Romanian Biotechnological Letters Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016 Copyright © 2016 University of Bucharest Printed in Romania. All rights reserved
ORIGINAL PAPER
12062 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016
Garlic, cilantro and chlorella’s effect on liver histoarchitecture changes
in Cd-intoxicated Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio)
Received for publication, February 16, 2015
Accepted, May 3, 2015
MARIOARA NICULA1, GABI DUMITRESCU1, NICOLAE PACALA1,
LAVINIA ŞTEF1, CAMELIA TULCAN1, MONICA DRAGOMIRESCU1,
DOREL DRONCA1, ADRIANA GHERBON2, LILIANA PETCULESCU
CIOCHINA1
1Banat’s University of Agricultural Sciences and Veterinary Medicine “King Michael
I of Romania” from Timişoara, 300645-Timişoara, Calea Aradului 119, Romania; 2University of Medicine and Farmacy “Victor Babeş” Timişoara, Department of
Physiology, 300173-Timişoara, Splaiul Tudor Vladimirescu 14, Romania; *Corresponding author: E-mail: [email protected]
Abstract Bioactive compounds from natural sources can act as oxygen free radical scavengers or metal chelators,
which enables them to be used as natural antagonists to heavy metals toxicity. So the purpose of this study was
to compare histologically the aspect of liver tissue of Prussian carps’ specimens, subjected to chronic Cd
intoxication with and without garlic, cilantro and chlorella dietary supplementation. 150 Prussian carps, with
weight of 10-12 g, were divided according to the following treatments for 21 days: C (without treatment), E1 (10
ppm Cd into water), E2 (10 ppm Cd into water+2% lyophilized garlic in feed), E3 (10 ppm Cd into water+2%
lyophilized cilantro in feed), E4 (10 ppm Cd into water+2% lyophilized chlorella in feed). Fragments of liver
were removed at the end of experimental period and analyzed in light microscopy and a specific QuickPHOTO
Micro 2.2 software has been used for the histological study. Mentioned epithelium suffered evident histo-
morphological alterations under the action of Cd while the active principles from garlic, cilantro and chlorella
powder have showed chelating and antioxidant potential, cilantro and garlic being the most effective.
Key word: cadmium (Cd) toxicity, fish, liver, histopathology, garlic, cilantro, chlorella
1. Introduction The metals are considered as major toxic pollutants that entering into biogeochemical
cycles they accumulate in natural and artificial aquatic ecosystems. Terrestrial sources that
generate heavy metals are natural - volcanic eruptions, natural weathering leading to rocks’
erosion and anthropogenic - wastewater treatment plants, industries, mining and agriculture
[1]. Non-essential metals (lead, arsenic, mercury, cadmium) are highly toxic, even at very low
levels [2], especially if they accumulate in metabolically active sites. Among them, cadmium
is considered one of the most toxic environmental substances due to its ubiquity, toxicity and
long half-life [3]. Cadmium not having an efficient excretory mechanism, its half-life in the
liver is between 4 and 19 years and, in the kidneys is between 6 and 38 years [4]. There are
three major routes to uptake heavy metals by aquatic organisms: respiratory system (gills),
digestive system and overall body surface (skin) [5]. In benthic aquatic ecosystems, where pollutants are associated with sediments, feed is an important source of their uptake [6]. Thus,
uptake of the contaminants leads to their concentration into aquatic organisms’ tissues,
including fish. Fish are ideal indicators of heavy metal contamination in aquatic ecosystems
Garlic, cilantro and chlorella’s effect on liver histoarchitecture changes in Cd-intoxicated Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio)
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016 12063
[6]. The contaminant can be sequestered and then neutralized, and/or may have specific
interactions with endogenous molecules (inhibition of enzyme) and/or can be metabolized by
enzymes of the biotransformation system. All these interactions may result in: long-term
storage (neutralized fraction); direct or indirect toxic effects (after biotransformation);
excretion of contaminants or their metabolites [7]. The cell membrane is the first target
structure when metals penetrate the cell. It has been shown that metals can bind to membrane
proteins and phospholipids altering their structure and functions [8]. Heavy metals can
stimulate lipid peroxidation processes, a complex sequence of biochemical reactions, defined
as "polyunsaturated lipid oxidative deterioration". The entire process results in production of
highly toxic compounds for the cell, because of high reactivity compared to other cell
components (membrane proteins, DNA). Toxic metals with high affinity to the active groups
of proteins may affect the structure and function of these molecules and finally, the cell
physiology [9]. Chelation therapy is the most commonly used therapeutic strategy for heavy
metal poisoning [10]. Synthetic chelating agents, such as DMPS, DMSA, EDTA and others,
bind poisonous metals rendering them inert and promoting their excretion from the body
without further interaction. There are advantages and disadvantages to using these ones. One
advantage is the power of their mobilizing activity –they are quick to mobilize and eliminate
certain metals in the body, but this may place a huge burden on the body’s detoxification
systems [11]. But natural chelators from some vegetal sources as chlorella [12], garlic [13]
and coriander [14] have been shown their detox ability in human and animals. Garlic contains
many active sulfur compounds derived from cysteine with metal-chelating potential roperties;
these garlic constituents may also protect from metal-catalyzed oxidative damage [15]).
Garlic increases antioxidant action by scavenging reactive oxygen species (ROS), enhancing
the cellular antioxidant enzymes and increasing glutathione in the cells [16]. Cilantro
(Coriandrum sativum) can bind and immobilize cadmium chloride from liver and kidney [17]
and decrease toxic tissue cadmium accumulation in cultured rainbow trout Oncorhynchus
mykiss [18]. One of its principal constituents is linalool. Several animal studies provide
evidence that coriander seeds can promote the hepatic antioxidant system [19]. Chlorella, a
unicellular green algae with the ability to bind cadmium (in animal models) [20], has been
used to detoxify wastewater of metal contaminants as well [21]). The aim of the present study
was first to highlight severity of histological liver damages and secondary to assess
comparatively the chelating and antioxidant property of chlorella, coriander and garlic
compounds in Prussian carp’s cadmium-induced intoxication.
2. Material and Methods Biological material - 150 Prussian carp fingerlings (Carassius gibelio Bloch) were
chosen as test species on the basis of accessibility and ecologically representation. Individuals
belonging to this species are easily acquired and adapt to captivity. Fresh fish samples were
collected from a local pond and were gravimetrically selected. Thus, individuals of 10-12 g
weight were acclimated for two weeks under laboratory conditions prior to experiment,
removing those ones with suspicions on their health. Then, Prussian carp fingerlings were
transferred in 5 glass aquariums equipped with aeration system and 60 L capacity at a
stocking density of 30 fishes per aquarium. The control and test organisms were randomly
distributed in test solutions as follows: the control ones were maintained in Cd-free
freshwater, the others four groups receiving: E1 (10 ppm Cd into water), E2 (10 ppm Cd into
water+2% lyophilized garlic in feed), E3 (10 ppm Cd into water+2% lyophilized cilantro in
feed), E4 (10 ppm Cd into the water+2% lyophilized chlorella in feed), respectively.
MARIOARA NICULA, GABI DUMITRESCU, NICOLAE PACALA, LAVINIA ŞTEF, CAMELIA TULCAN, MONICA
DRAGOMIRESCU, DOREL DRONCA, ADRIANA GHERBON, LILIANA PETCULESCU CIOCHINA
12064 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016
Chemicals -Fish in groups E1, E2, E3 and E4 were exposed for 21 days to chronic
cadmium intoxication in concentration of 10 ppm from a CdCl2 x ½H2O stock solution. The
sub lethal treatment was calculated from percentage mortalities of fish as described by B.
VEENA & al. [22].
Fish nutrition - Fish were fed twice a day with commercial dry pellets. Freeze-dried
garlic, cilantro and chlorella’s incorporation in fish feed has involved the following steps: 1)
bringing the dry pellets to fine size particles; 2) adding the lyophilized material in the
proportion determined by the experimental protocol setting the daily feed amount needed by a
specimen, according to the calculation model in fish proposed by L. OPREA & R.
GEORGESCU [23]; 3) wetting and homogenization of the obtained mixture; 4) regranulation
and drying of the final pellets. Chlorella pyrenoidosa powder was produced by Bucharest
Medical Laboratories; garlic (figure 1) and coriander (figure 2) powders were obtained by
lyophilization to Interdisciplinary Training and Research Platform "Sustainable Ecological
Agriculture, and Food Safety" from USAMVB Timisoara, Romania. Lyophilization was
carried out at a temperature of -53°C and a pressure of 0.05 mTorr and lyophilization
efficiency was 38.07% for garlic and 10.55% for cilantro, respectively.
Monitoring of physical-chemical parameters of the water in aquariums - Physical-
chemical indicators of water-dissolved oxygen, temperature, NO2-, NO3
-, pH, hardness were
daily measured (water temperature and dissolved oxygen with a movable oxygen-meter with
water resisting microprocessor Hanna HI 9145; pH, NO2-, NO3
-, pH, toughness of water with
a Germany termatest kit).
Histopathological examination - Fragments of liver were removed at the end of a 21
days experimental period after fish euthanasia with an overdose of anesthetic tricaine
methanosulfonate (MS-222) (>250 mg/L). The material was subjected to histological analysis,
being fixed in a formalin solution 10%, dehydrated, clarified, impregnated and embedded in
histological paraffin, according to standard routine methods in the Histology laboratory. Five-
micrometer-thick sections were obtained and stained by Mallory’s trichrome method. Liver
was estimated for 10 specimens from each population. Microscopic examination was
performed using a CX41 Olympus light microscope equipped with a digital camera and
specific QuickPHOTO Micro 2.2 software has been used for the histopathological study.
Tissue alterations were assessed using the histopathological score [24] ranging from – to +++
depending on the degree and extend of lesions: (-) none, (+) mild occurrence, (++) moderate
occurrence, (+++) severe occurrence. Statistical analysis was performed using SPPS IBM 22
software. Data were reported as a significant level of p<0.05. Test of differences between
means was realized by ANOVA completed with post-hoc Tukey test.
3. Results and Discussion Histopathological study of the liver
Histopathological alterations can be used as indicators for the effects of various
anthropogenic pollutants on aquatic biota and they are a reflection of the overall health of
entire population in the ecosystem [25]. The investigation of histological changes in organs of
fish is an accurate way to assess the effects of xenobiotics compounds in experimental studies
[26]. The liver performs many essential functions related to digestion, metabolism, immunity,
and the storage of nutrients within the body. At the same time, the liver is associated with
detoxification and biotransformation processes, and due to these functions combined with its
location and access to the blood supply, it is one of the organs most affected by water
contaminants [25]. But, liver ability to degrade toxic compounds can be overwhelmed by
Garlic, cilantro and chlorella’s effect on liver histoarchitecture changes in Cd-intoxicated Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio)
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016 12065
elevated concentrations of these compounds, and could subsequently result in structural
damage [27]. The microscopic examination of the liver sections of control group revealed that
liver parenchyma consists of liver cells arranged in uniform cordons (figure 1). Hepatocytes
have a polygonal appearance, the membrane is well defined and nucleus is spherical, centrally
or slightly eccentrically located with obvious nucleolus. Binucleated cells are also seen, they
being common among hepatocytes and they can account for as much as 25% of the
hepatocytes polpulation [28]. Sinusoidal capillaries with normal appearance are arranged
between hepatic cell cords (figure 2). Connective tissue from stroma structure is less obvious.
Figure 1. Liver–LC
uniform liver cords;
centered or easily
eccentrically
nucleus; obvious
nucleolus
(trichrome Mallory
staining, 400x)
Figure 2. Liver–LC
sinusoidal
capillaries with
normal appearance
(trichrome Mallory
staining,1000x)
Liver belonging to cadmium-poisoned fish loses its normal architecture and frequently
sinusoidal capillaries hypertrophy and congestive processes are manifested (figures 3 and 4).
Interlobular spaces are wide. Venulare and arteriolar vascular endings are frequently
congested and increased in volume into interportal spaces. The hepatocytes are arranged in
cords, they have a polygonal form, and clear cytoplasm due to the accumulation of numerous
microlipid droplets (fatty degeneration). Intense hypertrophic processes, nuclear chromatin
condensation, karyolysis processes are reported on wider territories, resulting in cell death.
Unlike the control group, in the individuals of this one, intralobular connective stroma
becomes visible. Consequently, interstitial fibrosis processes occur in liver of these specimens
(figure 5).
Figure 3. Liver–E1
sinusoidal capillaries hypertrophy
(trichrome Mallory staining, 400x)
Figure 4. Liver–E1
congestive processes
(trichrome Mallory staining, 400x)
Figure 5. Liver–E1
interstitial fibrosis
(trichrome Mallory staining 200x)
Light microscopic study of the liver sample from fish exposed to Cd and garlic powder
supplemented diet showed several changes: hepatocytes have polygonal form, clear and
central, slightly eccentric nucleus, or eccentric. Frequently, in the liver parenchyma cell
hypertrophy occurs. Cells are increased in volume, cytoplasm is clear, and a large number of
cells have no nucleus. Mild perisinusoidal lymphocytic infiltrates are present in the
connective tissue. Hypertrophic sinusoids capillary, containing erythrocytes, are arranged
between hepatocytes. Interlobular spaces are filled with fine blades of connective tissue,
containing fine capillaries (figure 6) and slightly hypertrophic vascular ramifications also can
be found in interportal spaces. Histological changes in liver specimens exposed for 21 days to
Cd intoxication and feed with an incorporated coriander diet were hepatic parenchyma
consists of dense cords of hepatocyteswith a polygonal appearance, a spherical central,
slightly eccentric or totally eccentric nucleus, with obvious nucleolus; the cytoplasm is clear,
but has fine granulations diffusely spread; hypertrophic hepatocytes with pyknotic nucleus or
without nucleus appear on smaller areas (figure 7). Hypertrophic sinusoidal capillary network
with rich erythrocytes content are distributed among the hepatocyte cords. Hypertrophic
MARIOARA NICULA, GABI DUMITRESCU, NICOLAE PACALA, LAVINIA ŞTEF, CAMELIA TULCAN, MONICA
DRAGOMIRESCU, DOREL DRONCA, ADRIANA GHERBON, LILIANA PETCULESCU CIOCHINA
12066 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016
processes appear in the peri- and interlobular venules and arterioles, vessels in which also is
viewing erythrocyte content. Lymphocytic infiltrates (figure 8) are reported surrounding the
connective tissue of the blood vessels. Histopathological alterations observed after sublethal
Cd exposure in liver of fish fed with a chlorella incorporated diet were: hepatocytes arranged
in cords, have clear cytoplasm with central, slightly eccentric or totally eccentric spherical
nucleus; hepatocytes in various stages of atrophy, increased in volume, with a single block
condensed chromatin, or showing karyolysis are observed on large areas (figure 9).
Figure 6. Liver E2: cell
hypertrophy; cells without a
nucleus;
mild perisinusoidal lymphocytic
infiltrates;
hypertrophic sinusoids capillary
(trichrome Mallory staining, 400x)
Figure 7. Liver E3
dense cords of hepatocytes;
hypertrophic hepatocytes;
hepatocytes with pyknotic nucleus;
hepatocytes without nucleus, spherical
central, slightly eccentric or totally
eccentric nucleus; obvious nucleolus;
clear cytoplasm with fine diffusely
spread granulations (trichrome Mallory
staining, 1000x)
Figure 8. Liver E3
hypertrophic sinusoidal capillary
network;
rich erythrocytes content; lymphocytic
infiltrates
(trichrome Mallory staining,
400x)
Figure 9. Liver E4: atrophied
hepatocytes; condensed chromatin;
karyolysis;
vascular congestions
(trichrome Mallory staining, 1000x)
Sinusoidal capillaries have wide lumen containing abundant red cells. Also, the
terminals veins are hypertrophic and have content. The liver is frequently identified as a target
organ in toxicity studies [29], partly attributable to its anatomical location and functional
complexity. If accumulation of toxins is faster than the liver metabolizing ability, hepatic
damage may occur [30]. Most of the hepatotoxic agents, including cadmium, damage liver
cells mainly by inducing lipid peroxidation and by generation of reactive oxidative
intermediates in liver [30]. Hepatic tissues of the fish exposed to cadmium chloride showed
high degree of congestion (table 1) that may be attributed to the decline in hematological
parameters as H. A. KAOUD & al. [31] observed since the hemoglobin contents are
insufficient for the respiration of the tissue. Congestion of the hepatic central vein and
sinusoids was also reported by H. A. KAOUD & al. [31]; Z. A. EL-GREISY & A. H. A. EL-
GAMAL [32]. In our study, the abundance of intrahepatic lymphocytes (table 1) found in
cadmium treated fish and fed with an incorporated garlic (E2) and cilantro (E3) diet, indicate
that liver is severely affected by the toxic chemical. This action on the immunological defense
of the fish was confirmed in many works as response to heavy metals stress [33], showing
evidence of cell irritability, inflammation and hypersensitivity to Cd. The fibrosis is other
liver damage caused by cadmium poisoning in the present work (table 1) and confirmed in a
lot of studies [34]. Although hepatic parenchymal fibrosis is rare, J. C. WOLF & M. J.
WOLFE [35] affirms that is not unusual to observe a scirrhous reaction in the fish liver that is
located around the bile ducts. The fibrogenic effect of oxidative stress induced by Cd [36] is
characterized by excessive connective tissue deposition in extracellular matrix. Lipocytes
(hepatic stellate cells (HSC)) may be the cell type responsible for periductal fibrosis [37]. In a
healthy liver, HSCs are quiescent cells and contain numerous A vitamin lipid droplets,
constituting the largest reservoir of A vitamin in the rats body [38]. When the liver is injured
due to viral infection or any hepatic toxins, HSCs receive signals secreted by damaged
hepatocytes and immune cells, causing them to trans-differentiate from a resting A vitamin-
rich cell into active, proliferating, fibrogenic, and contractile cell leading to hepatic fibrosis.
Garlic, cilantro and chlorella’s effect on liver histoarchitecture changes in Cd-intoxicated Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio)
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016 12067
Oxidative stress represents an imbalance between oxidant and antioxidant agents [39].
Cytoplasmic vacuolation and fatty degeneration associated with lipid accumulation was the
pathological features observed by us in all experimental groups (table 1).
Table 1. List of severity of liver lesions in Prussian carps specimens
Liver lesions
Control group
E1
10 ppm CdCl2
E2
10 ppm CdCl2
+2% garlic
E3
10 ppm CdCl2
+2% cilantro
E4
10 ppm CdCl2
+2% chlorella
Congestive processes - +++ - - -
Lymphocytic infiltrates - - + + -
Fibrosis of hepatic tissue - +++ - - -
Vacuolization - +++ ++ + ++
Necrosis
Pyknotic nucleus - +++ ++ + ++
Karyolysis - +++ ++ + ++
(−) none, (+) mild, (++) moderate, (+++) severe occurrence.
Liver fat accumulation in fish may be due to a various causes such as: greater capacity of wild
or captive fish species to store large amounts of lipid (triglyceride) in their livers compared to
mammals (G. J. ROSSOUW (1987), cited by J. C. WOLF & M. J. WOLFE [35]), overfeeding
of captive fish with an excessively energy-rich diet [40], lipid peroxidation, caused by the
feeding with diets high in polyunsaturated fats coupled with a lack of adaptive peroxisomal
proliferation, the suppression of vitamin [41] or toxicant-induced [42]. In our study, this lipid
vacuolization has led to an increase in the size of hepatocytes. But there are authors who
found that beside the toxicological causes of hepatocites’ hypertrophy there are physiological
ones such can be seen in reproductively active female fish [43] or in male fish which have
been exposed to exogenous estrogenic compounds, due to the ability of estrogens to boost
hepatocyte metabolism for vitellogenin (yolk lipoprotein) production [44]. Vacuolation of
hepatocytes is a cellular defense mechanism against injurious substances and it is associated
with inhibited protein synthesis, energy depletion, disaggregation of microtubules, or shifts in
substrate utilization, as described by E. K. AJANI & B. U. J. AKPOILIH [45]. A. ANNABI
& al. [46] previously noted the cytoplasmic vacuolization with lipid droplets and glycogen
accumulation in the liver tissue of Mosquito fish (Gambusia affinis) tissues following acute
and chronic cadmium exposure as well. Nuclear pyknosis observed in the four experimental
groups (table 1) suggests that the manifestation of apoptotic cell death and karyolysis are
followed by hepatocyte necrosis. This pathologic response of the fish liver to Cd is in
agreement with those of S. A. OMER & al. [47]. The results listed above highlights the
ameliorative effect of garlic, cilantro and chlorella powder on the fish liver histopathological
changes. This could be due to their antioxidant properties in combating the free radical-
induced oxidative stress and liver injury resulting from cadmium chloride exposure. In the
same time, these plants produce chelating compound involved in heavy metal detoxification.
Oxidative stress as a crucial factor in liver diseases, (H. CICHOŻ-LACH & A. MICHALAK
[39]), affecting the major cellular components: proteins, lipids and DNA as a result of
excessive production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) [48] such as superoxide ions,
hydroxyl radicals, and hydrogen peroxide. Protective actions against ROS are performed by
several enzymes (e.g., superoxide dismutase-SOD, catalase and glutathione peroxidase), as
well as no-enzymatic compounds (e.g., tocopherol, E vitamin beta-carotene, ascorbate and
glutathione-GSH) [49] many of them can be found in vegetables and microalgae. Thus,
carotenoids play an important role in quenching reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated
during photosynthesis, especially singled oxygen [50]. Green leafy vegetables are rich in
carotenoids, which have several proven and postulated health benefits. Carotenoids mostly
consumed in general diets are α-carotene, β-carotene, lutein, zeaxanthin, neoxanthin,
violaxanthin, and lycopene. Among these carotenoids, β-carotene is the most important
MARIOARA NICULA, GABI DUMITRESCU, NICOLAE PACALA, LAVINIA ŞTEF, CAMELIA TULCAN, MONICA
DRAGOMIRESCU, DOREL DRONCA, ADRIANA GHERBON, LILIANA PETCULESCU CIOCHINA
12068 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016
provitamin [51]. There are studies showing that carotenoids contribute significantly to the
total antioxidant capacity of microalgae [52]. L. C. WU & al. [53], has demonstrated that
antioxidants from spirulina and chlorella water extracts are able to inhibit the proliferation of
HSCs. A potential treatment for liver fibrosis is to inhibit activated hepatic stellate cell (HSC)
proliferation and, subsequently, to induce HSC apoptosis. The phenolic compounds salicylic,
trans cinnamic, synaptic, chlorogenic, chimic and caffeic acids found in the methanolic
chlorella extract may contribute to its higher antioxidant activity [54]. F. J. KAO & al. [55]
analyzed the total carotenoid content (TCC; i.e., lutein, zeaxanthin and β-carotene) in 25 fresh
vegetables commonly consumed in Taiwan, and found cilantro, Thai basil leaves, sweet
potato leaves, and choy sum contain the highest amount of TCC carotenoid-rich vegetables.
Garlic increases antioxidant action by scavenging reactive oxygen species (ROS), enhancing
the cellular antioxidant enzymes and increasing glutathione in the cells [16]. M. ABDEL-
TAWWAB & al. [56] reported that garlic contains numerous sulphur components, including
the most valuable sulphhydryl groups, which oxidize mercury, cupper, cadmium and lead,
make these metals water-soluble, and facilitate the body excretion of these substances. On the
other hand, chelators have the effect of mobilizing metals from tissues and maintaining the
chelate moiety during circulation to the kidneys for excretion in urine, and to the liver for
excretion in the bile [57]. Not only animals, but also plants produce chelating compounds (R.
PAL and J. P. N. RAI, [58] and metallothionein content of foods may affect bioavailability as
well as metabolism of toxic metals such as cadmium [59]. Thus, chlorella is a mild chelator.
Its detoxification capacity is due to its unique cell wall extremely resistant to breakage and the
material associated with it, sporopollenin (a naturally occurring carotene like polymer, which
is resistant to degradation) [60]. Cilantro is also considered as a natural chelator. In animals, it
decreased lead absorption into bone and inhibition of the delta-aminolevulinic acid
dehydratase (ALAD) enzyme [61]. Garlic is a good source of N-Acetyl-L-Cysteine (NAC).
N-acetyl-cysteine (NAC), contained in garlic is a chelator of toxic elements and may
stimulate glutathione synthesis, and production.
4. Conclusions The current result indicates that Cd contamination definitely affects the liver, inducing
pathological lesions, which can be summarized as follow: cytoplasmic vacuolization, blood
congestions, lymphocytic infiltrates, fibrosis and necrosis. Concomitant treatment with
Cd+cilantro, Cd+garlic and Cd+chlorella powder showed evident recovery and an almost
normal liver architecture with mild residual degeneration. Among the three lyophilized
products, cilantro powder proved to have the most chelating and antioxidant potential (liver
samples showed few lipid droplets and little focal necrotic area), while the response at
chlorella treatment was less effective.
References 1. A. VALAVANIDIS, T. VLACHOGIANNI, Metal Pollution in Ecosystems. Ecotoxicology Studies and Risk Assessment
in the Marine Environment, Science advances on Environment, Toxicology & Ecotoxicology issues, 1-14, (2010),
http://chem-tox-ecotox.org/wp/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/02-Metals-17_01_2010.pdf.
2. PANDEY G., S. MADHURI, Heavy Metals Causing Toxicity in Animals and Fishes, Res. J. Animal, Veterinary and Fishery Sci., 2(2), 17-23, (2014).
3. N. V. SOLENKOVA, J. D. NEWMAN, J. S. BERGER, G. THURSTON, J. S. HOCHMAN, G. A. LAMAS, Metal
pollutants and cardiovascular disease: Mechanisms and consequences of exposure, American Health Journal, 168(6), 812–
822, (2014).
4. L. JARUP, M. BERGLUND, C. G. ELINDER, Health effects of cadmium exposure-a review of the literature and a risk
estimate, Scand. J. Work Environ. Health., 24, 1–51, (1998).
Garlic, cilantro and chlorella’s effect on liver histoarchitecture changes in Cd-intoxicated Prussian carp (Carassius gibelio)
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016 12069
5. S. AFSHAN, S. ALI, U. S. AMEEN, M. FARID, S. AS. BHARWANA, F. H., R. AHMAD, Effect of Different Heavy Metal Pollution on Fish, Res. J. Chem. Env. Sci., 2(1), 74-79, (2014).
6. M. N. V. PRASAD, S. S. KENNETH, N. RAVI, Trace elements in the environment: Biogeochemistry, Biotechnology, and
Bioremediation, CRC Press, 668-669, (2005).
7. J. F. NARBONE, X. MICHEL, Use of biomarkers in the assessment of contamination in marine ecosystems Fundamental approach and application, in: Selected techniques for monitoring biological effects of pollutants in marine organisms,
UNEP/FAO/IOC, MAP Technical Reports, Series no. 71, UNEP, Athens, 1-20, (1993)
http://195.97.36.231/acrobatfiles/MTSAcrobatfiles/mts71.pdf).
8. A. VIARENGO, Heavy metal cytotoxicity in marine organisms, in: Advances in Comparative and Environmental Physiology, Springer Science & Business Media, 20, 88-91, (2012).
9. Q. ZHAI, A. NARBAD, W. CHEN, Dietary Strategies for the Treatment of Cadmium and Lead Toxicity, Nutrients, 7,
553, (2015).
10. K. D. KUSAL, A Comprehensive Review on Nickel (II) And Chromium VI Toxicities-Possible Antioxidant (Allium Sativum Linn) Defenses-review article, Al Ameen J. Med. Sci., 2(2) Special, 43-50, (2009).
11. G. J. GEORGIOU, A natural heavy metal chelator is born. Its use with pediatric cases, British Naturopathic Journal,
24(1), 14-17, (2007).
12. T. UCHIKAWA, Y. KUMAMOTO, I. MARUYAMA, S. KUMAMOTO, Y. ANDO, A. YASUTAKE. The enhanced elimination of tissue methylmercury in Parachlorella beijerinckii-fed mice. Journal of Toxicological Sciences, 36(1), 121–
126, (2011).
13. F. H. ABDALLA, L. P. BELLÉ, K. S. DE BONA, P. E. R. BITENCOURT, A. S. PIGATTO, M. B. MORETTO, Allium
sativum L. extract prevents methyl mercury-induced cytotoxicity in peripheral blood leukocytes (LS) Food and Chemical Toxicology, 48(1), 417–421, (2010).
14. K. DELDAR, E. NAZEMI, M. BALALI MOOD, Effect of Coriandrum sativum L. extract on lead excretion in 3–7 year
old children, Journal of Birjand University of Medical Sciences, 15, 11–19, (2008).
15. S. J. S. FLORA, Structural, chemical and biological aspects of antioxidants for strategies against metal and metalloid exposure, Oxid Med Cell Longev., 2(4), 191–206, (2009).
16. H. ABD EL AZEEM MAY, A. M HASSAN, M. M. HUSSEIN, H. ABD EL WAHED ZAMZAM, R. E SALEH, Some
heavy metal pollutants in fish farms and Effect of garlic on their bioaccumulation in Oreochromas niloticus, SCVMJ, XVII
(1), 57-69 (2012). 17. H. REN, H., H. ENDO, T. HAYASHI, Cadmium detoxification effect of Chinese parsley Coriandrum sativum in liver
and kidney of rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss, Fisheries Science, 75(3) 731-741, (2009).
18. H. REN, H. JIA, S. KIM, M. MAITA, S. SATO, M. YASUI, H. ENDO, T. HAYASHI, Effect of Chinese parsley
Coriandrum sativum and chitosan on inhibiting the accumulation of cadmium in cultured rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss, Fisheries Science, 72(2), 263-269, (2006).
19. C. M. KAEFER, J.A. MILNER, Herbal Medicine: Biomolecular and clinical aspects, 2nd Edition, Chapter 17. Herbs and
Spices in Cancer Prevention and Treatment, Boca Raton (FL), CRC Press, (2011).
20. Y. J. KIM, S. KWON, M. K. KIM, Effect of Chlorella vulgaris intake on cadmium detoxification in rats fed cadmium, Nutr Res Pract., 3(2), 89–94, (2009).
21. A. WORKU, O. SAHU, Reduction of Heavy Metal and Hardness from Ground Water by Algae, Journal of Applied &
Environmental Microbiology, 2(3), 86-89, (2014).
22. B. VEENA, C. K. RADHAKRISHNAN, J. CHACKO, Heavy metal induced biochemical effects in an estuarine teleost,
Indian J. Marine Sci., 26, 74-78, (1997).
23. L. OPREA, R. GEORGESCU, Nutritia si alimentatia pestilor, Ed. Colectia Fundatiei Universitare Dunarea de Jos,
Galati, (2002).
24. K. N. GIBSON-CORLEY, A. K. OLIVIER, D. K. MEYERHOL, Principles for Valid Histopathologic Scoring in Research, Veterinary Pathology, 1-9, (2013).
25. F. A. S. MOHAMED, Histopathological studies on Tilapia zilliand Solea vulgaris from lake Quran, Egypt. World
Journal of Fish and Marine Sciences, 1(1), 29-39, (2009).
26. R. VINODHINI, M. NARAYANAN, Heavy Metal Induced Histopathological Alterations in Selected Organs of the Cyprinus carpio L.(Common Carp), International Journal of Environmental Research, 3(1), 95-100, (2009).
27. A. F. AL-MANSOORI, Histological changes induced by cadmium ion in the Gills, Liver and Intestine of juvenile
Carassius carassius (L.), Basrah Journal of Science (B) 24(1), 32-46, (2006).
28. P. M. TREUTING, S. M. DINTZIS, Comparative Anatomy and Histology: A Mouse and Human Atlas, 198, (2012). 29. C. GOPINATH, V. MOWAT, Atlas of Toxicological Pathology, Springer, 46, (2014).
30. P. BIGONIYA, C. S. SINGH., A. SHUKLA, A Comprehensive Review of Different Liver Toxicants Used in
Experimental Pharmacology, International Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Drug Research; 1(3), 124-135, (2009). 31. H. A. KAOUD., M. M. ZAKI, A. R. EL-DAHSHAN, S. SAEIDAND, H. Y. EL ZORBA, Amelioration the Toxic Effects
of Cadmium-Exposure in Nile Tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) by using Lemna gibba L, Life Science Journal, 8(1), 185-195,
(2011).
32. Z. A. EL-GREISY, A. H. A. EL-GAMAL, Experimental studies on the effect of cadmium chloride, zinc acetate, their mixture and the mitigation with vitamin C supplementation on hatchability, size and quality of newly hatched larvae of
common carp, Cyprinus carpio, The Egyptian Journal of Aquatic Research, 41(2) 219–226, (2015).
33. M. WITESKA, Stress in fish: hematological and immunological effects of heavy metal, Electronic Journal of
Ichthyology, 1, 35-41, (2015).
MARIOARA NICULA, GABI DUMITRESCU, NICOLAE PACALA, LAVINIA ŞTEF, CAMELIA TULCAN, MONICA
DRAGOMIRESCU, DOREL DRONCA, ADRIANA GHERBON, LILIANA PETCULESCU CIOCHINA
12070 Romanian Biotechnological Letters, Vol. 22, No. 6, 2016
34. R. A. BABU, Effects of Cadmium on Digestive Organs of Teleost Fish Ophiocephalus (Channa), Universal Journal of
Environmental Research and Technology, 3(2), 173-180, (2013).
35. J. C. WOLF, M. J. WOLFE, A Brief Overview of Nonneoplastic Hepatic Toxicity in Fish, Toxicologic Pathology, 33(1)
75-85, (2005). 36. H. BABA, K. TSUNEYAMA, M.YAZAKI, K. NAGATA, TA. MINAMISAKA, T. TSUDA, K. NOMOTO,
S.HAYASHI, S.MIWA, T. NAKAJIMA, Y. NAKANISHI, K. AOSHIMA, J. IMURA, The liver in itai-itai disease (chronic
cadmium poisoning): pathological features and metallothionein expression, Modern Pathology, 26, 1228–1234), (2013).
37. S. BARONI, G. L. D'AMBROSIO, G. FERRETTI, A. CASINI, A. DI SRIO, Fibrogenic effect of oxidative stress on rat hepatic stellate cells, Hepatology, 27, 720-726, (1998).
38. M. PANDE, S. FLORA, Lead induced oxidative damage and its response to combined administration of lipoic acid and
succimers in rats, Toxicology, 177, 187-96, (2002).
39. H. CICHOŻ-LACH, A. MICHALAK, Oxidative stress as a crucial factor in liver diseases, World J Gastroenterol., 20(25), 8082–8091, (2014)
40. M. L. PENRITH, S. S. BASTIANELLO, M. J. PENRITH, Hepatic lipidosis and fatty infiltration of organs in captive
African stonefish, Synanceja verrucosa Bloch & Schneider, J Fish Dis 17,171–6, (1994).
41. E. SPISNI , M. TUGNOLI, A. PONTICELLI, T. MORDENTI, V. TOMASI, Hepatic steatosis in artificially fed marine teleosts, J Fish Dis., 21(3), 177-84, (1998).
42. R.T. DIGIULIO, C. HABIG, E. P. GALLAGHER, Effects of black rock harbor sediments on indexes of
biotransformation, oxidative stress, and DNA integrity in channel catfish, Aquatic toxicology, 26(1-2) 1-22, (1993).
43. P. CHAKRABARTI, N. CHATTERJEE, Seasonal changes in the architecture of hepatocytes in relation to ovarian activities during growth, maturation, spawning and post-spawning phases in Mystus vittatus (Bloch,1790), Journal of
Entomology and Zoology study, 2(4), 212-217, (2014).
44. P.W. WESTER., L. T. M VAN DER VEN, E. J. BRANDHOF, J. H. VOS, Identification of endocrine disruptive effects
in the aquatic environment: a partial life cycle assay in zebra fish, RIVM Report 6409200001/2003, 31–9, (2003). 45. E. K. AJANI, B. U. J. AKPOILIH, Effect of chronic dietary copper exposure on hematology and histology of common
carp (Cyprinus carpio), J. appl. Sci. Environ. Manage., 14(4), 39-45, (2010).
46. A. ANNABI, I. MESSAOUDI, A. KERKENI, K. SAID, Cadmium Accumulation and Histological Lesion in Mosquitofish (Gambusia affinis) tissues Following Acute and Chronic Exposure, Int. J. Environ. Res., 5(7), 745-756, (2011).
47. S. A. OMER, M. A. ELOBEID, D. FOUAD, M. H. DAGHESTANI, E. M. AL-OLAYAN, M. H. ELAMIN, P. VIRK, A.
EL-MAHASSNA, Cadmium Bioaccumulation and Toxicity in Tilapia Fish (Oreochromis niloticus), Journal of Animal and
Veterinary Advances, 11(10),1601-1606, (2012). 48. Z. HAOUAS, A. SALLEM I. ZIDI, H. HICHRI, I. MZALI, M. MEHDI, Hepatotoxic Effects of lead acetate in rats:
histopathological and cytotoxic studies, J Cytol Histol, 5(5), 1-6, (2014).
49. G. MAO, G. A. KRAUS, I. KIM, M. E. SPURLOCK, T. B. BAILEY, D. C. BEITZ, Effect of a mitochondria-targeted
vitamin E derivative on mitochondrial alteration and systemic oxidative stress in mice, Br J Nutr., 106, 87–95, (2011) [PubMed].
50. F. RAMEL, A. S. MIALOUNDAMA, M. HAVAUX, Nonenzymic carotenoid oxidation and photooxidative stress
signalling in plants, Journal of Experimental Botany, doi:10.1093/jxb/ers223, (2012).
51. F. J. KAO, Y. S. CHIU, W. D. CHIANG, Effect of water cooking on antioxidant capacity of carotenoid-rich vegetables in
Taiwan, Journal of Food and Drug Analysis, 22(2), 202–209, (2014).
52. K. GOIRIS, K. MUYLAERT I. FRAEYE, I. FOUBERT, J. DE BRABANTER, L. DE COOMAN, Antioxidant potential
of microalgae in relation to their phenolic and carotenoid content, J Appl Phycol, DOI 10.1007/s10811-012-9804-6, (2012).
53. L. C. WU, J. A. HO, M. C. SHIEH, I. W. LU, Antioxidant and antiproliferative activities of Spirulina and Chlorella water extracts, J Agric Food Chem., 53(10), 4207-12, (2005).
54. M. S. MIRANDA, S. SATO, J. MANCINI-FILHO, Antioxidant activity of the microalga Chlorella vulgaris cultered on
special conditions., Boll Chim Farm., 140(3), 165-8, (2001).
55. F. J. KAO, Y. S. CHIU, M. J. TSOU, Effects of Chinese domestic cooking methods on the carotenoid composition of vegetables in Taiwan, LWT-Food Sci Technol, 46, 485–492, (2012).
56. M. ABDEL-TAWWAB, M. A. A. MOUSA, F. E ABBASS, Growth performance and physiological response of African
catfish, Clarias gariepinus (B.) fed organic selenium prior to the exposure to environmental copper toxicity, Aquaculture,
272(1-4), 335-345, (2007). 57. P. K. ROONEY, The role of thiols, dithiols, nutritional factors and interacting ligands in the toxicology of mercury,
Toxicology, 234(3), 145–156, (2007).
58. R. PAL, J. P. N. RAI, Phytochelatins: peptides involved in heavy metal detoxification, Applied Biochemistry and
Biotechnology, 160(3), 945–963, (2010). 59. S. O. ASAGBA, Role of diet in absorption and toxicity of oral cadmium—a review of literature, African Journal of
Biotechnology, 8(25), (2009).
60. A. W. ATKINSON JR, B. E. GUNNING, P. C. JOHN, Saporopollenin in the cell wall of Chlorella and other algae:
Ultrastructure, chemistry, and incorporation of (14)C-acetate, studied in synchronous cultures, Planta, 107(1), 1-32. doi: 10.1007/BF00398011, (1972).
61. M. AGA, K. IWAKI, Y. UEDA, Preventive effect of Coriandrum sativum (Chinese parsley) on localized lead deposition
in ICR mice, Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 77(2-3), 203–208, (2001).