Doug Corey, MA, CMHC, Northlands Job CorpsVicki Boyd, PhD, Mental Health Specialist, Humanitas, Inc.
Job Corps National Health and Wellness ConferenceNovember 2-4, 2011Baltimore, Maryland 1
Contrast suicidal behavior and self-harming behavior.
Articulate the function of self-harming behavior.
Describe skills that students can learn to help them cope with difficult thoughts and feelings without engaging in self-harming behaviors.
Suggest different ways these skills might be taught to students while on center.
2
Part 1
3
Self injury is the act of deliberately harming your own body, such as cutting or burning yourself. It is considered an unhealthy way to cope with emotional pain, intense anger, and frustration.
Researchers have not been able to trace cutting to any single disorder
Some clinicians have insisted that cutting is frequently found with individuals suffering from borderline personality disorder
There is no evidence highlighting borderline personality disorder
Those in charge want to elevate cutting from a symptom to a disorder
The disorder would be called “non-suicidal self injury”
The jury is still out
7
Throughout history, the act of bleeding, bloodletting, and cutting share the same result: RELIEF
Relief from illness, relief from pain, relief from guilt and shame, always relief
The definition of self injury/cutting remains the same today
“There is no remedy as miraculous as Bleeding” -1645
Egyptians may have practiced bleeding as early as 2500 BC
Hippocrates (Father of Western medicine) wrote in the 4th and 5th centuries that bleeding addressed nearly everything that ails you
Early Roman church records indicate both bleeding and self injury were good for the body and the soul (The DaVinci Code)
Middle Ages: The Pope forbade all clergy from bloodletting, hence barbers and surgeons were the only ones allowed to perform the procedure
The second medical text ever printed on Gutenberg’s printing press was a “Bloodletting Calendar” in 1462
The Arab world embraced bloodletting as well, but bled from the opposite side as the malady. (The Greeks bled from the same side as the ailment)
George Washington was likely bled to death
Early years of out-patient experience: Patients were typically college students
and college dropouts Psychodynamic and behavioral
approaches were the order of the day
Early years of in-patient experience: University of Washington in-patient
psychiatric unit: Female, age 22 Veterans Administration
Neuropsychiatric Hospital: Male, age 37
Part 2
14
Cutting is rarely related to suicideCutting is believed to bring an
immediate, albeit momentary sense of calm and release of tension
A strangely effective coping behavior (though a self-destructive one)
Firearms 59.3 (2/3) Suffocation 24.8 (1/4) Poisioning 6.4 Fall 2.9 Other 2.5 Drowning 0.8 Fire / Burning 0.5 Transportation 0.5 Cutting 0.4 %
16
SUICIDE
Escape pain Unconsciousness Rarely chronic Few methods
SELF-INJURY
Relief from pain Too much or
too little emotion Frequent Several methods
17
SUICIDE
Persistent Unendurable pain Hopeless/helpless Only way out
Feel worse
SELF-INJURY
Intermittent Uncomfortable Some optimism Choices & control
Rapid relief
18
SUICIDE
Depression Rage about
unendurable pain
SELF-INJURY
Overwhelmingemotions
Body alienation Poor body image
NEW GROUP Intense stress Poor self-soothing Peer endorsement
19
Part 3
20
May not have history of abuse
Often have major strengths
Large group of friends
Peers play an important role: Also engaging in self-injury Reinforcing with support
21
Use the client’s language e.g., “cutting, scratching, carving” It’s joining, respectful, empowering
Rule out suicidal intent
Avoid inflammatory terms Not “suicidal” Not “self-mutilating”
22
Not a “Suicidal Gesture” Inaccurate and misleading Can lead to empathic failure-
“You don’t get it!”
Not “Self-Mutilation” Too extreme and sensational Self-injury mild to moderate damage
23
A pejorative response, stigmatizing Often in response to distress Many other ways to get attention
But can be a secondary reinforcer Those who inadvertently
reinforce the behaviorneed to be part of the response plan
24
Recoil, Shock, Avoidance Too upsetting Disorganizing for the caregiver Stigmatizing for the student
Concern & Support Inadvertently becomes reinforcing The more intense the response,
the greater the risk of reinforcement
25
Concern & Support (problematic) Suggests affective intensity A yearning to be of assistance A desire to quickly protect & intervene
Compassion (recommended) Acceptance A neutral stance No expectations of immediate change
26
They’re used to harsh, pejorative judgments
Nonjudgmental compassion is welcomed
Indicates you are ready to hear the rest of their story
Encourages full disclosure27
Baseline of wounds & episodes Extent of physical damage Body area Use of a tool Room or place
of self-injury Social context
28
Antecedents Cognitive (automatic thoughts & core
beliefs) Affective (primary reason for self-injury) Behavioral (triggers and precipitants)
Consequences or Aftermath Specifics of psychological relief Self-care and communication Social reinforcement
29
Commitment to reduce frequency
Replacement skills Self-soothing & distracting
Reward (often self-reward)
No punishment if not achieved Or they will withhold
information Unable to stop without
treatment Contract for tx (or
empathic failure)
30
Open for Discussion: Do we put everyone who engages in
self-injury on a medical leave? Would this drive the behavior
underground? They can’t change without treatment Must rule out risk to self and others They may need treatment elsewhere
31
Select the right skillsPractice diligently
Start when student is calm & focused Over learning skills will help later
Replacement skills have worked for many others and they will work for you if you find the right skills and practice, practice, practice
32
Negative replacement behaviorsMindful breathing skillsVisualization techniquesPhysical exerciseWritingArtistic expressionPlaying or listening to musicCommunication with others
33
Need multiple techniques Watch TV Play video games Read a book
Not a higher-order skill To use as they are learning new skills They already do these things… So they may not be so effective
34
Cognitive Behavioral TherapyDialectical Behavioral TherapyBody Image WorkExposure TreatmentTrauma Resolution
35
DBT- Developed by Marsha LinehanTreating Borderline Personality DxTeaching skills to regulate emotions
Mindfulness Distress Tolerance Emotional Regulation Interpersonal Effectiveness
36
Very helpful with difficult consumers at a community mental health center
Recently applied more broadlyMost self-injury is an effort to cope
with strong emotionsAt Job Corps, students…
Complain about “drama” Are drawn to it And are triggered by the drama
37
Had a history of self-harmLiving in the same dorm/roomTriggering and reinforcing each otherDecided to meet with them as a
group
38
Ground Rules (respect, confidentiality…)
Establish Safety and Support Don’t want to make them feel bad Not judging them in any way They are doing the best they can
Intro to DBT Biosocial Model Validating & Invalidating Environments
39
Imagine you’re a caregiver of a young child (2 or 3 years old)
Scared by a dog... that you know
is not a threatChild runs to you…What would you do?
40
What You Do: Comfort them
physically Reflect their feelings Reassure them verbally
What This Does: Teaches them to
identify feelings Feelings are
uncomfortable, but it’s OK to express them
Feelings will pass and you can go on
41
How their caregivers responded: Many examples of invalidation They had all been traumatized
What this taught them: Hide your feelings Bad things will happen
if you express your emotions They keep building up until
relief through self-harming behaviors
42
Immediately understood they had been inadvertently triggering and reinforcing self-harming behavior
What else could they do? It’s how they were raised It’s all they know
43
DBT Maxim Solve the problem if you can If you can’t solve it, survive it
Self-harm An effort to survive a problem they
couldn’t solve They were doing the best they could
in their invalidating environment
44
Skills Training Manual for Treating Borderline Personality Disorder, Marsha Linehan (1993), New York: Guilford Press
45
ActivitiesContributing to othersCompare your fate to othersOpposite emotionsPushing awayDistracting thoughtsOther sensations
46
Ground Hog Story
Anger isn’t bad, but… If you keep concentrating on it,
things won’t get better and they might get worse
47
Try some distraction skills
Try validating each other
48
Emotional mind Valuable and necessary Can’t always act from emotion
Reasonable mind Logical, problem solving Sometimes eclipsed by emotion
Wise mind49
ImageryMeaning or PurposePrayerRelaxationFocus one thing; in the momentBrief vacation from your troublesEncouragement
50
There’s a right way to feel in every situation Letting others know how I am feeling bad is weakness Negative feelings are bad and destructive Being emotional means being out of control Emotions can just happen for no reason Some emotions are really stupid All painful emotions are a result of a bad attitude If others don’t approve of my feelings, I obviously
shouldn’t feel the way I do Other people are the best judge of how I am feeling Painful emotions aren’t important and should be
ignored
51
Get training in DBT
Skills Training Manual for Treatment Borderline Personality Disorder by Marsha Linehan
Adapt the material for Job Corps groups
Develop staff trainings: Responding to students Dealing with their own emotions
52
53
54
Worked with self-injuring persons since the late 1970’s
Executive Director:The Bridge Central Massachusetts Network of 30 mental health programs
Conducted research, written extensively, and presented internationally on self-injury
He has also consulted on the topic in many settings (schools, clinics, and hospitals)
55
Job Corps Health and Wellness Website
National Public Radio (NPR.org) ‘Cutting Elevated from Symptom to
Mental Disorder’ by K. Masterson, February 10, 2010
‘The History and Mentality of Self-Mutilation’ by Alix Spiegel, June 10, 2005
S.A.F.E. Alternatives: A program for Self-Mutilatorswww.mayoclinic.com/health/self-injury/DS00775
Factsheet: Self-Injury. Mental Health America.www.nmha.org/go/information/get-info/self-injury
Starr, Douglas. BLOOD: An Epic History of Medicine and Commerce. New York, NY: Perennial, 2002