Upload File

imitating from memory: hybrid vessels and attempted replications of stylistic elements from central...

  • Home
  • Documents
  • Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
54
Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica John W. Hoopes Department of Anthropology The University of Kansas [email protected] Paper presented in the symposium “Itinerant Matters and Hybrid Objects: Research on Material Transfers and Contact Products,” 80 th Annual Meeting of the Society of American Archaeology San Francisco, CA, April 19, 2015

Upload: kansas

Post on 03-Dec-2023

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

Report

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in

the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica

John W. HoopesDepartment of Anthropology

The University of [email protected]

Paper presented in the symposium “Itinerant Matters and Hybrid Objects:Research on Material Transfers and Contact Products,”

80th Annual Meeting of the Society of American ArchaeologySan Francisco, CA, April 19, 2015

Page 2: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Copador Polychrome, El Salvador Mora Polychrome, Costa Rica

Page 3: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Guangala Polychrome, Ecuador Mora Polychrome, Costa Rica

Page 4: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 5: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 6: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 7: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 8: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Southern GreaterNicoya

Central CaribbeanLowlands

Central Region

Page 9: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Gran Coclé Semiotic TraditionCeramic Chronology

• El Hatillo AD 1300 - 1500• Parita AD 1000 - 1300• Macaracas AD 850 - 1000• Conte AD 700 - 850• Cubitá AD 550 - 700• Tonosí AD 300 - 550• Aristides 300 BC – AD 550• La Mula 150 BC – AD 300• Sarigua 1500 - 500 BC• Monagrillo 2800 – 1200 BC

Greater NicoyaCeramic Chronology

• Ometepe AD 1350 – 1550

• Sapoá AD 800 - 1350

• Bagaces AD 300 - 800

• Tempisque 500 BC – AD 300

• Orosi 2000 – 500 BC

Page 10: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Late La Mula GroupAD 100-200

Late Tonosí GroupAD 300-550

Macaracas GroupAD 850-1000

Iconographic Continuity in Central Panamanian Ceramics

Page 11: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Tripod Bowl FormAltiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya, Costa Rica

AD 800-1350

Pedestal Bowl FormMacaracas Group, Central Panama

AD 800-1000

Page 12: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Late Tonosí Style, Central Panama, AD 400-500

Altiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya, AD 800-1350

Page 13: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

DO PC.B.325Petroglyph, Guayabo de Turrialba, Costa Rica

Gold Disk, Sitio Conte

Page 14: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Altiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya, Costa RicaAD 800 - 1350Macaracas Polychrome, Central Panama

AD 800 - 1000

Page 15: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Tonosí Group, Central PanamaAD 300 - 550

Flying Panel Metate, Caribbean Costa Ricaca. AD 700-1000

Page 16: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Flying Panel Metate, La Unión, Costa Rica (ca. AD 700-1100)

Page 17: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Las Mercedes, Costa Rica Coclé, Central Panama

Page 18: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Macaracas Group, Central Panama, AD 800-1000

Page 19: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Spread-Eagled Figure in Greater Nicoya Ceramics

Page 20: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Mercedes White-Line, Las Mercedes, Caribbean Costa RicaAD 1100-1500

Gold Disk, Sitio Conte, PanamaAD 700-900

Page 21: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Las Mercedes, Costa RicaMacaracas PolychromeCentral Panama

Page 22: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Resist-decorated bowl, La Selva Period,Caribbean Costa Rica

AD 700-1100

Page 23: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Gold Disk, Sitio Conte, PanamaAD 700-900

Page 24: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Gold Helmet, Sitio Conte, Costa Rica, ca. AD 700-900

Page 25: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Gold ornament, Sitio Conte, PanamaPeabody Museum, Harvard UniversityDimensions: 27 x 30 x 0.2 cmPeabody Number: 30-49-20/C11036

Page 26: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Macaracas Group, Central PanamaAD 800-1000

Gold Disk, Sitio Conte, Central PanamaAD 700-900

Page 27: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Altiplano Polychrome, Costa RicaMacaracas Polychrome, Panama

Page 28: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Macaracas Polychrome, Coclé, Panama Mora Polychrome: Chircot VarietyAgua Caliente de Cartago, Costa Rica

Page 29: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Macaracas Polychrome, Coclé, PanamaMora Polychrome: Chircot Variety

Agua Caliente de Cartago, Costa Rica

Page 30: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 31: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 32: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 33: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 34: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Altiplano Polychrome, Guanacaste, Costa Rica

Page 35: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Macaracas Polychrome, Central Panama Altiplano Polychrome, Guanacaste, Costa Rica

Page 36: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Conte Style AD 600-800

Page 37: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Conte Style, Central PanamaAltiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya

Page 38: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Conte Style, Central Panama Altiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya

Page 39: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Altiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya

Page 40: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)
Page 41: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Conte Group, Central PanamaAD 700-850

Nicoya Polychrome, Greater Nicoya, Costa RicaAD 800-1350

Page 42: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Late Tonosí Style, AD 400-500 Mora Polychrome: Chircot Variety, Costa Rica, AD 800-1350

Page 43: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Roxana Shiny Maroon, Caribbean Costa RicaAD 400-700

Page 44: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Conte Style AD 600-800

Page 45: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Gold Pectorals, Sitio Conte, Panama, AD 750-950

Page 46: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Altiplano Polychrome, Greater Nicoya

Page 47: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Altiplano Polychrome, Guancaste, Costa Rica

Page 48: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Conte Style, Panama Mora Polychrome: Chircot Variety, Costa Rica

Page 49: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Macaracas Group, Central Panama, AD 800-1000

Page 50: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Coclé Style, Central Panama

Page 51: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Mora Polychrome: Chircot Variety, Guanacaste, Costa RicaAD 800-1350

Page 52: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Regional genetic structure based on mtDNA:

210-1-2

1.5

1.0

0.5

0.0

-0.5

-1.0

I

II

Maya_H

Coreguaje

Kiche_B

Necostla

Vaupes Guaymi

Guatuso_Maleku

Chorotega

Rama

Otomi

Purepecha

Triqui

Wounan

Embera

Ngobe

Kuna

Huetar

Taino Ciboney

Yanomamo1

Kogi

Ijka

Wayuu

Arsario

Cayapa

Shamatari

Kiche_Maya

MixtecYucatec

PoqomchiChorti

Nahua

MDS: Comparative populations (n=24)

Chibchan cluster (red); Green, orange, and symbols (Oto-manguean, Uto-Aztecan, Maya, Tarascan; Blue and symbols (Barbacoan, Chocoan, Yanomami); Open circles (Arawak)

Baldi 2015 (with permission)

Page 53: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Regional genetic structure based on mtDNA:

1.51.00.50.0-0.5-1.0-1.5-2.0

1.0

0.5

0.0

-0.5

-1.0

I

II

KogiIjka

Arsario

Chorotega NgobeGuaymi

Guatuso_M

Rama

Huetar

Kuna

MDS: Chibchan populations

Clusters: 1. Votic, 2. Isthmic (Otomanguean and Votic?), 3. Magdalenic

Baldi 2015 (with permission)

Page 54: Imitating from Memory: Hybrid Vessels and Attempted Replications of Stylistic Elements from Central Panama in the Pre-Hispanic Ceramics of Costa Rica (2015)

Southern GreaterNicoya

Central CaribbeanLowlands

Central Region


Media management in a small polity: Political elites' synchronized calls to regional talk radio and attempted manipulation of public opinion polls. (forthcoming in Political Communication)

Learning to Play Imperfect-Information Games by Imitating an

Impulsivity and clinical symptoms among adolescents with non-suicidal self-injury with or without attempted suicide

Fifty years of attempted biological control of termites – Analysis of a failure

Barroom incident brings attempted murder charge - The

Imitating Critique, or the Problematic Legacy of the Venice School (in The Missed Encounter of Radical Philosophy with Architecture) (2014)

Is conventional agricultural research fit for the purpose of supporting ecological agriculture? A case study of an attempted transition in Sweden

JOHN BAEZ & CHRIS HILLMAN ATTEMPTED TO STIFLE MY BLACK HOLE RESEARCH BY FALSE PROPAGANDA & WITHOUT SHOWING ANY ERROR

The pipeline project: Pre-publication independent replications of a single laboratory’s research pipeline

Imitating modeling of studying by students of a high school course, considering psychological regularities of assimilation and forgetting

Escapes and attempted escapes from corrections in Western

In search of a happy medium in instructional technology research: Issues concerning external validity, media replications, and learner control

ATTEMPTED CRIME: A COMPARATIVE STUDY

Receptors functionalized with chiral aza-crown ether rings. Attempted enantioselective catalysis of a Michael addition reaction

HOW HAVE LOCAL CONTENT REGULATIONS BEEN ATTEMPTED AND WITH WHAT OUTCOMES?

Lawyer sentenced for attempted swindle of ... - DigiFind-It

Counterfeit coinage of the Holy Roman Empire in the 16th century: silvering process and archaeometallurgical replications

ATTEMPTED DEFINITION OF THE KISAPOSTAG CULTURE OF THE EARLY BRONZE AGE IN NORTH-EASTERN SLOVENIA / POSKUS DOLOČITVE KULTURNE SKUPINE KISAPOSTAG V VZHODNI SLOVENIJI

Object Biographies / Project Description Attempted Methods, New Collaborations, and Altered Perspectives

Pro-Opiomelanocortin Gene Variation Related to Alcohol or Drug Dependence: Evidence and Replications Across Family- and Population-based Studies

No effect of 'watching eyes': An attempted replication and

Imitating gestures and manipulating a mannikin—The representation of the human body in ideomotor apraxia

Suicidal behaviour of young immigrant women in the Netherlands. Can we use Durkheim's concept of'fatalistic suicide' to explain their high incidence of attempted suicide?

How to imitate an unknown language? Russians imitating Finnish

[2015 open access] Suicidal journeys: attempted suicide as geographies of intended death

Imitating human playing styles in Super Mario Bros

Psychological and Psychosocial Interventions After Attempted Suicide

Identifying Experimental Incidents in Software Engineering Replications

Eliminating and Solving the Problem of Evil Mani, Manichaeism and the Attempted Refutations of Augustine of Hippo

Search of the Optimum Way of Training: Imitating Modelling on Computer

Therapeutic and nontherapeutic reactions in a group of nurses and doctors in turkey to patients who have attempted suicide

Replications types in experimental disciplines

Local optimality of replications from a minimal -optimal design in regression: A sufficient and quasi-necessary condition

Attempted 2013 Proxy conversion