BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Su Houng Lee, Yonsei Univ.Su Houng Lee, Yonsei Univ.
P.Morath, S.Kim, SHL, W.Weise, PRL 82 (99) 3396
S. Kim, SHL, NPA 679 (01) 517
Y.Oh, S Kim, SHL, PRC 65 (02) 067901
SHL, C.Ko, PRC 67 (03) 038202
QCD 2QCD 2ndnd order Stark Effect order Stark Effect and Heavy Quark Systems and Heavy Quark Systems
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
QCD Vacuum is non perturbative
symmetry breaking…
Light Hadron masses are O(GeV)
whereas light quark masses are less than 10 MeV
The lowest dimensional QCD Operator characterizing the non perturbative vacuum are,
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Light quark propagation in QCD Vacuum (QCD OPE)
+ ………….. Sensitive to vacuum quark and
gluon field configuration at small q
rho mass (770MeV), nucleon (938MeV)
Heavy quark propagation in QCD Vacuum (QCD OPE)
At heavy quark limit, sensitive to vacuum gluon field configuration
J/psi eta_c mass difference
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
At high T, quark and gluon condensates changes
Karsch 03 Diacommo 87, SHL 88,
The Heavy quark potential (Karsch et.al.)
E(T=0)
E(T)
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
At finite T
1. Everything takes place only near T_c1. Everything takes place only near T_c
2. Effects are difficult to observe in Heavy ion collision2. Effects are difficult to observe in Heavy ion collision
On the other hand, Heavy nuclei provides a constant density where, from low energy theorem
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Vacuum Heavy Nuclei
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Hydrogen Atom in external fieldHydrogen Atom in external field
2nd order Stark Effect
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
QCD 2QCD 2ndnd order Stark Effect order Stark Effect (proportional to dipole size)(proportional to dipole size)
( Peskin78; formalism. Luke Manohar 92; J/psi mass shift. SHL: BS amplitude)
Mass shift at nuclear matter
-8 MeV
-50 MeV
-100 MeV
-140 MeV
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
How reliable is the LO QCD result?How reliable is the LO QCD result?(If same formalism is applied to Charmonium absorption by nucleon)
Peskin, Bhanhot (78)Kharzeev, Satz (95)SHL,Y.Oh,S.Kim (01)
consistent with anaylsis of Fermilab p-A data at 10 GeV center of mass energy
by Hufner and Kopeliovich (00)
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Other Approaches for Charmonium mOther Approaches for Charmonium mass shift in nulcear matter:ass shift in nulcear matter:
Quantum numbers
QCD 2nd Stark eff.
Potential model
QCD sum rules
Effects of DD loop
1-- Peskin, Luke, –8 MeV
Brodsky et al. -10 MeV
Klingle, SHL,Weise –7 MeV
SHL, Ko<2 MeV
0,1,2+
+
SHL -40 MeV
SHL -60 MeV
No effect on chi_1
1-- -100 MeV < 30 MeV
1-- -140 MeV < 30 MeV
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Can we observe this?Can we observe this?Anti-Proton NucleusAnti-Proton Nucleus
In coming energy w (for all charmonium )
X (for all vector state) photon invariant mass s
(for all chi states ) or J/psi-photon invariant mass
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
First mehtod have been used at Fermilab First mehtod have been used at Fermilab
E835
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Expected shifts from a nuclear target including FExpected shifts from a nuclear target including Fermi momentum of the nucleons ermi momentum of the nucleons
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Expected shifts in the invariant mass spectrum from a Expected shifts in the invariant mass spectrum from a nuclear target including collision broadeningnuclear target including collision broadening
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
Such experiment can be done at Such experiment can be done at 1. Fermi Lab (E835) ⇒ Changing to a nuclear Target. 2. GSI planned accelerator facility ⇒ anti proton project (1-15 GeV)
SIS100/200
HESR
BNL 2003BNL 2003
Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.Nuclear & Hadron Physics Group at Yonsei Univ.
ConclusionConclusion1. Observing Mass shift of heavy quark system in nuclea1. Observing Mass shift of heavy quark system in nuclea
r matter (QCD 2r matter (QCD 2ndnd order Stark effect) order Stark effect)
⇒ give insight into QCD dynamics and
physical consequences due to change in QCD vacuum.
2. Hints, (Kaczmarek, Engels, Karsch, Laermann 99)