Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
A New Direction in the A New Direction in the Warning ProcessWarning Process
Add NameAdd Name
National Weather ServiceNational Weather Service
Add OfficeAdd Office
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
OverviewOverview
Brief History of Storm Based (SB) Brief History of Storm Based (SB) WarningsWarningsImplementation Schedule Implementation Schedule SB Methodology SB Methodology ResourcesResourcesBenefits Benefits Challenges Challenges Summary Summary
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
Brief History Brief History
Sub County Information Added to NWS Short Sub County Information Added to NWS Short Duration Warnings in the late 1990sDuration Warnings in the late 1990s– ““Area of Maximum Impact” Defined by Sets of Area of Maximum Impact” Defined by Sets of
LAT/LON Point Pairs At Bottom of Text LAT/LON Point Pairs At Bottom of Text WarningsWarnings
– Polygon – Graphical Depiction of the LAT/LON Polygon – Graphical Depiction of the LAT/LON Point Pairs Point Pairs
– Short Duration WarningsShort Duration Warnings – Tornado, Severe – Tornado, Severe Thunderstorm, Flash Flood and Special Marine Thunderstorm, Flash Flood and Special Marine
Sub County Information Added to Follow Up Sub County Information Added to Follow Up Statements in 2002 Statements in 2002 – Allowed Forecasters to Update the “Area of Allowed Forecasters to Update the “Area of
Maximum Impact” Based on Current Conditions Maximum Impact” Based on Current Conditions The Warning Still Involved the Entire County!The Warning Still Involved the Entire County!
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
Brief History Part II Brief History Part II
Demonstration at 25 Forecast Offices in 2005 Demonstration at 25 Forecast Offices in 2005 – Reduction in total area warned - Reduction in total area warned - 73% 73% – Reduction in total number of towns warned Reduction in total number of towns warned
- - 70%70%NWS Senior Leadership Approves The NWS Senior Leadership Approves The Change to Storm Based Warnings in Change to Storm Based Warnings in December 2005 December 2005 NWS Meets With National Private Weather NWS Meets With National Private Weather Vendors in December 2006 to Discuss Vendors in December 2006 to Discuss Software Changes Required to Support The Software Changes Required to Support The Change to Storm Based Warnings Change to Storm Based Warnings
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Approach EliminatesSB Approach EliminatesArea FalseArea FalseAlarmedAlarmed
SB False Alarm Area SB False Alarm Area ReductionReduction
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB False Alarm Area SB False Alarm Area ReductionReduction
County Based Warnings Storm Based Warnings
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
Value of reduced area Value of reduced area warnedwarned
Dr. Daniel S. Sutter*, Associate Professor of Economics, Dr. Daniel S. Sutter*, Associate Professor of Economics, University of Oklahoma estimates that…University of Oklahoma estimates that…
If the typical polygon warning was about 1/4 the size If the typical polygon warning was about 1/4 the size of the typical warned county, the value of reduced of the typical warned county, the value of reduced area under warnings would be almost area under warnings would be almost $50 million per $50 million per yearyear; ;
Reducing the area of the typical tornado warning to Reducing the area of the typical tornado warning to 1/41/4 of the current county size would produce about of the current county size would produce about the same increase in value of the warning as reducing the same increase in value of the warning as reducing the false alarm rate to the false alarm rate to zerozero. .
* Author of “eco-weather” articles in * Author of “eco-weather” articles in Weather and ForecastingWeather and Forecasting 2002 and 2005 2002 and 2005
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Implementation SB Implementation
Implementation Date – October 1, Implementation Date – October 1, 20072007
Products Impacted Products Impacted – Tornado Warnings Tornado Warnings – Severe Thunderstorm Warnings Severe Thunderstorm Warnings – Flash Flood Warnings Flash Flood Warnings – Special Marine Warnings Special Marine Warnings – Severe Weather StatementsSevere Weather Statements– Flash Flood StatementsFlash Flood Statements– Marine Weather Statements Marine Weather Statements
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Methodology SB Methodology Forecast Office Issues a Warning For A Portion of Forecast Office Issues a Warning For A Portion of County or Counties County or Counties – Warned Area Defined and Depicted By The Polygon Warned Area Defined and Depicted By The Polygon
(LAT/LON Point Pairs) (LAT/LON Point Pairs) – Portions of Counties Verbally Described by Compass Points Portions of Counties Verbally Described by Compass Points
(e.g. North, Northeast, East, Southwest, Central etc.)(e.g. North, Northeast, East, Southwest, Central etc.)
Forecast Office Updates a Warning Using a Follow Forecast Office Updates a Warning Using a Follow Statement Statement – Polygon Can Shrink In Area, But Not Expand Polygon Can Shrink In Area, But Not Expand
Forecast Office Cancels the Warning or Allows It to Forecast Office Cancels the Warning or Allows It to Expire When Conditions No Longer Meet Warning Expire When Conditions No Longer Meet Warning Criteria Criteria IMPORTANT – More Than One Warning Can Be IMPORTANT – More Than One Warning Can Be In Effect For One County at the Same Time!In Effect For One County at the Same Time!
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Resources SB Resources
NWS RIDGE Radar Display NWS RIDGE Radar Display – Available on Every WFO Web Site Available on Every WFO Web Site
Private Weather Vendors Were Briefed In Private Weather Vendors Were Briefed In December 2006 December 2006
Weather Data, WSIWeather Data, WSIBarons, MeteorologixBarons, Meteorologix
Graphical displays via weather radios, cell Graphical displays via weather radios, cell phones, PDAs, etc.phones, PDAs, etc.
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Benefits SB Benefits Warnings Focused on Weather and Water Hazards Warnings Focused on Weather and Water Hazards – Warned Area Reduced on Average By 75%; Up to 97% Warned Area Reduced on Average By 75%; Up to 97%
Reduction in Western U.S. CountiesReduction in Western U.S. Counties– ““Blue Sky” Effect Reduced By Finer Resolution WarningsBlue Sky” Effect Reduced By Finer Resolution Warnings
Warnings Defined By GIS CoordinatesWarnings Defined By GIS Coordinates– Adaptable to Local Distribution Via Cell Phones, PDAs, etc. Adaptable to Local Distribution Via Cell Phones, PDAs, etc. – Improved Display Capabilities for Television, Internet Improved Display Capabilities for Television, Internet
Better Public ServiceBetter Public Service– Improved Information For Decision Makers – Emergency Improved Information For Decision Makers – Emergency
Managers Managers – More Accurate Depiction of Threat To U.S. Citizens More Accurate Depiction of Threat To U.S. Citizens – Warnings Are The Best Science and Technology Can Warnings Are The Best Science and Technology Can
Provide Provide
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
One WFOs Study (2004)One WFOs Study (2004)
In 2004, issued tornado warnings for counties that In 2004, issued tornado warnings for counties that covered:covered:– 31,990 square miles31,990 square miles– Included 494 individual townsIncluded 494 individual townsUtilizing the polygon approach, the polygons Utilizing the polygon approach, the polygons covered:covered:– 9,500 square miles9,500 square miles– Included 152 individual townsIncluded 152 individual townsIf the polygon approach were in place:If the polygon approach were in place: – Would have Would have reducedreduced our total warning area by our total warning area by
22,490 square miles22,490 square miles– Would have unnecessarily warned 242 Would have unnecessarily warned 242 fewerfewer towns towns– That's a That's a reduction of 70%!reduction of 70%!
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Benefits – Demographic/Census SB Benefits – Demographic/Census Information Information
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SB Challenges SB Challenges Legacy Dissemination Technology Is County Based Legacy Dissemination Technology Is County Based – NOAA Weather Radio NOAA Weather Radio – EAS Activation (FCC) EAS Activation (FCC) – Majority of Siren Systems (County/Local Government) Majority of Siren Systems (County/Local Government)
Multiple Warnings in One County Multiple Warnings in One County – Easy To Differentiate Graphically; Easy To Differentiate Graphically; Hard to Describe Verbally Hard to Describe Verbally
– VTEC Event Tracking Number Uniquely Defines Multiple VTEC Event Tracking Number Uniquely Defines Multiple
Warnings For Parsing Computer Programs Warnings For Parsing Computer Programs
Environmental Factors and Drawing Polygons Environmental Factors and Drawing Polygons – Right and Left Turning Supercells Right and Left Turning Supercells – Pulse Thunderstorms Pulse Thunderstorms – Basin Flooding Basin Flooding
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
Multiple Warnings in One Multiple Warnings in One County/ParishCounty/Parish
Issue for text, Issue for text, radio, TV crawlsradio, TV crawls
Add reference to Add reference to other valid other valid warningswarnings
Include counties Include counties with directional with directional delimiters?delimiters?
Summary severe Summary severe weather weather statements?statements?
Madison
Bond
Clinton
Fayette
Marion
St. Clair
Washington
Randolph
Perry
Jackson
Franklin
Jefferson
Williamson
TOR until 3:30PM
SVR until 3:45PM
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
SUMMARYSUMMARY
SB Warnings Start On October 1, 2007 SB Warnings Start On October 1, 2007 These Warnings Are Weather and Water These Warnings Are Weather and Water Specific and Use GIS Coordinates to Define Specific and Use GIS Coordinates to Define the Warned Area the Warned Area Resources Such As The NWS RIDGE Radar Resources Such As The NWS RIDGE Radar Display Are Available Now For Partners and Display Are Available Now For Partners and Customers Customers Challenges Remain Such as Current NOAA Challenges Remain Such as Current NOAA Weather Radio and EAS Activation Weather Radio and EAS Activation Technology Technology SB Warnings Provide Better Public Service SB Warnings Provide Better Public Service and Reflect The Cutting Edge of Meteorology and Reflect The Cutting Edge of Meteorology and Hydrology and Hydrology
Storm Based WarningsStorm Based Warnings
QuestionsQuestions
[email protected]@noaa.gov
xxx-xxx-xxxxxxx-xxx-xxxx