Download - comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
1/26
Group 8
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
2/26
The assets of the Indian banking industry have increased over five times between March
2000 and March 2010 ( US$250 billion to more thanUS$1.3 trillion.) The industry has
recorded a CAGR of 18% as compared to Indias GDP growth of 7.2% during the same
period.
The industry has become more efficient and productive over the years. It should be noted
that Indian banks remained flexible and were not badly hit by the financial crisis which hit
the western economies during 2008.
The D&B report said the annual growth rate of old-time private sector banks stood at 7.1
per cent in assets, six per cent in deposits and 12 per cent in advances.
The commercial banking assets to GDP ratio has increased to nearly 100 percent while the
ratio of banks business to GDP has recorded nearly twofold, from 68 percent to 135
percent
The new age private sector banks such as HDFC, ICICI, and Axis have dominated the
growth with a year-on-year growth of 38.7% in the assets and 38.8% in deposits and 39.9%
in advances as of 2008.
Old-time private sector banks fared better in terms of profitability which stood at anaverage 30 per cent.
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
3/26
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
4/26
GDP growth moderating to near 5% Subdued Industrial growth
Current account deficit leading to exchange
rate volatility Monetary policy: increase in short term rates
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
5/26
Established in 1996 by the Industrial Credit and Investment Corporationof India, an Indian financial institution, as a wholly owned subsidiary. The parent company was formed in 1955 as a joint-venture of the World
Bank, India's public-sector banks and public-sector insurancecompanies to provide project financing to Indian industry.
In 1999, ICICI become the first Indian company and the first bank orfinancial institution from non-Japan Asia to be listed on the NYSE.
ICICI Bank Limited is an Indian diversified financial services companyheadquartered in Mumbai, Maharashtra. It is the second largest bank in India by assets and third largest by
market capitalization. ICICI Bank is Indiaslargest private sector bank in market capitalization
and second largest overall in terms of assets. The bank has a network of 1,626 branches and about 4,883 ATMs in
India and presence in 18 countries.
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
6/26
The Bank has a large footprint of 2402 domestic branches(including extension counters) and 12,922 ATMs spreadacross the country as on 31st March 2014.
The overseas operations of the Bank are spread over itsseven international offices with branches at Singapore,Hong Kong, DIFC (Dubai International Financial Centre),
Colombo and Shanghai and representative offices at Dubaiand Abu Dhabi. During the year, the Bank has upgraded its representative
office in Shanghai, China to a branch to become the firstIndian private sector bank to set up a branch in China.
Axis Bank is one of the first new generation private sector
banks to have begun operations in 1994 With a balance sheet size of Rs.3,83,245crores as on 31st
March 2014, Axis Bank has achieved consistent growthand stable asset.
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
7/26
Continued investment in key enablers: Branch network of 3820 (largest in private
banks)
Nearly 11000 ATMs Largest rural branch network
Increase in branch based origination of retailloans
Cautious approach to SME & corporatelending
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
8/26
The Bank continues to scale up its retailbusiness and invest in strengthening thefranchise and distribution infrastructure
Granular retail deposits resulting in relativestability in funding base and costs even involatile markets
Healthy growth in retail fees driven by liability
fees, third party distribution and asset linkedfees
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
9/26
Leveraging social networking platforms Advanced mobile banking platform
Enhanced ATM functionality
My Savings Rewards program Money2India mobile app for NRIs
24*7 electronic branch
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
10/26
profitability
Continued focus on
granular deposits
Low credit costs
Sustaining feeincome growth
growth
Healthy growth in
secured products
like mortgages and
auto loans Strengthening of
deposit franchise
Continued
investments in
physical andtechnology
platforms
Risk management
Secured lending
portfolios driving
growth
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
11/26
ICICI Bank (in Cr.)
Mar '10 Mar '11 Mar '12 Mar '13 Mar '14
Interest Earned 25,706.93 25,974.05 33,542.65 40,075.60 44,178.15
Change
0.010391
0.291391
0.194765
0.10237
Total Income
32,999.36
32,621.94
41,045.41
48,421.30
54,606.02
Change
-0.01144 0.258215 0.179701 0.127727
Employee Cost
1,925.79
2,816.93
3,515.28
3,893.29
4,220.11
Change 0.46274 0.247912 0.107533 0.083944
Total Expenses
28,974.37
27,470.56
34,580.16
40,095.83
44,795.55
Change -0.0519 0.258808 0.159504 0.117212
Net Profit for the
Year
4,024.98 5,151.38 6,465.26 8,325.47 9,810.48
Change
0.279852
0.255054
0.287724
0.17837
Total
6,834.54
8,615.76
11,483.44
15,379.70
19,712.77
Change 0.26062 0.332841 0.339294 0.28174
Earning Per
Share (Rs)
36.1 44.73 56.09 72.17 84.95
Change
0.239058
0.253968
0.286682
0.177082
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
12/26
Customer convenience and cost effectivecustomer delivery
Advanced use of technology
Continue to build and strengthen RetailBanking franchise
Leverage leadership position in Infrastructurelinked Financial services
Build a full-service offering to SME customers Capture end-to-end opportunities in
Payments across customer segments
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
13/26
Branches ATM
Point of sale
Internet banking Mobile banking
Call centre
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
14/26
sales
Relationship
ManagersBranch leads
Credit appraisal
Business Proposals
processed throughdedicated credit
cells at 32 SME
Centers
Proposals rated
and vetted byindependent Risk
team
Post sanction and
monitoring
Disbursement &
Monitoring byseparate
Corporate Banking
Operations Team
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
15/26
Axis bank (in Cr.)
Mar '10
Mar '11
Mar '12
Mar '13
Mar '14
Interest Earned
11,638.02
15,154.81
21,994.65
27,182.57
30,641.16
Change 0.302181 0.451331 0.235872 0.127236
Total Income
15,583.80
19,786.94
27,414.87
33,733.68
38,046.38
Change 0.269712 0.385503 0.230488 0.127846
Employee Cost
1,255.82
1,613.90
2,080.17
2,376.98
2,601.35
Change 0.285136 0.288909 0.142685 0.094393
Total Expenses
13,069.27
16,398.45
23,172.66
28,554.24
31,828.71
Change 0.254733 0.413101 0.232238 0.114675
Net Profit for the
Year
2,514.53
3,388.49
4,242.21
5,179.43
6,217.67
Change 0.347564 0.251947 0.220927 0.200454
Total
4,862.62
6,815.92
9,211.98
12,508.88
16,246.93
Change 0.401697 0.351539 0.357893 0.298832
Earning Per
Share (Rs)
62.06 82.54 102.67 110.68 132.33
Change
0.330003
0.243882
0.078017
0.195609
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
16/26
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
2011 2012 2013 2014
ICICI
Axis
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
17/26
Productivity is defined as the goods and services produced
per unit of labour, capital or both. The ratio of output tolabour and capital is a total productivity measure. In simplewords, productivity is the output per unit of input employed.The basic definition of productivity is:
Productivity =
Major Indicators of Productivity
Employee Productivity
1.
Deposit per Employee: This ratio reveals the deposit-collection capacity of anemployee. Higher the deposit peremployee ratio, higher the productivity per employee.
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
18/26
Table No. 1 (Rs. in Crore)
Years ICICI Axis Bank
2007-08 6.00 5.94
2008-09 6.31 5.70
2009-10 5.73 6.53
2010-11 8.38 7.18
2011-12 10.11 6.94
Average
7.31
6.46
CAGR 11% 3%
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
19/26
2 Advances Per Employee: These ratios reveal the contacts andconvincing skills of theemployee to disburse and invest the amountdeposited. This only ultimately results in the interest earning capacityof a particular bank. The deposits cannot be maintained unless they are
advanced for productive use by the people. As this entails involvementof employee time, this is also considered to be a ratio to measure theproductivity. Again higher the ratio, higher the productivity. The ratiosare as follows:
Table No.2
Year ICICI Axis Bank
2007-08 5.55 4.05
2008-09 6.31 3.95
2009-10 5.14 4.82
2010-11 8.03 5.41
2011-12 10.05 5.35
Average 7.02 4.72
CAGR 13% 6%
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
20/26
3- Advance +Deposits Per Employee : Deposit collection and theadvance disbursementare the two basic activities of any bank.Moreover, The productivity of any bank is related to the creation anddelivery of capital. Here creation means deposits and delivery meansadvances. Both together are the net measure of productivity. If this ratiois higher, the employee of the bank is better and the productivity of thebank is more.
Table No-3
Years ICICI Axis Bank
2007-08
11.55
9.99
2008-09 12.62 9.65
2009-10 10.87 11.35
2010-11 16.41 12.59
2011-12 20.16 12.29
Average
14.32
11.17
CAGR 12% 4%
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
21/26
Branch Productivity
While evaluating the results in terms of infrastructural facilities utilizedby the banks at various locations, places, again eight indicators havebeen used. A brief summary of these ratios are as under:
Deposit per Branch Ratio: A Branch is the initial organizational unit inany bankwith similar environment and clientele. This also follows thesimilar policies, methodologies and structure in a particular bank. Inorder to smoothen out the individual differences, this seems to be abetter unit for measuring productivity. It reflects the organizationaleffectiveness of the bank. Higher the deposit per branch, better the
system of collection and vice-versa.Table No. 4 (Rs. in Crore)
Years ICICI Axis Bank
2007-08 192.31 134.6
2008-09 152.48 141.24
2009-10 117.52 136.52
2010-11 87.95 129.62
2011-12 91.91 132.83
Average 128.43 134.96
CAGR 14% 00%
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
22/26
2.Advances per Branch: In addition to employee skills, the loan policiesas well asinterest rates etc of a particular bank also affect advances.This ratio reflects this aspect of the bank. Higher the advances perbranch, better the advance policies and hence the productivity.
Table No. 5 (Rs. in Crore)
Years ICICI Axis Bank
2007-08 177.51 91.65
2008-09 152.45 98.14
2009-10 105.41 100.81
2010-11 84.35 97.54
2011-12 91.27 102.45
Average 122.20 98.12
CAGR -0.12 0.02
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
23/26
3- Total Business per Branch: Advances and deposits of a branchtogether reflectthe overall banking system and its productivity. Thisratio compares the productive efficiency of two banks. Hence, Higherthe ratio, better and more productive the bank.
Table No-6
Years ICICI Axis Bank
2007-08 369.82 226.24
2008-09 304.93 239.4
2009-10 222.93 237.33
2010-11 172.31 227.15
2011-12 183.18 235.28
Average 250.63 233.08
CAGR -0.13 0.01
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
24/26
Comprehensive Analysis of Productivity ratios
Productivity ratios ICICI Bank Axis Bank
Deposit per employee
Advances peremployee
Advance + Depositsper employee
Deposit per branch
Advances per branch
Total business perbranch
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
25/26
Recommendation:
o Decrease costs and grow revenues in highly uncertain economic times.
o Operations departments should focused on substantially reducing the unitcosts of the key drivers (e.g. cost per current account). These reductions canbe achieved through a combination of automation, outsourcing.
o Longer-term sustainable cost reduction measures, such as straight-through
processing, first-time resolution and self-service channels.
o Eliminate paper, automate processes and retire physical infrastructure toright size their operating environments.
o Value chain and corresponding IT architectures should be in industry-widedata standards.
o Customer data held by one bank must be held in a format that enables it tobe processed simply and accurately by any other bank, as well as by anypotential new structures.
-
8/10/2019 comparing ICICI & Axis Bank
26/26
Thank You