Download - 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
1/60
Chapter 3
Trends, Growth and Direction of Diamond
Trade of India
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
2/60
3.1. Meaning of Trade:
In simple terms, trade is the transfer of ownership of goods and services
from one person or entity to another by getting something in exchange from the
buyer. It is a branch of commerce which is concerned with the exchange of goods
and services. It may be a barter exchange, i.e., exchange of goods for goods or
monetary trade where money is used as a medium of exchange.
In prehistoric times, trade was in crude form with goods being exchanged
for goods. This is known as barter exchange. Barter exchange suffered from
number drawbacks. Some of these drawbacks were double coincidence of wants,
indivisibility of certain goods, absence of common measure of value and difficulty
in storage of wealth. To solve difficulty of barter, money was evolved. Initially,
precious stones and metals were used as a medium of exchange. The evolution of
money gave boost to trade and commerce.
3.2. Classification of Trade:Trade may be classified on the basis of scope of its territorial boundaries as
under:
(a) Internal Trade: Trade between two regions of the same country is known
as internal trade. It is also known as domestic trade or home trade. It is
confined to the national boundaries of a nation. For example, trade
between Gujarat and Rajasthan.
(b) External Trade: Trade between two countries with different socio-
economic and political environment is referred to as external trade. It is
also known as foreign trade or international trade. For example, trade
between India and UK. External trade may be further classified as under:
- Export: Export means selling goods to the customers based
in a foreign territory, outside the national boundaries of a country. For
example, when goods are sold from India to Pakistan, it is an export
2
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
3/60
trade. Export is the best method of expansion when additional capacity
exists in the business organisation.
- Import: Import means purchasing goods from a seller
based in a foreign territory, i.e., outside the national boundaries of a
country. For example, when goods are purchased by India from the
U.S.A., it is an import trade for India. The government discourages
imports, unless essential because they lead to outflow of foreign
currency and depletion in foreign exchange reserves of the nation.
- Entrepot Trade: Trade that involves re-exporting of
imported goods is referred to as entrepot trade. It is also known as re-
export trade. For example, an Indian trader may buy goods from
Bangladesh and then sell to China. Ports which are conveniently
located act as the distribution centres for wide areas. For example, ports
of Singapore and Hong Kong.
Internal trade is important from national point of view while external trade
is significant from international point of view.
3.3. External Trade of India:
India is looked upon as a country with immense resources, spread through
its length and breadth. India was famed for her fabulous wealth ever since the
ancient times till the establishment of the British Empire. Indian goods were
exported to far off places which brought great wealth to Indian economy.
However, Mughal rulers and later the British plundered this wealth which made
Indian economy solely dependent upon imports for most of its requirements.
By the time India gained Independence from the British in 1947, the
economy has completely dependent on foreign sources for the supply of its
requirements. There were hardly any manufacturing facilities to suffice the needs
3
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
4/60
of the growing Indian population.
In post-independence period, the main objective of the Indias external
trade policy was to protect its market from foreign competition. In the late 1970s
and early 1980s, the trade regime was based on a complex system of licensing.
Indias trade policy heavily relied on quotas rather than on tariffs. 1 Imports were
regulated through a licensing system without any policy prescriptions. All these
factors led to poor development of Indias external trade, both imports as well as
exports, in the post-independence period.
The foreign exchange reserve crisis of 1991 made it necessary for India to
adopt policy of trade liberalisation. Licensing was scrapped and a number of trade
reforms were introduced to give boost to Indias export trade. This had significant
impact on several sectors of Indian economy such as IT sector, gems and
jewellery sector, capital goods sector, etc.
3.4 Trends in Indias Export and Import since Independence:
Indias foreign trade can be studies with reference to Export and Import:
(1) Export: Export means sale of goods or services by the resident of one country
to the resident of another country. The export of goods from India are broadly
classified into the following four categories:
Fig. 3.1 Composition of Indias Exports
1
Bhagwati, J.N. and Srinivasan T.N. (1975), Foreign Trade Regimes and Economic Development: India, New York, Columbia University Press.
4
http://lh4.googleusercontent.com/_iFIztPmvqg8/TZRfdIanroI/AAAAAAAAEa4/9CXrPt5OI4I/Composition-Of-India-Export.png -
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
5/60
(2) Import: Import means purchase of goods or services by the resident of one
country from the resident of another country. The import of goods in India
are broadly classified into the following four categories:
Fig. 3.2 Composition of Indias Imports
The following table analyses the export and import trade of India since
independence. It can be seen in the table 2.1 that the total exports of India stood at
Rs. 716 crore during the period 1951-52 while imports stood at Rs. 890 crore
resulting into trade deficits of Rs. 174 crore, which was 1.7% of the GDP of the
country. Due to the policy of protectionism, Indias export and import trade
remained sluggish in the post-independence period with import rising by 4754 %
between the periods 1950-51 to 1990-91, exports rising by only 4446% during the
same period. With imports rising at proportionately higher rate than exports, India
suffered from adverse trade balance. It rose to a maximum of 4.2% of GDP in the
year 1971-72 and then to gradually fall to 3.8% of GDP in the year 1981-82 and
2.1% in the year 1991-92.
Indias exports and imports experienced a significant growth in the post-liberalisation period. Within a span of two decades between 1990-91 to 2010-
2011, exports rose by 3410% and imports rose by 3797%. Some of the sectors in
India such as IT sector and gems and jewellery sector became the drivers of
export-led growth of the Indian economy. Trade balance eased at 1.4% of GDP at
the end of 2000-2001 which gradually increased due to liberalisation of imports in
the subsequent period to reach peak of 10.1% of GDP in the year 2008-2009. It
5
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
6/60
marginally reduced to 8.5% of GDP in the year 2009-2010.
Table No. 3.1
Indias Exports, Imports, Trade Balance and Share in GDP
Period Exports(Rs. Crores)
Imports(Rs. Crores)
Trade Balance Trade balance asa % of GDP
1951-52 716 890 174 1.7
1961-62 642 1122 480 3.7
1971-72 1,608 1,825 217 4.7
1981-82 6711 12,549 5838 3.8
1991-92 32,553 43,198 10,645 2.1
2000-2001 203,571 230,873 27,302 1.4
2010-2011 1,142,649 1,683,467 540,818 N.A.N.A. Not available.
Source: Economic Survey, Government of India, 201011, p.A-80.
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
1800000
1951-52 1961-62 1971-72 1981-82 1991-92 2000-01 2010-11
Exports (Rs. Cr.) Import (Rs. Cr.)
Fig. No. 3.1
Indias Exports, Imports, Trade Balance and Share in GDP
Analysis of the Exports:
It can be seen that Indias exports have registered a five-to-six fold increase
in the last decade from Rs. 203,571 crore in the year 2000-01 to Rs. 1,142,649
crore in the year 2010-2011. While the compound annual growth rates (CAGR) of
Indias exports (in US dollar terms) was 8.4 per cent in the 1990s, it increased to
19.5 per cent during 2000-01 to 2008-09. The resilience of Indias trade can be
seen from the fact that its export and import growth, which fell to 0.6 per cent as a
6
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
7/60
result of the shock from the 2008 global economic crisis, rebounded to 35.1 per
cent in 2010-11. India not only reached pre-crisis levels in exports, but surpassed
pre-crisis trends in export growth rate unlike many other developing and even
developed countries.
Indias share in global exports also increased from 0.7 per cent in 2000 to
1.5 per cent in 2010 (1.4 per cent as per WTO). Its ranking in the leading
exporters improved from 31 in the year 2000 to 20 in the year 2010.
During the first half of 2011-12, Indias exports witnessed a high growth of
40.6 per cent. However, since October 2011 there has been a deceleration in
export growth as a result of the crisis originating in the periphery of the euro zone
area and spreading to the core economies resulting in a now evident mild
recession in the euro area.
Exports registered a high growth of 61.1 per cent in July 2011. After that
growth decelerated to 41.5 per cent, 25.2 per cent, and 18.1 per cent in August,
September, and October 2011 respectively. In November 2011, export growth was
negative at 0.5 per cent but in December 2011 and January 2012, it was positive
but low at 6.7 per cent and 10.1 per cent respectively. Cumulative exports were at
US $242.8 billion, registering a growth of 23.5 per cent during 2011-12 (April-
January). During April-December 2011, the export sectors that have done well are
petroleum and oil products registering a growth of 55 per cent; gems and
jewellery 38.5 per cent; engineering 21.6 per cent; cotton fabrics made ups, etc.
13 per cent; electronics 21.1 per cent; readymade garments 23.7 per cent; and
drugs 21.5 per cent.
Analysis of the Imports:
Indias imports registered a seven fold increase in the last decade from Rs.
230,873 crore in the year 2000-2001 to Rs. 1,683,467 crore in the year 2010-2011.
7
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
8/60
While the compound annual growth rates (CAGR) of Indias imports (in US
dollar terms) were 8.4 per cent in the 1990s, it increased to 25.1 per cent during
2000-01 to 2008-09. Indias imports that had fell to 5 per cent in 2009-10 as a
result of the shock from the 2008 global economic crisis, rebounded to 28.2 per
cent in 2010-11.
Indias share in global imports also increased from 0.8 per cent in 2000 to
2.2 per cent in 2010 (2.1 per cent as per WTO). Its ranking in the leading
importers improved from 26 in the year 2000 to 13 in the year 2010.
The increase in growth of imports in rupee terms in 2010-11 was due to
growth in both volume and unit value indices. The volume index witnessed a
growth of 10.1 per cent in 2010-11, due to the high growth of manufactured goods
classified chiefly by materials (56 per cent), beverages and tobacco (31.1 per
cent), and chemicals and related products (8.9 per cent). The unit value index of
imports registered a growth of 11.2 per cent mainly due to growth in unit values
of crude materials, inedible, except fuels (23 per cent), mineral fuels, lubricants
and related materials (17.1 per cent), and machinery and transport equipment
(10.1 per cent).
Analysis of Trade Deficit:
India has been facing the problem of trade deficit since independence due
to excessive imports in relation to exports. India is leading exporter of gems andjewellery, textiles, engineering goods, chemicals, leather manufactures and
services. India is poor in oil resources and is currently heavily dependent on coal
and foreign oil imports for its energy needs. Other imported products are:
machinery, gems, fertilizers and chemicals.
Indias trade deficit widened considerably during April-February 2011-12
compared with the corresponding period of the previous year, owing to subdued
8
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
9/60
export growth coupled with high imports. Notwithstanding the rupee depreciation,
the trade deficit increased primarily due to a slowdown in global demand,
inadequate pass through of higher global oil prices and the relatively price inelastic
nature of some of Indias imports, viz., gold and silver. Even the growth in non-oil
non-gold imports remained sizeable despite signs of a slowdown in the domestic
economy. Given the adverse global environment and elevated global crude oil
prices, Indias trade deficit may remain high in near future. A slight moderation
may, however, be expected in imports of gold following the increase in import duty
announced in the Union Budget for 2012-13.
3.5 Composition of Indias Foreign Trade:
Over the last six decades, the commodity composition of Indian exports
has changed in the face of structural changes in the Indian economy. The
composition of Indian export has gradually changed from primary products to
manufactured goods and finally to services.
In the late 1970s and early 1980s, the trade regime was based on a complex
system of licensing. Indias trade policy heavily relied on quotas rather than on
tariffs.2 Imports were regulated through a licensing system without any policy
prescriptions. However, import licenses allocated reflect two major criteria:
(1) The principle of essentiality, and
(2) The principle of indigenous non-availability.
Thus, the imports, in terms of both magnitude and composition, were to be
permitted only if the firm in question certified to the government that they were
essential (as inputs or equipment for production). Almost all imports were
subject to discretionary import licensing or were canalized by the government
monopoly trading organizations. The only exceptions were commodities listed in
2
Bhagwati, J.N. and Srinivasan T.N. (1975), Foreign Trade Regimes and Economic Development:India, New York, Columbia University Press.
9
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
10/60
the Open General License (OGL) category. The import of consumer goods was
banned (except those that were considered essential and could only be imported
by the designated government canalising agencies).
Structural Changes in Exports:
In the 1950s, agricultural and allied commodities, including farm processed
products dominated the export basket. The share of these products was 32.75 per
cent. The share of agriculture and allied commodity exports fell steeply from
44.3% of total exports in the year 1960-61 to merely 8.5% of total exports in the
year 2010-11. The share of ore and minerals also fell from 8.1% of the total
exports in the year 1960-61 to 2.6% in the year 2000-01 and finally rose to 4.2%
in the year 2010-11. The share of the manufactured goods in the total exports was
nearly 39 per cent in 1950-51 which composed of cotton piece goods, gunny bags
and gunny clothes. These were basically agriculture-based products. In 1960-61
the share of manufactured products increased to 45.3 per cent and prior to
economic reforms in 1990-91 it went up to 72.9 per cent and reached its peak in
2000-01 to 72 per cent, thereafter downward trend was set in and it was 68.9 per
cent in the year 2010-11. Share of chemicals, dyes, pharmaceuticals, gems and
jewellery, iron and steel, machinery, transport equipment, electronic goods and
clothing products increased, both in total exports and in world exports. However,
the share of manufactures of metals declined in total exports but enhanced its
share in world exports. Crude and petroleum products entered in substantial
proportions in 2000-01 and reached 17.3 per cent of the total exports in 2010-11.The share of gems and jewellery has increased considerably in Indias exports
from mere 0.2% in the year 1960-61 to 16.6% of total exports in the year 2000-
2001 to fall marginally at 14.9% in the year 2010-2011. These trends can be seen
in the following table.
Table 3.2
Composition of Indias Exports since Independence (%)
10
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
11/60
Commodity Groups 1960-61 1990-91 2000-2001 2010-2011
Agriculture and Allied Products 44.3 19.5 13.5 8.5
Ores and Minerals 8.1 4.4 2.6 4.2
Manufactured Goods
Gems and Jewellery
45.3
0.2
73.0
16.2
78.0
16.6
68.9
14.9Crude and Petroleum Products 1.1 2.9 4.2 17.3
Other unclassified Items 1.2 0.2 1.7 1.2
Total 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
Source: Compiled from various issues of Economic Survey, Government of India.
Structural Changes in Imports:
Indias imports were broadly classified into bulk and non-bulk items. The
product groups such as food and allied products, fuel, ores and metals, fertilizers
and paper, paper board and pulp fall under bulk category and rest of the items in
non-bulk category. In 1960-61, the share of bulk items in total imports accounted
for 50 per cent which fell down to 44.5% in the year 1990-91. It further fell down
to 39% and rose to 52.5 in the year 2010-2011. The main reason for the rise in
value of bulk items in Indias import basket is the rise in international oil prices.
The liberalization episode did not dramatically alter the bulk imports although
there was decline in other items of imports, namely food and allied products and
fertilizers. Many of the restricted and canalized items were removed from
quantitative restriction lists. Bulk items still comprise the main proportion of the
national import bill. The crude oil production has increased in India after 2001-02.
Its contribution is less than 18 per cent of domestic consumption.
Table 3.3
Composition of Indias Imports since Independence (%)
Commodity Groups 1960-61 1990-91 2000-2001 2010-2011
Food and allied products 19.1 2.3 2.7 3.2Fuel 6.2 25.0 31.0 33.2
Ores and metals 15.2 11.0 2.6 14.1
Fertilizers 7.9 4.1 1.3 2.4
Paper, board and pulp 1.6 2.1 1.4 0.6
I. Total (Bulk Item) 50.0 44.5 39.0 53.5
Capital goods 31.8 24.2 11.0 13.1
Others:
Pearls & precious stones
Gold and silver
18.2
(0.6)
(N.A.)
31.3
(8.7)
(N.A.)
50.0
(9.6)
(9.2)
33.4
(7.7)
(8.1)
II. Total (Non-bulk Item) 50.0 55.5 61.0 46.5
(I + II) Total Imports 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
11
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
12/60
Source: Compiled from various issues of Economic Survey, Government of India.
3.6 Export of Gems and Jewellery from India:
Gems and Jewellery has become an important component of Indias
foreign trade. It is an important emerging sector in the Indian Economy. Ranked
among the fastest growing sectors, it is also a leading sector for foreign exchange
generation. The gems and jewellery industry is very much fascinating being
traditionally glamorous and artistically modern. It employees and engages
millions; cover wide activities such as raw material procurement from far flung
Africa, Australia, Canada and Russia, and transforming these into products in
demand with the skills available in China, India, Italy and Turkey for the
sophisticated markets in the USA, Europe, Far East, Middle East and Asia.
The Gems and Jewellery trade of India basically include the following
three commodities in its ambit:
(a) Diamonds: Diamonds is the main constituents of the Gems and Jewellery
trade of India. India mainly imports rough diamonds from other countries
and processes and re-export them. In recent years, the domestic demand for
cut and polished diamond has increased. In 2010-11, the export of cut and
polished diamonds was US$ 28251.92 million as compared US$ 18237.56
million during 2009-2010, recording a growth of54.91 per cent.
(b)Gold Jewellery:
Gold has always been the jewellers' favourite metal given
its intrinsic lustre and ease of fabrication. Gold jewellery enjoys the leading
position in most markets across the world, and in many ways forms the
backbone of the precious jewellery industry. Export of Gold jewellery also
grew in 2010-11, registering US$ 12885.59 million as compared to US$
9669.10 million in 2009-10. A growth of33.27 per cent was recorded.
(c) Coloured Gemstones: Coloured gemstones include all other forms of
12
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
13/60
jewellery; precious gemstones such as emeralds, sapphires, rubies and
tanzanite and semi-precious gemstones like pearls. Export of coloured
gemstones was registered at US$ 314.54 million in 2010-11 as compared to
US$ 286.78 million in 2009-10, showing a growth of9.68 per cent.
Among the three components of gems and jewellery exports from India,
cut and polished diamonds constitute a major segment. Export of cut and polished
diamonds constituted 66% of the total exports from Gems and Jewellery sector
during the financial year 2010-2011. The industry is highly fragmented making it
difficult to track supply, demand and global trade.
(A) Trends in Exports of Gems and Jewellery vis-a-vis Total
Merchandise Exports from India:
Gems and jewellery and diamonds have been a part of the Indian
civilisation since its recorded history. The significance of the gems and jewellery
industry in the Indian economic scenario is a development of the last four
decades. The industry has registered a remarkable growth over the last four
decades. The exports from gems and jewellery sector grew from just US$ 28
million in 1966-67, representing a 3 per cent of total merchandise exports of the
country, when the Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council (GJEPC) was
established, to US$ 42.84 billion in F.Y. 2011-12, contributing 15 per cent of total
exports, making it a significant foreign exchange earner for the country. The
industry is a truly global one, with both suppliers and buyers from many differentcountries. The UAE (44 percent), Hong Kong (25 percent) and USA (12 percent)
are among the major buyers, while Belgium, which accounts for 21.55 percent of
all imports of raw materials, is by far the major supplier.
The table no.1.1 and figure no. 1.1 analyses the share of gems and
jewellery sector in total merchandise exports of India during period ranging from
F.Y. 2001-2002 to F.Y. 2011-2012. Gem and jewellery sector is one of the
13
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
14/60
leading foreign exchange earners of the country.The export of gems and jewellery
sector stood at US$ 7306 million in the F.Y. 2001-2002 in the total merchandise
export from India which stood at US$ 43,827 million during the same period. The
gems and jewellery sector contributed almost 16.67% of the total merchandise
exports of the country. This proportion has remained more or less same till the
F.Y. 2005-2006. During the F.Y. 2006-2007, the share of gems and jewellery
sector in the total merchandise export of the country fell to 12.64% and further to
12.07% in the F.Y. 2007-2008. This was due to failure of major banks in the US
and the debt crisis in the European economy.
Table No. 1.1
Proportion of Gems and Jewellery Exports in the Total Merchandise Exports of
India (2001-2012)
Year Export of Gems &
Jewellery
(US$ in Million)
Total Merchandise
Export
(US$ in Million)
% Share
in Total Exports
2001-2002 7306 43827 16.67%
2002-2003 9030 52719 17.13%
2003-2004 10573 63843 16.56%
2004-2005 13762 83536 16.47%2005-2006 15529 103091 15.06%
2006-2007 15983 126414 12.64%
2007-2008 19692 163132 12.07%
2008-2009 28411 185295 15.33%
2009-2010 29081 178751 16.27%
2010-2011 40508 251136 16.13%
2011-2012 (P) 46957 304624 15.41%
Source: Compiled from the annual reports of GJEPC, 2001-2002 to 2011-2012.
14
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
15/60
7306 9030 10573 13762 15529 1598319692 28411 29081
40508 469574382752719
6384383536
103091126414
163132185295 178751
251136
304624
0
50000
100000
150000
200000
250000
300000
350000
2001-022002-032003-042004-052005-062006-072007-082008-092009-102010-112011-12
(P)
Export of Gems and Jewellery Total Merchandise Export
Fig. No. 1.1 Proportion of Gems and Jewellery Exports in the Total Merchandise
Exports of India (2001-2012)
The exports from gems and jewellery sector again bounced back in the
F.Y. 2008-2009 to reach US$ 28411 as against the total merchandise export of
India which stood at US$ 185295, thus contributing 15.33% of the total
merchandise export of the country. In the following years, the export of gems and
jewellery not only retained but strengthened its position to contribute 16.27% in
the F.Y. 2009-2010, 16.13% in the F.Y. 2010-2011 and 15.41% in the year 2011-
2012.
Observation: The share of gems and jewellery sector exports in the total exports
from India has remained more or less stable at 15% during last decade with some
variations in between 2006-2008.
(B) Average Annual Growth in the Exports of Gems and Jewellery vis-
a-vis Total Merchandise Exports from India: (2001-2012)
Table no. 1.2 and figure 1.2 analyses the average annual growth rate of exports of
gems and jewellery sector from India vis-a-vis average annual growth rate of total
15
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
16/60
merchandise exports from India. It can be seen that the export of gems and
jewellery from India has grown consistently over last decade at variable rate.
During last decade, the export of gems and jewellery has increased 5.5 times
while that of total merchandise exports from India increased by 6 times.
Table No. 1.2
Average Annual Growth in the Exports of Gems and Jewellery vis-a-vis Total
Merchandise Exports of India (2001-2012)
Year Export of
Gems &
Jewellery
(US$ in Million)
% Growth over
Previous F.Y.
Total
Merchandise
Export
(US$ in Million)
% Growth over
Previous F.Y.
2001-2002 7306 - 43827 -
2002-2003 9030 23.59 52719 20.29
2003-2004 10573 16.56 63843 21.10
2004-2005 13762 16.47 83536 30.85
2005-2006 15529 15.06 103091 23.41
2006-2007 15983 2.93 126414 22.63
2007-2008 19692 23.20 163132 29.05
2008-2009 28411 44.28 185295 13.59
2009-2010 29081 2.36 178751 3.53
2010-2011 40508 39.30 251136 40.50
2011-2012 (P) 46957 15.92 304624 21.30
Source: Compiled from the annual reports of GJEPC, 2001-2002 to 2011-2012.
16
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
17/60
0
23.59
16.56 16.4715.06
2.93
23.2
44.28
2.36
39.3
15.92
0
20.29 21.1
30.85
23.41 22.63
29.05
13.59
0
40.5
21.3
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
2001-022002-032003-042004-052005-062006-072007-082008-092009-102010-112011-12(P)
AnnualAveragegrowthRate(%)
Years
Average Annual Growth Rate of Gems and Jewellery Exports
Average Annual growth Rate of Total Merchandise Exports
Fig. No. 1.2 Average Annual Growth in the Exports of Gems and Jewellery vis-
a-vis Total Merchandise Exports from India: (2001-2012)
During 2002-2003, the export of gems and jewellery has increased by
23.59% over its previous year which is more that the annual average increase in
merchandise exports of India which was 20.29% during the same period. During
three years from 2003-2004 to 2005-2006, the exports of gems and jewellery has
increased at a constant rate of 16% p.a., as against total merchandise exports at
approximately 25% p.a. In the year 2006-2007, average annual growth rate of
export of gems and jewellery sector fell to mere 2.93%, although the annual
growth rate of total merchandise exports sustained at 23%. The reasons for this
sharp fall in average annual growth rate of gems and jewellery sector was due to
failure of some reputed companies and banks in the US and reports of debt crisis
in European economy.
In the year 2007-2008, the annual average growth rate of exports of gems
17
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
18/60
and jewellery sector revived at 23.20% and total merchandise exports at 29%. In
2008-2009, although the total merchandise exports from India fell drastically at
13.59%, export of gems and jewellery sector jumped up by 44.28%. In 2009-
2010, total merchandise exports grew negatively by 3.53% but export of gems and
jewellery sector managed to grow by 2.36%. The impact of crisis in USA and the
European economy can be clearly seen on both total exports as well as export of
gems and jewellery sector during this period. However, the revival package
announced by the respective governments and the efforts of the Indian
government to revive exports led to revival to exports in 2010-2011, with gems
and jewellery export rising by 39.30% and total merchandise export rose by
almost same rate at 40.50%. In the F.Y. 2011-2012, the average annual growth
rates of gems and jewellery exports and total merchandise exports of India
stabilised at 16% and 21% respectively.
(C) Correlation between Average Annual Growth in the Exports of
Gems and Jewellery vis-a-vis Total Merchandise Exports from
India: (2001-2012)
X = Average Annual growth Rate of Export of Gems and Jewellery Sector
Y = Average Annual growth Rate of Total Merchandise Exports from India
Table No. 1.3
Correlation between Average Annual Growth in the Exports of Gems and Jewellery
vis-a-vis Total Merchandise Exports of India (2001-2012)
Year % Growth over
Previous F.Y.*
(X)
% Growth over
Previous F.Y.*
(Y)
XY X2 Y2
2002-2003 24 20 480 576 400
2003-2004 17 21 357 289 441
2004-2005 17 31 527 289 961
2005-2006 15 23 345 225 529
2006-2007 3 23 69 9 529
2007-2008 23 29 667 529 841
2008-2009 44 14 616 1936 196
2009-2010 2 4 8 4 16
2010-2011 39 41 1599 1521 1681
18
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
19/60
2011-2012
(P)
16 21 336 256 441
Total 200 219 4988 5634 6035
*rounded off to nearest unit.
Source: Compiled from the annual reports of GJEPC, 2001-2002 to 2011-2012.
Karl Pearsons Coefficient of Correlation =
N
YY
N
XX
N
YXXY
22
22 )()(
=
10
)219(6035
10
)200(5634
10
2192004988
22
X
=1980.354228.40
43804988
X
=8017.1422
608
= 0.4273
Interpretation of the results: It can be concluded that there is a weak positive
correlation between average annual growth rate of export of gems and jewellery
and average annual growth rate of total merchandise exports from India.
Observation: It is observed in the above analysis that the average annual growth
rate of export of gems and jewellery from India is independent of the average
annual growth rate of merchandise exports. This is clearly reflected in the years of
the US and the European financial crisis.
3.7 Components of Export of Gems and Jewellery from India during
2001-02 to 2011-2012:
The gems and jewellery sector consists of export of the following 10 items in its
ambit:
(1) Cut and polished diamonds.
19
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
20/60
(2) Coloured gem stones.
(3) Gold jewellery.
(4) Pearls.
(5) Silver jewellery.
(6) Synthetic stones.
(7) Costume fashion jewellery.
(8) Sales of above items to foreign tourist.
(9) Export of Rough diamonds.
(10)Rough stones and pearls.
Among these, cut and polished diamonds, coloured gem stones, gold jewellery
and rough diamonds are the major contributors. Therefore, the researcher has
considered the above four items in his analysis.
Table 1.3
Components of Export of Gems and Jewellery from India during 2001-02 to 2011-
2012
(in US$ in Million)
Year Cut &
Polished
Diamonds
Coloured
Gem Stones
Gold
Jewellery
Rough
Diamonds
Total
Exports*
2001-2002 5982 183 1169 142 7569
2002-2003 7105 192 1512 241 9162
2003-2004 8603 178 2666 533 12112
2004-2005 11163 193 3784 357 15658
2005-2006 11831 234 3882 566 16701
2006-2007 10910 247 5209 565 17159
2007-2008 14205 276 5562 567 20921
2008-2009 14804 261 8746 776 24894
2009-2010 18244 287 9679 744 294422010-2011 28221 315 12702 1137 43048
2011-2012 (P) 23330 343 16517 1773 46957
*Total export includes export of all the constituents of gems and jewellery sector.
20
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
21/60
Figure No. 1.3 Major Components of Gems and Jewellery Exports from India
(2001-2012)
The table no. 1.3 and figure no. 1.3 analyse the export of gems and jewellery
sector from India during the period from 2001-02 to 2011-2012. Cut and polished
diamonds, coloured gem stones, gold jewellery and rough diamonds are the four
major components of export basket of gems and jewellery sector. Among these,
the export of cut and polished diamonds majorly contribute to total export of the
sector. Considering the major contribution of the cut and polished diamonds in the
total exports from the gems and jewellery sector, the researcher has selected
analytical study of diamond trade of India under the title Diamond Trade of
India.
Observation: It is observed in the above analysis that the cut and polished
diamonds constitute major parts of the gems and jewellery export of India. Cut
and polished diamonds consisted of more than 50% of the total export of gems
and jewellery sector from India.
4.1 An Overview of Indian Diamond Industry:
From ancient times, India is well known in the world as the birthplace of
21
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
22/60
diamonds. It has remained the home of diamonds for over two millenniums. It is
difficult to trace the origin of diamond but the history says that in the remote past,
diamonds were mined only in India. Diamond production in India can be traced
back to almost 8th century B.C. India in fact, remained undisputed leader till 18th
century when Brazilian fields were discovered in 1725 AD followed by
emergence of South Africa, Russia and Australia. World famous diamonds such
as Koh-i-noor, the Orloff, the Great Mogul, Sancy Hope, Florentine, Nassak,
Regent, Pitli, Nizam etc. were the products of India and many of these world
famous diamonds were discovered in India from 16 th and 17th centuries.
Today, Indian diamond trade mainly consists of import trade whereby rough
diamonds are imported into the country mainly for the purpose of cutting and
polishing and after processing they are re-exported. Nine out of ten diamonds cut
and polished in the world are cut and polished in India. India processes 100mn
carats of rough diamonds against the worlds total output of 117mn carats of rough
diamonds, and is the largest diamond polishing centre. The USA, on the other hand,
is the largest market for loose polished diamonds and diamond jewellery.
India leads the globe in diamond manufacturing with 60% share in value,
85% in volume and 92% share in the number of pieces produced. In India, rough
diamonds have been mined since historic times. But it was only after the year
1962 AD that processing, cutting and polishing of diamonds developed as an
industry. Nearly 80% of the country's natural diamond processing is done in
Gujarat, of which Surat and Navsari, and some districts of Saurashtra region
account for most of it. The cut and polished diamonds are mainly exported to the
United States of America, Japan, Belgium, Hong Kong, Switzerland and
Thailand. Of these, the USA, Japan and Switzerland are consumer markets and
the rest of them are trading countries. Some commission agents supply roughs to
the firms in India for processing on behalf of the sight-holders who take the
finished product for export.
22
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
23/60
The Indian gems and jewellery industry is competitive in the world market
due to its low cost of production and the availability of skilled labour. India has a
large pool of skilled and low cost manpower for its gems and jewellery industry.
The country has worlds one of the best skilled manpower to design and make
high volumes of exquisite jewellery at relatively low labour cost. The cost per
carat for cutting and polishing diamond is US$ 10 in India as compared to US$ 17
in China and US$ 150 in Belgium. The Indian diamond industry employs around
2 million people (constituting 94 per cent of global workers in the industry) with
more than 500 hi-tech laser machines. It also has the largest resource hub in
diamond cutting and processing. Low cost of labour involved in production of
finished diamonds has lured global attention, thereby resulting into the growth of
the industry. In addition, the industry has set up a worldwide distribution network,
of more than 3,000 offices for the promotion and marketing of Indian diamonds.
The industry is well supported by government policies and the banking
sector with around 50 banks providing nearly $3 billion of credit to the Indian
diamond industry. India has its diamond bourse functioning at Mumbai. India is,
therefore, a significant player in the world gems and jewellery market both as a
source of processed diamonds as well as a large consuming market.
The Indian diamond industry is largely family owned. Earlier it was
scattered in a cottage industry format but now it has emerged as a modern
mechanized industry undertaking its operations on a large scale with modern
technology. Still, 96% of industry consists of family-owned businesses scattered
in large area. Only 4% industry comes under organized sector.
4.1 Significance of Diamond Trade for Indian Economy:
The Gems and Jewellery industry in India is structured as diamonds,
23
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
24/60
jewellery and precious and semi-precious stones. These segments are further
divided into sub-segments. The following diagram indicates the structure of gems
and jewellery sector and various sub-segments operating under the umbrella term.
Gems and Jewellery Industry Structure
Among these, diamond has a lions share in Indian Gems and Jewellery
exports and contributes approximately 60-70% of the revenue of the Gems and
Jewellery sector. Diamond industry has been growing at 15-17% annually since
last two decades. The following diagram shows the growth rate of diamond
industry since the year 1975.
Figure 11: Gems and Jewellery share (%) in Indias total exports
24
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
25/60
Diamond trade constitutes an important industry for the Indian economy. It
is one of the fastest growing industries and a leading earner of foreign exchange
for India. As stated earlier, the diamond industry in India is mostly concentrated
in the unorganized sector and employs around 2 million workers. An important
feature of this industry is that it contributes a large share to Indias total exports as
well as to the countrys imports (averaging over 9 percent of total imports since
1997 and 15% of total exports). As a commodity, it has the (single) highest share
in Indian merchandise exports and is therefore, one of the most significant
industries for India. Rough and uncut diamonds are imported and processed in
India and finally exported in the form of diamond jewellery for final consumption.
It is this feature that makes the industry highly import-intensive in nature.
The diamond segment contributes a major share of nearly 60-70 percent of
the total (gems and jewellery) export and thus, the remainder of the analysis
focuses on the performance of Indian diamond exports. However, the latters
share has declined since 2008, in part, due to the economic meltdown which
reduced the import demand from USA and other trading partners of India.
25
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
26/60
4.2 Diamond Trade of India vis--vis Global Diamond Trade:
India is the world's largest diamond cutting and polishing centre in theworld with the country processing 11 out of 12 diamonds sold in the global
market. Even though diamond processing takes place in about 30 countries across
the globe, a big chunk of concentration lies in five countries of India, Belgium,
South Africa, Israel and US.
A unique feature of diamonds is that, unlike gold, silver or platinum, they
do not have an internationally set standard price. The price is determined based of
physical attributes such as cut, colour, clarity and carat (weight). Like other forms
of (valuable) jewellery, diamonds are a luxury item and consequently have a
highly elastic demand in the market. In this industry, India has a comparative
advantage in labour-intensive activities like gem cutting and polishing. Therefore,
Indian companies operate at a beneficial level in the value chain where they
import rough diamonds, which are processed and exported for final consumption
as diamond jewellery. India accounts for approximately 60% of the global
polished diamonds in value terms, 80% in karatage and 90% in pieces. China and
Thailand are also catching up as centres for diamond cutting and polishing.
The diamond processing industry is largely dependent on supply of rough
diamonds. Australia, Botswana, Russia and South Africa are the major suppliers
of rough diamonds. The production of rough diamonds from mines is presently
dominated by De Beers (DTC), which is the largest diamond miner in the world.
Diamond exports from India recovered substantially with the onset of a
gradual global economic recovery, although a part of the increase was attributed
to weaker Indian Rupee. The favourable exchange rate, coupled with higher
demand and government incentives, has led to improved liquidity for most
26
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
27/60
diamond processors and jewellery makers.
(A) Indias position in the export of diamonds in the global market:Indias position in the world market for gems and jewellery exports can be
seen in the Figure 12. The figure reveals that India has always been an important
source market for gems and jewellery and its significance has grown considerably
during last two decades. Indian exports performed particularly well in 2009 and
India became a leading exporter of gems and jewellery, with a market share
exceeding 23 percent.
Figure 12: Indias Share in World exports of Gems and Jewellery
Indias diamond exports, which form the major share of gems and
jewellery exports, too have an important share in the global diamond exports. It
has grown from 13.4 percent in 2000, to 20.1 percent in 2009. Indias main
competitors in the diamond industry are Israel and Belgium, and both thesecountries have a technological advantage in the processing of raw diamonds.
India has traditionally specialized in the processing of small diamonds, whereas
Belgium and Israel have had the advanced technology to work with larger
diamonds. Since the market for small-sized diamonds is relatively small, Indias
share in the world market has usually been lower than that of Israel and Belgium.
(B) Major Exporters of Diamonds and their Share in World Trade:
27
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
28/60
Table 2 reveals the change in market share since 2000. It is seen that
Indias market share remained unchanged and well below Israel and Belgiums
share between 2000 and 2005. In 2009, however, Indias share rose considerably
above that of Belgium and Israel, which could partly be due to the stronger impact
of the sub-prime crisis of 2008 on the demand for large sized diamonds, which
resulted in a decline in market share for Israel and Belgium.
Table 2: Major exporters of Diamonds and their share in world exports (%)
4.2Trends in Export of Diamonds from India:
The structure of the global diamond industry can be explained with the
help of the 3.1 diagram. India is the main centre for processing of diamonds, i.e.,
making cut and polished diamonds from roughs. India processes 100mn carats of
rough diamonds against the worlds total output of 117mn carats of rough
diamonds, and the largest diamond polishing centre. USA on the other hand is the
largest market for loose polished diamonds and diamond jewellery.
Australia India USA
(Largest Diamond Producer) (Biggest Diamond Processor) (Largest Diamond Market)
Fig 3.1 Global Diamond Industry Structure
28
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
29/60
The availability of low-cost labour is one of the main factors behind India's
dominance in export of cut and polished diamonds. India spends US$10 per carat
on the polishing and cutting of diamonds, against China's US$17 and South
Africa's US$40 to US$60, Belgium, Israel and Russia US$60-80 while United
States approximately US$ 100. The vast resources of manpower combined with
"the skill of the Indian artisan" and the "relentless efforts of Indian entrepreneurs
who took on the daunting task of setting up this industry" are additional
contributors to India's success.
Table 3.2
Estimated Cost of Cutting and Polishing, $ per carat
Country Estimated Cost of Cutting and Polishing
Diamond, $ per Carat
India ~10
China ~15-20
South Africa ~40-60
Belgium, Israel and Russia ~60-80
United States ~100+
Source: Dogrib Diamond Report; expert interviews
Currently 700,000 to 800,000 diamond cutters work in India, bolstered in
part by government subsidies. Before the recent recession, Indian craftspeople cut
14 out of 15 diamonds worldwide, mostly in the states of Maharashtra and
Gujarat. About 30,000 to 50,000 cutters operate in China and Thailand, and the
numbers there are rising. Guangzhou in China is now one of the worlds largest
global cutting centres. Sri Lanka is also making significant inroads.
In addition to export of cut and polished diamonds, India also exports
rough diamonds. But the proportion of export of rough diamonds in total export of
gems and jewellery sector is very low.
(A) Trends in Exports of Cut and Polished Diamonds vis-a-vis Gems
and Jewellery Exports and Total Merchandise Exports from India:
29
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
30/60
Table No. 1.4
Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds vis-a-vis Gems and Jewellery
Exports and Total Merchandise Exports from India
Year Cut &
Polished
Diamonds(US$ in Million)
% of Export
of Gems and
Jewellery
Total Export
of Gems &
Jewellery
Sector*(US$ in Million)
% of Total
Merchandise
Exports
Total
Merchandise
Exports
2001-2002 5982 79.03% 7569 13.65% 43827
2002-2003 7105 77.55% 9162 13.48% 52719
2003-2004 8603 71.03% 12112 13.48% 63843
2004-2005 11163 71.29% 15658 13.36% 83536
2005-2006 11831 70.84% 16701 11.48% 103091
2006-2007 10910 63.58% 17159 8.63% 126414
2007-2008 14205 67.90% 20921 8.71% 163132
2008-2009 14804 59.47% 24894 8.00% 1852952009-2010 18244 61.96% 29442 10.21% 178751
2010-2011 28221 65.56% 43048 11.24% 251136
2011-2012 (P) 23330 49.68% 46957 7.66% 304624
*Includes export of all the constituents of gems and jewellery sector.
The table no. 1.4 and figure no. 1.4 and figure no. 1.5 show the export of cut and
polished diamonds as a percetange of total exports from gems and jewellery sector
and total merchandise exports from India from 2001-02 to 2011-2012. It can be
seen in the above table that export of cut and polished diamonds is one of the
major constituents of the gems and jewellery sector. In the year 2001-02, the
export of cut and polished diamonds constituted almost 80% of the total exports
from gems and jewellery sector. By 2005-2006, this proportion fell down to 70%
due to increase in the export of gold jewellery and coloured gem stones. Between
2006-2007 and 2010-2011, the share of cut and polished diamonds in the total
gems and jewellery sector export fluctuated between 60% to 70%. In the FY
2011-2012, the share of cut and polished diamonds fell down to 50%.
The export of cut and polished diamonds constituted almost 14% of the total
merchandise exports from India in the year 2001-2002. This has fallen to merely
7.66% of the total merchandise exports of India in the year 2011-2012.
It is interesting to note that during the last decade the export of gems and
30
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
31/60
jewellery sector as a whole has increased at an average rate of 15% p.a. However,
the proportion of cut and polished diamonds in the export basket of gems and
jewellery sector has declined during the same period. There are several factor
responsible for this fall, prominent among them is the increase in the share of gold
jewellery and bottlenecks in the supply of rough diamonds from mines. The share
of export of gold jewellery in total exports of gems and jewellery sector has
increased from 15% in the year 2001-2002 to approximately 35% of the total
exports from gems and jewellery sector in the year 2011-2012.
Figure No. 1.4 Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds as a % of Total Exports of
Gems and Jewellery Sector
31
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
32/60
Figure No. 1.5 Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds as a % of Total Merchandise
Export of India
Observation: It can be concluded from the above analysis that cut and polished
diamonds have contributed almost 80% of the exports from gems and jewellery sector at
the turn of this century. However, this proportion has gradually come down to 50% of
the exports of gems and jewellery sector mainly due to increase in the export of goldjewellery, which constituted only 15% of the total exports from gems and jewellery
sector in the year 2001-2002 and increased to 35% of the exports from gems and
jewellery sector at the end of 2011-2012.
(B) Analysis of the Average Annual Growth Rate of Export of Cut and
Polished Diamonds from India during 2001-02 to 2011-2012:
Table No. 1.5
Year Export of
Cut &
Polished
Diamonds(US$ in
Million)
Average
Annual
Growth
Rate over
Previous
Year
Exports of
Gems and
Jewellery
Sector*(US$ inMillion)
Average
Annual
Growth
Rate over
Previous
Year
Total
Merchandis
e Export(US$ inMillion)
Average
Annual
Growth
Rate over
Previous
Year
2001-2002 5982 - 7306 - 43827 -
2002-2003 7105 18.77% 9030 23.59 52719 20.29
2003-2004 8603 21.08% 10573 16.56 63843 21.10
2004-2005 11163 29.75% 13762 16.47 83536 30.85
2005-2006 11831 5.98% 15529 15.06 103091 23.41
2006-2007 10910 - 7.79% 15983 2.93 126414 22.63
32
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
33/60
2007-2008 14205 30.20% 19692 23.20 163132 29.05
2008-2009 14804 3.90% 28411 44.28 185295 13.59
2009-2010 18244 23.24% 29081 2.36 178751 3.53
2010-2011 28221 54.69% 40508 39.30 251136 40.50
2011-2012 (P) 23330 - 17.33% 46957 15.92 304624 21.30
*Includes export of all the constituents of gems and jewellery sector.
The above table analyses the average annual growth rate of exports of cut and
polished diamonds vis-a-vis the average annual growth rate of exports of gems
and jewellery and total merchandise exports from India during 2001-2002 to
2011-2012.
It can be seen that the export of cut and polished diamonds has increased steadily
during the last decade at an average annual rate of 20% p.a. with few exceptions.
During 2002-2003 to 2004-2005, the export of cut and polished diamonds
increased at an annual rate of almost 20-25% p.a. However, during 2005-2006 this
growth slumped to mere 5.98% which turned into negative at 7.79% during
2006-2007. There are several reasons for this slump, the prominent among them is
the rise in the price of rough diamonds and slackening demand from the US and
European countries. The export of cut and polished diamonds revived during
2007-2008 to jump by over 30% over its previous year. In the year 2008-2009, it
again turned sluggish to increase by mere 3.9% over its previous year. This
sluggishness was marked by rapid increase in the export of gold jewellery. In the
year 2009-2010 and 2010-2011, the export of cut and polished diamonds revived
to rise annually by 23.24% and 54.69% respectively. The provisional figures
announced for the financial year 2011-2012 showed a fall of 17.33% in the annual
growth of export of cut and polished diamonds from India.
(C) Correlation between Average Annual Growth in the Exports of
Cut and Polished Diamonds vis-a-vis Total Exports of Gems and
Jewellery Sector from India: (2001-2012)
X = Average Annual growth Rate of Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds
33
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
34/60
Y = Average Annual growth Rate of Total Exports of Gems and Jewellery Sector
Table No. 1.3
Correlation between Average Annual Growth in the Exports of Cut and Polished
Diamonds vis-a-vis Total Exports of gems and Jewellery Sector from India (2001-
2012)
Year % Growth over
Previous F.Y.*
(X)
% Growth over
Previous F.Y.*
(Y)
XY X2 Y2
2002-2003 19 24 456 361 576
2003-2004 21 17 357 441 289
2004-2005 30 17 510 900 289
2005-2006 6 15 90 36 225
2006-2007 8 3 24 64 92007-2008 30 23 690 900 529
2008-2009 4 44 176 16 1936
2009-2010 23 2 46 529 4
2010-2011 55 39 2145 3025 1521
2011-2012 (P) 17 16 272 289 256
Total 163 200 4174 6561 5634
*rounded off to nearest unit.
Source: Compiled from the annual reports of GJEPC, 2001-2002 to 2011-2012.
Karl Pearsons Coefficient of Correlation =
N
YY
N
XX
N
YXXY
22
22 )()(
=
10
)200(5634
10
)163(6561
10
2001634174
22
X
=4228.404828.62
32604174
X
=7297.2525
914
= 0.3619
Interpretation of the results: It can be concluded that there is a weak positive
correlation between average annual growth rate of export of cut and polished
34
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
35/60
diamond and total exports of gems and jewellery sector from India.
Observation: It is observed in the above analysis that the average annual growth
rate of export of cut and polished diamonds from India is independent of the
average annual growth rate of total exports from gems and jewellery sector. This
is clearly reflected in the years of the US and the European financial crisis. There
are several factors that contribute to this independence:
(1) Gems and jewellery trade consists of a number of sub-sectors which are
independent of each others.
(2) Export of processed diamonds depends mainly on the supply of rough
diamonds which are sourced internationally.
(3) Processing of diamond also depends upon demand from the US and
European nations, which are facing a tough time.
(4) The Foreign Trade Policy of the Indian government and that of other
countries also affect the demand and supply conditions.
(D) Trends in Exports of Rough Diamonds vis-a-vis Total Exports of
Gems and Jewellery Sector from India (2001-02 to 2010-11):
Table No. 1.5
Trends in Export of Rough Diamonds vis-a-vis Total Exports of Gems and
Jewellery Sector from India
Year Rough
Diamonds
(US$ in Million)
Exports of
G&J Sector
(US$ in Million)
% Share of
Rough
Diamonds in
Total Exports
of G&J sector
Average
Annual
Growth Rate
over Previous
Year
2001-2002 142 7569 1.88% -
2002-2003 241 9162 2.63% 69.72%
2003-2004 533 12112 4.40% 121.16%
2004-2005 357 15658 2.28% 33.02%
2005-2006 566 16701 3.39% 58.54%
2006-2007 565 17159 3.29% 0.18%
2007-2008 567 20921 2.71% 0.35%
2008-2009 776 24894 3.12% 36.86%
2009-2010 744 29442 2.53% 4.12%
2010-2011 1137 43048 2.64% 52.82%
2011-2012 (P) 1773 46957 3.78% 55.94%
35
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
36/60
Rough diamonds are mined in more than 20 different countries including
India. Indias annual production is negligible at around 19000 carats. The share of
rough diamonds in total export basket of gems and jewellery sector is negligible.
The export of rough diamonds stood at US$ 142 million in the year 2001-2002
which constituted 1.88% of the total export of gems and jewellery sector. This
proportion increased to 2.63% and 4.40% in the year 2002-2003 and 2003-2004
respectively. However, in the year 2004-2005, the export of rough diamonds from
India again fell to 2.28% of the export of gems and jewellery sector registering a
negative growth of 33.02% over its previous year. Since then, the share of
export of rough diamonds in total exports of gems and jewellery sector has
remained between 2% to 4% of the total exports of gems and jewellery sector.
The average annual growth rate of export of rough diamonds from India showed a
spectacular rise of 52.82% and 55.94% during the year 2010-2011 and 2011-2012
respectively.
4.3Trends in Import of Rough Diamonds in India:
The Indian diamond processing industry took roots in the 1960s. As
compared with the traditional diamond cutting and polishing centres of Belgium,
India, with its low labour cost, opened up new possibilities for the world diamond
industry by making diamonds affordable for new, less affluent buyers. As a result,
India captured an increased proportion of this market, and at present, India is the
worlds leading diamond cutting and polishing centre.
Though India plays a dominant role in the Gems and Jewellery industry in
terms of processing and consumption, its role in the mining of gold and diamond
is minimal. India imports gold and rough diamonds along with other precious
metals. The African continent dominates the mining space of diamonds whereas
India is the dominant player in diamond processing. Thus, Indian mainly imports
36
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
37/60
raw and rough diamonds from other countries, mainly from African countries,
processes them into cut and polished diamonds and exports them to several other
countries of the world.
It can be seen in the following table that India imported 8.2% of the total
rough diamonds supply in the world in the year 2000. This share rose to 11.8% in
the year 2005, putting India at the second place next to the USA in terms of the
importer of rough diamonds. By 2009, India grabbed 16.8% of the market share of
total rough diamond supply in the world, bagging first position in terms of
importer of rough diamonds.
Table 4
Main World Importers of Diamonds
Reproduced from an ICRA Report on the Indian Gems and Jewellery Industry (October 2010), p. 30
(A) Trends in Import of Rough Diamonds by India:
Table No. 1.5
Trends in Import of Rough Diamond by India from 2001-2002 to 2011-2012
Year Rough
Diamonds
(US$ in Million)
Average
Annual
Growth Rate
over Previous
Year
2001-2002 4,207 -
2002-2003 6,273 49.11%
2003-2004 7,137 13.77%
2004-2005 7,648 7.16%
2005-2006 8,698 13.73%
37
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
38/60
2006-2007 8,767 0.79%
2007-2008 9,797 11.75%
2008-2009 7,960 18.75%
2009-2010 9,048 13.67%
2010-2011 11,994 32.56%
2011-2012 15132 26.16%
It can be seen in the above table that the import of rough diamonds has
gradually increased in India during last decade from mere US$ 4207 million in the
year 2001-2002 to US$ 15132 million in the year 2011-2012. Indian mainly
imports rough diamonds for processing and re-exporting. The year 2002-2003
showed a sudden jump in import of rough diamonds by almost 49.11% over its
previous year. There after it grew at an average of about 10% until 2007-2008. In
the year 2008-2009, there was a negative growth in the import of rough diamonds
in India. The import of rough diamonds during 2008-2009 fell by 18.75% over its
previous year. The main reason for this fall was the ban put by the GJEPC on
import of rough diamonds in the country.
The organized Indian diamond industry decided to stop all rough diamond
imports to the country for a month starting November 25. The cited reason was to
send a signal to the banks that the industry will not increase indebtedness. The
economic crisis followed by crippling demand forced GJEPC to urge for a 30 day
ban. The ban was in interest of the Indian diamond industry to help stabilize
prices by reducing oversupply of diamonds and shielding companies from
borrowing money to purchase diamonds. The following is the full text of the
GJEPC announcement:
The Global financial situation is causing a strain on the players throughout
the diamond value chain. In order to protect the interest of the industry at
large the Indian Diamond Industry has decided to curtail import of rough
diamonds. This will also send signal to the banking system that the
diamond industry will not increase its indebtedness at the time when our
38
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
39/60
downstream colleagues continue to meet consumer demand a demand
heightened by the inherent value which consumers attach to our product.
Therefore, the Gems & Jewellery Export Promotion Council has asked its
members to cease the imports of rough diamonds for a month from
November 25. Such import stoppage will help the industry face the
challenge that has arisen out of turmoil in the global financial market. 3
Mr. Vasant Mehta, Chairman, GJEPC, observed "Our members have
sufficient rough diamonds in stock to minimize the impact on our labour force".
Mr. Mehta added "Our move will basically cause fewer rough to enter the
diamond pipeline and the producer companies will thus indirectly share in the
financing burden and contribute to a faster restoration of normalcy in an otherwise
healthy business".
(B) Value Addition and Foreign Exchange Generation by Diamond
Processing Industry in India:
Table No. 1.6
Trends in Import of Rough Diamond by India from 2001-2002 to 2011-2012
Year Import of
Rough
Diamonds
(US$ in Million)
Export of
Cut &
Polished
Diamonds(US$ in Million)
AAGR of
Imports over
Previous Year
AAGR of
Exports over
Previous Year
Value
Addition
(US$ in Million)
2001-2002 4,207 5982 - - 1775
2002-2003 6,273 7105 49.11% 18.77% 832
2003-2004 7,137 8603 13.77% 21.08% 1466
2004-2005 7,648 11163 7.16% 29.75% 35152005-2006 8,698 11831 13.73% 5.98% 3133
2006-2007 8,767 10910 0.79% - 7.79% 2143
2007-2008 9,797 14205 11.75% 30.20% 4408
2008-2009 7,960 14804 18.75% 3.90% 6844
2009-2010 9,048 18244 13.67% 23.24% 9196
2010-2011 11,994 28221 32.56% 54.69% 16227
2011-2012 15132 23330 26.16% - 17.33% 8198
AAGR: Annual Average Growth Rate.
The Gems and Jewellery industry collectively contributed only 0.2% of the
3 Official web-site of GJEPC, accessed on 21st March 2013.
39
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
40/60
total export of the country in the year 1960-61. This contribution increased to
16.2% of the total exports in the year 1990-91 and further to 16.6% of total
exports in the year 2000-2001. The contribution of gems and jewellery sector to
the total exports of the economy stood at 14.9% in the year 2010-2011. 4 During
last four decades, the gems and jewellery sector has become one of the most
important sector of the economy, in terms of employment generation and foreign
exchange earner.
Diamond processing industry is one of the most important segments of the
gems and jewellery sector. In the year 2001-2002, export of cut and polished
diamonds contributed almost 80% of the export of gems and jewellery sector.
This proportion gradually came down to 65% in the year 2010-2011. The reason
being increasing demand for diamond studded gold jewellery from India. Thus,
there has been increasing trends in favour of gold jewellery rather than cut and
polished diamonds. Although the share of cut and polished diamonds in total
exports of the country fell down from 80% to mere 50% during the last decade, in
absolute terms it has increased. The exports from gems and jewellery sector could
sustain even during the phases of recession in the world economies.
In the year 2001-2002, India imported rough diamonds worth US$ 4207
million and exported cut and polished diamonds worth US$ 5982, thus making a
contribution to US$ 1175 to the foreign exchange account of the country. It
should be kept in mind that Indian processors do not necessarily process rough
diamonds in the year in which they buy. Generally, they buy rough diamonds as
and when site holders are allotted quota and rough diamonds are available at
cheaper rate. Liquidity and holding capacity are the other factors that affect the
purchase of rough diamonds by processors. In the following year, i.e. 2002-2003,
import of rough diamonds jumped up by 50% over its previous year while exports
remained sluggish registering a growth of 18.77%, pulling down the net value
4 Government of India, Economic Survey of India, 1960-61, 1990-91, 2000-2001 and 2010-2011.
40
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
41/60
additions to mere US$ 832 million. Since then there has been rapid increase in the
foreign exchange contribution of the diamond sector.
The net value addition by diamond processing industry stood at US$ 1466
million in the year 2003-2004. It further increased to US$ 3515 million in the year
2004-2005. The reason for this sudden increase in value addition by diamond
industry was fall in the average annual growth rate of imports (from 13.77% to
7.16%) and increase in exports (from 21.08% to 29.75%) over previous year
(2003-2004). In the following year, rise in imports and fall in exports pushed
down this figure to US$ 3133 million. In the year 2006-2007, the average annual
growth rate of exports of cut and polished diamonds turned negative ( 7.79%),
resulting in further fall in value addition to US$ 2143 million.
In the year 2008, the GJEPC put a ban on import of rough diamonds in
India on the ground that India had enough stock of rough diamonds and this
decision of GJEPC proved boon to diamond industry pushing net value addition
by diamond processing industry to US$ 4408 million in the year 2007-2008. IN
2008-2009, the import of rough diamonds fell down by 18.75%, resulting in
further rise in value addition to US$ 6844 million. The net value addition by the
diamond industry increased to US$ 9196 million in the year 2009-2010 and
further to US$ 16227 million in the year 2010-2011 due to the hopes of revival of
the US economy and steps taken by the European economies to resolve sub-prime
debt crisis in their economies.
In the year 2011-2012, the export of cut and polished diamonds fell down
by 17.33% over its previous year while imports increased by 26.15%. This led to
drastic fall in the value addition by 50% from US$ 16227 million in the year
2010-2011 to US$ 8198 million in the year 2011-2012.
A number of factors are posing challenge to Indian diamond industry.
41
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
42/60
Some of them are threat from upcoming processing centres such as China and Sri
Lanka, rising prices of rough diamonds shrinking margins, domestic competition,
falling demand for diamonds in the world market and so on. However, the Indian
diamonds industry is proactive and is gearing up to tackle these issues.
Companies have started to look at diamond branding and retailing to increase
margins. Jewellery retailing a $12 bn market is not new in India and is mainly
dominated by the unorganized sector. Organized retailing and branded jewellery
are two recent trends that are catching up. Even the Indian government is looking
for new suppliers for the supply of rough diamonds. Indian diamond processing
units have started installing new machines and latest technology to process
diamonds. These factors will collectively contribute to further growth and
development of diamond industry.
(C) Correlation between the Average Annual Growth Rate of Import of
Rough Diamonds and Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds from
India:
X = Average Annual growth Rate of Import of Rough Diamonds
Y = Average Annual growth Rate of Exports of Cut and Polished Diamonds
Table No. 1.7
Correlation between the Average Annual Growth Rate of Import of Rough
Diamonds and Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds from India (2001-2002 to
2011-2012)
Table No. 1.6
Trends in Import of Rough Diamond by India from 2001-2002 to 2011-2012
Year AAGR of
Imports over
Previous
Year*
AAGR of
Exports over
Previous
Year*
XY X2 Y2
2002-2003 49 19 931 2401 361
2003-2004 14 21 294 196 441
2004-2005 7 30 210 49 900
42
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
43/60
2005-2006 14 6 84 196 36
2006-2007 1 8 8 1 64
2007-2008 12 30 360 144 900
2008-2009 19 4 76 361 16
2009-2010 14 23 322 196 529
2010-2011 33 55 1815 1089 3025
2011-2012 26 17 442 676 289
151 163 3490 5309 6561
AAGR: Annual Average Growth Rate.
*rounded off to nearest unit.
Source: Compiled from the annual reports of GJEPC, 2001-2002 to 2011-2012.
Karl Pearsons Coefficient of Correlation =
N
YY
N
XX
N
YX
XY
22
22 )()(
=
10
)163(6561
10
)151(5309
10
1631513490
22
X
=4828.620354.55
3.24613490
X
=7659.3438
7.1028
= 0.2991
Interpretation of the results: It can be concluded that there is a weak positive
correlation between average annual growth rate of import of rough diamonds and
average annual growth rate of export of cut and polished diamonds.
Observation: Indian diamond industry, being raw material oriented industry,
purely depends on supply of rough diamonds for processing. Indian diamond
mines have almost exhausted and thus, Indian diamond industry is purely
dependent on foreign sources for the supply of raw material. Again domestic
market for processed diamonds in India is not much developed. Thus, most of the
imported rough diamonds in India are processed and exported back. However, the
43
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
44/60
result of correlation analysis shows a weak correlation between the average
annual growth rate of import of rough diamonds and average annual growth rate
of export of cut and polished diamonds.
The only reason for this is that the export of cut and polished diamonds in a
particular year does not depend on the import of rough diamonds of the same
year. Indian diamond traders stock diamonds as and when they get them at
favourable terms and export them as and when demand for them arises in the
world market. This balancing helps them to earn huge profits.
4.4 Challenges for Indian Diamond Industry:
It is said that higher you are more are the challenges. It is certainly true in the case
of Indian diamond industry. There are several factors, both local as well as global,
which pose a challenge to Indian diamond industry. Some of these factors are:
(1) Uncertainty in Supply of Raw Material: The diamond pipeline has been
witnessing a change since the early years of this decade. De Beers
monopolistic hold on the supply chain was loosening and suddenly, a host
of middlemen had access to an increasing share of rough distribution
straight from mines all over the world. Since then, De Beers rough
distribution arm, Diamond Trading Companys (DTC), share of rough
diamonds sold has declined to about 40-45% from about 85%.
In a bid to disrupt De Beers monopoly in India, Russian state-owned
diamond-giant Alrosa has struck a deal with three major Indian diamond
processors. Diamond India, Rosy Blue, and Ratilal Becharlal & Sons have
announced a USD 490 million deal with Alrosa to supply rough diamonds
over the next 3 years. Under the deal the mine will directly supply raw
material to the local diamond companies, who till recently had to import
raw material from Belgium and Israel. This agreement will lead to cost
44
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
45/60
savings of at least 3-4% for the companies.
(2) Unorganised Market: The Indian gems and jewellery market is
dominated by the unorganized sector. However, the trend is set to change
in near future with the branded jewellery market growing at an expected
CAGR of more than 41% over the next four years. According to market
reports, with its consumption pegged at nearly 20%, India remains worlds
largest gold consumer and this share is expected to grow further. Going
ahead, the organized jewellery sector is forecast to account for a significant
share in the country's total jewellery market.
Additionally, growing importance of India in global gems and jewellery
market has opened a lot of opportunities for exports. The country is fast
becoming a major export destination of gems and jewellery to various
developed and developing countries, including the US, the UAE, Hong
Kong and Belgium. Despite recession, the Indian gems and jewellery
exports sustained the positive momentum.
According to analysts the industry needs to take initiatives like setting up
design centres with the aim to train their employees to compete in the
international markets. Additionally, the Indian gems and jewellery industry
will have to set standards and certification.
(3) Rising Gold Prices: Gold prices have doubled over the past three years.
Such a sharp rise is usually associated with risky investment assets such as
equities. The recent rise in gold prices may not be the steepest like in the
1980s. During this decade itself, gold prices have risen almost five-fold.
This has affected the overall cost of jewellery for the end consumer,
thereby reducing his purchasing power and demand. The sizzling gold
price is one of the reasons for drop in jewellery sales.
45
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
46/60
(4) Competition from China: China is rapidly gaining ground in the diamond
trade, unsettling many Indian diamond traders. The Chinese government
has struck multi-billion dollar deals with various African countries, to build
their infrastructure in return for resources including rough diamonds. With
growing domestic demand, China is building its diamond cutting and
polishing infrastructure. In exchange for medicines, oils, industrial metals
and delivery of infrastructure projects, China is importing rough diamonds
from Angola, the Democratic Republic of Congo and other African
countries.
However, India is comfortably placed against its competitors in terms of
cost of production. India boasts of one of the lowest per carat diamond cutting and
polishing costs (at around USD 10) thereby leading to comparatively low cost
jewellery, and hence amplifying the overall consumption.
Additionally, growing importance of India in the global gems and
jewellery market has opened a lot of opportunities for exports. The country is
rapidly becoming a major exporter of gems and jewellery to various developed
and developing countries, including the US, the UAE, Hong Kong and Belgium.
The Indian gems and jewellery exports sustained its positive momentum even in
the times of recession.
Currently the Indian gems and jewellery market remains highly fragmented, but is
rapidly transforming into an organized sector. Additionally, apart from diamond
jewellery, gold consumption is also on a rise and India is expected to capture a
dominant share in global gold consumption in 2013.
Going ahead, the organized jewellery sector is expected to account for a
46
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
47/60
significant share in country's total jewellery market.
4.5Direction of Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds fromIndia to Major Markets:
Diamond processing takes place in about 30 countries but it is mainly
concentrated in five countries India, Belgium, S. Africa, Israel and the
U.S. India accounts for approximately 60% of the global polished diamonds in
value terms, 80% in karatage and 90% in pieces. China and Thailand are catching
up as centres for diamond cutting and polishing. The diamond processing industry
is largely dependent on supply of rough diamonds. Australia, Botswana, Russia
and South Africa are the major suppliers of rough diamonds. The production of
rough diamonds from mines is presently dominated by De Beers (DTC), which is
the largest diamond miner in the World. Diamond cutting is a great skill. The
natural form of a diamond would determine the shape of the final polished
diamond. Diamonds are usually distributed to one of the main cutting and trading
centres where experts cut and polish rough diamonds into various shapes.Polishing follows cutting before diamonds are again classified based on various
parameters. These are then sold to wholesalers or diamond jewellery
manufacturers. Indias dominance in the cutting and polishing segment can
be attributed to experienced craftsmanship and relatively low cost Indian labour.
Diamond processing remains highly fragmented in India with over 100,000 units.
There may be hardly any country where an unorganised economic activity makes
such a huge contribution to the trade, employment as well as foreign exchange
earnings of the country.
India mainly exports cut and polished diamonds to the United Arab
Emirates (UAE), Hong Kong, the United States of America (USA), Belgium,
Israel, Singapore, Thailand, the United Kingdom (UK), Japan and Australia. Lets
analyze trends in export of cut and polished diamonds from India to these
47
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
48/60
countries:
(A) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to the UAE:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to the UAE from India
Year US $ In
Million*
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 344 5982
2002-2003 425 7105
2003-2004 799 8603
2004-2005 1848 11163
2005-2006 985 11831
2006-2007 1145 10910
2007-2008 1914 14205
2008-2009 3357 14804
2009-2010 6167 182442010-2011 12432 28221
2011-2012 6016 23330
*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
(B) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Hong Kong:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Hong Kong from India
Year US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports2001-2002 1,600 5982
2002-2003 1,916 7105
2003-2004 2,437 8603
2004-2005 3,042 11163
2005-2006 3,432 11831
2006-2007 3439 10910
2007-2008 4881 14205
2008-2009 4784 14804
2009-2010 5745 18244
2010-2011 7893 28221
2011-2012 8177 23330*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
(C) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to the USA:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to the USA from India
Year US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 1,973 5982
2002-2003 2,259 7105
48
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
49/60
2003-2004 2,554 8603
2004-2005 2,585 11163
2005-2006 2,858 11831
2006-2007 2899 10910
2007-2008 3294 142052008-2009 2793 14804
2009-2010 2634 18244
2010-2011 3224 28221
2011-2012 3220 23330*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
(D) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Belgium:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Belgium from India
Year US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 842 5982
2002-2003 931 7105
2003-2004 1,038 8603
2004-2005 1261 11163
2005-2006 1,350 11831
2006-2007 1359 10910
2007-2008 1730 14205
2008-2009 1321 14804
2009-2010 1,297 18244
2010-2011 1,683 28221
2011-2012 2058 23330
*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
(E) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Israel:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Israel from India
Year US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 264 5982
2002-2003 438 7105
2003-2004 576 8603
2004-2005 701 11163
2005-2006 770 11831
2006-2007 860 10910
2007-2008 1019 14205
2008-2009 745 14804
2009-2010 810 18244
2010-2011 1,109 28221
2011-2012 1385 23330
*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
49
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
50/60
(F) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Thailand:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Thailand from IndiaYear US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 215 5982
2002-2003 207 7105
2003-2004 200 8603
2004-2005 263 11163
2005-2006 286 11831
2006-2007 303 10910
2007-2008 349 14205
2008-2009 282 14804
2009-2010 294 18244
2010-2011 379 28221
2011-2012 489 23330
*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
(G) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Japan:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Japan from India
Year US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 329 5982
2002-2003 354 7105
2003-2004 402 8603
2004-2005 469 11163
2005-2006 443 11831
2006-2007 383 10910
2007-2008 331 14205
2008-2009 249 14804
2009-2010 252 18244
2010-2011 276 28221
2011-2012 302 23330*Rounded off to the nearest unit.
(H) Trends in Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Switzerland:
Export of Cut and Polished Diamonds to Switzerland from India
Year US $ In
Million
Total Exports
$ In Million
% Share in Total
Exports
2001-2002 119 5982
2002-2003 133 7105
50
-
7/29/2019 3. Trends and Direction of Diamond Trade
51/60
2003-2004 236 8603
2004-2005 163 11163
2005-2006 129 11831
2006-2007 130 10910
2007-2008 207 142052008-2009 162 14804
2009-2010 103 18244