Demystifying “The Barbell Effect”:Financial Aid and the Middle Class
Mark J. Mitchell, VP School Information ServicesMark J. Mitchell, VP School Information ServicesMay, 2006May, 2006
CAIS/NYSAIS Business Affairs ConferenceCAIS/NYSAIS Business Affairs ConferenceMohonk Mountain HouseMohonk Mountain House
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
The American Middle Class
“There are three social classes in America: upper middle class, middle class, and lower middle class.”
-- Judith Martin, (Miss Manners)
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
The Barbell Effect Defined…The Barbell Effect Defined…
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Demystifying the Barbell Step 1: Defining Middle Class Who comprises the middle class?
– “What is the income of the ‘middle class’?”
The Census Bureau does not have an official definition of "middle class." We do, however, derive several measures related to the distribution of income and income inequality.”
– From the Census Bureau website, Frequently Asked Questions on Income
– EVERYBODY
Why do affluent people think they’re not affluent?
American phenomenon: “Looking Up” (see 4/3/06 New Yorker article, “Relatively Deprived” by John Cassidy)
The Independent School Middle Class?– Varies by school profile and locale– Starts as low as at $65,000 and goes as high as $200,000– Is this really “the middle”?
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Can the Middle Class Get Aid?Assumptions: using SSS 2005-06 methodology Family of four, two parents, two
children, parents age 45, both work, no assets - parent or student, NY state/other taxes,
Tuition+--Day Schools Full Aid Eligible* No Aid Eligibility**
No COLA COLA (NYC)
$19,931 $133,620 $309,140
$21,050 $ 0 - $52,785 $137,620 $319,560
$21,625 $139,675 $324,910+NYSAIS members, 2005-06 medians
*Families below this income qualify for FULL financial aid**Families above this income qualify for NO financial aid
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Can the Middle Class Get Aid?Assumptions: using SSS 2005-06 methodology Family of four, two parents, two
children, parents age 45, both work, no assets - parent or student, NY state/other taxes,
Tuition+--Bdg Schools Full Aid Eligible* No Aid Eligibility**
No COLA COLA (NYC)
$29,949 $165,115 $387,460
$31,908 $172,480 $405,260
+NYSAIS members, 2005-06 medians*Families below this income qualify for FULL financial aid**Families above this income qualify for NO financial aid
$ 0 - $42,015
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
How Many Families Make That Much?“No Need” PC at $21,625 tuition = $140,000
USA New York City Metro
Westchester County
New York State
$0 - $50K 46.2 48.8 27.8 44.0
$50 - $75K 21.3 16.9 15.2 19.4
$75 - $100K 13.5 11.6 14.9 13.5
$100 - $150K 12.0 12.4 17.3 13.6
$150K+ 7.2 10.2 24.8 9.4
Median Income $53,692 $51,150 $89,249 $56,556
Source: 2004 American Community Survey, www.census.gov
% distribution by income range, selected locales
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Can the Middle Class Get Aid?Assumptions: using SSS 2005-06 methodology Family of four, two parents, two
children, parents age 45, both work, no assets - parent or student, CT state/other taxes,
Tuition+--Day Schools Full Aid Eligible* No Aid Eligibility**
No COLA COLA (1.2)
$16,500 $119,360 $144,,008
$20,835 $0 - $51,572 $134,592 $163,250
$24,693 $148,430$180,360 +CAIS members, 2005-06 medians
*Families below this income qualify for FULL financial aid**Families above this income qualify for NO financial aid
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Can the Middle Class Get Aid?Assumptions: using SSS 2005-06 methodology Family of four, two parents, two
children, parents age 45, both work, no assets - parent or student, CT state/other taxes,
Tuition+--Bdg Schools Full Aid Eligible* No Aid Eligibility**
No COLA COLA (1.2)
$32,250 $171,120 $207,775
$35,444 $182,558 $223,130
+CAIS members, 2005-06 medians*Families below this income qualify for FULL financial aid**Families above this income qualify for NO financial aid
$0 - $41,370
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
How Many Families Make That Much?“No Need” PC at $24,693 tuition = $148,430
USA HartfordMetro
Fairfield County
Connecticut
$0 - $50K 46.2 33.6 24.5 31.4
$50 - $75K 21.3 18.5 17.3 19.6
$75 - $100K 13.5 17.6 15.1 16.9
$100 - $150K 12.0 19.7 18.5 18.7
$150K+ 7.2 10.6 24.6 13.4
Median Income $53,692 $71,997 $87,434 $73,458
Source: 2004 American Community Survey, www.census.gov
% distribution by income range, selected locales
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Who Applies for Financial Aid?
USA SSS Filers
$0 - $50K 46.2 36.9
$50 - $75K 21.3 21.9
$75 - $100K 13.5 16.7
$100 - $150K 12.0 16.4
$150K+ 7.2 8.0
Median Income
$53,692 ~ $57,500
Sources: 2004 American Community Survey, www.census.gov,SSS applicant data, 2004-05 processing year, NAIS
% distribution by income range, SSS filers 2004-05
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
2004
Lowest 5th <$24,780
Second 5th $24,781 - $43,399
Third 5th $43,400 - $65,827
Fourth 5th $65,828 - $99,999
Highest 5th >$100,000
So, What is Middle Income? SSS full need families stop at ~ $53K in day schools—THIS IS the middle income family; and they can benefit well with fin aid
Top 5% of family income begins around $173K
– Many of these would qualify for aid at high-cost schools with more than one child enrolled, especially if COLA factors are used
Should a need-based aid program do more? Should it consider “relative” poorness?
Source: US Census Bureau, 2005 Current Population Survey, http://pubdb3.census.gov/macro/032005/faminc/new06_000.htm
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Who Attends Independent Schools?
% of Current Families
$0 - $50K 5.9
$50-100K 17.8
$100-150K 21
$150-200K 13.8
$200-250K 11.0
$250-300K 6.1
>$300K 24.4
Sources: 2003 NAIS Parent Survey
% distribution by income range
44.7% of current families earn less than $150K
18.9% earn over $350K
“Emotional” middle class is well represented
“Statistical” middle class is underrepresented
Financial model requires preponderance of high-income families (i.e., tuition- and giving-dependent income streams)
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
At NY and CT independent schools, families stop qualifying for financial aid once income reaches around $140K-$180K
Middle income squeeze implicated ($95K-$180K) and many are led to believe that these people aren’t enrolling
– Do you know for sure that this is “middle class”?
– Do you know for sure that they aren’t enrolling?
Families in the true middle-income band ($43K-$65K) are served well through need-based financial aid guidelines
– But they represent a declining proportion of aid applicants
– This is NOT the middle-income group that schools are expressing concern about, even though underrepresented and underfunded
Demystifying the Barbell Step 2:Reality Check
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Income and need-based aid realities– About 91% of families in NY and about 87% in CT earn less than
$150K and would qualify for some financial aid at a $25K school– NYSAIS schools provide financial aid to 18.4% of enrolled students– CAIS schools provide financial aid to 20.8%
How can a barbell exist if only one-fifth receive aid?
What proportion of the full-pay families at the school fits the “middle income” range that you think is squeezed out?
Do you need to extend more aid for greater economic diversity? To which families?– Shift concern to serving the “real” middle class for truer
socioeconomic diversity– Or is serving the ‘emotional’ middle class a budget-building
agenda matter? Other motivation?
Reality Check (cont’d)
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Demystifying the Barbell Step 3:Contextualize the ConversationExplore the psychology of socioeconomics in the school and its impact on
experience and learning
Challenge the perceptions– “The only people who can easily pay tuition are those with high financial
aid or high income.” – “No one in the middle is enrolling.”– “The middle class can’t afford our school.”
Put data in context: Typical NY or CT school has 80-85% full-pay students– Too many full-pays to presume equal weights on both ends of
the bar– Not all full-paying students are millionaires– Not all aid recipients have high need/low income– Disabuse the notion that high-need families are doing it easily
Study and define the problem very specifically…not a ‘one size fits all’ solution for schools
– Do you really have a middle-income problem? Is it statistical or emotional? – If so, find solutions that do not siphon limited resources from those who
show greatest need?
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Conversation in Context: Three Examples
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Example 1: DC Area School
Financial Aid Awards and Family Income (2005 - 2006)
$0
$5,000
$10,000
$15,000
$20,000
$25,000
$30,000
$0 $20,000 $40,000 $60,000 $80,000 $100,000 $120,000 $140,000 $160,000 $180,000 $200,000
Family Income ($)
Fin
an
cia
l A
id A
wa
rds
($
)
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Number of Sample’s Financial Aid Grants awarded within each income quintile (2005 – 2006 academic year)
Source: US Census Bureau
National
Quintile
Family Income Range ($)
Number of Grants Awarded
Average Grant ($)
Lowest 0 - 24,780 5 22,898
Second 24,781 – 43,399 5 21,125
Third 43,400 – 65,827 21 16,817
Fourth 65,828 – 99,999 31 16,829
Fifth > 100,000 41 11,899
Example 1: Where’s The Barbell? What’s the “Real” Issue?
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
Addressing Middle Income Issues: Two Paths
Albuquerque Academy (New Mexico)– Board challenge to increase middle income enrollment through financial aid
and tuition discounts– Used survey to examine if there was a “barbell effect” and found there was
none– No need to change policy or commitment of aid dollars to wealthier families
St. Mark’s School (Texas)– Donor approached school to provide grants to middle income families– School research yielding a defined “middle-income” target for its population– Implemented policy of reducing SSS results of contributions for families in
the target range and offered aid from the donor-supported fund to meet the increased financial need
Study and define the problem very specifically…not a ‘one size fits all’ solution for schools
– Do you really have a middle income problem? Can you solve it without siphoning already limited resources from those who show greatest need?
Copyright National Association of Independent Schools 2006
NAIS Resources
School and Student Service for Financial Aid (SSS)– Need analysis, training workshops and consultation
on policymaking, Comp*Assist software
StatsOnline, other statistical resources– National, local/regional association– Trend analyses and environmental scanning
Financing Schools Institute– July 6 – 9, Bolger Center (Potomac, MD)
Financing Sustainable Schools book– Available at www.nais.org ($25 members, $38
nonmembers)