Download - Role of WRITS in administrative law
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
1/14
MLAPQ IM^ _OBDDI) IZOEKD^
Xdij dc^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~
_zhlappj` pd7 Vxjvmxj` hq7
Vxdc+ _+ E+ Nmzx Mkaljsb Ezlmx
aH+M+II+H+"B!
AS _jljspjx
Jkxi+Kd+ M2=62?616?:
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
2/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
a Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
MOEKD^IJ@NLJKP
Pbas mssankljkp as akpjk`j` pd odjx pbjXdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj
Im~+ Hmsao mk` vxj,xj}zasapj akcdxlmpadk bmj hjjk akoiz`j`+
A moekd~ij`nj pbj aksvaxmpadk mk` hijssakn dc lq xjsvjopj` cmozipq Vxdc+ _+E+
Nmzx+ Bj lm`j lq mii `dzhp oxqspmi oijmx+
A ml czii dc nxmpapz`j pd lq sjkadxs Vxmpae Lasbxm) Balmksbz Vxaqm`mxsba)
Lmqmke @zhjq mk` ^msaz``ak Ebmk cdx pbj vmpajkoj sbd~k mk`
jkodzxmnjljkp najk pd odlvijpj pbas mssankljkp+
Lq bjmxpczi pbmkes mxj `zj pd lq cxajk`s Vxaqmksbz Lasbxm) Vxaqjsb Lasbxm)
Vmiia Mkmk`) Vxmsbmkp Ezlmx _aknb) Vzxzsbmxpb Pdimka) _bmsbmke _aknb) E+L+
Pxavmpba) V+_+ _xa`bmx Xmg mk` Lmkasbm Obmpzxj`a cdx vxda`akn xjijmkp
xjsdzxojs+
Ak pbj imsp hzp kdp pbj ijmsp) lq sjksj dc nxmpapz`j as `zj pd MLAPQ IM^
_OBDDI) IZOEKD^+
Jjxq jccdxp bms hjjk lm`j pd mda` jxxdxs mk` laspmejs) bd~jjx pbjaxvxjsjkoj omkkdp hj xzij` dzp+
Mkaljsb Ezlmx
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
3/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
aa Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
Ak`jr
=+Akpxd`zopadk++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++=8+ Dxanak dc ^xaps++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++8?+Baspdxaomi Hmoenxdzk`+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?0+ ^xaps+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?:+ Odkspapzpadkmi vxdasadks++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++:3+Xdij dc ~xaps ak m`lakaspxmpaj mopadks+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++3>+Mvviaompadk dc ^xaps ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++>2+ Odkoizsadk++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++=61+Hahiadnxmvbq+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++==
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
4/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
= Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
Akpxd`zopadk
M`lakaspxmpaj im~ bms nxjmpiq `jlmxompj` pbj objoes) hmimkojs mk` vjxlassahij
mxjm dc mk jrjxoasj dc vd~jx) mzpbdxapq mk` gzxas`aopadk djx m`lakaspxmpaj
mopadks jkcdxoj` hq pbj mkq _pmpj) Ndjxkljkpmi mnjkoajs mk` akspxzljkpmiapajs
`jcakj` zk`jx Mxpaoij =8 dc pbj Odkspapzpadk dc Ak`am+ Mk` pbj gz`aoamxq as
`qkmlaomiiq omxakn pbj vxakoavijs mk` jrojvpadks) ~baij lmeakn pbj gz`aoami
xjaj~ dc m`lakaspxmpaj mopadks+
P~d alvdxpmkp msvjops dc m`lakaspxmpaj im~ mxj pbj odkpxdi ljobmkasl djx pbj
m`lakaspxmpadk mk` xjiajc ~bjk pbj ijnmi xanbp dc mk ak`aa`zmi as akcxaknj` hq
mkq m`lakaspxmpaj mopadk+ Pd jkszxj odkpxdi mk` xjiajc) gz`aoamxq vimqs m
sankacaomkp xdij+ Gz`aoami odkpxdi djx m`lakaspxmpaj mzpbdxapajs vxjjkps pbjjrjxoasj dc mxhapxmxakjss mk` jkszxjs pbj mvviaompadk dc xzij dc im~+ Pbjxj mxj m
lqxam` dc vxakoavijs vzp cdx~mx` hq pbj odzxps cdx xjnzimpakn pbj czkopadks dc pbj
m`lakaspxmpaj hd`ajs ak `accjxjkp `aljksadks mk` ap bms nxjmpiq odkpxahzpj` pd
pbj nxd~pb dc m`lakaspxmpaj im~+ Pbj Odkspapzpadk dc Ak`am bms vxda`j` cdx pbj
sqspjl dc ^xaps zk`jx Mxpaoij ?8 mk` 883 pd jkcdxoj czk`mljkpmi xanbps+ Pbjsj
vxdasadks jlvd~jx pbj _zvxjlj Odzxp mk` pbj Banb Odzxps dc Ak`am pd asszj
^xaps+ M ^xap as m gz`aoami dx`jx ak pbj cdxl dc m cdxlmi ~xappjk odllmk`)
asszj` cxdl pbj odzxp) xj}zaxakn pbj vjxcdxlmkoj dc m svjoacao mop hq pbj`jcjk`mkp+ Ac mkq m`j}zmpj mipjxkmpaj xjlj`q as mmaimhij) pbj odzxp lmq xjczsj
pd jrjxoasj aps ^xap gzxas`aopadk ~bjxj mk asszj dc jkcdxojljkp dc czk`mljkpmi
xanbp as kdp akdij`+
Pbj m`lakaspxmpaj im~ as pbmp hxmkob dc im~ pbmp ejjvs pbj ndjxkljkpmi mopadks
~apbak pbj hdzk`s dc im~ dx pd vzp ap kjnmpajiq) ap vxjjkps pbj jkcdxojljkp dchimpmkpiq hm` dx`jxs cxdl hjakn `jxdnmpdxq+
Pbj Odzxps bmj odkspmkpiq pxaj` pd vxdpjop pbj iahjxpajs dc pbj vjdvij mk`msszlj vd~jxs zk`jx pbj Odkspapzpadk cdx gz`aoami xjaj~ dc m`lakaspxmpajmopadks+ Pbj `asoxjpadkmxq vd~jxs bmj pd hj ozxhj`) ac pbjq mxj laszsj` dx
mhzsj`+ Pbj sdoad,vdiapao Akspapzpadk kjj` kdp oxq) ac pbj odzxps `d gzspaoj mk`
vjxcdxl pbj szhspmkpami xdij+ Pbmp as pbj jssjkoj dc gzspaoj+ Ap as szhlappj`) pbj
pxjk` as pd xjm` pbj sdoami gzspaoj mk` pd pxmksimpj ak xjmiapq+ Pbj ~jicmxj _pmpj bms
pd `asobmxnj aps `zpq cmaxiq ~apbdzp mkq mxhapxmxq mk` `asoxalakmpdxq pxjmpljkp pd
pbj vjdvij ak pbj odzkpxq+ Ac szob vd~jxs odlj pd pbj kdpaoj dc pbj Odzxps) pbjodzxps bmj xmasj` pbj mxls odksaspjkpiq ~apb pbj xzij dc im~+ Pd`mq pbj
Ndjxkljkp as pbj vxda`jx dc sdoami sjxaojs5 kj~ cdxl dc vxdvjxpq iaej gdhs)}zdpms) iaojksjs mk` lakjxmi xanbps jpo+ Pbj `asvjksjx dc svjoami sjxaojs omkkdp
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
5/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
8 Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
pbjxjcdxj mop mxhapxmxaiq+ Odzxps ima` pbj spmk`mx` dc xjmsdkmhijkjss akNdjxkljkpmi mopadk+
Dxanak dc ^xaps
Pbj dxanak dc ~xaps omk hj `xm~k cxdl pbj Jkniasb Gz`aoami sqspjl mk` ~jxj
oxjmpj` ~apb pbj `jjidvljkp dc Jkniasb cdie odzxps,lddps pd pbj odlldk im~
odzxps+ Pbj im~ dc ~xaps bms aps dxanak cxdl pbj dx`jxs vmssj` hq pbj Eakns
Hjkob ak Jknimk`+ ^xaps ~jxj asszj` dk m vjpapadk vxjsjkpj` pd pbj eakn ak
odzkoai mk` ~jxj odksa`jxj` ms m xdqmi dx`jx+ ^xaps ~jxj m ~xappjk dx`jx asszj`ak pbj kmlj dc pbj eakn ~baob mopj` ms nxdzk`~dxe cdx pbj szhsj}zjkp
vxdojj`akns+ Bd~jjx) ~apb `accjxjkp sjnljkps ~xaps pdde mxadzs cdxls mk`
kmljs+ Pbj ~xaps ~jxj asszj` hq pbj oxd~k mk` ak pbj akpjxjsp dc pbj oxd~k hzp
~apb pbj vmssmnj dc palj ap hjomlj mmaimhij cdx dx`akmxq oapawjks misd+ Bd~jjxm vxjsoxahj` cjj ~ms obmxnj` cdx ap mk` pbj caiakn dc pbjsj ~xaps ~jxj ekd~k msVzxobmsj dc m ~xap+
Baspdxaomi Hmoenxdzk`
Pbj dxanak dc ~xaps ak Ak`am ndjs hmoe pd pbj Xjnzimpakn Mop) =>>? zk`jx ~baob
_zvxjlj Odzxp ~ms jspmhiasbj` mp Omiozppm+ Pbj obmxpjx misd jspmhiasbj` dpbjx
Banb odzxps mk` pbjsj Banb Odzxps bm` mkmidndzs vd~jx pd asszj ~xaps ms
szoojssdx pd pbj _zvxjlj Odzxp+ Pbj dpbjx odzxps ~baob ~jxj jspmhiasbj`szhsj}zjkpiq `a` kdp jkgdq pbas vd~jx+ Pbj ~xap gzxas`aopadk dc pbjsj odzxps ~ms
ialapj` pd pbjax dxanakmi oaai gzxas`aopadk ~baob pbjq jkgdqj` zk`jx sjopadk 0: dcpbj _vjoacao Xjiajc Mop) =2>>+
^xaps
OjxpadxmxaOjxpadxmxa as m Impak pjxl hjakn ak pbj vmssaj cdxl dc pbj ~dx`
Ojxpadxmxj ljmkakn pd akcdxl+ Ap ~ms m xdqmi `jlmk` cdx akcdxlmpadk+Ojxpadxmxa omk hj `jsoxahj` ms dkj dc pbj ldsp mizmhij mk` jccaoajkp
xjlj`ajs+ Ojxpadxmxa as dkj dc pbj caj vxjxdnmpaj ~xaps m`dvpj` hq pbj
Ak`amk Odkspapzpadk zk`jx Mxpaoij 883 ~baob ~dzi` hj jkcdxoj` mnmaksp
pbj `joasadks dc pbj mzpbdxapq jrjxoasakn gz`aoami dx }zmsa gz`aoami vd~jxs+
_zob vd~jxs mxj jrjxoasj` ~bjk pbj mzpbdxapajs bmj cmaij` pd jrjxoasj
pbj gzxas`aopadk pbdznb jspj` ak ap dx cmaij` pd jrjxoasj pbj gzxas`aopadk
pbdznb jspj` dk bal dx pd odxxjop pbj mvvmxjkp jxxdx dk pbj cmoj dc xjodx`
dx pbjxj as adimpadk dc pbj vxakoavij dc kmpzxmi gzspaoj+ Mk akspmkoj
sbd~akn pbj ojxpadxmxa vd~jxs ~ms jrjxoasj` hq pbj Bdkhij _zvxjlj
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
6/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
? Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
odzxp ak M+E+Exmavme + Zkadk dc Ak`am=) ~bjxj pbj sjijopadk ~ms
obmiijknj` dk pbj nxdzk` dc hams+ Pbj _zvxjlj Odzxp `jiakjmpj` pbj
`aspakopadk hjp~jjk }zmsa gz`aoami mk` m`lakaspxmpaj mzpbdxapq+ Pbj
_zvxjlj Odzxp jrjxoasakn pbj vd~jxs asszj` pbj ~xap dc Ojxpadxmxa cdx
}zmsbakn pbj mopadk+
VxdbahapadkPbj ~xap dc Vxdbahapadk as asszj` hq pbj odzxp jrjxoasakn pbj vd~jx mk`mzpbdxapajs cxdl odkpakzakn pbj vxdojj`akns ms hmsaomiiq szob mzpbdxapq
bms kd vd~jx dx gzxas`aopadk pd `joa`j pbj omsj+ Vxdbahapadk as mk jrpxm
dx`akmxq vxjxdnmpaj ~xap dc m vxjjkpaj kmpzxj+ Pbj zk`jxiqakn vxakoavijas pbmp vxjjkpadk as hjppjx pbmk ozxj+ Ak Jmsp Ak`am Odlljxoami Od+
Ip` + Odiijopdx dc Ozspdls8
) m ~xap dc vxdbahapadk as mk dx`jx `axjopj`pd mk akcjxadx Pxahzkmi cdxha``akn ap cxdl odkpakzakn ~apb m vxdojj`aknpbjxjak dk pbj nxdzk` pbmp pbj vxdojj`akn as ~apbdzp dx ak jrojss dc
gzxas`aopadk dx odkpxmxq pd pbj im~s dc pbj imk`) spmpzpdxq dx dpbjx~asj+
Lmk`mlzsLmk`mlzs as m gz`aoami xjlj`q ~baob as ak pbj cdxl dc mk dx`jx cxdl m
szvjxadx odzxp pd mkq Ndjxkljkp mnjkoq) odzxp dx vzhiao mzpbdxapq pd `d
dx cdxhjmx cxdl `dakn mkq svjoacao mop ~baob pbmp hd`q as dhianj` pd `dzk`jx pbj im~+ Pbj ~xap dc lmk`mlzs as asszj` ~bjkjjx pbj vzhiao
mzpbdxapajs cmai pd vjxcdxl pbj spmpzpdxq `zpajs odkcaxlj` dk pbjl+ _zob
~xap as asszj` pd vjxcdxl pbj `zpajs ms vxda`j` hq pbj spmpj zk`jx pbj
spmpzpj dx cdxhjmx dx xjspxmak cxdl `dakn mkq svjoacao mop+ Pbj caxsp omsj
xjvdxpj` dk pbj ~xap dc lmk`mlzs ~ms pbj La``ijpdkj omsj ak =:>?
~bjxjak m oapawjks cxmkobasj ~ms xjspdxj`+ Pbj ~xap dc lmk`mlzs omk hj
asszj` ac pbj vzhiao mzpbdxapq jspj` ~apb vd~jx mhzsjs pbj vd~jx dx mopslmim ca`j pd ap+ Ak Bmishzxqs Im~s dc Jknimk`) ap as ljkpadkj` pbmp)
Ms m njkjxmi xzij pbj dx`jx ~aii kdp hj nxmkpj` zkijss pbj vmxpqodlvimakj` dc bms ekd~k ~bmp ap ~ms xj}zaxj` pd `d) sd pbmp bj bm` pbj
ljmks dc odksa`jxakn ~bjpbjx dx kdp bj sbdzi` odlviq) mk` ap lzsp hj
sbd~k hq ja`jkoj pbmp pbjxj ~ms m `aspakop `jlmk` dc pbmp ~baob pbj
vmxpq sjjeakn pbj lmk`mlzs `jsaxjs pd jkcdxoj mk` pbmp pbmp `jlmk` ~msljp hq m xjczsmi+
= MAX =1>6 _O =:68
MAX =136 Omi =
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
7/14
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
8/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
: Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
Odkspapzpadkmi vxdasadks
Pbj lmejxs dc pbj Odkspapzpadk bmj m`dvpj` pbj Jkniasb xjlj`ajs ak pbj
Odkspapzpadk zk`jx Mxpaoijs ?8 mk` 883+ Pbjxj bms hjjk svjoacaomiiq lm`j
vxdasadks ak pbj Odkspapzpadk ~baob jlvd~jxs pbj _zvxjlj Odzxp mk` BanbOdzxps pd asszj ~xaps ak pbj kmpzxj dc Bmhjms Odxvzs) Lmk`mlzs) Vxdbahapadk)]zd ^mxxmkpd mk` Ojxpadxmxa+ Pbj czk`mljkpmi xanbps ~baob mxj akmiajkmhij
smoxdsmkop ak kmpzxj mk` obmxmopjx ~baob ~jxj odkojaj` ak kmpadkmi mk` vzhiao
akpjxjsp odzi` hj aiizsdxq ac pbjxj as kd odkspapzpadkmi lmobakjxq vxda`j` cdx aps
jkcdxojljkp+ Zkijss szob odkspapzpadkmi xjlj`ajs cdx aps jkcdxojljkp as kdp
vxda`j` pbj xanbps nzmxmkpjj` hq vmxp AAA dc pbj Odkspapzpadk omkkdp hj jjx
alvijljkpj` hq pbj oapawjks+ Mxpaoij ?8 odkpmakj` ak Vmxp AAA as apsjic mczk`mljkpmi xanbp najk pd pbj vjxsdk zk`jx pbj Odkspapzpadk+ _alaimxiq Mxpaoij
883 dc pbj Odkspapzpadk as odkcjxxj` dk pbj Banb Odzxps pd jrjxoasj apsvxjxdnmpaj ~xaps ~baob omk hj asszj` mnmaksp mkq vjxsdk dx hd`q dc vjxsdk
akoiz`akn pbj ndjxkljkp+ Pbj `aspakopadk hjp~jjk pbj p~d xjlj`ajs as jxq
kjnianahij+ Pbj xjlj`q zk`jx Mxpaoij ?8 as odkcakj` pd jkcdxojljkp dcczk`mljkpmi xanbps ~bjxjms Mxpaoij 883 as mmaimhij kdp dkiq mnmaksp pbj
jkcdxojljkp dc czk`mljkpmi xanbps hzp misd cdx mkq dpbjx vzxvdsj+ Pbzs pbj
odkspapzpadk vxda`js pbj `asoxjpadkmxq xjlj`ajs dk pbj Banb Odzxp mk` pbj
_zvxjlj Odzxp+ Ak pbj mhsjkoj dc pbj vxdasadks dc szob xjlj`ajs kd dkj omk
jkcdxoj aps xanbps najk+ Pbzs ~bjxjjx pbjxj as m xanbp pbjxj lzsp hj m xjlj`q
cdx ap+ Pbzs ap sbdzi` smpascq pbj lmral) zha gzs aha xjlj`azl+
Dkj dc pbj vxakoavij lmejxs dc pbj odkspapzpadk) @x+ Mlhj`emx bms najk pbj
vxalj alvdxpmkoj pd Mxpaoij ?8 mldkn mii dpbjx mxpaoijs cxdl pbj Ak`amkOdkspapzpadk+ Bj bms xjcjxxj` pbmp) Ap as pbj jxq sdzi dc pbj Odkspapzpadk mk` pbjjxq bjmxp dc ap+
Ak@jaimi + _PD )ap bms hjjk lmxej` pbmp) Pbjxj omk hj kd `dzhp pbmp pbj
Czk`mljkpmi Xanbps) nzmxmkpjj` pd pbj oapawjks mxj m sankacaomkp cjmpzxj dc dzx
Odkspapzpadk mk` pbj Banb Odzxps zk`jx Mxpaoij 883 mxj hdzk` pd vxdpjop pbjsj
Czk`mljkpmi Xanbps+
Gzspaoj _zhhmxmd ak pbj omsj dcHmsbjsb~mx Kmpb + Odllassadkjx) AkodljPmr
3) spmpj` pbmp)
M imxnj lmgdxapq dc vjdvij mxj sdoamiiq vddx j`zompadkmiiq hmoe~mx` mk`
vdiapaomiiq qjp kdp odksoadzs dc pbjax xanbps) omkkdp hj vappj` mnmaksp pbj spmpj dx
pbj akspapzpadk dx pbjq omkkdp hj vzp dk j}zmi spmpzs ~apb pbj spmpj dx imxnj
dxnmkasmpadks+ Pbj vjdvij mxj xj}zaxjs pd hj vxdpjopj` cxdl pbjlsjijs+ Ap as
3=1:1 MAX =01
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
9/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
3 Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
pbjxjcdxj pbj `zpq dc pbj odzxp pd vxdpjop pbjax xanbps mk` akpjxjsps+ Czk`mljkpmixanbps mxj pbjxjcdxj pxmksojk`jkpmi ak kmpzxj mk` oxjmpj` mk` jkmopj` ak kmpadkmimk` vzhiao akpjxjsp mk` pbjxjcdxj pbjq omkkdp hj ~maj`+
Ak@mxqmd + _pmpj dc Z+V>+) ap ~ms bji` pbmp pbj xanbp pd dhpmak m ~xap lzspj}zmiiq hj m czk`mljkpmi xanbp ~bjk m vjpapadkjx vxjsjkps pbj omsj+ Pbzs) apomkkdp ljxjiq hj odksa`jxj` ms mk ak`aa`zmis xanbp pd ldj pbj _zvxjlj Odzxp
hzp ap as misd pbj `zpq mk` xjsvdksahaiapq dc pbj _zvxjlj Odzxp pd vxdpjop pbjczk`mljkpmi xanbps+
Xdij dc ~xaps ak m`lakaspxmpaj mopadks
Kd~ ms cmx ms pbj xdij dc pbj ~xaps as odkojxkj`) ijp zs nd hq aiizspxmpadk djx pbj
omsjs dk `asoxjpadk+ Odkcjxljkp dc `asoxjpadkmxq vd~jxs bms hjjk moojvpj` mskjojssmxq vbjkdljkm dc ld`jxk m`lakaspxmpaj mk` odkspapzpadkmi lmobakjxq+
Im~ lmeakn mnjkoq ijnasimpjs pbj im~ dk mkq szhgjop pd sjxj pbj vzhiao akpjxjsp
mk` ~baij lmeakn im~) ap bms hjodlj ak`asvjksmhij pd vxda`j cdx `asoxjpadkmxq
vd~jxs pbmp mxj szhgjop pd gz`aoami xjaj~+ Pbj xa`jx as pbmp pbj @dkkaj dc pbj`asoxjpadkmxq vd~jx bms pd jrjxoasj pbj `asoxjpadk ak ndd` cmapb mk` cdx pbj
vzxvdsj cdx ~baob ap as nxmkpj` mk` szhgjop pd ialapmpadks vxjsoxahj` zk`jx pbj
Mop+ Pbj Odzxps bmj xjpmakj` pbjax gzxas`aopadk pd pjsp pbj _pmpzpj dk pbj nxdzk`
dc xjmsdkmhijkjss+ Ldspiq) pbj odzxps xjaj~ dk p~d odzkps5 caxspiq ~bjpbjx pbj
spmpzpj as szhspmkpajiq mia` vajoj dc ijnasimpadk mk`) sjodk`iq ~bjpbjx pbj
spmpzpj vxda`js vxdoj`zxmi smcjnzmx`s+ Ac pbjsj p~d pjsps mxj kdp cdzk`) pbj im~as `joimxj` zipxm axjs mk` da` dc Mxpaoij =0 dc pbj Odkspapzpadk+
Hjsa`j pbas) Odzxps odkpxdi pbj `asoxjpadkmxq vd~jxs dc pbj jrjozpajndjxkljkp hjakn jrjxoasj` mcpjx pbj spmpzpjs bmj odlj pd jrasp+ Dkoj pbjq
odlj akpd jraspjkoj) ap hjodljs pbj `zpq dc pbj Jrjozpaj Ndjxkljkp pd
xjnzimpj pbj vd~jxs ~apbak ialapmpadks vxjsoxahj` pd mobajj pbj dhgjop dc pbj
_pmpzpj+ Pbj `asoxjpadkmxq vd~jxs jkpxzspj` pd pbj `accjxjkp jrjozpajs dc pbj
Ndjxkljkp vimq szhspmkpami xdij ak m`lakaspxmpaj `joasadk lmeakn mk`
allj`ampjiq pbj sjppij` vxakoavijs dc m`lakaspxmpaj im~ pxmv pbj jrjxoasj dcvd~jxs+ Ac pbjsj `asoxjpadkmxq vd~jxs mxj kdp vxdvjxiq jrjxoasj`) dx pbjxj as
mhzsj mk` laszsj dc vd~jxs hq pbj jrjozpajs dx pbjq pmej akpd moodzkp
axxjijmkp odksa`jxmpadk cdx pbmp pbjq mxj kdp jkpapij` pd pmej dx salviq las`axjop
pbjl ak mvviqakn pbj vxdvjx vxdasadk dc im~) pbj `asoxjpadkmxq jrjxoasj dc
vd~jxs as da`+ Gz`aoami xjaj~ as jroiz`j` ~bjk ap as cdzk` pbmp jrjozpajs
lmakpmak pbj spmk`mx` dc xjmsdkmhijkjss ak pbjax `joasadks+ Jxxdxs mxj dcpjk oxjvp
ak japbjx hjomzsj pbjq ~dzi` lmakpmak vzxj m`lakaspxmpaj svaxap ms dvvdsj` pd
gz`aoami cimdzx dx pbmp pbjq akcizjkoj pbjax `joasadks hq sdlj axxjijmkp
>=13= MAX =0:>
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
10/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
> Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
odksa`jxmpadks dx pbmp sdljpaljs) pbj mzpbdxapajs lmq pbjlsjijs las`axjop akim~ dx pbmp pbjq lmq kdp mvviq pbjax lak` pd pbj cmops mk` oaxozlspmkojs dc pbj
omsjs+ Hjsa`js) pbas msvjop) pbjq lmq mop ak `jxdnmpadk dc czk`mljkpmi vxakoavijs
dc kmpzxmi gzspaoj hq kdp odkcdxlakn pd pbj spmk`mx` dx xjmsdks mk` gzspaoj dx
pbdsj pbjq `d kdp gzsp pxziq mvvxjoampj pbj jraspjkoj dx kdk jraspjkoj dcoaxozlspmkojs pbmp lmq jkpapij pbjl pd jrjxoasj pbj `asoxjpadk+
Pbj Jrjozpaj bmj pd xjmob pbjax `joasadks hq pmeakn akpd moodzkp xjijmkp
odksa`jxmpadks+ Pbjq sbdzi` kdp xjczsj pd odksa`jx xjijmkp lmppjx kdx sbdzi`
pbjq pmej akpd moodzkp odksa`jxmpadks pbmp mxj ~bdiiq axxjijmkp dx jrpxmkjdzs+
Pbjq sbdzi` kdp las`axjop pbjlsjijs dk m vdakp dc im~+ Dkiq szob m `joasadk~aii hj im~czi+ Pbj odzxps bmj vd~jx pd sjj pbmp pbj Jrjozpaj mops im~cziiq+
Pbjq omkkdp mda` soxzpakq hq odzxps hq cmaiakn pd naj xjmsdks+ Ac pbjq naj
xjmsdks mk` pbjq mxj kdp ndd` xjmsdks) pbj odzxp omk `axjop pbjl pd xjodksa`jxpbj lmppjx ak pbj ianbp dc xjijmkp lmppjxs pbdznb pbj vxdvxajpq m`j}zmoq dx
smpascmopdxq obmxmopjx dc pbjsj xjmsdks lmq kdp hj dvjk pd gz`aoami soxzpakq+Jjk ac pbj Jrjozpaj odksa`jxs ap akjrvj`ajkp pd jrjxoasj pbjax vd~jxs pbjq
sbdzi` spmpj pbjax xjmsdks mk` pbjxj lzsp hj lmpjxami pd sbd~ pbmp pbjq bmjodksa`jxj` mii pbj xjijmkp cmops+
Pbj xdij dc ~xaps as misd sjksahiq ima` `d~k ak m cmldzs Vm`caji`s omsj7
Ak Jknimk` ak jmxiajx `mqs pbj Odzxps zszmiiq xjczsj` pd akpjxcjxj ~bjxj pbj
Ndjxkljkp dx pbj odkojxkj` dccaojx vmssj` ~bmp ~ms omiij` m kdk,svjmeakn
dx`jx) pbmp as) mk dx`jx ~baob dk pbj cmoj dc ap `a` kdp svjoacq pbj xjmsdks cdx pbj
dx`jxs+ ^bjxj m svjmeakn dx`jx ~ms vmssj` pbj Odzxps vxdojj`j` pd odksa`jx~bjpbjx pbj xjmsdks najk cdx pbj dx`jx dx `joasadk ~jxj xjijmkp xjmsdks+
^bjxj pbjxj ~ms m kdk,svjmeakn dx`jx pbjq zsj` pd smq pbmp ap ~ms iaej pbj cmoj
dc pbj _vbakr ak pbj sjksj pbmp ap ~ms akozxmhij mk` pbjxjcdxj bdi` pbmp pbjq
odzi` kdp odksa`jx pbj }zjspadk dc pbj mia`apq dc pbj dx`jx+ Jjk ak Jknimk` pbj
Odzxps bmj pxmjiij` jxq cmx sakoj pbdsj `mqs+ Pbjq kd idknjx cak` pbj cmoj dcpbj _vbakr aksoxzpmhij+
Mvviaompadk dc ^xaps ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~
Mvviaompadk dc pbj ^xap dc OjxpadxmxaPbj ~xap dc Ojxpadxmxa as hmsaomiiq asszj` mnmaksp pbj spmpzpdxq hd`ajs
jrjxoasakn gz`aoami dx }zmsa gz`aoami vd~jxs+ _zob ~xap as asszj` mnmaksppbj mzpbdxapajs kmljiq pbj ndjxkljkp mk` pbj odzxps dx dpbjx spmpzpdxq
hd`ajs ~bd bmj vd~jx pd `jpjxlakj mk` `joa`j pbj ias hjp~jjk pbj
vmxpajs+ Ak `joa`akn szob asszjs ac pbj `joasadk lmeakn dx`jx as vmssj`
~apbdzp mkq mzpbdxapq dx bms vmssj` pbj dx`jx ak jrjxoasj dc szob mzpbdxapqdx bms odllappj` mk jxxdx dc im~ mk` cmops pbj banb odzxp as jlvd~jxj` pd
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
11/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
2 Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
odxxjop szob jxxdx dc pbj id~jx odzxp dx ndjxkljkp mzpbdxapajs+ Ojxpadxmxalmq mvviq ~bjk pbj m`lakaspxmpaj dx jrjozpaj mzpbdxapq cmais pd dhsjxj
pbjax `zpq pd mop cmaxiq ~apb xjsvjop pd pbj m`lakaspxmpaj czkopadks+ Pbj
~xap dc Ojxpadxmxa lmq misd hj asszj` mnmaksp m szhdx`akmpj pxahzkmi jjk ac
pbj `joasadk alvznkj` as vxdkdzkoj`+ M ijm`akn omsj dc Xqdps dcNmxmhmk`bd + Wmlak`mx dc Vmximealj`a
2) ~ms pbj caxsp `joasadk dk pbj
~xap dc Ojxpadxmxa+
Mvviaompadk dc pbj ^xap dc Lmk`mlzsPbj ~xap dc lmk`mlzs as dx`jxj` ~bjk pbj spmpzpdxq mzpbdxapajs ~bd
jkpxzspj` ~apb pbj `zpajs cmai pd `asobmxnj aps dhianmpdxq `zpq+ Ap lmq hj
mvviaj` ~bjk pbj ndjxkljkp mzpbdxapajs jspj` ~apb mhsdizpj vd~jxs cmai
pd vjxcdxl pbjax m`lakaspxmpaj mk` spmpzpdxq `zpajs+ AkXmpiml LzkaoavmiOdzkoai + Smx`aobmk`
1) dk moodzkp dc pbj vzhiao kzasmkoj oxjmpj` ak pbj
mxjm hq pbj odxvdxmpadk ak kdp lmakpmakakn pbj `xmakmnj sqspjl mk` pbj
`axpq ~mpjx spakeakn bm` oidnnj` mxdzk` ~baob dhadzsiq oxjmpj`
kzasmkoj mp pbj bmk`s dc lzkaoavmiapq cdx kdp `asobmxnakn pbj `zpajs zk`jx
pbj mop+ Ms m xjszip pbj xjsa`jkps dc Xmpiml lzkaoavmiapq ldj` pbj _zh,
`aasadkmi lmnaspxmpj zk`jx sjopadk =?? dc Od`j dc Oxalakmi Vxdoj`zxj)
=1>? cdx mhmpjljkp dc kzasmkoj mk` pbj odzxp asszj` pbj `axjopadks pbmp)Gz`aoami `asoxjpadk ~bjk cmops cdx aps jrjxoasj mxj vxjsjkp bms m
lmk`mpdxq alvdxp+ Pbjxjcdxj ~bjk pbj _zh,@aasadkmi Lmnaspxmpj)Xmpiml) bms hjcdxj bal akcdxlmpadk mk` ja`jkoj ~baob `asoidsj pbj
vxjsjkoj dc vzhiao kzasmkoj) odksa`jxs ap im~czi pd xjldj szob
dhspxzopadk+ Pbas as m vzhiao `zpq alviaoap ak pbj vzhiao vd~jx pd hjjrjxoasj` dk hjbmic dc pbj vzhiao mk` as vzxszmkp pd vzhiao vxdojj`akn+
Idx` @jkkakn dhsjxj 7
Ak lq dvakadk jjxq njkzakj odlvimakp ~baob as ~dxpbq dc akjspanmpadk hq pbj
odllappjj dc akjspanmpadk sbdzi` hj xjcjxxj` pd pbmp odllappjj+ Pbj Lakaspjx as
kdp mp iahjxpq pd xjczsj ap dk nxdzk`s ~baob mxj mxhapxmxq dx omvxaoadzs+ Kdphjomzsj bj bms m vjxsdkmi mkpavmpbq pd pbj odlviamkp dx `djs kdp iaej bas
vdiapaomi aj~s+ Kdx dk mkq dpbjx axxjijmkp nxdzk`+++ Ap as sma` pbmp pbj `joasadk
dc pbj Lakaspjx as m`lakaspxmpaj mk` kdp gz`aoami+ Hzp pbmp `djs kdp ljmk pbmp bj
omk `d ms bj iaejs) xjnmx`ijss dc xanbp dx ~xdkn+ Kdx `djs ap ljmk pbmp pbj Odzxps
mxj vd~jxijss pd odxxjop bal+ Ndd` m`lakaspxmpadk xj}zaxjs pbmp odlvimakpssbdzi` hj akjspanmpj` mk` pbmp nxajmkoj sbdzi` hj xjlj`aj`+ ^bjk vmxiamljkp
bms sjp zv lmobakjxq cdx pbmp jxq vzxvdsj) ap as kdp cdx pbj Lakaspjx pd hxzsb ap
2 "=10:! 0> HDLIX :8:1
MAX =126 _O =388
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
12/14
-
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
13/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
=6 Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
_aknb==
ap ~ms spmpj` pbmp) pbj ~xap dc Bmhjms Odxvzs as ak pbj kmpzxj dc mkdx`jx cdx omiiakn zvdk pbj vjxsdk ~bd bms `jpmakj` dx mxxjspj` mkdpbjx
vjxsdk pd vxd`zoj pbj imppjx hjcdxj pbj odzxp) ak dx`jx pd ijp odzxp ekd~ dk
~bmp nxdzk` bj bms hjjk odkcakj` mk` pd sjp bal cxjj ac pbjxj as kd ijnmi
gzspacaompadk cdx pbj alvxasdkljkp+ Dkj dc pbj pjiiakn ~mqs ak ~baob pbjadimpadk dc pbmp xanbp omk xjmsdkmhiq hj vxjjkpj` mk` `zj odlviamkoj
~apb pbj lmk`mpj dc mxpaoij 8= sjozxj`) as pd lziop aps adimpdxs ak pbjvmqljkp dc ldkjpmxq odlvjksmpadk+
OdkoizsadkPbj vxjxdnmpaj vd~jxs dc ~xap gzxas`aopadk odkcjxxj` hq pbj odkspapzpadk cdx
gz`aoami xjaj~ dc m`lakaspxmpaj mopadk as zk`dzhpj iq `asoxjpadkmxq mk` qjpzkhdzk`j` ak aps ialaps+ Pbj `asoxjpadk bd~jjx sbdzi` hj jrjxoasj` dk sdzk`
ijnmi vxakoavijs+ Ak pbas xjsvjop ap as alvdxpmkp pd jlvbmsasj pbmp pbj mhsjkoj dcmxhapxmxq vd~jx as pbj caxsp jssjkpami dc pbj xzij dc im~ zvdk ~baob pbj ~bdij
odkspapzpadk sqspjl as hmsj`+ Ak m sqspjl ndjxkj` hq xzij dc im~ ~bjk
`asoxjpadk as odkcjxxj` zvdk pbj jrjozpaj mzpbdxapajs ap lzsp hj hmsj` dk oijmxiq`jcaj` ialaps+ Pbzs pbj xzij dc im~ cxdl pbas vdakp dc aj~ ljmks pbmp pbj
`asoxjpadk dx pbj `joasadk lzsp hj hmsj` dk sdlj vxakoavijs mk` xzijs+ Ak njkjxmi
pbj `joasadk sbdzi` hj vxj`aopmhij mk` oapawjks sbdzi` ekd~ ~bjxj bj as+ Ac m
`joasadk as pmejk kdp dk pbj hmsas dc mkq vxakoavij dx xzijs pbjk szob `joasadk asmxhapxmxq mk` as pmejk kdp ak moodx`mkoj ~apb pbj xzij dc im~+
Pbj im~ bms xjmobj` aps cakjsp ldljkps spmpj` @znims) O+G+ ak Zkapj` _pmpjs +
^zk`jxiaob=8
~bjk ap bms cxjj` lmk cxdl pbj sbmoeijs dc zkialapj` `asoxjpadk+
Pbj lmk bms szccjxj` dk moodzkp dc mhsdizpj `asoxjpadk+ Pbj `joasadk sbdzi` hjnza`j` hq xzij dc im~ mk` ap sbdzi` kdp hj hmsj` dk ~bals) cmkoq mk` bzldzx+
Pbj Odkspapzpadk as pbj im~ dc pbj im~s mk` kdhd`q as szvxjlj+ Jjk pbj gz`njs
dc _zvxjlj Odzxp mxj kdp mhdj im~ mk` pbjq mxj hdzk` hq pbj `joasadks ~baobmxj pbj im~ dc pbj imk` `joimxj` hq pbjl zk`jx pbj ~xap vjpapadks+ Pbzs) pbj
odkspapzpadkmi xjlj`ajs vxda`j` zk`jx pbj odkspapzpadk dvjxmpj ms m objoe mk`
ejjvs pbj m`lakaspxmpadk dc ndjxkljkp ~apbak pbj hdzk`s dc im~+
== =1:1 MAX =?6?=8
?08 Z+_+ 12 "=1:=!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Reportshttp://supreme.justia.com/us/342/98/case.htmlhttp://supreme.justia.com/us/342/98/case.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Reports -
8/7/2019 Role of WRITS in administrative law
14/14
Mlapq Im~ _obddi) Izoekd~ 86==
== Xdij dc ^XAP_ ak M`lakaspxmpaj Im~y M@LAKA_PXMPASJ IM^
Hahiadnxmvbq
Hddes xjcjxxj`7
Ijopzxjs dk M`lakaspxmpaj Im~) O+E+ Pme~mkaM`lakaspxmpaj Im~) _+V+ _mpbjM`lakaspxmpaj Im~) @x+ G+G+X+ Zvm`bqmq
^jhsapjs xjcjxxj`7
~~~+ijnmisjxaojak`am+odl ~~~+nzqmkmim~+kjp ~~~+ak`amkemkddk+dxn ~~~+ijnmiszpxm+dxn
http://www.legalserviceindia.com/http://www.guyanalaw.net/http://www.indiankanoon.org/http://www.indiankanoon.org/http://www.guyanalaw.net/http://www.legalserviceindia.com/