drive bpm value 10.06.08
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
1/15
Making Leaders Successul Every Day
Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To HigheBsiess Veb Coie Mooe
o Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
http://www.forrester.com/ -
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
2/15
2008, Forrester Research, Inc. All rights reserved. Forrester, Forrester Wave, RoleView, Technographics, TechRadar, and Total Economic Impactare trademarks o Forrester Research, Inc. All other trademarks are the property o their respective companies. Forrester clients may make oneattributed copy or slide o each gure contained herein. Additional reproduction is strictly prohibited. For additional reproduction rights andusage inormation, go to www.orrester.com. Inormation is based on best available resources. Opinions refect judgment at the time and aresubject to change. To purchase reprints o this document, please email [email protected].
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
Includes Forrester research panel data
ExECuTIVE SuMMary
Te business process management (BPM) value proposition goes ar beyond simple process automation,
but unortunately, that is where many organizations end their eorts. And while automation certainly
provides tremendous eciency, productivity, and reduced cycle time benets, automation alone
cannot unlock the more signicant benets that advanced BPM deployments oer. Enterprises with
greater BPM maturity (oen derived rom establishing centers o excellence) can take advantage o
many more eatures including integrated process modeling, model-driven development, monitoring,collaboration, and optimization eatures that leading BPM suite (BPMS) tools provide. o capitalize
on the transormational power o BPM, develop and implement a plan that advances your BPM
capabilities. Specically, move rom process automation to address (in increasing order o value) I
agility, process compliance and consistency, process insight, and, ultimately, business transormation.
Inormation and knowledge managers who use BPM soware should ollow Forresters maturity model
to help advance their thinking about BPM benets and deployment goals.
TaBlE OF COnT EnTSToo May Orgaiatios Shortchage
Themseles O BPMs PotetialMoe Busiess Process Iitiaties Up The
Maturity Ladder
Wide The Scope Of What BPM Meas To You
Projects Are Good, Eterprise BPM Is Better
rECOMMEnDaTIOnS
Uderstad Where You Are Headed Oer The
Log Haul, From The Begiig
wHaT IT MEanS
Start Small But Improe Quickly
nOTES & rESOurCESOve the pst 12 moths, Foeste hs
itevieed 72 compies tht hve depoedBPM d hs sveed 164 etepise chitects
i the uS d uK.
Related Research Documets
The BPM COE Is Hee: no wht?
Je 20, 2008
Ho The Covegece O Bsiess res, BPM,
ad BI wi Dive Bsiess Optimiztio
M 14, 2008
Cse Std: Qest uses Pocess Simtio To
Move at The Speed O Bsiess Chge
api 23, 2008
Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess VeMove Beod atomtio To Bsiess Optimiztio
by Coie Mooreith Ke Vome d nom nicoso
2
4
9
10
11
11
http://www.forrester.com/go?docid=46108&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=45638&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=45638&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=45638&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=45638&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=46108&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/ -
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
3/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio PohibitedOctobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
2
TOO MAnY ORGAnIzATIOnS SHORTCHAnGE THEMSELvES On BPMS POTEnTIAL
Over the past ew years, BPM has gained broad acceptance across companies as a valuable
methodology and technology. While vendors and practitioners alike talk volumes about business
agility, optimization, and centers o excellence, very ew companies have gone as ar in the real
world. As BPMS technology has increased in popularity, many case studies have extolled the
nancial and productivity gains their BPMSes have supplied. And while most BPM practitioners
know that process automation or workfow is only a small part o what a company using a BPMS
can accomplish, signicantly ewer companies currently use these technology tools advanced
eatures and this is especially true among smaller companies (see Figure 1).1 Most companies see
BPMS tools as a way to automate processes or enhanced productivity and are stuck at that level o
BPMS maturity.
Te lackluster eorts o BPM practitioners dont stop there: Many companies have also ailed to
set up ormal BPM centers o excellence (COEs) (see Figure 2). While a companys rst BPMproject may not require a COE, a COE is a must i BPM is to gain companywide acceptance and
our data shows that the existence o a COE strongly correlates with BPMS success (see Figure 3).
But organizational structures in both I and the business and overzealous, overtechnical, or
underexcited sta in any department stand in the way o many o these eorts.
While simple BPM projects can certainly deliver departmental value, BPM as a business
methodology has much more to oer as do the modern BPMS tools available. BPM practitioners
wanting to maximize value rom their eorts should make use o their total BPM suite and then
expand the scope o BPM eorts in both technical and organizational ways to take advantage o
the suites ull capabilities. For example, they should look to use eatures such as simulation and
roundtripping, business activity monitoring, business rules, and dashboards, to name a ew.
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
4/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio Pohibited Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
3
Figure 1 BPM Fctioit usge Vies B Comp Size
Figure 2 BPM Tem Mtit Vies B Comp Size
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46375
Source: October 2007 US And UK Enterprise Architecture And Business Process Management Online Survey
Less than $1 billionin annual revenue
$1 billion or morein annual revenue*
*Base: 56 IT architectsBase: 84 IT architects
Process redesign
Process reporting
Process modeling
Process optimization(continuous improvement)
Process monitoring
Process automation
What type of BPM efforts are under way at the present time?
61%64%
61%63%
57%48%
68%44%
57%
45%
59%45%
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46375
Has a team been created to provide BPM guidance?
Less than $1 billionannual revenue
$1 billion or moreannual revenue*
No formal team hasbeen created
A team has been createdto deal with BPM issues
A BPM center of excellenceis planned
A BPM center of excellencehas been created
*Base: 56 IT architects at companies with $1 billion or more annual revenuesBase: 84 IT architects at companies with less than $1 billion annual revenues
19%
30%
30%
40%
36%
11%5%
29%
Source: October 2007 US And UK Enterprise Architecture And Business Process Management Online Survey
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
5/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio PohibitedOctobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
4
Figure 3 BPM rests Vess Epecttios
MOvE BUSInESS PROCESS InITIATIvES UP THE MATURITY LADDER
Whether your organization can attain higher levels o BPMS value depends on two actors: 1) your
organizations maturity in the discipline o BPM and 2) your organizations access to technical
support or process disciplines and methodologies through advanced BPM tooling. I your
company lacks organizational maturity and uses products with limited BPM unctionality, theres
a limit to what you can achieve even through continuous improvement methodologies and BPMS
implementations. In other words, the most advanced tools are useless to companies that arentmature enough in their practice o BPM, and the most mature companies miss out on value when
they buy or use tools only or automation, ignoring process intelligence, process optimization, and
even business transormation.
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46375
It failed to meet our goalsbut was considered a
success because of otherdelivered benefits
It significantly failed tomeet our goals
It met our goals
It exceeded our goalssignificantly
According to these metrics, did the BPM project deliver on your
organizations expectations or goals after the initial implementation?
No formal team
has been created
A team has beencreated to dealwith BPM issues
A BPM centerof excellenceis planned
A BPM centerof excellencehas been created
Has a team been created toprovide BPM guidance?
Base: 21 IT architects
Base: 72 IT architects
10% 30% 50% 70%
67%14%
19%0%
23%32%36%
8%
Base: 7 IT architects
0%18%
73%9%
Base: 11 IT architects
14%71%
14%0%
Less than $1 billion in annual revenue$1 billion or more in annual revenue*
*Base: 46 IT architectsBase: 65 IT architects
(percentages may not total 100 because of rounding)
Source: October 2007 US And UK Enterprise Architecture And Business Process Management Online Survey
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
6/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio Pohibited Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
5
The Forrester BPMS Maturity Model: From Process Kowledge To Busiess Optimiatio
Forresters BPMS maturity model is based on raising the value o the realized benets o a BPMS
implementation, both to shareholders and in competitiveness as well as to increasingly higher
stakeholders within the organization, culminating with the most senior executives within the
organization (see Figure 4). Key phases o the BPMS maturity model and the overall value
proposition or BPM suites are:
Process knowledge. Many organizations make their initial move into BPM (the discipline)or BPMS (the technology) by ocusing on process modeling. Oen, the modeling tools these
organizations select are standalone products that are not linked to an execution environment.
A company may have many reasons or choosing a process modeling tool as its rst step; or
example, a company may want to use modeling or Six Sigma and Lean Six Sigma projects
(that sometimes go on orever), as a way o better understanding and communicating about
the business, or to capture knowledge rom retiring employees. For example, one US Federalagency ocused specically on process modeling because it aced massive employee retirements
within two years. But the problem is that in real lie, processes change all the time; in act, our
interviews consistently show that processes never stop changing. As a result, it is very dicult,
i not impossible, to keep process models up to date without linking them to an execution
environment. While standalone process modeling has some value, it can be quite limiting and is
airly low on the BPMS maturity scale and in derived benets.
Process eciency. For many years, process eciency has been the mantra or BPMS vendorstouting the benets o BPMS; they say, Buy a BPMS and get increased productivity and
reduced cycle time and drive eciency through the roo. But a primary problem inormation
and knowledge management proessionals ace is becoming overly enamored with the workfow
and BPM tooling in content management technologies, particularly transactional content
solutions. Tese practitioners oen move rom one enterprise content management workfow
system to the next, using each subsequent automation to deliver business value. So wheres the
problem? While this approach will deliver signicant cost savings at rst, it usually emphasizes
back-oce processes that arent dierentiating, arent important to top executives, and dont
ultimately create as much value to shareholders as do other areas o ocus.
Te unrelenting emphasis on back-oce processes may put too much corporate energy
and budget into eciency and productivity when the company actually needs to ocus on
innovation, new products, or greater customer satisaction. For example, Rich Phillips, ormerCOO o Maritz ravel and current President o Maritz Loyalty Marketing, recently observed:
Back-oce productivity is interesting and sounds like an appropriate goal. But the risk is that
an organization might end up improving a process that should be eliminated. It is also possible
to reduce organizational agility through such an initiative, ultimately hurting competitiveness.
Finally, the diversion o resources rom higher-value opportunities urther undercuts the value
o back-oce initiatives by adding opportunity cost.2
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
7/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio PohibitedOctobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
6
IT agility. About two or three years ago, many enterprise architects and application developersdiscovered the link between service-oriented architecture (SOA) and BPM. I proessionals
who had been having a dicult time explaining the benets o SOA to businesspeople realized
that BPM was a perect vehicle or selling SOA projects to the business. More importantly, CIOs
and vice presidents o enterprise architecture began to see how much BPM suites beneted
not only the business but also the I organizations internal eorts. Based on our interviews,
BPMS tools oen cut in hal both the time needed to develop new applications and the
maintenance backlog. Although I agility isnt a direct business benet, its a huge benet to the
I organization, which ultimately helps the business by reeing up I resources. Realizing the
benets o BPMS within an I organization is another notch up the BPM maturity model.
Process consistency and compliance. Some o the most advanced BPM practitioners we talkedwith were ocused on moving to more consistent processes within the organization. For example,
one global nancial services company had call centers in 50 locations around the world, andeach o those call centers handled customer calls dierently. While this wasnt a problem or a
specic call center, it meant that the company did not have consistent processes (which could
lead to internal or external compliance issues), and the cost o doing business was higher than
it would be i all call center processes were standardized. In another example, an insurance
company realized it was not as competitive as other insurers because its rates were higher.
When line o business (LOB) executives started investigating why, they learned that, though
the LOBs had basically the same or very similar processes, each LOB executed them dierently.
By moving to an organizationwide consistent process, the company was able to lower its rates.
However, most companies do not reach this maturity level until they have gone through the
process eciency stage, usually or one or a handul o processes.
Process insight. Advanced BPMS products rom vendors including Appian, Global 360,Lombardi, Pegasystems, and Savvion now oer process monitoring components that allow
managers and business analysts/architects to gain insight rom historical business intelligence
(BI) reports or rom dashboards that show process monitoring results as processes execute.3
When bottlenecks occur, business managers can take action or example, they might reroute
work to another location, add resources on a temporary basis, or even triage process instances
so that the most valued customers are taken care o rst. Many organizations implementing
BPMS tools or the rst time do not take advantage o these capabilities because they are
ocused on automating a single process. But ultimately, process insight is where all BPMS
implementations should end up, and its important when selecting a BPMS tool to make surethat its process insight eatures will be up to the task when the organization is mature enough to
use them.
Business transormation. BPMS deployments coupled with business model agility,workorce retooling, new ventures, customer/supplier value chain integration . . . business
value, and alignment with competitive strategies can ultimately bring the organization to
business transormation.4 Only a very tiny percentage o companies have reached this stage
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
8/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio Pohibited Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
7
in the maturity model, but more organizations, such as Ford Motor Company, are moving
in this direction. Business transormation at this level is based on many actors, but process
optimization is certainly one o them.
I your enterprise wants to move beyond mere eciency and productivity improvements or
back-oce processes and seeks to optimize (and even transorm) the business, look to the
convergence o BPMS, business rules, and business intelligence to serve as the oundation o
this progress.5 Many barriers still exist to ully realizing this level o the BPMS maturity model,
including: 1) most enterprises still embed processes, rules, and reporting in applications; 2)
many organizations build monolithic and infexible analytical environments; 3) organizational
barriers divide process, rules, and data proessionals; 4) suites are not yet adequate or many
organizations; 5) custom integration o best-o-breed products remains possible but is too
dicult; 6) metrics that span data and processes dont yet exist; and 7) standards that span the
three Bs (BPM, business rules, and BI) are not yet in sight.
Figure 4The BPM Cpbiit Mtit Mode
Source: Forrester Research, Inc.46375
Processmodeling
Processexecution SOA
Processmonitoring
Processoptimization
Knowledge
Efficiency
IT agility
Compliance and
consistency
Business insight
Transformation
Value to
shareholdersand
competitiveness
Lower
Higher
Stakeholders
Workers, supervisors, and managersCustomers and partners
CIO CFO CXO CEO
BPM adoption maturity HigherLower
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
9/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio PohibitedOctobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
8
How To Get Started O The BPM Jourey
Inormation managers who want to maximize BPM value and move up the maturity model should,
in order o execution:
Start with modeling or automation. Companies we have surveyed typically start in one othese two places. Many jump right into automation, getting quick business value rom cost
savings and increased productivity. Automation tools that replace paper-based processing with
electronic processing improve productivity by reducing the time it takes or work to move
around the organization and by allowing parallel processing by humans. Other organizations
model processes (to levels o detail that range rom basic to excruciating). Capturing the
inormation required to store a business process in a graphical model can signicantly enhance
understanding o the process and its potential problems.
Link modeling and automation. Both modeling and automation are ne starting places,but wherever you start, quickly expand eorts into the other. Adding modeling to existingautomation eorts can bring important process knowledge and identiy areas or improvement;
adding automation to existing models brings major productivity gains and helps ensure that
models stay current because changing the automated process requires a change to the model.
Tis also enhances an organizations ability to use gathered process inormation in other sections
o the process lie cycle, such as the monitoring and optimization phases.
Ensure that a solid, agile oundation exists or uture process eforts. Most technologyvendors will market service-oriented architecture (SOA) and BPM together, and the
combination makes obvious sense.6 But they are not joined at the hip in the way that some
vendors suggest. In act, miring your initial BPM eorts in SOA can kill them with burdensomeinrastructure costs and delays while you set up registries, repositories, services, and centers
o excellence. But while initial BPM eorts may proceed independent o SOA eorts, as both
expand to have enterprisewide impact, they should increasingly coexist and converge. An SOA
oundation or process means automated business processes are much easier to change and
helps create a business that can more agilely respond to new challenges by creating new processes.
Te integration-centric BPMS (IC-BPMS) vendors such as IBM, Oracle, Soware AG, and
Sun Microsystems already oer core SOA capabilities with their BPM products. In contrast,
most human-centric BPMS (HC-BPMS) products do not provide SOA components but instead
integrate with many products that do, including IC-BPMS products or enterprise servicebuses (ESBs). Alternatively, some HC-BPMS vendors partner with SOA vendors; or example,
Lombardi Soware has a relationship with Progress Soware, and W4 partners with Magic
Soware.
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
10/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio Pohibited Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
9
Establish rigorous metrics and begin actively monitoring and managing the process.Depending on the environment or example, a call center this may be an intrinsic part
o automation, but in many processes, monitoring is saved or later. But dont put it o
indenitely, as BPM practitioners will have a tough time optimizing a process with no metrics
and no data about its perormance. Plus, its essential to establish key perormance indicators
(KPIs), thresholds, notications, and alarms to provide management with greater insight into
the business as the process executes.
In a rush to get started, some organizations try to begin their BPM eorts with monitoring, but
usually that approach is not the way to go. o maximize the eect o the business process, you
need to understand how the process works, which requires modeling at the outset. Once you
establish the model, you can use BPM tools to create and monitor the appropriate KPIs. Be
leery o recommendations to monitor the as is process up ront, as there are normally too
many unknowns to make this a practical exercise, meaning that this eort ends up just divertingresources rom more eective starting eorts. An exception to this recommendation is i the
process is very chaotic or unknown: In this case, monitoring may be a backdoor way to get to a
process model.
Use simulation eatures to manage change and predict process results. Some people amiliarwith BPM suites may be surprised to see simulation this ar down the list. However, our
interviews with practitioners have consistently shown that simulation is not especially useul at
the modeling stage. Conversely, it can be an extremely powerul tool or optimizing processes
once rich data about the process is available or use as a baseline input to the simulator.
Move rom process improvement to true process and business optimization. Tis willmean pulling data into the process rom external business intelligence and business activity
monitoring (BAM) tools to optimize the process at runtime. It also includes incorporating
advanced business rules technology into process decisions to properly manage the process and
using reports and simulation tools aer the act to make structural process changes.
WIDEn THE SCOPE OF WHAT BPM MEAnS TO YOU
Until now, BPMS vendors and their users have ocused on structured processes, whether the
actors in those processes are mostly people or mostly systems. But many real-world, people-
intensive processes are so rie with exceptions that its impossible to model all the permutations in atraditional process modeling tool. Tese ad hoc, chaotic processes are dicult to support even using
todays BPMS tools.7
As an example, consider a sales process where senior account managers handle the large accounts and
make very individualized discounting and packaging decisions. Te outcome o a discounting decision
may be captured in the BPMS by integrating or embedding a business rules engine, but the way the
decision was made the reason or the discount is oen recorded in an obscure email thread, i at all.
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
11/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio PohibitedOctobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
10
Auditable, controllable tools or supporting this kind o work are already available in content
management systems and enterprise collaboration suites. But enterprise content management
(ECM) vendors havent caught up with the best o the pure plays or BPM unctionality, and
collaboration tools typically lack any kind o awareness o the users role, the process he or she isworking on, and what inormation is needed (unless these actors are manually congured, as in a
project-specic site on SharePoint). o support these real-lie human processes, BPM suites need:
Integrated group collaboration tools. Treaded discussions, document libraries, and evenemails mustnt stand alone; they must be created and audited as needed along with each process
instance.
Presence awareness and strong organizational management. While the fexibility o ad hocprocesses is a benet in that it helps work get done the right way, oen the appropriate actors
arent available when needed. BPM suites should be able to nd the right person or the job (or
at least present a list o possibilities), taking employees presence into account when doing so.
Business intelligence and enterprise search integration or runtime. Workers need dierentkinds o inormation at each point in the process; the smart work environment will use
contextual awareness and search tools to discover and present useul inormation. Each step
in a process will be like a miniature Inormation Workplace that automatically makes available
inormation such as reports, documentation, and eLearning objects when users need it.8
PROJECTS ARE GOOD, EnTERPRISE BPM IS BETTER
Many companies get into BPM because a particular project calls or it a merger means twodisparate enterprise application systems must be combined, or customer service problems require
an overhaul o externally acing processes. Teres nothing wrong with starting down the BPM road
with a single project in mind, and its not necessary to get bogged down in centers o excellence
and service-oriented architectures with that rst project. Even so, project leaders should look to the
uture when assigning sta and choosing technology or the rst project. Its critically important to
make sure that the BPMS provider you select has the unctionality, the product road map, and the
vision (plus customer reerences) to carry you through whatever level o the maturity model your
organization aspires to reach.
Also, as the previously discussed data shows, an established center o excellence is closely linked
with BPM project success no matter what the level o BPMS maturity. It doesnt make sense to hold
up initial BPM eorts until a center o excellence can be established aer all, it will be hard to
get a mandate or such an investment without proven successes.9 However, the staers on the rst
BPM project are likely to be uture COE members, so choose them careully.10 And, as having a COE
is widely acclaimed as a critical success actor or continued success in BPM and BPMS, plan to
implement one as soon as you can.
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
12/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio Pohibited Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
11
r E C O M M E n D a T I O n S
UnDERSTAnD WHERE YOU ARE HEADED OvER THE LOnG HAUL, FROM THE
BEGInnInG
Advanced BPMS technology is essentially useless at organizations that arent ready or it. Process
and knowledge management proessionals should:
Stick to the tools that are useful. a ot o BPM site compoets e it, bt compiestht et ed shodt bothe ith them. Fo empe, ithot e-deed bsiess
metics o pocess, simtio toos e most ste o time.
Pla for the future whe buyig. whie ogiztios m ot be ed o moe dvcedpocess toos, Foestes esech hs sho tht tight itegted BPM sites e mch
moe poe. Fetes sch s dt-dive simtio d optimiztio e ve dict to
se he dispte podcts peom the modeig, eectio, d dt-gtheig ctivities.Stdds e so to emege, so be se tht o BPM site vedo sppots o ed stte
o pocess mtit.
Aoid modelig without likig models to a executio eiromet. whie modeigc ceti povide pocess koedge isights, modes qick become otdted becse
pocesses costt chge (eve he the ogiztio doest eize the e chgig).
wheeve possibe, mke se tht o pocess modes c be impoted ito eectio
eviomet to keep them i sc ith the e od s it chges.
Pla for a ceter of excellece.The evidece is ce; thees cose coetio betee ce,mesbe, idetibe beets om BPMS d the cetio o COE. Most ogiztios
o eize this; the chege is ho to bid d st COE. Most COEs do ot eed to be
big i ct, s, stg it ith o to si membes is sciet. The s compositio is
oe o moe etepise chitects, ppictio deveope, bsiess st, d pocess
chitect. The COE shod so diect ik to the BPM govece committee.
w H a T I T M E a n S
START SMALL BUT IMPROvE QUICKLY
BPM pctitioes s get d ito the e b immedite eed pocess tht eeds
ig o sstem tht eeds itegtig. Bt oe ho stops t sig BPM methods d
techoogies o impovig podctivit is doig the ogiztio dissevice. It is i some s
s tht BPM vedos hve cosistet bee so ot i ot o thei cstomes. Fo es,
the hve sod the beets o pocess simtio toos, dvced moitoig sote, d i-
fight pocess chges to pospects the ko i eve se them. Bt s compies move om
simpe pocess impovemet to e bsiess optimiztio d s BPM eches mistem stts
i the mket, bsiesses i eed to stt sig moe dvced BPM etes to gi edge
ove the competitio.
-
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
13/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio PohibitedOctobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
12
EnDnOTES
1 In October 2007, Forrester interviewed 164 I architects in the US and the UK. See the February 19, 2008,
Te EA View: BPM Has Become Mainstream report.
2 Rich Phillips also noted that companies need to understand that rst, to win big, its all about business
transormation, not soware implementation. Substantial value can be delivered by infecting competitive
strategy, cultural behavior, leadership perormance, and product dierentiation. Also, go wide rst, beore
going deep. Mapping the businesss value chain (wide) ollowed by waves o mapping business subprocesses
(deep) prepares the organization or systemic change and highlights key leverage points or maximizing
BPM impact. See the August 21, 2007, Te New I Imperative: Design For People, Build For Change
report.
3 For a deep dive into BPM products in dierent market segments, interested readers should look into the
many Forrester Waves evaluations on BPM suites. See the August 2, 2007, Te Forrester Wave: Human-
Centric BPM For Java Platorms, Q3 2007 report, see the December 19, 2007, Te Forrester Wave:Human-Centric BPM or Microso Platorms, Q4 2007 report, see the July 9, 2007, Te Forrester Wave:
Business Process Management For Document Processes, Q3 2007 report, and see the December 20, 2006,
Te Forrester Wave: Integration-Centric Business Process Management Suites, Q4 2006 report.
4 Rich Phillips shared lessons learned rom the BPM initiatives at Maritz ravel. See the August 21, 2007,
Te New I Imperative: Design For People, Build For Change report.
5 With change endemic, business fexibility paramount, and the lines between strategic, tactical, and
operational decision-making blurring, inormation and knowledge management (I&KM) pros must
nd new application architectures or a new generation o requirements. Business process management,
business intelligence, and business rules engine (BRE) soware oer the architectural oundations to meet
the challenge o continual business optimization, but too many I&KM pros approach these technologieslargely in isolation. In act, these three Bs have signicantly greater business impact when used together
than when used separately. I your enterprise wants to move beyond mere eciency and productivity
improvements or back-oce processes and seeks instead to optimize (and even transorm) the business,
look to the convergence o the three Bs to serve as the oundation. See the May 14, 2008, How Te
Convergence O Business Rules, BPM, And BI Will Drive Business Optimization report.
6 Organizations are increasingly relying on business process management suite products to support their
process improvement eorts, and this is driving an annual growth rate o 20% and up in this market. BPMS
and service-oriented architecture implementations requently occur together, and this is no fuke, as these
two technologies complement each other very well, resulting in a more powerul solution than either could
provide on its own. In particular, advances in key standards such as business process management notation(BPMN), business process execution language (BPEL), and XML Process Denition Language (XPDL)
are making it possible or BPMS products to support a model-driven approach to process improvements
that can be signicantly more agile than earlier methods. At the same time, improvements in SOA-based
repository technology are acilitating the storage o important business metadata in a common location,
where it is easier to share, reuse, and modiy without aecting business applications. Tese advances
http://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43191&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43249&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38886&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38886&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=41982&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=41982&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38878&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38878&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38744&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43249&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43207&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43249&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38744&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38878&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38878&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=41982&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=41982&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38886&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38886&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43249&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43191&src=46375pdf -
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
14/15
2008, Foeste resech, Ic. repodctio Pohibited Octobe 6, 2008
Dive BPM Iititives To Highe Bsiess Ve
Fo Iomtio & Koedge Mgemet Poessios
13
enable I organizations to respond more quickly to new requirements while providing business units with
more visibility and control over their key business processes. See the March 10, 2006, Business Process
Management Suites And SOA report.
7 While most BPM vendors have been working to add collaboration and content management tools to
processes, one startup vendor has gone the other way, adding process tools to Web 2.0-style collaboration
capabilities. See the April 11, 2008, Vendor Snapshot: Itensil Brings Process o Web 2.0 Collaboration
report.
8 When Forrester rst described the Inormation Workplace in 2005, we positioned it as the next-generation
platorm that delivered collaboration, content, portals, and oce productivity plus a plethora o
new capabilities bursting on the scene, such as unied communications and expertise location. But the
Inormation Workplace (IW) has never been about the piece parts. Instead, what makes the Inormation
Workplace transormational is how the piece parts are built into a seamless whole that supports people
in the way they want to work. Specically, we described the IW as role-based, contextual, seamless,
visual, and multimodal. Now enterprise Web 2.0 is rapidly advancing, bringing even greater design or
people concepts into the IW. For example, through the power o social networking and mashups, which
allow people to have it their way, the IW can go beyond role based to even become individualized. With
enterprise Web 2.0, the IW also gains two new acets: social and quick. With all these characteristics, the
IW will better support a design or people world and allow people to work in a much more natural way.
See the November 26, 2007, Te Seven enets O Te Inormation Workplace report.
9 Forrester receives many inquiries rom I&KM proessionals within enterprises implementing BPM COEs.
Many questions concern COE goals, key roles, and organizational structure. Other questions relate to
specic work tasks, tools, and standards required or an eective BPM COE. Tese I&KM pros also want
to know what business processes they should ocus on or transormation. Forrester has synthesized the
top ve questions and provided answers based on industry best practices. See the June 20, 2008, Te BPM
COE Is Here: Now What? report.
10 Businesses across all industries are looking to BPM to help them gain new eciencies, create a more
consistent customer experience, and provide better data insights. Yet many rms have multiple
implementations o the same type o BPM tools, or their siloed departments dont leverage work done
in other divisions when improving processes. Forrester spoke with a variety o large rms adopting
an emerging trend: developing COEs or BPM. We uncovered best practices in ve areas: 1) executive
sponsorship; 2) process methodology and governance; 3) stang skill sets; 4) vendor alignment; and 5)
KPIs. See the March 26, 2008, Best Practices: Centers O Excellence For BPM report.
http://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38702&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38702&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=45681&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43451&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=46108&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=46108&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=44571&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=44571&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=46108&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=46108&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=43451&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=45681&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38702&src=46375pdfhttp://www.forrester.com/go?docid=38702&src=46375pdf -
8/6/2019 Drive BPM Value 10.06.08
15/15
Forrester Research, Inc. (Nasdaq:
FORR) is an independent
technology and market research
company that provides pragmatic
and orward-thinking advice to
global leaders in business and
technology. For more than 24 years,
Forrester has been making leaderssuccessul every day through its
proprietary research, consulting,
events, and peer-to-peer executive
programs. For more inormation,
visit www.orrester.com.
Australia
Brazil
Canada
Denmark
France
Germany
Hong Kong
India
Israel
Japan
Korea
The Netherlands
Switzerland
United Kingdom
United States
Headquarters
Forrester Research, Inc.
400 Technology Square
Cambridge, MA 02139 USA
Tel: +1 617.613.6000
Fax: +1 617.613.5000
Email: [email protected]
Nasdaq symbol: FORR
www.orrester.com
M k i g l e d e s S c c e s s E v e D
For a complete list of worldwide locations,
visit www.forrester.com/about.
Research and Sales Ofces
For inormation on hard-copy or electronic reprints, please contact the Client
Resource Center at +1 866.367.7378, +1 617.617.5730, or [email protected].
We oer quantity discounts and special pricing or academic and nonproft institutions.
http://www.forrester.com/