier to the customer. Carriers’ strike in our
country is a repetitive phenomenon to protest against role of government.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
36
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Government:-
Government while playing their role exercise control on all the players. They
want the business to flourish, at the same time benefits to reach uniformly all
over the country. They also have to provide the necessary infrastructure to
support transportation. It is said that one of the causes that expedited the
break up of Soviet Union was the weak infrastructure on account of which
products could not be transported to far-flung parts of the country. Hunger
deaths in India in spite of self-sufficiency in food production are examples to
illustrate the interest of the government. Government controls carrier rates
and licenses. Government owned carrier service is probably the cheapest
option for transportation available to business. Government supports
transportation by providing a network of roads, Airports and ATC, Ports and
Harbors. Government wants taxes to support above activities in national
interest. Ultimately the consumer, general public, has to bear the burden of
tax.
Public:-
Public as consumers trigger transportation activity by demanding products
and services of high quality from all over the world at minimum cost. They
have concern for safety as accidents of various kind have been a bye product
of transportation. Degradation of the environment is another threat about
which public are concerned as transportation is at the root cause of many
such concerns. Eg. Degradation of atmosphere and water, rise of noise
levels, oil spills due tankers carrying cargo of crude oil. When these parties
with separate and distinct interests interact transportation environment is
created. Conflict of interests raises issues that interrupt smooth transport of
goods in the country. Government as the main arbiter steps in to iron out
these differences in the interests of business.
Modes of Transport
Transportation modes are an essential component of transport systems since
they are the means by which mobility is supported. Geographers consider a
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
37
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
wide range of modes that may be grouped into three broad categories based
on the medium they exploit: land, water and air. Each mode has its own
requirements and features, and is adapted to serve the specific demands of
freight and passenger traffic. This gives rise to marked differences in the ways
the modes are deployed and utilized in different parts of the world. Recently,
there is a trend towards integrating the modes through intermodality and
linking the modes ever more closely into production and distribution activities.
At the same time, however, passenger and freight activity is becoming
increasingly separated across most modes.
Types of Transport
The basic modes of transportation are rail, highway, water, pipeline and air.
Rail:-
India has amongst the largest railway network in the world. Every city, town,
village has a rail connection. Through railways very large volumes of goods
can be transported economically over long distances to remote places in the
country. But railways in general incur high fixed costs because of expensive
equipment (i.e. railways must maintain their own rail track meant exclusively
for them) switching yards and terminals. However the railways experience
relatively low variable operating costs. Railways help to transport raw
materials from extractive industries which are located at considerable
distances. Besides this railways also transport massive amount of steel,
automobiles, war equipment, across the country.
Rail roads basically concentrate on the container traffic and are becoming
more responsive of the customer needs, emphasizing bulk industries and
heavy manufacturing. They have expanded their intermodal operations
through alliances and motor carrier ownership. Railroads are even
concentrating on development of special equipment. There are unit trains
which are entire train carrying the same commodity, which are bulk products
such as coal or grain. Unit trains are faster, less expensive to operate and
quick as it can bypass rail yarts and go direct to the product's destination.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
38
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
There are also various different types, such. as articulated cars for extended
Rail chassis, double stack railcars, have 2 levels of containers, thereby
doubling the capacity of each car. It also reduces chances of damage
because of their design. These technologies are being applied by railroads to
reduce weight, increase carrying capacity, and facilitate interchange. The
above examples show the attempts being made by the railways to retain and
improve their share of overall transportation market.
Road Transport:-
Road transport forms an essential part of any transport activity, whether rail,
sea or air. It is essential as a supplementary and complementary mode of
transport to complete movement by other modes of transport. Eg. From one
terminal i.e. the railway station the goods have to be carried to the destination
like an area by road.
Highway transportation has increased rapidly since the end of World War II.
This is because Motor carrier industry results from' door-to-door operating
flexibility and speed of intercity movement. They are even flexible because
they can operate on each and every kind of roadways. In comparison to
railroads, motor carriers have relatively small fixed investments in terminal
facilities and operate on publicly maintained highways. Although the cost of
license fees, user fees, and tolls are considerable, these expenses are
directly related to the number of over-the-road units and miles operated.
The variable cost per mile for motor carriers is high because a separate power
unit and driver are required for each trailer or combination of tandem trailers.
Labor requirements are also high because of driver safety restrictions and the
need for substantial dock labor. Motor carriers are best suited to handle small
shipments moving short distances. The characteristics of motor carriers favor
manufacturing and distributive trades, short distances, and high-value
products. Motor carriers have made significant inroads into rail traffic for
medium and light manufacturing. This is also because of delivery flexibility,
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
39
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
that they have captured a major chunk of the market. In short, the prospect for
maintaining a stable market share in highway transport remains bright.
This industry even has a few problems, and one of the primary difficulties
relate to increasing cost to replace equipment, maintenance, driver wages,
and platform and dock wages. Although accelerating, labor rates influence all
modes of transport; motor carriers are more labor-intensive, which causes
higher wages to be a major concern. One more threat for hire-motor carrier
industry is over-the-road transportation by shipper-owned trucks or by
specialized carriers under contract to perform transport services for shippers.
Since 1980, the industry segments have become more definitive since
deregulation, and include truckload (TL), less than truckload (LTL), and
specialty carriers. TL segment includes loads over 15,000 pounds that
generally do not require intermediate stops for consolidation. LTL segment of
the industry loads less than 15,000 pounds that generally requires stops at
intermediate terminals for consolidation. Because of terminal costs and
relatively higher marketing expenses, LTL experiences a higher percentage of
fixed costs then TL.
These characteristics have caused extensive industry consolidation, since
deregulation has resulted in small number of relatively large carriers
worldwide.
Specialty carriers include package haulers such as Federal Express and
United Parcel Service. These firms focus on specific requirements of the
market or product. It is quite apparent that highway transportation will
continue to function as the backbone of logistical operations for the
foreseeable future.
In short Road transport offers certain advantages like
Door to door service to
customers which neither rail nor neither sea nor air transport can offer.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
40
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
On per unit basis, the
cost of making a road is 1/6th that of laying a railway line.
Capital investment in
case of railways is much less then railways designed to carry equivalent
quantum of traffic.
Road transport
provides employment to six million persons (two million direct and four
million indirect)
Road transport faces a number of problems. This is evident from the
following facts:
T
There is an occasional storage of diesel fuel in the country.
V
vehicle availability in the country has been problematic. With the recent entry
of a number of manufacturers, the situation has improved to some extent.
T
The cost of components and accessories, such as tyres and batteries, has
escalated tremendously. The Octroi and police check posts are to many,
resulting in heavy detention to road vehicles.
T
The present Motor Vehicle Act regulating the issue of licenses and permits
and movement of vehicles is very restrictive. It was decades ago to control
and regulate traffic. The current requirements of traffic are for development.
There are persistent demands from various transport associations for
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
41
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
suitable amendments of the Motor Vehicle act. But they do not seem to
receive due attention.
C
Conditions on Indian road are very bad and hazardous. They tend to reduce
speed of vehicles, which leads to wastage of natural transport capacity.
R
oadside maintenance and service facilities have not developed though found
necessary.
T
he system of national, zonal and state permits restricts free growth of road
transport but the system has to be followed.
Water transport: - _
One of the oldest modes of transportation is water. In terms of time factor,
they may be slow. But, they can carry more shipment, at reduced cost over
longer distance. Water transport could be of inland type or oceanic transport.
Inland water transport
Inland water transport is used mainly for transport; within a country. In our
country Inland water transport through rivers and canals is quite popular
because of the low cost and bulk transport. But here, the inland water
transport system heavily depends upon the rain and in many places on the
tides. So, in our country, we cannot guarantee the functioning of inland water
throughout the year at the same efficiency.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
42
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Oceanic Transport
Oceans act as huge waterways for transport of goods form one country to
another. Oceanic transportation includes import and export of crude and bulky
commodities like materials which are removed from mines, cement, chemical,
crude oil, iron ore, coal, chemicals like sulphur, crude petroleum, and selected
agricultural products, etc.
The main advantages of transport by water are the cost and capability of the
operation. The capability of water to carry large tonnage at low variable costs
-makes it in demand. When a company desire low freight rates and the speed
and the time of transport are secondary, it has the option of selecting water as
a mode of transport.
The main disadvantage of water transport is the limited range of operation
and speed. Unless the origin and destination are adjacent; supplement haul
by rail or truck is required. Water transport isn't all that flexible. Labour
restrictions on loading and unloading at docks create operational problems
and tend to reduce the potential range of available traffic. Also, a highly
competitive situation has developed between railroads and inland water
carriers in areas where parallel routes exist
Air Transport:-
Air transport though new as compared to other modes of transportation, has
gained large popularity in transporting various commodities. The basic
advantage of Air transport is its high speed. By air, the time required may be
just a few hours, which may be days by other modes of transport. However
this being a major advantage,
Air transport also has various disadvantages. These are:
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
43
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Air transport is a costly
affair.
Air transport is limited
by 'lift capacity' i.e. goods upto certain load (weight) can be transported by
aircrafts.
Air freight variable cost
is very high due to fuel, maintenance and labour intensity of both in flight and
ground crew. The fixed cost of air transport is low as compared to rails, water
and pipeline. In fact, air transport ranks second only to highway with respect
to low fixed cost. Airways and airports are maintained by public funds and
terminals 'are by local communities. The fixed costs of airfreight are
associated with aircraft purchase and the requirement for specialized handling
systems and cargo containers. But the air freight variable cost is extremely
high as a result of fuel, maintenance, and labour intensity of both in-flight and
ground crews.
Even though it has all these disadvantages, high speed of air transport often
helps in compensating its other disadvantages. No particular commodity
dominates the freight carried by air transport. E.g. big courier companies such
as DHL, Fed Ex have their own air crafts to transport couriers between
different countries within a short time.
Other Modes of Transport:-
Other nodes of transportation includes the freight forwarder who accepts
small shipments and charge less carload (or less truck load or plane load)
rates and consolidates the small shipments into carload truckload, or
planeload tots, which are then sent by the lower quantity rates. Frequently,
the freight forwarder acts as a traffic department for small companies, which
usually ship in less carload lots. Shippers' cooperatives offer much the same
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
44
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
services as the forwarder in consolidating small shipments into larger ones,
except that the profits of the business are returned to the members of the
cooperative. Small packages can also be sent via speed post, and can use
some of the, expedited delivery services the Indian Post System now offers.
Transport Costing
Following are the essential elements of transportation to be taken into
account:
Transport Mode:-
The most critical decision is the "selection of appropriate mode of transport.
This fixes two basic elements of distribution function:-
a) Transit time or time lapse between production and sale;
b) Level of transportation costs.
There is an inverse relationship between transit time and transport cost; the
lower the transit time, the higher the transport cost. However, a decision that
takes into account only one cost factor cannot be justified. An evaluation of
the effect of transit time on other costs must also be considered. Unsold
production represents a high cost, and the longer the transit time, the higher
the level of unsold production.
Inventory Costs:-
A first class service to clients often requires immediate delivery and, hence
a higher level of inventory at the market centre. Economy, on the other hand,
calls for minimum inventory. The level of output held in stock is dictated by:-
a) Transit time: If the time lapse between production and sale is longer, the
level of inventory becomes higher.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
45
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
b) Sales pattern : If the pattern of sales is unpredictable, higher inventory
levels are caused.
c) Production pattern: If the production pattern is erratic (unpredictable),
higher (inventory levels have to be maintained to prevent stock outs.
Assuming that the sales and production patterns are largely fixed, the
important variable, which can influence stock, levels in transit time. As transit
time is reduced, the level of static (Non moving) stock can be reduced with
accompanying stock reduction.
Transit Capital:-
Capital can be released by changing the proportion" of the total output in
transit. This can be done by adjusting the transit time. As transit time is
reduced, the quantity of goods in transit can be decreased with an associated
reduction in transit inventory costs. By realizing the capital cost of transit
inventory and goods in transit, capital commitments can be reduced, and
more capital can be available for other purposes.
Obsolescence:-
When a slow or erratic mode of transport is employed, a higher level of
inventory is necessary to ensure continuous, prompt delivery to 'the customer.
However, when designs change rapidly, obsolescence reduces the market
value of the products in store. Rapid advances in technology bring about
swifter technical obsolescence. Any goods in the pipeline realize a lower
figure when new models are introduced by a company or its competitors. Air
distribution can overcome this problem, and the effect of such obsolescence
can be minimized.
Packaging:-
The nature of packaging of a products often determined by the mode of its
transport. E.g. Because of the dry conditions of carriage, short transit times
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
46
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
and minimum handling, air cargo generally requires much less packaging than
other forms of long distance transport. Goods dispatched by air may require
only a dust cover or even no cover at all. In some cases, savings on the
packaging of sophisticated products may more than pay for the actual
transport charges. Less packaging may lead to other advantages too. These
include lower unpacking costs and lower chargeable weight for freight.
Insurance:-
Insurance risks are based on transit time as well as the possibility of damages
en-route. With faster transit times, skillful handling, substantial reduction in
damage and greater security in transit, insurance premiums tend to fall
substantially.
Breakages:-
Cost of breakages is an important factor in any cost benefit analysis.
Therefore, only that mode of transport must be selected which substantially
reduces real damage in transit. This calls for a selection of the routes which
are more direct and which avoid transshipment, Handling equipment must
also be more sophisticated. Containers can be used by shippers for door-to-
door transportation, thereby avoiding all handling of goods by the carrier.
Pilferage:-
Many expensive administrative problems associated with breakages also
apply to pilferage.
Deterioration:-
In many surface, cargos Deterioration may be avoided only by complicated
and expensive packing to counteract mechanical shock, exposure to weather
or unfavorable temperature etc. Some cannot be stored at all, except at great
expense and others deteriorate slowly.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
47
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Deterioration can be costly in terms of packing stock losses and expensive
conditioning in store. It can only shut the door on many distant markets. A
high speed of transport and the frequency of services can overcome many of
these problems.
Transport Costs:-
Transport can be divided into 3 phases:
(i) Delivery to docks airport or railway station.
(ii) Transport from one terminal to another.
(iii) Delivery from the terminal to the consignee's place.
Miscellaneous costs:-
Local taxes, octroi, toll taxes etc during transport.
Customer Service Costs:-
Shortage of product when demanded by the customer leads to customer
dissatisfaction and thereby loss of sale for the company. So customer service
should be raised to be able to meet customer expectations. When we try to
raise customer service level costs are incurred conventionally, companies
stockpile to raise service level But the current thinking is to reduce
response time to customer need rather than increase the stock as costs of
inventory are well understood.
Freight rate structure
Freight rates are transportation rates charged by carriers for shipping the
goods to the consignee’s premises. These rates are structured round some
principles. Some of the principles are commercial nature and some of them
are structured by the state.
Principle of freight rates
Should cover actual cost of transportation:-
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
48
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Fundamental principle is that the rate should cover the cost without fail.
Factors influencing cost of transportation
A. Fixed costs:
• Interest on capital invested in the fleet
• Depreciation
• Insurance premium
• Administrative overheads and expenses on fixed facilities
B. Semi fixed costs:
• Salaries of the staff
• Miscellaneous maintenance expenses directly related to running of the
transport vehicle.
C. Variable costs:
• Cost of fuel and lubricants
• Maintenance directly attributable to a particular trip. Damage to the vehicle
and also the cargo. E.g. Hilly roads, bad roads, war effected sea routes
Vehicle utilization:-
Carrier likes to gain maximum mileage out of his vehicle. If vehicle is idle it is
a big loss to the carrier organization. Hence the carrier would like to run his
vehicle at top speed to cover max. Distance at min time. While structuring the
rates carrier would like to charge more if opportunity for maximum utilization is
limited.
Quote higher rates if following are not conducive to the above
Road conditions are
bad. Hence vehicle can not be driven fast.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
49
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Terminal detentions
[congestion, formalities, for loading unloading (handling) etc.]: a delay at the
terminal brings down vehicle utilization as the vehicle is idling. If the
destination is known for this kind of delays carrier would charge higher rates.
Obtaining a return load
[market factors]. If the destination does not offer opportunity for a return load
carrier asks for a higher rate as would not be able to utilize his vehicle during
return trip. Normally if the destination is a production center one would always
find return trip to consumption center. But the other way round probability of
return load is very low.
Nature of goods,
hazardous, corrosive [liability, insurance]. Such goods are detrimental to the
safety of the transport vehicle and operating staff. Hence rates are high when
such goods are shipped.
Density, consignment
light by weight: when the consignment is light by weight the truck becomes full
without full load being loaded. Hence the carrier doesn’t get paid for the full
load. So he hikes his rates when the consignment is light.
Storability, shape and
size of the product. When the load has an odd shape speed of the vehicle is
reduced to accommodate the center of gravity. This brings down the utilization
apart from being risky.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
50
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Traffic Bearing Capacity:-
Transportation adds value by making the product available to the customer.
But the cost incurred by the shipper while transporting should not outweigh
the value added. The carrier structures rates keeping this principle in mind.
Public use:-
State introduces the principle that the transportation of essential commodities
should be done at a lower rate.
Government Policy:-
Freight rates are controlled by the state for promotion of certain type of trade
and development of certain type of industry as per the industrial policy
prevalent at that time. Freight rates are hiked or depressed by state the to
meet the objectives of the policy.
Profit:-
Freight rate should cover costs of operation, capital investment and margin
for reasonable return on investment. It should also compensate
entrepreneurial time and efforts.
Business should generate enough funds to provide for future development of
business. The freight is expected to generate enough money to cover all
these requirements.
Transport infrastructure
Infrastructure is the main facilitator for any activity to take place. For
transportation to take place a strong infrastructure is primary. If this
infrastructure is inadequate transportation gets slowed down resulting into a
major obstacle in the growth of trade and business in that area.
Elements of transportation infrastructure
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
51
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
• Terminal facilities - well maintained loading unloading facilities, space
for movement of vehicles, platforms, railway yards
• Vehicles- trucks, ships or wagons depending on the mode. Their size,
shape & speed
• Right of way- passage to move on. Rails, roads, airways, limitations on
speed, weight, height etc. If we use this particular passage.
• Prime movers – the powerhouses moving the vehicle of transport
shortage of which seriously affect transportation. Shortage of good
locomotives impairs the utility of railway as a mode of transport.
Carrier organizations – are the transportation service providers in
business. Transportation is their core business. Good service provides a
vital fillip to business and trade. Railways, roadways, airlines, shipping
lines are service providers.
FINDING AND ANALYSIS
r 1. What type of Business you deal in
A. Retail B. Wholesaler C. Both
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
52
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Respondent
Retail 45
Wholesaler 36
Both 19
As per the procedure of primary data i have collected the data through the
structured questionnaire from Dealer, Wholesaler who are doing both of them
because those are people who let understand better the product offerings and
there classification. 36% of the people suggested are come from wholesaler
background although 45% data i have collected from the retailers. ‘
2. What All Flooring Brands do you Deal in ?
Company Brand Type of Dealership
Years of
Association
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
53
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
Shree
Cement
Cement
Authorized Dealers 10 Years
ACC Cement Authorized Dealers 6 Years
Lafarge Cement Dealers cum Retailers 2 Years
Birla Cement Dealers cum Retailers 3 years
JK lakshmi Cement Dealers cum Retailers 2 Years
As per the study reflects that most of the other company who is providing
Cement to the Indian customer are having Dealers and Retailers both in the
same company. Other companies like ACC, Shree cement are providing all
the cement and other solution to their authorized dealers of the company.
3. Does customer has some preference regarding any brand?
If yes name the brand in order of the preference.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
54
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
- Customer does not have any such brand preference who are first time
buyer and new to the market but second time purchaser has different
brand choice i.e.
- JK Laxmi
- Shree
If no,
i) Name the brand that you recommend to them:
- For some customer it is really new market so the prefer brand suggest by
the dealers is
ACC
JK Laxmi
Shree
4) On what basis Recommendation given to this brand.
A. Quality
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
55
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
B. Price
C. Users
D. Brand name
E. Any others.
A. Quality 10
B. Price 33
C. Users 38
D. Brand name 20
E. Any others. 5
As per the recommendation given by the dealers on the various basis 36% of
the dealers give the recommendation on the users basis for example
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
56
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
customers choice and uses. 31% of the dealers said they recommended
product on the Price basis because customer are very price sensitive.
5. In the last two years do you have some changes in dealership of any
brand?
A. Yes
B. NO
Yes 58
No 42
As per the study 58% of the dealers suggested there were no changes they
found in last two years in the dealership at the same time 42% of the dealers
said yes they have some sense of changes in this industry as well.
6. If yes Rate the reason in order of importance (1 for first importance)
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
57
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
A. Quality B. Company support
C. Customer Demand D. Price
E. Profit F. Supply
G. Any others.
Very
Important Important
Not
known
Less
Important
Least
Important
A. Quality 43 39 16 1 1
B. Company
support 32 34 13 12 9
C. Customer
Demand 22 29 16 20 13
D. Price 32 12 17 23 16
E. Profit 28 34 9 8 21
F. Supply 12 36 13 23 16
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
58
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
As per the study suggested that the most important factor which could be the
changes of dealership is the company supply of the product , price could be
the one reason as well because this is scattered market and the people are
using those product which comes in the budget. As customer awareness is
grown the quality of the product is the one of most important factor to decide
about the dealership and its impacted most of time during the data collection
process.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
59
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
7. In last two years any of the brands has increased its value in terms of
customer preference of selling volume, if yes rate the factors in scale of 1 to 5
where 1 stands for the Most Important factors.
Shree ACC
Birla
Cement Lafarge JK Laxmi
Improvement of
Quality 22 28 45 20 1
Company
Support 16 22 17 12 17
Price 28 24 16 11 12
New Policy 22 17 13 45 14
Any other 12 9 9 12 56
As per the survey result suggested that in the pricing factor there are some
major changes done by the Shree although all five factor as almost in the
equilibrium side of the company so it can be said that company has fair kind
of understanding of the Indian market and the Shree is not only working
towards the better price service but for also the other factors.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
60
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
8. Why you buy your Shree Cement from a particular company or Distributor?
A. Credit Facility B. Convenience
C. Availability D. Good Discounts.
E. After Sales Service F. Brand Name
A. Credit Facility 22
B. Convenience 16
C. Availability 12
D. Good Discounts. 22
E. After Sales Service 14
F. Brand Name 14
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
61
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
As per the study suggested that it depends upon all the factors equality when
it comes to the Shree Cement buying customer are looking for the Good
discount (22%) , because they are price sensitive , the Credit facility is also
impacting lot (22%) because if the real estate customer purchasing in bulk
they prefer to pay after some time. Brand name is also required as the Indian
customer are very particular about the brand name as these days.
9. Do you sell Shree Cement on Credit?
A. Yes B. No
Yes 98
No 2
As per the study reveals that people are selling the Shree Cement in to the
credit (98%) but it depends upon the what kind of customer they are dealing
with as the customer are from the big builders or retail house they will not
even think to not sell on the credit.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
62
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
RECOMMENDATION
• There are competitive advantages through enhanced relations with fewer suppliers, resulting in lengthy relationships, which are more likely to include assets dedicated to the partnership. Sharing greater information and assets enable such programmes as just-in-time manufacturing, which will increase the efficiency for benefits to all parties through cooperation and coordination.
• The organisation must focus on empowering designated groups. As such special training and development initiatives should be investigated which focus on providing respondents with the tools for effective decision making. Should pursue empowerment by encouraging employees to develop their own abilities through company sponsored training and development and to accept as much responsibility within their capability.
• A highly important element of this strategy is EDI, an electronic data interchange
system that directly connects customers to the overall distribution system. Point-of -sale information from major accounts provides the ability to generate instantaneous data relevant to reorders, invoices and shipments. This distribution system, while costly and effective, would enable major customers of its products, to avoid having to place orders and coordinate logistical arrangements. It would also help sales to maintain the appropriate product inventory at any given time.
• Low inventory levels can contribute vastly to a firm’s efficiency and cost. Inbound logistics revolve around supplier relationship. Greater collaboration needs to be established with suppliers to support a Just-In-Time system of manufacturing. With overseas suppliers a local warehouse could be established as an intermediate supply.
• Effort is required to reduce work in progress before normal production resumes. If work in progress goes over a pre-determined value, all production needs to stop. The situation needs to be analysed for the reason for the build up and corrective action implemented. Trials need to be conducted for increase in machine speed so as to reduce production time. If the physical
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
63
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
properties do not change then the new machine speed to be specified in the specification to load cement faster and reduce the demurrages .
• The marketing and sales segment of the value chain involves such activities as promotion and advertising, sales representation, relationships, technical support as well as pricing strategies. This link is an important aspect of reputation building by serving as the direct interface between the consumer and the product. Advertising encourages people to make purchases. A web site needs to be established with relevant technical support and applications for the various products it offers. Sales representatives have to be familiar with the product that they sell. The product however has to be backed up by one of high quality.
• ‘First off’ is important to ensure the process capability of the production lines. The ‘first off’ is the first sample from the production line that is inspected against the specification. If it conforms then only is the production line allowed to continue. If the product does not conform, then adjustments are made to the process or the machine and another sample is tested. At key points in the production process, quality inspectors need to monitor every production of the process. Extra personnel need not be employed. The current line operators could be multi skilled so that they become aware of the requirements of the product. They will be performing dual functions. Important tests can be performed on the line instead of this sample being tested in the laboratory.. Therefore the relevant equipment needs to be purchased and line personnel trained for effective utilisation and feedback.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
64
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
CONCLUSION
1. A cement distribution system comprising: a powdered cement packing
vehicle including a cement accommodating unit for storing powdered cement,
and an automatic packing machine for packing the powdered cement stored
in said cement accommodating unit into containers in predetermined
quantities; and a powdered cement service center for supplying the powdered
cement into said cement accommodating unit of said powdered cement
packing vehicle; wherein said powdered cement packing vehicle is operable
to pack a desired quantity of the powdered cement into containers based on
an order from a cement purchaser, and is operable to directly deliver the
packed cement to the cement purchaser.
2. The cement distribution system of claim 1, wherein said powdered cement
packing vehicle further includes a portable communication terminal; said
cement distribution system further comprising a managing headquarters
including a computer wirelessly connected to said portable communication
terminal of said powdered cement packing vehicle, said managing
headquarters being operable to receive orders from the cement purchaser,
and to transmit powdered cement distribution information to said powdered
cement packing vehicle via said portable communication terminal.
3. The cement distribution system of claim 2, wherein said powdered cement
packing vehicle is operable to transmit price settlement data to said computer
of said managing headquarters via said portable communication terminal.
4. The cement distribution system of claim 1, wherein said powdered cement
packing vehicle further includes a switching mechanism for feeding the
powdered cement from said powdered cement packing vehicle.
5. The cement distribution system of claim 4, wherein said powdered cement
packing vehicle further includes a distribution hose for distributing the
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
65
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
powdered cement, said switching mechanism being operable to switch a
distribution of the powdered cement stored in said cement accommodating
unit from said automatic packing machine to said distribution hose.
6. The cement distribution system of claim 1, wherein said automatic packing
machine is operable to pack an adjustable predetermined quantity of
powdered cement into each of a plurality of bags.
7. The cement distribution system of claim 1, wherein said automatic packing
machine is located at a center of said powdered cement packing vehicle.
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
66
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Hugos, Michael, 2003, Essentials of Supply Chain Management, John
Wiley & Sons.
Chopra, Sunil and Peter Meindl, 2001, Supply Chain Management:
Strategy, Planning and Operations, Prentice-Hall Inc.
Fredendall, Lawrence D. and Ed Hill, 2001, Basics of Supply Chain
Management, St. Lucie Press.
Council of Logistics Management, www.clm1.org
Integrated Business Communications Alliance, www.ibcaweb.org
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523
67
The Indian Institute of Planning & Management, New Delhi
BATCH: PGP/FW/2008-10 ALUMNI ID NO.: DF/08/10-M-523