Standards and Certification Training
Module A – AdministrativeA6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
Page
ASME 2013
2 ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
REVISIONSCHANGE DATE
1/31/14 First Edition
Page
ASME 2013
MODULE A COURSE OUTLINE
A1. Tools and ResourcesA2. Codes and Standards ProductsA3. Membership MaintenanceA4. Honors and AwardsA5. Publishing Codes and StandardsA6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate
Ballot Comments
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
3
Page
ASME 2013
LEARNING OBJECTIVESAt the end of this module, you will be able to: • Understand the ASME policies and procedures
that apply to member conduct in meetings.• Use the information presented to hold more
productive meetings.• Understand common individual and group
pitfalls in meetings.• Gain insight into how to make the most of your
ASME meeting.• Ensure that your ballot comments are in a
constructive format.
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
4
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
5
I. PRODUCTIVE MEETINGS
Page
ASME 2013
6
HOW TO HOLD PRODUCTIVE MEETINGS
• Objectives
• Agenda• Attendee
s
• Procedures• Participatio
n• Action
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
7
ADVANCE PLANNING• Why meet?
– Give information– Get information– Drive action– Foster understanding
• How and where to meet?– Face to face– Video conference– Teleconference– Web meeting
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
8
MEETING ATTENDANCEWho should attend and why?
• Stakeholder (affected by development of standard)
• Special knowledge/ experience
• Decision maker(s)/Regulatory agencies
• Administrative personnel
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
9
MEETING PREPARATION
• Announce meetings in advance to encourage maximum attendee participation.
• Agenda with time targets for each item– Distribute in advance
• Plan and prepare advance materials– Pre meeting reading / background material– Preparation / assignments
• Prior to the meeting, ensure that all required meeting materials are available and equipment is in working order.
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
10
STANDARDS AND CERTIFICATIONPolicies and Procedures
• CSP-10 Committee Meetings– selection of meeting location, requirements for
meeting notices and locations and staff attendance.
• CSP-34 Tape Recording of Committee Meetings and Teleconferences by members or officers is prohibited.– Only the secretary, who is a member of ASME's
staff, may be permitted to tape under certain guidelines.
• Procedures for ASME Codes and Standards Development Committees Section 6.2 Meetings.
Page
ASME 2013
11
RUNNING THE MEETINGTiming Can Be Everything
• Start your session on time• Control time: estimate time per agenda item
but be flexible• Use well-defined short breaks to divide long
meetings• Keep it short
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
12
RUNNING THE MEETING• Create a positive environment
– “Your attitude determines your altitude”
• Maintain an environment which is constructive, productive AND fun
• Appropriate humor is good– If you need a lightning rod, YOU are it !
– Use humor in good taste
– Be aware of cultural differences
• Society Policy 15.9 on Discrimination and Harassment
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
13
RUNNING THE MEETINGParticipation is Key
• Encourage participation by all attendees• Promote and stimulate discussion• Focus on content not personalities• Assist participants in expressing ideas• Don’t talk down to or argue with participants• Keep discussion on track
•Move unresolved items to a “Parking lot”• Sense tempo - Stay within allotted time• Handle all complaints
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
14
SOME COMMON ERRORSLEADER
• Lack of objectives, agenda, or planning• Loss of control (or no leader)• Too long — exceeded time limit• Wrong people• Few dominate meeting — lack of
participation
• Lack of objectives, agenda, or planning• Loss of control (or no leader)• Too long — exceeded time limit• Wrong people• Few dominate meeting — lack of
participation
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
15
SOME COMMON ERRORSPARTICIPANT CONDUCT
• Tardiness and absenteeism• Not paying attention (are you
sleeping?)• Over or under participation (don’t hog
the floor)• Lack of preparation (homework -
prepare notes)• Attacking leader/participants
(professionalism - focus on information)
• Tardiness and absenteeism• Not paying attention (are you
sleeping?)• Over or under participation (don’t hog
the floor)• Lack of preparation (homework -
prepare notes)• Attacking leader/participants
(professionalism - focus on information)
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
16
SOME COMMON ERRORSPARTICIPANT CONDUCT
• Side-tracking the discussion (ensure comments are relevant)
• Overt and blatant negativism (find one good idea)
• Fear of ridicule or embarrassment (set objectives)
• Unclear on future actions (ask for clarification)
• Side-tracking the discussion (ensure comments are relevant)
• Overt and blatant negativism (find one good idea)
• Fear of ridicule or embarrassment (set objectives)
• Unclear on future actions (ask for clarification)
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
17
MEETING WRAPUP
And in the end... • Review objectives to see if they have been met.• Review assignments — who, what, when• Discuss next meeting.
FINISH
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
18
POST MEETING EVALUATION
• As a result of this meeting, who is to do what, when? Review the Minutes to ensure the Actions are highlighted.
• Gap analysis … Three part question– What should we do to improve our meetings ?– What should we not do ?– What should we do differently ?
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
19
II. APPROPRIATE BALLOT COMMENTS
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
20
BALLOT COMMENTS• Many of the same behaviors identified in meeting
participant conduct slides apply to commenting on ballots.– Comments should be businesslike, not discourteous
or unprofessional.– Comments should only address the items out for
ballot.– Comments shall never be used as a tool to attack
or belittle others. – Comments should avoid blatant negativism.
• Comments posted on C&S Connect can be viewed by all S&C Staff and may eventually be viewed by parties outside the committee.
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
21
BALLOT COMMENTS
• Examples of inappropriate ballot comments:– “I don’t like this section.”– “The font used in this ballot is not appropriate.”– Comments unrelated to proposed revisions.
• Examples of appropriate ballot comments:– Section 4.2.1(a) replace the word “varies” with
“alternates”– 9-2.9.6(g), Repair - change "repairs shall" to
"repaired slings shall”– 17-2.1.4(e): Remove. This is covered in 17-2.1.1(a).
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
22
BALLOT COMMENTS
• Per Codes and Standards Procedures – Disapproved votes should include an alternative
action that will resolve their disapproved vote. – Disapproved votes accompanied by comments
unrelated to the proposal under consideration, or without comments, shall not be further considered, are not required to be submitted for recirculation and shall be reported as “Disapproved without Comment”.
– Comments that are not related to the proposal under consideration shall be documented and considered in the same manner as submittal of a new proposal. The submitter of the comments shall be so notified.
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
23
BALLOT RESPONSES• Per ANSI Essential Requirements, the committee
must give responses to all comments received on a ballot.
• Examples of appropriate responses to comments:– “Committee agrees” and/or “comment accepted”,
followed by proposed action.– “Committee disagrees” and/or “comment not
accepted”, followed by reason for disagreement with comment.
• Examples of inappropriate responses:– “The committee found your comments non-
persuasive.”– “You are the only one with this concern.”– “The committee did not agree with your
comments.” without a reason given.
Page
ASME 2013
MODULE SUMMARY• Hold meetings or electronic conferences only
when required, as determined by the standards committee or the Chair on behalf of the standards committee.
• Chairs can prepare for the meeting by developing an agenda or outline which leads to the achievement of the meeting’s objectives, ensuring that the right attendees are present.
• Leaders and members all play a role in a productive meeting - avoid the leader and participant pitfalls.
• Making appropriate and constructive comments on ballots saves the committee time and ensures that your comments are adequately considered by the committee.
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
24
Page
ASME 2013
REFERENCES• Codes and Standards Procedureshttp://cstools.asme.org/csconnect/CommitteePages.cfm?Committee=L01200000&Action=7609
− Section 6.2 Meetings− Section 7.2 Approval of Standards Action
• Codes and Standards Policieshttp://cstools.asme.org/csconnect/pdf/CommitteeFiles/7614.pdf
– CSP-10 Committee Meetings– CSP-34 Tape Recording of Committee Meetings and
Teleconferences – Procedures for ASME Codes and Standards
Development Committees Section 6.2 Meetings.
• ASME Society Policieshttps://www.asme.org/about-asme/who-we-are/governance/asme-society-policies?cm_re=Governance-_-Left%20Navigation-_-ASME%20Society%20Policies
– Society Policy 15.9 Against Discrimination (Including Discriminatory Harassment).ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot
Comments25
Page
ASME 2013
ASME S&C Training Module A6. Productive Meetings and Appropriate Ballot Comments
26
REFERENCES AND ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
• ANSI Essential Requirements: Due process requirements for American National Standards
http://publicaa.ansi.org/sites/apdl/Documents/Standards%20Activities/American%20National%20Standards/Procedures,%20Guides,%20and%20Forms/2013_ANSI_Essential_Requirements.pdf
ADDITIONAL ASME RESOURCES• ASME Career Center Podcast on Managing
Meetingshttp://www.ebmcdn.com/asme/podcast_media/jobboard/series5.html