Download - Dartmouth Park
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
1
1. Introduction 1.1. This report has been commissioned by Mr. Leslie Moore, City Parks Superintendent,
Dublin City Council. Its purpose is to research the sequence of development, determine its
historical significance, comment on its current condition and make recommendations for
the future management of Dartmouth Square as a historical city park.
1.2. The report is based on site visits carried out during December 2012, February, March
and April 2013; appraisal of the historical Ordnance Survey maps (Map Library TCD); site
maps provided by DCC Parks Service; archive searches, discovered records and
comparative researches; conversations with DCC Parks staff and two retired parks staff
who were all very helpful with their information. Drawing upon discovered information
and appraisals of the park and its features, the report makes recommendations whether
these should be retained or whether their sites could or should be better utilised to develop
new ornamental or practical features as part of a general upgrading of the park.
1.3. I thank chairperson Carmen Neary, Peter O’Brien and other residents for their
information, views and memories, gleaned in conversations and interviews.
1.4. Dartmouth Square Park, as a well-loved place at the heart of the local community has
many opportunities and few threats. Its recent ownership struggles have been overcome so
now, through partnership with the local community and united in determination for it to
survive, a very precious part of Ranelagh’s historical heritage can be given its chance to
thrive and blossom again.
‘OBEDIENTIA CIVIUM URBIS FELICITAS’
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
2
2. Guiding Principles 2.1. The various international charters of ICOMOS and in particular the Florence Charter
for the protection of historic parks and gardens provides guidelines for carrying out
appropriate conservation, restoration and re-instatement works; these works must be
compatible with the historic ambience of the site and be based on long experience and best
practice for historic sites worldwide.
2.2. It is recommended that all future works are based either on the layout depicted on the
OS map of 1909 which shows the original design with great clarity, or the 1987/88
landscape scheme which, despite the vicissitudes of recent years, has managed to survive
remarkably well. The recommendations for actions contained in this report should be
referenced when considering works or new planting schemes, during implementation of
any future works or on-going maintenance. This is to protect the historical ambience of
Dartmouth Square Park, the core of the Architectural Conservation Area.
General view across park towards the south-east.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
3
3. Report Summary 3.1. Dartmouth Square Park is a significant historical park dating from the late
Victorian/early Edwardian period. It is located in and bounded by Dartmouth Square
North, Dartmouth Square South, Dartmouth Square East and Dartmouth Square West,
Ranelagh. It lies midway between Upper Leeson St. and Ranelagh Road. Because of its
secluded location immediately south of the Grand Canal south bank but with no direct
access from Grand Parade road it is not a widely well-known square. To passers-by and
passing traffic short-cutting from Leeson Street to Ranelagh Road it seems to be a private
space solely for the residents of Dartmouth Square, though it is actually a public park.
3.2. Its boundary is still defined by its original wrought iron railings and gates and is the
focal point of an Architectural Conservation Area comprising several terraces of houses of
contemporary date surrounding it. Its built features and veteran trees are part of a
significant historical urban designed urban landscape and most worthy of continued
conservation. It has undergone a number of changes of use over its lifetime but despite that
has managed to retain a very pleasant ambience because of its setting in a quiet leafy
suburb among beautiful houses. The mature trees, wide pleasant paths, well-placed seats,
open grassed areas and views across it all contribute to its high amenity value.
3.3. Greatly used by strollers, dog owners and guide dog trainers, joggers, child minders,
‘tai chi’ and yoga practitioners, or those purely seeking a calm pleasant space, it is not
subject to any wanton ‘wear and tear’, very much litter or vandalism and therefore retains
its genteel Victorian ambience. This is a remarkable achievement through the combined
efforts of the residents and DCC staff.
3.4. With little cost much can be achieved to bring Dartmouth Square Park to a higher
level of awareness and enjoyment. It still has its original bones; that is the handsome
wrought iron railings and granite plinth walls and its four wrought iron gate entrances, its
veteran trees and its ambient setting amongst surrounding terraces. Its pergola, and paths
need a good smartening up, the grassed areas are fine but could be better, the cherry laurel
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
4
should be removed to open up the central areas to better view from the paths. The
shrubbery borders need re-vitalisation and much re-planting is needed though this should
not cause obstruction of open views or too dense a vegetation canopy.
3.5. Activities such as poetry, book readings (perhaps from the writings of Lafcadio
Hearn), classical music recitals should be encouraged. More seats should be provided to
encourage more people to enjoy its peaceful atmosphere. Passive recreations such as yoga,
tai chi, grass chess and bowls should be encouraged and facilitated, provided no permanent
fixtures are required or any ‘right’ is claimed that would affect other users.
3.6. The park, though simple is elegant in design and has a number of significant features
which taken as a whole gives it its distinctive character. Its original wrought iron railings
bedded in a low granite plinth wall and its wrought iron gates with their box piers are
beautiful. The dominant built feature is the pergola and its walkway, though its associated
flower beds are gone. The trees that enclose and frame the space are a huge asset to the
park environment. The perimeter shrubbery, and its trees and shrubs, that separate the
streetscape from the park landscape form a significant part of the park’s attraction for
visitors and wildlife. The path system is wide, spacious and easy underfoot, its edges
formed with fire-clay tiles in a ‘rope top’ pattern. The seats encourage people to linger and
enjoy the tranquility and views across the greenery. What better place to be than here.
3.7. Locals who enjoy the park’s amenities and whose properties benefit from its
environment could be asked to contribute to a ‘heritage’ fund for revitalisation works.
3.8. Archaeology could be undertaken to explore the water courses and the contents of the
old dumping ground (during the 1987/88 landscaping some contents were unearthed) and
would be fascinating for visitors. The information and documentation generated from these
works would form part of a historical archive for Dartmouth Park.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
5
Gate entrance sign.
Glimpse of terrace.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
6
4. General Description and History 4.1. Dartmouth Square Park is on a 2 acre (0.8 hectare) rectangular site which was
originally part of the Darley Estate, and developed as a central feature of Dartmouth
Square. The Square was the last one of a series of squares laid out and built in the late 19th
and early 20th centuries in Dublin as speculative developments. Comprising two-storey
over basement terraced red-brick houses, the terraces are protected structures and the entire
area is an Architectural Conservation Area. Its architectural history and development are
well documented in Dartmouth Square and Environs Architectural Conservation Area
((ACA) (Adopted Variation No. 23 ACA Dartmouth Sq.) and available on the web.
4.2. “According to the minutes of the Rathmines Urban District Council for 1896 the
owner of the land, a Mr Darley, ‘offered the council a small piece of land as a scavenging
station (dump)’ Some years must have elapsed between the laying out of the square and
the building of the houses, and this lapse of time suggests that the dump was used to raise
the level of the low-lying ground.” Extract from DARTMOUTH SQUARE AND ENVIRONS
Architectural Conservation Area (ACA) (Adopted Variation No. 23. ACA Dartmouth Sq.).
4.3. The ground area of Dartmouth Square and its park is still low-lying in relation to the
nearby Grand Canal. The canal (construction began 1756) is on significantly higher ground
level due to the fact that the canal route was raised and embanked wherever necessary to
provide a straight and evenly levelled ground for water flow. All the surrounding ground
levels along its route were corrected to facilitate the even flow between the locks, with
each lock dropping eastwards until it reached Ringsend and sea level. This is also evident
along other stretches of the canal, for example, near Robert Emmet Bridge, Harold’s Cross
where the old ground level is considerably lower. So the ‘low-lying ground’ mentioned in
the 1896 minutes of Rathmines UDC more likely resulted from the levelling carried out by
canal engineers. Mr Darley’s piece of low-lying wet land perhaps was a left-over of that
project and then used as a dumping ground.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
7
4.4. The park was developed as part of the development of the terraces surrounding it and
intended for the sole use of residents who had keys to it. Within a short number of years of
its creation it was probably already a financial burden on residents for its up-keep. Prior to
when Dublin Corporation took over the park in the late 1980’s it had been leased and used
by Loreto Hockey Club since it was founded in 1926 by Mother Bernadette IBVM and
Una Murray for the past pupils of all Loreto schools.
4.5. It was first leased to Loreto Hockey Club in 1926 as a hockey pitch for past pupils
only and then later for current pupils of Loreto College, St. Stephens Green. Hockey
continued to be played until the 1950’s when it became increasingly a burden to keep and
maintain. In the 1930’s Loreto Past Pupils Hockey Club moved to Cherryfield in
Templeogue for about a decade and subsequently to grounds behind the present
Ballyboden St. Enda’s GAA Club. When all hockey finally ceased there in the 1950’s the
park began years of slow but sure deterioration. The central cross-path had already gone,
probably to facilitate the dimensions of the hockey pitch, and gone before the OS map of
1936 was published because this edition does not record it.
4.6. For many years afterwards the park became increasingly overgrown with scrub and
volunteer saplings, the shrubbery more unkempt, the place slipping into a semi-derelict
state. Although still private and for the sole use of residents, it had become a non-descript
piece of land being used by ‘gentlemen occasionally kicking football about and urinating’.
Its future became too problematic, the cost of cleaning up and keeping it in good order too
prohibitive so things had to change and the residents decided to act to save it.
4.7. In 1987 The Residents Association approached the Lord Mayor, Mrs Carmencita
Hederman (Lord Mayor 1987-1988), and thanks to her intervention, this led to the City
Manager, Mr Frank Feely, and his office becoming involved with the local community in
solving the problem that Dartmouth Square Park had become.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
8
4.8. After discussions and meetings, imaginative new plans were devised by Dublin
Corporation Parks Dept., and the Survey and Drawing Dept. produced a bound
presentation of drawings and plans for consideration by all concerned. With the blessing of
the Lord Mayor who was the driving force behind the initiative, the City Manager, Dublin
Corporation and residents agreed the plans and it was decided it would be a Dublin
Millenium Year project, one of many in 1988 and a most successful one.
Drawing of gate entrance from 1987//88 landscaping scheme. Courtesy DCC.
4.9. Meanwhile Dublin Corporation (as it was then) tried to take out a lease from the
Darley Estate to allow its Parks staff to start clean up works with the intent to open it as a
public park. The title was imperfect and the lease never finalised so under the Derelict
Sites Act the City Manager and Corporation decided to commence the clean-up anyway.
4.10. The Parks staff set about cleaning out scrub and the heavily overgrown shrubbery
borders and preparing the soil for planting. Then the new designs and planting schemes
were implemented. The new shrubs were planted in groups, in a modern planting style, to
refill the shrubbery borders; many of these were robust evergreen species that would
tolerate the wear and tear of public use. A broad cherry laurel hedge, modelled on the
‘laurel lawn’ in Palmerston Park, was planted around the grass edges to separate the path
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
9
system from the grassed areas. An impressive new pergola was erected, its pillars planted
with climbers and associated flower beds also planted. The paths were realigned, widened
and edged with fireclay tiles in rope effect pattern. The pergola was the architectural centre
piece, its pillars modelled on the granite and brick detailing of the adjoining house
terraces. The flower beds around it were filled with low perennials and climbing roses,
wisteria and honeysuckle planted onto its pillars.
The new Landscape Plan of 1987/88. Courtesy DCC.
The Landscape Plan with vignettes. Courtesy DCC.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
10
4.11. Because the old path system had long gone a new wider path system was installed in
a strictly formal layout and aligned with the old gate entrances. The cruciform path in the
central grass area was not re-instated; instead two sets of circular beds were installed, each
segmented into four curved strips of greenery/hedging with a tree in the each centre, one of
which still survives, though it is poorly. Two areas of grass were made, one at either end of
the east side and the west side. At the east end the new path accommodated an old weeping
ash (Fraxinus excelsior ‘Pendula’) that had survived the years of dereliction. This was
done by creating a hexagonal shaped edge around its trunk and main root zone.
4.12. All of these works were designed to restore the park to a formal Victorian layout like
other historical city parks and squares. The landscaping scheme was a striking
improvement on the condition of the park left fallow after decades of hockey playing when
mowing was the priority task of any maintenance regime. The re-vitalised park became a
much used local amenity for the residents and entire local community. For the next 18
years the park was enjoyed and well looked after. When the lease expired inconclusive
talks took place between DCC and the Darley Estate but meanwhile Dublin City Council
Parks staff continued to manage it.
4.13. In 2005 information emerged that ‘years previously’ the freehold was purchased,
reputedly for €10,000 from P.J. Darley, a descendant of the square’s builder, by a
businessman. DCC would now have to buy the lease from him. Extravagant estimates were
published in newspapers on the monetary value of the site for development but the DCC
stood firm and it became a stalemate situation.
4.14. In 2006 the gates of the park were locked and then a car park began to operate from
it. Local residents blocked the locked gates to prevent this happening. In 2007 one of
companies owned by this businessman began selling tiles from the park but local residents
objected on the grounds of his having no planning permission.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
11
4.15. While this ownership saga was on-going DCC commissioned a tree survey. In
September 2007 ‘A Condition Assessment of the Trees on the Grounds of ‘Dartmouth
Square’ was carried out by Felim Sheridan, Arborist Associates Ltd. This was done to
assess trees for their suitability for inclusion in a Tree Preservation Order (TPO). This has
now been implemented and all significant trees tagged and numbered.
4.16. In October 2008 tents were erected in the park and residents urged city councillors to
take action. Somebody actually living in the park raised more concerns amongst the
residents and the businessman claimed that a man living in one of the tents was his
gardener. In December some tents caught fire and a man was hospitalised.
4.17. By June 2009 a deal was agreed with the businessman, facilitated by a local resident,
to allow the park to be opened again and run as an amenity for the local community until
the end of 2009. In September that year thirty three apple and pear trees were purchased
and donated by a local resident. These were planted in a tree planting ceremony co-
ordinated by another resident. One tree subsequently died.
4.18. In December 2012 the park was sold at auction by the liquidator of Marble & Granite
Tiles Ltd. and jointly purchased for €142,000 by DCC and local residents.
4.19. Finally, in January 2013 a report was commissioned by DCC Parks Service as the
beginning of an appraisal of its current condition and opportunities for its future use.
General view across the park
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
12
5. Analysis of the Historical Ordnance Survey Maps 5.1. Critical to an understanding of the site is the analysis of the historical ordnance survey
maps. These date from 1836/41 onwards and are valuable resources for the evolution of a
historical site, showing with every subsequent survey or revision of previous editions
subtle or significant changes. These changes when studied can bring forth information for
the interpretation of a site and its environs.
5.2. The first edition OS map is not relevant for Dartmouth Square as building
development did not commence until 1895 or thereabouts. The 2nd and later editions of OS
maps show the gradual development of Dartmouth Square and its Park. The second
edition, surveyed in 1865 and published in 1866 is the first one to show the proposed
location of what was to become the square with the park at its centre. Therefore the 1865
OS map is the earliest relevant one to study for the site’s evolution.
5.3. OS Map Publ. 1866. Surveyed 1865. 6 inch series:-
OS Map Publ. 1866 (Surveyed 1865).
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
13
5.3.1. The site is shown before the park and the sites for houses were apportioned and set
out. Buildings and trees are shown within an enclosed gated area of ground in the north-
west of the area; for its access this property opens onto the south bank of the canal. To the
east some houses are shown on narrow rectangular plots while other plots are still empty.
Later this area is to become Dartmouth Square East. At this stage ‘Northumberland Street’
is shown as the street name before it is changed to Dartmouth Square South. This OS map
also shows the pre-existing field system with marked boundaries and with Northumberland
Street cutting through it.
OS map 1866 (surveyed 1865).
5.3.2. According to the ACA - “the area where Dartmouth Square now is was relatively
low-lying with two streams crossing it. A small tributary of the river Swan, which started
in the vicinity of Portobello, went eastward along the canal and on reaching Ranelagh
changed course to diagonally cross the south-west corner of the square and continue down
Leeson Street. Another mysterious stream with no name is shown meandering snake-like
along the east side of the square. As the area was low lying this may account for the fact
that it was the last area between Ranelagh and the canal to be developed.”
5.3.3. This OS map edition does not show either of these streams. There is well
documented evidence and local knowledge that these two streams existed. Perhaps by this
time they were already underground, covered over by dumping activities or diverted into
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
14
box drains and therefore no longer visible over-ground for the OS survey of 1865 to record
them.
5.4. OS Map Revised and Publ. 1882. (Revision of 1866). 6 inch series.
This edition shows the site still vacant and the park dimensions still in outline. No
entrances are shown and there are no trees yet planted.
west side.
east side.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
15
5.5. OS Map. 2nd edition revision. 25 inch series. Publ. 1888 (surv. 1868). The 2nd edition OS map of 1888, a revision of the 1868 survey, shows the area of ground
still set out in outline for the park and terraces. Still no trees are shown on the park site
though this is not evidence of the absence of trees at that time. The housing development
was under way in 1895 so it is likely that some trees were planted by now but perhaps not
considered of significant size to record them. Trees are shown in a formal alternating
street-planting pattern to the south-east of the allocated park site on what is now shown no
longer Northumberland Street but as Dartmouth Road. The houses facing west and
previously shown on the 1866 OS map to the east of the park site are now gone, replaced
by a new terrace facing south, all fronting onto Dartmouth Road. The new back gardens
layouts are clearly visible and all have conservatories attached to the rear of the houses.
The sites for the remainder of the east side houses are still not apportioned so it is still in
the early stage of development.
OS Map 1888 (surv. 1868).
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
16
5.6. OS Map. 6 inch series. Publ. 1909 (surv. 1907/08).
The 1909 OS map has the most information for the site so this is the map to focus on.
OS Map 1909 (Surv. 1907/08).
5.6.1. Dartmouth Square park is now actually a long rectangular plot of land with plots for
the proposed terraces of houses shown as long narrow rectangular strips of land with
generous spaces now set out for front and back gardens. Many of the house sites show
glass conservatories attached to the houses. More than half of the entire north terrace
houses have conservatories attached and adjoining each other and all of the east side
houses also have conservatories.
5.6.2. This OS map now shows the completed original path layout, a perimeter shrubbery
border sectioned to facilitate the four entrances, trees planted both inside the park and
older ones planted outside the park on the south side, four central grass plots, the four
entrances are now shown and at the centre a ‘diamond’ shaped bed with two deciduous
trees planted close together on a north to south axis to avail of maximum sunlight.
5.6.3. The area has a central path running east to west and a wider path or walk running
north to south. The path converges at a cross junction and this arrangement divides the
area into four main central plots, the same pattern as many walled kitchen gardens of the
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
17
period. The perimeter path separates the grass plots from the continuous border around the
perimeter which is intended to contain trees and shrubbery. The path follows a route
parallel to the railings around the rectangular circumference of the site. The path curves at
each corner but is sharply angled to form each short section leading to each entrance.
OS Map 1909. Enlarged scale.
5.6.4. The perimeter path bounds a central area of grass which itself is subdivided by two
intersecting paths into four rectangular plots. One is on a north to south axis connecting the
north path with the south path and the other path is from east to west, effectively
subdividing the area into four rectangular plots. The north to south path is considerably
wider than the east to west path and equates to the width of the west and south borders.
This could be interpreted as the favoured main axis path but the positioning of the trees in
the diamond shaped bed, possibly to become an archway, would indicate that the east to
west path was intended to be the main axis of the park. Unlike walled gardens of the
period the south border (north facing) and the west end border are wider than the north and
east borders. The wider borders facilitate the more staggered row of trees planted inside
the park boundary and also the street trees on the south side of Dartmouth Square.
5.6.5. The 1909 OS map also shows the north and east shrubbery borders equally wide
enough to facilitate a slightly staggered row of trees as depicted. Both of these borders are
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
18
narrower than the west and south end borders. The south and west borders are equally
much wider and trees are shown in more obviously staggered formation. This extra width
is an interesting detail and may be explainable by the presence of a number of veteran trees
still existing today on this side of the park that probably all predate the enclosure of what
was previously open ground.
OS Map 1909.
5.6.6. Bearing in mind that surveyors didn’t always accurately record tree sites and
planting patterns it does seem that this OS 1909 edition is showing quite clearly and
accurately the trees within the park and larger ones around the environs of the square.
5.6.7. At the intersection of the two cross paths the 1909 OS map clearly shows the
curving of the grass plots to facilitate creating this bed shape. This ‘diamond’ bed contains
two deciduous trees planted on a north to south axis. This would indicate that this pair was
perhaps intended to eventually form a vegetal arch or bower. They are correctly planted on
this north to south axis for the best aspect to sunlight. It is also noteworthy that the north to
south central path is wider than it is east to west. This detail shows a well-considered and
cleverly thought out original design.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
19
5.7. OS Map. 1909. 25 inch series. 1936 revision.
1909 OS Map. 1936 revision.
5.7.1. By 1936 when this edition was published several dramatic changes had occurred.
The tree population had considerably diminished and the cruciform path and ‘diamond’
shaped bed had disappeared. The number of street trees had also considerably diminished.
5.7.2. The park at this time was still private but leased to the Loreto Hockey Club (1926)
as a practice pitch. This OS map confirms that the cruciform path and diamond bed must
have been removed to facilitate this use rather than worn away by ‘wear and tear’ as this
would have left some traces. The question arises whether the path base is still surviving;
only archaeological investigation could determine if this were the case.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
20
6. Significant Features – Commentary & Recommended Actions 6.1. Pergola 6.1.1. The pergola is the architectural focal point within the park but its not part of the
original design shown on the 1909 OS map, but dates from the 1987/88 landscape design.
The pergola on the design drawing 1987/88.
The pergola as it is today.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
21
6.1.2. It has a dominating presence because of its scale, positioning and chunky robust
construction. The structure visually dissects the park. It is constructed on a north-south
axis with its concrete flag/banded red brick walkway connecting the north and south
boundary paths. Its roof is unpainted horizontal timber planks and some planks are
missing. Its supporting pillars are constructed from cut granite blocks with two bands of
red brick in each. Each pillar is visually linked with a red brick band in the walkway.
6.1.3. As with other pergolas of the period there were flower beds at its base running
parallel to the walkway and filled with perennials but these beds have now gone and the
bed areas grassed down leaving just scraps of plants surviving. Roses, wisteria,
honeysuckle and jasmine were planted on the pillars. All the roses have gone while the
surviving wisteria, jasmine and honeysuckle struggle along so the area is ideal for a new
planting scheme. The pergola visually dominates the park, its architectural style could be
perceived by some as overbearing but this is partly because it is so bare of plants.
the pergola today.
It is similar in fashion to many other pergolas of the early 20th century design.
6.1.4. Because this pergola is apparently structurally sound and visual inspection shows no
settlement cracks or erosion of its stonework it is not a priority for repair.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
22
6.1.5. Should it deteriorate or become damaged it would be worth considering its
replacement with a new metal feature on its site, to continue to provide an architectural
focal point. Thus allowing for the re-instatement of the original design of a ‘diamond’
shaped bed at the axis of the paths, as depicted on the OS map of 1909.
Pergola Herbert Park. Courtesy DCC.
Pergola, Hever Castle, Kent.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
23
6.1.6. “The pergola at Hever Castle is planted with wisteria and the well spaced overhead
beams allow sunlight to cast dappled light patterns on the paved pathway and low
perennials are planted between the piers on the left hand side. Wisteria is a deciduous
climber so its autumn tints adds seasonal colour; its bare winter boughs allow snow to fall
safely though to ground level, reducing the threat of snow lodging on it to any great
extent.” Extract from Herbert Park Report, Finola Reid, March 2011
6.1.7. Unfortunately wisteria does not perform as well here as it does in the south of
England, no matter what gardening books say. It is rare to see wisteria flowering well
unless it is on a very sheltered hot wall .The wisteria on the pergola in Dartmouth Square
Park is a poor advertisement for itself and should be removed.
6.1.8. The pergola is a centrepiece that has been there since 1988 and is greatly used by
visitors. It would be far more costly to remove it than simply clean and repair it and then
re-plant it. The Plans and Drawings dating from the 1986/87 are archived and can be used
for reference so it would be straight forward to repair timbers and replant its pillars.
6.1.9. Actions • Repair the pergola roof by replacing missing or broken timber beams as necessary
• Do not paint the timbers but continue to keep them in natural wood finish
• Power-hose the walkway to remove debris and grime from flags and bricks
• Clean and re-paint the garden seats in a more cheerful colour – eg. peacock blue
• Clear out old straggling plants that are still around the pillar bases
• Carry out remedial pruning on climbers and train them to grow onto the roof timbers
• Consider planting a selection of repeat flowering, scented, climbing roses on the pillars
• Re-instate the associated flower beds, according to their original layout and dimensions
• Design new planting schemes for the flower beds:
A) Use choice hardy perennials that don’t require staking or constant dead-heading.
Varieties and cultivars of hardy geraniums, dierama, dianella, agapanthus, iris,
lavender, old shrub roses such as ‘Perle D’Or’ or ‘Cecile Brunner’ would provide
constant enlivenment or
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
24
B) Use seasonal bedding schemes in traditional park planting style - red flowered
pelargoniums, heliotrope, coleus, antirrhinums, pansies, kochia, tobacco, cosmos, etc.
• Consider using dwarf boxwood edging to the flower beds to form a strong vegetal
counterpoint to the dominance of the structure.
6.2. Trees 6.2.1 It is evident from the historical O.S. map of 1909 (surveyed 1907/08) that trees were
planted as slightly staggered rows on the north, south and west perimeter boundary
borders, with a tendency towards some having been planted as pairs. The limes at either
side of the north entrance gate and south entrance gate are matching pairs.
Matching Lime trees (Tilia x europaea).
6.2.2. The east boundary has a straighter row of trees in a somewhat narrower border. The
south boundary shows a definitely more staggered row in a wider border. This current site
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
25
survey has found that some visibly older veteran trees are still thriving in the south
boundary border. These much older trees are possibly survivors of the old field system that
predates the setting out and enclosing of the park, already in progress by the time of
publication of the OS map of 1888 (survey 1868).
6.2.3. One tree in particular on the south boundary pressing right against the railing is an
old parkland tree that once had many low lateral branches. These have been severely
pruned off completely to encourage more verticality of habit, a regrettably bad way of
pruning a veteran tree. It may be a tree that was already growing in the open field system
before the park was enclosed. Another tree close-by has engulfed the railing support rod
and it too appears to be of an earlier date than the park.
6.2.4. Other trees outside the park railings on this south side are also older than those
within the park. One huge lime at the junction of Cambridge Terrace with Dartmouth
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
26
Square South seems to be considerably older than any limes within the park. This is
certainly evidence that older trees were there before the park area was enclosed, though the
1866 and 1888 O.S. maps don’t record the existence of any trees. It could be speculated
that the more pronounced staggered row pattern and deeper border on the south boundary
was to enable the planting of new trees alongside older trees of considerable size and good
quality already there taking up space. It would be useful if future tree assessments included
trees growing outside the park so their girths could be compared with those inside the park.
6.2.5. Most of the original trees still thrive in the perimeter shrub borders though elms
have disappeared because Dutch Elm Disease would have ravaged this park, like so many
other parks and gardens during the 1970’s and 80’s. There is a group of elm saplings
growing on the north border close to the gate; these are spontaneous suckers from an old
stump.
6.2.6. Other diseases are now as big a threat to the surviving trees as elm disease. It is
evident now that two trees on the south side are suffering from sap oozing out from their
main trunks. This may be bacterial infection. Both trees were subjected to severe pruning
of main limbs in the past and cavities are visible at these pruning-wound sites. This must
be a recent outbreak as it was not recorded in the 2007 tree condition survey. To determine
exactly what is causing this ooze would require an arboricultural inspection.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
27
Ooze noticeable on several trees.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
28
Weeping Ash.
6.2.7. There is a Weeping Ash tree at the east entrance. This is a double-grafted specimen
and though gnarled (and with some ‘reversion’ on it that should be pruned to prevent it
becoming dominant) it should be conserved.
6.2.8. Actions
• Carry out a review of the 2007 Tree Assessment to determine current disease status
• Update tree assessment tags; many are twisted, damaged and difficult to read
• Carry out essential surgery or removal of trees that are sources of infection or
causing pressure on more desirable species
• Remove volunteer saplings that may cause damage to the railings, stays and plinths
• Remove several eucalyptus, holly seedlings, one Cupressus x leylandii and all
scrappy shrubs to generate space for new good quality trees, shrubs and perennials
• Remove stumps by root grinding to create spaces for re-planting these sites.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
29
6.3. Shrubs & Perennials 6.3.1. Many of the shrubs and perennials planted in the shrubbery borders as part of the
1987/88 planting scheme still survive though others have died out or were removed in a
recent clean-up of the park initiated by the residents. The 1987/88 landscaping scheme
involved planting groups of shrubs of the same genus/cultivar together to form large
blocks of greenery, a landscaping style not suited to a Victorian park. A great emphasis
was placed on evergreen species like buxus, olearia, ligustrum, euonymus, viburnum,
escallonia and other robust genera that could compete with the dry ground conditions and
shade created by the mature trees. The four perimeter shrubbery borders still contain a
collection of shrubs but most have become scraggy and tired from competing with trees.
North border shrubbery from west end.
6.3.2. There is a case to be made for a complete overhaul of the perimeter shrubbery
borders and a more traditional planting pattern implemented. This would entail selectively
removing all poorly, miss-shaped specimens and preparing the ground for planting new
flowering shrubs and low growing perennials under the mature trees. Using only the
choicest selection of flowering shrubs and perennials a sympathetic new scheme of
snowdrops, scented narcissus, native bluebells, species crocus, lily of the valley, spring
and autumn cyclamen, Algerian iris, brunnera, omphalodes, ophiopogon, polygonatum,
anemone, and many others, would quickly carpet the ground between the now more widely
spaced individual specimen shrubs.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
30
6.3.3. The clean out of old shrubs and the carefully thought out wider spacing of new
shrubs would ensure no area would become dense with vegetation in the decades ahead.
The use of species that do not need annual pruning would alleviate pressure on staff time
input. Species that flower and produce berries, fruits or seeds would increase the
biodiversity of the park, encouraging wildlife and birds. The use of ground-hugging
perennials would be a good substitute for the present layer of thick common ivy which
constantly creeps onto the tree trunks and becomes a tedious maintenance problem. It also
harbours dog excrement and discarded bottles, cans and litter so it cannot be pleasant for
staff to deal with. New attractive plantings would encourage a greater respect for the park.
6.3.4. Unwanted scrub, feral saplings, and weed vegetation has colonised the shrubberies
and various bed areas, engulfing many specimens. This vegetation must be carefully
removed to allow surviving, struggling plants to recover. Where plants have died out and
gaps have occurred these should be filled with appropriate new shrubs to enable the true
character and variety of the original planting scheme to be restored. More recently planted
shrubs should be assessed as to their suitability and compatibility with the original design
and if considered inappropriate then removed.
6.3.5. The residents recently planted a selection of spring flowering bulbs, daffodils, etc.
and these are filling the gaps well. However without a balanced structure to the plantings
of flowering deciduous and evergreen shrubs and hardy low growing perennials in clumps
– epimediums, polygonatum, ferns, brunnera, omphalodes, dianella, ophiopogon, comfrey,
etc. these spaces will seem empty all summer long when the daffodil foliage dies back.
6.3.6. Actions
• Re-visit the 1987/88 planting list as a basis for generating a new planting scheme
• Clear out all straggly shrubs, eucalyptus, holly seedlings and ivy
• Clear out old stumps except a few large ones to be left as larders for wildlife
• Carry out remedial work to the soil, adding fresh earth, compost and nutrients
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
31
• Design new planting schemes for each section of the perimeter border
• Plant thematically in different areas according to aspect, light and shade, moisture,
etc. so a wider variety of plants can be used to suit each location
• Use shrubs that are floriferous, produce fruits, berries and seeds and require a
minimum of pruning; the well tried and reliable old varieties and cultivars are best
• Choose a wide variety of hardy perennials that form clumps so the ground space
between shrubs gets blanketed in drifts of different foliage and flowers
• As part of the planting scheme consider planting high merit specimen shrubs that
commemorate local famous people – ‘local worthies’.
north border shrubbery east end.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
32
6.4. Cherry Laurel 6.4.1. The formidable cherry laurel hedge is planted around the edges of the perimeter path
system separating it from the central grassed area. The cherry laurel forms such a solid
barrier along the path that people are confined to the path or the central grassed area and
have to enter and exit via the pergola walk or through one of the six exits cut in the hedge.
6.4.2. It is part of the 1987 planting design and instead of a single row or staggered double
row it was planted approximately three metres wide, with the effect of being a ‘laurel
lawn’ as seen in old and well managed woodlands. It was inspired by the laurel lawn in
Palmerston Park. However it is a feature that is taking up a lot of space that might be better
utilized and easier managed.
6.4.3. Presently it is cut by machinery under a landscape contract. If it were removed and
the space it occupies renovated then the grassed area would be widened by three metres on
all sides.
6.4.4. With the widening of the grass area the re-instatement of the original east to west
path could be considered and circulation would greatly improve for visitors.
6.4.5. A series of narrow beds for old shrub roses and flowers could be developed along
the perimeter path edges and the effect would be dramatically improved.
Cherry Laurel hedge
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
33
6.4.6. Actions
• Remove cherry laurel hedge entirely
• Carry out remedial work to the cherry laurel site, raising fertility with nutrients
• Design a series of new beds to replace the cherry laurel along the path route
• Consider installing a series of narrow rectangular rose beds along the perimeter
path to enable the planting of carefully selected repeat flowering old shrub roses
• Consider placing memorial plaques, one in each bed, to commemorate a local
worthy – of which there are many who lived in and around Dartmouth Square.
View across the formidable Cherry Laurel hedge.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
34
6.5. Grassed Areas 6.5.1. The grassed areas are well used spaces so they should continue to accommodate
passive recreation. The openness of the grassed areas allows sky and clouds to be part of
the enjoyment of the park. The areas give a great breadth of view across to the houses,
gently screened by the trees.
6.5.2. A solitary poorly beech tree with damaged bark is in the west central plot, a survivor
from the 1987/88 planting scheme. It should be removed as it will never become a fine
veteran tree, even if it did manage to overcome its wound it would block a considerable
sunlight; either way it should go.
Damaged beech. A remnant of the 1987/88 landscaping scheme.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
35
Sodden grass area.
6.5.3. A small area of grass close to the cherry laurel hedge on the south east side of the
park is continuously sodden. This may be a manifestation of water oozing up from the old
streams courses and/or collapsed box drains. Its relatively recent and should be checked.
Owing to the earlier history of the site as low-lying ground and a dumping site, and as
good practice anyway, the park development works probably included the installation of a
series of ‘herringbone’ box drains to ensure the park never flooded. Careful investigation,
hand digging around the spot might reveal more information. If water is seeping through
its source needs to be established in case it is coming from blocked box drains or a
domestic source and could be a hazard.
6.5.4. The set of two circular beds in the grass areas on the 1987/88 design should not be
re-instated as this would limit the use of the space for playing and relaxing in and it would
add greatly to the amount of maintenance needed to keep such beds in good order,
especially if they are in the ‘line of fire’ for ball playing.
6.5.5. Actions
• Keep the grassed areas in continued good trim
• Investigate the sodden area for blocked drains
• Consider using part of one section as a horizontal maze for small children to enjoy
• If the cherry laurel is retained consider placing seats inside the area at spaced
intervals to allow adults enjoy the area while keeping an eye on small children.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
36
View towards north-east.
View towards south west.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
37
6.6. Fruit Trees 6.6.1. There are fruit trees that were planted in the park four years ago. Thirty three were
purchased in the autumn of 2009 (Tully’s Nurseries, Co. Dublin) by a generous donor and
planted in short rows at either end of the grass areas. At the east end one tree died and has
gone. There are 16 pear trees and 16 apple trees still growing but four years on from
planting their growth has not been as good as it should. Competition for nutrients with the
grass sward, and cherry laurel and shading from the trees has stunted their development.
6.6.2. Fruit trees need a good open aspect well away from shade cast of trees and
competition from hedges and should be kept free of thick grass. They are grafted onto
‘medium rootstocks’ which limits their vigour and better suited to a small garden than a
large park. However if they were transplanted into beds where there is no competition
from grass they could make better growth. Mowing around them wastes precious time and
inevitably there is mechanical damage from time to time. Also there is petty vandalism
with branches being broken so transplanting into beds would give them a better chance. to
thrive.
fruit trees in poor condition.
6.6.3. One of the varieties, ‘Golden Delicious’, does not fruit reliably in Irish weather
conditions .It is well known and looks good on supermarket shelves; always asked for and
readily on sale in garden centres and nurseries. Nevertheless it should be replaced with
reliable varieties like ‘Discovery’ or ‘Katya’ that do crop better. The pear trees are more
vigorous in habit than the apples and will continue to grow vertically and get very tall so
pruning needs to be very carefully carried out or they will be disappointing croppers.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
38
6.6.4. The suggested new beds on the site of the cherry laurel hedge could accommodate
the fruit trees to free them from the constraints of their present sites. The planting of roses
and these fruit trees is a compatible combination in path borders would hark back to
traditional planting patterns of walled kitchen gardens.
6.6.5. There is scope for planting a wider selection of fruit trees and bushes in properly laid
out beds/borders. Quince (Cydonia oblonga), black mulberry (Morus nigra), myrtle
(Myrtus ugni), damsons, sloes, elderberries, redcurrants, white-currants, blackcurrants,
gooseberries would all do well here with little effort. Finicky fruits that require a lot of
care should not be used. Raspberries, loganberries, etc. need training on wires and are
better suited to allotments or back gardens so these or strawberries, should not be
considered.
6.6.6. The more robust herbs like rosemary, fennel and lovage could also be planted.
6.6.7. Actions
• Re-plant the fruit trees into suggested new borders along the path system
• If decided not to transplant them then the grass should be cut in a wide circle
around each to allow for better growth
• Mulch and feed them annually with a balanced fruit fertiliser until they get strong
• Carry out judicious seasonal pruning to train them into better shape.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
39
6.7. Path System 6.7.1. The path system has been thoroughly discussed in the section dealing with the OS
maps analysis. The perimeter path is in four sections with each gate entrance creating this
separation. The path surface is finished and dressed with fine limestone quarry dust/grit
and is comfortable underfoot. Limestone is dull grey and when it gets mucky with spillage
form the borders and leaf fall it becomes unattractive and sloppy. The path system is kept
in reasonable good condition with fresh grit applied where pooling occurs after heavy rain.
Some stretches are muddy underfoot and this is inevitable after the recent bad weather.
Autumn leaf fall also contributes its share of debris onto the path surfaces.
The present path.
6.7.2. To make a really positive impact the path surfaces could be scraped off and a layer
of Ballylusk crushed gravel applied, then cambered and rolled to firm it. This would create
a better visual effect. Cambering also helps cast water to the edges to drain into shrubbery
and reduces the pooling.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
40
6.7.3. Ballylusk is honey-coloured sandstone and would blend well with the rope tile
edgings and enliven the whole park. It is also firm when rolled and easy to walk on for
visitors with less mobility. It shows up dirty patches and soil spillage quicker so these can
be cleaned off before they get muddy.
Walled garden path, Killruddery
6.7.4. Actions
• Continue to keep paths to the present standard, repairing worn spots as needed
• Consider replacing path surfaces with sand coloured material such as Ballylusk
• Camber the new surfaces so water is cast towards the edges.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
41
6.8. Fire-Clay ‘Rope’ Edgings 6.8.1. The paths are edged with fire-clay tiles with a rope effect top which is a typical
Victorian pattern still seen in many of our Victorian and Edwardian gardens. These rope
edges are fresh looking with very little weathering, supplied by Flemings, Kingscourt, Co.
Cavan and newly installed during the 1987 works. They are attractive and functional so
should be kept as part of any improvements. There is damage to some tiles where mowing
has broken the tops and also some lamination from recent bad winters. Replacements are
still available so the little amount of damage can be repaired.
6.8.2. Actions
• Replace any damaged tiles where damage has occurred. Matching old tiles can be
sourced in salvage yards
• Avoid further damage when mowing by cutting a strip off the grass to allow a gap
Damaged edging Edging around the Weeping Ash.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
42
6.9. Seats 6.9.1. Seats are positioned at intervals around the paths and six are under the pergola so
people can gather as a group if they wish.
6.9.2. The seats are reproductions of a traditional Victorian style, with painted timbers
bolted to metal end frames. There are two patterns, both equally appropriate for the park.
All seats need some cleaning, some need repairs and all would benefit from a new coat of
paint in a cheerful colour that would enliven the spots they occupy.
6.9.3. The seats are placed on the north and south end paths with another two sets of three
in the central section of the pergola. They look like traditional Victorian seats but are cast
metal reproductions installed in 1987/88. One has a date stamp of 1980 on its metal frame.
One of them is damaged and needs repair. They were last painted in 2009 by the residents
association and need freshening up again, perhaps with a more cheerful colour.
6.9.4. Actions
• Repair and paint seats in a cheerful Victorian period style colour – not black or
green but a more lively colour, perhaps a ‘peacock’ blue, royal blue or even red
• Consider providing more seats at spaced intervals on all the paths
• Continue to use the same style of seats so purchase matching ones if possible
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
43
• Consider using seats as memorials to local worthies, literary, artistic figures who
lived in the Ranelagh area and whose memory can thus be simply commemorated
• Record these ‘local worthies’ by the use of simple metal plaques on the seat backs
• Seek a number of sponsors to help purchase seats and plaques for this purpose.
a vandalised seat under the pergola.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
44
6.10. Gate Entrances & Railings 6.10.1. The park has four entrances, one on each side of the park. The north entrance is
framed by a pair of lime trees as is the south entrance. The east entrance has an old
‘Weeping Ash’ set into the pathway. The west entrance has veteran sycamores.
6.10.2. Of the four gates three are open daily, though kept shut over to deter stray dogs, the
south entrance is kept locked as this is the busiest traffic side, so children and pets would
be more vulnerable if they ran out this gate.
6.10.3. The gates and railings are original to the park design, made of wrought iron in a
neo-gothic pattern and painted black. They are the same pattern as those made by Messrs
M’Gloughlin, Dublin, for Harold’s Cross Park and Palmerston Park (both 1894).
6.10.4. The railings are bedded with lead into a low granite plinth wall and supported by
wrought iron support rods or stays. A number of the stays are now embedded into tree
trunks as the trees increase in girth and engulf them. At some places the trees are planted
too close to the railings so they are pushing the railings off vertical plane and causing
pressure cracks in the low plinth wall. This is a problem not easily solved without
sacrificing either the railings or the trees. As in many old sites, vegetation and architecture
compete for space. The park railings and plinths under threat from some of the veteran
trees need to be monitored and remedial work done before this becomes a safety issue.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
45
6.10.5. As part of an ACA the park gates and railings may take precedence over the
vegetation threatening them. Published guidelines for the care and conservation of
historical graveyards are not dissimilar and would provide information on management of
vegetation in conflict with the railings.
6.10.6. Actions
• Assess what trees are at risk and where railings and plinths are at risk
• Remove carefully all volunteer saplings growing too close to the railings
• Carry out annual inspection and cull any new saplings that pose a threat
• Monitor regularly the veteran trees that are putting pressure on railings and plinths
• Repair gates, railings and plinths as needed using traditional methods and materials
• Continue to paint railings in a plain matt colour rather than high gloss paint.
Box Pier at Gate Entrance.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
46
6.11. Signs and labels 6.11.1. Currently signs are affixed to the gates otherwise there are none in the park. It
would be useful if information boards were installed so visitors could learn about the
history and architecture of the square and about the trees and vegetation.
6.11.2. The trees were all surveyed in 2007 and given numbered metal tags to tally with
that inventory. For visitors information and enjoyment it would be useful to label the prime
specimens with common and botanical names, family, wild origin, height, girth, seasonal
values, etc.
6.11.3. Actions
• Discreetly label prime specimens of trees and shrubs to generate more interest
• Provide all information/bye-law signage in an attractive period style display board
• Avoid clutter by using carefully chosen positions for all notices, signs and labels
• Affix signs to all gates (which are kept shut) to indicate opening/closing times.
Tagged tree.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
47
6.12. Health and Safety 6.12.1. Visibility is one of the most important issues for public safety in public open
spaces. Being seen is important and not having to pass by dense, overhanging or tall
vegetation that can cause fear and reluctance to use public spaces. Dartmouth Square Park
does not have a problem with dense vegetation and is not a fearful place, though it is often
a very quiet spot to be when on one’s own. The north side greenery is somewhat thicker
than elsewhere and some thinning out and new planting would be beneficial. Generally the
park has good open views in all directions and it is a noticeably sunny and sheltered spot
despite the tall trees surrounding it. The trees themselves were well spaced when first
planted and have been recently pruned so good views are still afforded onto the terraces in
a most pleasing framing of their architecture. Any new planting scheme should reflect the
need to continue the sense of openness and visibility of the site.
6.12.2. The seats are well placed along the paths so people are visible from quite far off.
The seats under the pergola are set out in two groups of three so companionable
conversations can be struck up with strangers without being at too close quarters.
6.12.3. The formidable cherry laurel hedge forms such a solid barrier along the path that
people are either confined to the path or to the central grassed area. Having to enter and
exit via the pergola walkway or through one of the six exits cut in the hedge controls
circulation so people sitting on the path seats can clearly see others approaching.
6.12.4. The worst problem is dog fouling and excrement which is regularly encountered,
particularly at the east end grass area and throughout the perimeter shrubbery. Dogs are
often let off leads as they enter the park but despite that most owners are well behaved and
responsible. I witnessed one owner letting his dog race back and forth along the full length
of the path and dash into the shrubbery at terrific speed – this has caused a regular worn
track through the vegetation at either end of the south side. Young children could be
frightened or knocked over as animals dash along, but, discarded broken bottles and cans
pose a great risk too.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
48
6.12.5. Litter is minimal, randomly discarded cans and bottles are thrown into the greenery
or stuck onto the railings but it all seems to be a small problem.
6.12.6. There are key holders among the residents who voluntarily keep an eye out and
open and lock the gates. This is a good example of community partnership between the
residents and the DCC as it engages the local community in keeping an eye out for litter,
petty vandalism or any suspected unsavoury activity.
East end of park – gate and railings used to dispose of drink cans.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
49
6.13. Owners & their Dogs 6.13.1. The park is well used by dog owners to exercise their pets. There is a group of
owners who meet regularly to train guide dogs and this is a most welcome activity as it
probably has some beneficial effect on other owners with more boisterous animals. It
would be mutually helpful if the guide dog trainers were encouraged to do obedience
classes with other owners and their dogs on a weekly basis, even for 30 minutes, to raise
awareness of their work and receive voluntary donations for time well spent. This might be
more effective strategy than haranguing a few dog owners with signage about dogs being
kept on leads. ‘Well behaved owners and dogs are Welcome’ perhaps is the message.
6.13.2. Actions
• Encourage dog owners to use the park responsibly as this will increase everybody’s
enjoyment of the area
• Encourage dog owners to stop using the shrubbery borders to dispose of excrement
• Place a Bye-law Notice at each gate about dog soiling/health issues, dogs on leads
and under proper control, and the welcome there is for owners who do behave well
• Agree an initiative with the Residents Association so the few who are letting dogs
‘run wild’ are encouraged rather than challenged to control their pets better
• Encourage the use of the park for regular weekly or monthly ‘guide’ dogs training
sessions that would encourage others to teach their pets similar skills.
unleashed dog.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
50
6.14. Litter Bins 6.14.1 Litter is minimal, randomly discarded cans, bottles and paper wrappings thrown
into the cherry laurel, shrubbery or stuck onto railings is generally a small problem
compared to other public parks. The staff and residents are vigilant about fly tipping and
petty littering.
6.14.2. Actions
• Consider eliminating litter bins; those who do litter won’t use them, those who
don’t litter will walk to a nearby one outside the park or take their litter with them.
Robust litter bin.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
51
6.15. Wildlife & Birds 6.15.1. Wildlife and birds in Dartmouth Square have good opportunities for habitat. The
maturity and height of the trees, the nearby canal, the relative quiet and safety of the area
and the sheltered aspect of the park landscape must encourage many wild creatures.
Fieldfares, blackbirds, thrushes, robins and starlings all browse the ground. There are
probably tree creepers in the area as they prefer tall trees with fissured bark to browse;
long tailed tits which are in the area prefer tall conifers as roosts but will populate tall
deciduous trees as well. The population of beneficial insects, bees, butterflies wasps,
hoverflies must be relatively high given that the trees and canal and large mature gardens
offer them wide opportunities. The opportunity to encourage a more diverse range of bird
species can be greatly increased by planting of species that encourage birds.
6.15.2. With so many trees a bird survey and a bat survey would be useful for conservation
purposes. Determining the species that are present would add to the park’s biodiversity.
6.15.3. Urban foxes should be encouraged as they control the rodent population that the
canal attracts.
6.15.4. Actions
• Carry out a bird and bat survey to determine their populations in the park
• Encourage foxes to inhabit the park as a discouragement to rodents
• When replanting the shrubbery and borders - use beneficial plants that produce
nectar, fruits, berries and nuts to attract birds, red squirrels and beneficial wildlife
• Increase the number of fruit trees and plant fruit bushes to attract more wildlife
• Leave old dead stumps and large dead limbs as ‘larders’ for beetles, weevils,
centipedes, woodlice, snails, slugs and other small creatures to inhabit and feed off
• Utilise autumn leaf fall as a natural resource by recycling it into shrubbery borders
• Allow some of the limes to retain their ‘skirts’ to encourage small creatures
• Place suitable nesting boxes, bat boxes, roosts, etc., in the taller trees
• Provide an information board so birds and wildlife can be better appreciated.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
52
6.16. Cats 6.16.1. Birds and small creatures are at risk if cats are roaming. So the cats, if they are feral
and ownerless, that are seen prowling around the park should be humanely trapped and
neutered to limit their population. Pet cats should also be neutered and kept indoors at
night. Cats with bell-collars will deter them from hunting the birds on the grass areas.
6.16.2. Actions
• Seek the advice of a cat charity to help limit and control the feral cat population
• Provide an information board so birds and wildlife can be better appreciated.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
53
7. Chronology of the Park Land where the park and square are now located was initially in the ownership of the Rt.
Hon. Luke Gardiner (1745-98) and bought by the Darley Estate for the purpose of
developing it for residential use. Development of the square began shortly before 1865.
1866 OS map shows the site as a field with buildings in enclosed area to the north east.
Water is not evident on this map though other sources say two streams are here.
1882 OS map shows outlines of proposed new square and park with houses on east side.
1888 OS map shows corrected outline of the park, now with a gate entrance on the north
side. This map shows the park dimensions are not quite finalised.
1895/6 Development of the square starts with house Nos. 1 to 17 on the western side ready
for occupation in 1897. At this time it is called Uxbridge Terrace. The park is
solely for the use of residents with each house having its own key. There is no
indication that there are any other gates other than the one shown on the north side.
1897 The development of the park itself is now well under way. The period for its
development is from 1895, when the first terrace was started, to shortly before
1907/08 when the survey for the 1909 OS map was carried out, and that survey
records the full layout. The park can thus be dated to between 1895 and 1907.
1909 OS map shows the park plan with four gates, trees, a perimeter border and path
running around all sides and a cruciform path through the centre with a ‘diamond’
bed at the centre point of this path.
1926 The Loreto Schools Hockey Club is founded by Mother Bernadette IBVM and Una
Murray for past pupils. The park is leased from the Darley Estate for use as its
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
54
hockey pitch. Hockey is played there until the club moves to Cherryfield,
Templeogue, in the 1930’s and to another site in Templeogue in the 1940’s.
1936 OS map shows the park without its central bed and cruciform path. The likely
reason for the disappearance of the cruciform path and diamond bed is its use for
hockey. This indicates that the path was purposely removed. This edition also
shows a considerable reduction in the tree population in the perimeter border from
59 to only 24 trees and even less street trees than the previous OS map recorded.
1930’s - 1950’s there is a gap in the information. Differing accounts say that hockey
ceased in the 1930’s and other accounts say it continued until the 1950’s.
Loreto Archive and the Hockey Club are checking on the truth of these dates.
1950 - 1980’s The condition of the park deteriorates and residents consider their options.
1987 The residents approach the Lord Mayor who becomes the driving force for change
and the City Manager makes it a Dublin Millenium project.
Dublin City Parks devises a landscaping scheme to return it to a Victorian park.
Dublin City Council offers to buy the land but enters into a ten year lease instead
and begins its landscape renewal scheme and opens it as a public park.
The Dartmouth Square Park landscape renewal scheme is implemented. Entrances,
shrubbery borders remain unchanged but perimeter paths are widened and slightly
changed and a new Pergola Walk made on route of the old path connecting the
north gate to the south gate.
1988 Dublin’s Millenium Year sees the completion of the works.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
55
1997 When the lease expires inconclusive talks take place between DCC and the Darley
Estate. Dublin City Council continues to manage it.
2005 The information emerges that ‘years previously’ the freehold was purchased,
reputedly for €10,000 from P.J. Darley, a descendant of the square’s builder, by a
businessman.
2006 Businessman locks the gates of the park and begins to operate a car park from it.
Local residents block the locked gates to prevent this happening.
2007 Businessman begins selling tiles from the park but local residents object on the
grounds of his having no planning permission.
2007 September. A Condition Assessment of the Trees on the Grounds of ‘Dartmouth
Square’ is carried out by Felim Sheridan, Arborist Associates Ltd for DCC, to
assess trees for suitability for inclusion in a TPO (tree preservation order).
2008 October. Tents are erected in the park and residents urge city councillors to take
action. A man apparently living in one of the tents is reported to be a gardener.
December. Tents catch fire and a man is hospitalised.
2009 June. A deal is agreed between a local resident and businessman to run the park as
an amenity for the local community until the end of 2009.
September. 33 apple and pear fruit trees purchased, donated and planted in a tree
planting ceremony co-ordinated by a local resident. One subsequently dies.
2012 December. Park sold at auction by the liquidator of Marble & Granite Tiles Ltd.
Park is jointly purchased for €142,000 by DCC and local residents.
2013 January. Report commissioned by DCC Parks and Landscape Services Division.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
56
8. Some noteworthy figures who have lived on Dartmouth Square
No. 7 Dartmouth Square. Luke Kelly, of The Dubliners traditional ballad group.
No. 23 Dartmouth Square. 1923 – 1930. Alfred (Alfie) Byrne. Lord Mayor of Dublin
from 1930 to 1939 and from 1954 to1955.
No. 51 Dartmouth Square. 1921 – 1927. Frank Duff, founder of the Legion of Mary.
No. 55 Dartmouth Square. Joseph Michael O’Byrne SC, 1916 veteran, Bolands Mills and
Registrar of Deeds, Land Registry Office, Dublin.
No. 57 Dartmouth Square. 1944. Paul Durcan, the poet, was born in this house.
No. 61 Dartmouth Square. 1930’s. Micheal MacLiammoir & Hilton Edwards, Theatre duo.
No. 62 Dartmouth Square. Thomas Lopdell O’Shaughnessy, Recorder for Dublin.
In the 1950’s Power O’Mara, Globe Theatre Company and eldest son of opera
singer Joseph O’Mara lived here.
No. ? Dartmouth Square. Date unknown. Barry Fitzgerald (William Joseph Shields),
Actor, Abbey Theatre from 1916 - 1920 and an Oscar winning actor.
No. ? Donagh MacDonagh (1912-1968). Son of Thomas MacDonagh, Irish Patriot 1916.
A poet, playwright and short story writer lived on Dartmouth Square for a time.
No. ? Professor Kevin B. Nowlan. Conservation Supremo. Veteran of many battles to
save Dublin’s historic fabric and historical places.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
57
9. Lafcadio Hearn – a brief biography
9.1. Lafcadio Hearn (Koizumi Yakumo). Born 27th June 1850. Died 26th Sept. 1904 in
Japan.
9.2. Born in Lefkada a small village in Greece, to a local girl, Rosa Antonia Cassimati, of
the Greek Orthodox faith and an Irishman, Charles Bush Hearn, when he was serving as a
military surgeon there in the 76th Foot Regiment, British Army. Lafcadio, named after
Lefkada, as a very young child was sent home to Dublin with his mother when his father
went to the West Indies. They first stayed with an aunt, Elizabeth Holmes Hearn, in 48
Lower Gardiner Street, also at 73 Upper Leeson Street and then he was moved to 21
Leinster Square, off Lower Rathmines Road, to stay with another aunt, Mrs Sarah
Brenane, younger sister of Elizabeth Holmes Hearn. His father returned in 1853, the
marriage had broken up, his mother departed for Greece and she never saw her son again.
His father afterwards invalidated the marriage and re-married, abandoned Lafcadio, aged
seven, leaving him with his sister. She adopted him and, as a convert herself, raised him as
a Catholic. Lafcadio never saw his father again.
9.3. His early education was in Dublin before being sent to school in England. He lost the
sight of his left eye in an accident playing a school game. He later attended a Jesuit college
in France but gave up his studies. Meantime his aunt became bankrupt, her financial
advisor haing mismanaged her money. Lafcadio was brought back to Dublin, given a ticket
to sail to New York, where he arrived penniless. He worked at various jobs, ending up in
Cincinnati as a crime reporter, then a politics reporter in New Orleans, becoming a literary
editor there. He then went to Martinique, West Indies and wrote two books.
9.4. In 1890, aged 40, he went to Japan and within a year he had married a twenty-two
year old Japanese girl, Setsuko Koizumi, and became a Japanese citizen, taking her
family’s surname of Koizumi. They had a happy marriage, three sons, and he earned his
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
58
living writing and teaching. From 1896-1903 he lectured at the Imperial University in
Tokyo and later University of Waseda.
9.5. He wrote a great number of books on Japan and Japanese subjects, ghost stories, fairy
tales and folklore. His books are still widely read and on the school curriculum in Japan.
He is hugely well known, respected and commemorated there, all Japanese schoolchildren
know his work while he is almost unheard of in Ireland. In Tramore, Co. Waterford where
he spent many summer holidays with his aunt, the town council has recently began a
project to develop a Japanese garden in his memory. Dartmouth Square Park wasn’t even
built when he sailed to New York but perhaps he still could be given greater recognition
here, near to where he lived. A selection or a small grove of Japanese native plants with an
extract from ‘A Dream of a Summer Day’, in which he uses a theme used by W.B. Yeats in
his poem, ‘The Wanderings of Oisin’ might trigger more interest in his literary legacy.
9.6. A simple way to commemorate any of these noteworthies would be to add more seats
with small discreet plaques affixed. Another way would be to install small metal plaques in
the path surface similar to the ones embedded in the city pavements by Dublin Tourism
commemorating literary and historical figures. A theme could be ‘walking in the footsteps
of giants’ to encourage children to want to know more about figures from history. Another
way would be to plant more trees each with a label giving short vignette of these lives.
Dartmouth Square Park Management Plan August 2013 ________________________________________________________________________
59
10. Sources & References
TCD Map Library OS Map Publ. 1866. Surveyed 1865. 6 inch series.
OS Map Publ. 1882. Revision of 1866. 6 inch series.
OS Map Publ. 1888. Surveyed 1868. 25 inch series.
OS Map Publ. 1909. Revised 1907/08. 25 inch series.
OS Map Publ. 1936. Revision of 1909. 25 inch series.
Dublin City Council Parks Service OS Map 1868. 1888 revision. Coloured.
OS Map, undated. Revised layout of 1987. Survey & Mapping Section.
11. Bibliography A Literary Guide to DUBLIN, Vivien Igoe, Methuen, 1994.
DARTMOUTH SQUARE AND ENVIRONS Architectural Conservation Area (ACA)
(Adopted Variation No. 23 ACA Dartmouth Sq.)
Dublin City Public Libraries and Archive website.
Encyclopaedia of Dublin, Douglas Bennett, Gill and Macmillan. 1991.
Four Roads to Dublin, Deirdre Kelly, The O’Brien Press Ltd. 1995.
Irish Architectural Archive, Merrion Square, Dublin.
Library, National Botanic Gardens, Glasnevin, Dublin.
Loreto Archive and Hockey Club website, Bronwyn O’Donnell, Club Vice-President.
ULARA newsletters archive, courtesy Carmen Neary, Chair, Dartmouth Sq. Res. Assoc.
The Rivers of Dublin, Clair L. Sweeney, Dublin Corporation 1991.
UCD School of Archaeology Reports Archive.
Various newspapers and websites for the recent ownerships saga.