![Page 1: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET
with the ITER-like Wall
Costanza Maggi
CCFE, Culham Science Centre, Abingdon, OX14 3DB UK
26th IAEA Fusion Energy Conference, Kyoto, Japan, 2016
![Page 2: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Acknowledgements
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 2
L Frassinetti1, L Horvath2, A Lunniss2, S Saarelma3, H Wilson2, FJ Casson3, E Delabie4,
D King3, M Leyland2, I Lupelli3, S Pamela3, A Sips5, H Urano6, H Weisen7 and JET
Contributors*
EUROfusion Consortium, JET
Culham Science Centre, Abingdon, OX14 3DB, UK
1Association VR, Fusion Plasma Physics, KTH, SE-10044 Stockholm, Sweden 2York Plasma Institute, Department of Physics, University of York, York YO10 5DD, UK 3CCFE, Culham Science Centre, Abingdon OX14 3DB, UK 4Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee, US 5European Commission, Brussels, Belgium 6National Institutes for QST, Naka, Ibaraki 311-0193, Japan 7SPC, Ecole Polytechnique Federale de Lausanne, Switzerland
*See the author list of “Overview of the JET results in support to ITER” by X Litaudon et al., to be published in Nuclear Fusion
Special Issue: Overview and summary reports from the 26th Fusion Energy Conference (Kyoto, Japan, 17-22 October 2016)
![Page 3: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Outline
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 3
• Pedestal width scaling
• Pedestal evolution during the ELM cycle
• First results on isotope effects
![Page 4: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Width & gradient independent of r*
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 4
• No sizeable dependence of Dpe(y) and aexp on r*
• Consistent with JET-C/DIII-D and JT-60U
[Beurskens, PoP 2011] [Urano, NF 2008]
Dimensionless r* scan
[Frassinetti, PPCF 2016]
Dpe(y) aexp
![Page 5: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Pedestal width broadens with beta poloidal
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 5
• Dpe (y) broadens consistently with bpol,PED dependence at
low D2 gas injection rates
[Maggi, NF 2015]
Power scans at low and high d
1.4MA/1.7T
Low D2 gas rate ~ 3 x 1021 e/s
![Page 6: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Pedestal width broadens with gas rate
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 6
• Dpe (y) broadens with increasing D2 gas rate at constant bpol,PED
[Leyland, NF 2015]
[Maggi, NF 2015]
Power and gas scans
1.4MA/1.7T
G = 3 x 1021 e/s
G = 8 x 1021 e/s
G = 18 x 1021 e/s
G = 3 x 1021 e/s
![Page 7: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Dpe(y) broadens with n* at constant bpol,PED
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 7
Dpe (y) ~ (bpol,PED)0.5 (n*PED)0.26
Dimensionless n* scan at low d
[Frassinetti, NF 2016]
![Page 8: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Normalized Dpe broadens at constant n*
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 8
• Dpe (y)/bpol,PED broadens with increasing D2 gas rate at
constant n*PED possible role of atomic physics
Power and gas scans
1.4MA/1.7T
G = 3 x 1021 e/s
G = 8 x 1021 e/s
G = 18 x 1021 e/s
G = 3 x 1021 e/s
![Page 9: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Outline
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 9
• Pedestal width scaling
• Pedestal evolution during the ELM cycle
• First results on isotope effects
![Page 10: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
EPED model assumption
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 10
• P-B constraint
• KBM constraint
• Pedestal pressure gradient grows unconstrained (a)
• KBM boundary is reached (proxy: Dp ~ bpol,PED )
• pPED can only increase further via widening of Dp at fixed p (b)
• P-B boundary is reached type I ELM is triggered (c)
a
b c
[Snyder, NF 2011]
![Page 11: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Profile analysis during the ELM cycle
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 11
Te
ne
• pe,PED and Dpe from mtanh fit to experimental HRTS pressure data
Te,PED and ne,PED typically not
at same radial location
HRTS
![Page 12: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Low gas injection: P-B constraint satisfied
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 12
The pre-ELM edge stability (Helena/ELITE) is consistent with the
ELMs being triggered by P-B modes, both at low and high bN
[Challis, NF 2015]
[Maggi, NF 2015]
[Saarelma, PoP 2015]
Power scans at low and high d
1.4MA/1.7T
Low D2 gas rate ~ 3 x 1021 e/s
![Page 13: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
pe,PED evolution at low gas injection
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 13
• Low bN: pe,PED increases due to steepening of pe at ~ constant width
not consistent with KBM constraint not consistent with EPED
• High bN: pe increases, then saturates & Dpe narrows then widens
consistent with KBM constraint consistent with EPED
![Page 14: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Power scans at high D2 gas injection
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 14
• P-B constraint satisfied at low bN
• P-B constraint not satisfied at higher bN: missing physics for the
ELM trigger?
[Maggi, NF 2015]
![Page 15: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
pe,PED evolution at high gas injection
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 15
• Low bN: width narrows & gradient steepens, then Δp broadens & p reduces
qualitatively consistent with KBM constraint + P-B constraint satisfied
consistent with EPED
• High bN: Δpe ~ constant and pe first increases, then ~ saturates qualitatively
consistent with KBM constraint + P-B constraint not satisfied not consistent
with EPED
![Page 16: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Temperature gradient saturates at high gas rate
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 16
• Te initially increases, then clamps half way of ELM cycle
• suggestive of instabilities limiting growth of Te,ped : MTMs?
See e.g exploratory GK study by [Hatch, NF 2016]
![Page 17: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Increasing neutral gas (n*) reduces jBS
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 17
jBS(NEO) increases
jBS(NEO) constant
bN = 2.8
bN = 2.5
bN = 2.0
[Horvath, EPS 2016]
• Avoiding saturation of Te during the ELM cycle is crucial to
maximizing pedestal performance
![Page 18: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Outline
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 18
• Pedestal width scaling
• Pedestal evolution during the ELM cycle
• First results on isotope effects
![Page 19: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Isotope effect of type I / type III ELM threshold
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 19
• Power threshold for type I ELMs ~ doubles from D to H
1.4MA/1.7T, low d
Power and gas scans
![Page 20: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Isotope effect of energy confinement
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 20
• Lower energy confinement in H than in D
Preliminary,
assuming Ti = Te
Power scans at same
gas injection rate
L-modes
![Page 21: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Edge Te - ne diagram
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 21
• Weak fuelling efficiency in D type I ELMy H-modes
• pe,PED decreases in D as gas rate and power
G = 3-4 x 1021 e/s
G = 8 x 1021 e/s
G = 16 x 1021 e/s
![Page 22: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Hydrogen type III ELMy pedestals
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 22
• Lower density in H than in D
G = 3-4 x 1021 e/s
G = 8 x 1021 e/s
G = 16 x 1021 e/s
![Page 23: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
H vs D type I ELMy pedestals
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 23
• Lower density and stronger fuelling efficiency in H than in D
• Hydrogen type I ELMy pedestals evolve at similar pe,PED
G = 3-4 x 1021 e/s
G = 8 x 1021 e/s
G = 18 x 1021 e/s
G = 3.5 7.5 x 1022 e/s
![Page 24: Studies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER ... · PDF fileStudies of the Pedestal Structure in JET with the ITER-like Wall Costanza Maggi CCFE, ... PowerPoint Presentation](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022052710/5a9f00c37f8b9a67178c37e5/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Conclusions
CF Maggi | 26th IAEA FEC | Kyoto | 19.10.2016 | Page 24
• Pedestal width is independent of r*, widens with bpol,PED
at low gas injection and with n*/gas rate at constant bpol,PED
• Inter-ELM pedestal evolution depends on discharge
conditions & not always consistent with EPED paradigm
• Avoiding saturation of Te as pedestal re-builds between
ELMs is crucial for maximizing pedestal performance
• Edge GK analyses and experimental identification of
nature of pedestal turbulence in JET-ILW are needed
• Strong isotope effect in energy and particle confinement