confusing contours & pieces of glass rob van lier, tessa c.j. de wit, arno koning presented by...

12
Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Upload: karly-ivester

Post on 01-Apr-2015

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Confusing contours & pieces of glass

Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning

Presented by Nick van der Poel

Page 2: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Contents

• Introduction

• Experiment 1

• Results 1

• Experiment 2

• Results 2

• Conclusion & Discussion

Page 3: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Introduction

•Albert Michotte (1964)

•Kanisza square

Page 4: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel
Page 5: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Experiment 1

• 12 participants (students)

Page 6: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel
Page 7: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Experiment 1

• 12 participants (students)

• ‘Are the grey bars straight or indented?’

• 256 trials per participant

Page 8: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Results 1

Page 9: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Experiment 2

• 17 participants (students)

• Same stimuli and procedure as in Exp 1

• ‘What is the (possible) direction of shift?’

Page 10: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Results 2

Page 11: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel
Page 12: Confusing contours & pieces of glass Rob van Lier, Tessa C.J. de Wit, Arno Koning Presented by Nick van der Poel

Conclusion & Discussion

• Proportion incorrect judgements higher for the illusory surfaces

• Control group had many incorrect judgements

• Ramachandran’s checkboard illusion

• Attention and fixation