-
UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA
EFFECTS OF THINNING ON GROWTH AND SAP FLOW IN NINE-YEAR-
OLD AZADIRACHTA EXCELSA (JACK) IN MERLIMAU, MELAKA, MALAYSIA
ROSDI KOTER
FH 2007 7
-
EFFECTS OF THINNING ON GROWTH AND SAP FLOW IN NINE-YEAR-OLD AZADIRACHTA EXCELSA (JACK) IN MERLIMAU,
MELAKA, MALAYSIA
By
ROSDI KOTER
Thesis submitted to the School of Graduate Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia, in Fulfilment of the Requirements for the
Degree of Master of Science
July 2007
-
To My Wife, Patahayah Mansor and Children, Hafidz, Haziq, Hakeem, Haris and Nureen Asiah
2
-
Abstract of thesis presented to the Senate of Universiti Putra Malaysia in fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Science
EFFECTS OF THINNING ON GROWTH AND SAP FLOW IN NINE-YEAR-OLD AZADIRACHTA EXCELSA (JACK) IN MERLIMAU,
MELAKA,MALAYSIA
By
ROSDI KOTER
July 2007
Chairman : Associate Professor Ahmad Ainuddin Nuruddin, PhD Faculty : Forestry
Since 1997, the forest plantation in Malaysia has gained further momentum
with the inclusion of selected indigenous species for forest plantation
development. Considering the size of plantations being established, the need
for studies on silvicultural operation is widely recognized. Until now, except
for Acacia mangium, there was no specific model on silviculture and
maintenance of each species being planted in Malaysia. The objectives of
this study were to quantify the effects of thinning regime on the diameter
growth, stand volume and crown structure and to determine the effect of sap
flow of thinned and unthinned A. excelsa stands.
The study was conducted in the, Sime Darby Estates, Merlimau, Melaka.
The A.excelsa stands were planted at an initial spacing of 3 x 4 m (833 stem
ha-1) over 2 hectares in May 1995. There were two treatments used for this
study; unthinned as control and moderate thinning, where 50% of the stand
3
-
were felled systematic according to lines. In addition sap flow velocity of
selected trees in both treatments were measured using heat pulse probe
connected to data logger.
During the study, the achieved mean diameter at breast height of A. excelsa
was 14.30 ± 0.81 cm and the mean of the potential final crop trees (300 trees
ha-1) of 18.99 ± 0.78 cm. The mean periodic annual diameter increment was
1.87 ± 0.07 cm year-1 before thinning and 1.60 ± 0.08 cm year-1 23 months
after thinning. The periodical annual diameter increments are not
significantly different between plots after 23 months. The diameter increment
is still increasing indicating that the growth of the species has not reached
the optimum rate.
The response to thinning also includes the effect on the expansion of the
crowns. Results presented from this trial have indicated that the thinning has
a positive effect on crown development in which thinned A.excelsa stand
reached up to 6.5 m in length, as compared with the unthined treatment up to
5.0 m. The crown length increment was significantly, being greater by
quantify by 30% in the thinned plot. The crown radial of both unthinned and
thinned stand varied from 0.2 to 3.6 m and 0.1 to 4.2 m respectively.
The amount of water loss in the thinned stand was significantly higher than
those in the unthinned plot, 0.53 liter/hour compared with 0.32 liter/hour
respectively. The rate of water loss for A. excelsa at thinned stand was
higher than those from unthinned stand with a total of 12.02 liters and 10.27
4
-
liters over day respectively. Higher soil moisture content was also observed
in thinned plot compared to unthinned plot.
This study provides useful information on the growth of A.excelsa due to
thinning activities by creating the gap opening and the water loss implication
after thinning was undertaken. Such information is useful in making long-term
growth projections with growth adjusted to variation of microclimate within the
stand.
5
-
Abstrak tesis yang dikemukakan kepada Senat Universiti Putra Malaysia sebagai memenuhi keperluan untuk ijazah Master Sains
KESAN PENJARANGAN KE ATAS PERLADANGAN SENTANG (Azadirachta excelsa (Jack).)
BERUMUR 9 TAHUN DI MERLIMAU, MELAKA, SEMENANJUNG MALAYSIA
Oleh
ROSDI KOTER
July 2007
Pengerusi : Profesor Madya Ahmad Ainuddin Nuruddin, PhD Fakulti : Perhutanan Sejak tahun 1997, perladangan hutan di Malaysia telah berkembang ke
peringkat yang lebih intensif. Mengambilkira kepada saiz ladang yang
menunjukkan pertambahan dari segi keluasan dan adalah perlu diberikan
penekanan terhadap penyelidikan di dalam operasi silvikultur. Hingga kini,
masih tiada model silvikultur dan penyelenggaraan yang khusus untuk
spesies pokok yang di tanam secara ladang di Malaysia kecuali untuk Acacia
mangium. Objektif kajian ini dijalankan ialah untuk mengukur kesan
penjarangan ke atas pertumbuhan diameter, isipadu dirian, bentuk batang
dan struktur dan untuk mengenalpasti kesan penggunaan air di dalam dirian
yang dijalankan penjarangan dan tidak dijalankan penjarangan.
Kajian ini telah dijalankan di Estet Sime Darby, Merlimau, Melaka. Dirian ini
telah ditanam pada bulan Mei 1995 dengan jarak awal 3 x 4 m (833 pokok
/ha) di kawasan seluas 2 ha. Kajian dijalankan untuk menentukan kesan
penjarangan ke atas pertumbuhan pokok dan penggunaan air.
6
-
Purata pencapaian diameter paras dada ialah 14.30 ± 0.81 cm. Manakala
potensi pokok akhir (300 pokok/ha) mencapai purata diameter sebanyak
18.99 ± 0.4 cm. Pertambahan diameter tahunan didapati tidak menunjukkan
perbezaan yang bererti antara tahun dan plot dengan purata pertambahan
diameter tahunan ialah 1.87 ± 0.07 sm per tahun sebelum penjarangan dan
1.60 ± 0.10 sm per tahun selepas dua tahun penjarangan. Pemerhatian juga
menunjukkan pertambahan purata diameter tahunan masih meningkat dan
belum lagi mencapai tahap kemuncak.
Kesan penjarangan juga dapat diperhatikan ke atas pertambahan silara.
Keputusan menunjukkan bahawa penjarangan telah memebrikan kesan
yang positif terhadap perkembangan silara di mana dirian yang dijalankan
penjarangan mencapai 6.5 m tinggi silara berbanding dengan dirian tanpa
penjarangan yang hanya mencapai 5.0 m tinggi silara. Perbezaan ini
menunjukkan terdapat pertambahan sebanyak 30% apabila penjaranagn di
jalankan. Jejari silara pula menunjukan nilai dari 0.2 hingga 3.6 m dan 0.1
hingga 4.2 m masing-masing untuk dirian tanpa penjaranagn dan yang
dijalankan penjarangan.
Keputusan juga menunjukkan bahawa kadar kehilangan air adalah tinggi
iaitu sebanyak 12.024 liter berbanding dengan yang tidak dilakukan
penjarangan (kawalan) iaitu dengan kadar 10.273 liter dalam sehari. Kadar
purata kehilangan air menunjukkan terdapat perbezaan bererti di mana
penggunaannya ialah sebanyak 0.53 liter/sejam bagi petak penjarangan
manakala 0.32 liter/sejam bagi petak kawalan. Kandungan kelembapan air
7
-
tanah juga didapati tinggi di petak yang dijalankan penjarangan berbanding
petak kawalan.
Kajian ini dapat dijadikan asas dalam menyediakan data pertumbuhan
sentang kesan dari penjarangan yang mengakibatkan pembentukan ruang
hutan dan kadar kehilangan air selepas penjarangan dijalankan. Kesemua
maklumat ini amat berguna dalam membuat perancangan masa hadapan
melalui unjuran pertumbuhan berasaskan kepada variasi mikro-iklim di
dalam dirian.
8
-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I wish to express my most sincere and deepest thanks to the Chairman of my
Supervisory, Associate Professor Dr. Ahmad Ainuddin Nuruddin for his
valuable guidance, advice, encouragement, constructive criticisms and
suggestions throughout the study. I also wish to express my sincere thanks
to the other committee members, Associate Professor Dr. Mohd. Zaki
Hamzah and Dr. Ab Rasip Ab Ghani for their guidance rendered.
Grateful acknowledgement is due to the Director General of Forest Research
Institute Malaysia (FRIM) Dato’ Dr. Abdul Razak Mohd Ali for his permission
and encouragement to undertake this programme. I also acknowledge the
permission granted by Sime Darby Plantation, Merlimau, Malacca for
allowing me to use the study site. Sincere thanks are due to the staff of the
Forest Plantation Program, FRIM especially to Dr. Ahmad Zuhaidi Yahya, Dr.
Hashim Mohd Noor, Mohd Noor Mahat and Mohd Zaki Abdullah and also the
staff of the Silviculture Unit and Hydrology Unit for assistance in data
collection and analysis.
Finally, I would like to dedicate this work to my parents, my wife Fatah and
my children Hafidz, Haziq, Hakeem, Haris and Nureen, who without their love
and devotion, this study would not have been completed. I love you all!
9
-
I certify that an Examination Committee has met on 13th of July 2007 to conduct the final examination of Rosdi Koter in his Master of Science thesis entitled “Effect Of Thinning On Nine Years Old Azadirachta Excelsa (Jack) Plantation In Merlimau, Melaka, Peninsular Malaysia” in accordance with Universiti Putra Malaysia (Higher Degree) Act 1980 and Universiti Putra Malysia (Higher Degree) Regulations 1981. The Committee recommended that the candidate be awarded the relevant degree. Members of the Examination Committee are as follows: Azani Alias, PhD Associate Professor Faculty of Forestry Universiti Putra Malaysia (Chairman) Norani Abd Shukor, PhD Professor Faculty of Forestry Universiti Putra Malaysia (Examiner) Lai Food See, PhD Associate Professor Faculty of Forestry Universiti Putra Malaysia (Examiner) Aminuddin Mohamad, PhD Professor School Of Forestry Universiti Malaysia Sabah (External Examiner)
_______________________________ HASANAH MOHD GHAZALI, PhD Professor/Deputy Dean School of Graduate Studies Universiti Putra Malaysia Date:
10
-
This thesis was submitted to the Senate of Universiti Putra Malaysia and has been accepted as fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Science. The members of the Supervisory Committee were as follows: Ahmad Ainuddin Nuruddin, PhD Associate Professor Faculty of Forestry Universiti Putra Malaysia (Chairman) Mohd Zaki Hamzah, PhD Associate Professor Faculty of Forestry Universiti Putra Malaysia (Member) Ab Rasip Ab Ghani, PhD Forest Research Institute Malaysia (FRIM) (Member) ________________________ AINI IDERIS, PhD Professor and Dean School of Graduate Studies Universiti Putra Malaysia Date: 13 December 2007
11
-
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that the thesis is based on my original work except for quotations and citations which have been duly acknowledged. I also declare that it has not been previously or concurrently submitted for any other degree at UPM or other institutions.
________________________ ROSDI KOTER Date: October
12
-
TABLES OF CONTENTS
Page
DEDICATION 2 ABSTRACT 3 ABSTRAK 6 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 9 APPROVAL 10 DECLARATION 14 LIST OF TABLES 15 LIST OF FIGURES 16 LIST OF ABREVIATIONS 17
CHAPTER
I INTRODUCTION 19 General introduction 19 Forest plantation in Malaysia-background 19
Problem statements 22 Objectives 24 Hypotheses
24
II LITERATURE REVIEW 25 The current status of forest plantation programme in Malaysia 25 Introduction 25 Future direction of forest plantation in Malaysia 27 Forest plantation species 29 Azadirachta excelsa (Jack). Jacobs 29 Thinning 38 Thinning trial experiences on plantation species 42 Sap flow 43 III METHODOLOGY 46
Site description 46 Study site 46 Climate and rainfall 46 Sentang stand 50 Experimental approach 51 Data collection 54 Tree measurement 54 Diameter measurement 55 Total tree height and crown-length measurement 55 Potential Crop Trees (PCT) 57 Crown radial and diameter 57 Basal area 58 Stem and stand volume 58
13
-
Periodic annual diameter increment 59 Meteorology parameters 59 Heat pulse velocity technique 60 Data logger 63 Data analysis
64
IV RESULTS 65 Growth and yield 65 Basal area and volume increment 65 Potential crop trees (PCT) 69 Crown structure 70 Diameter class distribution 71 Diameter increment 73 Sap flow 74
V DISCUSSIONS 78 Growth and yield 78
Basal area and volume increment 83 Potential crop trees (PCT) 84 Crown structure 85 Diameter increment 86 Sap flow 88 Soil Moisture 90
VI CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 92 Conclusions 92 Recommendations 94 REFERENCES 95 BIODATA OF THE AUTHOR 104
14
-
LIST OF TABLES
Page
Table 2.1
Supply and demand of logs in Peninsular Malaysia, 1981 to 2010 (Mil m3)
26
Table 2.2 Growth rate of Azadirachta excelsa as compared to other forest plantation tree species (2004)
34
Table 2.3 Distribution of A.excelsa plantations in Peninsular Malaysia in 2001
37
Table 3.1
Diameter at breast height (DBH) for each selected trees measured for sap flow
61
Table 4.1 Stand and stock tables for 9-y old A.excelsa stands in Sime Darby plantation in Merlimau Melaka
66
Table 4.2 ANOVA table for diameter increment of Azadirachta excelsa after 9-years planting
67
Table 4.3 Calculated MAIv and CAIv at the beginning and at the end of the observation period (1999-2004)
68
Table 4.4 Current stocking parameters of potential crop tree (PCT) (200 trees/ha)
70
Table 4.5 Crown structure of unthinned and thinned Azadirachta excelsa after 9-years planting
71
Table 4.6 ANOVA table for crown increment of Azadirachta excelsa after 9-years planting
71
Table 4.7 Duncan Multiple Range Test of the daily hourly average between the treatments after 9-years planting
76
Table 5.1 The results of the daily hourly average for sap flow on other studies
89
Table 5.2 Soil moisture content (%) of thinned and unthinned stand of Azadirachta excelsa in Sime Darby Plantation Merlimau, Malacca (Mohd. Hanif 2003)
91
15
-
LIST OF FIGURES
Page
Figure 2.1 Azadirachta excelsa (Jack) Jacobs – 1, habit of young tree; 2, flowering twig; 3,sectioned flower; 4, branchlet with fruits
31
Figure 2.2 Mature stand of A. excelsa with pale brown bark, fissured longitudinally
32
Figure 3.1 Map showing the study site in Sime Darby, Merlimau, Melaka
47
Figure 3.2 Total annual rainfall and number of rain days at study site from 1997 to 2003
48
Figure 3.3 Maximum and minimum temperature at study site (1997 to 2003 )
49
Figure 3.4
Average hourly relative humidity (RH) and air temperature (AT) at study site (April to August 2002)
50
Figure 3.5 9-year-old Sentang stand in Sime Darby Plantation, Merlimau, Malacca
51
Figure 3.6 Diagram showing experimental plot and location of equipment
52
Figure 3.7 Systematic thinning activity
53
Figure 3.8 Tree felling using chainsaw in thinned plot
54
Figure 3.9 Drill the three holes slowly with the drill bits and drill guide to ensure that the holes are parallel.
62
Figure 3.10 The jig enforces a nominal spacing of 10 & 5 mm above & below the heater. The depth of the probe sensor placement was deliberately towards the outside where sap flux is higher.
62
Figure 3.11 The entire implanted portion of the trunk was wrapped with the aluminum foil to act as a solar radiation shield.
63
Figure 3.12 The logger was connected to the computer for starting the data logging and also data retrieving
64
Figure 4.1 Relationship between current annual volume increment and mean annual volume increment with age
68
16
-
Figure 4.2 Diameter Distribution of A.excelsa After 9-years Planting For control (unthinned plot)
72
Figure 4.3 Diameter Distribution of A.excelsa After 9-years Planting For thinned plot
73
Figure 4.4 Mean diameter increment of A.excelsa 9-years after planting
74
Figure 4.5 Sap flow rate of Azadirachta excelsa for thinned plot
75
Figure 4.6 Sap flow rate of Azadirachta excelsa for unthinned plot
75
Figure 4.7 Light intensity for one week period (20-24 January 2003)
76
17
-
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
asl Above Sea Level
Anon Anonymous
ANOVA Analysis of Variance
DBH
Diameter at Breast Height
DMRT Duncan’s Multiple Range Test
FAO
Food Agriculture Organization
FDPM Forestry Department Peninsular Malaysia
FRIM Forest Research Institute Malaysia
GLM Generalized Linear Model
ha Hectare
PROC Procedure
SAS Statistical Analysis System
UPM Universiti Putra Malaysia
PPFD Photosynthetic Photon Flux Density
18
-
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
General Introduction
Forest plantation in Malaysia-background
The history of forest plantation in Malaysia began in 1800 with the
introduction of exotic tree species such as rubber (Hevea brasiliensis) and
teak (Tectona grandis). H. brasiliensis was first introduced in Malaysia in
1877 when nine seedlings of rubber were planted at Kuala Kangsar in the
state of Perak.
By the early 1900's the demand for natural rubber had increased dramatically
as the result of the expansion of car and electrical industries. Introduction of
new land regulations also stimulated interests in rubber planting. The
suitability of climatic conditions and the liberal government allocation of land,
coupled with the availability of cheap labour led to rapid expansion of rubber
land in Malaysia. The rubber trees seemed to thrive better in Malaysia than
its native habitat in Brazil particularly for being more resistance against
natural diseases and pests. By the end of 1999 a total of 1,700 ha of pilot
rubber forest plantations had been established in various locations.
Teak, the most notable exotic timber species planted in plantation in this
country, was first introduced in Penang in the 1800's and the earliest teak
plantation was initiated at Sungai Raya in Langkawi Island around 1915. The
19
-
planting of teak was then extended to mainland Kedah and Perlis in 1940s
and 1950s. By the end of 2001, the total teak plantation established in
Peninsular Malaysia is 3,107 ha.
During the late 1950s and early 1960s, large scale pilot planting of several
fast growing exotic species was conducted, particularly Pinus, Araucaria and
Eucalyptus species, mainly in expectation of the establishment of the pulp
and paper industry in Peninsular Malaysia. The planting of pine was
discontinued in 1980 when the proposal to set up pulp and paper mill in
Peninsular Malaysia was cancelled.
Meanwhile, the search for potential fast growing hardwood species continues
persistently. Several exotics including Acacia mangium, Paraserianthes
falcataria and Gmelina arborea were identified as potential species for the
establishment of short-rotation forest plantation, to produce general utility
timber. Hence in 1982 the Compensatory Forest Plantation Project (CFPP)
was launched in the states of Pahang, Johore, Selangor and Negeri
Sembilan with the projected target of 188,000 ha. The project was jointly
funded through loans from the Government of Malaysia and the Asian
Development Bank. However, in 1992, there was a moratorium imposed on
the planting of A. mangium due to the widespread occurrence of heart rot
disease in most plantation sites.
Concurrently, potential of utilizing local species was also being explored.
Species such as Sentang (Azadirachta excelsa) has caught the attention of
the plantation industry. This species has shown good growth rates in early
years and is almost pest free. Planting of A. excelsa was initiated by the
20
-
State Forestry Departments in 1993 and 1994, including Kelantan and
Terengganu (Forest Department Peninsular Malaysia, 1999). Since then the
interest to plant A. excelsa has increased. A number of smallholders have
replanted their rubber with A. excelsa especially in the states of Terengganu
and Johore. In 1997 the government, through the Forest Research Institute
of Malaysia (FRIM) and other forestry agencies started to promote A. excelsa
for forest plantation (Baskaran, 1997). By 1999 the Forest Department of
Peninsular Malaysia had established 1765 ha of A. excelsa plantations
(Forest Department Peninsular Malaysia, 2000).
In 2001, forest plantations of Peninsular Malaysia covered a total area of
74,804 ha comprising mainly of A. mangium and small percentage of P.
falcataria and G. arborea. More than 15 000 ha were planted in 1988 and
more than 10 000 ha in 1985. Most of the plantations were established
during the first phase of the Compensatory Forest Plantation Programme
between 1982 and 1988. Since 1989, an annual planting rate had never
exceeded 7 000 ha (Baskaran & Ong, 2003). There was a dramatic drop in
planting rate after 1998 due to the economic recession across Southeast
Asia since late 1997.
21
-
Problem statements
The study of growth and yield of forest stands is a central issue in forestry
research and management. In recent years, much emphasis has been
placed on the growth and yield of mixed tropical forest and management
activities related to.(Lieberman & Lieberman 1987; Vanclay 1989; Yong
1990; Silva et al. 1995; Ong & Kleine 1995; Alder 1995; Kohler & Huth 1998)
and sub-tropical forests (Rautiainen, Pukkala, T. & Miina 2001). However, a
full understanding of the growth and yield of plantation-grown indigenous
tropical species such as A. excelsa is still lacking. Thus, this study was
initiated after recognizing the importance of growth and yield studies of
plantation-grown indigenous fast growing species for future forest
management decisions, coupled with a general paucity of knowledge on the
growth and potential yield of the species planted under plantation condition.
The species of A. excelsa is regarded among the most promising indigenous
species for forest plantation in Peninsular Malaysia and future reforestation
works with this species will cover a wide spectrum of land areas including
flat, undulating and even sloping topography.
Considering the size of plantation being established, the need for studies on
silvicultural operation is more widely recognized. Until now, except for
Acacia mangium, there was no specific model on silviculture and
maintenance of each species being planted in Malaysia. Most of the planting
is based on general plantation silviculture and management. Thinning
treatment for instance, gives a strong effect on the wood quality and the
22
-
yield. Therefore, as each tree species performed differently, the treatment
should be modeled accordingly to fit the growth behavior of the species.
Study on the influence of thinning on environmental factors is usually
neglected, although the cause of success or failure may be found in changes
in these factors brought about by the thinning operation. Studies of
environmental changes will not be necessary in all thinning plots. However,
sufficient studies should be made to show how much these factors are
altered by thinning practices. For example, if it can be shown that changes in
water use are most important, thinning should be made that creates optimum
conditions.
Only few studies have been made in Malaysia to study the water use in
relation to stand density with subjected to natural forest stand conditions only
(Siti Aishah, 2004)..Therefore when such management practice need to be
developed to a particular species in forest plantation it is important to monitor
not only the growth but also water uses which is related to the water budget
of the area.
The studies provide an opportunity to generate baseline information for future
planting of A. excelsa under plantation condition. Information on growth and
potential yield of the species can be used in the planning for future
establishment and management planning for future A. excelsa
plantations,while the sapflow study can provide information on how thinning
23
-
regimes has the potential on helping the forest to retain water in the soil and
evaporation.
In this thesis, the initial goal is to evaluate the growth performance and sap
flow within a thinning and adjacent unthinned stand of Azadirachta excelsa.
The knowledge will assist in establishing the best methods of thinning, and in
addition provide information on tree growth due to thinning activities.
Objectives
1. To evaluate and compare growth between thinned and unthinned
stand of. A.excelsa
2. To evaluate variation of microclimate within a thinned and adjacent
unthinned stand.
Hypotheses
H0: i) There is no significant effect on tree growth due to thinning.
ii) There is no significant effect on water use before and after thinning
H1: i) There is significant effect on tree growth due to thinning.
ii) There is significant effect on water use before and after thinning
24