Outbreak Management
Learning Objectives
1. Describe the occurrence of disease in a population.
2. Discuss how an epidemic curve can help in managing an outbreak.
3. Outline the steps in outbreak investigation.
2
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Time involved
• 60 minutes
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
3
Purposes of Outbreak Investigation
• To Identify the causal agent• To find the source of infection by studying
the occurrence of the disease among persons, place, or time, as well as determining specific attack rates
• Formulate recommendations to prevent further transmission
4
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Definitions - 1
• Outbreak or epidemic• An excess over the expected (usual) level of a disease
within a geographic area• However, one case of an unusual disease may
constitute an epidemic• E.g., postsurgical group A streptococcus infection
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
5
Definitions - 2
• Endemic• The usual level of a disease within a geographic area
• E.g., a hospital
• These ‘sporadic’ infections represent most preventable healthcare-associated infections
• Baseline incidence
• Pandemic• An epidemic that spreads in several countries• Usually affecting many people
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
6
Endemic and Epidemic
“Endemic”
“Epidemic”
Time
Num
ber
of C
ases
of D
isea
se
7
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Healthcare-associated infections
• Majority of healthcare-associated infections are endemic
• Outbreak of healthcare-associated infections occur typically in a specific group of patients
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
8
Definitions - 3
• Relative risk• A measure of association between a disease or
condition and a factor under study• Calculation
• Divide the incidence rate of those exposed to the factor by the incidence rate of those not exposed
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
9
Interpretation of Relative Risk
RR =1 Incidence in the exposed group is the same as in the non-exposed
There is no association between exposure and disease
RR >1 Denotes a larger incidence in the exposed than in the non-exposed
Exposure seems to increase the probability of developing the disease
RR <1 Denotes a smaller incidence in the exposed than in the non-exposed
Exposure seems to decrease the probability of developing the disease
10
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Types of Outbreaks
• Community-acquired• Food-borne infections, measles
• Healthcare-associated• When two or more cases of infection
appear to be epidemiologically related
11
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Steps of Outbreak Investigation
1. Verify existence of the outbreak2. Determine if there were changes in case
finding or diagnostics 3. Establish diagnosis of reported cases 4. Case finding5. Characterise cases 6. Formulate hypothesis7. Test the hypothesis 8. Institute control measures and follow up 12
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Verify existence of an outbreak
• Compare the number of current cases with the usual baseline incidence
• from previous months or years • If local data are not available, compare to
information from national surveillance systems or the literature • these data may not be applicable to the local situation
13
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Determine if there were changes in case finding or diagnostics • New techniques or laboratory tests may increase
identification when historically cases would not have been identified
• Provides a new ‘baseline’ of disease
14
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Define cases
• Typically involves identifying an agent• Define cases based on the following common
factors:• Population risk factors
• Age, race, sex, socioeconomic status
• Clinical data• Onset of signs and symptoms• Frequency and duration of clinical features associated with
the outbreak
• Laboratory results
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
15
Case Definition
• The inclusion and exclusion criteria for cases must be precisely identified
• The definition should differentiate between infection and colonisation
• Includes a unit of time and place and specific biological and/or clinical criteria
• A graded definition (definite, probable, or possible) often helps
16
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Case Finding
Collect critical data and specimen information from:
• Laboratory reports • Medical records• Patient charts• Physicians and nursing staff• Public health data
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
17
Characterise cases
• Assemble and organise available information for analysis
• From this information, the population at risk can be accurately described
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
18
Characterise cases - Time• The exact period of the outbreak• The probable period of exposure• Date of onset of illness for cases; draw an
epidemic curve• Is the outbreak common source or
propagated?
19
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Characterise cases – Place/TimePlace
• Service, ward, operating room• Clustering of cases
Person• Patient characteristics (age, sex, underlying disease)• Possible exposures (surgery, nursing and medical
staff , infected patients)• Therapy (invasive procedures, medications,
antibiotics)
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
20
Calculate rates
• Incidence rate• The number of new cases occurring in the
population during a specified time / number of persons exposed to the risk of developing the disease during that time
• Attack rate• The cumulative incidence rate of infection in a
group over a period of an epidemic• Number of people at risk who are infected / Total
number of people at risk
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
21
Source of Infection • Common source (single-point source)
• Same origin
• Propagated or continuing source (on-going transmission)• Infections are transmitted from person to person
• Both common and propagated source• Intermittent exposure to a common source • Produces an epidemic curve with irregularly
spaced peaks
22
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Epidemic curve - 1
• Also called a histogram• Determines the character of an epidemic • Cases are plotted by date of onset of illness• Time intervals (on the X axis) are based on
the incubation or latency period of the disease and the length of the period over which cases are distributed
23
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Epidemic curve - 2The reasons for constructing an epidemic curve include:
To determine whether the source of infection was common, propagated, or both
To identify the probable time of exposure of the cases to the source(s) of infection
To identify the probable incubation period To determine if the problem is ongoing
24
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
A . Propagated source: single exposure, no secondary cases (e.g., measles).B. Propagated source: secondary and tertiary cases (e.g., hepatitis A).C. Common source: point exposure . D. Common source: Intermittent exposure.
25
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Epidemic curve
26
Helps to develop hypotheses• Incubation period• Etiological agent• Type of source• Mode of transmission• Propagated source• Common source• Time of exposure
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Common Source Outbreak
27
December 1, 2013
An explosive epidemic of short duration generally indicates• A common source of infection
• Exposure over a short period of time
• A large numbers of susceptible exposed
• A high attack rate
• An incubation period with little variation
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
28
Propagated Source Outbreak
• Cases occur over a long period• Explosive epidemics due to person-to-person
transmission may occur• E.g., chickenpox
• If secondary and tertiary cases occur, intervals between peaks usually approximate to the average incubation period
29
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Propagated source - 1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Week
Cases
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
30
Single exposure, no secondary cases (e.g. measles)
Propagated source - 2
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Week
Cases
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
31
Secondary and tertiary cases (e.g., hepatitis A)
Determine Exposure Period
• Using the mean or median incubation period• Identify the peak of the epidemic or the date of onset
of the median case• Count back into one incubation period
• Using minimum and maximum incubation periods• Start with the first case identified and count back in
time the minimum incubation period• Then using the last case, count back in time the
maximum incubation period
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
32
Exposure Period
33
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Formulate hypothesis
• Make a best guess to explain the observations• The hypothesis should explain most cases
34
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Test the Hypothesis
• Many investigations do not reach this stage• Investigation may end with descriptive
epidemiology and then the problem goes away without intervention or does not require a special study
35
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Institute Control Measures
• Control measures are determined by the results of the initial analysis in consultation with appropriate professionals
• They will vary depending on the agent, the mode of transmission, and observations
36
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Control Measures
Interventions commonly used to control an outbreak are as follows:
• Control the source of the pathogen • Remove the source of contamination, e.g., discard
contaminated food
• Remove persons from exposure• Keep people from being exposed to mosquito bites to
prevent encephalitis
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
37
Healthcare-Associated Infections – Control Measures
Type of transmission suspected Suggested action
Contact- Cross-transmission (transmission between individuals)
Patient isolation and barrier precautions determined by infectious agent(s)
Contact- Hand transmission Improvements in hand hygiene (e.g., washing, disinfection, glove use)
Airborne agent Patient isolation with appropriate ventilation
Waterborne agent Checking of water supply and all liquid containers Use of disposable devices
Foodborne agent Elimination of the at-risk food
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
38
Evaluate Efficacy of Control Measures
• Cases cease to occur or return to endemic level
• No change (re-evaluate cases)
39
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Communicate and Write a Final Report • During the investigation, up-to-date information is
communicated to administration and appropriate authorities
• A final report should be prepared describing the outbreak, interventions, and effectiveness, and summarising the contribution of each team member participating in the investigation• It should include recommendations to prevent any future
occurrence40
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
Summary
• Outbreaks of infection should be clearly defined, identified, and promptly investigated because of their importance in terms of morbidity, cost, improvement of patient care, and institutional image
• Proper steps and effective techniques should be used to investigate a suspected outbreak
• Clear recommendations should be formulated to prevent further transmission and/or outbreaks
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
41
References• Flora IH, Manuel B. Disease Outbreak Investigation. The Young
Epidemiology Scholars Program (YES) supported by The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and administered by the College Board, 2005. http://www.collegeboard.com/yes/ft/iu/home.html
• Reingold AL. Outbreak Investigations—A Perspective. National Center for Infectious Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Emerg Infect Diseases 1998; 4 (1). http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/eid/vol4no1/reingold.htm
• Susan P. Outbreak Investigation. The University of Texas, Harris county psychiatric center, 2010. http://www.uth.tmc.edu/uth_orgs/hcpc/procedures/volume1/chapter6/infection_control-51.htm
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
42
Web Resource
• How to Investigate an Outbreak• http://
www.cdc.gov/excite/classroom/outbreak/index.htm • Communicable Disease Control: Outbreak Investigation
• http://www.healthknowledge.org.uk/public-health-textbook/disease-causation-diagnostic/2g-communicable-disease/outbreak-investigation
• Epidemiological Investigation of Outbreaks• http://
www.gov.mb.ca/health/publichealth/cdc/protocol/investigation.pdf
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
43
Quiz1. Outbreak investigations are performed primarily to:
a. Gather clinical information about a diseaseb. Find the source of infectionsc. Make sure patients are treatedd. All of the above
2. Epidemic curves help determine if the problem is on-going. T/F
3. Control measures for healthcare-associated infections include all except:
a. Patient isolationb. Use of disposablesc. Hand hygiened. Immunisation
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
44
International Federation of Infection Control• IFIC’s mission is to facilitate international networking in
order to improve the prevention and control of healthcare associated infections worldwide. It is an umbrella organisation of societies and associations of healthcare professionals in infection control and related fields across the globe .
• The goal of IFIC is to minimise the risk of infection within healthcare settings through development of a network of infection control organisations for communication, consensus building, education and sharing expertise.
• For more information go to http://theific.org/
Dec
emb
er 1
, 20
13
45