Sham, Due Process, & More – Trends in Sales Tax
SEATA63rdAnnual Southeastern Association of Tax Administrators Conference
Hilton Head, South Carolina July 28 – 31, 2013
Donald M. Griswold, Crowell & Moring LLP
23788317_2
2
Nexus Common Law Doctrines & Sales Tax Intrastate Transactions Statutory Discrimination SEC Actions
Trends in Sales Tax
3
Nexus
4
“Click-Through” Nexus Litigation Legislative Developments Attributional Nexus Due Process – PACT Act Due Process -- SCOTUS
Nexus
5
◦ Overstock.com, Inc. (N.Y. Ct. App. 2013)& Amazon.com, LLC
Facial challenge to the constitutionality of NY’s “click-through” nexus statute
Held: statute was not unconstitutional on its face
Taxpayers will petition the U.S. Supreme Court for review
Click-Through Nexus Litigation
6
Fifteen states have recently proposed or enacted nexus legislation:
Florida, Hawaii, Indiana, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia
Legislative Developments
7
Barnesandnoble.comLLC (N.M. 2013)
◦ Supreme Court of New Mexico affirmed: For GRT purposes, the in-state activities of an affiliate
could be imputed to a “dot com” out-of-state retailer
Attributional Nexus
8
Red Earth LLC (2d Cir. 2011 Gordon(DC Cir. 2013)
PACT Act’s requirement – retailers must prepay excise taxes on out-of-state sales – denies due process
Due Process Nexus – PACT Act
9
Goodyear (2011)
Due Process “minimum contacts” for tax may be tougher standard after all !
“. . . attenuated connections to the state fall far short of the ‘continuous & systematic general business contacts’ necessary to empower [the state] to entertain suit against them on claims unrelated to anything that connects them to the state.”
Due Process – US Supreme Ct
10
McIntyre (2011)
“The principal inquiry in cases of this sort is whether the defendant’s activities manifest an intention to submit to the power of the sovereign … and to have that … you must have purposeful availment … In this way, sovereignty prevails over metaphor as authority replaces fairness.”
Due Process – US Supreme Ct
11
Common Law Doctrines & Sales Tax
12
Sham, Economic Substance, Business Purpose
Policy
Sullivan Bros (WI Cir. Ct.) Dunk & Bright (NY TAT)
Common Law Doctrines &Sales Tax
13
Intrastate Transactions
14
Hartney Fuel Oil (Ill. App. Sept. 2012)
◦ Held: must follow statutory sourcing rule Source sales to jurisdiction where POs are received Rejected Department’s argument for sourcing
based on “totality of circumstances”
Intrastate Transactions
15
RTA v. United
◦ Regional Transportation Authority has accused United & American Airlines of operating small sham offices outside Chicago to avoid paying sales tax on fuel in Chicago.
Intrastate Transactions
16
California Enterprise Zone Credits
◦ DiCon Fiberoptics (Cal. S.Ct. 2012)
◦ Elimination of Enterprise Zone Program A.B. 93 signed by Gov. Brown (July 2013
Intrastate Transactions
17
Statutory Discrimination
18
CSX v. Ala. (11th Cir. July 2013)
◦ Sales tax on interstate rail carriers is discriminatory
◦ Alabama did not provide a sufficient justification for exempting interstate motor and water carriers
4-R Act
19
Chicago v. StubHub! (IL 2011)
Chicago overstepped its home rule authority by attempting to impose a tax obligation under Illinois law.
Internet Tax Freedom Act
20
Performance Marketing (Ill. Cir. Ct. May 2012)
Illinois’ “Amazon” law: violated the Commerce Clause because it
required retailers with no substantial nexus with the state to register and collect the state’s sales &use taxes
violated the ITFA as a “discriminatory tax” on e-commerce
Internet Tax Freedom Act
21
SEC Actions
22
Sprint Nextel
◦ SEC initiated an investigation following a suit attempting to collect taxes
SEC Actions
23
Hudson Highland
◦ SEC fined Hudson for failing to accurately reflect sales tax liabilities in its books
SEC Actions
24
Dell
◦ SEC charged two former Dell executives with fraud, alleging misconduct relating to the use of the company’s excess tax reserves
SEC Actions
25
Donald M. GriswoldCrowell & Moring LLP1001 Pennsylvania Ave., NWWashington, DC 20004(202) [email protected]