-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
1/37
Brill is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Numen.
http://www.jstor.org
On Hindu, Hindustān, Hinduism and HindutvaAuthor(s): Arvind SharmaSource: Numen, Vol. 49, No. 1 (2002), pp. 1-36Published by: BrillStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3270470Accessed: 21-03-2016 01:17 UTC
F R N S
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:http://www.jstor.org/stable/3270470?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents
You may need to log in to JSTOR to access the linked references.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/ info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of contentin a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/http://www.jstor.org/publisher/baphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/3270470http://www.jstor.org/stable/3270470?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contentshttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/stable/3270470?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contentshttp://www.jstor.org/stable/3270470http://www.jstor.org/publisher/baphttp://www.jstor.org/
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
2/37
O N HN DUHN DUTA N HN DUM A N DHN DUTVA
ARVNDHARMA
ummry
T h p p r ou o x m n h m rg n nd g n f n of h w ord H ndu
n d o d r mno ogy n d our bou nd n ord r o d rm n h gh
h d on wh urr n y h pp n ng n n d on u d h h w or d nd
d rv v on n r of m n b v n h r r d by unr o vd
n o n nd fur h r h h n on h p oun for h omp x g n r d
b y h n du o n of h w or d H nd u n d o d r m no o gy n m o d m n d n
po d o ur
H nd P n m An v o f nd n gro b k Ar b n n d n
o rE hop n G n oo H ndu v h f d
b k
H nd u n P n m n d h o un r y of H n du
F r o o n U rd u En g h D o n ry
A C om pr h n v D o n r y of C ur r n V o b u r y
K r h F ro o n n d p 8 21
T h wo rd H nd u w h d fo rm o n u h H nd u n H n
du m nd Hndu v h om o p o un u v n n h
on x o f nd v n d n d o u h wor d nd Bhdr
Ar yd o rM dh yd y no ny m of H nd u n W C m h
9 6 2 2 5 6Tk ku u 1 9 6 6 1 18W nk19 9 0 1 2 8 8N hru 1 9 4 6 4 9
Ary dh rm nd n D h rm o r u D h rm u v n of
H n du m J f fr o 1 99 6 18 n r o n 1 98 9 15 R n o u 1 95 3 4 8
n d n d nn o rH nd u n op o n fo rH nd uv L pn r
1 99 6 1 12 1 1 3 N p 1 99 9
Why
K on n k k B r N V L d n 2 0 0 2 N UM EN V o 4 9
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
3/37
2 A r v n d h r m
Ar gu b y h r r b u of h w ord H ndu p p r n h
Z n d Av J k o n 1 92 2 3 24 3 2 5
T h f r h p r of h A v n V nd d d wh v r my b h g o f h
h p r on n n u o n o p or o nof Nor h rn n d n wh h g v
o f x n n d or r g on r d by Ah ur M d n d pp r n y r g r dd
un d r r n n w y T h f f n h of h do m n o rd ng o V d 1 1 8 w
H p H nd u v n R v r r g on of b n or m h p ro b by d n
w h h rr ory of p ndh v v nR v r n h V d p y
R v V 2 4 27
A n o nb w n w o g nf on o f h rm Hn du r d y
r f d n h wo x p n o n off r dof h o u rr n G or g
T ho mp on 1 99 9 h r n y r gu d h h mp r o n of h
no n b v r fo un d n bo h Av n d h R gV d m y u y
r f h r g ou d ff rn of h w o ommun h m n
n r pr on wh h r d y mp r o h r m r g o u f vo ur O n
h o h r hnd n n o mm n ry mp r po rr or
rn g o T h v n H nd uk n h xp r o n v n H n du kn
du o h f h h ov r ord hp r x r v n nd
h r for do no y v n Rv r for h m n f from h
Av p g J k on 1922 324
On of h r d b d ngu h dfrom r b r fr
n o h w ord H ndu g n om f rom P r w h h r of h
A h m n d E m pr H W R w n o n 1 95 4 53 5 4 A n n r p o n o f
D r u w h h on d r d o h v b n r vd b w n 518 n d
51 5BC dd H du H ndu o h o f ub oun r R y h ud
hur 1 996 58 4 m r y y b from P r po n E m
d b o dff r n y r f rom h h r n h o h w n y g h hr g
n y r o fD r u m n o nH n u n d b 5 85 T h x mp
b h n g h p r m y of h r r or m n n g r o nf rm d by
H r od o u H o r 9 1 94 9 8 10 2 n h mp oym n o f h
word ndo n Gr k w h h k ng n p h b h r r of
h o un do fh d d no n h pr r v N r y n n 19 96 14
H pr d dby H u 5 20 BC h f r o mn on nd
m on g u r v v ng G r k w r r H G R w n o n 1 98 0 1 9 13 2 0 5
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
4/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 3
T h r v d n h X rx 486 465 BC on n d u or of
D ru d roy d nc ury of h D v or f d vn c
cordngtothePersanconceptRaychaudhur 1996586 butthssanc-
u ry w u d no n H n u H n du or o w r nd u r g on b u n
G n dh r b 5 8 6
On o f h n wy d cov r d o n b P r po r cord h X rx By
Ahur m d w pp d h f ound on o f r n mp of h D v nd
ord n d h h D v h no b w or hpp d Wh r h D v h db n
w or h p p d h k n g wo r h pp d A hu r m d o g h r w h R m d v n w o r d
ord r n d m y h v b n m ong h n d wh h w n d h o u o m of
h r g ou of h P r n k ng
Th nd w on fn d o nd f or w un dr X rx
h f or h f r m n h or y n n d n x p d o n ry for c fou gh
o n h o o f Eu ro p n d v n or m d h b ood yd f of
h rmopy Th nd n r r u o h rmy w r d by w o
n m G ndh r n nd n d n h r by o nf rm ng h wh h
f or m rw r f rom h p rov nc o f G nd hr d p r
p ro v nc h n d n w r f ro m h p r ov n c c o n ro d b y h
P r n m pr o h of h ndhu nd d r b d ndhu n
h A h m n n n r p o n M uk h r 1 9 51 4 2
T h w o rd H n d u d r v b y c om mo n c on n f ro m h w or d
nd hu r m rk b h h d r o no f r n fo rm o no f n dh u
*H ndu n d p r d n h oun o f h B uddh p gr m
X n u ng = H u n T n g 7 h c n ur y b y h w or d Sh n u H n
u *T n c hu nd v n m or u rp r n g h b c om n u
wh ch po n conno on ov rf ow n o h r g ou n
n u n g n r p r o no f B 1 96 9 18 84 6 9
N m o f nd
On x m n o n w f nd h h n m o f nd T n h u r v r ou n d
p rp x ng o h r u hor y w n n y d h n u o H n u bu
now ord ng o h r gh p ron un on d n u T h p op o f n u
h r o un r yb yd ff r n n m o rd ng o h r d r E h o un r yh
d vr u o m Am ng g n r n m wh h h b ound ng w w
h o un r y n u n C h n h n m g nf h M oo n Th m oo nh
m ny n m of wh h h on For d h v ng hng y
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
5/37
4 A r v n d h r m
r vo v n h w h o f r n m g r o n h ro ug h h o ng n g h o f gn or n
w hou gu dng r h r k h wor d h un gon down h n
h or h fford onn ng g h hough h r b h h n ng of h r
h ow d ff r n f ro m h b r g h o o m oo n u o h b r gh o nn d g h o f
h oy m n n d g g ud ng h w or d h h n ng of h m oo n h v m d
h oun ry m n n n d o d n u
h u or p gr m ng h ow v r r mr k om y n du
m n h m oon nd h C h n n m for n d ndu d r vd
from hough m ym n h n v rh no h ommon
n m T k k u u 1 9 66 1 18
A o n o n u d h r p d u r v y of h w or d H nd u n h
n n p r od wor h on r ng h d ff r n m n d n
of h m word n h nd h w ndhu b om nd n
Gr k u r ng p ur y r r or r f r n n v r o mpr om d on
u rd bu n h b o m n du n Ch n n h p ro
u r ng r g ou mb n
T hu n h n n w o r d h f o rm o n f ro m h o r g n w or d
ndhu b fur d m n y o ng dff r n n h w or d r v
d o h w nd h n P r n nd Gr k p on
h w or db m gn f r of r g o n wh h w r r d o h
ow r ndu n h of h r yP r n nd x n dd o o vr h
who o f nd n h of h Gr k n Ch n p on
p o d r g ou d m n o n x p n d by X nx un g Wh n n
d m n on w hAr b n d r h m wor d h m
w or d n dh u g n g v r o w o wo rd w ho m n n g b m
o h mor d n nd mor d wh n o mp r d o h u g of
h n n w or d r y ng H nd h rough n d o d no h
n d o f nd n d H nd u fr om n dh u o d n o h f o o w r o f r
g o n h ough no w h ou om o vr p d u d r
Th f r u pr d d h ond n d w k nown H nd n
r m A rb W nk 1 99 0 1 19 5 6 n d o n u n y h w or d
H ndu m p ym n n n d n un u r d r g ou on no on
BN Sharma1972128 EvenafterthewordH nduhadacqured
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
6/37
O n H n d u H n du d n H n d u m n d H n d u v 5
r g o u o nn o o n o n nu d o b u d yn on ym fo r
n n d n n o m p r o f h wo rd n f o rd ng o W f r d
C n w m h h u of H ndu n h m n ng n d n u rv v d
n po pu r E ng h n o h w n h n u ry n r m mb r
b oy h n C n d w d r m n d r d n d n fr om H nd u
nd n n d n n d h v h r d h p hr H ndu Mu m
d n gu h d f r om n A r b o r T ur k h M u m 1 96 2 25 6 o
Lo r n n 1 9 95 1 2 T h n d n o u r pr h w o rd n dh u
o rg n y h d g og rp h r f r n n do n n r n ow mu
fo u on wh n n dh ow m n gd o u r r g o u g n f on
Th u of h w or dH ndu n h n n b d d w h o m
p r o n b g n w h h A r b n v o n of n dh b y Mu h mm d b n
m n 7 12 T h d m n r v r r ng m n w h h Mu hmm d
bn Q m m d w h h n on Mu m f r h v o ry ov r D h r
r o f nr f rr d o h B rhm nb d m n T h b
p rn p w o r h H ndu p op of h b ook n d o o nf r
on h m h u o f mm h p ro d k rm 19 64 11 T h
H nd u no ww r p op w ho fo o w d r g on o h r h n m
R gh h r h w ord d p y n m bgu y wh h r n o h
d y n m y u nr o v d r o nw h h B ud dh Fo rw h n
H Muh mm d bn Q m mb o u f h r n w n dv roy
of h w r n pr ov n pp ro v d h r u fo r rp r n g d m g d
mp h r f r o h f of b ng p on dby h h f nh b n
f Br h mn b d o b o wd o r p r h m p o fB ud h nd o
p ur u h r r g on k r m1 96 41 1 h B udh h r h m
B uddh n n y wh ru h bo h H ndu n dBuddh
wou db mm r g rd d dh k now h d ff r n o
w or h no n g h o rd ng o o n r y Mu m h o r n h A rb
o n u ro r o un n n d v n h p r v g d p o o n of h B r hm n
no on y nr g ou m r bu o n h dm n r v p h r
k r m 19 64 1 1 T h g n f n o f h A r b o n u o f n d fo r
h ub u n h or yof n d r o un d n h f o ow ng p g
o of g n f n f or o ur x r
Th o n u o f n d b yM uh m m d bn Q m n d h n o rp or o n of
h prov n n o h M u m un v r ph brough h H ndu nd h
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
7/37
6 A r v n d h r m
Mu m h r n r on h pof v r y dff r n n u r h of h r u d
nd h r u r T h for mof po r on h p wh h o m n ur r
x n d d o h w ho ub o n n n nd u rv v dun w n o h gh n h
n ury n v b y d o h r on of n o n wh h d r mn d v ry r g y
h p y h o og o ur o f h h o ry of m d v n dm od m n d Ah md
196477
N o on y h H n du no w d n f d o n r g ou b o nv r o n
from h H ndu r g on now b o m p o b h b n r d
f or n n h Muh mm d bn Q m bo d nnov on w h
p po n m n o f k r h f or mr m n r of h v n u h d d v r r y
R f Dh r h dv r f r k rh d p d m Ahm d
1 96 4 1 01 C o b o r o n w h n o n H nd u ru r o b m p o b
u r d by h of K k R Ddh r n ph w A o rd ng o
n r y h o r n h w rn d mn n d p h o oph r of Hnd
Wh n h m o r n bu n Muh mm d bn Q m u d o
m k h m b for h h ron nd h n o n u h m n d Kk ook
r d n n h rmy b for h n ob nd o mm nd r H
o d h r v n u of h oun ry n d h r ury w p d und r
h H d Muh mm d bn Q m n h u nd r kng nd
w d dr d by h o fm ub r k mu h r pr o pr ou o un o r
krm 1964 1 0 1 1
A nd f M uh m m d bn Q m o m r r d R n L d D h r
w do w h u b o m ng h m r of Lo wr n d b 7 h n
p r nof Hndu Mu m n r on w p u n p wh h b m
r h y p n o m w y w h p ro fo un d mp o n fo r h m n ng
o f h w or d H nd u h ou gh m r u o v r n d d dn o o n g u rv v
M uh m m d b n Q m d h M u md r 1 9 70 1 7 2
wh nw r h h n x ph of m on w h nd h
m o r d vd u rf A N r y n G up 1 99 9 10 3 10 4 n o
f h on b o r M bu o mo nd n p r o on
nd h wo p M H ndu nd m v on n d
h k on o mn h b y M hmu do fGh n n 1 02 5h h m
mo v gn f n h T ur k o n u of Con n n op n 1453
h d fo r o nv n o n E ur op n h o ry T hu n h m o f M h m d
o f Gh n r 9 9 8 10 30 h w o rd H n du o n n u d o n r g o u
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
8/37
O n H n du H n d u n H n d u m n d H n du v 7
m n o ur n y A o rd ng o P r v p r M hm ud o n u
u p n nd n m nd r d o n of Mu m n o r nc n h
o pu r H n du m nd f r om n ow o n M u m w n o r n
B n w v r o u or R p u br v P rh p h h n o f h
u m on vr o nof nd o m w o n h d n of M hmud
do b r k n g 1 97 21 03 4 T h h ow v r u m or b ou h
v o v ng m n n g o f m fo r h H n d u h n h v o vn g m n n g of
h r mH nd u Fo r h w h v o u rn o h f m ou h o r A br Un
97 3 1 04 8 w h o w p r on d b y M h m d n d w ho r f r o H n d u
o ur r g ou n g on h u 1914 1 7 n h pr f of h
m u h u d db oo ko n nd n h bo ok f h ow v r h m d o
d r b w h h o b rv d p h no mn oo g y w w ou d
n ow o h on ou d d u w h h H ndu u on o fr g on
n or r u r on h v ry b of h r own v on 1 914
2246
A brf n oun n r gu ng W f nd h mwr n gw h u
wh h b d v h udy of H ndu m o h d y To on y f w
1 Wh w h r o n hp b w n H ndu m n d Bud dh m
A b rf n d n gu h b w n h w o 14 0 12 1 24 9 32 6 bu h
do no f o no h h B uddh r o r o h H ndu h n
h M u m H w r n r kng p g 1 21 m ph dd d
o M uk h r 1 9 61 2 2 2 3
Ano h r r um n wh h n r d h r d y x n g n gon m b w n
H ndu nd for g n r h h o d h m n yy B uddh hough h y
ord y h Br hm n r n r r k n o h m h n o o hr n form r
m K hu rd dn P r r k M o u h o un r yu p o h f r on r of y r
w B ud dh b u h n Z r h u r w n f or h fr om Ad hr b n n dp r h d
M g m n B k h B k r H d o r n m n o f vo ur w h K ng Gu h p
n dh on f n d yd p r d h n w f h bo h n nd w bo h by for
n db y r H f ou nd d f r mp h ro ug hh w ho mp r f r om h
f ro n r o fC hn o h o o f h G r k m p r T h u d ng k ng m d h r
r g o n Zoro r n m h o b g ory r g on for P r n d rf k
n o n u n h B uddh w r b n h d from h o oun r n dh d o
m gr o h o un r of B kh
2 W h o p k f or H n du m A o r d ng o A b r f n h m n
nd mo n p on o f h H n du wo rd of h oug h h wh h
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
9/37
8 A r v n d h r m
r hm n h n k nd b v for h y r p f y r n d for
pr r vng n dm n n ng h r r g on And h wh w h
x p n v h b f of h B r hm n h u 1914 1 39
r h who p k f or Hndu m w n u h n now
h oug hA b rn h o o r o v n h o w nw y 3 H ndu m
r d o r n h n r g on A b r n d r b H n du m w h gu o
bu w h n om o d fn ng h r r prob m A on p on h
v r ow rd r d d fn on 1 50
A h w o rd o f o nf o n T h r n o go d bu G o d M uh m m d h p ro ph
h h bbo h of m h Tr n y h o fChr n y n d h n u of
h bb h h of Jud m o m m p yho h h bbo h of h H n du
r g on T h r fo r h w ho do n o b v n d o n o b o ng o h m n d
n o r k on d o n of h m
B u d dA brm n no k now h h B uddh o b v d n o
h r w r b k o h prob m of h f u d bound r Th u o n
v n mor omp x for h d r p on r y f o h n r n
d v r y o f H nd u m On o f n n o un r u h x pr o n
om H ndu b v o h r ho d h mor r d on v w h
H ndu d ff r mon g h m v om H ndu m n n
ord ng o o h r h ommon p op d r b h h ng
h du d Hn du d ono h r h op non om H ndu
y o hr h v o dm f w now p f rom h d of h
d u d p op mo ng h H nd u o h o o f h o mmo np op w
mu f r h h y pr n gr v r y 1 61 63 82
1 0 4 1 7 5 1 7 6 3 2 4 2 1 5 2 3 1
A bru n m o b o ng b w n wh R h rd H Dv h
d r b d n r nd p ur v w o f ppro h n gH ndu m
r d y n r m of h d n on D v 1 995 6
C n r d n fy ng p n nd n m or o r h g mon or hodox r d
o n r n m d pr m r y n n k r n gu g h f y by m mb r o f h b r h
m n Th r d o n n r round V d n g of x n wh h r
n ud dno o ny h V d h m v bu o h M m m D h rm r
n dV dn orpu of x nd h ng V d r f h pr v g d
mo d of r u ondu h mp for ub u n n d n r u m V r ou
g ro up mp oy ng v rn u r n gu g n pr f r n o n k r u o nn g
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
10/37
O n H n du H n d u d n H n d u m n d H n du v 9
h ord r n dr ng h u hor y of h V d m yp rod y rb
g n h n r b u h o r ho do x h ro ug h n d p u o f n u o n n dr
p r v o r n m n g o ho d h h g h gr oun do fr g ou u ho r y
O n h o h r h n d 1 99 5 6 7
Th p ur by o n r nv o n d n r d profu o nof d nd pr
o r d n d n o r po r d u nd r h b g n o f H n du m N o m or
on m n of h v w n b f ound h n h of h m nn n kr
h o r J AB v n B u n n n h 1 98 6E n y op d B r n n n pr n p
H nd u m n or po r fo rm o f b f n d wo r hp w h ou n n g h
o no r m n o no f ny T h H nd u n n d o r v r h d v n y n
v ry mn f on wh v r m yb nd do r n y o r n H ndu m
h n bo h v on n d ong om r o n of r g on w h n h r b
g n n ng f ou nd r n o r n r u h or y h r r h y o r or g n o n
T h u g o f h w or dH ndu n h u b u n p r od r n h
w o mb gu 1 w h h r r f r o r g on or r g on n d 2
wh h r r g on o b und r ood n n r or pur
m nn r T hu d ur ng h D h u n 1 20 0 15 26 h w or d
H nd u on h o n h nd d n o d r g on o n h o h r r g on n d
mp rn h mb v n o ng o gr p hy f h A r b n r v r b n
B o b b v d H h H ndu Ku h Hndu k r
b m k no wn u h b u o f h n umb r of n d n v w ho
p r h d n p n g E n B r 1 96 7 1 1 51 4 H G R w n o n 19 80
1 913 19 3 n ow W ou d h nd n v n o h v b n mo y
Hndu
By h m h D h u n w r p d by h M oghu Emp r
f r h d b n o no d d by Ak br h G r r 1 55 6 16 05 h
u o n of d f n ng H n du m o n g n b g n o p o h k n d o f
pr ob m h b for nd n A w known x o f h p r od
h D b dn m h b wh h mp n ov rv w of h r g ou
n d p o f h m pr r fn H b b wr J oh n dJ oh 19 94
3185
T h r w r h r g ou r d o n o mn gf ro m n n n d w h h b y Mug h
m b g n o b d r b d un dr h r m Hn du T h u ho ro fD b n
M h b h r dpu o d r b wh h b f of H ndu r nd u m y
h k h r n v ry o nv n n p o on H ndu r ho who h v
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
11/37
1 0A rv nd h rm
b n r gu n gw h h o h r w h n h m f r m w or k of r g um n o v r h
n ur f h y r o gn h o h r p r on w hom w n h r u ppor o r
o pp o n r g ou r gum n h n bo h p r r H n du T h J n h oug h
h y r d Br hm n m w r H ndu b u h y w r r gu ng n d
o m ng w h Br hm n u h r gum n w r no k ng p b w n
H ndu n dM u m T h M u m d d no h r n yb r mn oo gy w h h
o h r M u m h d h r ow nf rm wo rk n d o o g fr m wo rk h m
frmwork
n r y o n rodu bro d r on d r on h po n
wh h w pr ov o b of ng g n f n A h ough on u
om d o o ok ng h nd n h or r y n r m of H n du
Mu m p o r y h mu w y b mp r dw h r o gn o n
of h p u r m w h h h r r d n d T h r w r w y m ny
n dk ng do m n d f r 1 00 0 u h r o ud b
w h h r n o H n du o o o h r o u d b k n gd om w h h w r n o
H nd u Bu u h b ro d fr m wo rk of mu p o ud
ommo d b rr o n or d v o n or x p o n o o u d h m u
p k n gd om o mm od h n w M u m k n gd om h r b y o n
nu ng r h r h n r p n g h r d on of n n m r m of
n n pr M u m n d B h m 1967 123 p rh p wo rh
omp r ng h u on n n d w h h n Ch n h r nd o r o g
n h n kr on dff r from n on n h mor
p ur u n r y pr o R ud op h1 98 77 41
Th o p ur m of nd h po p ur m of mu p
k ngd om o p y d off h o h r o p ro du h m o u o m
h m or T h gn f n of h f o ow ng f n n gd p
b yond h v o f h n d o n h gh h h ono
M h m d o fG h n p r m d m g w or h p o h H n du u b
n h r p r u r r n h o wn p Ahm d 196 490 n d
hr H ndu g n r un dr N h n dT k r o o po on
o f hgh r p on b y n h Gh n w d r my 1 0 1 n d h w h
F rf T u gh u p ur u d h o r p o h bo dy gu r d on d
of R p u h d d by Bh r B h r v o fh m o h r 1 02
no b n g m d h r h h H n du n d Mu m o mmun
hd v o v d n o or o w rd n g u u r n or h o ppo
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
12/37
O n H n d u H n d u d n H n d u m n d H n d u v 1 1
b ng m d h h yr m n dpo p r b n h v n r of
ord Th m mu hmor mod h h o po
nd r g ou p ur m of h nd n r y ow d for r n
m ur o fp rm b y m b y n df ud y wh h m y hv
b n ub u n y o r kr 1 99 62 77 2 78
T h p ro b m o fb ou nd r w h r p o H n du r g o n n g n r
d ff u o n n d m o b o m m or o d ur ng r y m d v
o r m d v / r y mod m pr od r wh h r h b
g ro un d b w n o n v n o n n d pr og r v h o r n n n d
n ow d y O n nu mr ou o o n H nd u n d Mu m r n o
d ngu h d u h wh ommun w h n h m r dur ng h
r y m d v p r o d C h o p dh y y 1 99 8 T h p r d m n o f
h r y Mod m p rod n h r g rd r b nd d by h
h d h h 3 5 0 00 r on g o m mu n y o f H n d u Mu h m m d n
n Gu r u d f or h B omb y n u u pr n n d n
19 11 o n o un o f n x r b o mb n o no fmu p
pr b f nd v n f df n o n Th r w pu d up
h r p y by h u p r or n u o mm o n r E A G w ho o rd r d
h o on of h p r on on r n d o h o n or h o h r
b h o ud r k r1 99 91 69 4 H r o O br o h d r wn
po n d n on o h p of fu dr g ou o y n h r y
o d m p r o d 19 94 1 9 88 1 36 1 58 w h h W m H m n
x p r n d f r h n d n 1 84 9 wh n h p d h r ou gh B h r h H
h ough r ng h H ndu h ou dr v r h Mu m hr n
h r o f y yd r mu h h M u m A o ur H ndu mp
fo ow r p d m uh rv rn o h h rn h yp d h
M h om d n T h H n do o w or h p p d n y g n o fm n f d
m gh o r po w r h ou gh x r d g n h m v W nk 19 90
2133
Th p on h n h n h p r 1 900 p rod r ommo
d o no fn on H nd u m n n g n r n dM u m n p r u r
w p o b h o nd po v Mor ov r h r d
on h m v h H ndu n dMu m w r p ur n n u r
f w h h fu r h r o n d d w h h p ro n dfu r h r d
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
13/37
1 2A rv nd hrm
u h o mm od o nw n o on g rpo b f r p on u nd r
B r h r u H n n 1 99 92 9ff b u o f m u n o u d v o pm n
of h o n p o f n o n n d of mo no h r g on T h f r d v
opm n m n h po d ff r n b d on r g on o ud no b
ommo d d r g o n y G v n h m rg n o n p o f n o n h y
h d ob d w h h n o n v n h ngu r Mor ov r h
ono h on of h H n du n d m r d o n o d o ff h f
ur o f d u mn b w n h m o y nd o y n dm d h m
f nd h n onfron h oh r ng on o d d n Th
ru by wh h h g m h d o b p y d now w r r d y r d
b o h n r m o f h p y r n d h p y n g f d K o ff 1 99 0 J ff r o
19 96 B y y 1 9 8 5 r k r 1 99 6 L 1 99 5 J o n 1 9 8 1
m po r n o n r ru p h d u o no f h r g ou g nf
n of h w ord Hndu o b r u md r o g n
n o h r wo rd w h h h d b yn ow o m n o p y n m y H n du n
A w d o o w m g h do w o r o gn h n h w or dH nd u
w o nfr on d w o mb gu o r d ou b m b gu y 1 w h h r
gn f g ogr ph or r g ou r f r n n d 2 f d no
r g on h n wh on u
Th w or dH nd u n m y w r v m p ho ro f h f r
mb gu y T h w or d r y m n h n do f h H n du N g
n d B ur m n 1 94 7 1 1 n d h d b o m o mm on w o rd f or n d
p y nor h nd by h h r n h n ury r h n u r
u r y how h w or dH ndu o b k n h r r d n o f
g o gr p h r g o n W nk 1 99 0 1 12 5 o r h f o o w r o f
pr u r f h or h r d n of p r u r r gon who o
h f o ow r of p r u r f h r n v n 19 89 13 3 A h
n r p o b b u of h r m ndou d mogr ph ov r p
b w n h wo gor U m y h m n ng rm n un r
On mgh n y hnk h n u on o p n n h
word f wou d or n m n ng g ogr ph y Th nd d o
B h m 1 96 7 1 2 N hr u 19 46 3 35 b u h g n f n o n n u
o r m n doub dg d for ou d b k n o m n h r h
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
14/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 1 3
b od o f n d n F ry k n b r g 19 8 93 1 o r h b od o f h H n du
M on r W m 1 960 12 98 T h m n o u db m d h r
d r p v y o r p or v y d p n d ng on ho wo n f b ou h
H ndu M u b 1967 331 h b n u d n h n nd
v n f o r un d v d d n d N h r u 19 46 5 4 3
W r n o don y w h h wor d for n d v f orm
n du n op n up n o hr v of m n ng f on n of h
wo rd H nd u n n ud n d n n d no h r H nd u h n n
d v f orm m o r h ou for n w h hr on bo h
n d p y H ndu w h M u m T h mo obv ou n h p r
P r on propo h nd ngu f rn b H ndu n w h h r
m dd our b w n n kr ng Hnd nd P r n n g
nd A r b n g Ur du h n gu g o f h u nd v d d u b on n n
n h n o fh pp y omp ro m h w or d m o go b k f w
n ur B bur f or n n v n h ough h h nd n H n du
n d Mu m o g h r h d v o v d h r o wn w y o f v n g o g h r
w h h o h r by h m h f oun d o n o f h M og hu E mp r
w r d by hm n nd H d h H ndu n w y h rv v
198112
V
fw w h o o nn h h h r o h o r d u on of h
r m H n du n d H nd u n w h f r m od m n d h n o n m po r ry
d v opm n n nd h n on ru u on n d o b k d n
o rd r o m k h r n on w hn d d h H ndu h m v b g n
o u h w or d f r f r n y g r n ng h h w or dH nd u n o
Hnduword
Th k y u on h n wh n dd h H n du r u n g h w or d
H nd u fo r h m v
uh u g bg n o m rg by h x n h n ury
p o n d o u b y J o p h T O C o n n 1 97 3 3 40 3 4 3 B u R E
F ryknb rg o b rv 1 9 8 9 30
Bu h r pp r o ny n x d r bng p od o f r n d r on hp b
w n Hndu n v nd Mu m for gn r Y vn or M h
T h rm w r o d w n v r u d by Hn du mo ng h m v o d r b
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
15/37
1 4A rv nd hrm
h m v mo r ov r h r m H nd ud h rm w h h o u r v n m f our
m n B ng x w o n yu d n h m w y nd nv rw h n y xp
d f n o n or d u o no fw h H ndu o f H nd ud h rm f m n H nd u
dh rm h rfor h o r mb n o h rm Hndu m wh h n
b f o un d o h v r n o u o f nd g n ou o ur w h n n d
h ow v r po b o d n f y h f u o f h w or dH nd u n
n v n r r p rod
r h by h x n h n ury H ndu w r r f r rng o
h m v H ndu E kn h 1 548 1600 wr f my f
H nd u w b b n up n dM u m m no H nd uK h n
m r y m u m n b h n h J o h n d J o h 19 94 3 1 89 E r r o n
v r r u r o fV y n g r h d k n h H ndur dy ur r dn
u n of h H nd uk ng n m o no f h u n o f M du r n d
h B hm n u n h rf 1989 79 M or pr y o u r n
f v n r p o n f ro m h r g n o f B uk k r 1 34 4 1 37 7 W g o n r
1 996 861 862 n d u n o b r d n f our by k ng
o f V y n g r f ou r h n d d yn y h A r v d u 1 57 0 16 49
w h n o h r f v u n h n r v n ng p r od n u dn g om b y
K r h n d v r y r 1 50 9 15 29 b 8 62 n 8 n o m n r p o n o f
B uk k h p r f x Hn du o d ro pp d b 8 63 T hu b g n n n g w h
3 52 h n o n f or mo r no h r o n nu d n u by Buk k
u or for 250 y r hrough h r h n g n d yn y
b 8 6 2
Th xpr on n o n r y fr from m bgu y bu g n r
y p d h ur r n n kr d form of m u n
A o rd ng o V undh r F o wh h wou dh v b n
g v n o B u kk b y h M u m n g hb ou r W g o n r 1 99 6 86 2 A
ord ng o H rm nn Ku k m k y h h r y kn g of V
y ng r d m o u m ong h H ndu R u o h o f
u n mo ng h M u m ru r b 8 62 P h p B W go n r p r
p rd om k rong r m nd ugg h bo h u n
nd u n m on g h H n du K ng w r u d n mu h mo r r
nd dr r h r h n homo og n m n o fpro m ng
h h V y n g r ru r o ud u y b o n d rd u n n o
n rm of r v po und r n dng bu n on r rm of
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
16/37
O n H n d u H n d u d n H n d u m n d H n d u v 1 5
ub n nd y n pr u r h h ndurdy u r r n wou d
h v r v d o d ff r n b r r f ro mo rd n ry H nd u n d
k ng gn n gh w ngn o pr p n h po d o ur
o f m v o n b 8 62 W g on r h ow v r r n d r H ndu
nd on n y w h h v w h h H ndu v Mu m rh o r n
h h o ro gr ph yo f h V y n g r m pr h b n o v rd on b
851 852 T h m yw b o nd h u k u o h h r of
h m r f w formu h u fo ow h ow H ndu n h x
p r o n H nd ur dy u r r dn o b u n d r o od W g o n r fo u o n
u r rd n w n d o f o u on h w or dH ndu h H nd uh r
n n d n o r n f o o wr of H nd u m n m b gu y n o un r d
r r n h P r n w or d H nd u n W C m h 1 9 62 2 56 f or n d
do m n h nd of h nd n o rof Hndu h ou d r
Pr n u n h fr n b d bu nd n h m v o n
h ond wh n on m gh y d r b h p r on of nd h
d v o n of H nd u d n n o P dk d n n d H nd u d n H r r v r
n oun r d P k n m y k H ndu n o m n b oh h n dof
n d n n d of H nd u m u n o u y b u n d n w ou d n h
u o ny n h fo rm r n fo r nd n n u v o fb o hH nd u
n dMu m b o h nh b p r n d y H nd u n
n n h rfor h u r m n w hu bu n n oh r n
r o v d H ndu r r yu n g h wor d o rf r o h m v
h ough wh h r h y r u n g o r f r o h m v g ogr ph y
u u r y o r r g ou y m y no b n r y un pr ob m N v r h
h h r r g ou o mpon n n h u o n wh ou d
b x gg r d W C m h 19 62 25 7 n no b d n d O n m y
p ro po h b y h f o ur n h n u ry h u o f h w o rd H n du d d
n u d n m n o fH ndu f o n o u n
T h o f h v 1 62 7 16 80 n r o n o h M o gh u Em pr
p ro v d n n r n g x m p K n g A kb r r 1 5 56 1 60 5 f rm y
b h d M og hu r u o v r n d H w k no wn P dd h dh n d
h r u Pdd hh H or n h v d r b d h v f m on
n m r rm on o f b h n g H ndu pdd hd h rd
1974 26 3 n r wr n n 1646 AD h v d r b h
r n d r m nor h o b h H nd v v r y v rk r
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
17/37
1 6A rv nd hrm
969 57 W h v m ng o b h H ndu f ru o r n d n
fru Or w h h h oppon n w p r v d
f or g n r bo h by n g n dr g on h r w n on d o dr w u h
d n on
Our k on h nd h ow v r no o r y o n w r h u on
b u o n o h h mb gu y n r o n o h w or dH nd up r
wh n H ndu h m v r o u h r mAnd bo h h mb gu
p r no w y r wh h r h o nno on g ogr ph
o rr g ou nd no w y r wh ompr H ndu m
f h r f r n n r m of f h h p p n o b u nm bgu ou R h r d
K n g n o 1 99 9 1 62
A h o ug h n dg n ou u o f h r m by H nd u h m v n b f o un d
r y h f f n h nd x n h n ur u g w d rv v o f
P r n M u m n fu n nd d dno r p r n ny h ng mor h n d n on
b w n n d gnou o r n v nd for g n m h For n n wh n
B g n T h rry V rh n r v w d n n d n n u f rom T m N du h
r o r d d h f o o w ng n r h n g
Q A r y o u H n du
A No gr w r of b u o f m A u y you hou dno
k p op f h y r H ndu T h d o n o m n mu h f y ou k h m
wh h r r g on h yw y b ong o h
H g o o n o y b 1 63
n d d r h h rm H ndu v n wh nu d by h nd gnou n
d n d d no h v h p f y r g ou onno on wh h ub u n y
d v op d und r Or n nf u n un h n n n h n ury Th u gh
n h n ur yr f r n o H n do o Ch r n o r H n do o Mu m w r n o
u n om mo n A R om T h p r po n o u n h r d u o n of h r p o n o f
Mu m n o nd Th p o p o f nd d o no m o h v p r v d h n w
rr v u nf d b od yo fM u m T h n m M u m d o n o o ur n
h r o rd of h r y on Th rm u dw h r h n uru k r
f rr ng o h T ur k o r g og r ph Y v n o r u ur m h O n h ou d
o n o h d n v y n g v n ur o f h r m h p rm ry fun on of
w h h o prov d h d g n o nfor h O h r wh h r n g v y
on r d w h h n n P r n w h h r Mu m d nd n o rw h h
r Europ n O r n who v n u y dop d h r m nd d h m
p p r n f ro m n x m n o n of m od m n d w F or x m p h 1 9 55 H n du
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
18/37
O n H n d u H n d u d n H n d u m n d H n d u v 1 7
M rr g A on 2 1 d f n H ndu gory n u dn gno o ny
Buddh J n nd k h b u o n yon w ho no Mu m C hr n
P r o r J w T hu v n n h o n mp or r y on x h r m H nd u n d
Hndu m r n y ng v pp on f un o nng n n u v
r ub r f o r h n o n Ju d o Ch r n o h r
V
D p h k of r y or b u of h word Hndu f r
b r f p r od o f f r o n w h o h r w or d M r h 1 97 0 w
dop d by h Br h o h r r h ng n nd p y
m n n df u r f ou nd n h u u r n dr g on o f n d
wh h w r n o Mu m n o C hr n n o J w h or h n no
W r n F r y k n b rg 1 98 9 3 1
now m o p u n d k o k b for w v n u r n o
h B r h p r o d By x m n n g h h o ry o f h w o rd H n du
nd u g b o m o bv ou h h w or dd d no om n o
o mm on u u n f r 1 0 00 A D D u r ng h p r 1 0 0 0 p r od n d
r pr n d ng po o r g o u u r n y P nd 1 984 170
p r 1 972 93 ub u n y u gr du y p r d n u h w y
h b y h gh n h n ur y b m ommon o u o nof n
u d b y bo h n d r n do u d r W C m h 19 62 70 o d no
r g o u u r o mp x w h h w d n f ro m o d ff r n f ro m
nd om m d m r y oppo d o h m p r n
n r g o u ur rm f h p r n of no hr r g o
u u r o mp x now o h r r d h nd n m y h m
Th B r h pr n n n d n r odu d n o h rr g o u u r o m
p x on o pof n m y W r n/Chr n U p o p on h B r h
r n n n d o u d mo b on d r d b ngn y nu r f no
u y pr oH nd u fr om H nd up r p v h v n b n p u
b y rgu d h h C omp ny R w u y f or mo n n nd
p ur po d f o H n du R F ry k nb r g 19 89 3 4
By h m n v r h ng h h R n mp r y m of ru w
g n un y n d g no u r h r h n mp y f or g n or o on o n r u h
hn w m or n d n h n Br h n nn r og r g rd of x r n
n r f r n n dv o o n of h og b y Br n p y dur ng h C rown
pr od of h R h n rm of r g ou n u on nd gnou nd
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
19/37
1 8A rv nd hrm
o for of k nd w r b o r v r o gn o n nd pro on w
p on on f rom h nd mor ov r h h yh db n b
o d o h n d r p ro po r o n o h r b y w h h r b y po w r of n f or m o n
on ro n umb r n o k or w h o n f un o gov rnm n
A br h op n u p f r 1 81 8 h y r n wh h b o h h M r h
C onf dr y w d f d h r by m n ng h m or h
ng o Br h p rmoun y n nd nd o h y r n wh h J m
M pub h d h f mou m u v o um w ork n y n d Th
H ory of Br h n d w h h w r y p h p g n H ndu m
D v 1 99 5 46
M H o ry n m m n n d ho ro ug h nd m n f or h n d n p op r d
o u fy h n d f or Br h ru mo ng po pu o n up po d y un b o
g ov rn f M p y o nd mn d H nd u m b m ng fo rm uh of wh
w w rong w h nd H ndu m r u up r ou rr on nd pr
r dd n M h rg d h p mp y on r n g w h h d v r on
of Ch r n y h h b v d o b h h gh form of r g on For v r
d d h E n d C om pn yp ro vd d o py of M o m o n w C omp ny
off mb rk ng for nd o u n h m n h r n of r nd u ur
u p r or y w h n h o on y
Th u f r n n p h o fH ndu y mp h y h r u r r u d
r on hp m o h for b y ff ng f no w rp ng h
r p o nof h W rn /C hr n r g o u u r omp x w
n o w d y r ogn d hou db h h 1 818 18 57
pr od w h r r d by n n n ffor o o nv r n d or
h n d n rmy o Chr n y hough h f r p od
o f h r u r n of h u pp o d g o f o mn h f r om Gh n d ur n g
h f r A fg h n W r u n d r Lo rd E n bo ro ug h o f d ur n g h
p r od n m b o n h w o ny b n do n dw h n h n d n M u ny
r d h k for bdd ng y n f rn hou db n o d h
h M u m w r b m d d p ro po r o n y f or h ou gh b o h
H ndu n dMu m poy w r r d w h u v r y dur ng
h u pp r o n T h o nd w v o f H n du y mp h y o n h p r
o f h Br h b b dw h h r of n o n m for wh h h y r
1 8 85 n w h h h n d n N o n C o ng r w f ou nd d p r ov d
o n v n n b n h m rk
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
20/37
O n H n d u H n d u d n H n d u m n d H n d u v 1 9
Th up ho of h d v opm n w h f h no h r
r g ou ommun y p r f rom h m n m y h C hr n h d
o b n r d Wh n d o b r yr ogn d n h on x
h r o o fpo n po ng h ommun n n oppo on
r h r h n n p po o n f r m wo rk n r o n o h H ndu T h
x n o f h Jw n d P r f o h f h m nor
r n o u n kn ow n o h H n du b u h y d d n o p o p ro b m fo r
n du po y b u h r pr n w n o v d by h r u r
ru d po f o rUn h f or m rg d v n m
p r n w no p r v d prob m Ar b Mu m r d r on
nd o b w n h v nh nd nn h n ur w r r d
w h o r n by H nd ur u r n d h g nd of h o nv r o n of
Ch r m n P rum R h ow h h y w r o wd o p ro pg
m on M u m on rbu d fn n y o H ndu
mp Ah md 19 64 77 E v n n h n or h h r p r n
o r d on n r n od n r n h h r of U r Pr d h h
Mu m f m h d d h r o ng bfor h on u of h
r b yM uh mm d Gh ur n h y of B n r h r r M u m
moh wh h d r n r or nd o h on u o f
B n r b y Mu m nd m r r d on r urr n bou M n r
n Bh r k r m1964 32 E vn f r h r dpo u o n n
h n or h m d h M u m p r n p ro b m fo r h H n du
d d no ff h ou h Th u Abdu R k h P r n m b dor
h V y n g r o ur o ud wr r oun d h m d d o f h f f n h
n ury T h P op or C u r n fd on u n y on d r
m y f n n n m y o un r y h M oh mm d n o n d r v ry on
who h n o r v d h Qur n Y dm h m w h p rf
o r on nd v n f vour w h v wo mo u nd r ow d
o pr y n pu b R dh k r hn n 19 39 31 2 m r y h yr n
C hr n pr n n n d d d n o po p ro b m fo r h H n du
bu E ur op n C hr n pr n b m p ro b m wh n Ch r n
b m r u r n d Hndu h r u d
T h f u d u o n ho w vr b g n o o d fy n h p o M u n y
pr od o n h r u o f h E n d C om pn yw k n ov r by
h B r h Cr ow n Th o n o d o n of Br h ru w o mp n d
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
21/37
2 0A rv nd hrm
by h on o d o nof H ndu m On n d o p b k o
ppr h d v o pm n
V
Th B r h pr n n n d h d p u n o h r wo rd n o p y
Hndu m Th d u o nof wh n w f r u d f nd v
of gn f n wh h on rov r y ur round ng r on h p
w h wh p for Hndu mor g nr y o h b h of
h p p r L o r n n 1 9 99 6 30 6 5 9 T h O x f or d En g h D o n r y
d n f u b yM x M r n 1 85 8 K ng 19 99 16 5 C h r
N um nn m p oy d n h o fh w or k n 18 31 b 1 65
Th O xford En g h D on ry d n f r r u n 1829
b b u D rmo K n g y d n f u b yR mmo hu nR oy n
1 81 6 n d u gg h R m mo hu n w p r ob b y h f r H n du
o u h word Hndu m b hough w r n o u r n
h h r w f r u d b y H n du B u h w or d oo n u gh o n
n dw h h n gu u nf o no f nd h ro ug hE ng h P n kk r
1 96 31 20 1 21 n d h n r n gu o fE ng h n n r f h v y
h n H nd u m H n 1 97 71 06 n d h v o f h m rg ng
En g h k no wn g H nn n d h rp 1 97 24 n h po
Mu n yp r od Th p r od o w h u mn on w r
o f h n um r o u r f o rm m ov m n b g n n n g w h h B r h mo
m f ou nd d n 1 8 28 n d u m n n g n h G n dh n d p n o n
d ng o n n r ng d n f on of n d nn on m w h
r f or m d H nd u m E v r 1 99 7 74 P n k k r 1 96 3 p m J n
1996 Ch Thu h u r r of h n n n h n u ry w n d
h m rg n o fb o h nd n n o n m n d p n n d n H nd u m
h r by r n g h u on of h r on hp b w n h wo
Th u w h h rm n unr o v d o h d y go b k o h
m bg u y n h r n n h w or d H nd u do n d fo r o un r y
or r g on T h f h bo h h word nd w H ndu
ymo og y go b k o h m w or d n dh u dr m h
u of m bgu y w h h now r n r n d f n h u o n
w nd n n o n m o rn on m b rr or or r g ou n
n u r T h m n mb gu y n h w or dH nd u f o fo un d
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
22/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 2 1
x pr on n h u on wh h r h n w Hndu m f w b
r oh or un vr n h r r
On n h u v u wo h nn ong wh h h n rg r
d by h m rg ng n o n for n n d o u dp y h m
v o u w h n h p o w r r dby h P r o no fB n g n 1 90 5
p r 1 99 47 59 O n h n n o ng wh h h n o n n r g
ou df ow w h o f r r or n o n m n p r o n r pr
n d b y h n d n N o n C on gr An o h rw r p r n d by
h A n d M u m L g u f or md n 1 90 6 mo r n n w h h
op o n h nn of r g ou n on m A h ough h r w n n
H n du r o n o o mo v n h d r o n J ffr o 1 99 66 19
w b y h k d b y h r of G ndh n n fu n Ev r
1 99 7 73 n n d n p o f ro m 19 20 o nw r d n d h p r m y wh h
h n d nN on C ongr b g n o n oy h r f r D E m h
1 96 34 56 n d n n dH nd un o n m b g n o d v r g f r h
o p of h K h f mov m n M n u 1 982 T h Kh f m
p g n wh h b g n w h h M u m o n ng fo r w h h H n du
b fo r h n r du ou y o f h B r h p r 1 99 47 84 n 1 91 9
nd d n r o f o mm un r o b y md 1 92 0 P g 1 98 2 74
h f ou nd n g of h R n 1 92 5 y mb o d h b r h A nd r o n
n d D m 1 98 7 3 4
n h m n m n o H ndu m w b ng r vv d o ng n y
un vr n hough b m om wh r v v w h h
r of h Ary m N v rh h n d n N on C ongr w
b o on n h w n h 1 920 h n o Hndu m bg n o
d p y d n y h n r k n d vo vd w ord o go w h
Hnd u v
V
T h word H ndu v g n d u rr n y f r pp r d h of
b oo k wr n b y VD v r k r f r p ub h d n 1 9 23 V D v r k r
n dM h m G n dh m y b r g rd d h p r on n of h wo
d n f or m o fH n du m h m b gu y o f h w or d H nd u g v
r o P rdox m gh p p r bo h h r nd r o ou
o f h m p r ob m h o f d fn n g H nd u m A nd b o h w r
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
23/37
2 2A rv nd hrm
n n r p on o h mp d d f n o n of H ndu m un dr
W rn g
W rn mp d f nng H ndu m fo ow d w od n our
o n mo vd n h d r o no f d n fy ng w h B r hm n m
hrough nd h o h r n h d r on of d n f yn g w h p r
u y n g n r h ro ug h Hn du o r n T h yr f p r hp
h En g h nm n n d h R om n Mov m n p y r p v y
on h o nom h r of H ndu m no of n r d h
n o f h m o r on r n o f VD v rk r n v o v ng h o n p o f
H ndu v w o v od h p o f ou o f n x v y n rr ow
d f n o n of H n du m n h v w w h h h d h u nh p py o n
u n o f x u dng h B uddh h kh nd h J n f rom h
H n du o m m un y 1 9 69 1 06 B y o m p r o n G n d h d d n o h v
mu h r o ub w h h r n u o n w h n o r x u o n fr om H nd u m
b u f ro m h p on o f v w of h p r u n r p r o no fH n
du m wh h h pou d h w mm r A r g on h r d
n h p r u y n o mmo nw h H n du m r r p v o f wh h r
h y o u d fo rm y b b d H ndu or no F or n n w h n
R dh k r hn n po d h u o n W h yo ur r g o n n 1 93 6
M h m G ndh r p d My r g o n H nd u m wh h f o rm
R g on of Hu mn y n d n u d h b o f h r g on k no wn
o m R d h k r h n n n d Mu r h d 1 9 3 6 2
Th f u of VD v rk r r H ndu v W ho H ndu
d n f h wo or u w h hh d dr 1 who H ndu
nd 2 wh H ndu v Th wo u r onn d H d fn
H ndu on w ho 1 r g rd h n r ub on n n h or
h r m o h r n d /f h r n d v r k r 19 69 8 41 19 2 d n d d
o fH nd up r n b 1 29 13 1 n d 3 n d o n d r h n dh oy
b113 134 T h h n on u h hr n of Hndu v
ommo n n o n R h r o mmo nr J n d o mmo n
v on n kr b 116 N o h r g on do no f gur
n h n mb n d h u n of H ndu v r o h
d n of n o n y b 137 Th n ff of h x r
o o nf r H ndu n o n y on h f o o wr o f h f ou rr g on
o f n d n or g n H n du m B u dd h m J n m n d k h m
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
24/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 2 3
On m y w h o d n gu h h r b w n w o xpr on n
d nr g on nd r g on pr d n nd f h r gory
u d o d no H nd u m Bud dh m J n m k h m Jud m
C hr n y m n d o on h n h f orm r gor y ou db u d
o n u d o n y h d h r n o f h f r f ou r H nd u m B ud dh m
J n m nd kh m A o rd ng o h on p o f Hndu v b
or d by v rk r H ndu n o n y wou d b r r d o nd n
r g on n o n r pr u m b yw h n d n n o n y wh h w ou d
h r dby h f o ow r of r g on T h on n f ur of
H ndu v Th o h r no d r d y on of h f h po
n mp d n o nb w n r g on nd h w y u u r n
or d r o br k h f ou r n d n r g o n o g h r
v r k r v o n y m or bun df or o ng m o h x n o fb
ng o n d r d d d T h m y b o n w y o f x p n n g w hy W
rn ho r v n n h 1 960 w r u y d u d dby h r n
d n o gu from h ow ng n r n n ypo n d u ur
ou f o d w hH ndu v u h h J n n gh nd h R
A h b y 19 7 41 1 5 E v r n M r G n d h E m r g n y h o w v r
h org n on n h r v rou n rn o n h v b n n r m n
y r ng h r p rof nd now nd n r g h b g nn ng of
h n w m n n um J f fr o 1 99 6 D v 1 99 5 30 6 32 2 Kh n n
19 97 1 89 1 90 M o n d n n d W r n h o r f u n om fo r b
n d ng w h r g on g vn h r u r or n on n d h d om
for v r fur h r wh n om o fund m n m n r g on
Th und r n db b u h d o k of nu n n d n g w h
k y on p H nd uv p ro vd n x m p h r M o r g r d
o n u n g n dmo no h o n p f ro m1 92 3o nw r d wh n
w f r p ropo d Th r y h on x x n d ub x
h h n g d ov r m d p n d ng o n h p r o d n v ov d w h h r
h p ro d x nd ng f rom 192 3 1 94 7 o r1 9 4 7 1 9 7 5 o r1 9 7 5 1 99 1 o r
p o 1 9 91 n d h p r o n xp oun dn g w h h r V D v rk r
M G ow k r o r B r M d ho k fo r n n
U pu n h n m n of n d p nd n n 19 47 h h ru o f h
H nd uv m ov m n r pr n d b y h H n du M h b h n d h
R w f r o r wh w v w d po y of pp m n
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
25/37
2 4A rv nd hrm
o wr d h M u m n d o op po h m ov o wr d h P r o n
f nd wh h w v w d h o g ou o m of h p o y
D ur ng h ph h H n du v m ov m n w n o b ou g n ng
po pow r Th h f n H ndu v h n kng m bou r u
of rf on h w h wh h h p r y n pow r h nd n
N o n C on gr o ud u pp r h H n du v f or n h w k
of h n o n of Mh m G ndh n 1948 Th r on d
o h f or m o n o f h J n n gh n 1 9 51 J f fr o 1 99 6 87 G r h m
1 99 0 D ur ng h p r od wh n h J n n gh fu n o n d p r y h
o n p o f Hn du v u nd r wn n d o o g h f o ok h fo rm of
d n f yn g nd w h H n du v r h r h n H n du v w h n d A
r u h r w mu h k of h n d for n d n n g h C hr n
n dM u m m no r n n d r h r h n H nd u n g h m M dh ok
1969b T h m gh m k p ng p r u r yf n h r o h
ou d r bu r f d ub r gnm n w h nH ndu v hou d
b n o d h h n d n go vr nm n bo h n h n gu g o f h n d n
C on u o n dop d n 1 950 nd u b u n g on h v r u y
d op d h H n d u v d f n o n of H n du o n w ho b o n g o
n y r g o n of n d n or g n H n h n d n h mo dm u dy
o f H nd u m o d n gu h o n w h o H n du u nd r n d n w f ro m
o n w h o H n d u b y r g o n B r d 1 9 93 4 1 4 3 3 1 5 8 D r r
196846
T h m p o o n of E m rg n y b y Mr n d r G n dh o w rd h
nd of Jun n 1975 n w r of fo r n mo o n now
w d yh d h h o ny m or m n n pub f M r G ndh
o ud no u f u y up pr du rn g h E m rg n y d p v g
orou mp o do o w r h m n o d w hH ndu v
J ffr o 1 99 62 73 7 7 T h w h r y o un f or ub u n
g m on n h pub y D ur ng h ph h H ndu v for
w r r on y o n p f r h n w gov rnm n ook off b
u h yh dd d d o mrg h r d n y n h J n P r ywh h
o n d of h o mb n d op po o n wh h h d b n o r y v
o ro u n 1 97 7 On g n h H n du v f or h d g on u u r
h y h d b n p r or o n d p nd n n 1 94 7
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
26/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 2 5
Th H ndu v for h v w y b n ur n h r u u r
d n y h r xp po ro h yf un ur b ou O n
g n h po h d p d no h u u r gn f n y h J n
P r y b ro k u p ov r h u o f r u r n g f or m r J n n g h
m mb r o g o b yo nd f or m m r g r w h h J n P r y n d
or noun h r R onn o n wh h h J n n gh b k d
p ng h J n P r y n1980 Th u p y known
h d u m m b r h p u J f fr o 1 99 6 30 4 11
Th p r o d om m r f rr d o r u rn o p o un ou h
y o r gn y mm ng fr om h g u of b ng o d w h M
m Gndh n on Th p w o d d W h
h r m rg n o f h B JP f r 19 90 h u o n of d u m mb r
h p h u rf d g n n n o h r n d mo r o ng n fo rm n ow h
h B JP no ong r p o p r h n h f orm of n n on
h o n h nd h h n o b n don d n on h R m Tmp
Ar 356 n d h U nform C v Cod nd m on h o h r h
o mm d o h o mm on p ro gr m o f h N D A N o n D m o
r A n n wh h h B JP h y n hp n wh h x u d h
u
T h u o f du m mb r h p o bv ou y y mm r w h h
d ou b d k r g n f n o f h w o rd H n du n d n o r H nd u
h r u r fur h r omm n mor n r u o fH ndu v
d n y
V
Th u o f H nd uv d n y o b r fu y d n gu h d f ro m
h o fH nd u d n y b n v g d by x p or ng h h oug h of
h r m n d o og u o n h p on V n y k D mo dr v r kr
p op u r y kn ow n V r v r k r 1 88 3 19 66 M h d v d h v
Go w k r o h r w k no wn G ur u G o w k r d 1 9 73 n d
B r M d ho k 1 92 0 K o r m r 1 9 94 C h 3 0 K oh 1 99 3
Mdhok1982
Th b mp of v rk r h ough w p r n d r r o
o n n d o fo u o n h r n fo rm o no fh g y n h h n d o f
h o w h o fo o w d h m n h h n d o f G ur u Go w k r u nd r w n
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
27/37
2 6A rv nd hrm
wo n r n gmo df o n 1 H ndu d n y w pr omo d n h
hough h xp n o f d n y H n du v for h v o ok d
k n n g n r h o dng r p on b n good m u r for
h d o wn f o f h H n d u h o w v r K n 1 9 77 5 2 1 64 2 b u
mostHndutvareactonstot havebeenreformst Gowakars am
how vr w o b o h o o bu d n on df nd n
g gr g o f n dv du J f fr o 1 99 6 61 T h n o n h ow v r
no d f nd u r bu H ndu n on G ow k r d fn o n
of n on w m or r r v h n v rk r H ndu pp r n
h wr n g h n o n n nd b 56 2 u h n gr o n
n H ndu r m o r f d rong r n of p r o n fr om
o h r r g ou ommun w h n n d n on r o h o v r ur
V D v rk r md o h ommun on o un o f h r H ndu
g n Go w k r wr o b 56
Th f or g n r n H nd u h n mu h r d op h H n du u u r n d
n gu g mu r n o r p n dh od n r v r n H nd ur g on m u
n r n no d bu ho of g or f on of h H n du r nd u u r
o rm y y n h o un r y wh o y ubo rd n d o h H n du n o n m ng
no h ng d rv ng no pr v g f r n ypr f r n r m n n o v n
n r gh
f h ow v r h h n m n mph d n Go w k r h ough
h x pn o f h un v r h h r vr n om wy n
h h ou gh o f B r M d ho k M dh ok m m b r of h J n n gh
r omm nd d h hou d rnoun h n g h n R mod
nd p f d n y o u bm rg f n h d of H ndu r d
on m T h w o go hnd n h nd w h h nd n on n
f f H nd u o n of Mu m n dC hr n J ff r o 1 99 62 34
bu h w d nd n on on u gn f n d ff rn
n n u n f ro m Go w k r d o o gy
X
T h m h om o ry o r h vo u on o r v n onvo u
o n of Hndu v o h b h of h p p r h k h word
H nd u n n dH nd u m h w or dH nd uv o ug h up n h
m bg u y n d m b v n o f h w o rd H n du
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
28/37
O n H n d u H n d u d n H n d u m n d H n d u v 2 7
Po n dp nd n on p u d v opm n n H ndu v b y
ur no n wo d ff r n x o fr g on n d/o r u u r n dn o n
n d/or H ndu v h ough n g n r h r d o gn f w h
h u u r x n rm of h f r of r m nd w h h n on x
n h ond of rm O u of h r g on/ u ur d v o n u ur
ou db v w d bro d r gory u h n on wou db
v w d bro d r gory n r on o H ndu v h ough h n
h r d o o nn f w h h mor n omp ng of h p r d
g or v no on y h xp n of h o hr
g nd h b n o h r by o v h prob m of h p r n
o fn on H nd u m n n n d n o y n d po y pr m r y of
h M u m n dC hr n n d o nd r y of u h B ud dh J n
n d k h do no r p ond o h g n r n r pr on of h r m
H n du o ff r B y n v n g h m o p r k o n y of H n du u u r n d
o r g on w n o mk o y r for h ommun
o b om p r of h rg rwho k o omp h h m
n dp o y by d n f y ng f w h h p r o no fn o nh oo d
oppo d o h m h n ry of o h ou d h nb ong
o h H ndu n on n h r o n u d o y nd h ou d
h nb f f v y u r Bn r 1 990 133 gn f n h
h H ndu v rh o r o h d y h rg y nd n r y b n h of
n on H ndu R h r r h r h n of H ndu R v n h v
po k o f H nd u v r n o H n du R v r k r 19 69 5 7 T h k y
go ry n o H nd u m bu H n du n o n m J n 1 99 6
T h n r n o n r d o n o f h w o rd H n du h o w v r m p r
h x r wh h r on urn o r g on or u u r O n r u
mov v rk r n d w h nd ny o o H ndu m w h
u u r r h r h n r g on H mo v n do ng o w o r
o n p u g or yf or n d n r g o n d n gu h d f ro m
r g on p rc d n nd Bu w h h nd con u on y
h v d h ough n o n n o n oon v ov d h o u o n
o fH ndu u u r f rom w h n h p n d n d nr g o n o
mbr h r g on pr d n nd n m nn r n ogou o
h w y w mp oy d by v rk r o m br nd n r g o n
wh u d w h n H nd u m h ro ug h h o n p o f Hn du v
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
29/37
2 8A rv nd h rm
T h ur ou y o rr p ond o h u g n h gh n h n ury n
h g h of wh h d gn o n u h H ndu Mu m n d Hn du
Ch r n w r n o oxymoron w h h d ff r n h h m
n x p p n nd n d n y n r m of Hn du m w n o n h
p u r n ow h K n g 19 99 1 63 M h mo ud 1 99 4 75
T h h f n h r m of d o ur o r r w h h m
bv n wh h h h r r d h w ord n r r p p rn
H nd u H nd u d n n d H nd u m P h p H A h b y wr p r p v y
1974121122
Mo d m n r pr o n of n d n u u r h v g n r y f n n o w obr o d
f on T h f r h d n f d H ndu u u r w h n d n u u r ug
g ng h h o pr n g norm for h r h b n h gr r d o nof h
H ndu r g on nd h o r ur nd u o m h h v omp n d h
r d on Th w w mo r y n h po r for x mp n h J n
f gh d o og p form n d mp o d r mod rn n d n po
v y
Th o h r n rpr on n m y h nd u ur ompo no o b
d n f d w h h rm H ndu h b n mor r n r ogn n g h on
mp or r y nd n u u r k w d p r d n d o ng n du rn g u u r h
b n h p r od u o f m n y nf u n f ro m h r y D r v d n of h r y f v o r
m or h u nd r d y r d o wn o h B r h n d W r n of h h un dr d o r w o
h un dr d y r T h p pr o h r o gn h v r b n d mpo nd r b h
n yg v n m w or k og h r o o n u u u r n d n h n kr w ho d h r
o h po on hv o mph d w h pr d nd pow r of m on
n d po n u u r mod f or h mod m wor d Th v w r f
o m h n g of b o h h p o o n of h n n n h n u ry r f or m mo v m n n d
h o u ur m b v n o f h b r n u n d po of h
w n h n ury
T wo o n p o n of n d n u u r n ow v w h h o h r fo r
p n
W h h w or dH ndu h w or f r n n r m of r g on or r g on
w r n o n n o n w h h w or dH ndu n h b v n ook h
form of n ur o f h r g on f n h r m of r g on urf d n
h hn nd n h un v r o r n on o fH ndu m n d now
m nf f n h r m of u ur
T h d v opm n r f d ff r n n mph n rm of
h vo v ng wo rd v w o r n d v w o f H nd uv B u
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
30/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 2 9
ong w h h m mor p o n y g n f n on p u d vd n ow
urf wh h n on y b m n on d h r n d n no b d w h
ng h b u n Hndu v r f on ym n on d nd no
d v o p d Th u u rn o n h u o no fw h h r h H ndu v
m ov m n d r d o w rd h f or m o n of H nd un o n or
H ndu Th on p o f n on m rg h wo n dob u r
h po n bu n d o b ddr d u r y n h o n x o f
o un r y k n d
A u y m r prob m n b d n f d n h on x o f
h n o n f Hr h rux of h u n h d n on
b w n m u n on nd n o n G v n p ur m
nd h n ff u u yfun o nd mu n o n wh h r
u nd r A ok o rAk br o r h B r h T h mp o un fy n d w h
h u u r n o n m of h w h u mbr wh n h w y
b n p o y h ro m r v v h o d m b gu y o f wh h r H n du m n
n d/ p op o r r g o n / u ur T h m b g u y no w b g n o m n f
f w hn h gory of h f n on o rmu n on
Th n d d o n o h u on wh h r on h n mnd n n d n
or H ndu Th p of h pu r n rn h or g n
onundrum
X
H ndu v h u o m f u r n r y ng o o v h p ro b m of
H nd u d n y w h h o fH nd uv d n y n d up b o m ng p r
o f h p r ob m o n g n O n m y n ow b o n d ff r n p r o f h
r bu on up h m r
T h hou dn o b k n o m n h ow v r h our x r h
b n n v n u h n xr do ow u o po b v n
H n du r y p b o fmu p for mu on n v r w y
o / gob g ogr ph / v on hn / un v r nd o on
o n b on o d n fy four mp o n gg h mb v n
H ndu h o r / mp r r y n rm of h gor of 1
r g on 2 r g on 3 u u r n d 4 n o n Th f r mp
r p r n d b y h w or d H nd u n h o nd b y h w o rd H n du m
h h rd by h x pr o nH nd u u u r n d h f ou r hb y h r m
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
31/37
3 0A rv nd hrm
n du v Th of h w ord wh h o mpo h of h y
u r h omp x on of n n v nory r u of h x r
B u of h omp x n u r of h n d nr y h p pro h
run n o own m on h gn r own d mm Th r
gon ppro h g n r h d mm d o nd b ong o h H n
du o r d o H nd u b o n g o n d T h r g o u p p ro h g n r
h d mm H nd u m r g on k n yo h r r g o n or do
f n u d o h rr g o n d no mn o n y or un v r y
Th u u r p pro h g n r h d mm H ndu u u r o n
u v o f nd n u u r o r xpr v o f And fn y h n o n
ppr o h gn r h d mm hou d nd o p f or h u r m
of H n du m o r h H n du m o f u r m
A h h r of h h u on n r o u of dn y
d o h o h r b o n g o m or do b o ng o
F u y o fR g o u u d A RV N D H AR MA
M G U n vr y
3 52 0 Un v r y r
M o n r P Q H3 A 2A 7
Cn d
x @ mu m g
B BLOGRAPHY
A h m d A
1 96 4 u d n m C u u r n h n d n E nv r on m n O x fo rd C r n do n
Pr
An d r on W K n d D D m
1 98 7 Th B r o h r ho od o f f f ro n T h R h r y w y m v k n gh n d
H ndu R vv m N w D h V r Pub on
A h by P h p H
1 97 4 M od r n T r n d n H n d u m N w Y o rk n d Lo nd on C o u mb U n v r y
Pr
B r d R o b r
1 99 3 d R g on n d L w n n d pn d n n d N w D h M n o h r
B n r N y N r yn
1 99 0 H nd u Ou o o k C u H n du v P u b o n
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
32/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 3 1
B h m A L
1 96 7 Th W o nd r T h W n d 3 rd r v d L on do n d gw k & J k o n
B y y C A
1 98 5 T h P r H o ry o fC om mu n m R g o u Co nf n n d 1 70 0
1 8 00 M od r n A n u d 1 9 17 7 2 03
B mu
1 96 9 18 84 r Yu K B udd h R o rd o f h W r n Wo rd D h
O r n R p r n C or po r o n
B v n E R
1 922 nd n E ry Gr k nd L n L r u r n An n n d d E J
R p o n C m br d g U K C m br d g U n v r y P r 3 91 4 26
B d w P r fu H r b n M uk h n d A h n V n k
1 99 6 d R g on R g o y n dC omm un m D h M n oh r
C h o p d hy y B r d u
1 99 8 Rp r n n g h O h r n kr o ur n d h M u m D h Ox fo rd
U n v r y P r
D v R h rd
1995 n rodu on n R g on o f nd n Pr d D v d L op Jr
Pr n o n N w Jr y P r n o nU nv r y Pr 3 5 2
D r r J Dun n M
1 96 8R g on L w n d n n d N w Yo rk T h F r P r
D v u n BC
1995 o d n H ndu Fund mn m n dPo n nd n Bh k
R g o n n No r h rn n d C ommu n y d n y n d Po A o n d
D v d N Lo r n n A b ny N Y U nv r y of N w Yo rk Pr 3 06
322
E n y o p d B r n n
19 67 C h g o W m B n o n V o 1 1
E vr W m Jo hn on
1 99 7R g on F d r m n d h r ug g f or Pu b L f C fr om G r
m n y n d n d Am r N w Y or k O xf or d Un v r y P r
F ryknb rg R E
19 89 T h E m rg n o fM od m H nd u m C on p n d n n u
o n AR p pr w h p R f rn o o uh nd n Hndu m
R o n d r d d G n h r D o nh m r n dH r mn nK uk N w D h
M n o h r 2 9 4 9
G r h m B ru
1 99 0 H nd u N o n m n d n d n P o T h O r g n n d D v o p m n o f
h B h r y J n n gh C m b rd g U K C m br d g U n v r y P r
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
33/37
3 2A rv nd h rm
G up N r y n
1999 "Stereotypes Versus Hstory" nd a nternat ona Centre Quartery
u m m r10 2 1 0 5
H n n T ho m B o m
1 99 9 Th f fr on W v D m o r y n d H nd u N o n m n M od r n n d
P rn o n N w Jr y P r n o nU nv r y Pr
H n N or v n J
977 H ndu m n A R d r Gu d o h G r R g o n d Ch r J
A d m N w Y or k T h F r P r 1 06 1 55
H n n J oh n R n dE r J h r p
1 97 2 H nd u m N w U po n Ty n O r P r
kr m M
1 96 4 Mu m C v o n n n d E d A n T E mb r N w Y or k C o um b
U n v r y P r
J k o n AV W m
9 22 T h P r n D om n on n N or h r n n d D o wn o h T m o f A x n
d r nv on n An n nd d E J R pon C mbr dg U K C m
r d g U n v r y P r 3 19 3 44
f f r o C hr o ph
1 99 6 Th H n d u N o n M ov m n n n d N w Y or k C ou mb U n v r y
Pr
J n G r
1 99 6 T h H n d u Ph n o m no n N w D h U B P D
J on K n n h W
198 1 R g ou d n y n d h n d n C nu n Th C n u n B r h n d
d N G B r r r N w D h M n oh r 7 3 1 01
J oh h n dB h gv n Jo h
9 94 r ug g f o r H g mo ny n n d 1 9 20 4 7 3 v o N w D h g
P ub on
K n P V
1 97 7 H o ry of Dh r m r P oo n B h nd r kr Or n R r h n u
K r D
1 9 88 V r v r k r B o mb y P o pu r P r k h n
Kh n n un
9 97 T h d o f n d N w Y o rk F r r r r u n d Gr ou x
K n g R h r d
1 99 9 O r n m n d h M od m M y h o f H n du m N um n 2 6 1 66 1 7 2
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
34/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 3 3
Ko rm r K u K
1 99 4 A u rv y o f H nd u m 2 nd d A b n y N Y U n v r y o f N w Yo rk
Pr
K oh R u
1993 Po d of M G o w k r N wD h D p & D p Pub on
K o f f D r k H A
1 9 90 N u k r R p u n d p oy L o nd on C m b r d g U n v r y P r
L J yn K
1 99 5 H n du v T h E m r g n o f h R g h M d r E r h w or m B oo k
L pn r J u u J
1 99 6 A n n B n y n A n n u r y n o h M n n g o f H nd un R g o u
u d 3 2 1 09 1 2 6
L or n n D v d N
1995 T h H o r V ud of Bh k R g on n Bh k R g on n
N or h r n nd C ommu n y d n y n d Po A o n d D v d N
L or n n A b ny U nv r y of N w Yo rk Pr 1 32
1 99 9 Wh o nv n d H n du m C omp r v u d n o y n d H o ry
41630659
M d ho k B r
1 958 H nd R r n H nd N w D h B hr n y d n
1 96 9 B r M dh ok on n d Fo r gn Po y N w D h B hr h y
dn
19 69b n d n on Wh Why n dH ow N w D h B hr h y d n
19 69 P or r o f M r y r B o g r p hy o f D r h y m P r d M oo kh r
B o mb y J o P ub h n g H ou
1 97 0 n d n o n W h W hy n d H ow D h C h nd & C o
1 97 2 A o r y of B un g n g n K h m r N w D h Y ou ng A P ub o n
1 9 73 M ur d r o f D m o r y N w D h C h n d & Co
9 78 R f o n o f D n u N w D h N w m n Gr ou p of P ub h r
1 98 0 o r my D d n d n P o 1 97 0 19 80 D h n d B o ok G r y
1 98 2R o n fo r H n du D h n d n Bo ok G r y
19 8 5 Pu n b P r ob m T h M u m C on n o n N w D h H n d u Wo r d
P ub on
1 98 6R n dPo N w D h H nd uW or d Pu b o n
1 98 7 J mm u K h m r n d L d k h P ro b m n d o u o n N w D h R n
P ub hng Ho u
M h m ou d C y n h K p p y
1 99 4 A y od hy n d h H n d u R u r g n R g o n 2 4 73 7 6
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
35/37
3 4A rv nd h rm
M u m d r R C
19 70 d T h C Ag B omb y B h r y V d y B h v n
M r h P J
1 97 0 d T h B r h D o v ry o f Hn du m n h E g h n h C n u r y C m
b r dg U K C m b r dg U n v r y P r
M r y M r n E n dR Ap p by
1 99 1 d F un d m n m O b r v d C h g o U nv r y o fC h g o P r
M nu G
19 82 Th K h f M ov m n R g ou ym bo m n d Po M ob o n n
n d N w Y o rk C o u mb U n v r y P r
Mo n r W m M o n r
1 96 0 A n k r E ng h D o n r y O xf or d C r n do n Pr
Mu b M
1 96 7 T h n d n M u m L on do n G o r g A n & U n w n L d
Mu khr R d h K u mu d
1 95 1 F or g n n v o n n T h A g o f mp r U n y d R C M u md r
B om b y B h r y V d y B h v n 3 9 5 3
19 61 G m p o f An n n d B om b y Bh r y V d y B h v n
N g K d n dD b y o B ur mn
1 94 7 d T h E ng h W or k o f R R m mo hu n Ro y C u d h r n
B r hm o m
N p MD
1 99 9 n du v D h H r A n nd
N r y n n V u dh
1 99 6 Th H n du Tr d o n n Wo rd R g o n E r n Tr d o n d W r d
G O x o b y To ro noO x f o rd Unv r y P r
N h r u J L
1 9 46 T h D o v r y of n d N w Y o rk T h J oh n D y C om p n y
O b ro H r o
1 98 8 F ro m R u o C ou n r R u R h n k n g h H n d u k h Q u o n
1 88 4 19 15 n k h H o ry n d R g o n n h T w n h C n ur y d
Jo p h T O C on no M o n r n d W r d G O x o by T or on o C n r
f o u h A n u d U n v r y o f T or on o 1 3 6 15 8
1 99 4 Th C o n r u o n of R g o u B ou nd r C u u r d n y n d D v r y
n h k h Tr d o n D h O xf or d Un v r y P r
O C on n J T
1 97 3 G u d y V n v y mb o m o f D v r n F ro m Ev J ou rn o f h
A m r n O r n o y 93 34 0 34 3
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
36/37
On H n d u H n du n H n d u m n d H n du v 3 5
Pg D
1 98 2P r ud o P r o n Th n d n Mu m n d h m p r y m of
Co n r o N w D h O xf or d U n v r y P r
P n d G C
1 98 4 D m n o n o f An n n d n o H o ry N w D h B oo k & B oo k
P n k k r K M
9 6 3 Th F ou nd o n o f N w n d L on do n G o r g A n & U n w n
R d h k r h n n
1 93 9 E r n R g o n n d W r n T ho ug h O xf or d C r n d on P r
R dh k r h n n n d JH M u rh d
1 9 36 d C on m po r r y n d n P h o o p h y L on do n G o r g A n & U n w n
R w n o n H G
1 98 0 1 91 3 B ud dh A h ok A kb r h v & R n n gh N w D h E E
P ub on
R w n o n H W
1 95 4 n d A h or C u u r H o ry L on do n T h C r P r
R y h u dh ur H m h n d r
1 99 6Po H o ry of An n n d W h o mm n r y by B N Mu kh r
D h O xf or d Un v r y P r
R no u L o u
1 95 3 R g o n o f An n n d L on do n T h A h o n P r
Ru do p h u n n H o b r
1 98 7 Pr d n Ad dr F or m o n n A P ro g om no n o C o m
p r v u dy T h J ou rn o f A n u d 4 6 73 1 74 6
h u E dw r d C
1 91 4 r d A b r u n n d 2 v o L on do n K g n P u T r n h T r b n r &
Co
rd G
19 74 h v n T h M og hu E mp r d R C M u md r B o mb y B h r y
V d y B h v n 7 3 1 01
r k r u m
1996 nd n N o n m n d h Po of H ndu v n Con ng h
N o n R g o n Co mmu n y n d h P o o fD mo r y n n d d
D v d Lu dd n P h d p h U n v r y o f P n n yv n P r 2 70 2 93
1 99 9 C on v r o n n d Po o f H nd u Rg h E o no m n d Po W k y
J u n2 6 1 6 93 1 6 9 6
v r k r V D
1 96 9 1 92 3 H n du v W ho H n du B o mb y v r k r d n
This content downloaded from 141.211.4.224 on Mon, 21 Mar 2016 01:17:30 UTCAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsphttp://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
-
8/19/2019 Arvind Sharma--On Hindu, Hindustan, Hinduism, Hindutva
37/37
3 6A rv nd h rm
h r f H r m u
1989 Th n n d n Tr d o n H ndbu h d rOr n k 2 A b 3 2
L d n E J Br
h r m B r n dr N h
1 97 2 o n d Cu u r H o ry o f No r h rn n d 1 00 0 12 00 A D N w
D h A bh n v Pu b o n
h rm r R m
1 9 62 T h R g o u P o y o f h M ug h E m p r or B om b y A P ub h n g
Hou
h r v v A h ok K um r
19 81 H ndu o y n h x n h C nury w h p R f r n o Nor h rn
nd N w D h M n d Pub on P rv L d
m h D o n d E u g n
1963 nd u r Pr n o n Nw J r y Pr n o nUn vr y Pr
m h W f r dC n w
1 9 62 T h M n n g n d E nd o f R g o n N w Y o rk T h M m n C o mp n y
p r P r v
1 97 2 n d A M od r n H o ry A n n Ar bo r T h U n v r y o f M h g n P r
9 94 d T h O xfo rd H o ry of n d b y h L V n n A m h C E 4 h
d D h O xf or d U n v r y P r
r n v n K
1 9 89 r N r y n G u ru T r v nd ru m J y r P ub o n
n r on H n r h v o n
1 98 9 H n du m O n h P ro p r U o f D p v T r m n H n du m
o n d r d d G n h r D o n h m r n dH r mn nK uk N w D h
M n o h r 1 1 2 7
T k k u u J
1 96 6 r A R o rd of Bu ddh R g on Pr d n n d n d h M y
A r h p g o A D 6 71 6 95 b y n g D h M un h r m M n oh r
Thom p onG o rg
1 99 9 O n h L n g u g o f h D u v P p r d v r d o n M r h 21 1 9 99
h 2 09 h n nu m ng of h A m r n Or n o y B mor
W g on r P h p B
19 96 u n Among H ndu Kng Dr T n d h m on of
H n du C u u r V y n g r T h J ou rn o f A n u d 5 5 85 1 88 0
Wnk A ndr
1 99 0 A H nd T h M k n g of h n do m W or d 2 v o L d n E J B r