Download - Stabilization status and plans
STABILIZATION STATUS AND PLANS
The research leading to these results has received funding from the European Commission under the FP7 Research Infrastructures project EuCARD
K. Artoos, C. Collette, R. Leuxe, C.Eymin, P. Fernandez, S. Janssens*
2
Outline
Requirements Review status 2012 Plans for 2013, objectives Manpower & collaboration status
Requirements
Stability (magnetic axis):Nano-positioning
3992 CLIC Main Beam Quadrupoles:
3
Type 4: 2m, 400 kgType 1: 0.5 m, 100 kg
A. Samoshkin
Main beam quadrupoles
Final Focus
Vertical1.5 nm > 1 Hz
Vertical0.2 nm > 4 Hz
Lateral5 nm > 1 Hz
Lateral5 nm > 4 Hz
Ground motion External forces Flexibility of magnet
4
Other requirements
Available spaceIntegration in two beam module620 mm beam heightAccelerator environment- High radiation - Stray magnetic fieldPositioning-Steps of tens of nm +/- 1 nm
Stiffness-Robustness Applied forces (water cooling, vacuum, power leads, cabling, interconnects, ventilation, acoustic pressure)
-Compatibility alignment-Transportability/Installation
5
Review status 2012MBQ Stabilisation
Type 1
Collocated pair
X-y proto
Seismometer FB max. gain +FF (FBFFV1mod): 7 % luminosity loss(no stabilisation 68 % loss)
Courtesy J. Snuverink, J. Pfingstner et al.
Main linac Req.: 1.5 nm r.m.s.
6
Inertial Reference mass
No stabilization 68% luminosity lossInertial ref. mass 1Hz (V3mod)
11%
Inertial ref. mass 1Hz + HP filter (V3)
3%
Inertial ref. mass 7 Hz (V3 mod 1)
Orbit fb optimised V3: 0.7%
Courtesy J. Snuverink et al.
Stef Janssens
C. Collette
“Comparison of new absolute displacement sensors”, C. Collette et al. , ISMA 2012
7
X-y prototype: Nano positioningResolution, precision, accuracy
Capacitive sensor
3 beam interferometer
Optical ruler
Actuators equipped with strain gauges
8
X-y positioning: Study precision, accuracy and resolution
The precision required (0.25 nm): • demonstrated with
optical rulers• in a temperature stable
environment • for simultaneous x and y
motion.
Absolute accuracy:• calibrated within 10-8 m
Tests in a temperature unstable environment will be made (ISR re installation)
9
X-y Positioning: roll
1&2Parasitic roll
• 2 legs 3 d.o.f. > parasitic roll• Measured with 3-beam interferometer• ~3 μm lateral movement > ~7 μrad
rotation• Early simulations suggest~100
μrad/0.5% luminosity loss (J. Pfingstner)
K.Artoos, Stabilisation WG , 21th February 2013
10
2013 Build three “best available design” MBQ
modules
Functional performance testing + development time: Study and try assemblyRequires controlled stable environment (Temperature, Vibrations, Access)Demonstration feasibility + ultimate performanceWater cooling + powering magnet
Test module location not adapted for this.Magnetic measurements and fiducialisation
Type 1 Test module with dummy magnetIntegration in test module, connections to other modules, robust show case, transport, …Demonstration alignment and stabilization but not representative for CLIC tunnel
Type 1 ISR
Type 4 ISR
Type 1 CLEX
Type 4 Test module
MBQ modules upgradable (bolted together, no welds).
11
Type 1 and Type 4 mechanical design
FE simulations are doneexpected (good) results
Production plans finished end of next week
K. Artoos, R. Leuxe, C. Eymin
Lateral mode:~139 Hz
Vertical mode:~315 Hz
12
Combination of fast positioning and stabilization
Combining positioning and stabilization:
• Making error to requested position R as small as possible
• Additional displacement measurement for low frequency to DC
• Sensors separated in bandwidth• integrator at low frequency to eliminate drift• Simulations function > To be implemented on x-y
prototype
Stef Janssens
13
Communication with Control Center
Labview communication program between magnet and simulated control room
Signals out:Geophone/position signalsSDI signal for DIG_POTSSignals in:CS signals for DIG_POTSCLK signals for DIG_POTSNew position X/Y
Signals out:New positionGain FF/FBFilter positionsSignals in:Transfer function (every 5 s)Rel./abs. PositionError signals
14
Preparation test modules and CLEX:Two type 1 MBQ and one Type4
• Flexural joints machined. Actuators with amplifiers and sensors delivered January 2013.
• Electronic boards under construction,
• Design Type 1 and type 4 mechanical support ongoing (80% ready)
• Demonstrators T1 and T4 planned for April 2013.
• Issue: Reduction manpower stabilisation MME in 2013
EUCARD deliverable
15
Manpower + collaborationstatus
CERN S.Janssens (PhD > Fellow) 100%K.Artoos (100% > 50%)M. Esposito (50%, 12/2012)P. Fernandez Carmona (August 12)Designers: R. Leuxe, C. Eymin (jobs)
MBQ stabilisation + nano-pos.Sensor development
CERN Networking with NIKHEF (PhD Stef, TNO, MI Partners, TU Delft,…) Synergy sensor development with LIGO, VIRGO. Contact Christophe Colette
Action CLIC : new collaboration agreements + K contracts
16
Build and test 3 MBQ modules with controller hardwareType 1 ISR + CLEX (precursor PACMAN) Type 4 ISR + Test moduleType 1 Test module
X-Y guide:Continue tests stopped in 2012Test absolute sensorsDevelop and test positioning controllerTest inertial sensors prototypes + stabilisation controller
Vibration measurements module + pulsed dipole correctors
• Outsource: • Construction of adapted sensors
(transfer function, AE compatible, noise level)• Collocated sensor-actuators
If time permits: Ground motion measurements around CMS
Objectives 2013 at CERN
17
SPARES
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
18
Controller ElectronicsHybrid Second generation
2 d.o.f. Position input terminal Switchable
(displacement/velocity) Manual or Digital gain/filter
control FPGA control digital part
started Improved radiation hardness
(choice components Tested for SEU and induced
noise at H4HIRRAD
P. Fernandez Carmona
H4IRAD test stand
No damage nor SEU after 18 GyTest not completeReport to be finalized
Piezo amplifier not radhard
19
CERN “team”: Build and test 3 MBQ modules Type 1 ISR + CLEX (precursor PACMAN) Type 4 ISR + Test moduleType 1 Test module
Outsource:• Construction of adapted sensors (transfer function, AE compatible, noise level) (in progress)• High stiffness actuators (done)• Collocated sensor-actuators• Characterization existing systems • ? Study pre-isolator Final Focus (Model (almost) done=>Test beam simulations)• High load high range high resolution actuators• Construction electronics (in progress (soldering components))• Implementation of custom digital slow control (in progress)• Construction mechanics: flexural joints, monolithic , machining, assembly,…• Displacement sensors and their implementation (in progress)• Development Radiation hard components
Objectives 2013
20
Stabilization with Interferometer based geophone
Interferometer based geophone built and tested:-Very high sensitivity, high resolution-Wider bandwidth-Proof of concept
Issue:
Due to higher bandwidth, actuator slew rate gives instabilities in the loop
-> New batch of actuator amplifiers have a higher slew rate
Measured open loop on x-y guide
Stef Janssens
21
Comparison sensors
Sensor Resolution Main + Main -
Actuator sensor 0.15 nm No separate assembly
ResolutionNo direct measurement of magnet movement
Capacitive gauge 0.10 nm Gauge radiation hard Mounting tolerancesGain change w. Orthogonal coupling
Interferometer 10 pm Accuracy at freq.> 10 Hz
CostMounting toleranceSensitive to air flowOrthogonal coupling
Optical ruler 0.5*-1 nm Cost1% orthogonal couplingMounting toleranceSmall temperature driftPossible absolute sensor
Rad hardness sensor head not knownLimited velocity displacements
Seismometer (after integration)
< pm at higher frequencies
For cross calibration
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
22
Five R&D themes :
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
1. Performance increase →Reach requirements from higher background vibrations + include direct forces
→ Increase resolution (Final focus)
2. Compatibility with environment → Radiation, magnetic field, Operation, Temperature
3. Cost optimization → Standardize and optimize components, decrease number of components, simplify mounting procedures,…
4. Overall system analysis → Interaction with the beam-based orbit and IP feedback to optimise luminosity Integration with other CLIC components
→ Adapt to changing requirements
5. Pre-industrialization → Ability to build for large quantities
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
23
Extra slide:Measured slew rate of actuator
24
Bill of Materials
Amplifiers LMP2022MA: Zero Drift, Low Noise, EMI Hardened Amplifier AD8230YRZ: Zero-Drift, Precision Instrumentation Amplifier AD8691AUJZ: Low Cost, Low Noise, CMOS Rail-to-Rail Output
Operational Amplifier Power regulator ICs: TPS76550, REG1117-2.5, TPS72325,
UCC284-5 FLASH Digital potentiometers: AD5231, AD5204 Diodes: BAV199 Capacitors: Tantalum Resistors: Thin film 1% Potentiometers: Cermet Digital slow control
National Instruments PXI with DAQmx card FPGA: Spartan 6 evaluation board (under development)
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
25
Controller electronics: Hybrid
2 analogue chains+ positioning offset
Local electronics ADCs digitize signalsFor remote monitoring
Communication to remote control center with optical fiber
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
SPI
P. Fernandez Carmona(until end of August)
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
26
Inertial reference mass proto (v3): With interferometer/with capacitive gauge
27
Active Stabilization
B10
No stab. 53%/68%
Current stab.
108%/13%
Future stab. 118%/3%
Luminosity achieved/lost [%]
Machine modelBeam-based feedback
Code
Typical quadrupole jitter tolerance O(1nm) in main linac and O(0.1nm) in final doublet
Final Focus QD0 Prototype
Close to/better than target
28
3D simulated Kinematics
M. Esposito, IWAA 2012 Fermilab
PITCH YAW
T1 MBQ
T4 MBQ
• No loss of translation range for T4• About 25% of loss of vertical translation range for T1 pitch• About 80% of loss of lateral translation range for T1 yaw
29
Roll simulations
S. Janssens, CLIC Workshop, January 2013
30
The influence of the orbit feedback is in general small. For the main linac the tolerance for 0.5% lumi loss is about 100urad (already provided by Daniel before). Including also the BDS without the final doublet, since not actuated by the tripot, (dashed pink curve), the tolerance is about 1um.