© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
1
Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI)
Oli Coe – Farm Energy Centre
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
2
International Pressure
Kyoto Protocol
Climate Change Act in 2008
- 2050 Target - Carbon Budgets - The Committee on Climate Change - A National Adaptation Plan
- Europe surpassed it with ease, but…
- So did the US without even trying
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
3
Climate Change Performance Index (CCPI) 2015
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
4
FIT & RHI
Feed-in Tariff (FIT) Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI)
• Wind
• Solar Photovoltaic (PV)
• Hydro
• Anaerobic Digesters (AD)
• Micro Combined Heat and
Power (CHP)
• Biomass Boilers
• Ground, air and water
source Heat Pumps
• Solar thermal
• Biogas combustion
• Biomethane injection to the
grid
• Solid biomass CHP
• Deep geothermal
• Waste
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
5
What is the Renewable Heat Incentive?
- It pays participants that generate and use renewable energy
- Attempts to reduce dependency on fossil fuel use
- The aim is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions
- Domestic and non-domestic schemes
Non-Domestic Scheme
- Administered by Ofgem
- Introduced in November 2011
- Payable to eligible installations on heat used
- 20 year index linked subsidy
- A number of eligible technologies
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
6
Uptake of RHI (MW)
Solid Biomass Boiler, 995.836, 99%
Biogas, 2.077, 0%
Deep Geothermal, 0, 0%
Ground Source Heat Pump (GSHP), 7.8, 1%
Solar Thermal, 2.247, 0%
Water Source Heat Pump (WSHP), 1.285, 0%
Solid Biomass CHP, 0, 0%
Air Source Heat Pump (ASHP), 0.145, 0%
Waste, 0, 0%
Other, 13.546, 1%
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
7
Who is making use of the RHI?
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
8
What size is best for the RHI?
Key Points
• There have been a couple of rate drops
on small biomass systems
• Very little movement on medium biomass
rates
• An increase in the rates for large biomass
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
9
Biomass Rates
Small Commercial Biomass (<200kW)
Medium Commercial Biomass (200-1000kW)
Large Commercial Biomass (<1000kW)
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
10
Example – 199kW Boiler
Key Stats
199kW boiler providing an eligible use with 300,000 kWh annual heat
demand.
Tier 1 (kWh) = 1,314 hours x 199 kW = 261,486 kWh
Tier 2 (kWh) = anything over 261,486 kWh in the year
Why 1,314 hours?
- Ofgem expect biomass boilers to have a utilisation factor of
at least 15%
Tier 1 = 261,486 kWh x 6.8 p/kWh = £19,141.05
Tier 2 = 38,514 kWh x 1.8 p/kWh = £693.25
Total RHI Payments = £19,834.30
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
11
Example – 990kW Boiler
Key Stats
1.5 Ha Nursery is using a 990kW Biomass Boiler for 50% of site heat. The heating requirement is 500 kWh/m2/year.
Total heat from biomass is 3,750,000 kWh.
Tier 1 (kWh) = 1,314 hours x 990 kW = 1,300,860kWh
Tier 2 (kWh) = anything over 1,300,860 kWh in the year
Tier 1 = 1,300,860 kWh x 5.1 p/kWh = £66,343.86
Tier 2 = 2,449,140 kWh x 2.2 p/kWh = £53,881.08
Total RHI Payments = £120,224.94
One Step Further
RHI Payments = £120,224.94
Biomass Fuel Cost = £151,260.50
Net Cost = £31,035.56
Gas Cost = £93,750.00
Net Cost = £93,750.00
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
12
Degression Mechanism
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
£ m
illio
n
Small biomass plants forecast expenditure, as at 31.12.2014
Forecast expenditure (£m) -Accreditations receiving payment
Forecast expenditure (£m) -Accreditations that have not yetreceived payment as at 31.12.2014
Forecast expenditure (£m) - Fullapplications
Forecast expenditure (£m) -Preliminary applications andpreliminary accreditations
Expenditure threshold (Totalexpenditure anticipated forsubsequent year) (£m)
Expenditure threshold (or scaledtrigger) (£m)
5% Tariff Reduction
Announced
10% Tariff Reduction
Announced
10% Tariff
Reduction
Announced
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
13
Degression Mechanism
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
£ m
illio
n
Medium biomass plants forecast expenditure, as at 31.12.2014
Forecast expenditure (£m) -Accreditations receiving payment
Forecast expenditure (£m) -Accreditations that have not yetreceived payment as at31.12.2014
Forecast expenditure (£m) - Fullapplications
Forecast expenditure (£m) -Preliminary applications andpreliminary accreditations
Expenditure threshold (Totalexpenditure anticipated forsubsequent year) (£m)
Expenditure threshold (or scaledtrigger) (£m)
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
14
Batch burner
• Does what it says on the tin – Manual loading
– Will ‘burn out’
– Can be kept topped up, but only if people are around to do so
– Needs accumulator
– Cheaper to buy
– High operational cost
– Low maintenance costs
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
15
Automated System
• Gives continuous heat supply – Load fuel feed once/day
– Can be modulated
– Typically higher efficiency
– More expensive
– Less operation cost but maybe higher maintenance?
– More cost effective in the end?
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
16
Considerations
• De-ashing
• Tube cleaning
• ‘Fettling’ controls
• Breakdowns
• Clinker removal
• 1 hour/day
• Plus 2-5 hours/week
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
17
Batch Burner vs Automatic
Batch burn Automated
Capital cost - Boiler £70,000 – 100,000 £180,000 – 250,000
Capital cost - Buildings £20,000 – 40,000 £30,000 – 80,000
Installation cost £50,000 £100,000
Daily operation 3 hours/day 1 hour/day
Maintenance 2 hours/week 2 hours/week
RHI eligibility Yes if emissions certificate NOX and dust?
Yes if emissions certificate NOX and dust?
RHI rates Tier 1 – 5.1 p/kWh Tier 2 – 2.2 p/kWh
Tier 1 – 5.1 p/kWh Tier 2 – 2.2 p/kWh
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
18
Case Study 1
Ornamental Grower
- 1.9 Ha and 3.0 Ha areas
- Two 4MW Existing Oil Boilers
- Installed two 990 kW woodchip boilers
- Capital Cost of £1,000,000
- Annual RHI Income of just over £180,000
- Annual cost of fuel of £50,000 where it
would have been <£350,000 on gas oil
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
19
Case Study 2
Ornamental Grower
- 1.2 Ha area
- Two existing 950 kW Gas Oil burner
- Installed one 995 MW pellet boiler
- Capital Cost of £280,000
- Annual RHI Income of £120,000
- Annual cost of fuel of £175,000 where it
would have been £80,000 on gas
They liked the system so much they bought another one
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
20
Case Study 3
Edibles Grower (Cucumbers)
- 4.25 Ha area
- A 2.7 MW coal boiler, two 1.6 MW CHP
engines and 5.6MW Gas Boiler
- Installed one 2.8 MW cereal straw boilers
- Capital Cost of £600,000
- Annual RHI Income of £70,000
- Annual cost of fuel of £190,000 where it
would have been £250,000 on coal and gas
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
21
Eligibility Criteria
Providing heat for eligible purposes
Has to be new (Commissioned after July 2009)
Solely Biomass
Emissions
Installation & Metering is correct
No grants or public funding
Biomass Sustainability
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
22
Emissions Criteria
- Boiler model needs to be tested to ISO 17025 standard
- Issued with an RHI-EC (Exemption Certificate)
Ensure this is the case BEFORE buying a boiler!
Pollutant NOx PM
Emission limit, g/GJ 150 30
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
23
Metering
Essential for RHI Need at least 1
May need more if fossil fuel boilers in system
Must be MID compliant or equivalent
Mechanical flow meter
and digital integrator
Ultrasonic
flow meter
and digital
integrator
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
24
Applying for the RHI
• Can be made online
• Documentation needed • Schematic
• Independent metering report
• Boiler warranty and commissioning
• Proof of eligible use
• Calibration certificates
• Emissions Certificate
• Bank account details
• Photographs
• Meter readings
• Etc.
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
25
Ongoing Obligations
Meter Readings
- At least quarterly for <1MW
- Would recommend weekly or daily if possible
Fuel Records
- Amount burned, not just amount bought
- Moisture content on arrival
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
26
Biomass Sustainability
• Land Criteria – sustainable source
• GHG Emissions
• Only wood fuels currently
• Soon to be a non-woody biomass list
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
27
Ofgem Audits
Ofgem carry out two types of audit
- Desk based
- Site Audit
They publish results of audits, main non-compliances are:
“• participants have not been maintaining fuel records for biomass installations, particularly
where harvesting their own fuel. We would like to remind participants that records of the
quantity and type of fuel used and the date of supply to the boiler must be maintained.
• meters have not been installed in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions. Metering
equipment and meter installation manuals must be checked to ensure the meter has been
installed correctly.”
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
28
Issues to Consider
• Fuel Storage
• CO2 Requirements
• Planning Permission
• Project Lead Time
• Impact on Energy Savings
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
29
Alternatives
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
30
• Feasibility
• Boiler sizing
• Design assistance — especially metering
• Independent metering report
• Application
• Ongoing meter reading submissions, support and audit advice
Seeking Advice
© 2015 Farm Energy Centre
31
Question Time