BULLET OFTHE STITIJTE FCLASSICALSTUDI SuPPLEME Tl14

DIRECTOR & GE ERAL EDIT R: J HN ORTH

DIRECTOR OF PUBLICATIONS: RICHARD SIMPSON

PHILOSOPHICAL THEMES

INGALEN

EDITED BY PETER ADAMSON

ROTRAUD HANSBERGER & JAMES WILBERDING

INSTITUTE OF CLASSICAL STUDIES SCHOOL OF ADVANCED STUDY

UNIVERSITY OF LO DON

2014

The cover imag how Hippocrate and al n, in a fr co fr m th thirt enth century, in the Crypt of t Mary' Cathedral, Ana ni, Ital . De Ago tirri Picture Library I A. Dagli Orti I Bridg man Imag .

ISB 978-1-905670-50-5

© 2014 Institute of Classical Studies, University of London

All rights reserved. o part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a

retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic,

mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwi e, without the prior permi sion

of the publisher.

The right of contributors to be identified as the authors of the work published

here has been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, D igns and

Patents Act 1988.

Designed and computer typeset at the Institute of Classical Studies.

Printed by Short Run Press Limited, Bittern Road, Exeter EX2 7LW.

Introduction

P. N. Singer

Todd Curti

Riccardo hiaradonna

Philip van der Eijk

Glenda McDonald

Inna Kupreeva

Peter Adamson

David Leith

Katerina lerodiakonou

James Wilberding

Caroline Petit

TABLE OF CO TENTS

Galen and the philosophers: philosophical engagement, shadowy contemporaries, Aristotelian transformations

Genre and Galen 's philosophical discourses

Galen on what is persuasive (pithanon) and what approximates to truth

Galen on the nature of human beings

Galen on mental illness: a physiological approach to phrenitis

Galen's theory of elements

Galen on void

Galen's refutation of atomism

On Galen 's theory of vision

The secret of sentient vegetative life in Galen

What doe p eudo-Galen tell us that Galen doe not? Ancient m dical chool in the Roman Empire

Index of subjects and per ons

Index locorum

v

7

39

61

89

135

153

197

213

235

249

269

291

299

INTRODUCTION

The present volume has, as what Galen might call its 'antecedent cause', a series of seminars held at the Institute of Classical Studies in 2008 and 2009 on the topic ' Galen and philosophy' . It was not originally anticipated that this series of seminars would result in a volume. But the talks delivered by an outstanding international field of scholars seemed to c1y out for publication. Thus we asked the speakers who had appeared in the series whether they would be willing to publish their papers with the ICS, and sought out further contributors who could add to an already rich set of offerings. The result is a mix of papers given at the original series and papers commissioned thereafter. ot all of the contributors to the seminar series have been able to take part in the volume. We would especially like to note the sad absence of the late R. W . Sharples who spoke on 'Galen and the Peripatetics ' in the seminar series. In 2012 the ICS published a special volume of the Bulletin in bis honour, and we would also like to pay tribute to his memory here. 1

The idea of a vo lume looking at philosophical themes in Galen is not a new one. An excellent and ground-breaking collection appeared with the Fondation Hardt in 2003. 2

This confirmed what was already widely accepted a decade ago, namely that the study of ancient medicine in general , and the Galenic corpus in particular is an indispensible part of the study of ancient philosophy. The first person to have seen the Galenic corpus in this light was, of course, Galen himself. He emphasized that his own commitment to the study of philosophy should come as no surprise to those who are sufficiently familiar with the teachings of the legendary physician Hippocrates. He even encouraged his fellow physicians to follow his lead in this respect if they ever wished to approach the Hippocratic ideal of medical practice. 3 This claim is likely to strike today's readers who are acquainted with the Hippocratic corpus as at once obvious and a bit misleading. On the one hand, the easily detectable influence of Presocratic thinker uch as Empedocles, Democritus, and Heraclitus within some Hippocratic treatises bears powerful witness to philosophy ' s contribution to Hippocratic medical theorie .4 On the other hand, thi same corpus also contains some straightforward attack against the intrusion of philosophy into medicine. The most striking of these is found in On ancient medicine where the author appears to brush off philosophy a a mere exerci e in rhetoric and insfat that 'it i

1 Bulletin of the lnstilute of Cla sical Studie 55. I (2012) ed. P. Adam on. 2 Galien et la philosophie: huit expo es uivis de di cussio11s, ed J. Barn s and J. Jouanoa (Geneva 2003). 3 Galen, Opt. Med. J.53 .1-54.12 K = 1.1-2.5 Mi.Iller. 4 See, for example, 1. M. Lonie, The Hippocratic treati e · 'On generation', 'On the nature of the child' and 'Diseases IV' (Berlin and ew York 1981) 62-70.

2 LE

impo sible to have any clear knowledge about natur from an other ource than

medicine'. 5

In fact Galen's remark on the relation of m dicine and philo oph hould be under tood again t an hi torical background in which the e two di iplines are not only interacting on a theoretical 1 vel but al o in mutual competition. prominent means by which one di cipline could a rt its up riority o er the other wa the etiology of health and di ea e. The Hippocratic On acred di ea e offi rs a well-k:no' n xample of thi , in which the author seeks to e tabli h the primacy of medi ine over the ancient counterpart to faith-ha ed healing, by demonstrating that the cau e of epilepsy are located squarely in the domain of bodies and nature. The ame approach can be witne ed with respect to the competing demand of philo oph and medi ine. Plato, for exan1ple, can be found doing preci ely thi in the Charmid when he ha aerate report the view of the Thracian

Zalmoxi:

And thi , he said, i the very rea on why mo t di a e are b yond the Gr ek doctor , that they do not pa attention to the \ hole as they ought to do, sine if the whole i not in good condition it i impo ible that the part hould be. Because he aid, the out i the ource both of bodily health and bodily di ea e for the whole of man, and these flow from the oul. .. . Becau e nowadays he aid, thi i the mi take ome doctors make with their patients. They try to

produce health of bod apart from health of soul. 6

On this account, since both somatic and psychological disease have their cause in the soul philosophy, being the skilJ that attends to the oul, gains supremacy even in the medical arena. 7 This could be een as a re ponse to the kind of medical etiology that one finds in the Hippocratic Regimen I. The author of tbi treati e in i ts that even the tates and faculties of the soul are largely determined by physical causes. Moreover, in the case of cognitive abilities, these cau es are held to be medically manipulable, whereas in the case of emotional and character-based features of the soul, they are inalterably determined by one's physiological constitution, just as much as one s oice is. The underlying message, then, would seem to be that medicine has shown the efficacy of philosophy to be significantly reduced even in its own traditional domain.

This is, however, hardly the only way in which philosophy and medicine vied for a privileged position with respect to each other, as a brief comparison between Plato's

5 On ancient medicine §20, I.620.14-622.l Littre = 146.9-11 Jouanna, trans. Schiefsky. See also the

comments in M. J. Schiefsky, Hippocrates. On ancient medicine (Leiden 2005) 293-98. On Galen's attitude towards this treatise see Inna Kupreeva' s contribution to this volume, at pp. 155-56. Compare

the criticism of philosophy in On the nature of man §§1-2, VJ.32.1-36.16 Littre = 164.1-170.7 Jouanna. 6

Plato Charmides 156e; trans. from Plato, Laches and Charmides, trans., with intro. and notes by R. K. Sprague (lndianapolis 1973). 7

Socrates reports that the soul must first be cured by 'certain channs, and these charms consist of

beautiful words' (Charmides 157a), which are widely widerstood to be a reference to ocratic elenchus and more generally to philosophical discussion.. 8

See especially Regimen I §36 (Vl.522.17-524.1 O Littre = 156.19-32 Joly).

INTRODUCTION 3

Republic and Galen' The best physician is also a philosopher shows. In the Republic, Plato appear to grant medicine the tatu of a techne whose aim is to cure the body. Yet he denic that medicine i an autonomou practice, becau e the aim in medicine is ubservicnt to the higher aim of the philosopher-rulers. Since they have privileged access

to the Form of the Good, they alone can determine in which cases the physician ought to apply hi craft. Furthermore despite thi hierarchy of ends, Plato does not think that medicine i in any way a prerequi ite to philo ophy. Plato ' philosopher i not a physician, but the phy ician ' ethical upervisor. 9

With Galen things look somewhat different. While he clearly agrees with Plato that in the ab encc of philo ophy phy ician cannot be counted on to apply their craft well he refu e to rob phy ician of their autonomy in medical practice. A a result he ends up walking a very fine line. There are many indications that Galen considers philosophy to be simply ubordinate to medicine. The physician, we are told, must study 'a ll the parts of phi lo ophy' as part of his ' preliminary learning ', 10 yet he adds that philosophy should also form a part of their 'sub equent practice' and concludes not merely that a physician must be familiar with philosophy but that he must philo ophize. o philo ophy can hardly be ome stepping- tone to a higher discipline of medicine. One is left with the faint impre sion that Galen does not ultimately want to distinguish between the two di ciplines at all , which is to ay that he i also of the opinion that the true phi lo opher is also a physician.

Two of the contributions offered in this volume look more closely at the role of philo ophy in Galen' elf-conception and self-pre entation. Todd Curtis con iders the question of 'genre ' and asks how everal of Galen ' more phi lo ophica1 works might be classified in terms of their genre. For instance the Exhortation to medicine is comparable to works of protreptic by philosophers ranging from Plato to Plutarch. The topic is attacked from a different angle by Peter . Singer who ask whether, or rather in what sense, Galen was happy to describe himself as a 'phi lo opher. inger s discu ion raises a question that i inevitably central in the volume as a whole: can we read Galen as a philosopher, or only as a medical author who occa ionally ays thing relevant to philo ophy? For in tance, hould we expect him to be consistent aero hi work when it comes to philosophical i ue , or to argue for po ition he take on philosophical matters? Do his well-known profes ions of agno ticism on certain topics (the nature of the oul or of god, for instance) tern from a con idered view about the limit of human knowledge or merely ignal hi limited intere t in philo ophy, given that hi main focu lie with medicine?

9 ee e pecially Plato, Republic 405c-410a on Plato' po ition on medicine in the Kallipoli. The philosophers a ume the ame role relati e to medicine that they assum relati e to all craft : they use the craft to achie e their i ion of iety (cf 60lc-602a). Proclu offers a compact account of thi Platonic vision of a hierarchy of end in hi comment on Timaeu 90c4-7. (The e comments have only been pre crved in Arabic translation, and a French tran lation may be found in the fifth volume of Fe tugiere' translation of Pr tu 's Timaeus commentary. The editio princep of Proclu ' comments on 89e3-90 7 along ' ith an Engli h tran larion and note has recent! been completed by Rildiger Arnzen: R. Arnzen, 'Proclu on Plato' Timae11 9e -90c7,' in Arabic ciences and philo ophy 23 (2013) 1-45). 10

alen, Opt. Med. 1.60.10-61.15 K = 6.23-7 .24 Millier.

4 PHIL PHI L THEM

However we an w r th que tion , it i clear that alen pr me of the mo t fa cinating refle tion on tandard t pi in an ient phil evident from a volume like The ambridge companion to Gal 11 \J hich ha era! hapt rs on philo opbical topic ucb a I gi and p hology. 11 Th philo phical int r t f alen' writing i often becau f, not in pit of, hi primaril medical int re t . For in tan , with Galen' h Ip ' e an hart an imp rtant hift in an ient oncepti n of human nature within the earli r medi al tradition. Anat mi t in H 11 ni ti le andria di o ered the n rvou tem and bowed that nerve mu t be di tingui hed from bl d el . octor and philo oph alik need d to re n ile thi ne\ empirical data ' ith older phi lo ophical po ition on the oul' relation to bod . al n him elf u ed hi anatomical, philo ophi al and rhetorical kill to onfim1 and e p und th impli ati n of th brain­centered anatom implied b the 1 andrian di c eri . fter al n, it wa all but impo ible to a oid admitting that the commanding facu lt ' i eated in the brain, and not the heart. Thi pro ided ome di comfitur to taunch ri totelian a lat a al-Fariibi in the I Oth century. He implau ibl argued that the di agr ement b t\ en Ari totle and Galen , as m rel verbaJ. 12 TI1i i of our e on\ one e ample of ho\J Galen' writing make an imp rtant contribution to ancient anthropology, and in our olume, Philip an der Eijk' pie pro ide a broad exploration of human nature in Gal n. Hi tud can be profitabl read along ide that of Glenda McDonald, ho look at the more pecific ca e of Galen on mental illne .' 3

The pr ent olume al o include four pap r that look at pe ific philo ophical theme in Galen that have pre iou I remained all but un plored. Riccardo Chiaradonna' contribution repre en an important advance in our under tanding of Galenic epi temology, focu ing on the central notion of the per uasi e (pithanon . Thi bears, incidentally, on the que tion rai d abo e, a to the moti ation under! ing the agno tici m that tends to ari e when Galen con ider philo ophical i ue . And to return to the related que tion of con i tency. we find here Katerina lerodiakonou and Jame Wilberding dm ing together pas age from e era\ Galenic treati e in hope of finding a ' ell-worked-out position on a pecific philo ophical i ue. lerodiakonou di cus e 1 ion, Wilberding \egetative life. Both are able to how that Galen wa capable of adopting con istent and opbisticated iews on tandard issue in philo ophy, aero s a range of works. Of course, thi expectation i fulfilled to arying degree depending on the topic in question and on the nature of the survi ing evidence. Peter Adam on a ks whether we can discern a consistent po ition on the po ibility of oid in Galen, drawing not only on extant work but also on fragments and te timonia from the lost On demon tration.

11 The Cambridge companion to Galen, ed. R. J. Hankinson ( am bridge 200 ).

12 ee his Risa/a fi l-radd 'ala Jiilinus, in Rasii 'ii falsaflyya li-1-Kindi wa-1-Fiiriibl wa-bn Biijja wa-bn

'Adi, ed. A. BadawT (Benghazi 1973; repr. Beirut 1980), and further F. W. Zimmennann, 'Al-FarabT und die philosophische Kritik an Galen \'On Alexander zu A erroe ,' in Aklen des Vil. Kongresses far Arabistik und 1 lamwissenschafi, ed. A. Dietrich (Gottingen I 976) 401-14. 13

For a detailed look at Galen philosophical anthropology a it bears on psychology see . Gill, aturalistic psychology in Galen and Stoicism ( xford 20 I 0).

INTRODUCTION 5

More commonly, it ha been the Galenic corpu that has been exploited a a mine of information about hi contcmporarie and predece or . 14 We speak here advisedly of the Galenic corpus and n l ju l Galen, ince a aroline Petit how here, Pseudo-Galenic works can al o be a valuable source of information. On the other hand, David Leith's contribution hows that one needs to treat Galen's testimony with some caution. (This echoe \ aming i ued in previou tudies of Galen as a reporter on the philo ophical tradition. 15

) Leith examine the refutation of atomi m in On the elements according to l/ippocrates, and hows how freely alen manipulate the Hippocratic source . The same material is approached from a different direction by Inna Kupreeva, who eeks to reconstruct alen's theory of element , which wa developed in polemic against both atomi t and Pneumati t . alen i clearly drawing on the Peripatetic tradition here as Kupreeva brings out, but he of cour e insists that his elemental theory is faithful to Hippocratc . This bring us full circle, to Galen 's appeal to the authority of Hippocrates in justifying hi own medical and philo ophical approach - and reminds u that the Hippocrate Galen claim to be following is to ome extent Galen ' own creation.

Wa alen a philo opher, then? Would he even have claimed to be one? s inger point out, the answer to the latter que tion is surely 'ye ' in ome sen e, given that Galen famou ly claimed that the best doctor is also a philo opher (and he would certainly have been happy to claim the tatus of ' be t doctor'!). Of course, thi does not mean that he was primarily a philo opher. But many ancient author who were not primarily phi lo opher may be u efully read from a phi lo ophical point of iew. ln Galen' own era for instance, we have the example of the early church father , rhetoricians, grammarians writer on Roman law, and so on. The tudy of ancient philo ophy as a whole benefits from the tudy of such author ju t a the tudy of Galen benefits from a focu on phi lo ophical theme in hi work . 16

14 For a re ent collection of papers on Galen and the world of knowledge, ed 15 ee e.g. T. Tielemann, Galen and placitis, Books 11-111 (Leiden 1996).

alen' rea tion to hi come t and th previous think rs see . ill, T. Whitmarsh, and J. Wilkins (Cambridge 2009).

hry ippu on the 0111: argument and refutation in the De

16 The edit rs would like t thank the Le erhulme Tru t for upporting the work of Peter damson and Rotraud I lansbcrger, a well a Da id Kai er and Katja Krau for their work on the indice . We are also grateful to the I for pon oring the original eminar erie on 'Galen and Phil sophy' and to . peaker at thi erie who c pie e ould not appear in the volume: Rebecca Flemming, hri Gill, Ben Moris n, Vi ian utton, and, a already mentioned, the late and great Bob harple .

I DEX OF UBJECT A D PERSO S

Academy 62, 74-78, 79n59 Acron of Acraga 276, 281 , 290 Adamson, Peter 37n73, 252n21, 267n92 Aetiu 251 , 286n56 affection 129-30, 138-39, 144-46, 169-70,

21 , 224-25, 276, 285, 287 Agathinu of Lakedaimon 285, 286n57 Alexander of Aphrodi ias 21-23, 25n50,

32n60 34, 38, 84- 6, I 76n72, 193-95, 23 , 243,245, 2

al-Farabi 4-87, 4n7 I critici m of Galen 4- 5

Allen, Jame 83 al-Razi66-67, 134nl0 , 19 , 207-11

atomi t 209, 210 on phy ical ub tance 20 on temporal generation of the universe 210 on oid 207-11

alteration 163-166, 170 172 192, -1 -22. 224, 226-2 , 237, 240, _44-45, 2 6- 7

anatomy 4, 7n2, 90, 135 13 , J 4 . 200, 210,236

Anaxagoras 164,220,221.2- ,2 0.- 0 Andronicu 21, 23, 2n60 animal 26, 3 , 42, 9-. 99-101, 10 • 111-1

116, 175-76, 241, r1--3, _60-6-anthropocentri m I 06-07

ntipater 275n 19. _ 76, 27 2 0 Apolloniu of Anti hu (fath rand n)

276,290 polloniu of Memphi 2 0

Archig ne of pamea 27 -7 • 2 4- . _ 7, 2 9,290

gymna. ti n t an art 42,

hierarchy of arts , 10-11, 17-1 , 42-43, 46

Asclepiades of Bithynia 9 , 153, 160, 162, 171 173,200,207,213-215,233.234. 258-259, 275-276 281-2 2, 2 9-290

clepiu I, 6, 273, 277 a trology 45, 270 270n4 Athena 75 Athenaeus of ttila 173. 177-7 • 177n76.

I I, I 4- 7 275-76,2 5,2 7,2 9.290 athletic 27, 42-43, 46-49, 54-5 , 57-59

tomi m5, 153, 160, 170,205.20-n20, 213 214, 214n6, 217-20, 222-26, 22 -30, 231- 4 2 Galen' anti-atomi m . 214, _17-219, 233-34

atom 162-64, 16 -6 , 170-71, 21 , 219. 220,223,226,230,231

attraction IOI. 177, 200-03, 210, 236, 242, r6-60. 26

tticu 65, 66, 70

I, 2_7n 2

B

·phreniti ')

u ·hus Aurd1anu - (l, • "· '.

( 'unon or l'ol ch tu 11 •. 11 '· 11 I. 711114

·.inh1>e ·ntn m "I nfl, 1 "K Carncadc fl 1, fl K

I I 'II 11 I fil ft!! n cau at11111 7. K. • • .. 71.117.111<,I l , lfil I •111 111 I / 11111 r1 I uu

292

higher-I vel I di 'nothing occur cau ele I ' 63, 6

chang I 3. 160, 16 , 166 16 -72, 179- 0. 190-94, 21 -19, 221, 2-3, 226-2 , 231 Ari totl on 163, I 63n33

orpulari ts on 166 Galen on 166, 16 -72 pb iological 172 qualitative 153, 160 163. 170-71, 191. _21, 221n37, 223-24, 226-28 quantitative I 63n33. 170 elemental 160. 169. 170-72. 194

Chartier, Rene 274 Chry ippu 74-76. 172. 174 chwno 260-61. 263-64 Cicero 53, 74, 222n4 I Cleitomachu 77-7 colour I I- 2, 235-40, 242, 244-46

cau e of change in tran parent medium 237.244 fiery effluence from objects 236 nature of235 quality of objects 237 tran ient disposition of objects 23

conjecture 7 , 0, 82- 3, 7, 256 contingency 4-Corpusculari m 153, 160, 162-63, 166-67,

169' 172, 193 cosmology I cosmos 66, 70-71, 77, 176-77,

195-96, 210, 258 Cte iphon 290

Dahriyya (Arabic cbool of thought) 89 133-34

delirium 13 , 140, 141-42, 144, 145-46, 148, 150 151

Demiurge70, 7ln35, 124,2 8n6S Democritus I, 162-64, 217. 230, 237, 250 destruction I destructible, the 33, 67-71, 127,

141 174 diaeresis 56, 58, 220-21, 228, 230 diagnosis I diagnostics 7, 82, 135, 138, 144,

146, 167 dialectics 2 , 41, 53-59, 63, 72, 76, 160, 173,

178, 180-82, 209 dietetic 69, l 03 Diocles ofCarystos 276, 290 Diodorus Cronus 2 I 4n6 Diogenes of Apollonia 251 Dionysius 276, 290

di ea e / di ea econcept47, 79,8 1_82 90 9 , 100-01. 101n33, 105, 122-23, 127_' 28 130, 134nl0 , 135, 135nl , 156-S7

diori mo (qualification, pccification) 69_71 dissection 136, 138nl4 divine craft manship 175

Dogmati m (see al o Rationalists) 269, 275 281, 283 •

double-criterion theo1y 62n5

Eclecti i 111 275-76, 2 4-85, 289 education 10-11, 35n70, 43 , 48, 50, 121 Eijk. Philip van der 20, 22, 25, 29, 32, 69-70 element 5, 8. 9, 17, 29, 30, 33, 153-196,

213-34 251, 287

compound produced of218, 220-21, 227-2

co mic element 155-61, 170, 174-75, 177-79, I 5- 7, 195 'form and power 231-32

Galen on 5, 157 173, 175, 180-89, 192-93, 195-96 213, 221, 233-34 Hippocrate on 153, 155 hylomorphic I mixed 193-95 interdependence of 159 nature of 161-62, 169 178 Pneumatists on 160-61, 175, 177-79, I I, 183-85 principles of change 180, 190-94 proximate 158, 159, 173-75, 177-78, 181, 184-87 Stoics on 173, 175

elite 12, 13 I 9n33 embryology 8, 36, 120, 265, 270n2, 270n3 Empedocles 1, 222, 224n45, 230, 250-51 empirical testing I data 4, 61 , 63, 69, 73, I 08,

180, 197, 211 249-51, 258-59 Empiricism 45-46, 63-64, 79-80, 3, 87,

156, 178-79, 269, 275-78, 280-81,

283-85, 289 Epictetus 45, 45n28, 49, 52, 54

picureans 166, 222, 223, 227, 228, 235,

237-38, 240, 245 Epicurus 98, 162-64, 217, 226, 228-29, 230,

234,258 epideictic speech I style 45, 47-50, 59 epistemology 4, 7, 40, 46, 62-63, 67-68,

71-74, 79-80,87,209 Episyntheticism 275-76, 284-85 Erasistratus 98, 198-207, 210-211, 258,

274-276,281,289,290

I DEX OF UBJE T A D PER ONS 293

eternity of the world 65 71, I 97, 210 ethic 8- 10, 12, 14, 16- 17, 32, 39, 40, 44 50,

52-53, 61, 93, 116, 125, 128, 223 everla ting, the (aidion) 66-6 ( ee also

inde tructible, the) evident, the (enarges) 62-65, 67-68, 70-7 l ,

78-80, 178, 184-85 axioms 63-64, 68, 70-71, 0-81 common ly agreed principle 64-65

exten ion (diastema) 205-07 eye 235-47

Flemming, Rebecca 2 8, 2 8n65 form (eido ) 24, 28, 31, 36, 178, I 9, 192-95 fortune I chance (luche) I 0, 42, 45, 49, 52,

55, 99, 122, 123, 226 Frede, Michael 68 Furley, David 226-227, 227n5 I, 22

Galen agno ticism 3, 4, 66 66n23, 71 n35 , 7 , 9, 97, 123, 204, 209, 211, 267n91

Ari toteliani m , I 3n 14. 19-26, 27-30 30n5 , 32-36, 3 , 1, 7n 2, 89, 96-9 , 100, 153, 161, 166, 169, 171, 1 9, 191-194, 205, 20 ,2 14 230-34,235.244. 246,261 anti- toici m 33, 75 authenticity of works 271 271 n7 27 1-72n autobiography 21-22, 39, 4-, 53 1 4 eccentricity 20, 3 eclectici m 73, 0, 235, 246 epi temology 62-63, 67, 7 1-72, 73-74, 77, 79- 0, 7, 209

Galenic corpu I, 4, 272 Hippocrati m 9, 100-01, 13 -36, - - 4 library 12n 12, 25n50, 9, 50 medicine and phil ophy 1-3, -9. 11, 17, 40-42, 46, 59, 0- I. 7- '160-161, 17 , I 0 Platonism 9, 1 -19, 2 -26, 36, 3 , 46, 96, 240-41, _4 P rrhoni m 76 rationali ·m 7 -79, 154, 160-61 rec pti n of 125- 3 ar a m 15 elf-pr scntation , 7, 12-1 , I -19,214

ta her. f2l-22, 36, 1 I, 1 2, l 6 Garofalo, I an 274 Gcmelli , Marcian 225n4

generation I generated, the 64, 65-71, 95, 157-5 '160, 174-75, 187, 208, 210, 218, 226

genre 3, 39-42, 59 geometry I 0-1 I , 45-46 76, 80, 86-87 Gourevitch, Danielle 282 gymna tic see athletics

handbook 35n70,53 273,2 Hankin on R. J. 33, 35 64, 77, 167n4 .

191nl 16, 221n37 health 46-47, 48-50, 54-55, 59, 156-57 heart 27-2 199-200, 203, 204-05 heat27-28, 176-78, 182 187-90, 192 Helleni m I Helleni tic period 62, 74. 79-81,

269,274,2 9 Helmreich I 06, I I 8 Heracl itu of Ephe u I, 19 Heraclitu of Rhodiapoli 40 Herodotu 290 Herophilu ofChalcedon 274-76, 290 Hippocrate I Hippocratic doctrine I, 9,

12nl2 7 , I. 90, 100-01, 104n42, 126, 135, 145, 145n55, 153-60. 162. 169. 214-19, 229-34, 261, 273-74. 276. 2 1-3 2 7.290

Homer290 homoiomeries (uniform body-parts) 24, 36,

136-37, 137n 161, I 5- 7, 220-21 qualitative imbalance (dy krasiai) 136. 140-41. 143

Horte(n) iu 40 human body 3 , 9-90, 9_-93, 97-9 , 100-

01. 110-11. 125-26. 133-34. 156-59. 161. 211.217.227.230

human nature, theory of 4, 9-134 an ient di u ion of 9-90 Galen on divine de ign I explanation of 9. 9 , 101-02. 111, 113. 115, I 15n6 •

11 --4 Galen on ideal of human nature 9 • 107, I J 1-12, 114. 114-5n6 , 116-117, 120-22,

l 6 Galen. materiali t d ign I explanation

of 9, 97, IOI reception of Galen' 125-34

humours 135-136, I • 144. 148, 150, 151. 154-61. 173-74, 275, 2 9

ijunayn ibn I l,\iq 27106 hylomorphism 31. 9. 97, 193-94

294 PHILO OPHI AL THEMES 1 GALE

immortality 69-70, 91, 96-97, 12 n97 ind tructible th (aphthorto ) 67-70 ( e

al. o verla ting. the) intellect 30n , 90-9-, 19 -96, 252-53 I el Emil 277, 2 0, 2 6, 2

Jouanna, Ja qu 154, 27 -79

Kudlien, Fridolf2 0

Leonide of lexandria 276, 2 4, 290 life/Ii ingbeing 101-03.113, 157-61. 167-

6 , 170, 173-7 '249. 253. 264, 266 di elution I 7-5 generation l ·7_ - . 174-76

ub i tence 15 light / luminou 37n73, 236, 237, 239, 240.

242.243,245,247 actualized state of transparent medium

237 coalescen e with fire-particle 236 necessary condition for i ion 236. 247 ufficient condition for i ion 247

logic 7-10, I l, 12, l3n 14 14, 39-40, 4 -46, 54-55, "7-59, 61, 64-65, 67-6 . 71. 73,

75, 7 - 0. 82- 3 architektonia I On , 14 argument I mode of argumentation -9, 14-15, 16, 35 axioms 63-64, 68, 70-71, 80- l (see also evident, the) certainty 62, 72. 75, 77- 0 2- 3, 6 demonstration 15-17, 63, 67, 72, 75, 76,

0, 87, laws of 63-64 modality 78, 3-88 non-deductive reasoning 82 probability 80, 82- 3 rhetorical argument I premises 9 15, 63, 72-76 (see also protreptic) theorems 0-83, 85 truth-conductive 11, 14

logos 28, 68-70 80, 90, 174 Lucretius 164, 166, 170, 226-29, 228n53 Lyceum 225, 229

madness 135, 139, 145 magnet 202-03, 257-58, 264, 266-67 Maimonides 84 mania 145 Marcus Aurelius 8, 12, I 3n 14

matter 2 , 33-34, 161, 172, I 7-90, 192-96, 213n3,2l4n6,227,23 ln68 prime 153. I 77 qualityles I 9, 192, unformed matter 33-34

Ma, imus of Tyre 46-47, 49, 52 mechanical theorie l 01-05, 122-23, 200,

202, 25 -59

medicine 2, 8, 11 , 17, 39-44, 46-48, 52, 54-56, 59. 61, 71, 73, 78-79, 0- 8, 15 ' 160-61. 175, 178-80, 214, 233, 2331173, 270, 273-77,279,2 1-87,289

melanchol 145 Meli u 215nl I, 216-17 Menemachu of Aphrodi ias 276, 2 4, 290 mental illne es 4, 135-5 1 Menodotu 276, 290

ethodism 269, 275 aelius Aurelianu 276

do trine 282-83 founder 2 2

mixture 19, 23, 24, 29, 31 33-34, 2, 89, 98, 101-34, 136, 140, 171-72, 177, 185, 195-96, 222-23 connate 103-04, 104n42 determination of 104-05, 115, 118, 120 heredjtary I 04, 104n43 middle position 108, 113, 115 simple 102 tales of imbalance (duskrasiai) I 03 ,

121, 122 well-mixed state (eukrasia} 102-03, 106

Mnaseas 276, 290 Mnesitheu of Athen 276, 290 monism 156, 162, I 0,216-17,229-30.233-

34 anti-monism 219, 234 Eleatic 217 Ionian 217, 229, 233

motion 176-77, 253-56, 259, 26 1-63, 265-68

circular 253-54, 259 repelling 253-54, 259, 261 self-motion 253-56, 267 vegetative 255-56, 259

Munro, H. /\ . J. T. 226

nature (phusis) 8, 9, 11 , 28-29, 30n58, 32, 39, 39n2, 61 , 87, 89, 90nl, 92, 94, 106,

107, 122-23, 174-75, 200-02 natural powers 254, 256, 259-60, 262, 264•

266-67

J D X

'handmaid ' of nutrition 256-57 of alteration I as imilation 256-57, 259,

263 of attraction 256-60, 26 , 265-67 of growth 255-56, 26 1 of nutrition 252, 257, 25 , 261, 266n 7 of reproduction 252 of retention 256-57, 256n39, 259, 266n 8 of eparation I elimination 256-57, 266

needle 166-67, 219, 24, 225, 225n48 eme iu of me a 89-91, 93, 96, I I 3n67,

125-29, 131-33 eoplatonism 3 7, 125

nervous y tern 4, I I 6n70, 124, 13 , 240, 262

nominali m 194 umeniu 195-96

Olympicu of Mile u 276-77, 284, 290 orator 47, 49-50, 63

paideia 47, 49 pain 156-57, 162, 165-69, 216-19, 229-33,

252,253,263-65,266,26 n94 Palladiu 28 pathos 2 , 45, 50 perfect mean 93, 93n 12, I 06 persua i e, the (pithanon) 4 15, 4 , 61-62.

64-66, 71- 0, 3, 7 a oppo ed to certitude 72 regard le of truth 61, 65, 72

• 224,

9n21, 14-- I

BJ T A D PER 0 295

phy iology 7, , 9, 26, 89-91, 97, 100-01, 103-04, 117, 125-26, 133, 135, 151, 241, 242,247,258,264-65 287

Phy icali ts 174, 258-59 physics 8, 39n2, 167, 176, 180, 188, 2 I 3n3,

229 Pigeaud, Jackie 139, 142 place 203-04, 205, 207 plant see vegetative life Plato 2, 3, 7, , 9, 17. 21, 25-26, 36-37, 61,

66, 69-71, 73, 74, 80, 9, 90-94, 171 , 175, I 95-96, 201, 235-37, 239-42, 245-4 7 251-56, 261, 263-67, 290

Platoni m7.18-19,21,23,25-26,36-3 .61, 96-97' 188- 9, 235, 240-42 Galen Platoni m 9, I - I 9, 25-26. 3 Middle Platoni m 7. 23, 65, 70-71

pleasure 32, 52-53. 223, 250, 252-53, 263-6 Plutarch 43, 49, 52. 53, 6 , 77, 222-23, 225,

226, 22 -29 pneuma 37, 91, 9 , IOI , 125 127 129. 133.

172-176 17 , 19 -00 204-05, 23 -47. 276,2 - 7,2 9 as imitation of air to 244 cone of pneumatic air 23 -39 emanation from eyes 23 luminou character 242

Pneumati m 5. I 3, I -3, 159-62, 172- , 192-93, 195-96. 269, - 76. - o. 2 3, 2 4, 2 6- 9

Polybu 155 Porphyry 3 , 265, 270n2, 270n3 Praxagora 276. _90 predication I 2- 4, I 5- 7, 192-94 Pre ocratic philo ophers 2, 249, 251 probability 6lnl, 74. 7 . 0. 2- 3, 7.

0 Proclu 3n9, 131, 195.-76.2 4,290 propertie 62, 72, 112. 150, 160. 163-64.

167-6 . 170-7-. 176-77. 196. 201. 22ln 7.263.267

Protagora 25 I protrepti 3, 9. 41. 43-46. 47, 49-50. 51. 59 pro.,idence 71n 5. 9 -99. 124-25. 25 - 9 p eudo-Galen 5, I. 269-90

dating of works by 275, 275nJ9. 277-7

Ddi11itione · medicae 2 5 De optima secta I lntrodu,·tio. ·fre medicus (Introduction, or the physician) 269-70. 272-7 • 2 0- 9

296 PHILO OPHICAL TH ME l GALEN

Kuhn edition 27-, 274, 2 n50 chool 269 ( ee also Dogmali m,

Empiri i m, Methodism) ariation of orpu 271

qualitie 33- 4, 9, 97, 101-03 107, 110, 122, 127, 134, 13 -36, 140. 14', 149, 153, 157-66.170-71 , 176-94,213113, 214. 215, 21 -19, 223, 226, 231 , 239-40

Qal nymo 250

Ra hed, farwan 194 Rationali m ( ee also Dogmati m) 80, 160,

167 274, 276, 2 1- 2, 2 4- 6. 2 9 rhetoric I, 5, 9-11 , 19, 41, 43-50, 59. 63, 72-

76, 0, 142 Rufu ofEphe u 177n76 Runia, David 2 2

ceptici m 46, 62-63, 75-7 , 153 ect 14, 17, I , 21 n3 edley, David 75, 22 -29 eneca 51-53 ense-perception 61-63, 6 153, 164-72,

174-76, 179, I 5, 191, 196. 21 -30, 224n44.234 argument from ensation 21 -20, 222-30 234 condition for 153, 165-66, 168-69, 172, J 6 elements and compounds' usceptibiLity to 221 insentient co mic elements 170-71 mecbani m of 169-70 mental states 163, 166 potential 220 sentient humorous elements 16 -72 supervenience on alterable elements 164, 167n48, 171 'the ultimate judge' 63 touch I 08, 110, I 16n70

erapion of Alexandria 276, 290 Sex:tus Empiricus 40, 45 269, 276-80,

288-89, 290 shape I shaping 24, 29-30, 36, 120, 120n77,

127, 161-62, 171, 208, 22ln37, 238-39 Sharples, R. W. 1 Simplicius 198,206-211 skin99, 106, 110-11, 114n70-115n70, 116,

136, 166, 219, 225 sophists 18, 18n32, 49, 72-73, 76, 90 Soranus of Ephesus 276-77, 284, 290

orite argument 166-70

oul (ps11cfle) I theo1y of the soul 2, 4, 7, S, 9, 15-16, 19, 23-27, 36- 7, 42-43. 46, 52 72, 75 , 90-91 , 95-97, I 13n67, l 16n70 ' 123-29, 131-32, 140, 174-76, 183-84' 189, 191, 194, 205, 208, 24 1, 253-55

1

261 -63, 265 ' Aristotelian p ychology 2 , 25 capacity I capacities 16, 26, 36 corporeality ver u incorporeality 37 ethereal body 37 Galen's equation of Ari totle ' and Plato' 25-26 Galen ' psychology 19, 27, 30n58 Plato' I Platoni t p ychology 7, 26 relation to body 4 ub tance of 16, 23-24, 31

tephen of Ale andria 28 tephen of then 28 toics 7, 19. 28, 34, 37, 3 , 68, 74-77, 153,

172-77' 226-27, 235, 238-39, 242-44, 247, 261,267 276,285-90

trato 22 1153, 229 ub ta11ce(ousia)8, 16 24 27,28,31,

33-34, 205, 208 ub trate90 127 131, 168, 170, 191-93 yllogi m 13n14, 84-85, 87-88

teacher 43-44, 47 teleology I telo 7 8, 31 , 92-98, I 00, I 06,

113, 115, 122-23 125, 129, 153-54, 160, 202,254n32,258

Tbemistius I 98, 206-1 1 theodicy I 34n I 08 Theophilus 142, 142n39 Themison ofLaodicea 276, 281-82, 284, 290 Theophrastus I 4n 14, 35n70, 62, 86, 229, 251 therapy7,51,81, 104, 124, 135, 143, 147-

51,283 The salu ofTralles 276, 282, 290 Tieleman, Teun 26n55, 35 time 197-198, 206n24, 207, 208n28 truth 12, 14, 61-64, 66-68, 71-73, 75-80,

82-83, 87-88, 163, 167

vegetative life 4, 249-68 animals and 251, 253 intelligence I cognition 249, 250

memory 249 principle of life 261 soul255

rNDEX OF BJ T A D PER 0

vegetati e en ation 249-26 delined by motion 253, 266, 267 (see

also motion) Plato' doctrine on 251-54 pleasure and pain 264-266

virtue 16, 32, 36, 41 , 44-47, 49, 51-52 59,

95 vision 4, 104, 235-47, 287

Ancient theorie of235-39 as touch 238, 244 Epicurean on 235, 237-38, 245 Galen on 235, 239-47 medium of237, 240, 243, 245 object of235-47 transmis ion of eidola 237, 245

void4, 16, 61 , 63, 197-2 11 , 218, 222-25,

22 n53,258 conceptual po sibility of207 211 di per ed 204-05 205n20, 211 existence of 198, I 05, 20 -09 ma ed void 204-05, 204nl9, 210 outside the univer e 198

void principle (horror vacui) 199-207, 21 O-

il , l 99n6, 25 von taden Heinrich 274

Wellmann, Max 286, 289 Wilberding, Jame 68 World oul 64, 6 -69, 253n27

Xenophane 223 Xenophon 290

youths (noei) 42-44, 52, 58

Zeller, Eduard 253 Zeno of Citium 50 Zeus 75 Zeyl, Donald 253 Zimmermann, F. W. 6- 7

297

INDEXLO OR M

bii •Jsn al-Warrl'lq On the Dahriyya ection I, 395 McDermott ection I Va, 399 McDermott ection IVc, 400 McDermott

etius IV 5, 12 (Dox. 392, 4-7) V 26, I (Dox. 43 , 6-11)

al-Fllr bT

133 133 133

251nl7 251

Commentary on Aristotle 's Analytica Priora 4 Short Commentary on Aristotle' de Jnterprelalione 6

1-RllzT Doubt about Galen 3.1 -21 Mohaghegh (44.10-16' bd al-Ghani) 3.22-4.7 Mohaghegh (44.17-45.13' bd al-Ghani) 7.22-8.6 Mohaghegh (52.20-53. 'Abd al-Ghani) .1-2 Mohaghegh (53.1-2 'Abd al-Ghani .7-9.12 Mohaghegh (53.10-55.16 · bd al-Ghani)

35 Mohaghegh (I 0 -9 'Abd al-Ghani)

Rasii 'ii Jal ajiyya 218.5-219.2 Krau

lcinou Disdascalico (Didasc.) 11, 166.15-3 Hermann-Whittaker

134nl08 66 209n33 20

2 n32

I 4n94

Ale ander of Aphrodi ia In Ari ·toteli Analyticonim prion11n libntm I commentarium (in APr) 7.11-13 allie 67 39.27-40.5 Walli 4

de Anima (de An.) 5.4-9 Brun 6.2-3 Brun 50.1 -51.6 Brun

de Anima libri mantis. a (Mont.) 3, 117. 2-11 .4 Brun 3 6 7 10, 130.14-17 Brun

de Mixtione (Alixt.) 2 16. 14-2 18.6

Re/11talion of Galen· · the 1. • 'On the pos. ible ·

193nLI t93nt21 -4

22n43 176n72 I 4n94 184n94 195, t95nl26 23

243

5

300 PHIL OPHI AL THEM, I GALE

Alexander Rhetor cf, Figuri

na agora Fragment a

9A 116 Diel -Kranz

IAndronicus) Peri PathOn 4

Anonymu Londinen i d Medicina (Med.)

l 2 l - I Manetti

Ari totle

Categoriae (Cat.) 2, lb24-25 5. 2a l l-3b 11 5, 3a33

Analytica Priora (A Pr.) l.3 , 25bl4-15 1.3, 25bl4-l9 1.13, 32b4-13

Analytica Po ieriora (APo.) 1.24, 6a3-I 0

To pica vm.12

Physica (Phys.) L2, 184bl5-22 I.2, l84b2 l 1.2, J 84b25- l 85a4 1.2, 185al 7-20 1.2, l 85b35- l 86a3 f.4, l 87a26 I.4, 187b7-12 I.6, 189a I 2- 13 l.7, 19la20-22 1.7-9 lll.5 , 204b33 IV IV.4 IV.4, 21 la3 IV.4, 2llbl4-!7 IV.4 21 lb19-21 JV.7, 214a32-b3

de Caelo ( Cael.) I.IO J.10-12

49n48

250n6

2 n56

155

34, 153, 17 '183, 184, 19011113, 194 183n90 34n64 183n92

4 85 4 5

81

53 551183

215nl I 230n63 232n70 232n7! 231n67 193nl 17 2251147 225n47 215nl 1 192 193nl 17 207 205 207 205 205 228n53

65 66

(.) 0, 279b20-2 I I.I 0, 280a28-32 J.12 1.12, 2 2a30-b I J.12, 282b4 Ill 111-IV Ill. I, 299a2-4 111.4-5 111.4, 303a I 0-13 111.4, 303a20-2 I 111.4, 303a24-29 111.7, 305b20-27 111.7, 306a26-b2 Ill. '306b22-29 111-IV IV

I DEX LOCORUM

de Generalione et Corruptione (GC) I.I 1.1-4 I.I , 3 I 4b4-28 I. , 325b34 I. , 325b35-326a3 I. ' 326b2-6 l.9, 327al4-16 II II.I 32 b31 II. I, 32 b33-329a5 II.I, 329a26 11.1-3 11.1-4 11.2 11 .2, 329bl3 11.3, 330a30

Meteorologica (Mete.) l.3, 339b5 4

de Anima (de An.) I.I , 403a 16 1.2. 403a29-40 b2 l.2,403b7-12 1.2, 404a27-3 I l.2,405a9 l.5,411b27-2 II.I , 412al9-21 11.2, 41 a31-32 11.2, 41 a 2-bl 11.3 , 414a 2-33 11.4, 41 b24-25 ll.4, 416al9 11.4, 416bl7-2 11.5, 4 I 6b33-3

66 66 65 67 66 224,225n47 192 225n47 215nl I 225n47 225n47 225n47 225n47 225n47 225n47 192 224

33 222n39 192 224n45 224 224n45 231n6 224n45 LOO 193nl 17 215nl l l93nl 17 162n31 192 161. 171 193nl I L93nl l , l62n31

100 193nl 17 100. 171

301

24, 25. 26. 2 • 29. 31. 90, 13lnl00. 249,

129 2 2 251nl7 251nl7 26ln72 24 252n22 252n24 252n24,26ln72 223n44 252n2 252n23 223n44

302 PHILO OPHl AL THEM IN AL

Il.6,41 al8 TI.7, 419a7-I JT.12,42 bl­fll.3 TJ[.4 429a2 -2 m. , 4 Oal7-23 TII.7, 4 1a2 l-432b7 Ill.13. 4"5bl-2

Parl'a aturalia

de ensu (Sen . ) 3 4 4. 44 la2 l-2_ 4. 44Ja30-b7

Historia Animalium (HA) TII.3, 5 l 2b-513a

de Partibus Animalium (PA) I.J 64 laL5--7 I.l, 64la32-b23 II II. I , 646a 13 Il.L 646al3-24 ill. I 0, 672b28ff. TV.JO, 6 6a25-b28 IV.IO

de Motu Animalium (Ji,fA) 6, 700b20 7, 701bl6-23

de Generatione Animalium (GA) II.I 731 b23-24 TI. I, 731b25-732a3 IJ.L 732al-3 JI.3, 736b21-33 fl.3, 736b28 H.3. 736b28-29 ll.3. 736b3 l Il.3, 737a25 ll.4, 740b37-41a3 U.6. 744b22 IV.I, 766al5ff. IV.3, 767b10ff. fV.4, 770bl6 IV.5, 772b30ff. JV.JO, 777b28-778a9 V.J 780bl0

[Aristotle] de Plantis I.I, 8I5a15-16 1.1, 815bl 6-17

245 237 2 2n24 251nl7 91n 91n 261154 2521124

90

237 26 11170 261n70 261n70

155

31,90,96, 113, 125 9111

91n9 100 193nll7 161 91n6 92 94

91116 223n44

30n58,90 30n58 95 96n21 301158 91nl0 9ln8 193nll7 96nl9 261n72 91nl0 96nl9 96nl9 961120 96nl9 95 96nl9

250 250n9 250nl 0

Mewphy ica (Metaph .) I.I , 9 !al -20 tV.5 , t009bl2-15 VIJ.16, I 040b5-9

IJ .16, I 040b5-10 Xl.10, 1066b36 Xll.4, t070a33-b4 Xll.4 , t070b4-1 l Xll.4 , I 070b5-8 Xll.4, I 070b 16-19 Xll.4, 1070bl9-2 1

Ethica icomachea (EN) 1.7, I 097b22- l 09 a20 11.2, 1103b34-1 l 04a I 0 111.3 , l I I 2b8- l 5

Politico 1.6, 1255bl-4 Vl.6, I 320b34-39

Rhetorica (Rh.) I.I t 355b9- I 5 1.2 t 355b25-26 1.3, 135 b

I 0 X LO ORUM

[Ari totle] Rhetorica ad Alexandrum I, 142lb 2-3, 1425b

Caeliu Aureliu Acutae Pas ione 11.7 124

Calcidiu in Platoni. Timaeum 237

icero de atura Deorum 2.37.94

Corpus Herm ticum X I . -9

Demo ritu de atura Homini

Diog n Lacrtiu Vitae Philo opho111m 7.7 7.1 I 7.156-57 7.1 7 7.199-200

81 251nl7 16 n49 193nl 19 193nl 17 189nl07 !89nl08 I 9nl09 J89nl 11 !89nl 12

32 32 80 80

94n13,95nl7 93nl2

80 73 44n24

44n24 44n24

276llL. I. 2 n52

23

__ 2n41

96n21

90

75 243 174 2 75

303

304

9.116 I 0.49- 0 10.6 -69 10.6 -71 10.69. -ll

Diogenes of Apollonia de atura Homi11is

Fragment a 64A 19 Diel -Kranz

PHILO OPHr AL Tl I -MES TN

Diony iu of Halicarna su Ar RheJorica TI.2 3.20-292.23 U ener and Rademacher

Empedocle Fragment a 31A 70 Diets-Kranz 3 lB 17 Diel -Kranz 3 I B I 03 Diel -Kranz 3 l B I 05 Diel -Kranz 31B 107 Diel -Kranz 31B 109 Diel -Kranz 3lB I 10 Diets-Kranz 31 B 117 Di els-Kranz

Epictetu Dissenationes ab Arriano digestae 1.7.22-29 chenkl 2.12.1-2 chenkl 2.12.5-13 chenkl 2.12.9 . chenld 2.12.14-16 chenkl 2.12.17-25 chenkl 3.23 chenkl 3.23.33. 1-35. l chenkl

Epicurus Epistula ad Herodotum (Ep.Hdt.) 10.49-50 10.68-71 10.68-69 10.69.8-ll

Euclid Elementa (Elem.) Icn.1-3

Galen Protrepticus (Protr.) Ll K (84.5-6 Boudon) l.6-7 K(88.19-89.5 Boudon) f.15.9-18.11 K (96.3-98.17 Boudon) 1.17.17 K (97.20 Boudon)

L N

279n38 237 16 I 4n94 163n35

90

2511120

47n37

25ln17 2 lnl7 2511115 251nl5 2511114 251nl4 2511115 251nl6

55n84 54n75 54n76 54n77 54n78 54n79 49n50 45n27

237 184n94 163 I 63n35

63

3, 8, 10, 1lnlO,38, 41-50, 53, 57 38n74 10 43n20 43nl6

1.1 9.13 K (99.16-17 Boudon) 1.20.4-5 K (I 00.1-2 Boudon) 1.21.l K (100.17 Boudon) 1.21.4 K (101.3 Boudon)

INDEX LO ORUM

l.25. l l-16K (I 04.20-105.4 Boudon) 1.26 K (I 05 Boudon) I.26.11-16 K (105.17-22 Boudon) 1.2 .10-12 K(107. I0-12 Boudon) 1.31. -9 K (I I 0.1-2 Boudon) 1.39.6- K (117.14-16 Boudon) 1.3 K (I I 7.2- oudon) 1.3 -39 K ( 117 Boudon) 1.39.6-10 K (117.14-1 Boudon)

de Optima Doctrina (Opt.Doc/.) 1.42 K 1.45 K 1.48 K 1.49 K

de Sec/is ad Eos Qui lntroducuntur (SI) l.75-76K 1.76 K

43nl9 43nl7 43nl6 43nl 49n53 48n45 4 n46 48n43 49n49 43016 l lol I 46033 42n13

76 62 63 62 62 63

269 79 71 74

Quod Optimus Medicu Sil Quoque Philo ophus (Opt.Med.) 3, , 9, 11 1.53 .1-54.12 K (1.1-2.5 Millier) ln3 1.60-61 K 61 1.60.10-61.15 K (6.23-7.24 Millier) 3n 10 1.61-62 K (291.22-292.5 Boudon-Millot) 9n6

[Galen] de Optima ecta Opt.Sect.) 1.114-15 K

de Constiwtione Arli Medicae (CAM) 1.245-51 K(74.16-7 . I Fortuna) 1.246-47 K 1.24 K (76.4-7 Fortuna) 1.290-91 K 1.29 K 1.299 K

Ar Medico (Ar Med.) 1.336-37 K (30 .2-7 Boud n-Millot) 1.343 K

I. 290 I

_l4n7 69n30 222n39

2, 6 143n44, 150n7 150n 0

120, 1_3, 13-. 209, 271 12ln 0 l 14n6

305

de Elem 11/i ex Hippocrate (Hipp.Elem.)

1.413 K (56. -7 D La )

5, 32-33, 100, 13 • 153. 154, 15 • 162, 213-14, 215, 225-26, 22 • 230, 233-34 191nl 15

1.415 K (5 .7-9 De Lac ) 1.415 K (5 .7-10 De La ) 1.415 K (5 .10-15 De Lac ) l.41 5. l -16K( .14-15DeLay) 1.416 K (5 .15-17 De La ) l.416K(5 .17-19DeLa ) l.416.6K(5 .19-20DeLa y)

230n59 215n9 216nl2 162n32 217nl , 230n60 217nl7 162

306 PHILO PHI L TH ME 1 GALE

1.416 K (5 .19-21 De Lacy) l.416K(5 .19-22DeLacy) f.416 K(5 .21-22 De Lac ) I.416 K (5 .25-26 De Lac ) l.416-434K (60.1-76.1 De Lay) l.416-17 K (60.1-2 De Lacy) I.416.9 K (60.1-3 De Lac ) T.417 K (60.3-6 De Lacy) T.417-419 K (60.3-62.13 De Lacy) T.417-1 K (60.5-J DeLacy) I.417K(60. -15DeLac) I.41 .7-419. K (60.19-62.13 De Lacy) I.41 K (62.3-4 De Lac ) T.419 K (62.7-9 De lac ) l.419 K (62.9-13 De Lacy) I.419 K (62.13-14 De Lacy) I.419.IQ-.12 K (62. l --16 De Lacy) I.4-0.4-7 K (62.21-r De Lacy) I.420-24 K (62.26-6 .2 De Lacy) l.420.15-421.4 K (64.5-10 De Lacy) I.424-25 K (6 .3- l I De lacy) I.424.16-426.11 K (6 .3-24 De Lacy) 1.424.17-425.5 K (6 .4- De Lacy) l.425 K (68.8-9 De Lacy) 1.426.3-7 K (6 .1 -21 De Lac ) I.426 K (6 .23-26 De Lacy) T.427 K (70.2-3 De Lacy) l.427 K (70.2-9 De Lacy) 1.427.2-15 K 70.2-12 De Lacy) 1.427 K (70.3 De Lacy) 1.427 K (70.4 De Lacy) 1.427 K (70.6 De Lacy) I.427 K (70.8 De Lacy) l.427.15-428 K (70.12-1 De Lacy) l.428-32 K (70.24-74.18 De Lacy) 1.430.6-14 K (72.16-22 De Lacy) I.430 K (72.18-20 De Lacy) I.431.2-3 K (74.2-3 De Lacy) 1.431.8-10 K (74. 7-8 De Lacy) I.431.13-432.2 K (74.7-7 De Lacy) 1.431-32 K (74.8-15 De Lacy) 1.432.11-12 K (74.24-25 De Lacy) I.431-32 K (75.4-18 De Lacy) 1.433.9-434. l K (76.12-15 De Lacy) I.44 -49 K (92.21-24 De Lacy) 1.449.5-10 K (92.26-94.2 De Lacy) l.450 K (94.12 De Lacy) 1.450 K (94.14-15 De Lacy) 1.450.9-13 K (94.14-17 De Lacy) 1.451.4-9 K (94.23-28 De Lacy) 1.451 K (96.1-2 De Lacy) I.45l.l1-457.5 K (96.2-100.24 De Lacy) l.453.15-454. 11 K (98.6-15 De Lacy) 1.457 .8-13 K (I 02.1-7 De Lacy) I.457.13-15 K(J02.7-9 De Lacy)

217nl6,230n61 214n6 217n19,230n62 217nl8 217 2 1 n20 162 2 14n6 2 1 2 1 1122 163 164 218n23 2 1 n24 219n26 2191127 165. 165n41, 169n52, 2181121, 22ln36 166n42,219n28 219n29 166 220n30,22ln35 16 n50 169 220n31 16

220n32 220n34 220n33,230n58 168n50 220 220 220 220 170 221n37 171, 171n56 221n37 166n44 167n48 168n49 22ln37 172n58 222n38 167n47 233n73 179 233n72 233n73 180n84 180 233n74 179n80 195 178 173n61

fND X LO ORUM

1.45 .4-9 K {I 02. 14-18 De Lacy) 1.459.10-15 K (I 04.6-1 I De Lacy) 1.461.4-462.14 K (I 06.3-108.1 De Lacy) 1.465 K ( 110.13-15 De Lacy) 1.465.10-1 3 K {I10.15-17 De Lacy) t.466.4-467.1 K (110.21-1 12.2 De Lacy) 1.467.4-6 K ( 112.8- 10 De Lacy) 1.46 .5-469.1 K ( 112.21-114.4 De Lacy) 1.469. -12K(l14.10-13 De Lacy) 1.469.12-471.1K{114.13-116.5 De Lacy) 1.469-470 K {I1.4.16-18 De Lacy) 1.470.4 K (114.20 De Lacy) 1.470.7 K (114.22 De Lacy) 1.470. K (I 14.23 De Lacy) 1.484 K ( 130.8-9 De Lacy) 1.4 4K(130.8- 10DeLacy) 1.4 6.3-7 K ( 132.18-22 De Lacy) 1.492. 1-493.1 K ( 13 .15- I 40.2 De Lacy) 1.507. 15-16 K (156.10 De Lacy)

de Temperamenti (Temp.)

1.529 K ( 13.13-16 Helmreich) 1.541 K (20.2 1-21. 1 Helmreich) 1.541 K 1.542 K (21.10- 19 Helmreich) l.546-47 K (23.29-24. Helmreich) 1.547-48 K(24. 16-25.2 Helmreich) 1.552 K (27. I 0 Helmreich 1.557-5 K (31.3- 11 Helmreich) 1.55 -59 K (31.17-32.4 Helmreich) 1.55 K (31.20 Helmreich) 1.559 K (31.2 -32.4 Helmr ich) 1.559 K (32. Helmreich) 1.560-61 K (32. -12 Helmreich) 1.560 K (32.26 Helmreich) 1.561 K (32.10 Helmreich) 1.560 K (32.24 Helmreich) 1.560-62 K (32.24- 4.4 Helmreich 1.561 K 33.12 Helmreich) 1.561 K (33.13 Helmreich 1.562-63 K (34.5-19 Hclrnreich) 1.563 K (34. I 0 Helmrei h) I. 63-65 K ( 4.20- 5.16 Hclmrei h) I. 63- 4 K ( 4.2 -25 1 lelmrei h) 1.564-6 K ( . I - 16 I lelmn.::ich) 1.56 -67 K ( 5.17- 7. I Helmreich) 1.5 6 K (36.9-12 Helmreich) 1.566 K (36.16-26 Helmr i h) 1.566 K 36.19-20 Helmreich) 1.566-67 K ( 6.20-24 llelmreich) 1.567 K 1.567 K (36.22-24 llelmreich) I. 67 K (36.21-24 Helmreich) 1.567 K (36.23-24 Hclmreich)

181n87 17 n79 181 184 I 79n80. I 84n96 185 185n99 186 I 7nl01 187 33 18 nl02 18 nl02 18 nl02 220n31 222n39 174n65 173n63 257n47

307

29,30n5 31n59,32 9,97 100, 101-05, 106, 11 , 120, 121-24, 126-30, 133, 136 106n51 10 n57 J36n2 102n3 107n5 , 122n 2 107n56 10 o5 102n39 103040 103041 127n92 10 o5 10 059 10 n5 10 n5 I 1-063 109n60 10 o5 I 14n6 1 IOn61 106 1 I ln62 106 10 057 I 12n66 120 127n94 I 14n6 29 136n2 I 15n69 102n36 119

30 PHILO OPHI L TH ME I G LE

1.567-6 (37.1-24 Helmreich) I.575-77 K (41.24-43.9 Helmreich) I.575 K (42.2-4 Hehnreich) 1. 77 K(4 .17-19Helmreich) I.577-7 K ( 43.17-44.7 Helmreich) l.57 K ( 44. -10 Helmreich) I.5 9-90 K I.603-04 (59.24-60.4 Helmreich) 1.604-05 K (60.6-21 Helmreich) 1.604 K (60.10 Helmreich) 1.609-10 K (63. -19 Helmreich) 1.611-14 1.616 K (67.27 Helmreich) 1.617 K (6 .11-12 Helmreich) I.61 K (6 . I -19 Helmreich) 1.61 K (6 .2 Helmreich) 1.619 K(69.14-22 Helmreich) J.619K(69.l Helmreich) 1.622-23 K (71. , 71.14, 71.22 Helmreich) 1.623-24 K (7-.7-9 Helmreich) 1.626 K (73.25-26 Helmreich} 1.62 K (74.7-75.2 Helmreich) 1.6"4 K(7 .17-1 Helmreich) 1.635-37 K (79.6- 0.24 Helrnreich) 1.635-36 K (79.20-29 Helmreich) 1.636 K ()9.23-27 Helmreich) I.636 K (79.29 Helmreich) 1.636 K ( 0.9-10 Helmreich) 1.636-37 K ( 0.9-11 Helmreich) 1.640 K ( 2.6 Helmreicb) l.647 K (87.4 Helmreich) l.654.6-9 K I.654.9-1 l K 1.655.1-2 K 1.659 K (94.10 Helmreich) I.660 K (95.9 Helmreich) 1.675 K (104.1-4 Helmreich)

de 'aturalibus Facultatibus (Nat.Fae.) Il.l.1-3 K ll.1.1-2.5 K 11.1.5-2.6 K ll.3.3-17 K 11.20 K 11.24.3-12 K 11.25 K 11.27-30 K (120.7-122.16 Helmreich) 11.29 K (121.25-122.3 Helmreich) 11.29-30 K IJ.30 K Il.42 K II.42.2-7 K 11.45.2 K ll.44-56 K H.45.8-14 K

1161171 117 106 120n77 104n43, 120n79 120n77 45nJI 105n46 I 04n42, I 17n73 10Jn41 105n50 IJ6nJ 104n44 120n77 104n44 104n44 11 1061153 105n47 105n47 106n5J, 122 104n45 11 7 11 '119 29, 106 1021136 123 11 120n7 106 106 256039 257n45 257n43,266n87 106n54 106n54 89nl, 101n35, 123

9 , I 00, 198, 256, 261, 264, 266 261n71 261n74 175n71 163n33 2601168 256n40 257n42 213n3 213n3 256n39 257n45 257n47 259n60 257n47 257n49 258n53,258n54

11.47-51 K !I.48.12-16K 11.53.13-14 K 11.55 K 11 .55.5-6 K 11.55.6-7 K 11.55.10-12 K 11.55.17-56.12 K 11.57-60 K 11.59-60 K 11.60 K !l.60-62 K (94-96 Brock) 11 .62-63 K Jl.63-65 K 11.64.16 K 11.73 K 11.73.3 K 11.75 K 11 .76 K 11.76-77 K 11.76.5-7 K ll.63-64 K 11.64 K 11.76 K 11.78.11-12 K 11.78-79 K 11.80 K ll.80.12-15K 11.81 K II.81.l-6K 11.85 K II. 6.14-87.6 K ll.87.6-7 K ll.88.12-13 K ll.96.l -2K 11.99 K fl.103-06 K 11.106 K 11.106-07 K 11.125-42 K II.143-45 K U.144 K ll.1-6 K IJ.l60.--l-l K II.I .3 K fl.I 2.1 K II.I 9. -9 ' 11.193.4-6 K IJ.19 .15-1 , ll.19 99 , 11.199.1~ K !LOO.I -1-ILOl.3 K ILOI.- K 11.2

INDEX LOCORUM

202 266n89 258n52 71 257n47 257n48 258n51 57n50 259n61 202 200 274nl5 201 25 n56 258n57 201 258n56 200 201 25 n56 258n57 258n58 200 258n58 25 n55 25 n58 200,256n39 257n42 202 256n39 202 266n90 25 n55 25 n55 266n87 204 201nl3 202 257n49 173n64 256n39.-56n-W 257n42 199n9 _66n _56n3

309

310 PHlLO OPHlC L THEME I G LE

11.206.6-11 K lT.206 K 11.206 K 11.206.1 -19 K 11.206-07 K ll.210K 11.212 K

de Anatomies Administrarionihus (AA.) Il .545 K

de lnsrmmento Odoratus (lnsr.Od.) II. 71 K

de Usu Partiwn (UP) 111.2 K ( 1.1.l 0-16 Helmreich) IIl.29 K Jll.80 K (1.59.4-6 Helmreich) 111.275.3-9 K (1.201.14-21 Helmreich) lll .275.3-12 K (1.201. 14-23 Helmreich) lll.276.5-8 K (1.202.10-12 Helmreich) lll.276.11-16 ( 1.202.16-22 Helmreich) 111.308-309 K (1.226 Helmreich) Jil.30 .17-309.2 K(l.226.I -20Helmreich) Jll.310.--16K (l.227. 17-22 .5 Helmreich) 111.310.11 -13 K (1.227.23-22 .I Helmreich) UI .350-51 K (1.257.4-8 Helmreich) Ill.362.6-367.4 K ( 1.265.13-269.2 Helmreich) lll.378.1-8 K (l.276.22-277.4 Helmreich) lll.418.8-11 K (l.305.16-20 Helmreich) lll.480-81 K lll.501. -lOK (I.365.5-7 Helmreich) llI.501.10-15 K(l.365 .7-13 Helmreich) III.523 K UJ.640.15-641.14 K Ill.759-841 K III.842-989 K. Ul.885-86 K (2.143-44 Helmreich) llI.899-91 l K (2.153.27-162.12 Helmreich) JJI.906-07 K (9.14, 2.158.21-59.19 Helmreich) I .248 K IV.352-59 K (2.441-47 Helmreich) JV.352 K IV.355 K JV.360-61 K (2.447.21-44 .5 Helmreich) IV .362~63 K (2.449 .15-18 Helmreich)

de Utilitate Respirafionis {Vt.Resp.) IV.473 K JV.474 K TV.474-75 K lV.475-76 K

199117 20 202 199118 203 203 260n68

l 14n68

251151

14. 17. 91-92. 98, IOI. 125, 262 I 131167 1141168 1131167 2561139 2621176 2571144, 2621176 2601168 261n74 2621176 262n75 262n76 89111 259n61 262n76 266n87 199n8,203 262n76 2621176 203 242 149n71 l32nl05 100n30 118n74 25n87 I 14n68 99n28, 1141168 I 14n68 I l4n68 17n31 17n31

199,2041119 205, 211 199 200

de Semine (Sem.) IV.512-13 K IV.513K IV.606 K IV.625. 11 K ( 178. 10- 11 De Lacy)

I DEX LOCORUM

de Foe111um Formatione (Foet.Form.)

IV.687-88 K (92.3-9 ickel) IV.688 K (92. 16-2 1 ickel) IV.695 K (I 00.6 ickel) IV.698 K ( 102.10-2 1 ickel) IV. 699-702 K (I 02-06 ickel) IV.700 K ( I 04.11-12 ickel) IV.700 K IV.700-1 K (104.25-26 ickel) IV.70 1 K (104.27- 106.7 ickel)

An in Arteriis Sanguis Contineatur (Art.Sang.) IV.710 K IV.727 K

20n38 64 80 I 14n68 260n66

311

15, 16, 17 36 89, 97, 100n29, 123, 124, 132, 133, 134 15 124n85 15n24 15n25 15n23 19n37 71 36 124n86

199,200,204 45n31

de Optima C01pori o tri Constilutione (Opt.Corp.Const.} IV.744-45 K I 14n68

de Substantia Facultatwn aturalium (Sub. at.Fae) IV.758. 16-759.11 K IV.759.11-13 K IV.759 K IV.76 1 K IV.761 K fV.761-62 K IV.764 K IV.764. 11-15 K fV.764.15-765.14 K IV.765 K IV.765.1-3 K IV.766.6-9 K

Quod Animi Mores Corpori · Temperamenta Sequanrur (QAM)

IV.76 K IV.769 K ( 3.17-20 MUiier) IV.770 K IV.773 K ( 6.12-16 MUiier) I .773 K (37.4-5 Millier) I .773-74 K (37.5-12 Millier) IV.774K( 7.17- 19MUller) IV.775 K( .4-1 MUiier) IV.775 K ( .14 MUiier) l .775 K( . I Mi.Iller) IV.779 K I .7 2 K IV.7 2 K (44.12-1 MUiler)

26 n93 256n39 71 , 72, 74 72 16n30 17n31 16n2 260n63 263n 0 72 265n 4 266n 6

I , 23-25, 27. 34, 36-37. 9, 97, 117. 12 -30, 140 140n25 36 139n20 1_ n97 36n71 24 34n66 I9n37 19n37 126n91 140n26 _6ln73 2ln41

312 PHILO OPHICAL Tl I M • ' I G LE

lV.7 3.3-9 K lV.7 6-87 K J . 05 K (64.19-20 Muller) l . 09 K (6 . I Muller) .I . JI K(70.13-14Muller)

de Propriorum Animi Cuiu libel Ajfectuum Dignotione et Curatione (Ajf.Pecc.Dig.)

V. -12K(7.7-J0.4deBoer) .20-24K (l .6- 17.IO deBoer) .3 1 .33-34 K

V.33.1 • -34.6 K (23.9-16 de Boer) V.40-42 K (27.22-2 ·-' de Boer)

.41 K (2 .12 de Boer) V.41 K (28.16 de Boer) V.41-43 K

.60 K (42.1 -19 de Boer) V.71 K (49.9 de Boer) V. 75 K (51.l • de Boer)

. 7 KC 1.23 de Boer)

.76 K (52.6 de Boer) V.80 V. 0- 2 K (54.20-55.27 de Boer) V. K (59.23-_7 de Boer) V.92 K (62.6-7 de Boer) V.94K V.9 K V.9 K(65.16-2ldeBoer) V.9 -101 K(65.16-67.l de Boer) V.l 00 K (66.23-24 de Boer) V.102 K Y.103 K (68.5-6 de Boer) V.103 K (68.14-15 de Boer)

de Atra Bile (At.Bil.) V.110 K

de Placitis Hippocratis el Platonis (PHP)

V.208 K V.213-14 K V.217K V.221 K V.221-22K V.227 K V.243 K V.273 K V.349 K V.354 K V.355 K V.397 K V.449 K V.507.16-18 K (362.8-9 De Lacy)

195nl24 1411130 19n36 19n36 19n36

10, 14, 16, 32, 59

51n6 1 511161 441123 51116 1 511162 10n8 21n39 211140 73 14nl6 1411I7 14nl7 l4nl7 14nl 67 10n8 14nl9 14n20 63, 64 63 16n27 10n8 14n2l 63 15n22 1 lnl2

I 14n6

26, 35, 37, 61-62, 64-65, 70-77, 87, 101, 139, 197, 203, 210, 239, 245, 246 62n3 75 73 72, 73 72 72, 73 74, 75 72 75 75 75 114n68 I 14n68 2551135

INDEX LOCORUM

V.519-20K V.52 1.5- 18 K(374.9-19 De Lacy) V.524.11-12 K 376.22-23 De Lacy) V.549 K V.575 K (416.34-35 De Lacy) V.593 K V.600-01 K (2.438 De Lacy) V.606 K (442.37-444.1 De Lacy) V.606 K (444.5-6 De Lacy) V.608.1-609.9 K (444.29-446.17 De Lacy) V.60 K (444.30-32 De Lacy) V.609 K ( 446.12-13 De Lacy) V.617.11-18 K (452.22-28 De Lacy) Y.618.3-15 K (452.30-454.4 De Lacy) V.618.15-619.2 K (454.4-7 De Lacy) V.619.2-13 K (454.8-16 De Lacy) V.625.6-626.7 K (460.1-16 De Lacy) Y.625.15 K (460.7 De Lacy) V.625.19 K (460.11 De Lacy) Y.626.6 K ( 460.15 De Lacy) Y.626.14-627.4 K (460.22-28 De Lacy) V.627.4-10 K (460.28-33 De Lacy) V.637.IL-638.17 K(470.3-21 De Lacy) Y.642.6-12 K (474.3-7 De Lacy) Y.642.12-18 K (474.8-12 De Lacy) Y.643 K (474.22-26 De Lacy) V.661.7-14 K Y.661.15-662.5 (490.16-21 De Lacy) V.663-4 K (492.11-21 De Lacy) Y.665 K (492.31-33 De Lacy) V.673-5 K (500 De Lacy) Y.675 K (502.10-11 De Lacy) Y.6 1-82 K (506.25-33 De Lacy) Y.6 4-85 K (510.1-3 De Lacy) Y.696-99 K (518.26-520.35 De Lacy) Y.7 10-13 K (530.12-532.27 De Lacy) Y.713 K (532.28 De Lacy) V.713-16 K V.723 K Y.766-67 K Y.778 K Y.779 K Y.7 0 K

.7 0- I K Y.780- 2 K Y.7 2 K

.792 K

.795 K

72 26Jn73,26ln74 260n67 199n8 9n7 76 139n23 37 37 241 37 37 243 239 243 240 245 246 246 246 246 242 244 246 244 37 189nl06 l91nl JS 232n69 9n7 l36n5 9n7 9n7 9n7 9n7 9n7,203 9n7 199n 62 61. 197 77 61 71 64 7

65 70. 72, 74 62. 71. 72

Thra ybulu ·ive Utrum Medicinae it an Gvmnasticae Hygiene (Thras.) · , 41, 46n35, 54-55. 56-59

V.807. -9 K ( 3.27-34. l Helmreich) 54n 0 V.809.3-9 K ( 5.4-l l Helmreich) 55n82 V. 14.10- 15 K ( 9.1-7 Helmreich) 57n94

. 16.9-15 K (40.10-16 Helmreich) 57n94

313

314 PHILO PHI AL THEME IN GALEN

V. 17. -lOK(41.4-6Hehnreich) . 17.1 K(41.9Helmreich) . 2 I. -9 K ( 44. -9 Helmreich) . 21. -9K(44.10Helmreich) . 21.17 K (44.1 Helmreich) . 22.1 - 23.1K(45.I1-12 Helmrcich)

V. _2.16 K (4 .1 I Helmreich) . 24.16-17 K (46.21-22 Helmreich) . 27.2-7 K(4 .6-12Helmreich)

V. 27. -9 K ( 4 .13-14 Helmreich) . 27 K (4 . 13-16 Helmreich)

V. 36.3-4 K (54.l 7 Helmreich) . 36.11 K (54.22 Helmreich)

V. 37.2 K (" .6 Helmreich) . 40.14-41.6 K(57.23-5 .7 Helmreich) . 41.11-16 KC .13-1 Helmreich)

V. 46.11 K (62. I Helmreich) . 4 .1 4K(63.I Helmreich)

V. 4 .17K(63.19Helmreich) . 51.15-19 K (6-.21-24 Helmreich)

V. 60.4-7 K (71.24-27 Helmreich) . 60 K (71.24-72. Helmreich) . 60.6 K (71.26 Helmreich) . 61. -9 K (72.19-20 Helmreich)

V. 61.10 K (72.20 Helmreich) .864.1 K (75.3 Helmreich) . 64.6 K (74. I 7 Helmreich)

V.865.10 K (75.13 Helmreich) .866. IO K (76.7 Helmreich)

V.866.11-13 K (76.9 Helmreich) . 66.13 K (76. I 0 Helmreich) .866.16 K (76.13 Helmreich)

V.866. I 8 K (76. I 5 Helmreich) .867.3-5 K (76.18-20 Helmreich)

V.867.3-16 K (76.18-77.6 Helmreich) .868.6 K (77.12 Helmreicb)

V.869-76 K V.869.6 K (78.7 Helmreich) V .876.4 K ( 3. I 3-14 Helmreicb) V.880.4 K (86.9 Helmreich) V.88J .2 K (86.25 Helrnreich) V.881.13K(87.I1 Helmreich) V.881.17 K (87.15 Helmreich) V.882.13 K (88.5 Helmreich)

.884.3 K (89.6 Helmreich) V.885.16 K (90.11 Helmreicb) V.887.5 K (91.15-16 Helmreich) V.887.16 K (91.26 Helmreich) V.891.15 K (94.23 Helmreich) V.892.13 K (95.16 Helmreich) V.894.16 K (97.6 Helmreich) V.894. I 8-95.4 K (97 .8-12 Helmreich) V.895.13-15 K (97.22-24 Helmreich) V.896.4-7 K (98.5-9 Helrnreich)

57n92 56n 7 58n97 57n96 57n92 57n94 57n96 57n93 56n86 55n85 8n4 57n96 56n 7 56n 7 57n94 57n95 5611 7 57n96 56n87 57n9J 56n 9 8n4 561187 56n 8 56n87 56n 7 56n 7 56n87 56n90 57n96 57n96 57n96 57n96 58n98 57n91 56n90 46n35 57n96 56n90 57n96 56n87 56n90 56n90 56n90 57n96 56n87 56n90 56n87 57n96 56n87 56n87 59nl01 58nl00 57n91

de anilate Tuenda (San. Tu.) Vl.14-29 K VI.39-42 K ( 19. I 5-20.20 Koch) Vl.1 26 K Vl.l 38-39 K (61.21-34 Koch)

I D XLO ORUM

de Alimentorum Faeultatibus (Alim.Fae.) VJ.533 K

de Bonis Malisque Sucis (Bon.Mal.Sue.) VJ.755 K (392.2 1-24 Helmreich)

de Morborum Diflerentiis (Morb.Difl.) VJ.841 K VJ. 44 K Vl .848-49 K VJ. 55 K

de Causis Morborum (Caus. Morb.) VII.20-2 1 K Vll.24.6- I 0 K

de Symptomalum Diflerentii (Symp.Difl.) Vll.42- 4 K Vll.50 K (2 I 0.3-4 Grundert) Vll.60 K Vll.60-61 K VIJ.60-62 K VIJ.61 K

de Symptomalum Cau ·i (Caus.Symp.) VII. 5-272 K Vll.95-96 K VII.97 K Vll.129.4-10 K VII.200-01 K VII.200-02 K

27 103 l 16n71 I 14n68 27

I 14n68

10

136n4, 137n8 136n6 136n6 137nl0

136n7 256n39,257n45

141, 147 145n5 10 1n33 142n36, 142n37 142n39, 142n40 14ln35 143n42, 147n65

135 141. 14 145n5 149n71 149n73 175n71 I40n27. 141n32 141n I 140n2

315

Vll.201 K VII.202 K 13 nl5, 139n20, 14ln33. 14In34,

Vlf.256. I 7-1 K

de Febriwn Differentii (Di.fl.Feb.) Vll.27 K Vll.3 I. -9 K

11.3 I. -14 K

l.Wn46, 14 n6 256n41

2 n64 _57n44 256039

d Plenitudine (P/en.) VII.529.6-12 K 260n64 de Tremore, Pa/pitatione, on\'11/ ione el Rigore (Trem.Palp.) VIl.597 K 2 n64

de Comate ec11nd11m Jlippocratem (Hipp.Com.) Vll.643-65 K 145n5

316 PHILO OPHT L TH ME fN GALEN

de Marcore (Marc.) TT.671 K

Vll.761

de Inaequali lntemperi (lnaeq.Jnt.) 11 .733-52 K

de Difficultale Re :pirationi (Diff.R :p.) TI.753-960 K

de Loci A.jfecti (Loc.Aff.) Ul.14K

Vlil.16 K Yllf.21K vm.2_K

111.30-31 K lll.39 K Tll.44 K

VTII.49 K lll.126-27 K

Vll1.l27 K Ylll.127-2 K Vlll.129 K Vlll.130 K

lil.131 K Vlll.134 K Ylil.137 K Ylil.14- K YIII.156-57 K

lll.160 K YIIl.161 K Ylll.162K Ylll.166 K Ylll.177-78 K

III.178K III.178-79 K III.221-22 K llI.255K

VUI.226 K YIII.226-27 K VlJI.227 K Vlil.293-94 K VUl.329 K VJII.329 K VIH.329-30K VIII. 330-31 K

JII.331 K VIII.332 K

de Pu/sibus ad Tirones (Puls.) VTTI.453-92 K

de Differentiis Pulsuum (Di.ff.Puls.) Ylll.609 K VIJJ.631.1-4 K

65.66,69n3l, 71 69n I

136n7

145n58

135. 13 ' 139, 140, 143, 145, 148,284 7 .83 13 nl4 149n72 I nl I nl5 143n44 137111 2 13 nl6 139n24 137n9 36 1431143 150n I 143n44 140n27 13 n I , I 38n 19 13 nl5 2

139n21 139n20 140n27 140n28 140n29 .13 1115, 1381118 14 n67 144n47, 144n48 144n49, L44n51 149n73 1491174 147n64 1471166, 149n76 148n70, 150n82 277n29 1441147, 144n49, 144n50 146n60 144n52 146n62 146n61 146n63

145n58

67 172n59

VII l.642.4-7 K Vll 1.6 2-702 K Vlll.704-05 K Vlll.711 K

I DEX LOCORUM

de Dignoscendibus Pulsibus (Dig. Puls.) Vlll.7 1-83 K

de ausis Pulsuum (i aus.Puls.) IX.1-204K lX.92 K

de Cri ibus (Cris.) lX.550-760 K lX.5 3 K lX.707 K

de Methodo Medendi (MM) X.14-15 K X.32 K X.34 K X.36 K X.40 K X.42 K X.47 K X.50 K X.52 K X.66-67 K X.205 K X.205-07 K X.206 K X.207 K X.217K X.635.6-1 K

.635.14-15 K

.653 K X.665 K

. -1-53 K

. 52.9- 53.2 K X. 60K X.92 K

.1015. -9 K

de Curandi Ratione p r Venae ectionem (Cur.Rat. Ven. 1.257. - K l.257. -11 K

de implicium Medicamemonim Facultatibus ( MT)

Xl.4 I K Xl.450.12-14 K

1.791.17 K 11.160 K

172n59 65n16 76 62, 76

45n31

145n58 114n68

145n58 3

146n62

1, 137, 150 219n25 64,64n15 63,81 62 64, 76 64 137n9 64 10ln33 10ln33 2 2 1 I 1, 2

26ln73 26ln74

1 1

214n7 214n4

1 150n 3 260n65

ct.) 214n4 214n5

72 26ln69 129 129

de Compositione Medicam1mtorum ecundum Locos (Comp.Med.Loe.) Xll.379-80 K 9nl

317

31 PHILO OPHl AL TH M IN LE

de Theriaca ad Pi 011em (Ther.Pi .) fV.250-53 K

de Praenotio11e ad Epig n m (Praen.) XN.612K ( 0.16-19 utt n)

N.613 K ( 2.6-7 utton) rY.613 K ( 2.1- utton)

rl .6 I K ( 6.29-30 utton) XIV.627-30 K (96. -100.6 utton) XfV .629 K (98. t 2 utton)

fV .647 K (I I 6.20-22 utton) XN.660 K (12 .27-2 utton) Xl .660 K ( 12 .2 -30 utton)

I .660 K (12 .27-30 utton)

[Galen] Jmroductio il'e Medicu (Int.) XI .6 0- 3 K (pp. 6-9 Petit)

N .6 3- 4 K (pp. 9-10 Petit) XN.6 4K(p.10Petit) XN.6 8 K (pp. 13-14 Petit) XI .68 -89 K (pp. 13-14 Petit) XIV.696-97 K (p. 20 Petit) XN.696-97 K (9.2 Petit) XI .696-97 K (9.2-3 and 5-6 Petit) XN.697 K (p. 21 Petit) XN.69 K (9.5 Petit) XN.69 .5-12 K XN.69 -99 K (pp. 21-22 Petit) XN.699 K (p. 22 Petit) XN.701-2 K (10.4 Petit) XN.710-11 K (11.3 Petit) XIV.726 K (p. 45 Petit) XI .726K(I3.t Petit) XI .727-2 K (p. 46 Petit) XI . 728-9 K (13.4 Petit) XI .731 -32K(pp.49-50 Petit) XI .752 K (13.36 Petit) XIV.793 K (p. 101 Petit)

in Hippocratis de atura Hominis (H 'H) XV.l-2 K (3.4-9 Mewaldt) XV.3 K (3.24-4.2 Mewaldt) XV.8 K (6.19-20 Mewaldt) XV.9.16-11.10 K (7.21-8.18 Mewaldt) XV.11.14-12.4 K (8.22-28 Mewaldt) X .13.7-11 K (9.15-19 Mewaldt) XV.13.11-14.1 K (9.19-24 Mewaldt) XV.30.4-31.4 K (l 7.2 -18.15 Mewaldt) XV.30.8 K (18.4 Mewaldt) XV.31 K(18.13-15 Mewaldt) XV.32 K (19.7-12 Mewaldt) XV.36-40 K (21.1-23.8 Mewaldt) XV.49.8-50.3 K (27.20-27 Mewaldt) XV.80.1--6 K(42.16-21 Mewaldt) XV.80.12-15 K (42.27-30 Mewaldt)

2 14n7

12, I , 22 I nl4 I nl4 13n14 13nl4 I nl4 13n l4 13n 14 n3

12nl3 52n70

2 2 2761124,277,28 1 274,2 1, 282,285 274 2741117 2 5 2 7n62 2 7 274 2 7n61 173 2 4,285 276n22 287 287 285 287 285 2 7 2 3 287 283

33, 100 232n69 33 36n71 155nl I 155nl I 155nll 155nl I, 155nl3 190 191nl 16 34n63 222n39 214n7 158n2I 261n70 26ln70

INDEX LOCORUM

XV.9 1.12-92.9 K(48.15-25 Mewaldt) XV.93.1-4 K (49.4-7 Mewaldt) XV.97.4-14 K (51.9- 18 Mewaldt) XV. I 02-07 K (53.15-56.6 Mewaldt) XV.105.2-10 K (55.6-14 Mewaldt) XV. I 07 K (56.4-6 Mewaldt) XV.108. 1-109.14 K (57.4-2 1 Mewaldt) XV.124.5-8 K (64. 1.9-22 Mewaldt)

in Hippocratis Prorrheticum (Hipp.Prorrh.) XVI .489-840 K

in Hippocratis Epidemiarum XVllA. l-XVllB.344 K.

in Hippocratis Epidemiarum (Hipp.Epid. VI} XVllB.250. I 2-251.5 K

in Hippocratis Aphorismos (Hipp.Aph.) XVJIB.345-XVllIA. I 95 K XVIJB.382 K XVUB.529 K XVllB.532 K

Adversus Julianum (Adv.Jul.) XYIIlA.266.9-13 K

in Hippocratis Prognosticum (Hipp.Prag.) XVlIIB.71-75 K XVfllB.73 K XV!IIB.300 K

in Hippocratis de Officina Medici (Hipp. Off.Med.) XVIJIB.650 K XVIIIB.86 I K

de Libris Proprii (Lib. Prop.) XIX.8-9 K (134 Boudon-Millot I 2.91-92 Muller) XIX.13K XIX.16 K {140. 16 Boudon-Millot) XT .23-48 K ( 145-73 Boudon-Millot) 155.15-22 Boudon.Millot (not in Kilhn) XIX 36.13-15 K 161.15-17 Boudon-Millot) XIX.36.11-17 K(9. 12, 161.14-20 Boudon-Millot)

LX.38.11-12 K(l63 . Boudon-Millot) I ' .40 K I .40-41 K 1 .42.12-43.1 K (166.22,167.6 Boudon-Millot) IX.43 K (167.6 B udon-Millot)

XI .44 K XI .45 K (16 . 19-169. I Boudon-Millot) XIX.45 K ( 170.2-3 Boudon-Millot) XIX.47 K XI .47.5-6 K(l71.12 Boudon-Millot)

I .4 7 K ( 171. 15-16 Boudon-Millot)

159n23 159n24 163n37 215nl I 155nl I 154n6 155nl I 257n44

145n58

145n58

261n73

145n58 82 89ol 89nl

175n71

149075 149071 82

3 074 2

-5011,277 277n30 73 2ln39 39n3 154n6 155nl I J54n6 45n30 76 45n31 I 4n93 21n40, 74 76. 3 40n4 40n4 4

184n93 13nl4

319

320 PHILO OPI ll L THEM I G L •

de Ordine Librorum Propriorum (Ord.lib.Prop.)

1.7-12 K( 9.16-20 Boudon-Millot) K (93.9-15 Boud n-Millot)

[Galen] Definitiones Medicae (Def fed.) I .346-462 K I .3 3 K

Quod Qualitates /11c01poreae Sin/ (Q11al. /11c01p.) I .463-4 4 K

43nl6 213n2

2 6n56 273 276112 1, 285

1841194

[Galen] Prog110 tica de Decubiht ex Mathematica Scientia (Prag.Dec.) IX.529--73 K 270

de A clepiadae Placitis [not in Kiihn]

de Causis Contemivis (CC) [not in Kiihn] l.2

de Causis Procatartici [not in Kiihn]

de Demonstratione (DD) [not in Kuhn]

Book VIII Book Ill

de !11dolentia (Ind.) [not in Kiihn] 2.3 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 2.3-15 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 2.3-13.2 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 2.4 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 3.1 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 5.6 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 5.16 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 6.19 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 6.21 Boudon- tf.illot and Jouanna 11.9 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 13.3 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 13.8 Boudon-Millotand Jouanna 13.10 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 15-1 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 16.18 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 18.13-16 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 18.16 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 18.19 Boudon-Millotand Jouanna 21. l l Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 24.12 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna 26.3 Boudon-M illot and Jouanna 13.2-16.2 Boudon-Millot and Jouanna

de Moribus [not in Kuhn]

213-14

311159 173n60

4, 65-67, 70-7 1, 4, 86, 197-198 197nl , 207-ll,210n35 214 207 213

41, 50-51, 52-53, 59 52n59 50n55 50n56 5ln59 51n59 Sln59 Sln59 77n4 Sln59 51n59 5ln59 5ln59 Sln59 77n48 Sln59 51n60 Sln59 Sln59 511159 511159 5ln59 501157

32,209,260,263,265,268

l DEXLO ORUM

de Partium Homoeomerium Differentia (Part.Hom.Difl.) [not in Kuhn] 87-94 Strohmaier 161n29, 185n97

de Propriis Placitis (Prop.Plac.) [only a fragment in KUhn] 16, 66 2. 1, 56.12-58.1 Nutton 2.1, 56.12-20 Nutton 2.1-3.1, 56.12-60.6 utton 4.1, 62.18- I 9 Nutton 9.3, 86.23-88.5 Nutton 13.1-2, I 02 utton 13.5-7, 106.20-108.14 utton 13 .6, 186.37 Boudon-Millot 13 .7, I 08.14-17 Nutton 14.4, 188.9 Boudon-Millot 14, I 14.16-19Nutton (188.11-13 Boudon-Millot) 14, I 14.19-27Nutton (188. 13-17 Boudon-Millot) 15.2, 116.20-118.5 utton 15.5, 120.5-10 utton ( 189.12-15 Boudon-Millot) 15.6, 120.19-25 utton 15.7-8, 122. l-124. 15-1 6Nutton 15.7, 122.7-12 utton 15.8, 190.6 Boudon-Millot 15.8, 124.17-18Nutton 15.8, 124.18 utton 15.9, 124.18-20 utton

in Hippocratis Epidemiarum (Hipp.Epid.11) [not in Killin] 220.6-17 Pfaff

in Platonis Timaeum (Plat.Tim.) [not in KUhn] 11.9-11 Schroder 11.12-20 chroder 11 .15-16 Schroder 11.15-20 Schroder 12.7-13 chroder 12.9-15 chroder 12 .22-13.7 chroder 12.30-34 chrOder 22-23 chroder 23.13 chroder 26. I chroder

lnstiturio Logica (In I.Log.) [not in Kiihn] 1.5 Kalbflei ch 2.4.3-5 Kalbfleisch

ubjiguratio Empirica ~ ub/Emp.) [not in Kilhn] 2, 44.34 Deichgriibcr 2 45.24-30 Dei hgriiber 7, 64. I Dei hgrabcr 11 , 2- 4 Deichgriiber

66,69 66n23 l61n28 l61n28 256n39,257n44 261n73 268n93 71,72,74 256n39 72 16n30 17n31 l28n97 l6n28 260n63 263n80 265n84 72 265n85 266 266n 6

156

255n34 260n64 263n79 256n37 268n94 263n77 255n33 256n36 203nl 25 n56 25 n56

63 l90nl 13

79 3

79 45n3l

321

322 PHILO PHICAL TH M fN GALE

Hippocratc and the orpu Hippocraticum de Alimento

de arnibus

de Diaeta J (Regimen J) VI. 22.17- 24.10 Littre (156.19-3 Joi )

de Diaeta Acutorum ll.232 Littre

de Locis in Homine

deMorbi IV

de Morbo Sacro

de atura Hominis ( at.Hom.)

I. I, VI.32 Littre (164.3-5 Jouanna) 1.1-2.5, VI.32.1-36.1 6 Linne (J 64. 1-170.7 Jouanna) 1.1- . , VT.32-52 Littre 2.2, VI.34 Littre (166.14-16 .2 Jouanna) 2.3, VI.34-36 Littre 2.3, VI.34.17-1 Littre (16 .4-5 Jouanna) 3.1-4.3, VI.36-40 Littre 3.1-4, Vl.38.2-1 Littre (J 70.11-172.12 Jouanna) 4.1-3, VI.38.19-40.6 Littre (172.13-174.3 Jouanna) 5.2, VI.42 Littre (176.8-9 Jouanna) 7.7-9, 1.48.20-50.9 Littre 184.16-186.9 Jouanna) 11,1-6, VU -60 Littre

de atura Pueri

de Prisca Medicina J.620.14-622.l Littre (146.9-11 Jouanna)

de Semine

Epidemiarum VJ (Epid. VI) .344-6 Littre ( l 70 Manetti-Roselli)

Praecepta IX.250 Littre

Maimonides On Medicine

Maxim us of Tyre Dissertationes 1.56-<i3 Trapp 1.236-61 Trapp 1.248-<i I Trapp 1.290-92 Trapp

2 7

90

2n

145n56

90

90

2

90, 154, 155, 155nl I, 156, 162, 213, 213nl, 215, 216nl I, 216n12, 216nl3, 217,229,230,232,234 233n72 2n5 155, 155n 11 231 216, 230 162n32 155 157 156 23ln64 15 155

90

l , 80, 155, 156, 160 2n5

90

243

78

84

52n67 49n50 52n68 52n69

37.41-55 Trapp 7.45-47 Trapp

Meli u Frogmen/a 308 7.1-2, 4-6 Diel -Kranz

Lucretiu de Ren11n atura 2 2.865-7 2.865-96 2.891 -96 2.902-30 2.931-62 2.931 ff. 2.937-62 2.944-62 2.952-63 2.952-62 5.31 ff.

eme iu of Erne a de atura Hominis 3.2-4 Morani 18.5-9 Morani 23.24-26.9 Morani 37.9-10 Morani 37.10 Morani 6 .13-15 Morani 69.20-22 Morani 75.22-76.4 Morani 117.6-120.5 Morani

Oriba iu

I DEX LO OR M

ollectione Medicae 6.10.19.5-20.1(6.1.1,163.11-15 Rader 9.12 tl-2 (6.1.2, 12.25-26 Raeder)

Philo Judaeu Quod Deu it immutabili 35, 41

de Aetemitate fundi (A et.Mund.) 24 .2 (9 .10-14 ohn)

Philoponu de Aeternitate M1111di contra Proclum (Aet.Mund.)

5 9.22- 01.16 Rabe 600. -5 Rabe 600.7- 14 Rabe 600.12-14 Rabe 600.17-1 Rab 600.17-601.16 Rabe 600.21 Rabe

46n32 46n34

216

90,226,226049 164 226 164 164, 170 226 226,229 226n51 227 227 227 227 226n51

90 125 90n2 174n67 126-2 1l3n67 127n93 126n 9 9ln5 91n5 12 n95 96n22

176, 176n74 173n61

174n66

174n6

65nl 65 67 6 6 69n31 69 6

323

324 PHIL OPHI L THEM IN GA LE

600.22-23 Rabe 600.26-60l.4 Rabe 601.4- Rabe

in Ari tote/is de Anima (in de An.) 0.16-52.26 Haydu k

13 .5 Heyduck 155.4-"'5 Hayduc I .27- 5 Haydu k 274. -JO Ha duck

in Aristotelis de Generalione el or111plione (in GC)

68 70 70

129-30 13211104 9ln7 132nl04 13211105

164.10-1 itelli 224 J 64. 13-14 itelli 224 164.-4-165.4 itelli 225

Philostratu Gymnasticus 261 .1-14 Jiithner

Plato Channides 156e

Euthydemu 276a 276c

Gorgias

Parmenides 13 c3

Phaedo

Phaedn1s (Phdr.) 246a-254e 269c 270c-d 272d-e

Phi/ebus (Phfb.) 24b3-e2 55d-56b

Polilicus 270a5 288e 289b

Respublica 405c-410a 60Jc-602a Theaetetus 167b-c 182d2-5

Timaeus (Ti.) 29c--d

47n36

2n6

43nl6, 47 44 44

73

163n33

37, 201

37 46n34 73 2 15nl I 74

183n89 80

36 70 36 36

3, 93 3n9 3n9

252n2l t63n33

70, 71, 7 ln35, 90,96 71

IND X LOCORUM 325

lib 195 37a5-7 253n27 37b7-8 253n27 44e 91n4 45b2-d3 236 64b3-6 254n28 64b5 265n82 64c8-d3 264,264n81 65a4 265n82 67b3 91n4 67c4-d2 235 73d-e 9 ln4 76al 91n4 76e3-4 254 76e7-77c5 252 76e7-77e5 256 77b5 253,254 77b6-c5 259 77b7 259 77b7-cl 259 77b7-c3 255,256 77cl 256 259 77c3-5 255 77c4-5 254 79a-e 203 89e3-90c7 3n9 90a 91n4 90c4-7 3n9

Plutarch Adversus Colotem (Adv.Col.) 222 228 7, 111 Oc-d 229n57 9, 111 le 223 10 I 112b-c 223 10-12 222 12, I 113e 223

de Animae procreatione 1022e 6

de Commzmibus otitii (Comm. ot.) 107 e 243 10 4d7-c4 176n73

de Fortuna 49

de liberi Educandi 43,43nl5,47

8c-d 47n36,47n40

de toico11Jm Repugnantiis ( toic.Rep.) 226 l052f

1053c4-dl 176n73

Moralia Xtrl, Part I 6 n29

I 223n42

326

Porph ry ad Gawwn (Gour.) 37.27-41.4 Kalbflei ch

de Ab ti11e111ia 3.2.1

Proclu

PHILO PHI

in Platoni Tima w11 commentaria (in Tim.) 2.9.4-5 Diehl

Prodicu de atura Homini

Protauora Fragment a

0 21a Diel -Kranz

Pythagorean Fragmenta 5 B 1 Diel -Kranz

Rufus of Epb u de C01poris Humani Appellationibu 22 .1 (166.9-11 Daremberg and Ruelle)

eoeca Episru/ae morale ad Lucilium 4.66.12-19 Precbac (94.1 4.77.17-78.5 Prechac 94.39-40) 4. 1.2 - 2.5 Prechac (94.55)

Se tus Empiricu At:h-ersus Mathematicos (M) 5.104 7.174-75 7.179 7.217-1 8.275 8.2 6

implicius in Aristotelis Categorias commentarium (in Cat.) 78.10-20 Kalbfleisch

in Aristotelis Physica commentaria (in Ph.) 573.6-8 Diels 573.19-22 Diets 573.31-32 Diets 652.18 Diels 718.19 Diels

Stobaeus Anthologium 2.91.10

265n

38

195

90

252n21

250n7

177n76

51n64 51n65 52n66

83n69 76 79n59 62 3 n76 251nl7

194

207 206 207 228n53 206n24

28n56

INDEX LO ORUM

Stoics Stoicorum Veterum Fragmenta (SVF) 2.135 2.223 2.4 13 2.416 2.451 2.458 2.459 2.804ff. 2.806 2.841 3.395 3.397

Strato de atura Hominis

Fragmenta Fr. 61 Wehrli

Themi tiu in Physica paraphrasis (in Ph.) 113.11 chenkl 114.1 chenkl 114.7- 12 Schenkl 114.11-12 chenkl 114.18-20 Schenk!

Th eon Progymnasmala

Theophrastus de Sensu el ensibilibus (Sen .) 4 10

Vindicianus de atura Hominis

Zeno de atura Hominis

38n76 38n76 188nl 04 173 174n67 174n66 174n68 226n51 226 174n69 28n56 28n56

90

228n53

206 207 206 207 206

44n24

25lnl 7 251nl 7

90

90

327