1
How Does NCEP/CPC Make Operational Monthly and Seasonal
Forecasts?
Huug van den Dool (CPC)
CPC, June 23, 2011/ Oct 2011/ Feb 15, 2012/ UoMDMay,2,2012/ Aug2012/ Dec,12,2012/UoMDApril24,2013/May22,2013/
2
Assorted Underlying Issues
• Which tools are used…• How do these tools work?• How are tools combined???• Dynamical vs Empirical Tools• Skill of tools and OFFICIAL• How easily can a new tool be included?• US, yes, but occasional global perspective• Physical attributions
3
Menu of CPC predictions:
• 6-10 day (daily)• Week 2 (daily)• Monthly (monthly + update)• Seasonal (monthly)• Other (hazards, drought monitor, drought outlook,
MJO, UV-index, degree days, POE, SST) (some are ‘briefings’)
• Informal forecast tools (too many to list)
• http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/predictions/90day/tools/briefing/index.pri.html
4
EXAMPLEPUBLICLY
ISSUED
“OFFICIAL”FORECAST
5
6
7From an internal CPC Briefing package
8
EMP EMP EMP EMP
EMPDYN
DYN
CONCON
N/A
99
SMLR CCA OCN
LAN
LFQ
(15 CASES: 1950, 54, 55, 56, 64, 68, 71, 74, 75, 76, 85, 89, 99, 00, 08)
OLD-OTLK
CFSV1
ECPIRI
ECA CON
10
Element US-T US-P SST US-soil moisture
Method:CCA X X XOCN X X CFS X X X XSMLR X XECCA X XConsolidation X X X
Constr Analog X X X XMarkov XENSO Composite X XOther (GCM) models (IRI, ECHAM, NCAR, N(I)MME):
X X
CCA = Canonical Correlation AnalysisOCN = Optimal Climate NormalsCFS = Climate Forecast System (Coupled Ocean-Atmosphere Model)SMLR = Stepwise Multiple Linear RegressionCON = Consolidation
11
Long Lead Predictions of US SurfaceTemperature using Canonical CorrelationAnalysis. Barnston(J.Climate, 1994, 1513)
Predictor - Predictand Configuration
Predictors Predictand
* Near-global SSTA
* N.H. 700mb Z * US sfc T
* US sfc T
four predictor “stacked” fields one predictandperiod
4X652=2608 predictors 102 locations
Data Period 1955 - last month
12
13
14
About OCN. Two contrasting views:- Climate = average weather in the past- Climate is the ‘expectation’ of the future
30 year WMO normals: 1961-1990; 1971-2000; 1981-2010 etc
OCN = Optimal Climate Normals: Last K year average. All seasons/locations pooled: K=10 is optimal (for US T).
Forecast for Jan 2012 (K=10) = (Jan02+Jan03+... Jan11)/10. – WMO-normal
plus a skill evaluation for some 50+ years.
Why does OCN work?1) climate is not constant (K would be infinity for constant climate)2) recent averages are better3) somewhat shorter averages are better (for T)see Huang et al 1996. J.Climate. 9, 809-817.
15
OCN has become the bearer of most of the skill, see also EOCN
method (Peng et al)
16
17
GHCN-CAMS
FAN
2008
NCEP’s Climate Forecast System, now called CFS v2
• MRFb9x, CMP12/14, 1995 onward (Leetmaa, Ji etc). Tropical Pacific only.
• SFM 2000 onward (Kanamitsu et al• CFSv1, Aug 2004, Saha et al 2006. Almost
global ocean• CFSR, Saha et al 2010• CFSv2, March 2011. Global ocean, interactive
sea-ice, increases in CO2.18
NCEP’s Climate Forecast System, now called CFS v2
19
20
21
Major Verification Issues
• ‘a-priori’ verification (used to be rare)
• After the fact (fairly normal)
22
Source Peitao Peng
After the fact…..
23
(Seasonal) Forecasts are useless unless accompanied by a reliable a-
priori skill estimate.
Solution: develop a 50+ year track record for each tool. 1950-present.
(Admittedly we need 5000 years)
24
Consolidation
25
--------- OUT TO 1.5 YEARS -------
26
OFFicial Forecast(element, lead, location, initial month) =
a * A + b * B + c * C +…
Honest hindcast required 1950-present. Covariance (A,B), (A,C), (B,C), and
(A, obs), (B, obs), (C, obs) allows solution for a,
b, c (element, lead, location, initial month)
27
CFS v1 skill 1982-2003
28
Fig.7.6: The skill (ACX100) of forecasting NINO34 SST by the CA method for the period 1956-2005. The plot has the target season in the horizontal and the lead in the vertical. Example: NINO34 in rolling seasons
2 and 3 (JFM and FMA) are predicted slightly better than 0.7 at lead 8 months. An 8 month lead JFM forecast is made at the end of April of the previous year. A 1-2-1 smoothing was applied in the vertical to
reduce noise.CA skill 1956-2005
29
M. Peña Mendez and H. van den Dool, 2008: Consolidation of Multi-Method Forecasts at CPC. J. Climate, 21, 6521–6538.
Unger, D., H. van den Dool, E. O’Lenic and D. Collins, 2009: Ensemble Regression.Monthly Weather Review, 137, 2365-2379.
(1) CTB, (2) why do we need ‘consolidation’?
30
31
(Delsole 2007)
32
3CVRE
SEC
SEC and CV
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
See also:
O’Lenic, E.A., D.A. Unger, M.S. Halpert, and K.S. Pelman, 2008: Developments in Operational Long-Range Prediction at CPC. Wea. Forecasting, 23, 496–515.
41
Empirical tools can be comprehensive! (Thanks to
reanalysis, among other things).
And very economic.Constructed Analogue(next 2 slides)
• Given an Initial Condition, SSTIC (s, t0) at time t0 . We express SSTIC (s, t0) as a linear combination of all fields in the historical library, i.e.
2010• SSTIC (s, t0) ~= SSTCA(s) = Σ α(t) SST(s,t) (1)
t=1956 (CA=constructed Analogue)• The determination of the weights α(t) is non-trivial,
but except for some pathological cases, a set of (55) weights α(t) can always be found so as to satisfy the left hand side of (1), for any SSTIC , to within a tolerance ε.
• Equation (1) is purely diagnostic. We now submit that given the initial condition we can make a forecast with some skill by
2010• XF (s, t0+Δt) = Σ α(t) X(s, t +Δt) (2)
t=1956Where X is any variable (soil moisture, temperature, precipitation)• The calculation for (2) is trivial, the underlying
assumptions are not. We ‘persist’ the weights α(t) resulting from (1) and linearly combine the X(s,t+Δt) so as to arrive at a forecast to which XIC (s, t0) will evolve over Δt.
44
45
SST Z500
PrecipT2m
CA
46
SST Z500
PrecipT2m
CFS
Source: Wanqiu Wang
Physical attributions of Forecast Skill
• Global SST, mainly ENSO. Tele-connections needed.
• Trends, mainly (??) global change• Distribution of soil moisture anomalies
47
Website for display of NMME&IMME
NMME=National Multi-Model EnsembleIMME=International Multi-Model Ensemble
• http://origin.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/NMME/
Please attend
• Friday 2pm June 14• Tuesday 1:30pm June 18
Two meetings to Discuss the Seasonal Forecast.
49