executive summary of the project - environmental clearance
TRANSCRIPT
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 1
Executive summary of the project
SNN infra power projects private limited, is a SPV set up under the companies act 1956 in
March 2012 by SNN infra a local construction company in Visakhapatnam who are the project
developers along with Korean South Eastern Power company KOSEP to develop a 1320 MW
supercritical thermal power plant in Andhra Pradesh. The latter is a government owned
subsidiary of KEPCO which is the chief generator, transmission and distributing arm of Korean
power sector.
The proposed project would be located in VEMAVARAM village of THONDANGI mandal of East
Godavari district of Andhra Pradesh. A total of 700 acres of land has been identified for the
proposed project and the land is a mix of single crop and dry scrub land.
The proposed project would be based on super critical technology with a capacity of 2*660MW
capacity each. The technology improves the turbine cycle heat rate significantly than sub critical
technology which is prevalent in the country thus increasing savings on the fuel to an extent of
5% and overall plant efficiency using this technology will be 42%.
The project would be based on 70:30 ratio of domestic and imported coal in case of fuel
availability from CIL. However in the event of non availability of domestic coal the project
would be based on 100% imported coal. The total coal quantity required would be around 6
million tones approximately. The ration of domestic and imported coal or solely imported coal
would be decided at a later stage.
Source of water would be sea water and providence of a de-salination plant is proposed to
convert sea water. Mode of fuel transport would be through sea and rail depending on the
logistic advantage.
PRIYA ENERGY CONSULTANTS, a Bangalore based consulting group has done the pre feasibility
study of the proposed site as well as alternative sites for the project.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 2
Promoters and investor background
LOCAL DEVELOPERS:
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED, a company registered under the INDIAN
COMPA NIES ACT 1956 and having its registered office in Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh is a
SPV set up in March 2011 intending to set up a 1320 MW super critical thermal power project
in VEMAVARAM village and THONDANGI mandal of Andhra Pradesh.
In January 2011 KOREAN SOUTH EASTERN POWER (KOSEP), one of the ten subsidiaries of
Korean Power visited India to explore the possibility of setting up a super critical thermal power
project in India. KOSEP had then initiated extensive discussions with its local partner DUCKJIN
GLOBAL INVESTMENT in Korea along with SNN INFRA of India for a proposed plant of 1320 MW
capacity in Andhra Pradesh.
Some of the key milestones over the course of last 16 months among the developers of the
project and KOSEP& SI involve
MOU and CA among SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PVT LIMITED, DUCKJIN GLOBAL
INVESTMENT KOREA and KOSEP KOREA – April 2011
MOU among KOSEP & KEPCO KPS – October 2011
MOU among KOSEP, PTC INDIA & KEPCO KPS- January 2012
Term sheet & binding agreement among SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS, KOSEP,
KEPCOKPS, PTC & DUCKJIN GLOBAL INVESTMENT – JUNE 2013 (proposed date)
In accordance with the discussions SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LTD was established
in March 2011 as per the Indian companies’ act of 1956 as an SPC for the project development
by SNN INFRA, Visakhapatnam.
The SPC would do all the local development works including finalizing the land acquisition for
the project and obtaining all the necessary permits for the project. After all the approvals for
the project are obtained KOSEP would take over the control holding of the project along with its
consortium members of the project.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 3
The main role of the SPC along with DUCKJIN GLOBAL INVESTMENT is to
Identify land for the project
Identify Indian partners for the project
Obtaining MOEF clearance for the project
Clearances for the project
Consultations with the state government of Andhra Pradesh for providing the necessary
infrastructure facilities for the project.
The strategic investor group led by KOSEP, KEPCO KPS & PTC India would take over the project
once all the permitting is done and complete the financial closure.
SNN INFRA is the local developer for this project while DUCKJIN GLOBAL INVESTMENT is the
developer based in South Korea. SNN INFRA is a partnership firm based in Visakhapatnam
primarily into infrastructure and real estate sectors. SNN INFRA is currently involved in a 400
million INR mining contract for DALMIA CEMENTS plant in CUDDAPH district of Andhra Pradesh
and also constructing nearly 50000 SQ.FT of real estate development in Visakhapatnam district
of Andhra Pradesh.
Mr. K.SURENDRANATH is a young entrepreneur with an MBA.MS degree from who is the main
promoter of the company as well as the SPV is currently involved in infrastructure projects as
well as energy project including fossil fuel and renewable projects in India.
The local developers are mainly responsible for land acquisition and obtaining the necessary
permits for power projects. SNN INFRA is currently pursuing development activities for two
projects in Karnataka and one in Andhra Pradesh and also does financing arrangements both
equity and debt depending on the requirements.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 4
Korean South Eastern Power (KOSEP)
KOSEP is one of the 10 subsidiaries of GENCOS established from its parent organization KEPCO
in the republic of South Korea as a part of the re organization plan of the government in 2001.
KOSEP currently has 8199MW under operation of which the major chunk is coal based power
generation. Their operations contribute to nearly 11% of the total power generation in South
Korea.
Overseas operations of KOSEP involve projects in Vietnam and Kazakhstan.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 5
Kazakhstan Balkhash Coal Power Plant
Vietnam Nghi Son II Coal Power Plant
KOSEP currently has 6 power plants under operation in different provinces of the Republic of
South Korea and they include
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 6
KOSEP has excellent track record of construction and operation of thermal power plants in
Korea with high PLF and some of the key figures explaining their capabilities include
Lowest fuel cost rates among all the generating companies in Korea
Highest PLF at an average 77% annually
Superior operating efficiency and market share of 14% with facility share of 12.1%
KEPCO KPS
KEPCO PLANT AND ENGINEERING SERVICES KEPCO KPS is an electric power facility management
company carrying out high quality maintenance works on power generation and transmission
facilities in Korea and various other countries including India. It was established in 1974. SINCE
ITS ESTABLISHMENT the company managed to maintain the best electric power and industrial
facilities both in South Korea as well as abroad in the countries of their operations.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 7
KEPCO KPS has been consistent in its performance both domestic and international from the
date of its commercial operations and ranked top internationally both in high PLF and low
transmission losses.
PTC INDIA
PTC India is one of India’s leading providers of power trading company established in 1999 as
part of Public Private Partnership (PPP) project by the Indian government. It is a pioneer in
implementation of power trading concept in India. Its key services include
Long term PPA agreements with IPP’S
Short term PPA agreements
Power trading on exchanges
Financial services for power projects
Fuel supply to IPP’S
Joint project development with other power producers
Shareholding pattern of PTC India is
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 8
PTC energy (PEL) was established in 2008 as a wholly owned subsidiary of PTC India to
undertake various activities related to the business of power generation, distribution, coal
supply and allied activities.
Some of the key achievements of PTC India include
PTC India has entered into bilateral agreements of more than 15000 MW with IPP’S
2013MW of PPA’s were signed by PTC India in 2011 with distribution companies in
various states of India
PTC India has signed agreement with the Nepal electricity sector for the supply of 150
MW of power from India
Under long term bilateral agreements PTC has been engaged in 3 hydro electric projects
in Bhutan
PEL has entered into agreements with various power producers for supply of 1.76 MT
per annum for 5 years thus entering into coal trading business
PTC is one of the major stake holders in IEX Indian Energy Exchange.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 9
Some of the conventional investments from PTC include
26% equity in 189 MW imported coal based power project in Tamil Nadu - The project is
a merchant power plant and has three units of 63 MW each. The first unit was
commissioned in August 2009. The other units are expected to be commissioned by Mar
2010.
26% equity in the first phase of 270 MW imported coal based power project in Andhra
Pradesh. This is the first of its kind of tolling project in the country in which PTC India Ltd
will be supplying coal to the project and will purchase the power by paying conversion
charges. Financial closure has been achieved. The project is expected to be
commissioned by 2011.
Equity in stage I of 2*660 MW thermal power project in Andhra Pradesh. 70% of coal
required for the project has got the linkage by Ministry of Coal, GOI. Required land for
the project has been already acquired. Financial closure is expected to achieve by Jan
2010. The project is expected to be commissioned by 2012.
Equity in 2*350 MW thermal power project in Orissa. It is a domestic pit-head coal
project, for which the coal linkage has already been obtained. The first unit of IBEUL has
already achieved the financial closure and financial closure for the second unit is in
advanced stages. The first unit of the project is expected to be commissioned by
December 2011 and second unit by March 2012.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 10
Current Indian power sector snapshot
INTRODUCTION
The Indian economy has experienced unprecedented economic growth over the last decade.
Today, India is the ninth largest economy in the world, driven by a real GDP growth of 8.7% in
the last 5 years (7.5% over the last 10 years). In 2010, the real GDP growth of India was 5th
highest in the world, next only to Qatar, Paraguay, Singapore and Taiwan.
Sustained growth in economy comes with growth from all sectors, among which growth in
infrastructure sector is a key requirement for growth in sectors within manufacturing and
services. With in infrastructure, growth in power sector is one of the most important
requirements for sustained growth of a developing economy like India.
“Indian Economy has witnessed rapid growth in the past decade and to sustain a similar growth
trajectory of 9%, power sector needs to grow at-least 8.1 % per annum” - Planning commission.
The present installed power generation capacity in the country as on October 31, 2011 was
182689.62 MW. Thermal power projects of 78545 MW and hydropower projects of 15707 MW
are under construction in the country for likely commissioning during 11th and 12th Plan.
India’s power requirement over the years has largely been dominated by coal based
generation, with close to 55% of the 182 GW of installed capacity being coal based power
plants, accounting for over 80% of the total units generated in the country.
CURRENT MARKET SCENARIO OF THE INDIAN POWER SECTOR
Mismatched demand supply scenario:
The energy availability in the country has increased by 5.6% in 2010-11, while the peak demand
met has increased by 6% in the same period. Despite the increase in availability, India faced an
energy deficit of 8.5% and a peak deficit of 9.8% in 2010-11. It is expected that the energy
deficit and peak deficit will rise to 10% and 13% respectively in 2011-12.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 11
Low Per capita consumption of electricity:
The average per capita consumption of electricity in India is a mere 478 kWh2 (2010),
compared to the world average of 2,300 kWh. This is as per the CIA fact book of 2011-2012.
However according to the UN report on per capita consumption Indian consumption is 770 kWh
in 2010. The other comparable countries, like the other BRIC nations, have significantly higher
per capita consumption compared to India.
The average per-capita consumption has grown steadily at 1.3% CAGR annually over the last 10
years.
The Government of India targets a per capita consumption of 1,000 kWh by 2011-12.
Encouraging policy measures
The policy landscape in India has progressively evolved since Independence and has led to
radical changes in the power sector, especially in terms of competition, private sector
involvement and focus on green energy over the last decade, commencing with the passing of
the Electricity Act 2003.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 12
Till early 1990s’, the power sector was shielded from any private sector involvement; however,
the mounting pressure on Government resources to support capacity additions, repeated
delays encountered by state utilities and the growing demand-supply gap urged the
Government of India to open the power generation sector to private participation along with
country’s globalization policy.
The amendment of Supply Act (1948) in 1991, followed by the enactment of Electricity
Act(2003) and notification of Mega Power Policy(1995), National Tariff Policy (2005), National
Electricity Policy and Integrated Energy Policy have all led to a much liberal power sector, which
then saw active investments from private sector across the value chain.
However, most of the participation by private investors has happened in generation sector,
driven by de-licensing of generation, fiscal incentives for large scale capacity additions and
competitive procurement of power.
The Indian power sector has achieved a lot over the last decade in the areas of policy reforms,
private sector participation in generation and transmission, new manufacturing technology and
capabilities, but there is still much to achieve and a number of challenges to overcome before
the opportunities can be leveraged.
Indian market has evolved over the years as expressed below
Investment in the power sector
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 13
The power sector ranked sixth among the leading sectors of the Indian economy, attracted US$
4.6 billion in Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) since 2000, according to the Ministry of Commerce
and Industry’s Department of Industrial Policy & Promotion (DIPP). FDI in petroleum and
natural gas totaled US$ 2.7 billion for the period, ranking the sector ninth in foreign investment.
The investment climate is very positive in the power sector. Due to the surge in the sector, the
power sector has witnessed higher investment flows than envisaged. The Ministry of Power is
believed to have sent its proposal for addition of 76,000 MW of power capacity in the 12th five-
year plan to the planning commission. The power ministry has set a target for adding 76,000
MW of electricity capacity in the 12th Plan (2012-17) and 93,000 MW in the 13th Five-Year Plan
(2017-2022).
The Working Group on Power for formulation of the 12th Five Year Plan has estimated total
fund requirement of INR 13,72,580 crore for the power sector. During the Twelfth Five Year
Plan, the main sources of financing are commercial banks, public financial institutions,
dedicated infrastructure/power finance institutions, insurance companies, overseas markets,
bilateral/multilateral credit, bond markets and equity markets. In addition, steps have been
taken by Government to make available funds through Credit Enhancement Schemes and
Infrastructure Debt Fund etc.
In order to attract foreign investments in the power sector, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) up
to 100 per cent is permitted under automatic route for projects of electricity generation (except
atomic energy), transmission, distribution and power trading. Major contributing countries to
the FDI equity inflows during this period are France, Mauritius, Singapore, UAE, United
Kingdom, USA and Morocco. US$ 330.99 million of FDI equity has been received from USA in
the power sector during April 2008 to September, 2011.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 14
KEY CHALLENGES FACING INDIAN POWER SECTOR
Securing fuel:
India’s power requirement over the years has largely been dominated by coal based
generation, with close to 55% of the 182 GW of installed capacity being coal based power
plants, accounting for over 80% of the total units generated in the country.
India has a coal production to reserve ratio of 0.94 compared to 2.83 for China, which indicates
that India’s current production, is far less compared to its potential. Hence, it is imminent that
India boosts its coal production.
However, more stringent rules and norms brought about recently by the MoEF over award of
coal blocks have left many developers devoid of coal linkages. Even state Gencos are repeatedly
under pressure due to lack of adequate and timely supply of fuel.
“Country will have a shortfall of coal of 238 MT/ annum by 2016-17, if current scenario
continues...,” - Working Committee Group on coal.
Securing fuel from imported coal market is becoming increasingly costly and uncertain.
The recent change in international markets, most notably among which being the enactment of
the new mining law in Indonesia, has significantly impacted the cost of imported coal for Indian
companies, many of which were relying on supply of coal from this south-east Asian nation.
Recently, both Krishnapatnam and Mundra UMPPs expressed their concern over rising cost of
imported coal, which would make the projects unviable at the tariffs quoted by them. This has
been aggravated by the fact that changes in international law and regulations are not currently
covered under change in law in Indian Power Purchase contracts.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 15
Erratic gas supply for gas based power projects:
The gas supply to power sector has been lower than the requirement over the last 10 years,
although the deficit for gas has reduced from 45% in FY01 to 20% in FY11.
CEA report states that “The total loss of generation in FY10 is 3.24 billion units due to shortage
in gas supply.”
The need to revive confidence in nuclear - based power generation:
The recent calamity in Japan has also lowered the confidence on nuclear fuel as an alternative
to conventional fuels and there seems to exist an apprehension regarding nuclear power, even
as the country intends to supply 25% of the electricity through nuclear power by 2050. Nuclear
power remains important for the country’s energy security and an important means of
protecting against fuel inflation, and must be pursued, but clearly addressing the safety aspects
in design, planning, construction, and periodic monitoring.
Securing land and clearances:
Land is a basic necessity when it comes to pre-requisites for power generation projects. A lot of
projects are either cancelled or delayed due to non-availability of land or difficulties in land
acquisition. Another major hurdle post identification and selection of land is securing the
required clearances. There are a number of clearances required from the MoEF, Ministry of
Aviation, Department of Forests and other government bodies. Past experience indicates that
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 16
there are major hurdles for land acquisition and securing clearances which include the
following:
a. Social reasons like opposition from nearby residents due to concerns over loss of
land, water and pollution;
b. Resettlement and rehabilitation issues;
c. Regulatory delays;
d. Environmental issues like afforestation;
e. State specific issues like unavailability of supporting infrastructure;
f. Financial reasons resulting from rising costs of land.
Issues pertaining to competitive bidding:
Competitive bidding in power generation and transmission is viewed as a major fundamental
change – a move towards a competitive market, which would attract private sector
participation and also help in discovering competitive prices in a largely regulated market. The
typical duration for which companies quote their tariffs in competitive bidding scenario, is 25
years and 35 years for generation and transmission, respectively. The duration is fixed
considering the life of assets and the period within which companies would be able to recover
their costs at reasonable tariffs. The results in competitive bids in the recent past in India
indicate that the tariffs discovered have been in most cases significantly lower than regulated
tariffs.
There are risks associated with projects that, if the bidder does not cover/hedge, would expose
the bidder to a potential downside over a 25/35 year period. The table below is a macro level
risk matrix for generation and transmission:
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 17
Recently, a company undertaking two IPTC projects under competitive bidding has declared its
inability to develop the project at quoted tariffs due escalation in raw material prices. Similar
trends are also seen emerging in power generation, where a number of imported coal based
power projects (including 2 UMPPs) have expressed their inability to deliver power at the
quoted tariffs. This puts a serious dent on the Indian power sector and mechanisms needs to be
put into place, to deal with such default scenarios and parties.
Project execution challenge
The major players in India Power Sector have shown strong operational capabilities but have
fared poorly in project management and execution. A capacity addition of 41,110 MW was
planned in the 10th five year plan period, against which only 21,180 MW was achieved, i.e., an
achievement of merely 51.5% against the set target.
As on 31st March 2011, 41,297 MW of capacity has been added during the 11th Plan against
the revised plan target of 62,374 MW (66%). It is widely expected that the actual realization
would not exceed 50 GW3, during the end of 11th 5 year plan.
In addition to bottlenecks in manufacturing (i.e. BTG and BoP manufacturers); environment
clearances and land acquisition have been the major issues for delay in project execution.
Investment of time, effort and money in developing project planning and project execution
capabilities, streamlining of business processes and adoption of advanced technologies in the
sector would enable the investors overcome such strategic hurdles to a large extent.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 18
Change in regulation in transmission sector
Mid of 2010, CERC issued new regulation on Point of Connection (PoC) method for sharing of
transmission charges of inter-state transmission services in India. Point-of- connection (POC)
scheme of transmission pricing charges the participants a single rate per MW depending on
their point-of- connection.
According to the commercial arrangement proposed under the PoC regime, the CTU would now
be responsible for collection and settle of transmission charges on behalf of all transmission
service providers. This would imply that there would no more be a TSA directly between
transmission service providers and the beneficiaries (DICs). The collections would be disbursed
by the CTU among the transmission service providers on pro-rata basis.
The change in regime is expected to increase the perceived business risk for transmission
sector. Investors would no longer treat transmission as a safe business, if the issues pertaining
to the change in regulation are not addressed.
Competition from International OEM
The strong demand growth in the country has led to increased competition for domestic BTG
industry from OEMs based in China (like Shanghai Electric, Donfang Electric Group and Harbin
Power Equipments), as several private players are opting to import BTG sets from China due to
faster delivery of equipments and lower cost of sourcing. The prices quoted by Chinese
manufacturers are below INR 2 crores/MW compared to price range of INR 2.8-3.2 crores/MW
of domestic OEMs (Infra line Research).
Importing equipment also provide developers opportunity to tap into Export Credit Market for
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 19
equipment financing at extremely competitive rates.
The Mega Power Policy has provided waiver of customs duty on import of supercritical
equipments. In July 2011, to further eradicate difficulties faced by developers on furnishing
“Certificate from Ministry of Power”, Government of India enabled duty-free imports which is
likely to continue till 2012.
KEY OPPORTUNITIES IN THE INDIAN POWER SECTOR
Strong growth in generation capacity led by per capita consumption, urbanization:
Indian power sector has made considerable progress in the last decade and has evolved from a
nascent market to a developing market led by policy reforms and increased private sector
participation. Challenges do exist in the sector, which India has to overcome, to evolve from a
developing market to a matured market. Meanwhile, the gap between what can be achieved
and what is currently present, uncovers a number of possibilities and opportunities for growth.
There is strong growth opportunity in power generation led by exponential growth in economy,
increasing propensity for electricity consumption and urbanization. India has made
considerable progress in building up capability and uncovering opportunities for capacity
additions.
Indian companies have shown a huge interest in power generation and the recent change in
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 20
power procurement landscape towards competitive bidding is expected to drive investments
and efficiency in the sector.
Compared to the 10th five year plan, the capacity additions have increased considerably in 11th
five year plan as India Inc is slowly developing execution capabilities
Investment in clean technology
Close to 55% of the installed capacity in India is coal based, as coal is the most abundant fuel
available domestically. As the demand for electricity grows, the role of coal would remain
undiminished.
Indian coal however has a high ash and mineral content while cleaner imported coal is very
costly. Hence, the focus is on development of clean coal technologies which is of paramount
importance for a country like India.
Currently there are a number of existing technologies like coal beneficiation, coal combustion,
coal conversion, coal gasification and carbon capture.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 21
India has made some progress in implementing super critical, pulverized coal combustion, coal
gasification technologies. Such technology choices would have a long term impact (life of the
plant) and needs to be chosen carefully. More favourable policy initiatives would help
overcome any economic hurdles towards which investors might face.
CONCLUSION
The last decade has seen a sea change in India’s electricity sector, from being 10th largest in the
world to 5th largest now. The industry is moving away from negotiated & guaranteed
arrangements of the past era, to more open market and performance based competition. The
approach now is more pro-investment, although the legacy problems of cross-subsidies, losses,
and rural access remain a challenge. The private sector has emerged as a key player in both
conventional and renewable power, and increasingly in other parts of the business. There is still
a long way to go.
The significant achievements of the power sector all sit atop a distribution business that
depends on subsidies and carries growing uncovered financial losses. The losses are said to
have ballooned to over Rs 1 lakhs crores and could get worse as we import higher proportion of
coal and as global commodity prices rise. The resulting uncovered losses will impact the
consumers and investors unless vigorous distribution reforms are pursued.
An encouraging development is the larger number of private bidders showing interest in
distribution. The recent DF (Distribution Franchisee) tenders have attracted 20 to 30 bidders,
and many bring experience from other industries such as power equipment, construction, and
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 22
telecoms and IT. This helps seed in new technologies and strategies, such as the use of smart
meters, targeting tools and CRM (Customer Relationship Management), shared services,
standardization, multi-skilling, and other techniques that can upgrade management of
distribution businesses. The size of the distribution opportunity is very large; India could easily
have over 50-60 specialist DF companies even at an enhanced size, that will attract more
investment and innovation.
It is important to get back to basics, namely tariff reforms, private participation, and
competition to make the sector attractive to capital flow. In last one decade, bank credit
doubled in share from about 6% to 12% , and many private and state-owned power companies
accessed capital markets. But it is hard to see the investors and lender return in strength
without an improvement in overall credit standing of the power sector. Addressing sector
viability is a must to avoid risk of non-performing assets cascading upstream. The Discoms must
aggressively pursue performance improvement as the new generation capacity coming from
large UMPPs to smaller solar power plants, can be both a boon (with improved supply and
additional revenue) and a bane (worsening financial losses leading into a liquidity crunch)
depending on how effectively the losses on every kWh sold are reduced.
The spotlight is as much on sector regulation as financial viability of licensees. The sector is
impacted with several years of not revising tariffs, even to cover genuine and reasonable cost
increases. To avoid lumpy hikes and inter-generational conflicts, there is a need to significantly
improve the multi-year tariff methodology to incorporate costs in time, say on quarterly and
annual basis.
Given our energy mix, and fast growing demand, we need to equally pay attention to the
challenges of climate change. The energy efficiency initiatives introduced by the BEE (Bureau of
Energy Efficiency) and others are necessary to reduce our energy intensity, but for them to bear
fruit, we also need to redesign tariff structures to be cost reflective. The REC mechanism is a
major step forward to bring renewable energy into market pricing, in a way that helps move
away from administrative feed-in tariffs, but the REC market cannot form if the RPO (renewable
procurement obligation) is not mandatory.
A closure can now be drawn on industry restructuring with unbundling nearly concluded.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 23
However, there remains considerable work in enhancing the capabilities and systems of these
new companies and in preparing the STUs (State Transmission Unit) to act independently. The
regulatory process for open access approvals also needs streamlining and made more
transparent to promote competition. There is a good case for pursuing open access and
competition for the long-term economic gain in investment, employment, better supply and
lower tariffs.
Energy security is a significant challenge for future as coal based power plants fuel about
80% of power generation today and increasingly coal is imported. The regional electricity
market integration initiated with Nepal, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka and the strengthening of
Bhutan relationship through the umbrella agreement are important for regional energy
security. Hybrid technologies can also help such as use of concentrated solar power to pre-heat
at power plants to save on coal and transport costs, which will only become costlier over time.
The interest in power sector has spurred a rush for resources viz. wind zones, coal blocks and
hydro sites; and those owning these resources discovered tendering them a good way to raise
funds, in form of upfront premium, in-kind royalty payments over the term, etc. The challenge
is to ensure that these do not end up in a race to corner scarce resources but translate into
producing assets.
The power sector plays a key role in industrialization and urbanization of India and faces
challenges in absorbing high cost of inputs. It plays a socially responsible role in bridging rural-
urban disparities by improving provision of affordable commercial energy access. These are
important goals, and will help improve living standards of a billion people directly and
indirectly, but will clearly need support and collaborative working of all the stakeholders.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 24
Andhra Pradesh electricity scenario
In 1999, the first phases of electricity reforms were initiated in Andhra Pradesh, with
unbundling of the erstwhile AP State Electricity Board (APSEB) into APTRANSCO and APGENCO
in Feb1999. APTRANSCO was further restructured into APTRANSCO managing the transmission
system, and four distribution companies.
Current market scenario of Andhra Pradesh electricity market are highlighted below
Andhra Pradesh has a total thermal installed capacity of 10,797 MW, out of which state
generation utility AP Genco owns over 3,800 MW.
Majority of the 3,734 MW hydro capacity is owned by AP Genco.
Total renewable capacity for the state stands at 870.5 MW.
The CAGR of Domestic & Non-Domestic Consumer has increased by 10.9% & 30.4%
respectively (FY08-10).
The CAGR of agricultural consumer has increased by 9.8% (FY08-10).
The CAGR of industrial HT & LT consumer has increased by 6.7% and 0.2% respectively
Andhra Pradesh had peak and energy deficits of 12.5% and 6.4% in FY12 (till Dec).
Peak and Energy deficits in Andhra Pradesh were at their highest in FY07 and FY09 at
15.4% and 6.8% respectively
Peak and energy deficits for FY11 stood at 6.3% and 3.2% respectively
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 25
Need for the project
POWER CRISIS IN ANDHRA PRADESH:
Andhra Pradesh is facing sever power crisis over the last year and half due to increased demand
as also various other reasons. Some of the key findings with regards to the worsening electricity
situation in Andhra Pradesh are explained below
According to APTRANSCO the total demand in the first quarter of 2012 was 261MU per
day while the DISCOMS were able to supply only 245MU per day.
The total demand from April 2011 to February 2012 was 81,320 MU as against 71,301
MU registering a 14% rise in demand.
The average deficit of power this year has been 6.2% in spite of addition of 5311MW
over the last seven years.
Of the nine gas based projects in the state with a combined capacity of 2772 MW only
1272 MW is in generation due to lack of availability of gas.
The Singereni strike last year also added to the woes of the power crisis in the state.
The hydel generation in the state also has decreased from 7048MU to 5837 MU. Severe
transmission corridor constraints also lead to lesser availability of power from the NE
grid.
In the industrial sector 12 days in a month have been declared as power holidays for
SME as well as large scale industries in the state thereby explaining the deteriorating
situation.
Andhra Pradesh state government has recently hiked charges of power to consumers to
overcome financial burdens of the DISCOMS. The state government has recently proposed to
increase tariffs by a minimum of 20% starting April 2013 to overcome the financial burden.
According to recent estimates the state government would need 49,189 INR crores to supply 1
trillion unites of power in the current year but the current recoveries using the DISCOMS is only
around 31,000 INR crores. Of the state deficit around 6000 INR crores would be given to
DISCOMS by the state government and the balance would be through increase in power tariffs.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 26
Over the last year the hikes in power tariffs have been more than thrice in the state.
ADVANTAGES OF THE PROJECT PROPONENTS AND INVESTORS
Operational capabilities of the SI group: The strategic investor group led by KOSEP has
exceptional operational capabilities in the thermal power sector. KOSEP has two major
plants with each operating capacity of over 3000MW capacity and their PLF on average
is more than 90% in the last few years. KEPCO KPS has immense experience in O&M of
virtually every type of fuel in the power sector while PTC India is India’s first company
completely concentrating on power sale. Thus all the three factors together give
exceptional advantage to the project over the others for successful running.
Experience of the group: KOSEP, KEPC KPS and PTC have immense capacity and
experience of successfully managing thermal power plants. Unlike even big Indian firms
like RELIANCE POWER or LANCO INFRA or JSPL which are either in the starting stage or
have minimal capacity running till now KOSEP and the SI group have vast experience like
NTPC and with its vast experience, technology and financial capabilities could prove
more successful in operating projects in India.Though the market has many players in
the sector very few of them actually have the capacity to materialize the projects
planned like KOSEP, KPS & PTC.
Excellent opportunity in the sector: Indian economy is growing at a pace which is second
only to China and thus any company in any sector would see India as a boon for their
project because of huge scope of development. Indian infrastructure requires a lot of
investment and expertise from foreign participants like KOSEP with technical knowhow
knowledge. A large deficiency of power in India and lack of meeting targets over the last
few plans provide the project and its SI’s a valuable opportunity to make its footprint
into Indian power sector.
Availability of coal at competitive prices: Over the last few Indian power sector has been
facing extreme hardships for running due to high cost of imported coal and non
availability of domestic coal. KOSEP has long term relationship with SAMTAN mining
corporation of Korea which has 49% stake in one of the largest mines in Indonesia
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 27
KIDECO MINES. KOSEP imports coal from the mines at approximately 10% cheaper price
than others thus becoming more competitive in the Indian power sector.
Availability of the land: The land for the project has no rehabilitation issues and also not
environmental sensitive thus making the project more realistic of coming to production.
The toughest part in starting a power project is land and the land identified for the
project would be ideal due to its coastal region, lack of forest, human inhabitance in the
site and also supportive villagers for industrial development.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 28
General features of the project
Location: Vemavaram village, Thondangi Mandal, East Godavari district, Andhra Pradesh
Extent of land: 700 acres
Land classification: 500 acres single crop land and 200 dry scrub land
Seismic zone of the site: Zone number 2 as per IS 1983
Wildlife sanctuaries and reserve areas in the surrounding areas: none
Rehabilitation issues for the project: none
Land ownership: private lands held by large families
HTL: As per the CRZ coastal regulatory zone rules of coastline the land does not come
under the 500 meters of the High tide line.
Price of the land: Ranging from 600000-1300000 per acre
Surrounding villages: Pydikonda, Vemavaram
Fishing village: None
Interstate borders: none
Railway station: 7 km from the site
Jetty construction feasibility: yes, sea draft I around 15 mts which is ideal for
construction of jetty
Defense areas: None
Archeological important areas: None
Estuaries, water bodies and ecological sensitive areas: None
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 29
Location of the project
The project is proposed in Vemavaram village of Thondangi Mandal of East Godavari district of
Andhra Pradesh. The village is located 15 Km from nearest town Tuni and 40 Km from district
headquarters Kakinada. Apart from the village other nearest village is Pydikonda village which is
around 3 km from the site.
Google co-ordinates of the site:
17.2671 N 82.5054 E
17.2617 N 82.4973 E
17.2481 N 82.5100 E
17.2600 N 82.5162 E
There are two villages namely VEMAVARAM and PYDIKONDA near the proposed site.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 30
Village record of Vemavaram village as per NRSA RECORDS
Village record of Pydikonda village as per NRSA RECORDS
The nearest town is Tuni which is around 15 KM from the site. The town has a total population
of 50,217 while Kakinada is the second major town and headquarters of the district and has a
population of over 400,000.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 31
Land requirement for the project
The extent of land required for two units of 660 MW supercritical plants is as follows:
A total of 700 acres of land has been identified for the project which includes crop and dry scrub land.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 32
Ecological aspects of the proposed project
The site is located 1.8 KM from the sea from and there are no creeks or estuaries near the site.
The site meets the condition of HFL 500 MTS distance however since laying of pipeline for sea
water is required, permissions from the state government and APCZMA is required. The
National Institute of Oceanography NIO does the demarcation of CRZ line for construction.
There is a small pond of 8-10 acres near the size which is an artificial one made by farmers for
harvesting rainwater for cultivation. The pond has been left out from the plant site.
Abandoned aqua ponds are present nearly 2 KM from the site.
The nearest water reservoir is Pampa water reservoir which is around 11 km from the proposed
site.
There are no reserve forest, wildlife sanctuaries or parks anywhere near the surrounding 15 Km
radius.
Jagnnadhapuram reserve forest is around 9 KM from the proposed site while Coringa wildlife
sanctuary is around 50 KM aerial distance from the proposed site.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 33
Accessibility to the site
Accessibility of the site:
Road accessibility
The proposed site is around 7.4 KM from the national highway NH-5. Near to the site a
few meters away a 40 feet village road exists which connects the highway to the site.
Another 40 feet road connecting the site to Kakinada also exists. Both of the roads are
pretty big enough for transportation of construction material as well as heavy duty
equipment.
Railway accessibility
The proposed site is around 6.3 KM from the nearest railway line and the nearest
railway line is HAMSAVARAM railway station. PYDIKONDA village is the only village
which exists in between for railway sidings which could be laid parallel to the panchayat
roads however a detailed report by consultants like RITES etc.
Sea connectivity: Bay of Bengal is around 1.8 KM from the proposed site. Land exists for
construction of a jetty however a 40 feet road connecting TUNI and KAKINADA in
between therefore connecting jetty with the plant through a conveyor needs to be
taken into account.
Air connectivity: the nearest airport is Visakhapatnam airport which is around 110 KM
from the proposed site.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 34
PCPIR REGION:
One of the key advantages of the proposed site is the fact that the site exists between the
PCPIR region which is proposed by the state government and developed already by APIIC which
is the nodal agency for infrastructure development of the state.
Once the PCPIR region is fully developed the logistic connectivity for the proposed project
would be greatly enhanced.
The total area notified for the PCPIR is aroung 605 square kilometers with 5 SEZ coming up. The
major players already in the PCPIR include HPCL, Hetero drugs, GMR industries, Nagarjuna
fertilizers, LG polymers etc which entail total investments of over 75 billion USD over next 5
years.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 35
Proposed PCPIR and project site
Road connectivity: the proposed site comes in the PCPIR zone and is hardly 1.5 KM away from
the proposed extension of 138 KM PCPIR expressway which would connect the site to
GANGAVARAM and KAKINADA.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 36
Railway connectivity: apart from the existing railway connectivity near HAMSAVARAM the
PCPIR project entails construction of SCR south central railways trunk lane which would be
nearly 5 km distance from site and also a railway freight station as well as logistic hub is
proposed by SCR railways already which would then provide good connectivity for the plant for
fuel transportation.
Airport connectivity:
Apart from the current airport in Visakhapatnam PCPIR entails construction of new airports
including cargo airport near Kakinada and up gradation of Rajahmundry airport.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 37
Key advantages of the project to the thermal plant would be
Enhanced logistic connectivity
Construction water for industrial activity in the proposed region has already been
developed at 525 crore INR thus supply of construction water wouldn’t be a problem. A
total of 10TMC of water is available from river Godavari for industrial activity.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 38
Technical issues of the project
Fuel
The proposed project would use steam coal as fuel for the project. The project is proposed to
use either 70:30 domestic to imported coal or 100% imported coal from Indonesia incase of
lack of availability of coal in India. Typically the Indian coal allocated for the power plant has
less calorific value and high ash content when compared to imported coal which has
comparatively higher GCV and less ash content. CEA have stipulated that all coastal power
projects will be allocated upto a maximum of only 70%. In the present scenario, obtaining coal
allocation from the Ministry of Coal is very difficult considering the coal shortage in the country
and the maximum allocation that can be expected could be only 30%. Therefore the major coal
source for the propose project could be only Imported coal. Therefore Imported coal is
considered for computing the area requirement for the proposed plant. The area requirement
for ash pond will be comparatively less with Imported coal and the report considers 100% ash
utilization from the 4th year of operation in line with MoEF regulations. The coal that is
considered is a typical sub-bituminous Indonesian coal that is presently adopted for many
projects considering the cost effectiveness. The GCV and ash content considered for computing
are 4200 Kcal/kg and 12% respectively.
Fuel transportation;
Coal will be received either in the nearest Port or in a captive jetty constructed for the project.
The available transportation modes for the site are by Railways and by Conveyors from coal
receiving point. The nearest Port being Kakinada port at about 30 km from the project site,
establishment of a coal conveyor system from the Port to plant site will not feasible. However
coal can bev conveyed by rail from the Port to the nearest Railway station Hamsavaram which
are at about 6.5 kms from the site area. From the station to the site area, a new railway line has
to be laid out for about 9 km to the site area and this requires a separate study by a railway
consultant for exploring the possibility of providing new line/ railway siding considering the
availability of corridor, traffic density etc. Another aspect to be considered in case of utilization
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 39
of existing Ports is that the capacity of the existing ports for the proposed additional capacity
and their willingness to include additional traffic and the commercial terms associated with it.
This needs discussions with the respective Ports for a complete assessment and finalization.
Coal handling system:
In crusher house the coal will be screened and crushed. Crushed coal will be conveyed to the
Steam Generator (SG) bunkers / stored in stockpile. Crushed coal from the stockyard will be
reclaimed and conveyed, to the SG bunkers through belt conveyors as when required.
The system will comprise the following:
a. Unloading System, Crushing and Bunker Feeding System
b. Stacking, Reclaiming and Bunker Feeding System
Water requirement for the project:
Water requirement for the proposed 1320 MW power plant will be in the order of about 12500
m³/h with natural draft cooling tower (NDCT). The required water will be drawn from the Bay of
Bengal near the coal jetty. The intake pipe line can be routed along the conveyor system. Water
for ash slurry / bottom ash system has to be utilized from CT Blow down system. Plant water
requirements can be met by dedicated desalination system. Construction water requirement
for the plant will be about 750 m3 per day during peak construction period. The same can be
met from ground water / local water authorities.
Power evacuation:
Technical requirements of power evacuation from the proposed power plant will be decided by
the grid authority. The power delivery point will be firmed up based on the transmission study
by grid authority. The total power generated by the power plant will be 1320MW. After
meeting the auxiliary power consumption of 6% which is 79.2 MW, 1240.8 MW will be available
for export. Generated power will be stepped up to 400kV level by using step up generator
transformers. To enable power evacuation, a 400kV outdoor air insulated switchyard with one
and half breaker arrangement will be provided.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 40
Stack height requirement:
Sulphur dioxide levels are controlled by dispersing the pollutant to atmosphere through a tall
stack.
The minimum stack height to be maintained to keep the sulphur dioxide level in the ambient
within the air quality standards, as furnished below:
S.NO GENERATION CAPACITY STACK HEIGHT
1 Less than 200 MW H=14(Q)0.3
2 Between 200-500MW 220 MT
3 More than 500 MW 275 MT
Where,
Q = Sulphur dioxide emission rate in kg/h
H = Stack height in metres
With this, the stack height for the 660 MW units under consideration will be 275 metres. Since
two 660 MW units are considered, there will be single chimney with bi-flue arrangement.
Cooling water system:
The cooling water system will comprise of Natural draft cooling towers having capacity of about
80000 m3/hr with cooling tower basin, circulating water (CW) pumps and circulating water
piping. For each unit independent CW pumps with a capacity of 50% each will be employed for
pumping water to condenser. The CW pumps will be located in a circulating water pump sump
which will receive cooled return water from the cooling tower basin through open channel. The
CW pumps shall circulate the cooling water through the condenser, extracting heat therein and
return the hot water back to the cooling tower through C.W. pipe/ducts. The capacity of each
CW pump will be 40000 m3/hr. The CW pumps for both the units will be 4 nos. working (2 for
each unit) and a common standby.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 41
Ash handling system:
a. Bottom Ash Removal System will consist of a refractory lined W-shaped, water
impounded, storage type, water-cooled bottom ash hopper located directly below the
bottom water wall header of boiler. Bottom ash (BA) will be collected continuously. BA
hopper will be provided with clinker grinders to limit the size of clinkers. Bottom ash and
economiser ash slurry will be collected in the hydrobin and further disposed by the
trucks. In emergency case, i.e. non-availability of ash utilization, bottom ash slurry will
be diverted ash slurry sump and further to ash pond.
b. Fly ash collected in Air pre-heater hoppers and ESP hoppers will be evacuated by
vacuum cum pressure conveying system. Fly ash can be disposed off in dry mode
through buffer hopper. The dry fly ash collected in fly ash silos will be transported using
trucks. In case of emergency, during non-availability of fly ash utilization, fly ash will be
disposed in wet mode through collector tank and disposed to ash pond through slurry
pump.
c. Ash pond: For estimating the area required for ash pond, fly ash utilization and bottom
ash utilization are considered as per MoEF regulations. For ash handling system, blow
down water from Cooling Tower will be utilized. Dry ash from the silos will be loaded to
trucks for utilization purpose.
Switchyard:
Land requirement for switchyard depends on type of scheme, voltage level and number of bays.
The area requirement varies for 1-½ breaker scheme (D-type), 1-½ breaker scheme (Itype) and
2 main & transfer bus. Land requirement further gets reduced if Gas Insulated Switchgear
Switchyard (GIS) is used over Air Insulated Switchgear Switchyard. GIS option is generally
adopted in coastal areas or in areas where there is acute shortage of land. However a 400kV
outdoor air insulated substation is assumed for the current land requirement study although
GIS may also be selected for the 400 kV level.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 42
Site analysis
The project is proposed in Vemavaram village of Thondangi Mandal of East Godavari district of
Andhra Pradesh. The village is located 15 Km from nearest town Tuni and 40 Km from district
headquarters Kakinada. Apart from the village other nearest village is Pydikonda village which is
around 3 km from the site. The site is a combination of single crop agriculture land and barren
scrub.
Soil analysis: the proposed site soil has been analyzed basically from 3 different locations and it
has been inferred that the soil is sandy clay, silt soils and partly loamy soils. Most of the
agriculture land is single crop land and a waste land of around 200 acres with dry scrub is also
part of the land.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 43
The wastelands include dry scrub land as per NRSA National Remote Sensing Authority records
and an extent of 200 acres is this type.
The soil slope is very less or flat which indicates no much filling required for the site. The slope
of the proposed site is estimated to be around 0-3% which is nearly level to slight slope. Thus
construction of the plant may be considerable easy for the site.
Mean sea level of the site: As per GPS data identified among 4 corners of the site the Average
Mean Sea Level has been estimated to be between 5-15 metres.
DRY SCRUB
WASTELANDS
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 45
Land use land cover mapping: though a detailed land use land cover mapping would be done at
a later stage primary data for 2011-2012 as per NRSA indicates that the proposed site involves
single crop land and dense scrub.
Andhra Pradesh land use land cover map 2008:
Detailed site land use land cover map 250K resolution for 2011-12
Project site
Project site
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 46
Seismicity and meteorology of the site
CLASSIFICATION OF INDIAN EARTHQUAKE REGIONS
The Indian subcontinent has a history of devastating earthquakes. The major reason for the
high frequency and intensity of the earthquakes is that the Indian plate is driving into Asia at a
rate of approximately 47 mm/year. Geographical statistics of India show that almost 54% of the
land is vulnerable to earthquakes.
The latest version of seismic zoning map of India given in the earthquake resistant design code
of India [IS 1893 (Part 1) 2002] assigns four levels of seismicity for India in terms of zone factors.
In other words, the earthquake zoning map of India divides India into 4 seismic zones (Zone 2,
3, 4 and 5) unlike its previous version which consisted of five or six zones for the country.
According to the present zoning map, Zone 5 expects the highest level of seismicity whereas
Zone 2 is associated with the lowest level of seismicity.
The MSK (Medvedev-Sponheuer-Karnik) intensity broadly associated with the various seismic
zones is VI (or less), VII, VIII and IX (and above) for Zones 2, 3, 4 and 5, respectively,
corresponding to Maximum Considered Earthquake(MCE).
ZONE 2: This region is liable to MSK VI or less and is classified as the Low Damage Risk Zone.
The IS code assigns zone factor of 0.10 (maximum horizontal acceleration that can be
experienced by a structure in this zone is 10% of gravitational acceleration) for Zone 2.
ZONE 3: The Andaman and Nicobar Islands, parts of Kashmir, Western Himalayas fall under this
zone. This zone is classified as Moderate Damage Risk Zone which is liable to MSK VII. The IS
code assigns zone factor of 0.16 for Zone 3.
ZONE 4: This zone is called the High Damage Risk Zone and covers areas liable to MSK VIII. The
IS code assigns zone factor of 0.24 for Zone 4. The Indo-Gangetic basin and the capital of the
country (Delhi), Jammu and Kashmir fall in Zone 4. In Maharashtra Patan area(Koyananager)
also in zone 4. but East Delhi is an earthquake prone area.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 47
ZONE 5: Zone 5 covers the areas with the highest risks zone that suffers earthquakes of
intensity MSK IX or greater. The IS code assigns zone factor of 0.36 for Zone 5. Structural
designers use this factor for earthquake resistant design of structures in Zone 5. It is referred to
as the Very High Damage Risk Zone. The state of Kashmir,the western and centralHimalayas,
the North-East Indian region and the Rann of Kutch fall in this zone.
INDIAN SEISMICITY MAP FROM IMD:
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 48
EARTHQUAKE HISTORY IN INDIA FROM 1813-2011
Significant earthquakes in India from the last 200 years as per the meteorological department
of India is given below:
All the earthquakes with magnitude of over 6 are given in the above map.
SNO LOCATION AND YEAR MAGNITUDE
1 KANGNA , HIMACHAL PRADESH, 1905 APRIL 4 8
2 KINNAUR, HIMACHAL PRADESH, 1975 JANUARY 19 6.2
3 UTTARKASHI, UTTARAKHAND, 1990 OCTOBER 20 6.6
4 CHAMOILI, UTTARAKHAND 1999 MARCH 29 6.8
5 KUTCH, GUJARAT, 1819 8
6 BHUJ, GUJARAT, 2001 JANUARY 26 7.7
7 BHUJ, GUJARAT 2001 JANUARY 27 8
8 JABALPUR, MAHARASTR, 1999 MAY22 6
9 BIHAR NEPAL BORDER, 1988 AUG 22 6.4
10 BIHAR NEPAL BORDER, 1988 AUG 22 6.4
11 SIKKIM NEPAL BORDER, 2011 SEP 18 6.9
12 DHUBRIL, ASSAM, 1930 JULY 02 7.1
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 49
13 SHILLONG PLATEAU, 1897 JUNE 12 8.7
14 SRIMANGAL, ASSAM 1918 JULY 8 7.6
15 CACHAR, ASSAM, 1869 JANUARY 10 7.5
16 ASSAM, 1943 OCTOBER 23 7.2
17 ARUNACHAL PRADESH CHINA BORDER, 1915 AUG 15 8.5
18 MANIPUR CAMBODIA BORDER, 1988 AUG 6 6.6
19 KOYNA, MAHARASTRA, 1967 DEC10 6.5
20 LATHUR, MAHARASTRA, 1993 SEPT 30 6.3
EARTHQUAKE HISTORY IN ANDHRA PRADESH AND SEISMICITY MAPPING
The revised map of seismic zones in Andhra Pradesh has identified Ongole area as the most
earthquake-prone in this part of the country, instead of the Bhadrachalam belt as was believed
earlier.
While India is divided into five seismic zones depending on the degree of their vulnerability, the
entire north from the Himalayas down to Koyna in Maharashtra, barring a few patches, are
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 50
rated as susceptible to quakes with a very high damage risk and accordingly listed in Zone V and
IV.
Andhra Pradesh lies on the Peninsular Indian Shield (PSI) long considered as stable and not
vulnerable. The earthquakes of Koyna (1967), Latur (1993) and Jabalpur (1997), however,
demolished this theory, according to the report. Subsequently, a few zones of faults in the
crystal layers of the Peninsular region causing quakes, had been identified, it said.
Many northeast-southwest trending fault-bound basement ridges and depressions traversed by
transverse features like cross-trends have been found, especially in Ongole, Vizianagaram and
other areas. These are likely to cause reactivation with a progressive build up of stress.
The geographical areas of AP fall in Zone I and II where both vulnerability and damage risk is
held low. Ongole area spread over as many as 30 mandals which faced 12 earthquakes in the
past 30 years, including two big ones in 1967 and 1959 with magnitude of 5.4 and 5 on Richter
scale, is held as the most active zone in the State.
Earthquakes in the recent past have occurred along and off the Andhra Pradesh coast and in
regions in the Godavari river valley. Mild tremors have also hit the capital city of Hyderabad
such as in September 2000. In the north, faults associated with the Godavari Graben show
movement during the Holocene epoch. Another NW-SE trending active fault called the Kaddam
Fault runs in a section of the northern Andhra Pradesh and continues in the same direction
towards Bhusawal in north Maharashtra. The other prominent active fault is the Gundlakamma
Fault which trends in a NW-SE direction from near Ongole on the coast running inland in the
same direction for about 100 kilometres. Several smaller faults have been found in the delta
region and along the coast near Vishakhapatnam. However, it must be stated that proximity to
faults does not necessarily translate into a higher hazard as compared to areas located further
away, as damage from earthquakes depends on numerous factors such as subsurface geology
as well as adherence to the building codes.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 51
TECTONICALLY ACTIVE
Eastern Ghats belt and Godavari Valley are found to be tectonically active. A reference is made
to the State's biggest earthquake (5.7) that occurred in Bhadrachalam area of the Godavari
Valley in 1969 when the nearby Kinnerasani reservoir was disturbed. Vizianagaram area of the
Eastern Ghat belt experienced a series of quakes, including one with an intensity of 5.5 in 1917.
SEISMICALLY ACTIVE AREAS
Pinapaka, Gundala, Kothagudem, Manuguru, Yellandu and six other mandals in Khammam
district where Bhadrachalam lies, and 10 mandals in Vizianagaram district, including Garividi
and Nellimerla, are listed as seismically very active.
In Hyderabad, Jubilee Hills and Banjara Hills are included in this category along with the
neighbouring areas of Medchal, Shamirpet, Shankarpalli, Serilingampalli, Rajendernagar and
Moinabad.
CONCLUSION:
The proposed project site comes in the border of Visakhapatnam and East godavari districts and
as per the Indian earthquake zone it is under zone 2 which implies the probability of an
earthquake in the surrounding regions are least thereby concluding the safety of the project.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 52
Alternative site analysis
Alternative site 1:
The first alternative site taken into consideration was 1200 acres of land near Gunupudi village,
Nakkapalli mandal of Visakhapatnam district.
The proposed site is around 1 KM from the sea. This site is fairly flat and predominantly barren
land and abandoned aquaculture lands. About 300 acres is Government land and the balance is
private land. The Vijayawada - Visakhapatnam railway line is about 9.0 KM from the site. Bay of
Bengal coast is about 2.0 KM from the site. NH5 is about 8km from the Project site. As such, this
site is selected for the proposed Coal Based Thermal Power Project.
However it has been identified that the site has the following issues
The site has been observed to have a large low lying tract of land of around 120 acres
which would get completely filled with water during rainy season.
Brackish waste has also been seen on the topo map
A water channel is passing through the land and ends in the low lying area
The site is pretty close to the new defense installation to be set up by Indian navy
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 53
Toposheet of the site
Alternative site 2:
A second alternative site was studied near Hamsavaram village in East godavari district of
Andhra Pradesh . the co-ordinates for the site are Latitude :17°18’43.05N,Longitude:
82°28’49.27E About 700-800 acres of land was identified near Hamsavaram village. The
Vijayawada – Visakhapatnam railway line is at a distance of 500 m and the National Highway is
about 1 km. The sea is at a distance of 10 km from the proposed site. Adequate land was not
available after complying with site criteria of minimum distance of 500 m from the railway line.
The erection of water pipeline crossing the railway line and National high is very difficult. Hence
this site is not considered for the development of the project.
SNN INFRA POWER PROJECTS PRIVATE LIMITED 55
Rehabilitation and resettlement R&R issues, Employment
generation
The project does not involve any resettlement and rehabilitation issues. A small temple exists in
the site which would not be disturbed. The industrial activity of the proposed project coupled
with the ancillary facilities /industries, would contribute to the overall socio-economic
development of the region.
Some of the direct benefits to the state and national exchequer include
Power Tariff
• Excise Duty
• State Sales Tax or VAT
• Income by way of registration of trucks, payment of road tax and payment of tax
for interstate movements.
• Income by way of transporting clinker /coal / cement / fly ash for railways.
• Income Tax from individual as well as corporate taxes by the Cement Company and Ancillary
units.
• Benefit to local community
Though power projects are highly capital intensive the employment generation would not be in
the proportion to the investment size.
Skilled/Unskilled/semi-skilled manpower related to industrial activities will be drawn locally or
from nearby places. Preference during recruitment will be given to the people of surrounding
areas according to their qualification and experience.