![Page 1: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
MarijuanaintheWorkplace:LegalizationandMedicinalCannabis
SeatoSkyConference2017MatthewR.Letson
August9,2017
![Page 2: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
CANNABISACT– BillC-45
• Notyetpassed– Marijuanastillillegal
• Permitspossessionupto30gfor18yo+
• Ticketfor31g-50gwith$200fine
• Licensesvendorsandproducers
• Leavesmuchofimplementationtoprovinces
• NotawareofanyProvincethathasannouncedregulation
![Page 3: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
CANNABISACTDiscussionPaper
• Marijuana impairs a number of brain functions needed for safe driving such as coordination,judgement of distances, reaction time, and ability to pay attention. Marijuana is second to alcoholas the drug most frequently found among drivers involved in crashes and drivers charged withimpaired driving, and among seriously injured drivers. Marijuana and alcohol are also among themost frequently occurring alcohol-drug combinations.
• In contrast to alcohol, there is currently no roadside "breathalyzer"-type test to detectimpairment with marijuana. However, roadside oral fluid tests are being used in otherjurisdictions that can detect the presence of marijuana in oral fluid which can besuggestive of recent use. This is an active area of Canadian and international research.
Toward the Legalization, Regulation and Restriction of Access to Marijuana - DiscussionPaperhttp://healthycanadians.gc.ca/health-system-systeme-sante/consultations/legalization-marijuana-legalisation/public-safety-protection-securite-public-eng.php
![Page 4: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
CANNABISACT– TaskForce
June2016– FederalGov’tappointed9membertaskforce• TaskForceonCannabisLegalizationandRegulation• ChairAnneMcLellan(formerJusticeMinister)• FinalReportNovember2016
http://healthycanadians.gc.ca/task-force-marijuana-groupe-etude/framework-cadre/index-eng.php• Approach:“apublichealthapproachtoreduceharmandpromotehealth”
• TaskForcedealtwithmarijuanause/impairmentintheworkplace• Specialconcernforsafety-sensitiveworkplaces• Notedlimitationsonrandomdrugtesting• Recognizedneedforaccommodationofdisabilities
• NothingincorporatedintoBillC-45
![Page 5: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
CANNABISACT– BillC-45
• WhatdoesitmeanforEmployers?
• Treatmuchlikealcoholfor30gorless
• 30gto50g– specialproblem
• limitationsontesting
• ImplicationsforHealthandSafety
• Impairmentvspresence
• Casefor‘marijuanaaddiction’andaccommodation
• Medicalmarijuanauseatwork
![Page 6: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
CANNABISACT– TaskForce
AdvicetoMinistersTheTaskForcerecommendsthatthefederalgovernment:• Facilitateandmonitorongoingresearchoncannabisandimpairment,consideringimplicationsforoccupationalhealthandsafetypolicies
• Workwithexistingfederal,provincialandterritorialbodiestobetterunderstandpotentialoccupationalhealthandsafetyissuesrelatedtocannabisimpairment
• Workwithprovinces,territories,employersandlabour representativestofacilitatethedevelopmentofworkplaceimpairmentpolicies
![Page 7: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
CANNABISACT– TaskForce
Problemswithmarijuanatesting• Cannabis-impaireddrivingandworkperformance;
• THCimpairsdrivingperformance,thelevelofTHCinbodilyfluidsdoesnotreliablyindicatethedegreeofimpairment;
• NoequivalenttoBloodAlcoholConcentration(BAC);
• Problemofchronic,heavyusersofcannabis;
• testingtools:oralfluidscreeningdevicesarethemostadvancedtoday(andhavetheaddedadvantageofsignalling recentuse);
![Page 8: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
CANNABISACT–EmploymentProblems
Problemswithmarijuanauseafterlegalization• Prohibitionofuse/impairmentatwork– testingproblems
• Policies
• Proxiesforimpairment
• Multiplemethodsofingestion– notlikefindingthevodkabottleinthetrunk;
• EmployeeswhotraveltotheUSforwork– maybebannedfromentryeveniflegalinCanada;
• Addictionandhumanrights
![Page 9: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
CanadianModel
• In 1999, Construction Owners Association of Alberta developed model policy• Updated 4 times since then (most recent 2014)
Available at: http://www.coaa.ab.ca/safety/CanadianModel.aspx
![Page 10: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
CanadianModel
![Page 11: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
CanadianModel
![Page 12: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
ProposedUSFederalGuidelines
MandatoryGuidelinesforFederalWorkplaceDrugTestingProgramsbytheU.S.SubstanceAbuseandMentalHealthServicesAdministration• Currentlyproposedamendmentsto1988guidelines• OraltestingstandardsameasCanadianStandardforMarijuana
• 4ng/mlinitial• 2ng/mlconfirmatory
![Page 13: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
CanadianModel
![Page 14: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
CanadianModel
Upheld in:• FluorConstructorsCanadaLtd.andI.B.E.W.,Loc.424(Chornyj)(Re),(2001)100LAC(4th)391• Clearwater Fabrication GP Inc. v. United Assn. of Journeymen and Apprentices of the
Plumbing and Pipefitting Industry of the United States and Canada, Local Union 488(Johnston Grievance), (2013) 234 L.A.C. (4th) 132
• Good Construction Industry standard• In unionized context, will be largely respected IF incorporated by Employers and Unions into
the Collective Agreement or otherwise agreed to by both• Must be applied reasonably• No cases dealing with non-union context• No reason to think it would not be considered applicable if incorporated by non-union
employers into the terms of employment• Random testing and other aspects MAY be at odds with the Human Rights Act
![Page 15: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
StatusofDrugTesting
Tolko Industries Ltd. v United Steel, Paper and Forestry, Rubber, Manufacturing, Energy, AlliedIndustrial and Service Workers International Union, Local 1-425, 2017 CanLII 46450 (BC LA)
• E’ee operating heavy equipment involved in serious, preventable accident causing sig.damage – E’ee dismissed for cause
• E’ee testing positive for marijuana metabolites 241ng/ml in urine – over 200ng/ml aboveCanadian Model (not raised here)
• Union argued E’ers justification argument should be summarily dismissed as evidence ofmetabolites in urine does not demonstrate impairment
• Arbitrator dismissed Union’s argument, ordering full hearing with additional evidence• Not satisfied that presence of metabolites could not be used as corroborative evidence of
impairment in light of serious accident• Implication: Cannot safely rely on blood/saliva/urine testing alone
![Page 16: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
MedicalCannabis
• Calgary(City)vCUPE,Local37,2015CanLII 61756• In2009,Employeeprescribedmedicalmarijuanaforchronicdegenerativeneckproblem• Informed2supervisorsofprescription,andallowedtokeepworkinginsafetysensitivepositionusingheavyequipmentforoverayear
• ManagerlaterlearnedofprescriptionandEmployeewasremovedfromsafety-sensitivepositionpendinginvestigation
• E’er orderedanIMEthatshowedhecouldwork,butE’er perceivedtherewasalingering“drugdependence”issuethatwasunresolved
• E’er triedtohaveAlbertaTransportationremovetheE’ee’s Class3license• Tribunalfoundthatthe“drugdependence”issuewasartificiallycreatedbyE’er• E’er failedtoprovideanyevidenceofactualimpairmentonthejob• E’ee statedthatheconsumedonlyasmallamounteachnighttoeasepainatnight,andneverconsumedduringtheday
![Page 17: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
MedicalCannabis
• FrenchvSelkin Logging,2015BCHRT101• E’ee operatingheavingloggingequipmentwasterminatedbecauseherefusedtoceasesmokingmarijuanaonthejob
• E’ee hadpainfulcancerwhichhewasself-medicatingwithmarijuana(splitting6-8jointsperdaywithaco-worker)
• E’ee didNOThaveaprescriptionformedicalmarijuana,buthisoncologistwashelpinghimgetoneandwasawareofthedrugusetomanagepain
• E’er hadazero-tolerancepolicy,butallowedweekstogobybetweenfirstreportsofonthejobmarijuanauseandconfrontingE’ee
• Tribunalfoundthatterminationforuseofmarijuanatocontrolpain(whetherprescriptionornot)wasprimafacie discrimination
• PolicywasjustifiedandrequesttoallowE’ee tosmokemarijuanaatworkasunduehardship• Tribunalacknowledgedthat,intherightcase,anE’er mayhavetotoleratesomemedicalmarijuanaconsumptiononthejobasacomponentofaccommodation,solongasitwasnotimpairing
![Page 18: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
MedicalCannabis
• IBEW,Local1620vLowerChurchillTransmissionConstructionEmp’s Assn.Inc.,[2016]N.L.L.A.A.No.5• E’ee workedbuildingtransmissionlinesforalargehydro-electricproject• E’ee residedatworkcampfor21daysatatime• E’ee hadavalidprescriptionformedicalmarijuanaandpurchasedhissupplylegally– usedforbackpainandaxiety
• E’ee didnotdiscloseprescriptionatthetimeofhiring(afraidhe’dnotbehired),andtookstepstohidhismarijuanasupplyoutsideoftheworkcampastherewasazero-tolerancepolicy
![Page 19: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
MedicalCannabis
• IBEW,Local1620vLowerChurchillTransmissionConstructionEmp’s Assn.Inc.,[2016]N.L.L.A.A.No.5• NoevidenceE’ee everimpairedatwork• E’ee dismissedasaresultofhisfailuretodisclosehisprescriptionandhistakingactivestepstoconceal• GrievanceDeniedduetoE’ee deceptionandpossessionatworksiteinviolationofzerotolerancepolicy
Causefordisciplineupheld,butpenaltyreferredbacktoarbitrator: IBEW,LocalUnion1620v.LowerChurchillTransmissionConstructionEmployers'AssociationInc.andValard ConstructionLP,2016CanLII 84114(NLTD)
Questions:• WhatifE’ee hadbeenupfrontaboutuse– couldE’er haverefusedhimthepositiongivenhisprescription?
UnitedSteelWorkersLocal7656vMosaicPotashColonsay ULC(Danyluk Grievance),[2016]S.L.A.A.No.4
• CouldE’er maintainzero-tolerancepolicyforpossessionatworkcampifhehaddisclosedhisprescription?
![Page 20: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
MedicalCannabis
MedicalMarijuana– CanadianModel
• Musthaveaprescription
• Regardless– musthavenoimpairingeffectonE’ee
• Notificationofside-effects
• Stigmaof‘smokingup’atwork• Doess.3.2workforsmokedmedicalcannabis?
![Page 21: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
RandomTesting
Significantdifferencebetweenunionizedandnon-unionizedworkplaces
Unionizedworkplace• Extraordinarycircumstances
• historyofdrugabuseinworkplace• safetysensitiveworkplace
• Post-incidenttestingmorejustifiable
Non-unionizedworkplace• Noexplicitrestrictiononrandom/post-incidenttesting• Mainconsiderationinhumanrights(addictionandmedicalmarijuana)
HumanRights• Mosttestingisprimafacie discriminatory
![Page 22: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
HumanRights
• Prohibitdiscriminationforphysicalandmentaldisability
• Addictionisconsideredaphysicaland/ormentaldisability
• MedicalCannabisusersalsoprotected
• Addiction/MedicalCannabisusecannotbeafactorindiscipline/dismissalatallunless itisjustifiedasabonafideoccupationalrequirement
• Employersmustaccommodatetothepointofunduehardship
• SomeFactors:• Safetysensitiveposition• Evidenceofimpairmentatwork• Natureofemployer’sworkplace• Economiccostofaccommodation(ie:costoftreatmentprograms,etc.)
![Page 23: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
HumanRights
• Brooksv.Martin-BrowerofCanadaCo.,[2008]BCHRTDNo.49• Employeecaughtsmokingmarijuana
• Employeeadmittedaddiction,andreferredbyemployerforcounselling
• Signedanagreementthathewouldabstainfromdruguseandattendoutpatienttreatment
• Employeelaterrefusedtosignupforexpensiveoutpatientprogramandrefusedalternativeproposedbyemployer
• HRComplaintdismissedashefailedtocomplywithaccommodation
![Page 24: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
HumanRights
• StewartvElkValleyCoalCorporation,2017SCC30– IMPORTANTNEWDECISION
• E’er policyrequiredemployeetocomeforwardwithoutconsequenceifsufferingdrug-addictionandE’er wouldprovidetreatmentifreportedbeforeanyincident
• Policyprovidednearautomaticterminationifincidentoccursandnopriorselfreporting
• Post-accident,E’ee wholateradmittedtocrack-cocaineuseoff-duty,wasterminatedbecausehedidnotcomeforward
• AlbertaHumanRightsCommissiondismissedcomplaintbecauseE’ee inviolationofmandatorydisclosurepolicy
• E’ee testifiedthathedidnotperceivehehadanaddictionuntilafteraccident– BUTSCCruledthatwasirrelevant
![Page 25: Marijuana in the Workplace€¦ · Marijuana in the Workplace: Legalization and Medicinal Cannabis Sea to Sky Conference 2017 Matthew R. Letson August 9, 2017. CANNABIS ACT –Bill](https://reader034.vdocuments.mx/reader034/viewer/2022050222/5f67ab946199a962b27385ae/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
THANKYOU!!