Download - CUNY #$$ Not All Pronouns are Resolved Rapidly Online ... · Not All Pronouns are Resolved Rapidly Online! Joshua K. Hartshorne & Jesse Snedeker! CUNY!"#$$! %&'()!*+',-.('/01!2+33+!4!5/06070'1!89:;

Not All Pronouns are Resolved Rapidly Online!Joshua K. Hartshorne & Jesse Snedeker!

CUNY!"#$$!

%&'()!*+',-.('/01!2+33+!4!5/06070'1!89:;<!"#$#=!

• >+3?6!('60'@(A@)0/B(/!0C0D,-!+'0!'(EF-,!?/!+6FG,.((6!+/6!D.?G6.((6H!

I5+GGJ$!K0/,!,(!,.0!-,('0!K?,.!L+'J

"H!5.0

$!E(FM.,!-()0!?D0!D'0+)HN!

!"#$%&%'(&)*+)$%',!0C0D,-!+G-(!'+3?6!?/!+6FG,-H!%:(OP?/1!:())+/60F'1!Q(/7!4!2(('6)+/1!"#$$R!S(('//00A!4!T+/!80'7F)1!"##UR!!

! ! !!!!!!!!!!VJJ77(/0/!4!W+'T?7?T?1!"#$#R!Q+/!80'7F)!0,!+GH!"##X=!

!!!!!!-FEP0D,@E?+-06Y!I5+GGJ$!A'?M.,0/-!L+'J

"!E0D+F-0!-.0

$!?-!?-!A'()!:+)E'?6M0HN!

!!!!!!!!(EP0D,@E?+-06Y!I5+GGJ$!G?70-!L+'J

"!E0D+F-0!-.0!?-!A'()!:+)E'?6M0HN!

89Z!?)3G?D?,@D+F-+G?,J!-,F6?0-!-.(K!'0-(GT?/M!,(!$-,@)0/B(/!?-!A+-,0'!,.+/!'0-(GT?/M!,(!"

/6@)0/B(/H!

!!!!@80D+F-0!(A!+/!(T0'+GG!['-,@)0/B(/!E?+-\!

VG+/Y!!!!$=!>03G?D+,0!2V$!+6T+/,+M0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!"=!:(/,'(G!A('!('60'!(A!)0/B(/H!

-.#/0%"/1'(2!Q?-F+G!K('G6!3+'+6?M)!%Z+/0/.+F-!0,!+GH1!$]]^=H(

3)+4(@ !;?-,0/!,(!-,('?0-!K.?G0!T?0K?/M!-D0/0-!!!!D(/,+?/?/M!,.0!)0/B(/06!D.+'+D,0'-!

@ _J0!)(T0)0/,-!'0D('606!%Z(E??!-J-,0)=!

_`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!%-FEP0D,@E?+-06=!T0'E-!!

!!!!!D(/AF-01!A'?M.,0/1!-D+'01!-F'3'?-0!

_`30'?0/D0'@-FEP0D,!%(EP0D,@E?+-06=!T0'E-Y!!

!!!!!+6)?'01!G?701!G(T01!.+,0! !"#$%&'()*+&",-,&.*$/&01234&5*2%1+*&+3*&(+&+123&%&6(2*&7($',&8%6&/#1&9#(6:&:#&3*$;<&

"#!

a#!

b#!

^#!

U#!

X#!

c#!

dE+-0G?/0e!

L+'J!

A0+'-!

5+GGJ!

T0'J!

)FD.!

E0D+F-0!

-.0!

?-!

-FD.!

+!

-?GGJ!

M?'G!

M?'G!!f!"##)-!

;((7?/M!+,!-FEP0D,!

;((7?/M!+,!(EP0D,!

2g"c!

-.#/0%"/1'(5!h'0!0`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!T0'E!-0/,0/D0-!'0-(GT06!)('0!iF?D7GJ\!

!!!!('!

h'0!?-!'0-(GT?/M!,(!$-,@)0/B(/!0+-?0'\!

<0-?M/!

9-0!3+--?T0!-0/,0/D0-!?/-,0+6!(A!+DBT0H!

!!!!@I<HjH$!?-!G?706!EJ!<('+

"!T0'J!)FD.1!E0D+F-0!-.0

$!?-!-FD.!+!/?D0!M?'GH!:+/!J(F!3(?/,!,(!.0'\N!

6/+*$'Y!&+-,0'!'0-(GFB(/!A('!0`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!T0'E!-0/,0/D0-!%'03G?D+B/M!3'0T?(F-![/6?/M-=H!

6/+*$'Y!$=!>0-(GT?/M!,(!$-,@)0/B(/!6(0-!/(,!)+70!0`30'?0/D0'@-FEP0D,!T0'E!-0/,0/D0-!A+-,H!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!"=!_`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!T0'E!-0/,0/D0-!A+-,!0T0/!K.0/!'0-(GT?/M!,(!"/6@)0/B(/H!

89Z!L+JE0!3+--?T0-!(A!3-JD.!T0'E-!+'0!F/F-F+GH!%L+'+,-(-!0,!+GH1!$]c^=!

-.#/0%"/1'(7!k)3G?D?,!8#6+*=1*6>%'(:/!%5,0K+',1!V?D70'?/M!4!5+/A('61!$]]c=(!!!!(EP0D,%?-.=@E?+-06Y!I80D+F-0!5+GGJ

$!A'?M.,0/-!L+'J

"1!-.0

"!?-!'0+GGJ!M(//+HHHN!

((((((((((-FEP0D,@E?+-06Y!I80D+F-0!5+GGJ$!G?70-!L+'J

"1!-.0

$!?-!'0+GGJ!M(//+lN!

k/A0'0/D0!'0A0'-!,(!*?*2:!/(,!,(!D+F+*H!

"#!

a#!

b#!

^#!

U#!

X#!

c#!

dE+-0G?/0e!

80D+F-0!

L+'J!

A0+'-!

5+GGJ!

T0'J!

)FD.!

-.0!

?-!

'0+GGJ!

M(//+!

.+T0!

,'(FEG0!

E0?/M!

!%A'?0/6-=!

;((7?/M!+,!-FEP0D,!

;((7?/M!+,!(EP0D,!

2g"c!

2g"c!

6/+*$'Y!$=!5G(K!A('!E(,.!T0'E!,J30-H!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"=!8F,!/(!-,'(/M!E?+-!A('!0`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!T0'E-H!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!@500)-!,(!E0!6F0!,(!,0/-0H!

6/8/0/1&/+!$H!h'/(G61!WH_H1!_?-0/E+/61!WHmH1!8'(K/@5D.)?6,1!5H1!4!Z'F0-K0GG1!WH:H!%"###=H!Z.0!?))06?+,0!F-0!(A!M0/60'!?/A(')+B(/Y!0J0,'+D7?/M!0T?60/D0!(A!,.0!B)0@D(F'-0!

(A!3'(/(F/!'0-(GFB(/H!8#76(>#61!XU1!8$a@8"UH!"H!h'/(G61!WH_H1!8'(K/@5D.)?6,1!5H1!4!Z'F0-K0GG1!WH!%"##X=H!:.?G6'0/n-!F-0!(A!M0/60'!+/6!('60'@(A@)0/B(/!6F'?/M!3'(/(F/!D()3'0.0/-?(/H!@%671%7*&%6A&8#76(>.*&B$#2*++*+4&CC4&DCEFDGD,!aH!*+',-.('/01!WHSH1!2+33+1!>H1!4!5/06070'1!WH!%"#$#=H!h)E?MF(F-!3'(/(F/!3'(D0--?/M!60T0G(3)0/,Y!V'(E+EGJ!/(,!F@-.+306H!V+30'!3'0-0/,06!+,!89:;<!a^H!

bH!S(('//00A1!hHjH1!4!T+/!80'7F)1!WHWHhH!%"##U=H!o/!,.0!F-0!(A!T0'E@E+-06!?)3G?D?,!D+F-+G?,J!?/!-0/,0/D0!D()3'0.0/-?(/Y!_T?60/D0!A'()!-0GA@3+D06!'0+6?/M!+/6!

0J0!,'+D7?/MH!H#1$6%'&#I&J*0#$/&%6A&@%671%7*1!^b1!bb^@bU^H!^H!L+'+,-(-1!LH1!&(`1!<H1!80D70'1!WH1!4!:.+G70J1!LH!%$]c^=H!50)+/BD!'0-,'?DB(/-!(/!D.?G6'0/n-!3+--?T0-H!8#76(>#61!$]1!$UX@$]$H!UH!V0-0,-7J1!<H!%$]]^=H!K*$#&L/6:%MH!:+)E'?6M01!LhY!Z.0!LkZ!V'0--H!

XH!VJJ77(/0/1!VH1!4!W+'T?7?T?1!WH!%"#$#=H!hDBT+B(/!+/6!30'-?-,0/D0!(A!?)3G?D?,!D+F-+G?,J!?/A(')+B(/!?/!-3(70/!G+/MF+M0!D()3'0.0/-?(/H!_M9*$(0*6:%'&B+/23#'#7/1!^X1!^@$UH!

cH!VJJ77(/0/1!VH1!L+p.0K-1!<H1!4!W+'T?7?T?1!WH!%"#$#=H!Z.'00@J0+'@(G6-!+'0!-0/-?BT0!,(!-0)+/BD!3'()?/0/D0!6F'?/M!(/G?/0!G+/MF+M0!D()3'0.0/-?(/Y!h!T?-F+G!

K('G6!-,F6J!(A!3'(/(F/!'0-(GFB(/H!@%671%7*&%6A&8#76(>.*&B$#2*++*+1!"^1!$$^@$"]H!]H!5(/M1!*H@PH1!4!&?-.0'1!:H!%"##^=H!j.(n-!I-.0N\!<?-D(F'-0!3'()?/0/D0!?/qF0/D0-!3'0-D.((G0'-n!D()3'0.0/-?(/!(A!3'(/(F/-H!H#1$6%'&#I&J*0#$/&%6A&@%671%7*1!^"1!"]@^XH!

$#H!5(/M1!*H@PH1!4!&?-.0'1!:H!%"##X=H!<?-D(F'-0!3'()?/0/D0!0C0D,-!(/!"H^@J0+'@(G6!D.?G6'0/n-!?/,0'3'0,+B(/!(A!3'(/(F/-H!;(671%1!$$X1!$]^]@$]cXH!!$$H!5,0K+',1!hHWH1!V?D70'?/M1!LHWH1!4!5+/A('61!hHWH!%$]]c=H!k)3G?D?,!D(/-0iF0/B+G?,JH!k/!B$#2**A(67+&#I&:3*&CN:3&O661%'&8#6I*$*62*&#I&:3*&8#76(>.*&L2(*62*&L#2(*:/!%33H!$#a$@$#aU=H!L+.K+.1!2WY!;+K'0/D0!_+'GE+F)!h--(D?+,0-1!k/DH!

$"H!Z+/0/.+F-1!LHSH1!53?T0J@S/(KG,(/1!LHWH1!_E0'.+'61!SHLH!4!506?TJ1!WH_H!%$]]^=H!k/,0M'+B(/!(A!T?-F+G!+/6!G?/MF?-BD!?/A(')+B(/!?/!-3(70/!G+/MF+M0!

D()3'0.0/-?(/H!L2(*62*1!"Uc1!$Ua"@$UabH!$aH!Q+/!80'7F)1!WHWHhH1!S(('//00A1!hHjH1!op0/1!LH1!4!2?0FKG+/61!LH5H!%"##X=H!_-,+EG?-.?/M!'0A0'0/D0!?/!G+/MF+M0!D()3'0.0/-?(/Y!h/!0G0D,'(3.J-?(G(M?D+G!

30'-30DBT0H!

9:1&$*+%:1+!

• V'(/(F/!'0-(GFB(/!?-!/(,!+GK+J-!A+-,H!!!!!!!@2(,!0T0/!,(!,.0!$

-,@)0/B(/H!

• >+3?6!'0-(GFB(/!?/!?)3G?D?,!D+F-+G?,J!)+J!6030/6!(/!D+F-+G!-0)+/BD-!A('!,.0!T0'EH!

&F,F'0!6?'0DB(/-Y!@Z0-,!?)3G?D?,!D(/-0iF0/B+G?,J!?/!3+-,!,0/-0!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!@Z0-,!(,.0'!-FEP0D,@E?+-06!?)3G?D?,!D+F-+G?,J!T0'E-H!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!@Z0-,!(,.0'!(EP0D,@E?+-06!?)3G?D?,!D+F-+G?,J!T0'E-!%0HMH1!PF6M)0/,!T0'E-=!

;((7?/M!+,!-FEP0D,!

;((7?/M!+,!(EP0D,!

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18

Speed of First-Mention Effect

Tim

e A

t Su

cces

sful

Res

olut

ion

Mean Age of Participants

(Song & Fisher, 2005)


(Pyykkonen & Jarvikivi, 2010)

(Hartshorne, Nappa,& Snedeker, BUCLD 2010)

(Arnold et al. 2000)

(Nappa, Hartshorne& Snedeker, in progress)


(Nappa, Hartshorne& Snedeker, in progress)

(Hartshorne, Nappa,& Snedeker, BUCLD 2010)

D.+/D0!

D.+/D0!

D.+/D0!

r! r!r!

r! r!r!

r!!!!!!!!r!!!!!!!r!!!!!!!!r!!!!!!!!r!!!!!!!r!

!!!!_`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!T0'E-!0/D(60!D+F-0!!!A+-,!'0-(GFB(/!(A!?)3G?D?,!2%1+%'(:/\!!!!!_`30'?0/D0'@-FEP0D,!T0'E-!6(/n,!0/D(60!D+F-0!!!-G(K!'0-(GFB(/\!%-00!V0-0,-7J1!$]]^=!!

!!!!!!!('!

!!!!_`30'?0/D0'@(EP0D,!T0'E-!+'0!0+-J!,(!3'(D0--!!!A+-,!'0-(GFB(/\!!!

!!!!_`30'?0/D0'@-FEP0D,!T0'E-!+'0!.+'6!,(!3'(D0--!!!-G(K!'0-(GFB(/\!!!!!!

Download - CUNY #$$ Not All Pronouns are Resolved Rapidly Online ... · Not All Pronouns are Resolved Rapidly Online! Joshua K. Hartshorne & Jesse Snedeker! CUNY!"#$$! %&'()!*+',-.('/01!2+33+!4!5/06070'1!89:;

Top Related