draft proposals re. reporting of accidents, illnesses and...

16
Draft Proposals re. Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences as at 6 January 2012 Comparison Document (Column 1) Draft Proposals for Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences) Regulations 2012 and (Column 2) Part X (Notification of Accidents and Dangerous Occurrences), Regulations 58 to 63 of and the Twelfth Schedule to the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (General Application) Regulations 1993 (S.I. No. 44 of 1993) 1 comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

Upload: lamphuc

Post on 11-Apr-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


5 download

TRANSCRIPT

Draft Proposals re. Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences

as at 6 January 2012

Comparison Document

(Column 1)Draft Proposals for Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences) Regulations 2012

and

(Column 2)Part X (Notification of Accidents and Dangerous Occurrences), Regulations 58 to 63 of and the Twelfth Schedule to the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (General Application) Regulations 1993 (S.I. No. 44 of 1993)

1

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

(1)Safety, Health and Welfare at Work

(Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences) Regulations 2012

(Subject to ongoing development)

(2)Safety, Health and Welfare at Work

(General Application) Regulations 1993(S.I. No. 44 of 1993)

Part X Notification of Accidents and Dangerous

OccurrencesI, ……….., Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, in exercise of the powers conferred on me by section 58 of the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 (No. 10 of 2005) as adapted by the Enterprise, Trade and Innovation (Alteration of Name of Department and Title of Minister) Order 2011 (S.I. No. 245 of 2011) and for the purpose of giving further effect to Council Directive 89/391/EEC of 12 June 19891 on the introduction of measures to encourage improvements in the safety and health of workers at work and after consultation with the Health and Safety Authority, hereby make the following regulations:Citation and commencement.1. (1) These Regulations may be cited as the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences) Regulations 2012.

(2) These Regulations shall come into operation on ……….. 2012.

Covered by the overall citation and commencement provisions of the General Application Regulations.

1 OJ No. L183, 29.6.1989, p.12

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

Interpretation2. (1) In these Regulations-

"Act" means the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work Act 2005 (No.10 of 2005);

(see “prescribed dangerous occurrence” below)

No corresponding provision

“prescribed dangerous occurrence” means an occurrence listed in Schedule 1 which occurs at any place of work other than at a mine within the meaning of the Mines and Quarries Act 1965 (No. 7 of 1965);

“prescribed occupational illness”2 means an illness, that is the immediate result of a discrete event including an accident, listed in an approved list;

No corresponding provision

No corresponding provisio n

58. Interpretation of Part X(1) In this Part—

No corresponding provision

“dangerous occurrence”3 means an occurrence which occurs at any place of work other than at a mine or quarry within the meaning of the Mines and Quarries Act 1965 , and is an occurrence which is specified at a reference number in the Twelfth Schedule;

"pipeline" means—

(a) any pipeline or system of pipelines with a minimum internal diameter of 300 millimetres carrying or liable to carry flammable gases in a gaseous phase at a pressure above 8 bar absolute, or

(b) any pipeline or system of pipelines carrying or liable to carry any other dangerous substance or preparation;

(See “dangerous occurrence” above

No corresponding provision

"public road" means a road the responsibility for the maintenance of which lies on a road authority;

"road authority" means—

2 No equivalent provision in the 1993 Regulations3 “dangerous occurrence” is not defined in the draft 2010 Regulations in view of the definition in section 2(1) of the 2005 Act, but see definition of “prescribed dangerous occurrence”

3

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

“responsible person" means—

(a) in the case of any event required to be reported under Regulation 3 involving an employee at work, his or her employer;

(b) in any other case, except where subparagraph (c) applies, the person having control of a place of work for the purpose of any trade, business or undertaking (whether for profit or not) at which the accident or dangerous occurrence required to be reported under Regulation 3 occurs; and

(c) where a self-employed person is fatally injured at a place of work, the person who owns the place of work or, in the case of a tenancy existing in respect of the place of work, the tenant.

(2) In these Regulations, a reference to an accident, a prescribed occupational illness or a prescribed dangerous occurrence arising at or in connection with work includes a reference to an accident, illness or dangerous occurrence which is attributable to the manner of conducting the undertaking concerned or to any article or substance used for the purposes of the undertaking concerned or to the condition of any part of the place of work where the undertaking concerned is carried on.

(a) the council of a county,

(b) the corporation of a county or other borough, or

(c) the council of an urban district;

“responsible person” means—

(a) in the case of any event required to be reported under Regulation 59 involving an employee at work, his employer;

(b) in any other case, except where subparagraph (c) applies, the person having control of a place of work for the purpose of any trade, business or undertaking (whether for profit or not) at which the accident or dangerous occurrence required to be reported under Regulation 59 occurs; and

(c) where a self-employed person is fatally injured at a place of work, the person who owns the place of work or, in the case of a tenancy existing in respect of the place of work, the tenant or, in a case where the fatally injured person is the owner or tenant, the next of kin.

(2) In this Part, a reference to an accident or a dangerous occurrence arising at or in connection with work includes a reference to an accident or dangerous occurrence which is attributable to the manner of conducting the undertaking concerned or to any article or substance used for the purposes of the undertaking concerned or to the condition of any part of the place of work where the undertaking concerned is carried on.

4

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

Reporting of Accidents, Illnesses and Dangerous Occurrences3. (1) Where—

(a) a person, who is an employee, dies as a result of an accident at their place of work or in the course of carrying out their work in a location other than their normal place of work,

(b) a person, who is an employee, is unfit, as a result an accident at their place of work to perform their substantial usual work for more than three consecutive days, excluding the day of the accident but including any days which would not have been working days,

(c) a person, who is an employee, notified under (b) dies within one year as a result of that accident at their place of work or in the course of carrying out that work in a location other than their normal place of work,

(d) a person, who is not at work who, as a result of an accident related to a place of work or a work activity dies, within one year of the accident,

(e) A person, who is not at work, as a result of an accident related to a place of work or a work activity suffers any injury or condition which, due to the nature or severity of the injury or condition, results in the person being taken from the site of the accident to a hospital for treatment in respect of that injury,

(f) A person presents with a prescribed occupational illness at a place of work as a result of which that person dies or is prevented from performing his or her normal work for more than three consecutive days, or

59. Notification of Accidents and Dangerous Occurrences(1) Where -

(a) any accident occurs at a place of work as a result of which any person carrying out work at that place of work dies or is prevented from performing his normal work for more than three consecutive days, excluding the day of the accident but including any days which would not have been working days, or

(b) in the case of any person who is not at work but who as a result of an accident related to a place of work or a work activity dies or suffers any injury or condition as a result of an accident which results in the person requiring treatment from a registered medical practitioner or treatment in a hospital as an in-patient or an out-patient, or

(c) there is a dangerous occurrence,

the responsible person shall—

(i) in the case of a death, supply the Authority by the quickest practicable means with the name of the deceased, brief particulars and the location of the accident, and

(ii) as soon as practicable send a written report in the approved form to the Authority of the death, injury, condition, accident, or dangerous occurrence.

5

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

(g) there is a prescribed dangerous occurrence,

the responsible person shall—

(i) in the case of a death, supply the Authority by the quickest practicable means with the name of the deceased, brief particulars and the location of the accident and, within 5 working days of the death, send a written report to the Authority in the approved form,

(ii) in the case of a non-fatal injury, prescribed occupational illness or prescribed dangerous occurrence, as soon as reasonably practicable and not later than 10 working days after the event, send a written report to the Authority in the approved form, or

(iii) in the case of a death within one year of a notified non fatal injury, as soon as practicable, within 5 working days of the death, send a written repot to the Authority in the approved form,

(2)(a) Where an accident which is reportable under paragraph (1) occurs and causes loss of life to a person no person shall disturb the place where it occurred or tamper with anything thereat before—

(i) that place has been inspected by an inspector, or

(ii) the expiration of three clear days after notification, in accordance with paragraph (1), of the accident.

(2)4 Where as a result of an accident at work an employee or a self-employed person sustains an injury or suffers a condition which is required to be reported under this Regulation to the Authority, and as a result of that accident the employee or self-employed person dies within a year of the accident, the responsible person shall, as soon as possible after the death comes to his knowledge, inform the Authority in writing of the death, whether or not the accident has been reported under paragraph (1).

(3)5 In the case of a responsible person who is a self-employed person, it shall be sufficient compliance with paragraph (1) if the self-employed person makes arrangements with some other person for that other person to make the notification or report required by that paragraph on behalf of the self-employed person.

(4) (a) Where an accident which is noticeable under paragraph (1) occurs and causes loss of life to a person no person shall disturb the place where it occurred or tamper with anything thereat before—

(i) that place has been inspected by an inspector, or

(ii) the expiration of three clear days after notification, in accordance with paragraph (1), of the accident.

(b) Nothing in this Regulation shall prohibit the doing of anything by or with the consent of an inspector.

(c) In any proceedings taken in respect of a contravention of this paragraph consisting of the doing of

4 No equivalent provision in draft 2012 Regulations5 No equivalent provision in draft 2012 Regulations

6

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

(b) Nothing in this Regulation shall prohibit the doing of anything by or with the consent of an inspector, or anything required to be done in compliance with any other statutory provision.

(c) In any proceedings taken in respect of a contravention of this paragraph consisting of the doing of any act, it shall be a defence to prove that the doing of the act was necessary for securing the safety or health of any person.

any act, it shall be a defence to prove that the doing of the act was necessary for securing the safety or health of any person.

Keeping of Records4. (1) The responsible person shall keep a record of any accident, prescribed occupational illness or prescribed dangerous occurrence which is required to be reported under Regulation 3 to the Authority, for a period of ten years from the date of the accident or dangerous occurrence, or the diagnosis of the illness.

(2) A record required to be kept under this Regulation shall contain the same information as in the approved form referred to in Regulation 3(1).

(3) A record required to be kept under this Regulation shall be kept at the place where the work to which it relates is carried on or, if this is not practicable, at the usual place of business of the responsible person.

(4) Where an employer is required by or under statute (other than the Act) to keep a record of injuries, illnesses or deaths at work, such a record shall be sufficient compliance with paragraph (1) if it contains the particulars specified in paragraph (2).

(5) Where the Authority requests a responsible person to send it extracts from a record required to be kept by this Regulation, the responsible person shall comply with such a request as soon as possible.

60. Keeping of Records(1) The responsible person shall keep a record of any accident or dangerous occurrence which is required to be reported under Regulation 59 to the authority, for a period of ten years from the date of the accident or dangerous occurrence.

(2) A record required to be kept under this Regulation shall contain the same information as in the approved form referred to in Regulation 59(1)(c)(ii).

(3) A record required to be kept under this Regulation shall be kept at the place where the work to which it relates is carried on or, if this is not practicable, at the usual place of business of the responsible person.

(4) Where an employer is required by or under statute (other than the Act) to keep a record of injuries or deaths at work, such a record shall be sufficient compliance with paragraph (1) if it contains the particulars specified in paragraph (2).

(5) Where the Authority requests a responsible person to send it extracts from a record required to be kept by this Regulation, the responsible person shall comply with such a request as soon as possible.

7

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

Non-Application of Regulations5. The provisions of these Regulation do not apply in a case where a person dies or is injured or suffers ill health while a patient undergoing medical treatment carried out by a medical practitioner or at the point when the death, injury or ill health occurs the person is not undergoing treatment for an accident at a place of work, a prescribed occupational illness or an injury due to a prescribed dangerous occurrence.

61. Application of this Part(1) The provisions of Regulation 59 relating to a death, injury or condition do not apply to a person who, at the time death occurs or injury is sustained or a condition is suffered, is a patient undergoing treatment in a hospital or in a doctor's or dentist's surgery and is not undergoing treatment for an accident at a place of work or for an injury due to a dangerous occurrence, unless the cause of death or injury is unrelated to the patient's pre-existing medical condition or the treatment being provided.

(2) The provisions of Regulation 59 relating to the death, injury or condition of a person as a result of an accident shall, in the case of an accident arising out of or in connection with the movement of a vehicle on any public road, apply only if that person—

(a) was killed or suffered an injury as a result of driving or riding a vehicle in the course of work, or

(b) was killed or suffered an injury or condition as a result of exposure to a substance or injury from an article being conveyed by a vehicle,

(c) was either himself engaged in, or was killed or suffered an injury or condition as a result of the activities of another person who was at the time of the accident engaged in, work connected with the loading or unloading of any article or substance onto or off a vehicle, or

(d) was either himself engaged in, or killed or suffered an injury or condition as a result of the activities of another person who was at the time of the accident engaged in, work on or alongside a road, being work

8

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

concerned with the construction, demolition, alteration, repair or maintenance of—

(i) the road or the markings or equipment thereon;

(ii) the verges, fences, hedges or other boundaries of the road;

(iii) pipes or cable on, under, over or adjacent to the road; or

(iv) buildings or structures adjacent to or over the road.

Defence in Proceedings6. It shall be a defence in any proceedings against any person for an offence under these Regulations for such person to prove that he or she was not aware of the accident, illness or dangerous occurrence in relation to which he or she was required by Regulation 3 to send a report to the Authority and that he or she had taken all reasonable steps to have such accident, illness or dangerous occurrence brought to his or her notice.

62. Defence in ProceedingsIt shall be a defence in any proceedings against any person for an offence under this Part of these Regulations for such person to prove that he was not aware of the accident or dangerous occurrence in relation to which he was required by Regulation 59 to make a notification or send a report to the Authority and that he had taken all reasonable steps to have such accident or dangerous occurrence brought to his notice.

Examinations and Tests7. (1) Where there is an accident, a prescribed occupational illness or a prescribed dangerous occurrence at a place of work and the Authority is satisfied that the accident, illness or occurrence may have been caused (whether wholly or partly) by any article, if the authority considers it necessary for the proper investigation of the accident, illness or occurrence, it may, by a notice in writing, require the employer, self-employed person or the owner of the article concerned:—

(a) to have such article or part thereof, examined and tested forthwith by a competent person,

(b) to have a report of the results of the examination and test prepared and submitted to the employer, self-employed

63. Examinations and Tests(1) Where there is an accident or dangerous occurrence at a place of work and the Authority is satisfied that the accident or occurrence may have been caused (whether wholly or partly) by any article, if the authority considers it necessary for the proper investigation of the accident or occurrence, it may by a notice in writing require the employer, self-employed person or the owner of the article concerned:—

(a) to have such article, or in a case where the accident or occurrence is believed to have been so caused by a part thereof, that part, examined and tested forthwith by a competent person,

(b) to have a report of the results of

9

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

person or such owner, as may be appropriate, by the person by whom the examination and test was carried out, as soon as may be and in any case not later than 28 days after the completion of the examination and test, and

(c) to give to the Authority a copy of such report within seven days of its receipt in pursuance of subparagraph (b).

(2) A report required under paragraph (1) of this Regulation shall include particulars of:—

(a) the manner in which the relevant examination was carried out,

(b) the method used when making tests,

(c) any defect which in the opinion of the person carrying out the examination could account for or contribute to any failure in the article examined, and

(d) such other matter as the Authority may specify when making the requirement.

(3) Where the Authority is not satisfied as to the adequacy of a report under this Regulation, or as to the competence of a person employed to make an examination and test referred to in this Regulation or as to the adequacy of such an examination and test, it may require the employer, self-employed person or owner of the article concerned to have it re-examined and tested at the expense of such employer, self-employed person or owner by a person

the examination and test prepared and submitted to the employer, self-employed person or such owner, as may be appropriate, by the person by whom the examination and test was carried out, as soon as may be and in any case not later than 28 days after the completion of the examination and test, and

(c) to give to the authority a copy of such report within seven days of its receipt in pursuance of sub-paragraph (b).

(2) A report required under paragraph (1) of this Regulation shall include particulars of:—

(a) the manner in which the relevant examination was carried out,

(b) the method used when making tests,

(c) any structural or other weakness or defect which in the opinion of the person carrying out the examination would affect the ultimate strength of, or account for any failure in the article examined, and

(d) such other matter as the Authority may specify when making the requirement.

(3) Where the Authority is not satisfied as to the adequacy of a report under this Regulation, or as to the competence of a person employed to make an examination and test referred to in this Regulation or as to the adequacy of such an examination and test, it may require the employer, self-employed person or owner of the article concerned to have it re-examined and tested at the expense of such employer, self-

10

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

nominated by the Authority, and where the Authority makes a requirement under this paragraph, such employer, self-employed person or owner shall give any necessary facilities for such re-examination and test.

(4) In any proceedings for an offence under this Regulation it shall be a good defence for the accused to prove that he or she used all due diligence to comply with the requirements of the relevant notice.

employed person or owner by a person nominated by the Authority, and where the Authority makes a requirement under this paragraph, such employer, self-employed person or owner shall give any necessary facilities for such re-examination and test.

(4) In any proceedings for an offence under this Regulation it shall be a good defence for the accused to prove that he used all due diligence to comply with the requirements of the relevant notice.

Revocation8. Part X of and the Twelfth Schedule to the Safety, Health and Welfare at Work (General Application) Regulations 1993 (S.I. No. 44 of 1993) are revoked.

No equivalent provision

Schedule 1 (Regulation 2 and 3)Prescribed Dangerous Occurrences

Twelfth Schedule (Regulation 59)Dangerous Occurrences

Vehicles, lifting and mobile machinery, etc.1. (1) The collapse of, the overturning of, or the failure of any load-bearing part of—

(a) any lift or lifting equipment;

(b) any excavator; or

(c) any pile-driving frame or rig having an overall height, when operating, of more than seven metres.

(2) The overturning of any vehicle or ‘ride-on’ mobile work equipment and/or its towing equipment.

(3) The load shift/loss of load from(a) any vehicle;

(b) any mobile machine; or (a) any towing equipment

Causing a serious risk to a person at work

(4) The failure or malfunction of any lifting equipment associated with a diving project which puts a diver at risk.

Lifting machinery, etc.1. The collapse of, the overturning of, or the failure of any load-bearing part of—

(a) any lift, hoist, crane, derrick or mobile powered access platform;

(b) any excavator; or

(c) any pile-driving frame or rig having an overall height, when operating, of more than seven metres.

11

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

Pressure and vacuum vessels2. The explosion, collapse or bursting of any closed vessel, including a boiler or boiler tube, in which the internal pressure was above or below atmospheric pressure

Pressure vessels2. The explosion, collapse or bursting of any closed vessel, including a boiler or boiler tube, in which the internal pressure was above or below atmospheric pressure.Electrical short circuit3. Electrical short circuit or overload attended by fire or explosion which results in the stoppage of the plant involved for more than 24 hours.

Explosion or fire3. An explosion or fire occurring in any plant or place of work,

Explosion or fire4. An explosion or fire occurring in any plant or place of work which resulted in the stoppage of that plant or suspension of normal work in that place of work for more than twenty four hours, where such explosion or fire was due to the ignition of process materials, their by-products (including waste) or finished products.

Escape of flammable substances4. The sudden uncontrolled release of one tonne or more of highly flammable liquid, liquified flammable gas, flammable gas or flammable liquid above its boiling point from any system, plant or pipe-line.

Escape of flammable substances5. The sudden uncontrolled release of one tonne or more of highly flammable liquid, liquified flammable gas, flammable gas or flammable liquid above its boiling point from any system, plant or pipe-line.

Collapse of scaffolding5. The collapse or partial collapse of any scaffold more than five metres high, including, where the scaffold is slung or suspended a collapse or part collapse of the suspension arrangements (including an outrigger) which causes a working platform or cradle to fall more than five metres.

Collapse of scaffolding6. The collapse or partial collapse of any scaffold more than five metres high which results in a substantial part of the scaffold falling or overturning, including, where the scaffold is slung or suspended a collapse or part collapse of the suspension arrangements (including an outrigger) which causes a working platform or cradle to fall more than five metres.

Collapse of building or structure6. Any unintended collapse or partial collapse of —

(a) any building or structure under construction, reconstruction, alteration or demolition, or of any falsework, involving a fall of more than five tonnes of material; or

(b) any building being used as a place of

Collapse of building or structure7. Any unintended collapse or partial collapse of —

(a) any building or structure under construction, reconstruction, alteration or demolition, or of any falsework, involving a fall of more than five tonnes of material; or

( b ) any floor or wall of any building

12

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

work, not being a building under construction, reconstruction, alteration or demolition.

being used as a place of work, not being a building under construction, reconstruction, alteration or demolition.

Escape of a substance7. The uncontrolled or accidental release or the escape of any substance, which, having regard to the nature of the substance and the extent and location of the release or escape, might have been liable to cause personal injury to any person.

Escape of a substance8. The uncontrolled or accidental release or the escape of any substance from any apparatus, equipment, pipework, pipe-line, process plant, storage vessel, tank, in-works conveyance tanker, land-fill site, or exploratory land-drilling site, which, having regard to the nature of the substance and the extent and location of the release or escape, might have been liable to cause serious injury to any person.

Explosives8. Any unintentional ignition or explosion of explosives.

Explosives9. Any unintentional ignition or explosion of explosives.

Freight containers9. (1) The failure of any container or of any load bearing part thereof while it is being raised, lowered or suspended.

(2) In this paragraph—

"container" means an article of transport equipment which is—

(a) of a permanent character and accordingly strong enough for repeated use, and

(b) designed to facilitate the transport of goods by one or more modes of transport without intermediate reloading, and

(c) designed to be secured or readily handled or both, having corner fittings for these purposes, and

(d) of a size such that the area enclosed by the outer bottom corners is either

Freight containers10. (1) The failure of any container or of any load bearing part thereof while it is being raised, lowered or suspended.

(2) In this paragraph—

"container" means an article of transport equipment which is—

(a) of a permanent character and accordingly strong enough for repeated use, and

(b) designed to facilitate the transport of goods by one or more modes of transport without intermediate reloading, and

(c) designed to be secured or readily handled or both, having corner fittings for these purposes, and

(d) of a size such that the area enclosed by the outer bottom corners is either

13

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

(i) if the container is fitted with top corner fittings, at least 7 square metres, or

(ii) in any case at least 14 square metres

and includes a container when carried on a chassis but does not include a vehicle or packaging or any article of transport equipment designed solely for use in air transport, or a swap body except when it is carried by or on board a sea-going ship and is not mounted on a road vehicle or rail wagon.

"corner fittings" means an arrangement of apertures and faces at either the top or the bottom or both at the top and the bottom of the container for the purposes of handling, stacking and securing or any of those purposes.

(i) if the container is fitted with top corner fittings, at least 7 square metres, or

(ii) in any case at least 14 square metres

and includes a container when carried on a chassis but does not include a vehicle or packaging or any article of transport equipment designed solely for use in air transport, or a swap body except when it is carried by or on board a sea-going ship and is not mounted on a road vehicle or rail wagon.

"corner fittings" means an arrangement of apertures and faces at either the top or the bottom or both at the top and the bottom of the container for the purposes of handling, stacking and securing or any of those purposes.

Pipe-lines10. Either of the following incidents in relation to a pipe-line—

(a) the bursting, explosion or collapse of a pipe-line or any part thereof;

(b) the unintentional release of a substance whether it ignites or not, which by its nature is liable to cause personal injury to any person.

Pipe-lines11. Either of the following incidents in relation to a pipe-line—

(a) the bursting, explosion or collapse of a pipe-line or any part thereof;

(b) the unintentional ignition of anything in a pipe-line, or of anything which immediately before it was ignited was in a pipeline.

Carriage of dangerous goods by road11. Any incident in which a vehicle or tank being used for the carriage of dangerous goods by road—

(a) (i) overturns; or(ii) suffers damage to the package, container, bulk container or tank in which the dangerous goods are being conveyed, and

Conveyance of dangerous substances by road12. (1) (a) Any incident in which a container tank, tank vehicle, tank semi-trailer, tank-trailer, tank-container or goods vehicle being used for conveying a dangerous substance by road—

(i) overturns; or(ii) suffers damage to the package or tank in which the dangerous substance is being conveyed, and

(b) in which there is, in relation to

14

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

(b) in which there is, in relation to such a package, container, bulk container or tank —

(i) an uncontrolled release or escape of the dangerous goods being conveyed; or

(ii) a fire which involves the dangerous goods being conveyed.

such a container, tank, tank vehicle, tank semi-trailer, tank trailer or tank container—

(i) an uncontrolled release or escape of the dangerous substance being conveyed; or

(ii) a fire which involves the dangerous substance being conveyed.

"tank", "tank-container" and "vehicle" have the meanings respectively assigned to them by Regulation 2 of the Dangerous Substances (Conveyance of Scheduled Substances by Road) (Trade or Business) Regulations, 1980 ( S.I. No. 235 of 1980 ), as amended; "container", "tank vehicle", "tank semi-trailer" and "tank trailer" have the meanings respectively assigned to them by Regulation 2 of the Dangerous Substances (Conveyance of Petroleum by Road) Regulations, 1979 ( S.I. No. 314 of 1979 ); "dangerous substance" has the meaning assigned to it by section 24 of the Dangerous Substances Act, 1972 (No. 10 of 1972), as amended, and includes petroleum and petroleum-spirit within the meaning of that Act.

(2) Any incident involving a vehicle, other than a vehicle to which paragraph (1) applies, carrying a dangerous substance by road, where there is—

(a) an uncontrolled release or escape from any package or container of the dangerous substance or dangerous preparation being conveyed, or

(b) a fire which involves the dangerous substance or dangerous preparation being conveyed.

"dangerous substance" has the meaning assigned to it by Regulation 5 of the European Communities (Dangerous

15

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc

Substances) (Classification, Packaging and Labelling) Regulations, 1979 ( S.I. No. 383 of 1979 ), and "dangerous preparation" has the meaning assigned to it by Regulation 5 of the European Communities (Dangerous Substances) (Classification, Packaging and Labelling of Dangerous Preparations) Regulations, 1992 ( S.I. No. 393 of 1992 ).

Breathing Apparatus12. Any incident where breathing apparatus while being used to enable the wearer to breathe independently of the surrounding environment malfunctions in such a way as to be likely either to deprive the wearer of oxygen or, in the case of use in a contaminated atmosphere, to expose the wearer to the contaminant to the extent in either case of posing a danger to his health, but excluding such apparatus while it is being used in a mine or is being maintained or tested.

Breathing Apparatus13. Any incident where breathing apparatus while being used to enable the wearer to breathe independently of the surrounding environment malfunctions in such a way as to be likely either to deprive the wearer of oxygen or, in the case of use in a contaminated atmosphere, to expose the wearer to the contaminant to the extent in either case of posing a danger to his health, but excluding such apparatus while it is being used in a mine or is being maintained or tested.

Overhead Electric Lines and Underground Electric Cables13. Any incident in which plant or equipment, or a person, either comes into contact with an overhead electric line or underground electric cable in which the voltage exceeds 200 volts or causes an electrical discharge from such an electric line or cable by coming into close proximity to it, unless in either case the incident was intentional, arising from or in connection with work activities.

Overhead electric lines14. Any incident in which plant or equipment, including any other overhead line, either comes into contact with an overhead electric line in which the voltage exceeds 200 volts or causes an electrical discharge from such an electric line by coming into close proximity to it, unless in either case the incident was intentional, or any incident involving a live conductor accidentally falling due to breakage or otherwise.

Locomotives14. Any accidental collision between a train and any other vehicle at a factory or at dock premises.

Locomotives15. Any accidental collision between a locomotive or a train and any other vehicle at a factory or at dock premises.

Bursting of vessel, etc.15. The bursting of a revolving vessel, wheel, grindstone, or grinding wheel moved by mechanical power.

Bursting of vessel, etc.16. The bursting of a revolving vessel, wheel, grindstone, or grinding wheel moved by mechanical power.

16

comparison document reporting of accidents illnesses and dangerous occurrences 06 january 2012.doc