Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
1
Elements of Effective Board Policy
2017 PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference
What Do I Know About Policy?
A. I’m a new board member or administrator, I barely know what policy is
B. I’m familiar with what policy is and how to look it up
C. I’m a policy veteran – I research, revise and implement policy
Pennsylvania School Boards Association
Principles for Effective School Governance
➢Advocate Earnestly
➢Lead Responsibly
➢Govern Effectively
➢Plan Thoughtfully
➢Evaluate Continuously
➢Communicate Clearly
➢Act Ethically
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
2
School Board’s Role in Policy Making
• Policymaking (Legislative) Function – one of the most important responsibilities of an elected school board
• Ethical and Legal Duty – from which all actions of the school entity should be derived
• PA School Code – 407 and 510 grant school boards authority to adopt and enforce “reasonable rules and regulations” for the operation of the school entity
Governing Through Policy
• Policy is a clear statement that sets forth the purposes and prescribes, in general terms, the organization and programs of a school system
• Policy creates a framework within which the Superintendent and staff can discharge assigned duties with positive direction
• Policy is a course of action
Elements of PolicyPurpose – why is this important to the district?
Authority – the board adopts, directs, authorizes… (often tied to law)
Definition – is there a relevant legal definition or should a term be defined for consistent interpretation?
Delegation of Responsibility – who is ultimately responsible?
Guidelines – necessary general guidelines, not detailed procedures
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
3
Board policy = WHAT
• What is required by state and federal laws, regulations and court decisions?
• What is necessary for legal liability?
• What is the directive of the board?
Policy is –
•Related to a general topic
•Broad statement guidingadministrative actions
•Applicable over time
•Communicated to all stakeholders
•Equivalent to law
The Seven C’s of Policy
1. Codification
2. Clarification
3. Consistency
4. Currency
5. Communication
6. Continuity
7. Compliance
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
4
An effective school board governs through policy by:
• Seeking input from stakeholders and following an established procedure for consideration
• Regularly reviewing and, as necessary, revising and adopting board policy
• Delegating to the Superintendent responsibility for implementation of board policy
• Ensuring public access to adopted board policy• Purposefully linking its actions to applicable board
policies
Policy and Administrative Regulations
• Establishing compliant policy that clearly communicates the district’s vision is only the first step
• Consistent and effective implementation of those policies is the key to compliance and success
Administrative Regulations
The mechanics and details needed for administrators and staff to implement a policy
Procedures FormsSpecific
Responsibilities
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
5
An administrative regulation is –
• Tool to implement policy
• Precise statement with specific details
• Related to a specific issue
• Directive for staff actions
• Communicated mainly to employees
• Subject to administrative changes without board approval
Administrative regulations may include:
• Building-wide procedures• Charts• Forms• Timelines• Dollar amounts• Step-by-step process
Administrative regulations =
How it happens
How are the goals of the policy going to be achieved?
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
6
Administrative Regulation Development Tips:
• Involve relevant staff in development process
• Review applicable policy
• Ensure compliance with other resources
• Effectively communicate to employees
• Add an approval date
• Make available for board review
Identify Need/Gather Information
Policy Adoption Process
Policy Implementation
(ARs)
Data and Feedback
Evaluation
Common Elements
• Comply with state and federal laws, regulations, court decisions, collective bargaining agreements, compensation plans
• Consistent when addressing the same issue
• Superintendent is involved with process
• Communication tool
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
7
Policy vs. Administrative Regulations
Policy Administrative RegulationGeneral Topic Specific Topic
Broad statement allowing discretion
Precise statement with detail
Applicable over time Could change frequently
Communicated as a public document
Communicated mainly to staff
Equivalent to law Directives for staff actions
WHAT HOW
Pop Quiz
Where would this language be found?
The Board shall adopt a Student Code of Conduct to govern student discipline, which shall be distributed to
staff, students and parents/guardians.
Pop Quiz
Where would this language be found?
Field Trip Chaperones
10 elementary students – 1 chaperone
15 secondary students – 1 chaperone
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
8
Pop Quiz
Where would this language be found?
The Reconsideration of Resource Materials Committee will include the building principal, head librarian, one department head and two subject area teachers.
The committee will meet once a month in the high school library.
Pop Quiz
Where would this language be found?
In accordance with state law, the Superintendent shall annually, by July 31, report all incidents of possession, use or sale of tobacco by students to the Office for Safe Schools on the required form.
Why Do We Review and Revise Policy?
• Changes in law, regulations, court decisions, state and federal guidance
• Audit findings
• New or revised school procedures and processes
• Identified need to address specific situations
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
9
How Do I Develop and Revise Policy?
• Review existing policies in light of changes in law, regulations, court decisions and district processes
• Identify areas where new policies may be needed
• Review resources such as PSBA’s Policy News Network service, school solicitor, PDE guidance to identify needs for new or revised policy
• Look at model policy guides or samples from other school entities
• Collaborate with board policy committee, administrators and other community stakeholders
Examples of policies requiring review and revision thisyear . . .
• Attendance – School Code changes
• Immunization and Communicable Diseases – state regulation updates
• School Wellness – federal regulation changes
• Food Services – federal regulation changes
• Nondiscrimination/Harassment – case law and Office for CivilRights
Policy Review and Approval ProcessPSBA Policy Services Resources -
• Policy News Network (PNN)• Newsletter – discusses policy issues, provides additional
resources and information• PSBA Policy Guides
• Policy News Network+ (PNN+)• Newsletter – discusses policy and administrative regulation
issues, provides additional resources and information• PSBA Policy Guides and correlating Administrative Regulations
• Sample Policy Research Assistance
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
10
Reviewing a Policy
• Compare existing policy language to new recommended updates based on changes in law/regulations, court decisions or district practices
• Determine what elements need to be revised—• Should definitions be added? • Should Delegation of Responsibility be changed? • What new guidelines are required?• Should the entire policy be redrafted?
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
11
Reviewing a Policy• Administration should make district-specific revisions and
suggestions for optional language
• Review with school solicitor especially when:• There is current or past district litigation in that area that
may affect the district’s determinations• The subject is unsettled in the law or courts• The subject is controversial in the community• The board is considering language that goes beyond the
scope of the law
Reviewing a Policy
• Review with Policy Committee – recommended practice• Provide drafts ahead of time • Seek consensus on recommendations
• Present to full board for first reading
• Provide time and method for public review and comment
• Present to full board for second reading and approvalReview Policy 003 for process and type of vote (majority)
Benefits of a Policy Committee
• Focused group of board members with expertise or interest
• Specific time allotted for policy development/review
• Sounding board for administration on policy issues
• Facilitates movement through the policy process
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
12
What other documents impact policy?
• Student/Parent Handbooks
• Collective bargaining agreements and compensation plans
• Employee handbooks
• Budget and financial documents
• Grants/Funding requirements
• Board resolutions
• Comprehensive Plan
Don’t forget to review these when revising policy
Recommendations for Reviewing Policy
• Establish policy review schedule(on average, policies reviewed every 3 years—be aware of legal requirements such as Bullying and Wellness policies)
• Ensure flexibility for revisions made based on changes in law, court decisions, or operations
• Policies that interact should be reviewed during same timeframe (i.e., discrimination/harassment, personal leave/FMLA, electronic devices/Internet acceptable use)
• Correlate with timelines for other documents (updating handbooks, bargaining agreement changes)
Communicating Policy
• Adopted policy should be readily available and searchable to parents and the community
• Handbooks should reference adopted policy
• Be aware of online posting requirements
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
13
What Do I Know About Policy?
A. I barely know what policy is
B. I’m familiar with what policy is and how to look it up
C. I’m a policy veteran – I can research, revise and implement policy
Questions and Discussion
What works in your school entity?
Elements of Effective Board Policy PASA-PSBA School Leadership Conference 2017
14
Contact Information
Heather Masshardt
Policy Services Manager
Pennsylvania School Boards Association
800-932-0588 ext. 3401