-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
1/12
aslow, Na han E q.La ice f t a M Z s181 D v e S r eSa J se CA
R
r t pp qt C rk
5107 Le sburg Pk , S ite 0Fal Ch c . V n 2 J
O e s u se / FR Box 26
Sa Fra s 94 26
ame: ARM S-B RRA ZU A OSE RTO A09 81211
e o s ce2/26/2
Enclosed i a copy of eBo rd' c sio a d ord e re e ec .
E c o u
P M mb s:E w d R
e e
Do
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
2/12
v
Board f m ig t n Ap e ls
F irg n a J
F : A094 8 - San Francis o AIn re: JOSE ALB RTO R B R U L
V PROC D G
PE L
D :
ON B H F O ON Na Za lowEsqui
ON BEHALFF e F Ho
A ChiefCo sICA ON; Te inat o
8 ZO
Th e on n , a a d zn Pe a pea l d m d on of a Im ig at on udgea ed D emb r 2 20 8whic e th r o n ' o o o n e dthe spo e t
bj to em val c h g , d o e r mov . Th a p alw ll s d
We r v w thd ng c u g thed e i at onof cr b ,mad byIm onJu g e e o o s" . 1 )(3) We v wao e su s, cl d ge p es ve et e u de o oof d s of
o s d . C F R 3 (d )a d ( ; o4I&N D 4 (BI 8
fa u n ng of I i r o Ju arnot e o s Ex i ow a pt eg o c u o o Im g dg o g
e - e so ci o f 72, 4 994 ; g8 C.F R { )f . r l r i .h & t m M s r i t : a _v l O . _
. - s tu io r De r e o o an S c DHS a e Jac ang o e by H g F d4 9t
C r. 94). As e I on g d, a s s h l a nn o g es n nt ha b a p ce, a o
au B u l y a m
a a o s ide e m vab wa gaHyo am s e ab i a i a ow g aDHS'
c du t g g la uAme t g M o &D 6 B 988 u he o n 's ga l o i q e .n s E 5h
s m (Tr. at a i s a yk y e m o . x 0) g
Cite as: Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
3/12
A 1
- cs ' dmis ion ) e tab h emen fr v b .We e conc Imm g Judge's f in h hes ss ss cl s m r t
ORDE : T p m .
Cite as: Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
4/12
-
UNI D STAT DEPARTM N OF JUS ICEEX CUTIVE O F E FOR M G R VIEW
S E G N S
ile A 94 812 Dec r , 0
of
O ALBE O ARMA -BA RA Z , R OV L O G
s p ond nt
H E: S 21 (a) 6 A i - ali n pr s n t d t w h u b ing e p o
P LI mina e.
B H HE T:
s q D J 95
B T D M NM Y
C s W o sh ef u
r a f I g s ms ms orcem ntp f H m c y
1 Mo o e y, S 2n c
N I GRT ON
s p y h n c s c o
t e o ox c 2 6 wh le h m a
v .
c o h x b 5 h h b ki g
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
5/12
.
e nd is w f r a i n g a g n A h cal l
e d t po i c iv . T nd n w s a
k n n y , n u d th S n
F nc o ou y a He as ar e w m e s
p ursu e 273, f l o por l nj r pon ous
273.5 e as e n S n a c c y un. or ab D be 18 006 he w s ns d m
San n ja l co jai S u n nDe , 00 w s n c s o y a pol ma wa
nd no h s m J A n
t re was an to H a
h s n n bu h e e c e o n r a a wo n
z wa n r u
i n g n g a i n n s o as e
s o n so q s n s Re s nd e n a e not
wer e s o e u
c n s l r n o n A c d
h s a on, f e r t g a M x n .
n n n
e ng a 29 200 s po
crim n l cou n . T r m judg i fo m d
c d r e w r g za c exc p f r
a n I on m An h r or
po n ac u d ov r n s
r n D c
e m e ,
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
6/12
( .
O J y 3, 20 7, a e e ew ea nd vidu l,
no er INS office a e to s e e r e s po e t , d n rod e to
he es n e t e w s I igra o f ic e r a e s
i g o sk s o me q s ti o s . He sked e e s p n e n bou s
a i ali a d e esp de s e ed o h e es La e
esp de w s o s g some p pe . H d ot
s g a y p e s. He w e sub eq e y s e ed o a
ja l Y a u e r e g a o e e
Ja 1 he ad a I g a n C r n S
F s o bo d p cee g n w s el a d $10,0 0 bo d.
See J nu ry 8 2 7 c im l o S n
e a ge s st he es o de ee
Exh b
Re p e app re be e C t o Ma 29, 2
d f ed a mo o s p e s d e m e. T e mo i n
supp ess q i e e Co r s ppr e s a vide o ed b
e Go e r me n s e s u l follo g e de e e S
F a c i The G e men fi ed o pos t o e
o o to e n e, 8. A hed o e o o
e e e was o e o u ob j e e by e
es o de ' o e , f om o I leg ede
e e e 8, 2 6, a d e e o o e ho e w e
r e s po e , e v e e on Ja a y 3 , E i its
.
4 12 4 3 De e e ,
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
7/12
P
O Ja ar 22, 2 8 e Co t t ot on o
s pp ss an t m na d he mat r was es t for he
respo d o state what e f he would be s k ng Respon en
ap pear e or h C d a e ha h no se an
r l f o l s e o ter io of e o e s
Gove n nt ntrod ed to dence he record o depor a e
a e Exh b an so od o co r , reco d o
s o n d e y e o er me t r io o e o
J y 3 007 b
hose re h ts h h s b n broug t b h
s ond nt a d b e d n n the r or
he ss e n s se s w e e a o d g to he
spo 's o e , e r h spo n s p ace o
igratio o s a v olat o of fo rt
The e s ue s he er e record o de o ab e
a en s trus o hy doc en sho l be a te as
e e to pro e e a an d po ab y.
The fo r h en o h gh o e eop
s ur d t e r erson ouses ap r an fe ts
a s he un so ab e sea hes nd se z s. aw e fo emen
o cers m y ot a res e o o w o t a res
e o i ed ce ons co en hot s i o
e o , o o d c a he k o
ng r o he o e o to o er er o s e o o side e
d e g See Min sota v. n 495 1, 00 (1 9 )
A 9 8 2 4 Dece e 2 08
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
8/12
When espon e q est ons the ega y o ev dence
s t s c se e us co e w t o est s ng
pr e c s t t Go e me t's e de e w s u w u
o e Mat e B rc n s 1 &N D c 1 (BIA 1 8
d s u de aff da i a o e is o s ff c e
R t er t e tes mony o e o e is e u e . O ce res e
m es r ma s ow , h de s s o e o er me
pro e hat i obta ed s e en e ful y
I he o o s p ss t es o den es he
c se o O ho ag v. NS 38 F 3 488 9 C r 994) n st te
at t t o h rc e th o e g so nd g
es t o de co st tut on y sufficient b sis fo the
se z e of e so or nce h n e e gen s us ec e
perso s an l eg l e . T e Cou t l no e n
or sup , e Ci t o n t e o e ege
entr n o e espo den s apa tme t w t ou se ur his
l conse t d ased so y on he act t a he ha
N ge n-sound ng na e as e eg ous fo ur en e t
v o tio
a case s co p e e ist nt om t s c se.
i c se e es on en a no a es ed y t e I ig io
The p ol e a F a a ed a e e f
e espon en s f ly fol o ng a a g en ich he
es o de a o e be ween s
w e e as k g He as ken leg ly nto usto y t e
0 8 2 e e be
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
9/12
-'
p of S n F sco n h t f ct s eve is p t e .
n stody , t e I g tion o cer then c me d sked him o e
qu es o n o f . H o e h i s
p o e d g c o u be re e sed on h s n r c g izanc
exce h had n I g r I ee , e s d
f c th t he s re e se fro the S n r n is o r m n sys e
ra s e r t e c od of INS a w h i t s e c o d
Im g o o c p n e h m e t o s Ac or g
to the s on e ' e c ar o , Ex t 5 e to the
q o w ll ully nd o a y He e e
h s t a y T e Go er ent mo e to ev ce th I- 2 3
s po te y the te en h r e po e e dur ng
w t e i ie th NS o ce Exhib .
Res on ppe e th C r t y w as
r e s cou o o an we a y o e g r g
i o a i t y h C urt as e e e t cord, o
t s r e po , cco o he 2 , at
e o e t e a o vo y w c s E hi 2,
eco o d ep or ble ie , p a e e t
d t e to h e d d d d E 6, e s r m
Peru I e e d, x t i d c at e s t he was b r o Oc o
3 a uj o La e a Pe u. Re po e
c s as o p ov d r a o e o o co a i e
the 2 s e s in e h b t is cor ect T at
i i i o m t h w o coer io o
8 2 ece e
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
10/12
LP
d re The C ha ha h I-2 3 eren
us r hy and a is bl as v nce to pr al enage and
e p ab .
o n s a es n e a no se a
p a ac ca e a ou am n n io a ion warran in
s p r ss f stat m ts O s no r qu r o prov d
t e Co t i h ea on p ana io e a n is c ai ed
c ns itu ona v a n d ased o h r spo d t' s
c arat n, pur uan o c pro d l nta ly
for ation a nat na t to he NS off cer bas d n
E h bi 12 wh c is a co d o dep r abl a ie pu uan
t e n or at on o id o he I ra ff ce as
a a d a h i ha no a s t e
U ed S at and a prov ded free b the resp den
Ex 2, uppor ed by Exh bi nd bas d
os id nc ha h a ua a le a i ns 4
s s ained e Go n A h o I fur h r n a
va l t u cti (a) ( (A) i) a so
s pp ted b e c d
h o r bas d n h v d n on the 2
an e Q a d A s at nt, E h a P u sd s na ed as cou ry of r m a
As esponden s n seek ng an r e , as
t r q s g for v n ar par ur , a d as h Cou as
u d ha he s ovable as charg a u r r a
09 812 1 7 D em r 22 0
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
11/12
LP
he respo d r e remov d f the Un e a es to Pe u.
T a C o o e
8 8 008
-
8/13/2019 Jose Alberto Armas-Barranzuela, A094 812 114 (BIA Feb. 26, 2010)
12/12
( .,I 'CERTIF C G
I hereby ce r f hat e at ac ed pro eed ng
f PH N-QU G U ma of:
JOSE ALB RT R S B R NZUE
A 9 1
n F an is , Cal a
w e pp a a d a is o ig l
s t f h x v O f f
D os t Se v , I c.5 Ex u ou ev d
kv l M a d 0 530 ) 33
ebruary 13, 2 9{ p n ate)