Re-Imagining the Organization
2008Financial Management Institute of Canada –
Manitoba Chapter Professional Development Day
Presented by: David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFMCo-Author: Government Performance Audit in ActionFaculty: Siena College and USDA Graduate School, Washington DCDirector of Audits: NYS Comptroller’s Office
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
2
Kudos to Tom Peters
• Re-imagine: Making the Compelling Case for Radical Enterprise Change … and then Doing Something about It!
• The Audit Profession is failing and not meeting the public’s expectation – dramatic change is needed
• All we do is tinker – Incrementalism is the death of innovation Nick Negroponte
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
3
• Peters was inspired to write Re-Imagine! because he is "madder than hell." He rants about organizational barriers and the egos of "petty tyrants" thwarting the good intentions of enterprising people in numerous ways. He sets out to reinstall the will, passion and know-how into every executive and employee who is ready to take on a renewed sense of individual responsibility.
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
4
“If you don’t like change, you’re
going to like irrelevance even less.” —General Eric Shinseki, Chief of Staff. U. S. Army
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
5
• “Good management was the most powerful reason [leading firms] failed to stay atop their industries. Precisely because these firms listened to their customers, invested aggressively in technologies that would provide their customers more and better products of the sort they wanted, and because they carefully studied market trends and systematically allocated investment capital to innovations that promised the best returns, they lost their positions of leadership.”
Clayton Christensen, The Innovator’s Dilemma
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
6
PASSION! ENTHUSIASM!
Passion & Enthusiasm have to be at the
Head Table
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
7
Static/Imitative
Integrity.
Quality.
Excellence.
Continuous Improvem
ent.
Superior Service (Exceeds Expectations.)
Completely Satisfactory Transaction.
Smooth Evolution.
Market Share.
Dynamic/Different
Dramatic Difference!
Disruptive!
Insanely Great! (Q
uality++++)
Life-(Industry-)changing Experience!
Gam
e-changing!
WO
W!
Surprise!
Delight!
Breathtaking!
Punctuated Equilibrium!
Market Creation!
The Auditors
Today
Where
the Auditors
should
be today!
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
8
• “The ‘surplus society’ has a surplus of
similar companies, employing similar people, with similar educational
backgrounds, coming up with similar ideas, producing similar things, with
similar prices and similar quality.”
Kjell Nordström and Jonas Ridderstråle, Funky Business
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
9
• Experience: “Rebel Lifestyle!”
“What we sell is the ability for a 43-year-old accountant to dress in black leather, ride through small towns and have people be afraid of him.”Harley exec, quoted in Results-Based Leadership
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
10
• “This is an essay about what it takes to create and sell something remarkable. It is a plea for originality, passion, guts and daring. You can’t be remarkable by following someone else who’s remarkable. One way to figure out a theory is to look at what’s working in the real world and determine what the successes have in common. But what could the Four Seasons and Motel 6 possibly have in common? Or Neiman-Marcus and Wal*Mart? Or Nokia (bringing out new hardware every 30 days or so) and Nintendo (marketing the same Game Boy 14 years in a row)? It’s like trying to
drive looking in the rearview mirror. The thing that all these companies have in common is that they have nothing in common. They are outliers. They’re on the
fringes. Superfast or superslow. Very exclusive or very cheap. Extremely big or extremely small. The reason it’s so hard to follow the leader is this: The leader is the leader precisely because he did something remarkable. And that remarkable thing is now taken—so it’s no longer remarkable when you decide to do it.” —Seth Godin, Fast Company/02.2003
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
11
• “The Bottleneck is at the Top of the Bottle”“Where are you likely to find people with the least diversity of experience, the largest investment in the past, and the greatest reverence for industry dogma?
At the top!” — Gary Hamel/“Strategy or Revolution”/Harvard Business Review
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
12
•Innovation!
NOT
Imitation
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
13
• I Borrowed Your Watch: Here’s What Time It Is
Make a DifferenceAdd Exceptional ValueEnduring Relationships with others who Have the Potential to Be GreatFocus/Strong Sectoral Approach
Dramatic DifferenceResearch RootsResearch InvestmentUnique Analytic ProcessHighly Disciplined Fundamental Intrinsic Value Analysis
Partnership CultureMutual SupportEnthusiasmMake a DifferenceVisibility/Tell Story/Brand
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
14
Credo•
1. Ready. Fire! Aim.2. If it ain’t broke ... Break it!3. Hire crazies.4. Ask dumb questions.5. Pursue failure.6. Lead, follow ... or get out of the way!7. Spread confusion.8. Ditch your office.9. Read odd stuff.
10. Avoid moderation!
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
15
•“Beware of the tyranny of making Small Changes to Small
Things. Rather, make Big Changes to Big Things.” —Roger
Enrico, former Chairman, PepsiCo
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
16
• “Ninety percent of what we call ‘management’ consists of making it difficult for people to get things done.” – Peter Drucker
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
17
• Organizing Genius / Warren Bennis and Patricia Ward Biederman
“Groups become great only when everyone in
them, leaders and members alike, is free to do his or her absolute best.”“The best thing a leader can do for a Great
Group is to allow its members to discover their greatness.”
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
18
•Insist on Speed!
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
19
•Dispense Enthusiasm!
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
20
•“You must be the change you wish to see in the world.”Gandhi
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
21
•“You can’t behave in a calm, rational manner. You’ve got to be out there on the lunatic fringe.” — Jack Welch
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
22
What We Need to Do To the Auditing Profession
• The auditing profession is under siege
today
• We have to get back to basics and assure
we meet the public’s expectations
• We need to lead our staff in a new
direction
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
23
Agenda
• Define five major challenges and the
cause
• Propose a focus that will enable auditors
to meet the public’s expectations
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
24
Challenges to the Auditing Profession
1. Not using due professional care
2. Not properly assessing internal controls
3. Not obtaining sufficient, competent evidence
4. Not obtaining sufficient knowledge about the area being audited – (inherent risk)
5. Not developing an appropriate level of professional skepticism
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
25
Not using due professional care
• The complexity of today’s organizations creates challenges in understanding what to do
• Technology drives most organizations and it’s constantly changing – it’s hard for auditors to keep up-to-date
• Distance between audit locations and main offices can create supervision challenges
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
26
Due Professional Care
• Internal Controls– Do we really assess the five components of
COSO?• Control Environment• Risk Assessment• Control Activities• Information & Communication• Monitoring
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
27
Due Professional Care
• Evidence– Do we really obtain sufficient, competent and
relevant evidence?• Paramlat
• Inherent Risk– Do we fully understand the risks to the area
we are auditing – do we have enough knowledge?
• Worldcom
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
28
Due Professional Care
• Professional Skepticism– Do we have a questioning mind and make a
critical assessment of evidence?– Are we willing to suspend judgment about the
honesty of agency management?– Do we use diligence which a prudent and
competent person would exercise under a given set of circumstances?
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
29
Not properly assessing internal controls
• Most large organizational frauds can be traced to the control environment– Managements, attitude, philosophy, operating
style – the ethics and integrity of people in the organization – the competence of people. It is the foundation of all other control components
• Auditors shy away from this component because it is more subjective
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
30
Not obtaining sufficient, competent evidence
• Documentary evidence has limited value today because of technology– Color copiers, color printers, Internet access
to corporate logos, scanners and software enable anyone to duplicate and alter original documents
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
31
Not obtaining sufficient knowledge
• Too many auditors are desk-bound
• The desk is a dangerous place from which to view the world
• Understanding inherent risk requires knowledge of programs, functions and activities
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
32
Not being professionally skeptic
• Too often auditors accept at face value what is told to them
• Challenging management is not in keeping with good relationship management – it’s not what your mother taught you
Financial Management Institute
Copyright 2008 David R. Hancox, CIA, CGFM
33
Summary
• Doing a good audit is hard work
• Much of what we are asked to do, requires us to challenge others and to not accept at face value what we are told or evidence we review
• We need to step up to the plate and accept that some parts of our work are subjective and depends on our professional judgment