Mind the riskA global ranking of cities under threat from natural disasters
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 1
Preface
Forthefirsttimeinhumanhistorymorepeopleliveincitiesthaninruralareas.TheUnitedNationsexpects6.3billionpeopleor68%oftheworld’spopulationtobelivinginurbanareasby2050,withthehighestincreaseoccurringinhighgrowthmarkets.Manyofthesecitiesarelocatedonthecoastandarethreatenedbyfloods,storms,earthquakesandothernaturalhazards.
Thevibrancyofthesecitiesisakeydriverforeconomicdevelopment.However,thegrowingconcentrationofpeople,assetsandinfrastructurealsomeansthatthelosspotentialinurbanareasishighandrising.Atthesametimethegapbetweeneconomicandinsuredlossesislargebecauseinsurancepenetrationisrelativelylowandcityinfrastructureoftennotinsuredatall.Anotherreasonisthattheriskexposurefacedbytheworld’smetropolitanareasremainsunderexplored,largelyduetothelackofdetailedhazardinformationandpoordataquality.
Thispublicationseekstoaddressthisknowledgedeficitbyprovidingacomprehensiveanalysisofnaturaldisasterriskinlocationsaroundtheworld.BasedonSwissRe’sriskmodellingexpertiseandthelatesthazardinformationfromourCatNet®tool,itfocusesonthemostseverenaturaldisastersconfronting616oftheworld’slargesturbanareasandassessesthepotentialimpacttheyhaveonlocalresidentsandthewidereconomy.
Weknowfrompasteventsthatphysicalpreventionmeasuresalonedonotsufficetobuildaresilientcity,sincedamagefromthemostseverecatastrophescannotbefullyaverted.Animportantpartofresilienceishowwellurbansocietiesareabletocopewiththefinancialconsequencesofadisaster,whichincludesaccesstotherequisitefundingforrelief,recoveryandreconstruction.SwissRecanofferrisktransfersolutionsthathelpbridgethegapbetweeneconomicandinsuredlossesandreducethefinancialburdenonlocalcommunities.
Wehopethefindingsofthisstudywillgivefreshimpetustotheglobaldebateaboutstrengtheningtheresilienceofcitiesandencouragegovernments,citizensandtheinsuranceindustrytotakecollectiveactiontomitigatetherisksfacedbyurbancommunitiesaroundtheworld.
Matthias WeberGroupChiefUnderwritingOfficer
2 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 3
Tableofcontents
Preface 1
Part I – Introduction 5Citiesatrisk:anintroduction 5Riskanalysisof616metropolitanareas 6Ourapproachinfocus:ExamplePearlRiverDelta,China 8
Part II – Global findings 11Peoplepotentiallyaffected–aglobalranking 11Workingdayslost–aglobalranking 14Multipleperils–aglobalranking 18
Part III – Regional findings 21AsiaandOceania 21NorthandCentralAmerica 22Europe 23SouthAmerica 24Africa 25
Conclusion 26Buildingcityresilienceiscritical 26
Appendix 28
4 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
New Orleans under water after severe flooding caused by Hurricane Katrina in August 2005. Total damage amounted to USD 108 billion, the costliest natural disaster in US history.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 5
PartI–Introduction
Citiesatrisk:anintroduction
HurricaneSandyhitNewYorkCityaftermakinglandfallinNewJerseyintheeveninghoursofMonday,29October2012.Sandyshowedushowsusceptiblemodernsocietiesandmetropolitanareasaretotheimpactofnaturalcatastrophes.AcrosstheeasternseaboardoftheUnitedStates,thehurricanekilled72peopleineightStatesandcausedUSD68billionindamage.InNewYorkState,48peoplelosttheirlivesandover300000homesweredestroyed.Besidesthesecasualties,thestorminundateddozensoftunnelsandsubwaystations.Evenresidentsofneighbourhoodsnotdirectlyaffectedwereunabletogettowork.Consequent-ly,shortlyafterthestorm,NewYorkGov-ernorAndrewCuomoconvenedtheNYS2100Commissiontoproviderecommen-dationsforamoreresilientNewYork.
Initswake,Sandyleft8.5millionpeoplewithoutelectricityacrosstheTri-Statearea.1Scoresofresidents,companiesandlocalauthoritieshadtowaitforweekstogettheirpowerback.TheNewYorkStockExchangeclosedtradingfortwofulldays,airlinescancelledmorethan12000flightsandabout70%ofallEastCoastoilrefinerieswereshutdown.Gasstationsacrosstheregionstayedclosedfordays.
Theeventnotonlygeneratedenormousreconstructioncostsforthecity.ItalsohadasignificantimpactontheUSecono-mysincethemetropolitanareaofNewYorkproducesabout8%ofthenation’stotaleconomicoutput.WhileHurricaneSandylaidbarethedisasterriskfacedbyaworldcitylikeNewYork,itisworthnot-ingthatSandywaslittlemorethanan
averagestormwhenmeasuredintermsofwindforce.BearinginmindthatNewYorkisnotamongthecitiesmostexposedtonaturaldisasters,weareremindedofthefactthatthingscouldgetalotworsewhenthenextmajorhurri-canehits.
Citiesaretightlywovenintotheglobalrisklandscapebecausetheyarehighlyinterconnectedandintegratedinaglobal,digitisedeconomy.Perhapsmorethananything,Sandyshowedushowvulnera-bleourcitiesare,andhowfastabreak-downofcriticalinfrastructurecanhappen,particularlyinareaswithahighconcen-trationofpeopleandproperties.Thisiswhytheneedfordisastermanagementisnowheremoreurgentthanintheworld’ssprawlingurbancentres.
Whilenaturalcatastrophescausedaver-ageeconomiclossesofUSD60–100bil-lionannually,asinglelarge-scaledisasterintheheartofabigmetropolitancentrecansurpassthisfiguresignificantly.2Re-centeventsshowedhowrealtheriskisinsomeoftheworld’smostpopulatedregions.WithanestimatedUSD210to300billionintotaleconomiclosses,the2011TohokuearthquakealongthenortheasternseaboardofJapanwasthecostliestcatastropheever.FloodingaroundBangkok,Thailand,inthesameyearbrokeanewrecordforbeingthemostexpensivefreshwaterfloodinhistory,causingUSD47billionineconomiclosses.
Rapidgrowththatoutpacesplanning,flawsinzoninglawsandconstructionfailurescanallexacerbatetheriskofnaturalhaz-ardstourbancommunities.Whenaneventdoesoccurinsuchcircumstances,itdrivesupthecostsfordisasterrecov-eryandincreasestheburdenonpublicbudgets.Allofthiscombinedraisesthepressureoncityauthoritiestoprovideserviceswhichnotonlymakeurbancommunitiesfunctionmoresmoothlybutalsomakethemmoreresilientwhenadisasterstrikes.Understandingtherisksfacedbycitiesisanecessaryfirststeptobetterpreparethemforfuturecatastrophes.
Theimpactofanaturaldisasterinadenselypopulatedareacanbecatastrophic.Thisiswhydisasterplanningisnowheremoreurgentthanintheworld’sbigurbancentres.
1Source:http://news.msn.com/us/new-york-new-jersey-put-dollar71b-price-tag-on-sandy
2sigmaNo2/2013:Naturalcatastrophesandman-madedisastersin2012
6 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Riskanalysisof616metropolitanareas
Theworld’sbigandsprawlingcitiesarecentresofeconomicactivityandgrowth.Butmanyofthemarealsohighlyexposedtonaturalhazards.Asmorepeoplemovetothecitiesandbusinessesinvestintheirlocaleconomy,morelivesandassetsconcentrateindisaster-proneareas.By2050,thenumberofpeopleresidingincitieswillhavereached6.3billion,ac-cordingtotheUnitedNations.Strength-eningtheresilienceofthesecommunitiesisthereforebecomingamatterofurgency.
Toassesstheriskexposurefacedbyurbanpopulationsaroundtheworld,weinvesti-gatedthelosspotentialof616majormetropolitanareasusingSwissRe’spro-prietaryhazarddataonfiveperils:earth-quake,storm,stormsurge,tsunamiandriverflood.Wechosethelargesturbanagglomerationsbasedonthemostrecentpopulationdataandidentifiedcitylimits,includingcityoutskirtsandcommutertowns,usingsatellitedata.These616urbanareasarehometoabout1.7billionpeople,roughly25%oftheworld’stotalpopulation,andcoverUSD34000billionorabout50%oftheglobalGDP.3Ofthesemetropolitanregions334arelocatedinAsia/Oceania,90inEurope,83inNorthAmerica,60inAfricaand49inSouthAmerica.
BasedonhazarddatafromSwissRe’sCatNet®wedevisedariskscenarioperperilforeachmetropolitanarea.Wefocusedonrarecatastrophes:ahurricanewithwindssubstantiallystrongerthanSandyoratsunamisimilartotheonetrig-geredbytheTohokuearthquakeinJapan.Statistically,acitywouldbehitbysuchaneventonceeveryfewhundredyearsorless.Atthislevelofintensity,protectionmeasurestypicallyfailbecausetheforceofthedisasterexceedstheimpactanticipatedbylocalbuildingcodesandprotectionmeasures.
Thehumanandeconomictollofaneventlikethiscanbeenormous.Toshowtheeffectsanaturaldisastercanhaveonametropolitanareaandtheeconomy,weconsideredtwoindicators:thesizeoftheurbanpopulationthatcouldbehitbyoneormorenaturalperils(indexofpeoplepotentiallyaffected)andtheimpactthiscanhaveonthelocalandnationaleconomy(indexofthevalueofworkingdayslost).
Citiesarecentresofeconomicactivityandgrowth.Asmorepeoplemovetothecitiesandbusinessesinvestlocally,morelivesandassetsconcentrateindisaster-proneareas.
3UnitedNationsDepartmentofEconomicandSocialAffairs/PopulationDivision,WorldUrbanizationProspects:The2011Revision
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 7
Forthepopulationindex,wecalculatedtheeffectsoncityresidentsusingdetaileddataonpopulationdistributionandhazardvulnerabilityestimatesforallrelevantperils.Ourdefinitionof“peoplepotentiallyaffected”comprisesfatalities,injuriesandevacuations.Italsoincludespeoplewhosehomesweredamagedandwhowereunabletoaccesstheirwork-place.
Fortheeconomicindex,weassessedthecostsoflargenaturalcatastrophesintermsoflosteconomicproductionorthevalueofworkingdayslost.Thisesti-mateapproximatesthetimeduringwhich
affectedresidentswouldbeunabletogotoworkintheeventofadisasterandthecostsresultingfromlostoutput.4Thedefi-nitiondoesnotincludesecondaryeffects,suchaspoweroutagesorinterruptionoftrafficlines.OurassessmentofthePearlRiverDeltainChinaprovidesapracticalexplanationofhowweusedthismethod-ology(seepages8–9).
Asetofriskparametersguidedouranalysis:thegeographicareaaffectedbyastorm,flood,earthquakeortsunamiandtheintensityusedtoassesstheimpactofeachperil(table1).
Table 1: Assumptions used to calculate exposed metropolitan area by city and peril
ScenarioAssumedaffectedareapercity
Intensityparameterforimpactassessment
Storm(Winterstorm,tropicalcyclone)
Fullarea Peakgustwindspeed
Stormsurge
Reducedarea(lowlyingcoastalareas)
Coastalfloodriskzones,incombinationwithsimplifiedfactorsforbathymetry,coastalmorphology,estuarineconditions,peakgustwindspeedandangleoflandfall
Riverflood Reducedarea Variableintensityperfloodriskzone
Earthquake
Fullarea
Peakgroundaccelerationandpotentialforseismicwaveamplification
Tsunami
Reducedarea(lowlyingcoastalareas)
Coastalfloodriskzones,incombinationwithsimplifiedfactorsforbathymetry,coastalmorphology,estuarineconditionsandregionalseaquakerisk
4WorkingdayslosthererevealafractionoftheGDP/capitawhichisnotbeingproducedintheshorttermduetotheevent.Weaccountfortheeconomicimportanceofthemetropolitanareasandbuildworkingassumptionsbasedonvariouspubliclyavailablesources;countryGDP-dataisbasedonOxfordEconomics.ForareaswithoutinformationonarespectivecityGDP/capita,weusemultipliersonthecountryGDP/capita.ThesemultipliersaretailoredtotheWordBankcountryclassifications.
8 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Ourapproachinfocus:ExamplePearlRiverDelta,China
ThePearlRiverDeltaisadenselypop-ulatedmetropolitanareathatishometomorethan42millioninhabitants.Coveringaterritoryofsome20600squarekilometres,itcomprisestheur-bandistrictsofHongKong,Shenzhen,Dongguan,MacauandGuangzhou.TheregionisoneofChina’smaineco-nomiccentres,withanestimatedGDPofUSD690billion.ItsaverageGDPpercapitaismuchhigherthanthenationalaverage.
Perils affecting Pearl River DeltaThemapsonpage9(fig.1.1to1.4)showthemetropolitanareaofthePearlRiverDelta,localpopulationden-sityandfourperils:typhoon-relatedstormhazard,riverandcoastalfloodzones,andearthquakeintensity.
Population potentially affectedInafirststep,weoverlaidpopulationdatawithourhazardandvulnerabilityinformationpresentedinCatNet®andidentifiedthenumberofpeopleatriskfromeachperil.Weusedtheresulttogloballyrankall616cities.Duetoitshighexposureandthegreatnumberofresidents,thePearlRiverDeltaranksnumberoneamongallmetropolitanareaswhenlookingattheabsolutenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffected
bystorm,stormsurgeandriverflood(seetable2).Theareadoesnotfeatureintheearthquakerankingsbecausetheearthquakeriskisalmostinexistent.DuetoanactivesubductionzonealongthePhilippinestrenchseveralhundredkilometresaway,thereissomeprobabilityofatsunamihittingthearea,butitisrelativelylow.Sincetheareaisverylarge,thepicturechangeswhenlookingatthepercent-ageofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedratherthanabsolutenumbers.
Index of working days lostInasecondstep,wecalculatedthepotentialeconomicvalueofworkingdayslost–orthetotalGDPvalueforalldaysduringwhichacertainper-centageofthepopulationcannotgotowork.Again,wecomparedittotheother615metropolitanareas.Inthisrespect,thePearlRiverareaisrankedhighestforstormsurge,thirdforwindbehindTokyo-YokohamaandOsaka-Kobe,andfifthforriverfloodafterTo-kyo-Yokohama,Nagoya,Osaka-KobeandParis.Thevalueofworkingdayslostcouldreachuptoalowtwo-dig-itbillionUSDfigureforastrongty-phoon–andisthereforeintherangeof1–2percentoftheregion’sannualGDP.Duetoourgeneralapproach,however,wedecidednottoprovidespecificGDPvaluesandinsteaddevelopedarankingofall616cities.
Table 2: Results and global rankings for the Pearl River Delta with a population of approximately 42 million
Perilscenario
Populationpotentiallyaffectedinmn(absolutenumbers)
Rankpopula-tionpotentiallyaffected(absolutenumbers)
Populationpotentiallyaffectedin%ofmetroareapopulation
Rankvalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Storm 17.2 1 41 3Stormsurge 5.3 1 12 1Riverflood 12.0 1 28 5Earthquake – – – –Tsunami – – – –
ThePearlRiverDeltaisadenselypopulatedmetropolitanareacomprisingHongKongandGuangzhou.Situatedinoneoftheworld’smostdisaster-proneregions,floodsandtyphoonsputmorepeopleatriskthaninanyothermetropolitanareaintheworld.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 9
Figure 1.1:Populationdensity,PearlRiverDelta,AsiaSource:EastviewLandScan2011™
Figure 1.3:Riverfloodriskzones,PearlRiverDelta,AsiaSource:SwissReGlobalFloodZones™
All figures based on:©GfkGeoMarketingMapEditionWorld/Imagery:©2013ESRI,i-cubed,GeoEye
Figure 1.2: Tropicalcyclonetracksandcoastalfloodzones,PearlRiverDelta,AsiaSource:Unisys/trackset,SwissRe
Figure 1.4:Earthquakerisk,PearlRiverArea,AsiaSource:GSHAP
Pearl River Delta: population at risk from multiple perils
10 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Roads in the North Bangkok Business District are submerged in floodwaters in November 2011 after heavy rainfall during the annual monsoon season. The Thailand flood of 2011 cost the insurance industry USD 15 billion, the largest insured fresh water flood loss ever.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 11
PartII–Globalfindings
Peoplepotentiallyaffected–aglobalranking
Someoftheworld’sfastest-growingmet-ropolitanareasaresituatedalongChina’scoastlines,suchasthePearlRiverDeltaandShanghai.Besidesbeingexposedtofrequenttropicalcyclonesandstormsurges,manycitiesintheregionarealsolocatedinzonesofhighseismicactivity,includingTokyo,TaipeiandManila.
Whenlookingattheirexposuretonaturaldisasters,mostoftheworld’sriskiestcitiesarethereforesituatedinEastAsia,notablyChina,Taiwan,thePhilippinesandJapan.Buttherearedifferentwaysoflookingatriskexposure.Nodoubt,humanlifecomesfirst.Inthatrespect,Tokyo-Yokohama,thePearlRiverDeltaandOsaka-Kobearetheriskiestmetro-politanareasintheworld(table3).
LikeEastAsia’ssprawlingconurbations,mostothermajorcitiesdevelopedalongtheseaandnaturalwaterwayssuchaslakesandrivers.Soitishardlysurprisingthatfloodriskthreatensmorepeoplethananyothernaturalcatastrophe.Acrossthe616metropolitanareasincludedinthisstudy,riverfloodingposesathreattoover379millionresidents.Thatismorethanthe283millioninhabitantspotentiallyaffectedbyearthquakesandthe157mil-lionpeopleatriskfromstrongwinds.
Incontrast,coastalstormsurgepotentiallyaffectsonlyabout33millionurbandwellers,andtsunamisposearisktojustover12millionpeople.Thisisbecauseonlyabout220million–or13%–ofthemetropolitanareas’residentsactuallyliveincoastalplains.Themapsonthefollow-ingpagesillustratehowdifferentregionsarepotentiallyaffectedbyeachoftheseperils,withdetailedresultslistedintheappendix.
The vast majority of cities are prone to river floodingSituatedonriverfloodplainsoralongriverdeltas,almostalllargemetropolitanareasareindangeroffloodingtosomedegree.IndiaandChina,inparticular,faceasignificantthreatfromriverflooding.With12millionresidentspotentiallyaffected,thePearlRiverDeltaisthemostflood-exposedurbanareaintheworld.Shanghai(11.7million)andKolkata(10.5million)followinsecondandthird
place.WedonotfindasingleEuropeanmetropolitanareaamongthetwentymostpotentiallyaffectedurbanpopula-tions.This,however,changeswhenlookingattheeconomiclosspotentialfromriverfloodinginthenextchapter.
Earthquakes are prevalent in many locationsMostpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyearthquakeslivealongtheso-calledRingofFire,anareaofhighseismicandvol-canicactivityalongthePacificOcean.Besidestheirproximitytothesea,manyofthesesettlementssitinflatbasinsoftencharacterisedbysoftsoilconditions,whichmakeshakingintensitiesevenstronger.Earthquakesintheseareascanalsoresultinsoilliquefaction,aphenom-enonwherebythesaturatedsoilsubstan-tiallylosesitsstrengthandreactslikealiquid.
Withcloseto30millionpeoplepotentiallyaffected,themetropolitanareaofTokyo-YokohamainJapanisbyfarthemostearthquake-exposedcommunityinourrankings.OtherpopulationsthreatenedbyearthquakesareJakarta(17.7million)andManila(16.8million),followedbyLosAngeles(14.7million)andOsaka-Ko-be(14.6million).
ThedangerfacedbycitiesneartheSanAndreasFault,suchasSanFranciscoandLosAngeles,iswidelyknown.ButthetremendouslosspotentialinregionsofCentralAsiaandalongtheNorthernAnatolianfaultintheMiddleEastisoftenoverlookedandnotimmediatelyappar-ent.Forexample,thepopulationsoftheIraniancapitalofTehran(13.6million)orTashkent(2.9million),thecapitalofUzbekistan,arehighlyexposedtoearth-quakeriskandfeatureprominentlyinourearthquakerankings.UnlikecitiesinNewZealand,metropolitanareasinAustraliaarerelativelysafe,asarecitiesintheeasternpartsofSouthAmericaandmostregionsofAfrica.
Table 4: Cumulative number of people potentially affected in all metropolitan areas – by peril
Peril Peoplepotentiallyaffected globally,inmillionRiverflood 379Earthquake 283Windstorm 157Stormsurge 33Tsunami 12
Table 3: Most people potentially affected, aggregated for all five perils (in million)
Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN) 57.1Manila(PHL) 34.6Pearl-RiverDelta(CHN) 34.5Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 32.1Jakarta(IND) 27.7Nagoya(JPN) 22.9Kolkata(IND) 17.9Shanghai(CHN) 16.7LosAngeles(USA) 16.4Tehran(IRN) 15.6
12 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Storms endanger mostly urban areas on the coastThedangerofwindstormsismostacuteinthemetropolitanareasofeasternAsia.Tropicalcyclonesinthispartoftheworld,alsoknownastyphoons,aremostactiveinthebasinoftheWestPacific.Inaddition,morepeopleliveinlargerandmorecondensedmetropolitanareaslocatedalongthecoastthantheydoanywhereelseintheworld.
EightoutofthetenmostheavilyexposedurbancommunitiesarethereforeallinEastAsia,withthePearlRiverDelta(17.2millionpeoplepotentiallyaffected),Tokyo-Yokohama(14.1million)andManila(12.6million)toppingtherankings.TheIndiancitiesofMumbai(4.3million)andChennai(4.0million)areranked8th
and9th.Thehighestnon-Asianmetro-politanareaisLondon(2.2million,winterstorms)ranked18th.Miami(1.4million,tropicalcyclons)isranked23rd.
Incontrasttowinterstorms,tropicalcycloneslosetheirdestructionpotentialrelativelyquicklyoncetheymakelandfall,andtheirgeographicexpanseislimited.InwesternandcentralEurope,metropoli-tanareasarethreatenedbywinterstormswhichmaintaintheirstrengthevenwhentheymovefarinland.However,theirwindspeedsarelowerthanthoseoftropicalcyclones.WhenlookingatwinterstormsinEurope,London(2.2million),Paris(1.1million),theRhine-RuhrareainGer-many(1.0million)andAmsterdam-Rotterdam(0.9million)assumethetopfourspots.
Sincemostmajorcitiesdevelopedalongtheseaorwaterways,floodriskthreatensmorepeoplethananyothernaturalcatastrophe.Acrossthe616citiesassessed,riverfloodingposesathreattoover379millionresidents.Over283millioninhabitantscouldpotentiallybeaffectedbyearthquakes,and157millionpeopleareatriskfromstrongwinds.Inmanycases,urbanpopulationsmustbepreparedtocopewithmorethanonehazard.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 13
CatNet®Mostresultsofthisstudy,includinghazarddataused,areavailableinCatNet®,SwissRe’sonlinenaturalhazardinformationandmappingsystem.Thistoolallowsyoutozoominonindividualregionsandproducetailor-mademapsliketheonesbelow.Userscanimporttheirowncoordi-natesandinformationintothetooltogeneratecustomiseddatasets.
CatNet®isfreeofchargetoSwissReclientsandisavailableonrequesttothirdparties.
Forfurtherinformationortoregister:www.swissre.com/catnet [email protected]
Figure2.1:CatNet®mapshowingthenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyriverfloodsinblueandstormsurgesinlightblue.
Figure2.2:CatNet®mapshowingtheaggregatednumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedandtheshareperperil.ThebubblesareexemplarilydisplayedontopofSIGMAworldinsuranceinformationforthedensityofnon-lifepremiums.
I
MosturbanpopulationspotentiallyaffectedbyearthquakeslivealongtheRingofFire,anareaofhighseis-micactivityinthePacificOcean.WhilethedangerfacedbyAmericanandJapanesecitiesiswellknown,thelosspotentialfromearthquakesinCentralAsiaandtheNorthernAnatolianFaultintheMiddleEastissignificantandoftenoverlooked.
People potentially affected by earthquakes and tsunamis
People at risk per metropolitan area and peril scenario
Earthquakes: 10 million people potentially affected
Tsunamis: 2.5 million people potentially affected
Source: GSHAP, www.swissre.com/catnet
II
Most of the world’s major cities developed along the sea and natural waterways such as lakes and rivers. Many are situated on river flood plains or near river deltas. Almost all large metropolitan areas are therefore exposed to some risk of flooding. The threat from river flooding is particularly high for cities in India and China.
III
IV
People potentially affected by river floods
People at risk per metropolitan area and peril scenario
River floods: 10 million people potentially affected
Source: www.swissre.com/catnet
The danger posed by storms is most acute in eastern Asia. Tropical cyclones in this region, known as typhoons, are most active in the basin of the West Pacific. In Europe, cities are threatened by winter storms. While they have lower wind speeds than tropical cyclones, winter storms can keep their force even when far inland.
V
VI
People potentially affected by storms and storm surges
Source: http://weather.unisys.com/hurricane and data processing by Swiss Re, www.swissre.com/catnet
People at risk per metropolitan area and peril scenario
Storms: 10 million people potentially affected
Storm surges: 2.5 million people potentially affected
14 Swiss Re Mind the risk
Storm surge risk is linked to heavy windsPeople living in coastal areas exposed to heavy winds are also endangered by storm surge. Eastern Asia is most at risk because typhoons, which have the high-est wind speeds, regularly hit the region. Pearl River Delta (some 5.3 million peo-ple), Osaka-Kobe (3.0 million people) and Mumbai (2.6 million people) are ranked highest for storm surge risk, since these metropolitan areas developed on large coastal plains.
The Amsterdam-Rotterdam conurbation in the Netherlands is entirely located within a zone of highest risk and holds a top spot in the storm surge rankings, with 1.8 million people potentially affected. Most sections of these cities are even situated below sea level. However, it is important to point out that these areas are protected extremely well by massive storm surge defences, so the chance of catastrophic damage is substantially lower than in other lesser protected areas. New York City is the most exposed urban area in the United States, with more than 1 million people directly at risk from storm surge. Following Hurricane Sandy, city authorities are taking measures to strengthen local defences.
Tsunami risk dominates in the PacificThe cities most exposed to tsunami risk are in Japan, since they are located along the active faults of the Western Pacific. Tokyo-Yokohama and Nagoya, each with around 2.4 million people who are poten-tially affected, top our tsunami rankings. Osaka-Kobe (1.8 million), Shantou (0.7 million) and Kolkata (0.6 million) complete the list of the five most tsunami-exposed metropolitan areas.
Subduction zones, whereby oceanic plates dive underneath the continental crust, are expected to create much larger tsunamis than so-called strike-slip faults such as the San Andreas Fault. For this reason, the Californian coastline is only classified as a medium risk zone. A tsunami can, however, travel over very large distances and affect coastal areas far away from the triggering seaquake. Metropolitan areas within the medium and low risk zones can therefore also experience devastating tsunamis.
Working days lost – a global ranking
Natural catastrophes do not only affect people. They can also significantly disrupt the economy of an affected metropolitan area and, in some cases, the economy of an entire country. We estimated the eco-nomic effects of earthquakes, storms and floods using average assumptions of working days lost for each hazard and developed an index for cross-city com-parisons.5
We can look at the results from a global and a local perspective. In our global rankings, standardised absolute values of working days lost apply. By this measure, the metropolitan areas of high-income countries top the list. This is because ab-solute losses are generally higher in plac-es like Tokyo-Yokohama or Los Angeles than in Jakarta or Istanbul, even though similar numbers of people are potentially affected by a natural disaster.
However, when we take a local view and put the productivity losses of a city in relation to the GDP of an entire country, the picture changes. In this case, a small-er country with only one or a handful of urban centres can end up in the first ranks because these cities play an essential role to their home country’s national econo-my. Examples include the Latin American capitals of San Jose, Costa Rica and Lima, Peru. These local rankings give an indi-cation of how a disaster can impact the resilience of a whole nation.
Natural catastrophes not only endanger human lives, but they can also significantly disrupt the local economy of a city and, in some cases, the economy of an entire country.
5 In our rankings, an index value of “1” denotes the city with the highest potential impact from one particular peril. To index the impact of all five perils combined (earthquake, wind speed, river flood, storm surge and tsunami), the individual peril indices are added up.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 15
How to read the chartsEachchartshowstheeconomicimpactranking(workingdayslost)foreachcityfrombothaglobalandanationalperspective,alongwiththesizeoftheurbanpopulationpotentiallyaffectedbyoneormoreperils.Thesketchbelowillustratesthefourvaluespre-sentedineachchart(figure3):
1)Thesizeofeachbubblerepresentsthenumberofinhabitantslivinginagivenmetropolitanarea.
2)Thecolouredwedgeinthepiechartistheshareofinhabitantspotential-lyaffectedbyagivenperil.
3)Thex-axismarksthevalueofworkingdayslostpercityusingalogarithmicscale(globalindex).
4)They-axismarksthevalueofwork-ingdayslostpercityinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy
usingalogarithmicscale(globalindex,relativetothenationaleconomyofhomecountry).
Asthefourquadrantsillustrate,wecandrawdifferentconclusionsfromthepositionofeachcityonthechart.Sincewecannotfitall616citiesinonechartwehavelimitedthechoicetothetoptenranksusingalogarithmicscale.Theycombinethetop10ranksfortheanalyses‘peoplepotentiallyaffected,’‘globalindexofworkingdayslost’,‘globalindexofworkingdayslostrelativetothenationaleconomy’.
Forillustrativepurposes,figure4showsthedistributionofcitiesonalinearscaleforearthquakerisk.Ithighlightsthewidedivergencesinnumericalvaluesbetweencities,suchasthegapbetweenthefirstandsecondranks.
Manila (PHL)
San Francisco (USA)
Taipei (TWN)
San Jose (CRI)
Lima (PER)
Los Angeles (USA)Nagoya (JPN) Osaka-Kobe (JPN)
Tokyo-Yokohama (JPN)
1.0
0.5
00.5 1.00
Value of working days lost, global view
Valu
e of
wor
king
day
s lo
st, n
atio
nal v
iew
Severe impact per country, low global ranking
Severe impact per country, top global ranking
Limited impact per country, top global ranking
Limited impact per country, low global ranking
Value of working days lost, global view
Valu
e of
wor
king
day
s lo
st, n
atio
nal v
iew
KeyUnaffected population
Share of population potentially affected by peril
Figure 4: Illustrativechartusingalinearscaleforearthquakeriskinsteadofalogarithmicscale(seefigure7forcomparison).Thisshowstheactualdistributionofcitiesandtheunequalgapsinriskexposurebetweenthem.
Figure 3: Visualisationofglobalrankings.Citiesintheupperright-handcornerofeachchartfacethehighestpotentialimpactinabsolutetermsandinrelationtotheircountry’snationaleconomy.
16 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
EarthquakesAmajorearthquakecanaffectalmostallresidentsofacity.Givencountries’differentlevelsofeconomicdevelopment,theabsoluteimpactonproductioncanbemagnitudeshigherindevelopedcoun-triesthaninemergingmarkets.TheTokyo-Yokohamaregionhas37millioninhabitants,ofwhich80%or29millioncouldbepotentiallyaffectedbyaverylargeearthquake.Ofall616metropolitanareasstudied,ithasthehighestvalueofworkingdayslostandsocarriesanindexvalueof1onthex-axis(figure5).
Japan,however,hasseveralotherurbancentreswhichsustainthecountry’seconomy.Bycontrast,anearthquakeofasimilarmagnitudewouldhaveamuchmoresevereimpactonthenationalecon-omyofacountrylikeCostaRica.Some2.2millioninhabitantsliveinthecapitalofSanJose,whichmakesupahighpro-portionofthecountry’stotalpopulation.Almostallofthemareexposedtosignifi-cantearthquakerisk.SanJoseistheeco-nomichubofCostaRica.ThepotentialcostsofanearthquakemakesSanJosethecitywiththehighestpotentialfalloutforacountry’snationaleconomy,indi-catedbyanindexvalueof1onthey-axis.
Wecandrawsomeinterestingconclusionsfromthis.Smallerurbanareasaremorebroadlyaffectedthanlargerareas(egLimarankshigherthanJakarta).Butahighnumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffecteddoesnotautomaticallymeanahighglobalrankwhenmeasuredintermsofproductionlost(egJakartais25timeslessaffectedthanLosAngeles).LessobviousperhapsisthatalthoughLosAngelesandSanFranciscoarewidelyconsideredathighriskofearthquakes,theyarefromanationalperspectivelowerrankedthancitieslikeManilaorLima.Finally,thedif-ferenceinproductionlossescanbehuge.Forexample,thenationalimpactofanearthquakeinYerevan(Armenia)andTo-kyo-Yokohamaissimilar,buttheabsoluteimpactinTokyoismorethan300timeshigher.
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
Jakarta (IDN)33.1 mn
Santiago (CHL)6.2 mn
Taichung (TWN)5.8 mn
Tehran (IRN)15.1 mn
Shizuoka (JPN)1.6 mn
Almaty (KAZ)1.7 mn
Manila (PHL)21.0 mn
San Jose (CRI)2.2 mn
Bishkek (KGZ)1 mn
Osaka-Kobe (JPN)18.6 mn
Los Angeles (USA)15.4 mn
San Francisco (USA)5.0 mn
Taipei (TWN)8.1 mn
Santo Domingo (DOM)3.3 mn
Istanbul (TUR)11.5 mn
Nagoya (JPN)11.6 mn
Tokyo-Yokohama (JPN)37.1 mn
Lima (PER)8.9 mn
Yerevan (ARM)1.4mn
Figure 5: Metropolitan areas at risk from earthquakes
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 17
River floodsThefloodrankingsofmetropolitanareasinfigure6showasomewhatdifferentpicturecomparedtoearthquakes.Metro-politancentreswithmorethan50%ofthepopulationpotentiallyaffectedareex-ceptionsandaremainlylocatedineast-ernChina.Yet,anumberofcitiesappearintherankingswhicharenotknowntobeparticularlyexposedtoflooding,suchasMexicoCity,Baghdad,ParisorDoha.
TheanalysisshowsthatBangkokishighlyexposedtoriverfloodingwithpotentiallymassiveimpactstothenationaleconomy.Thiswastragicallyconfirmedbythe2011ChaoPhrayaRiverflood,thelargestin-suredfreshwaterfloodeventeverrecord-ed.Thetotallossamountedtoaround10%ofnationalGDP,whichhighlightsthecriticalimportanceoffloodprotectionmeasuresfortheThaigovernment.
Storms Fewermetropolitanareasareexposedtoheavydamagefromstormsthanbyearthquakesorfloods.Thecitiespoten-tiallymostaffectedbyhighwindspeedsarelocatedalongthecoastlinesofAsia,suchasTokyo-Yokohama,Manila,TaipeiandthePearlRiverDelta.
AsFigure7shows,onlythreeofthemostexposedmetropolitanareasareoutsideAsia:Havana(Cuba),Port-au-Prince(Haiti)andSantoDomingo(DominicanRepublic).AllthreeCaribbeancitiesplayanessen-tialroleinthefunctioningoftheirsmallislandeconomies.Perhapssurprisingly,bigUScitiesknowntobeexposedtostormandhurricanerisk–suchasMiamiorNewYork–donotfeatureintheworldtop10forthisperil,ranking23rdand45threspectively.
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
Cairo (EGY)17.7 mn
Jakarta (IDN)33.1 mn
Pearl River Delta (CHN)42.4 mn
Osaka-Kobe (JPN)18.6 mn
Nagoya (JPN)11.6 mn
Doha (Qat)1.4 mn
Dehli (IND)21.9 mn
Khartoum (SDN)5.6 mn
Bagdad (IRQ)8.0 mn
Kolkata (IND)19.1 mn
Ndjamena (TCL)1.2 mn
Phnom Peng (KHM)1.6 mn
Ulaanbaatar (MNG)0.9 mn
Paris (FRA)11.2 mn
Amsterdam-Rotterdam (NLD)5.4 mn
Mexico City (MEX)19.6 mn
Milan (ITA)7.3 mn
Bangkok (THA)9.5 mn
Yerevan (ARM)1.4 mn
Shanghai (CHN)17.6 mn
Tianjin (CHN)5.8 mn
Tokyo-Yokohama (JPN)37.1 mn
Manila (PHL)20.9 mn
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
Pearl River Delta (CHN)42.4 mn
Busan (KOR)5.0 mn
Shantou (CHN)10.0 mn
Fukuoka (JPN)3.9 mnChennai (IND)
8.5 mn
Port-au-Prince (HTI)2.0 mn
Santo Domingo (DOM)3.3 mn
Tainan-Kaohsiung (TWN)5.1 mn Taipei (TWN)
8.1 mn
Mumbai (IND)20.6 mn
Taichung (TWN)5.8 mn
Nagoya (JPN)11.6 mn
Tokyo-Yokohama (JPN)37.1 mn
Osaka-Kobe (JPN)18.6 mn
Manila (PHL)20.9 mn
Figure 6: Metropolitan areas at risk from river flooding
Figure 7: Metropolitan areas at risk from storms
18 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Multipleperils–aglobalranking
Manyoftheworld’smetropolitanareasarethreatenedbymorethanjustonenat-uralperil,andsomeevenfacetheriskofbeinghitbyseveralperilsatonce.The2011Tohokuearthquake,forexample,triggeredamassivetsunamiwavewhichledtoextensivefloodingacrossthenorth-easternseaboardofJapan.FloodingwasalsobroughtonbyHurricaneSandyin2012andsubmergedvastpartsofNewYorkCitywhilewinddamagewasminorinthiscase.
Naturalperilshavedifferentphysicalcharacteristicsandprobabilities.Forex-ample,thechanceofamajorearthquakeandatyphoonhappeningatthesametimeisextremelylow.Nevertheless,tocreateagloballyconsistentriskindexitmakessensetolookattheaggregatedriskthatalltheperilsposetoanurbancommunity.Todoso,weaddeduptheresultsforallfiveperilsforeachcity.Accordingly,theindexvalueofworkingdayslostcanadduptoamaximumof5.
Urbanresidentswhoarethreatenedbymultipleperilsaremorelikelytobehitbyanaturalcatastropheintheirlifetimethanthoseconfrontedwithonlyoneperil.Inourstatistics,theseresidentsarecountedmorethanonce.Theaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbymultipleperilscanthereforeexceedtheactualsizeofacity’spopulation.Themoreitdoes,themoreprobableitisthatlocalresidentswillatsomepointhavetocopewithanaturaldisaster.
Table5showsaggregatedrankingsforallfiveperils.Theylisttheabsolutenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffected;thevalueofworkingdayslostinrelationtothelocalandnationaleconomy.Insmaller,denselypopulatedmetropolitanareas,earth-quakesandstormscouldaffectvirtuallytheentirepopulation.Althoughmorecommonthananyothernaturaldisaster,riverfloodstypicallyonlyaffectalimitedpartofametropolitanarea.Stormsurgesandtsunamisonlyaffectpeoplelivingnearthecoast.
Table 5: Top ten city rankings by analysis for all aggregated perils
Metroarea
Ranking:peoplepotentiallyaffected(aggregateforall5perils)
Metroarea
Ranking:valueofworkingdayslost(globalindex,aggregatedforall5perils)
Metroarea
Ranking:valueofworkingdayslostrelativetonationaleconomy(globalindex,aggregatedforall5perils)
Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN) 57.1mn Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN) 4.50 Manila(PHL) 1.95Manila(PHL) 34.6mn Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 2.71 Amsterdam-Rotterdam
(NLD)1.31
PearlRiverDelta(CHN) 34.5mn Nagoya(JPN) 2.69 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN) 1.29Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 32.1mn PearlRiverDelta(CHN) 1.78 SanJose(CRI) 1.26Jakarta(IND) 27.7mn Amsterdam-Rotterdam
(NLD)0.96 Guayaquil(ECU) 1.20
Nagoya(JPN) 22.9mn LosAngeles(USA) 0.93 Taipei(TWN) 1.02Kolkata(IND) 17.9mn NewYork-Newark
(USA)0.62 Ndjamena(TCL) 1.00
Shanghai(CHN) 16.7mn SanFrancisco(USA) 0.47 Nagoya(JPN) 0.97
LosAngeles(USA) 16.4mn Paris(FRA) 0.46Tainan-Kaohsiung(TWN)
0.90
Tehran(IRN) 15.6mn Taipei(TWN) 0.39 Lima(PER) 0.90
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 19
Withsomeexceptions,theworld’sriski-estmetropolitanareasarelocatedinAsia,especiallyinChina,Taiwan,thePhilip-pinesandJapan.Hostingseveralmillionpeopleindenselypopulatedconurbations,Asia’scitiesarelikelytobethehardesthitbynaturalcatastrophes,bothintermsofabsolutenumbersofpotentiallyaffectedpeopleandeconomicimpact.
Figure8showsanoverviewofthemostexposedcitiesworldwide.Becauseearth-quakescanaffectthemajorityofthepopulation,theirsharedominatesthepiechartinseismicallyactiveorexposedregions.Inlocationswithamulti-hazardrisk,theprobabilityofaneventincreasessubstantially.Tokyo-Yokohama,Osaka-KobeandNagoyainJapanaswellasthePearlRiverDeltainChina,Taichung,TaipeiandTainan-KaohsiunginTaiwanandManilainthePhilippinesfaceahighlikelihoodofbeingimpactedbydifferentperils.Thisamplifiesthethreattotheirin-habitantsandeconomies.
Figure 8: Impact of all perils by metropolitan area – Top 10Thechartincludestheaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyallrelevantperils(bubblesize)andglobalrankingsbythevalueofworkingdayslost,inabsoluteterms(x-axis)andinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy(y-axis).Residentsarecountedmultipletimeswhenaffectedbymorethanoneperilbecauseeachperilisaccountedforindividually.
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.010 0.100 1.000 5.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
5.000
Shanghai (CHN)
Tehran (IRN)Taipei (TWN)
Los Angeles (USA)
Lima (PER)
Manila (PHL)
San Jose (CRI)
Guayaquil (ECU)
Osaka-Kobe (JPN)
Nagoya (JPN)
Jakarta (IDN)
San Francisco (USA)
Pearl River Delta (CHN)
Paris (FRA)
Tokyo-Yokohama (JPN)
Amsterdam-Rotterdam (NLD)
Tainan-Kachsiung (TWN)
Kolkata (IND)
New York-Newark (USA)
Whenconsideringtherelativeimportanceofametropolitanareatothenationaleconomyofacountry,othercitiesmoveuptherankings:Amsterdam-Rotterdam(Netherlands),SanJose(CostaRica),Lima(Peru)andGuayaquil(Ecuador).
Thefollowingchapterpresentstheglobalresultsbycontinent.Wechosetoonlydisplaythetoptenpercontinent.Locationsshowninthischapterreappearalongwithcitiesnotrepresentedintheglobalrankings.
EarthquakeWindspeedRiverfloodStormsurgeTsunami
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(cumulativenumberinmn)
15
20 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Two men stand among the debris from the March 2011 earthquake and tsunami in the Japanese city of Kesennuma. The magnitude 9.0 quake off the coast of Japan is considered the costliest natural disaster in history, causing an estimated USD 235 billion in total losses.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 21
PartIII–Regionalfindings
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000 5.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
5.000 Manila (PHL) Tokyo-Yokohama (JPN)
Osaka-Kobe (JPN)Jakarta (IDN)
Kolkata (IND)
Yerevan (ARM)
Phnom Penh (KHM)
Fukuoka (JPN)
Shizuoka (JPN)
Shanghai (CHN)
Tainan-Kaohsiung (TWN)
Bangkok (THA)
Taichung (TWN) Taipei (TWN)
Pearl River Delta (CHN)
Nagoya (JPN)
Teheran (IRN)
Figure 9: Impact of all perils by metropolitan area – Top 10Thechartincludestheaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyallrelevantperils(bubblesize)andglobalrankingsbythevalueofworkingdayslost,inabsoluteterms(x-axis)andinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy(y-axis).
AsiaandOceaniahostmanylarge,eco-nomicallyvibrantmetropolitanareas.Comparedtoallothercontinents,citiesinAsiaandOceaniastandoutasbeingmostexposedtonaturaldisasters.Manyofthemalsoappearinthetop10globalrankings.Ingeneral,Asia’smetropolitanareasarethreatenedbythewidestmixofallperilswithmanyofthemendangered
Table 6: Asia and Oceania at a glanceMetropolitanareasanalysed 334–totalpopulation 989.0mn–totalcombinedGDP USD12.6trnMostpeopleendangeredbysinglescenario
29.4mnearthquakeTokyo-Yokohama,17.7mnearthquakeJakarta,17.2mnwindPearlRiverDelta
Top3allperils:peoplepotentiallyaffected Tokyo-Yokohama,Manila,PearlRiverDeltaTop3allperils:absolutevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Tokyo-Yokohama(4.50),Osaka-Kobe(2.71),Nagoya(2.69)
Top3allperils:relativevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindexrelativetonationaleconomy)
Manila(1.95),Tokyo-Yokohama(1.29),Taipei(1.02)
AsiaandOceania
byallfiveperilsincludedinthisstudy.Therisksofearthquakes,typhoonsandriverfloodingdominateinthenorthernhemisphere.Thisisillustratedinthechartsbythelargebubblesizesandtheclustersintheupperright-handcorneraswellasthecolourscheme.
AustraliaandNewZealandarealsoexposedtonaturalcatastrophes,buttheyhavesmallercitiesandthereforedonotfeatureinthetoptenriskiestcities.
Othercountriesmayplayalesserroleintheworldeconomy,buttheireconomiesdependheavilyonahandfulofcitiesthatfunctionascentresofeconomicpro-duction.HerewefindmetropolitanareassuchasBishkek(Kyrgyzstan),Almaty(Kazakhstan)orYerevan(Armenia),wherealargerearthquakeorriverfloodcouldbedisastrousfortheentirecountry’seco-nomicproduction.
EarthquakeWindspeedRiverfloodStormsurgeTsunami
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(cumulativeinmn)
15
22 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000 5.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
5.000
San Salvador (SLV)
Tegucigalpa (HDN)
Guadalajara (MEX)
Port-au-Prince (HTI)
Havana (CUB)
Managua (NIC)
Panama City (PAN)
Boston (USA)
Washington-Baltimore (USA)
San Francisco (USA)
Miami (USA)
New Orleans (USA)
Houston (USA)
Tampa (USA)
Guatemala (GTM)
Mexico City (MEX)
New York-Newark (USA)
Los Angeles (USA)
San Jose (CRI)
Santo Domingo (DOM)
Table 7: North and Central America at a glanceMetropolitanareasanalysed 83–totalpopulation 222.7mn–totalcombinedGDP USD10.5trnMostpeopleendangeredbysinglescenario
14.7mnearthquakeLosAngeles,6.1mnriverfloodMexicoCity,5.0mnearthquakeSanFranciso
Top3allperils:peoplepotentiallyaffected LosAngeles,MexicoCity,SanFrancisoTop3allperils:absolutevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
LosAngeles(0.93),NewYork-Newark(0.62),SanFrancisco(0.47)
Top3allperils:relativevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
SanJose(1.26),SantoDomingo(0.69),Port-au-Prince(0.49)
NorthandCentralAmericacomprisearegionthreatenedbyearthquakesalongthePacificcoastaswellasbyhurricanesandstormsurgesfromtheAtlantic.Riverfloodingcanhappenpracticallyany-where.AkeydifferencebetweenNorthandCentralAmerica,however,isintheirdistributionofeconomicproductionsites.
WhiletheeconomiesofthesmallercountriesofCentralAmericaarehighlydependentonjustafewmetropolitanareas,theUS,CanadaandMexicohave
moreurbancentres.ThedifferenceineconomicgeographyisreflectedonthechartbythefactthatNorthAmerica’scitiesarelocatedinthelowerright-handcornerwhileCentralAmericancitiesarefoundintheupperleft-handcorner.
Fromtheperspectiveofthenationaleconomy,theCentralAmericancapitalsofSanJose(CostaRica)andSantoDomingo(DominicanRepublic)rankhighest.Aca-tastropheineitherofthesetwolocationswouldheavilyaffecttheentirecountry.ThedeadlyearthquakethatravagedHaitiinJanuary2010isrememberedasoneoftheworstdisasterstohittheimpoverishedislandnation.ButitisworthnotingthatSantoDomingohasanevenhigherearth-quakeriskthanPort-au-Prince(Haiti).
IncontrasttoCentralAmerica,metropol-itanareasoftheUnitedStatesarenu-merousandhighlydeveloped.Theyarerankedhigherintermsoftheabsolutevalueofworkingdayslostwhencomparedtoallothercitiesintheworld.
Figure 10: Impact from all perils per metropolitan area – Top 10Thechartincludestheaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyallrelevantperils(bubblesize)andglobalrankingsbythevalueofworkingdayslost,inabsoluteterms(x-axis)andinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy(y-axis).
NorthandCentralAmerica
EarthquakeWindspeedRiverfloodStormsurgeTsunami
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(cumulativeinmn)
15
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 23
ThevulnerabilityofEurope’scitiestonatu-raldisastersvariesfromregiontoregion.CountriesineasternandsouthernEuropefacerisksfromearthquakes.Windbe-comesmoreimportantasanaturalperilwhenmovingtowardscentralEurope,whilethehazardfromriverfloodingispre-sentalmosteverywhere.Metropolitanare-asofcentralEuropearenotwidelyspreadonthechart.However,althoughmanyeasternEuropeanmetropolitanareasstillhaveaGDPpercapitabelowtheEurope-anaverage,theycanbeevenmoreimpor-tantfortheircountry’snationaleconomy.
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000 5.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
5.000
Liverpool (GBR)
Budapest (HUN)
Zagreb (HRV)
Lille (FRA)
Hamburg (DEU)
Rhine-Ruhr (DEU)
Milan (ITA)
Berlin (DEU)
Frankfurt (DEU)
Sofia (BGR)
Istanbul (TUR)
Brussels-Antwerp (BEL)
Zurich (CHE)
Athens (GRC)
Dublin (IRL)
Amsterdam-Rotterdam (NLD)
Paris (FRA)
London (GBR)
Onelikelyscenariocouldbeastrongwin-terstormintheNorthSeathatpushesastormsurgetowardsAmsterdam-Rotter-damandcauseswindstormdamageatthesametime.WhilefloodprotectionmeasuresaregenerallywelldevelopedinEurope,mostdefencesaredesignedtoprotectagainstlocalriverfloodsexpectedonceevery50to100years.Asaresult,onlylargefloodeventsshouldtriggerma-jordamage,atleastifthedamsdonotfailatlowerwaterlevels.
Amajorwinterstorm,whichhasthelarg-estexpanseofallperilscoveredinthisstudy,orafloodcanaffectseveralcitiesheavily.ThisisparticularlytrueinEuropewherecitiesarelocatedclosertogetherthanelsewhere.ThishastobetakenintoaccountwhenEuropeiscomparedtootherregions.Istanbul,ahugeurbansprawlhighlyendangeredbyearthquakes,isalsocoveredintheregionaloverviewofAsia,butdoesnotfeatureinthetop10.
Table 8: Europe at a glanceMetropolitanareas 91(incl.Istanbul)–totalpopulation 206.4mn–totalcombinedGDP USD8.2trnMostpeopleendangeredbysinglescenario 6.4mnearthquakeIstanbul,2.7mnriverflood
Paris,2.2mnwinterstormLondonTop3allperils:peoplepotentiallyaffected Istanbul,Amsterdam-Rotterdam,LondonTop3allperils:absolutevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Amsterdam-Rotterdam(0.96),Paris(0.46),London(0.32)
Top3allperils:relativevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Amsterdam-Rotterdam(1.31),Istanbul(0.27),Zagreb(0.26)
Figure 11: Impact from all perils per metropolitan area – Top 10Thechartincludestheaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyallrelevantperils(bubblesize)andglobalrankingsbythevalueofworkingdayslost,inabsoluteterms(x-axis)andinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy(y-axis).
Europe
EarthquakeWindspeedRiverfloodStormsurgeTsunami
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(cumulativeinmn)
15
24 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000 5.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
5.000
5
Valencia (VEN)
Valparaiso (CHL)
Quito (ECU)
Rio de Janeiro (BRA)Maracay (VEN)
Caracas (VEN)
Sao Paulo (BRA)
Buenos Aires (ARG)
Santiago (CHL)Bogota (COL)
Guayaquil (ECU)
Cali (COL)
Lima (PER)
SouthAmericafaceslittleriskofextendedandhighwindspeeds,apartfromafewexceptionsclosetotheCaribbeanandEastBraziliancoastline.Butotherhazardsareclearlypresent.Wecanseeearth-quakesincombinationwithsomeriverfloodinginthewest,whereaseasternmetropolitanareasofBrazilandArgentinafaceriverfloodasthedominantperil.Tsunamihazardsaccompanyseismicallyendangeredmetropolitanareasalongthewesterncoastlineattimes.
Table 9: South America at a glanceMetropolitanareas 49–totalpopulation 148.5mn–totalcombinedGDP USD2.1trnMostpeopleendangeredbysinglescenario 8.9mnearthquakeLima,5.3mnearthquake
Santiago,3.9mnearthquakeBogotaTop3allperils:peoplepotentiallyaffected Lima,Santiago,BogotaTop3allperils:absolutevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
SaoPaulo(0.12),Lima(0.12),SantiagodeChile(0.07)
Top3allperils:relativevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Guayaquil(1.20),Lima(0.90),SantiagodeChile(0.47)
Onaglobalscale,theeconomicproduc-tioninSouthAmericaisrelativelyevenlydistributedamongthecountriesranginginthemid-scale.Thisresultsinaverydenseclusterforthetop10ranks.
Adequatebuildingstandardstoimproveearthquakedamageresistanceaswellasfloodriskmapswithconsecutiveplanningmeasureswouldimprovetheresilienceofmanymetropolitanareasintheregion.
SouthAmerica
Figure 12: Impact from all perils per metropolitan area – Top 10Thechartincludestheaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyallrelevantperils(bubblesize)andglobalrankingsbythevalueofworkingdayslost,inabsoluteterms(x-axis)andinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy(y-axis).
EarthquakeWindspeedRiverfloodStormsurgeTsunami
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(cumulativeinmn)
15
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 25
Africa’scitiesarealmostexclusivelythreatenedbyriverfloodingalone.Africaisrelativelysafewhenitcomestonaturalhazardsanalysedhere.TheonlyareasthreatenedbyearthquakesaresituatedalongtheMediterraneanSeaandalongtheAfricanriftsystem,fromCairodowntoTanzania.Tropicalcyclonesonlyposearisktocommunitiesalongthesoutheasterncoastline.
0.001
0.010
0.100
1.000
0.001 0.010 0.100 1.000 5.000
Value of working days lost (global index, relative to national economy of home country)
Value of working days lost (global index)
5.000
Durban (ZAF)
Kinshasa (COD)Algiers (DZA)
Antananarivo (MDG)Tripoli (LBY)
Nairobi (KEN)
Tunis (TUN)
Lusaka (ZMB)
Casablanca (MAR)
Lagos (NGA)
Cairo (EGY)
Ndjamena (TCL)
Khartoum (SDN)
Cape Town (ZAF)
Table 10: Africa at a glanceMetropolitanareas 60–totalpopulation 155.7mn–totalcombinedGDP USD0.7trnMostpeopleendangeredbysinglescenario 5.5mnriverfloodCairo,2.5mnriverflood
Khartoum,1.8mnriverfloodKinshasaTop3allperils:peoplepotentiallyaffected Cairo,Khartoum,KinshasaTop3allperils:absolutevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Cairo(0.05),Khartoum(0.02),Kinshasa(0.01)
Top3allperils:relativevalueofworkingdayslost(globalindex)
Ndjamena(1.00),Khartoum(0.45),Cairo(0.30)
Onaglobalscale,theeconomicoutputofAfrica’scitiesiscomparativelylow.Thisisillustratedbythepositionsofthemetropolitanareasontheleft-handsideoffigure13.Ontheotherhand,theindividualimpactonacountrycanbeenormousinAfrica.
Forexample,amajorriverfloodinNdja-mena(Chad)orKhartoum(Sudan)wouldaffectvirtuallytheentirepopulationandsignificantlydisrupttheircountries’nationaleconomies.Inabsoluteterms,Cairo–whichfacesrisksfromearthquakesandriverfloods–rankshighestamongAfrica’scities,bothbyworkingdayslostandpeoplepotentiallyaffected.
Africa
Figure 13: Impact from all perils per metropolitan area – Top 10Thechartincludestheaggregatenumberofpeoplepotentiallyaffectedbyallrelevantperils(bubblesize)andglobalrankingsbythevalueofworkingdayslost,inabsoluteterms(x-axis)andinrelationtothecountry’snationaleconomy(y-axis).
EarthquakeWindspeedRiverfloodStormsurgeTsunami
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(cumulativeinmn)
15
26 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Conclusion
Buildingcityresilienceiscritical
Millionsofpeopleliveintheworld’sbigmetropolitancentres,andtheyarebeingjoinedbymanymorepeoplewhoflocktothecitiesforeconomicpursuits.Amajornaturalcatastrophecancausetremen-doussufferinganddisruption.Thethreattocityresidentsandlocaleconomiesisreal,anditismountingrelentlesslyasmegacitiescontinuetoexpandandriskmanagementpracticesfailtokeepupwiththepaceofchange.
Asthefindingsofthisstudyshow,therearesubstantialdifferencesinriskexposureacrossregions.Asia’scitiesaremostatriskfromnaturalhazards,followedbycitiesinNorthAmerica.Theyalsoshow
Making cities more resilient
Risk transfer solutions – the example of Mexico’s MultiCatMexico’sMultiCatcatastrophebondprogramme,whichwasdesignedbytheWorldBankandtheMexicangovernmentwithsupportfromSwissRe,formsakeypartofMexico’ssovereigndisasterrisktransferstrategy.Theprogrammecombinesriskmitiga-tion,riskmodeling,andtraditionalandparametricinsurancetoallowthegovernmenttofinanciallypreparefordisasters.Itcoversearthquakeandhurricanerisk.
ThetransactionhighlightsSwissRe’slong-standingcommitmenttohelpingcountriesandlocalcommunitiesbuildresiliencethroughinnovativeinsur-ancesolutionsandthepublic-privatepartnershipmodel.SwissRewasthefirstglobalreinsurancecompanytodedicateateamofexpertstoworkwithnationalandmunicipalgovern-mentsontheirriskmanagement
needs.ThesuccessofMultiCathigh-lightsthegrowingdemandwithinthepublicsectorforthesesolutions.
Economics of Climate Adaptation – tackling climate risk locallyClimateadaptationisanurgentpriorityfornationalandcityauthorities.Whilemanyadaptationmeasuresareavailabletomakecitiesmoreresilienttotheimpactofclimatechange,decision-makersneedtoidentifythemostcost-effectiveinvestments.TheEconomicsofClimateAdaptation(ECA)method-ologygivesthemthefactstodosoinasystematicway.Ithelpsthemassessthelocalimpactofclimatechangeandtakeactionstominimisethatimpactatthelowestcosttosociety.Withitspartners,SwissRehascarriedoutECAstudiesinover20locations,includingseveralcities.Theyallpresentastrongcaseforimmediateaction:itischeapertostartadaptingnowthantobearthecostsoffuturedisasterstomorrow.Source:http://www.swissre.com/rethinking
thatmanyofthesmallerandoftenlesserknownmetropolitanareasdeservemoreofourattention.Notonlyarethesecen-tresdevelopingrapidly,butinourrankingstheyalreadyappearalongsidecitiestypicallymentionedasnaturalcatastrophehotspots,suchasTokyo,SanFrancisco,Miamior,morerecently,NewYork.
Savinglivesisandshouldbethehighestpriorityinriskmitigationefforts.However,higherlivingstandardsinmanycitiesmeanthatdemandforbetterprotectionmeas-uresisalsosettoincrease,especiallyintheworld’shighgrowthmarkets.Com-biningsuchmeasureswithinsurancecoversforresidualriskisthemostcost-effectiveandrecommendedapproach.
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 27
6SeeSwissRePrivateEquityPartners(2010):Anintroductiontoinfrastructureinvesting,SwissReCentreforGlobalDialogue(2012):IntegrativeRiskManagement:FosteringInfrastructureResilience.
7UNISDR(2013):MakingCitiesResilient:SummaryforPolicymakersAglobalsnapshotofhowlocalgovernmentsreducedisasterrisk.8OECD(2012):DisasterRiskAssessmentandRiskFinancing–AG20/OECDMethodologicalFramework.
Yetthemajorityofurbanassetsinhighgrowthmarketsiscurrentlynotinsured.Asaconsequence,insureddisasterloss-esintheUnitedStates,CanadaandEu-ropearestillsignificantlybigger.AsChinaandothereconomiescatchup,Asiaissettoemergeastheregionwiththehighesteconomiclosspotentialandthebiggestgapbetweeneconomicandinsuredloss-eswithinthenextdecades.
Investmentsininfrastructurearevitaltostrengthentheresilienceofmetropolitanareas.Thepotentialdamagethatalargenaturaldisastercancausetoroads,bridg-es,telecommunicationsandotheressen-tialinfrastructureisperhapsnowheremoreapparentthanintheworld’sbigcities.Thisiswhystrengtheningurbanresilienceisalsoaprimeconcernfortheinsuranceindustry.Asanultimaterisktaker,theinsuranceindustryhasavestedinterestinnewinfrastructureinvest-ments,upgradestoageinginfrastructureandadaptationmeasures.6
Investmentsininfrastructurewouldalsohelpcitiestocopebetterwithnaturaldisastersandothershockssuchashumanpandemicsandactsofterrorism.Asmanyoftheserisksarelikelytomaterial-iseinurbanlocations,buildingresilienceintheworld’scitiesisanurgentpriority.Butresourcelimitationsandbudgetcon-straintsmakethisachallengingtaskformayors,cityplannersandlocaldisaster
riskmanagers.Thisstudyaimstosupporttheirworkbyprovidingnewinsightsintothepotentialimpactofnaturaldisastersonurbancommunities.
Sincepeopleandeconomiesareinter-connected,comparisonsacrosscitiesandregionsarerelevanttocityauthorities.However,morespecificassessmentsoflocalconditionshavetobemadetogivethemanaccuratebasisfordecision-mak-ing.Initspublication‘MakingCitiesResil-ient,’theUnitedNationsOfficeforDisas-terRiskReduction(UNISDR)providesguidelinesandbestcaseexamplesforsuchplanning.7TheOECDalsoprovidesadetailedG20/OECDframeworkontheintegrationofriskfinanceandinsuranceintodisasterriskmanagement.8
Theimpactofalargenaturalcatastrophecanonlyeverbeavoidedtoacertainex-tent.Therewillalwaysbecostsforrelief,recoveryandreconstructionefforts,andtheywillconstituteafinancialburdenfortheaffectedregion.However,insurancecanhelpsoftentheimpactbyofferingrisktransferproductsthathelpnarrowthewidegapbetweeneconomicandinsuredlosses.
SwissReworkswithlocalandnationalgovernments,businessesandmanyotherstakeholderstostrengthenriskmanage-mentanddisasterpreparedness.Itdoessobyassessing,takingandsharingrisks,providingcapitaltotherealeconomyandpayingoutclaimswhendisastershap-pen.Furtherstrengtheningthesepartner-shipscangoalongwaytowardsmakingurbancommunitiesmoreresilientandsupportingthemtorecoverfasterwhendisasterstrikes.
Naturaldisasters,alongwithothershockssuchashumanpandemicsandactsofterrorism,arelikelytomaterialiseinurbanlocationsandaffectmillionsofresidents.Strengtheningtheresilienceoftheworld’scitiesisthereforeanurgentpriority.
28 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Appendix
Tables 11–15: Top 10 ranks per peril for the three analyses: (1) people potentially affected; (2) value of working days lost, global index; (3) Value of working days lost, relativ to national economy, global index
Earthquake ranking (see figure 5)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(mn)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost(globalindex0–1)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost,relativtonationaleconomy(globalin-dex0–1)
1 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
29.4 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
1.00 SanJose(CRI) 10002.2
1.00
2 Jakarta(IDN) 1160033.1
17.7 LosAngeles(USA) 1440015.4
0.79 Lima(PER) 26008.9
0.73
3 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
16.8 SanFrancisco(USA)
53005.0
0.40 Taipei(TWN) 21008.1
0.41
4 LosAngeles(USA) 1440015.4
14.7 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1360018.6
0.32 Bishkek(KGZ) 16001.0
0.36
5 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1360018.6
14.6 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
0.24 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
0.36
6 Tehran(IRN) 1100015.1
13.6 Taipei(TWN) 21008.1
0.15 Yerevan(ARM) 18001.4
0.34
7 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
9.4 Lima(PER) 26008.9
0.10 Almaty(KAZ) 22001.7
0.32
8 Lima(PER) 26008.9
8.9 Shizuoka(JPN) 21001.6
0.10 SantoDomingo(DOM)
8003.3
0.28
9 Taipei(TWN) 21008.1
8.0 Taichung(TWN) 57005.8
0.09 Santiago(CHL) 38006.2
0.26
10 Istanbul(TUR) 410011.5
6.4 Istanbul(TUR) 410011.5
0.09 Taichung(TWN) 57005.8
0.24
Storm ranking (see figure 7)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(mn)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost(globalindex0–1)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost,relativtonationaleconomy(globalin-dex0–1)
1 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
17.2 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
1.00 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
1.00
2 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
14.1 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1360018.6
0.49 Taipei(TWN) 21008.1
0.46
3 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
12.6 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
0.39 Tainan-Kaohsiung(TWN)
31005.1
0.38
4 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1360018.6
7.8 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
0.30 Port-au-Prince(HTI) 3002.0
0.38
5 Taipei(TWN) 21008.1
5.4 Taipei(TWN) 21008.1
0.18 Havana(CUB) 5002.0
0.34
6 Shantou(CHN) 520010.0
5.1 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
0.17 SantoDomingo(DOM)
8003.3
0.32
7 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
4.3 Tainan-Kaohsiung(TWN)
31005.1
0.15 Taichung(TWN) 57005.8
0.31
8 Mumbai(IND) 260020.6
4.3 Fukuoka(JPN) 29003.9
0.14 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
0.19
9 Chennai(IND) 16008.5
4.0 Taichung(TWN) 57005.8
0.12 Busan(KOR) 25005.0
0.12
10 Tainan-Kaohsiung(TWN)
31005.1
4.0 Busan(KOR) 25005.0
0.11 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 13600 0.10
Swiss Re Mindtherisk 29
River flood ranking (see figure 6)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(mn)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost(globalindex0–1)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost,relativtonationaleconomy(globalin-dex0–1)
1 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
12.0 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
1.00 Ndjamena(TCL) 8001.2
1.00
2 Shanghai(CHN) 800017.6
11.7 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
0.64 PhnomPenh(KHM) 5001.6
0.81
3 Kolkata(IND) 320019.1
10.5 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1350018.6
0.48 Bangkok(THL) 45009.5
0.80
4 Jakarta(IDN) 1060033.1
10.0 Paris(FRA) 1360011.2
0.42 Doha(QAT) 10001.4
0.52
5 Delhi(IND) 570021.9
8.9 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
0.40 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
0.46
6 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
8.9 Shanghai(CHN) 800017.6
0.28 Khartoum(SDN) 26005.6
0.45
7 Bangkok(THL) 35009.5
7.1 MexicoCity(MEX) 450019.6
0.20 Yerevan(ARM) 18001.4
0.43
8 MexicoCity(MEX) 450019.6
6.1 Bangkok(THL) 45009.5
0.20 Baghdad(IRK) 45008.0
0.41
9 Cairo(EGY) 350017.7
5.5 Amsterdam-Rotterdam(NDL)
108005.4
0.20 Ulaanbaatar(MNG) 10000.9
0.35
10 Tianjin(CHN) 26005.8
5.5 Milan(ITA) 149007.3
0.20 Cairo(EGY) 350017.7
0.29
Storm surge ranking
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(mn)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost(globalindex0–1)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost,relativtonationaleconomy(globalin-dex0–1)
1 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
5.3 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
1.00 Amsterdam-Rotterdam(NDL)
108005.4
1.00
2 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1350018.6
3.0 Amsterdam-Rotterdam(NDL)
108005.4
0.73 HoChiMinh(VNM) 2’0009.1
0.32
3 Mumbai(IND) 260020.6
2.6Osaka-Kobe(JPN)
1350018.6
0.73 PearlRiverDelta(CHN)
2060042.4
0.20
4 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
2.3 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
0.61 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1350018.6
0.15
5 Amsterdam-Rotterdam(NDL)
108005.4
1.8Nagoya(JPN)
1560011.6
0.51 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
0.13
6 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
1.7 NewYork-Newark(USA)
1190016.5
0.46 Manila(PHL) 290020.9
0.13
7 Shanghai(CHN) 800017.6
1.4 NewOrleans(USA) 27001.0
0.18 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
0.11
8 Kolkata(IND) 320019.1
1.4 Hamburg(DEU) 60002.3
0.09 Rangoon(MMR) 11004.2
0.10
9 HoChiMinh(VNM) 20009.1
1.3 Shanghai(CHN) 800017.6
0.07 Bangkok(THL) 35009.5
0.09
10 NewYork-Newark(USA)
1190016.5
1.1 Fukuoka(JPN) 30003.9
0.06 Havana(CUB) 5002.0
0.08
30 Swiss Re Mindtherisk
Tsunami ranking
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Peoplepotentiallyaffected(mn)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost(globalindex0–1)
Metroarea
Area(km2);population(mn)
Valueofworkingdayslost,relativtonationaleconomy(globalin-dex0–1)
1 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
2.4 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
1.00 Guayaquil(ECU) 9002.4
1.00
2 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
2.4 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
0.88 Nagoya(JPN) 1560011.6
0.63
3 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1350018.6
1.8 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1350018.6
0.68 Tokyo-Yokohama(JPN)
1630037.1
0.55
4 Shantou(CHN) 520010.0
0.7 Busan(KOR) 25005.0
0.06 Osaka-Kobe(JPN) 1350018.6
0.43
5 Kolkata(IND) 320019.1
0.6 Izmir(TUR) 14002.7
0.06 PanamaCity(PAN) 6001.1
0.33
6 Dhaka(BGD) 180012.9
0.4 Kagoshima(JPN) 5000.6
0.04 Izmir(TUR) 14002.7
0.28
7 Izmir(TUR) 14002.7
0.4 Shizuoka(JPN) 21001.6
0.04 Busan(KOR) 25005.0
0.21
8 Jiaojing(CHN) 27003.1
0.3 Shantou(CHN) 520010.0
0.04 Tainan-Kaohsiung(TWN)
31005.1
0.21
9 Guayaquil(ECU) 9002.4
0.3 Tainan-Kaohsiung(TWN)
31005.1
0.03 Jaffna(LKA) 8000.7
0.15
10 Chennai(IND) 16008.5
0.2 Istanbul(TUR) 410011.5
0.02 Dhaka(BGD) 180012.9
0.13
© 2014 Swiss Re. All rights reserved.
Title: Mind the risk – A global ranking of cities under threat from natural disasters
Authors: Lukas Sundermann, Oliver Schelske, Peter Hausmann
Editing and realisation: Patrick Reichenmiller, Katharina Fehr
Managing editor: Urs Leimbacher
Proofreading: Swiss Re Language Services
Graphic design and production: Swiss Re Corporate Real Estate & Logistics/ Media Production, Zürich
Photographs: Getty images, Corbis images
Cover picture: New York taxis are stranded on a flooded street in Queens following Hurricane Sandy, 2012.
Disclaimer: The content of this brochure is subject to copyright with all rights reserved. The information may be used for private or internal purposes, provided that any co-pyright or other proprietary notices are not removed. Electronic reuse of the content of this brochure is prohibited. Reproduction in whole or in part or use for any public purpose is only permitted with the prior written approval of Swiss Re, and if the source refe-rence is indicated. Courtesy copies are appreciated.
Although all the information used was taken from reliable sources, Swiss Re does not accept any responsibility for the accuracy or comprehensiveness of the details given. All liability for the accuracy and completeness thereof or for any damage resulting from the use of the information contained in this bro-chure is expressly excluded. Under no circumstances shall Swiss Re or its Group companies be liable for any financial and/or consequential loss relating to this brochure.
Visit www.swissre.com to download or to order additional copies of Swiss Re publications.
Order no: 1505715_13_en 12/14
Swiss Reinsurance Company Ltd Mythenquai 50/60 P.O. Box 8022 Zurich Switzerland
Telephone +41 43 285 2121 Fax +41 43 285 2999 www.swissre.com