ARTICLE 68 71 RIGHSTS AND OBLIGATIONS BETWEEN HUSBAND ANDWIFE | 1G.R. No. 139789July 19, 2001IN THE MATTER OF THE PETITION FOR HABEAS CORPUS OF POTENCIANO ILUSORIO, ERIN!A ". IUSORIO, #$%&%&o'$(, )*.ERIN!A ". IUSORIO+BILDNER, S,-IA ". IUSORIO+,AP, JOHN !OES .'/ JANE !OES, ($*#o'/$'%*.0+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++0G.R. No. 139808 July 19, 2001POTENCIANO IUSORIO, MA. ERIN!A I. BI!NER .'/ S,-IA ". IUSORIO, #$%&%&o'$(*, )*.HON. COURT OF APPEAS .'/ ERIN!A ". IUSORIO, ($*#o'/$'%*.R E S OU T I O NPAR!O, J.1O'2$ .3.&' 4$ *$$ %5$ *./ %.l$ o6 . #(o7&'$'% 6.7&ly *5.%%$($/ 8y 2o'6l&2%* o' $0#$2%.'2y &'6.8l$/ 6o(%u'$.*O' M.(25 11, 1999, E(l&'/. ". Ilu*o(&o, %5$ 7.%(&.(25 45o 4.* *o lo)&'3ly &'*$#.(.8l$ 6(o7 5$(5u*8.'/ *o7$ y$.(* .3o, 6&l$/ . #$%&%&o' 4&%5 %5$ Cou(% o6 A##$.l*1 6o( habeas corpus %o 5.)$2u*%o/y o6 5$( 5u*8.'/ &' 2o'*o(%&u7.O' A#(&l 9, 1999, %5$ Cou(% o6 A##$.l* #(o7ul3.%$/ &%* /$2&*&o' /&*7&**&'3 %5$ #$%&%&o' 6o( l.2:o6 u'l.46ul ($*%(.&'% o( /$%$'%&o' o6 %5$ *u8;$2%, Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&o.T5u*, o' O2%o8$( 11, 1999, E(l&'/. ". Ilu*o(&o 6&l$/ 4&%5 %5$ Su#($7$ Cou(% .'.##$.l via 2$(%&o(.(& #u(*u&'3 5$( /$*&($ %o 5.)$ 2u*%o/y o6 5$( 5u*8.'/ Po%$'2&.'oIlu*o(&o.2 T5&*2.*$4.*2o'*ol&/.%$/4&%5.'o%5$(2.*$3 6&l$/8yPo%$'2&.'oIlu*o(&o.'/5&*25&l/($', E(l&'/. I. B&l/'$( .'/ Syl)&. ". Ilu*o(&o .##$.l&'3 6(o7 %5$ o(/$( 3&)&'3 )&*&%.%&o' (&35%*%o 5&* 4&6$, .**$(%&'3 %5.% 5$ '$)$( ($6u*$/ %o *$$ 5$(.O' M.y 12, 2000, 4$ /&*7&**$/ %5$ #$%&%&o' 6o( 5.8$.* 2o(#u*< 6o( l.2: o6 7$(&%, .'/ 3(.'%$/%5$ #$%&%&o'9 %o 'ull&6y %5$ Cou(% o6 A##$.l*= (ul&'3> 3&)&'3 )&*&%.%&o' (&35%* %o E(l&'/. ". Ilu*o(&o.7?5.% &* 'o4 8$6o($ %5$ Cou(% &* E(l&'/.=* 7o%&o' %o ($2o'*&/$( %5$ /$2&*&o'.8O' S$#%$78$( 20, 2000, 4$ *$% %5$ 2.*$ 6o( #($l&7&'.(y 2o'6$($'2$ o' O2%o8$( 11, 2000, .%10100 .. 7., 4&%5ou% ($@u&(&'3 %5$ 7.'/.%o(y #($*$'2$ o6 %5$ #.(%&$*.I' %5.% 2o'6$($'2$, %5$ Cou(% l.&/ /o4' %5$ &**u$* %o 8$ ($*ol)$/, %o 4&%1ARTICLE 68 71 RIGHSTS AND OBLIGATIONS BETWEEN HUSBAND ANDWIFE | 2A.B To/$%$(7&'$%5$#(o#(&$%yo6 .#5y*&2.l .'/7$/&2.l $0.7&'.%&o'o6 #$%&%&o'$(Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&oCA8B ?5$%5$( %5$ *.7$ &* ($l$).'%C .'/A2B I6 ($l$).'%, 5o4 %5$ Cou(% 4&ll 2o'/u2% %5$ *.7$.9T5$ #.(%&$* $0%$'*&)$ly /&*2u**$/ %5$ &**u$*. T5$ Cou(%, &' &%* ($*olu%&o', $';o&'$/ %5$ #.(%&$*.'/ %5$&( l.4y$(* %o &'&%&.%$ *%$#* %o4.(/* .' .7&2.8l$ *$%%l$7$'% o6 %5$ 2.*$ %5(ou35 7$/&.%&o'.'/ o%5$( 7$.'*.O' No)$78$( 29, 2000, %5$ Cou(% 'o%$/ %5$ 7.'&6$*%.%&o' .'/ 2o7#l&.'2$ o6 %5$ #.(%&$* 4&%5%5$ ($*olu%&o' o6 O2%o8$( 11, 2000.10O' J.'u.(y 31, 2001, %5$ Cou(% /$'&$/ E(l&'/. Ilu*o(&o=* 7.'&6$*%.%&o' .'/ 7o%&o' #(.y&'3 %5.%Po%$'2&.'oIlu*o(&o8$#(o/u2$/8$6o($%5$Cou(% .'/8$7$/&2.lly$0.7&'$/8y.%$.7o67$/&2.l $0#$(%* .##o&'%$/ 8y %5$ Cou(%.11O' M.(25 27, 2001, 4$ /$'&$/ 4&%5 6&'.l&%y E(l&'/.=* 7o%&o' %o ($2o'*&/$( %5$ Cou(%=* o(/$( o6J.'u.(y 31 , 2001.12T5$ &**u$* (.&*$/ 8y E(l&'/. ". Ilu*o(&o &' 5$( 7o%&o' 6o( ($2o'*&/$(.%&o' .($ 7$($ ($&%$(.%&o'* o65$( .(3u7$'%* %5.% 5.)$ 8$$' ($*ol)$/ &' %5$ /$2&*&o'.N$)$(%5$l$**, 6o( $7#5.*&*, 4$ *5.ll /&*2u** %5$ &**u$* %5u*1First. E(l&'/.". Ilu*o(&o2l.&7$/%5.% *5$4.*'o% 2o7#$ll&'3Po%$'2&.'o%ol&)$4&%55$(&'2o'*o(%&u7 .'/ %5.% Po%$'2&.'o=* 7$'%.l *%.%$ 4.* 'o% .' &**u$. Ho4$)$(, %5$ )$(y (oo% 2.u*$o6 %5$ $'%&($ #$%&%&o' &* 5$( /$*&($ %o 5.)$ 5$( 5u*8.'/=* custody.13 Cl$.(ly, E(l&'/. 2.''o% 'o4/$'y %5.% *5$ 4.'%$/ Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&o %o l&)$ 4&%5 5$(.Second. O'$ ($.*o' 45y E(l&'/. ". Ilu*o(&o *ou35% 2u*%o/y o6 5$( 5u*8.'/ 4.* %5.%($*#o'/$'%* &' .'/ Syl)&. 4$($ &ll$3.lly ($*%(.&'&'3 Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&o %o 6(.u/ul$'%ly /$#(&)$5$( o6 #(o#$(%y (&35%* ou% o6 #u($ 3($$/.1< S5$ 2l.&7$/ %5.% 5$( %4o 25&l/($' 4$($ u*&'3 %5$&( *&2:.'/ 6(.&l 6.%5$( %o *&3' .4.y Po%$'2&.'o .'/ E(l&'/.=* #(o#$(%y %o 2o7#.'&$* 2o'%(oll$/ 8y &'.'/Syl)&.. S5$.l*o.(3u$/%5.% *&'2$Po%$'2&.'o($%&($/.*/&($2%o(.'/o66&2$( o6 B.3u&oCou'%(yClu8.'/P5&l#&'$O)$(*$$*T$l$2o77u'&2.%&o'*, *5$4oul/lo3&2.lly.**u7$5&*#o*&%&o' .'/ 2o'%(ol. ,$%, &' .'/ Syl)&. 4$($ %5$ o'$* 2o'%(oll&'3 %5$ 2o(#o(.%&o'*.19T5$ 6.2% o6 &ll$3.l ($*%(.&'% 5.* 'o% 8$$' #(o)$/ /u(&'3 %5$ 5$.(&'3 .% %5$ Cou(% o6 A##$.l* o'M.(25 23, 1999.1>Po%$'2&.'o 5&7*$l6 /$2l.($/ %5.% 5$ 4.* 'o% #($)$'%$/ 8y 5&* 25&l/($' 6(o7*$$&'3 .'y8o/y .'/ %5.% 5$ 5./ 'o o8;$2%&o' %o *$$&'3 5&* 4&6$ .'/ o%5$( 25&l/($' 45o7 5$lo)$/.ARTICLE 68 71 RIGHSTS AND OBLIGATIONS BETWEEN HUSBAND ANDWIFE | 3E(l&'/. 5&35l&35%$/ %5.% 5$( 5u*8.'/ *u66$($/ 6(o7 ).(&ou* .&l7$'%*. T5u*, Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&o/&/ 'o% 5.)$ %5$ 7$'%.l 2.#.2&%y %o /$2&/$ 6o( 5&7*$l6. H$'2$, E(l&'/. .(3u$/ %5.% Po%$'2&.'o8$ 8(ou35% 8$6o($ %5$ Su#($7$ Cou(% *o %5.% 4$ 2oul/ /$%$(7&'$ 5&* 7$'%.l *%.%$.?$ 4$($ 'o% 2o')&'2$/ %5.% Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&o 4.* 7$'%.lly &'2.#.2&%.%$/ %o 25oo*$ 45$%5$(%o *$$ 5&* 4&6$ o( 'o%. A3.&', %5&* &* . @u$*%&o' o6 6.2% %5.% 5.* 8$$' /$2&/$/ &' %5$ Cou(% o6A##$.l*.A* %o 45$%5$( %5$ 25&l/($' 4$($ &' 6.2% %.:&'3 2o'%(ol o6 %5$ 2o(#o(.%&o', %5$*$ .($ 7.%%$(* %5.%7.y 8$ %5($*5$/ ou% &' . *$#.(.%$ #(o2$$/&'3, &(($l$).'% &' habeas corpus.Third. P$%&%&o'$( 6.&l$/ %o *u66&2&$'%ly 2o')&'2$ %5$ Cou(%45y 4$ *5oul/ 'o% ($ly o' %5$ 6.2%*6ou'/ 8y %5$ Cou(% o6 A##$.l*. E(l&'/. 2l.&7$/ %5.% %5$ 6.2%* 7$'%&o'$/ &' %5$ /$2&*&o' 4$($$((o'$ou* .'/ &'2o7#l$%$. ?$ *$$ 'o ($.*o' 45y %5$ H&35 Cou(% o6 %5$ l.'/ '$$/ 3o %o *u25l$'3%5. T5$ 5o('8oo: /o2%(&'$ *%.%$* %5.% 6&'/&'3* o6 6.2% o6 %5$ lo4$( 2ou(%* .($ 2o'2lu*&)$ o'%5$ Su#($7$ Cou(%.17 ?$$7#5.*&D$, &% &* 'o% 6o( %5$ Cou(% %o 4$&35 $)&/$'2$ .ll o)$(.3.&'.18 Al%5ou35%5$($.($$02$#%&o'* %o%5$(ul$,19 E(l&'/.6.&l$/%o*5o4%5.% %5&* &* .'$02$#%&o'.l &'*%.'2$.Fourth. E(l&'/.*%.%$*%5.%A(%&2l$EII o6 %5$1987Co'*%&%u%&o'.'/ A(%&2l$*>8.'/>9o6 %5$F.7&lyCo/$*u##o(% 5$( #o*&%&o'%5.% .**#ou*$*, %5$yAPo%$'2&.'o.'/E(l&'/.B .($/u%y8ou'/ %o l&)$ %o3$%5$( .'/ 2.($ 6o( $.25 o%5$(. ?$ .3($$.T5$ l.4 #(o)&/$* %5.% %5$ 5u*8.'/ .'/ %5$ 4&6$ .($ o8l&3$/ %o l&)$ %o3$%5$(, o8*$()$ 7u%u.llo)$, ($*#$2% .'/ 6&/$l&%y.20 T5$ *.'2%&o' %5$($6o( &* %5$ F*#o'%.'$ou*, 7u%u.l .66$2%&o' 8$%4$$'5u*8.'/ .'/ 4&6$ .'/ 'o% .'y l$3.l 7.'/.%$ o( 2ou(% o(/$(F %o $'6o(2$ 2o'*o(%&u7.21O8)&ou*ly,%5$($4.*.8*$'2$o6 $7#.%5y8$%4$$'*#ou*$*E(l&'/..'/Po%$'2&.'o, 5.)&'3*$#.(.%$/ 6(o7 8$/ .'/ 8o.(/ *&'2$ 1972. ?$ /$6&'$/ empathy .* . *5.($/ 6$$l&'3 8$%4$$'5u*8.'/.'/4&6$$0#$(&$'2$/'o% o'ly8y5.)&'3*#o'%.'$ou**$0u.l &'%&7.2y8u% ./$$#*$'*$ o6 *#&(&%u.l 2o77u'&o'. M.(&%.l u'&o' &* . %4o+4.y #(o2$**.M.((&.3$ &* /$6&'&%$ly 6o( %4o lo)&'3 ./ul%* 45o )&$4 %5$ ($l.%&o'*5 4&%5 Famor gignit amoremF($*#$2%, *.2(&6&2$.'/.2o'%&'u&'32o77&%7$'% %o%o3$%5$('$**, 2o'*2&ou*o6 &%*).lu$.*.*u8l&7$ *o2&.l &'*%&%u%&o'.22O' Ju'$ 28, 2001, Po%$'2&.'o Ilu*o(&o 3.)$ 5&* *oul %o %5$ Al7&35%y, 5&* C($.%o( .'/ Su#($7$Ju/3$. $% 5&**oul ($*% &'#$.2$.'/5&**u()&)o(*2o'%&'u$%5$7u25#(olo'3$/6(.2.* exaequo et bono.IN -IE? ?HEREOF, 4$ !EN, E(l&'/.=* 7o%&o' 6o( ($2o'*&/$(.%&o'. A% .'y (.%$, %5$ 2.*$ 5.*8$$' ($'/$($/ 7oo% 8y %5$ /$.%5 o6 *u8;$2%. SO OR!ERE!.