توالد النصوص وإشباع الدلالة: تطبيقا على تفاسير القرآن

53
Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo /ﺗﻮﺍﻟﺪﺍﻟﻨﺼﻮﺻﻮﺇﺷﺒﺎﻋﺎﻟﺪﻻﻟﺔ: ﺗﻄﺒﻴﻘﺎﹰﻋﻠﯩﺘﻔﺴﻴﺮﺍﻟﻘﺮﺁﻥTexts' Generation and the Saturation of Meaning Author(s): ﺳﻴﺰﺍ ﻗﺎﺳﻢ ـ ﺩﺭﺍﺯandCeza Kassem-Draz Source: Alif: Journal of Comparative Poetics, No. 8, Interpretation and Hermeneutics / ﺍﻟﻬﺮﻣﻴﻨﻮﻃﻴﻘﺎ ﻭﺍﻟﺘﺄﻭﻳﻞ(Spring, 1988), pp. 30-81 Published by: Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo and American University in Cairo Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/521559 . Accessed: 21/03/2014 15:55 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. . Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo and American University in Cairo Press and Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Alif: Journal of Comparative Poetics. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Upload: independent

Post on 19-Jan-2023

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo

Texts' Generation and the Saturation of Meaning /توالدالنصوصوإشباعالداللة: تطبيقاًعلىتفسيرالقرآنAuthor(s): سيزا قاسم ـ دراز andCeza Kassem-DrazSource: Alif: Journal of Comparative Poetics, No. 8, Interpretation and Hermeneutics /pp. 30-81 ,(Spring, 1988) الهرمينوطيقا والتأويلPublished by: Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo andAmerican University in Cairo PressStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/521559 .

Accessed: 21/03/2014 15:55

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

.

Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo and American University inCairo Press and Department of English and Comparative Literature, American University in Cairo arecollaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Alif: Journal of Comparative Poetics.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

A1 Ahwani's Memorial Lecture

Texts' Generation and the Saturation of Meaning Ceza Kassem-Draz

If we look at culture as the collective memory that saves all the texts produced by a society? we should think of it not as a static order, but rather as a dynamic mechanism that affects the interaction of the collective memory's confents. One of the major mechanisms of this interaction is intertextuality as a means of text generation: one text is apt to generate an infinite number of texts that are variations on it. The nature of the variations differs, and their relation to the matrix-text, varies from being a distant echo, hardly audible; to a verbatim repetition of tlle matrix: or a counter text.

The most prominent matrix-text, the Quran, is the source of a great number of texts within Islamic culture. This paper explores the relation between this matrix-text and some of its closest emanations, namely the works of the Muslim exegetes. This relation is scrutiriized through a close reading of a sample of the matrix-text and its epiphanies in the exegesis of the Muslim scholars. It studies the ways in which two of the most outstanding interpreters of the Quran, al-Tabari and al-Zamakhshari, have dealt with a specific type of discourse: narrative. Narrative in the Quran, centering mainly on the lives of the Prophets, is elliptic, characterized by its great conciseness and brevity, while on the other hand, the same story recurrently appears in various suras.

Al-Tabari and al-Zamakhshari represent two opposite approaches to the interpretation of the Quran. The former, addressing the wide audience of believers, tends to fill in all the "gaps" left out in the matrix-text, presenting all the different interpretations, exhausting all possible meanings of the text; while the latter, who is turned towards an elite of learned and specialized listeners, keeps to the letter of the text, and leaves the unsaid unsaid. One could say that al-Tabari is oriented towards the listener and tries to clarify the text as much as possible, while al-Zamakhshari focuses on the speaker, and tries to understand the gist and dense complexity of the morale and thrust of the message.

Turning to a specific example of the Quranic narrative, the writer of the article studies the story of Job in the Quran and the way in which each scholar "rewrote" it in his exegesis. Al-Tabari in his attempt to satisfy the curiosity of the listener, saturates the meaning of the story, unveils all ambiguities, turns to the Old Testament and re-transcribes the Book of Job, but in the process al-Tabari "Islamicizes" Job, presenting a patient sufferer who does not question the equity or justice of God, who knows that he is being tested to prove true faith in his creator. The great revolt of Job and his stature facing God in the storm, in the Old Testamentus absent from al-Tabari's text. The study of intertextuality is broadened then, as the Job of al-Tabari is compared not only to the Job of the Quran, but also to the Old Testament Job. Beside Islamization, al-Tabari "purged" his text from any '4subversive" elements that can be read as anti-establishment; a move that emanates neither from the Quran, nor from Islamic values, but rather conforms to the prevailing Abbasid- establishment, to which he belonged. When we turn to al-Zamakhshari we find a text shaped on the "model" of the matrix, that is succinct, brief and concise. The rhetoric of the matrix- text is his major concern. He seeks to uncover the true intention of the speaker through the mode of the discourse, rather than its content.

It seems, as the writer of the article concludes, that some interpretations that seek to exhaust the meanings of a text, dotting every unsaid "I" and crossing every assumed "T", tend to suffocate the text, closing its openness and eliminating its poignant potential for future experiences that may allow different interpretations and understanding of the original text.

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

: X Jlfyl 49W

: wSs t *aJJ s Ml * b898 )*s^ai 9

-

; t+tiJz S!i- CJ Ji ur J of, g1;Q8vYz °vj a-$ t °

Y <3 Y li I + ; oUl % \J} e3 %°tAV J C ^ s 1v! ¢a Jr ? , 8 r 3; 0l> jWJ; 0s-, * **- ai PX > Oi_l, Wi>; lul bS Q wA e3 ) i! i Lc; i39! 4 iX- #1 o4-LYl s? i,aiL. i:__j_l b.k;!

k L i e J>-} J 9 # Of zis; SA 4J91 ;J*YI ? siwi ou;

Li Ji Ji! ;8.8! a; z d!; - i S u! + 9 i ;)1 < u> Sl

. j3ol o 8n4 e3 i;e i1> S 2 > N 1

,

- voAl Sj oul

9 i S 49 os (8)\ oW\Xs ? _4Ws S_448 o1

s; 4w; oU} oW; 9, . oS o +:il p ao+lJ JljYI y

o ( Ji ) 5:1t ,.fs,JX18 ; S (; >; 9 fipJt, JzjYt u;!

,^YI A1! i Ss,;18 0 9 JJ v JJl lv ,,B1! . M18! JtjYz

Jl jY: o I-j ffi)1 4s%J: s ; lsib 9 e11 !\ ,8 Li ; 11

>8z-9 wE8 sl a l 8-r^;4,; N m i!; A z 3+8 98 Al Ji M es8! sY O f ju! R\+ i 9>! s> s =B

X8 >Yz JS ? ; ov 4> JW M iWllSt a11 w3 J- Y ? ' a al_ JSL S tC i 9 ;j Ot g55! ; 4>> i i tHJ}

rsY' i-io e5i-45=28 JUs )L, a s, A sg, Sj

3! oS a y :); e58 _ JjV;Js JL18 Sif JA 4AJ S YI Q

* S 3! °s J ,^ A; 441 FIS

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

.n 1 wS '3M? -S J X A fl R wz >

:A:ba::av:

u -

X'h .o

-

- I .

*n

b.A -

t

.n

*n

- A

.a -

u -

-

A A ;E

*n .o t - t

) | - l bes z

J l j - - v

-

*} u-n .S

b n uM S

. t As

A 3s

- *

w R' n v - - )

twq j A Q - M - - - + w

uM ER

-

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

? F S v cL A X m! i \l,Xiz 9 zz S

. S ja J S AuS SJ; J 4Jg

< a 91 ts zi i ;gEl z + 51 9 y ; Us ,,Ls . uAl zS1, i US M eDI Y!, i

J< a bS, i +1 a o Ej $1 SS1 z J>, i 4,

YY, ,pUl i,1 1,@11 ob J%-a! o> ° t1>! J

g iAJ i _t, i;e, l > . .-! ; v o>

,5 jJI L-tz , SB, ji 91 i SY i.t: U S z J,YI i 3!

.

* 8>! @e i5 jill! as, U 8 _n, i a M

* JU<El! i F 91! i J21 J SYI st 1 ,p+l os !ti-!

ov i;e i_LL;JI j!> is Y . ! ,,$s1 W Sj a SX

s;L;s I Ma a SS! o ouP a+1 oo !X- W!>!; oW 91 Ou-S! W Xos1a 1 .,^rj .

al; 3 > 1) ov1 )4- sJ . Xl ,pUl J>; << lil ,rLl ,_>J*

as U; J ) 1 ,1; ( lSM 4,,> sS, S;1 sl! S;1 11

* ( \! a ? oSM ?+l ?

i3 o5t;! ; \ \ ,! X silz ,\ tv,18 3! ;8 'i!! Jw u 4-98 o48 o!: u5z aI} 0JWWb ix ,t lLlc wax;; 4,+0v, -; +1 ;< ,,;> Y ,>5 2A1 , d! ,liJl g; * 8 cf a

<,kl / i;>l ag! 1S1 <.X! <+8 _ jl! i )8S1 P yz ' ^-i 9 a;i ;! J! a-;+! i J otb->! 3 5'

a Jw S Js >Jx g!S z ; 4>>! o! >! i kW6 =

s $1A1 #;8 8z s b! ziX1 ! is<Yz-sz ? 51 3 <1 z! Js i 3+; W98 0 jo3> j4 b1 1A:k!;

_aj1 ve-/! * >z jJI o ;rS olJ o;i J >3 W!-> * i\,;1 1 i;,¢ ; > S,l 1! ; o;

(1J;S?)9l-J!l,;s8_ial jlss,+

i 5JI _ lXllLYI S + X )< 8 jS t 1 > 3! -X ZW . 9 A:

9r?S1 )SYI S! v 1!a1 uS e51 >! v ># 8 C1 Sk WAJ v S<Jb *' 1 v;u;! P z5 jJl

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

, S i1 a, i X s191 1 U1 J,- J > ( £ )6p Jl9 J 9 a1 wils 1 -tf tv; 8 q £y Ck J a1 W 1 1921 ob Wt- > Sk fl91 j

> ;< 4^Ai u oJbY es _ a l Y! ) . olJJJI JJ > J ; 1 oUll 1JA11 oiz ,< o oUtj t>j 4 a 4%! 4191 i eto ̂ s Do palJ iLiJ: AIL1 C1 J i 4J! i W;JU2;! +JJ 8 j

i5A1 1 LS-! i ii _91 1 i3 a1 sui A! * O19 a1 ijLlnL O i,+ t -! ( t91 \sd; t;S- - X; >1!

b a1 Wily C Xi_ ,,;1,;1 ,1 InJd Oill i;,+U1 w? o9J_

96! oJ +i ti4! <Zi38 1iz al; 1!; jljUl 9 S ssaU c

i;;ll Oib ;'! i S P i_,1 i;,, 11 i;; ffi ul ,9 9t; t 41 ,8

sx S 8 iWl o ji 3! i ,,11 , , Wj 8 4;> i 1

c . c S

wZ 1- -! e5ill JSl jl! 3! + zz 9 51 . Irs Y<, ov1 us J

< 3! , ' ( 1 ) >1 91, ( jlSl ) >1 9

. J>L: liz ;1,, 9

1 jA J s191v_,4d\1 %u C ji+Y iqll oizl 4Lt ivSJf 9 e i J91 UI °Jfi j!; ?; 19 i $%YI

ra . ,3JZ ) ,5 41 ,- M ;, ;,- z a;, , :il

OrA, ,3F ) >;gjJI J-! Ol91 5 wpJ\; X;+ /u 4ri ( 4J?

. fij.1.JU: fi? d1 9..JJY: OfJ 9..#: 9|f 3-a )u: ( 4 ; a b&_YI AA1 L ,.X LI Y ;N,11 i;CB Gs 1 M!

KJ i Ml-, H P-! E;d1 i;r-> i-; > %YI OYI i z

59 l1 @U1! i _LL'I<YI ? l1 J!YI : W) ,!X- p1 _t1 ,JS 9La ¢Si t;ljS t;;i ZfJ JjEl )YI liz iJI 9 ,1 Cj i X OS 3 JJl ;, XY MF f E;<! i oJlkl . gU1 W as-!; blAl J i 4 w _ Q c Q Q OM! YY" i; ; A^ll 0S!

i j,A,6! i 4Jr1 e dS1 51 _G1 J _- tS1 J >y

._,2,+Yl 42t1 J-%E, .gif s > f; 4!; X+}!; J%ij

* ;S1 - :_.s ? ¢ =j J 3 4*w09 4lg N-i fi

- ov>5 _1J 51 1iz 95o ,Lllil! i ¢! SJI 5wJI ,LJI <81Ju i;? 41)

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

4.e 4i sj ( ° )28! 4-^91 8l 3! o>Yt ' 'Y8, >8 9 - - - - - tS-l .c z;l ilL28 8 Yz i i \ i +1 4 <1 igigj i ( n )J! i * 5 98 S

i rObtlz S.98 -Jyz S3! * tN! J! J<W s g

j vyP y 1 0 S J H S f

;91! s>1 1St L.-j _YYS: ? W os S. UY, s S i alls Ji osl ;JIX J Y,L&51 , + > ;LJYI 1= W! i ,aL ;YCI

. JY

S Ib! i 4. 49o1 4@192l a-l- tv;1 1 Ji 2 .5,1 ,,1 H Mu i o 19 .sY ;< J

Y S1 b >!; yA1 +11 J _yi ,! sA1 uPI U!W! ' 21 SL 1 J s1 _>1! 41S1 1 H

_XLI 1i^ Fa;Y 5991! 5A1 @! - 4p1-zJJyI J CE11 W)

S > - Mi! i dY! 91 oS S > CCuz °b b=n Mi

,15-4J- zJU L9i us 1 SU1 ? < $1 _ - yz

. i_so rtll 4JS

_L)98 olY U!W J @JJI 91 w.M96 il;_ st.U) > O

L8)Z8 zSlStY. - WSaiAs-SlUA

e 9! i .. + wi , ( , ;11 L51 ;=YI! ,§A1 .;S ' s1 _iLI CS!-U1 J , F 1 1 _>91 . ;Ji1 J _ - 1 1 , 1

Ar ssJ Ar ss ;Jk

-U CE;! 8 ; ( isX ) ,,fiX u;* S * ( i59 )l )

? GH ZL!! a5U- s ,- _UiL1 F ii i;,^ i fot> t j J1

:SYcl CS eN _g1 WNe ? 1 A i s1 _1! J91

_291 H °W _Wa- S. $tE; l SJ1 J 9 J > t 2y _ jgl i S _ * .>J 1Jj ov _s1 SJ;S W =. 19

* ,,§Ay1 SA

rO

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

to f -s i5J]: g1 ji oll ob J a**

_O j jl by 1 ) _ sn l ̂ _i 1l _ i * ; SAn\ * sA

t; Dr! i ( 9 9 >11 rll 11 t a:^ i ,21 _,§>,;>t1 \+

J JS ; E > ai ! w jJJ ^ i o u1l H ,r E MYI 8

,, -,, J; ̂ > :,111 0 ziX > aii s ; _l^. - 3! j. X ̂ * t;2! 86. R aJ11 o>

.il:i; ,r18; ojliAl JljY: e ul o4 e ,5J18 _l!siL: zJl;) i allJ 29ll! i *;-Jl! i JI! i >lil v-> ? S>YI 11 .,; 16 ̂..

J zIf N ;JJ; J ? N; - _g1 o iJ . .5z?vL LbY; J

Q!; 83!! * jlvil A; 2>1 a >3 !; a11 ut2! u; af WSs; 1

+ + ja + ;s , _a,+ >3 JljY: . - H! i Uk > i 11^ Jw a li A! _s1! ? t;ik i, S Ki ?

J Li4! W4! . +1 1iz S oLill ,JllJ - YI Y i dllbJ 5,:11 _XLI ib w W3 SkiS i ,I JHi ; JP

JljY W 21 Su1 ;,^; W jE 21 Jl jY 1 S t S >1 W P ji v1 ¢>W: ? <ru1 4Ab!; WrJ WJs ^1^ ji; - 3! 9! ; blSl ;1} J 9 >> 951 ,- J J b-;Y t Jll s 1, t;I wt-- s!911 ? xcJ4 4

i >1 Jr 49 >; 66 ( 4s,?- ct 8 8 ,3s ) w5bS1 i

i ;M1! i O\i - YI! i A1! i X1! i M1: H

Jyl _ - iJ; 4iil JiJ; >S1 JiJ; _1;l,XlJ; SL1! julJ Y OJ . J11 +J; yJ;N:!; 4iiJ1!; 91! =U1!; 1!

A1 jf I3!! i 1 H W tS p1 ZJ191 , t#1 oiz ji 4 - SY a i a u1 @>1 >,i 1 t#1 WX a ,1 Ji + s 1 U1 i iy1 ;t; J! kLL ;s ) 1 o- i

¢>W! i >1 rkJ i >1 , y i S¢YI CEWI , ssi A; >)

* M1 ,< _:.- ji , vHi , ,W1 s ;tU1 JS,- v;! 451 . 47;J1

5 ji 4i9; esua_ as1 _vJ2iL O%,- ip1 JljY: 9 ,! ,k11 si I3!!

j i ' 9+1 - 'S J o 21 c#1 i ;19 sX W

rl

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

\ . \>,2 pl * stlL -k- 1 S- ;! i SS 1 Si

S \\jy oS i1 jo_S\1 Ofl 2! zlLYz ov S > wfW j ,: W jj Xy Sll hAl: 's Hj) z 11 l: ; J {lJ, E Sill ,;l: o+1 , ji W1J; Ij!! J iL- ji->

C S _SS1 i e @1! 18 j!.; Zi S i al {t: {y?

* S-1 ,¢ j; 5ill sl;J\l t83-3f \^z l! bJvk s-is vgl3^; ;>lpt

wH >1 3! 1,> ,i S s1 , .s! s ,> C ,2- , z3!^

t-vot? {W! - \ S f 11! W U1 + J -?s WA -

W A S > ;s w gL u1 1 - s1 - . j -

^,s1 _ut1 ;u! s Y 1u S Di S; v1 J 2 a1

> 2! S Z ; Xcs W- 91 aI Di a Ovrj > L¢!; +¢e ^

tj>W! t191 ( W JaruX a11 ,\ si i au rSx {YP U!) ? xY A!; S ? 1o; At ed- . rrS>k dlljS!; l1 1+

t1 - it5;1t JJI i3 SiS jj- aI ji 3! i Sz ; ? J s

. W A-! .u1 oSz o, ,f2>1 o jA 1 CS j! 3! i 1 1 95; ; 9 SjJ iallt j 8 jf uA 11 ; j! Jfl ji 9 biJ > ;r^; bl A ̂ J&ii ! ULLSi S 3 o1 4j211 oLI jJ9 C- ilisY oz _f fl v i 5J>YI iilJ51 ilisYI ? a F! i ¢< x) ds lAoX 5 iXi;Y: Oib ez y! % - Y i ,i, _g- ji z;.U ;-s%JZ ;r! . o;v$!I iAl /tiAll CYl JvaJ ff _v01

; H91 U1!-91 >91 H b ,- Or Ji1 P! i 59nt1

a1 < j!, +b i;K! ' _S ? J I jr 21 S jY r 9 ( A ) \ SJI! .]jli3sz bX %J;! _J08 fipJi ;;6 e59 jJ

i S 91 >Y' -s ? \ J Sz CA JYI ! Ctwli; e5a;* ? #\ 8 lls \AtiAJ f ? ; dLi- _1J6; 4b e5J; t v j+s ,S,28 jf IjS : _LSyLJZ ¢1; P >l e5 3! ;,54o-

oXllSJ lt)r-- v Ijf 42JI -siLI tlji XZS v jLA;^ Ijf ii>!

ul O!A1 5! Jfl 5Sz .5,UYCI i-, JsYZ 5; J/1 ffi! v SS

95;Jz ;1 iXz sj ? ;w_01 i3 @'S-! $,;1 4e X 4S ou b

ooW yl L4 - jUl Yz OW S o - 1 fl W A w i _tS9^ 2 3 >)JJ ? e5 i SJ ) uS Yl! i Al

JS Y! osiSz ;WJ Q jE ji > Y p1 lS9JI oS 4 jM Lo

rv

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

- t_j-\ A,58 i dy: ? Po tuS! i S: tuS! i ( >1 J liS^

J9l b! 9 6 aJ t! : +!; 8! i zl._XgJ1! 8! iOu\ F!}H o; ory ^ 4.S: oN1 J s\ 91 JU

S f tn s o r; 0 >b > ! _S%\ W} WX Ji Jj UJu! s: z: : \b !

u! ^ J,> a,

_+ i a01 i;¢ ivyj > _L0j j w ,59¢01! 5uX1 * i -,"

9" <! ,bJ ; Wu! ,bJ ; ,z J,> ,;1z 3 iv 8 " zi ; pZ a " IZ oib i3 i)-i;i

Jz Jly a "jZ y 1! @'3! 1 5998! 5As

>? 1! @S1 " 9 ' ?+1 z! >o 1! 0 jYI " b! ' 4.S1 1 ,-1! t_-; ,4 *Z\.-18 (>i tvro.l; ;,4 ;S 1z ! . J1 u;!

- ,L1 tfX L ip1 i ̂J>\ iS fl: i 9 C^" J zi, i W WS1 J 1u,, J ji 91 a, . ;i 1ML s91 "

5, i; - S Sj J H &,; W HEJ A A 191 J J,;", i ,59> ui > 4" 1 4Y J ¢s z ss91 si . " : S Ml J J _

aS- J ¢91 ? 's! z191 J tz + .- 1s ...

J iJI 9 >; 198! Jl>8 v; 5< J<!; ov4JI

iJ ; rUl 1 <J; oJl,;; > 18 Z <:j; W!!; t; bY

. YE i ;;L i aX # A

t. I 8 M

;Z898 ,58 9Ju ;,; ouI \< Ji ; Jj!; + Ji ffi f Ji 441 JF! 3 >8 5A1 >= ;8- ; ° i;r4 448 ZjMi t4 29

JD l;! . als, s 8 ,>1 y ! ; *J;

SYI 441 i3 Jj S W^; b J;l JA I! i oX'lJI oli:JZ " Y

>1 @8 ow; : >8 o1 3! °J8 ° ualrYL e " C\e u> z31>! i 3! 11 0 esJXI ^, 1a < a,)N SX ep "" Ce Uslj e5991 Si * u"'zrYI ° )'

. ilol\! il\! 4XLJI o1 ? =Li 9

rz

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

C *8|: *^,i ,5aSll -__v," 3 jl;Al ,Sar Xl _vU sv$121 1 !

LLi , ;1l Ly z! 4 si1 #W 098 s i w- I J

i A__> , L'Ly z! 4 Jill $;8 i59 J ffi \ ( ' )vx,t1 51, .4uX1 LLi " $51 i ,, oU1 ,, 9'b si

o)22 i juvxl s51 z , i -M E S Ji J! ibrY <! skj! ' $w\1 sA1! ,;Uz sA: H H\: a _ sit Hs 1

(4 W1 ,) 1 l 21 S T S

Jf 521 5,;1 1 ? _,;L PW J 4YI S! 19S, i U1,)1,

: iN- 11 fE? Ji J s i;,f1 I-Y wiJ . ZJIA;I ,^11 ojgAl i3 .k1u

i gi 3 i .18!; J)8! J+lJ ; ieJIJ ,S1 > ,>_;,-,

o\>JI <F* S W! ; k Yj jv

ZA} jil' d! JA- 2 ;$ ot b! ziv- zi!, i ̂ Y8, p W$ti i )t;\ )\ri! ;LliLZ f>! L,<18 Li e.!

?! J;\ <;e °\u98 Jvi ! i e . ,, k ̂ + m, s N S\ \ i;H*S\ O\)Az 98J 5JS * l ? +J -

i i;e o;1 4,^ S Y! Si ? JjO Y i + ,6 8 )o >t;\

g t * il <;< ' Gl ? Lj f 5A1 Ji = y OJ .>F_ Zt g zi ! JH °J- >b- 3! 521 91 3! #L LI ^ - C sr Zi 1 i5! ' Ms!-1; i;? *91 42! ?ub S S

o+JI o 9-; 8 <;< +i38 >; 4;$> ny AicjJ 58 . o;J <;< 5JSJ : Je

; ; us1 lJI a1 Hs1 <;< 21 3 a;8<! -iJ S : J w: ,,z: + .

8^18 Mu

J j$Y i;v M - 8 j h w M>Yf wg S i 1 ! Ax

e5il; g o<Y w)L.! n: tp oulil o bs ;;;; JlWS;l 9> jc - ll

; o 19 w)!! <i aW. ; oS < s, 5iJI ; (z 9SSE\ )) ; 8 e [ t, / 8 1z18 ] . (I i! sr .51 i ,,!,$1 w

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

xy .s ( u: ,, ̂ sa, W , tx9, s ji si a , ou vS s o\S: M > LS Si!; o_ tL) o JA Ji Ji!

3! t>. o! i! "( t+Y' , M J,Y: tu9' ow ° > s' A8 $8 3! ^i oi sa1 ^ 2, - y A s % 91 i;e * ss 1gU 91 1 SN g J - SSYI 94 1, 1 , i J1S1 .s e jwlx sill

i YI, .91 s W W1 3! , ' J1S1 J ;S -t1 YI

@>898 21 cgl J fi 5 gn ts 2; u 0 l; a rkt

oj,;L5Ij i \sI.i- ! t>91 6 ws ; \\ \ ostS sj i <\LSt

Je . ¢LjUl , ,5,X1 ,; jLtl ji tli oA _j, * >\<tl l+ \

D N 2 ov ; a ^ ^. a 5 v g ... Ijs

oWi s - g Ji 2; v Zi Ss Jf; * S211

Y - . v i 3! sj Y, ' jI W Y! ? Ii

9;\ ji .5S JY i 1! 9;\ ^ g^! )L--! ) Y! i t>

SL wki M ' d! Z 9.ij Z 5 8 ! ' d!

L tu)\! z oS 8 i! i {\r °! tu)\ ba 9! ; Ji e 3M _ oXj , w\! i b; gj 9 Z Jf

; d! J<.i Ji 9 0Xs y Y tz, Ji Ji ; bS

* \! Hz i s <;e z Si jY

v l 8 Ou ri

u! 1Sl S Ji sf u ; <? [ Ji! esAt ffi! ; f ' J! 1 W tu)z o* ; 4-.SL A <;< y Js J Hi ̂

esAI M Jj sj <;e e)L ai i,+1 t H li oS aS! i s! s! o\Sz w s. Ji! i \

; wz Y! wJU- + Y 5 i !; L;\ .-v;\ ( A ) i-8o >e .L! ,),!t;J r ) ; J - ,lz L. Y! 4JU P 1! 9N- Y 5 $ ; Uz -J18! ( t )

J i58 t_Lt, P 3 , w ts +s S ? atjz z L1!

_ 2s$L XyZ y s\ S dU v-jZ oo J sUS vi ;; p\ LE 9Ju 8 JuL + 4 a 9 i oo! &\yj

: .SLZ tzjyz o y W

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

2 o! : 4,- 9 Y, J J; S v Y S Je oz Ju zY

" fl > Y! ! ou8! ,8 a. ^,< N * N

Z 0,! 0 jx f -

rv _ rn / fi bLIS Ck

i oPll oo e5-liC.. Y; JXJ1 ? 918 9; S 5 s jjl S

-

91 Y s Y! o;4 N 4, > ouv8 1, J o89 w os f , iL 4|4t; ST ( ! +1! >& Y! cS1 o J! A YJ ' a TJ

Q ol;c ; 16 191 J8<T :,; eys S1J,!is OWc >> S [ 8L ] . [ V / 8 )ss ] . ff >b! ly + mL; > Y ; 11 >

e5j,$,,,2@'S-NjJHt=IjUz>X11o!

: J11 )\rT M > )> s s J\JUZ Z J; 528 JUL

s Ou1 +, @M1 +,) O196 J tj fi >, Y!

<P- > 4;s,!; jT lsc >i;bl 3 !; Z 8 ) LS 1 JV

°_;? A;_\ jC w: u t; -* J W; \WT2t? 2S Hl St- E;2 \> 1 ;)A OT s WI J) rJ s s OW1v11 JeJ1s W;I JV s ! : <>T

8 El {> J -Js s a ;uj JJj; L! O)! LS s aJz l s Si C ofJ w@l s J

+ i WU J!! ;< \; s A: J11R s >Xl;! i;Sl i ; LiS iJV Y, - S 1;A Wa > b!! owil >

>1 6 9 .e k; >1; s t;1 pilll JuL Z J zj

CJus* j!+v!''Sj¢@lj aRs

. Wl?! 1-X3 C!! s > 3!

8 v l 8 Mms

yy1 z ,H1 s; a11 t , ,H1 1+ 5, ; 1 ¢T S

tZ AI ,< 4J> Ol,21 , W S 421 !,>; O$SX &W 1! ;91 X3 )U! s JWl! 1 X3 ;ur ;__S 41 ,,: 0;<LZ - LiL} 195 X3 J<2l! s W .#JI! ¢911 JA ,# S18 s ff SH8!

)L: X3 ,;*All )u11! . 41j8! {a;YI CL! .1; °JA1! s DY! J! ,; S *!T ? 4@1 Q a.l! ';51 4,_v1. ,Z51 z X

£ 8

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

d i t2ti ,\b! t t ,$_,t, t1 _L o Jf 5

Wlu atj j<E >! i 44u1! aLL 5\1 sAI 41:S$ jj 1 ^ t,,\1 ,es z>x; i_6 i5i\1 ,\1 wJj S! zi e > f; 91 !

+> jf 5 1o 4.t > 5991 jf 2 \ i .5l!\S dj! . iilS1! 491

w . jvv paJ Y ou.Sz1! tESl ji a L>i s si1 91 J M ! P! j-! lA- i \y! ¢<JI < , + ,) oSiiJI 0 ,3

D!>3eJe11as. . ,t,,91¢AzF1! lo LL o? Jli ? ow >) s991 W 4 H 8 jul H! sM1 k

> ] J!yl >1 <21 jV! . oW vLYI I vs 91

_* 2 bi >5iu J91 sPi51 w$J!;-+yl P Ji ,=1 + [ sm ! + f 9 jYs ,1D ,3 4YI, US1 F ju i d Y

W * 4. d ,; We + >>LT KYI 1 <# - ( Er )(z q 1 ;;11

>.1 _zJ,i ;! jl jlo oSi 8bS : ol- Jlb ;.rzill 3! uL- >! 1v Ju w3 1 U s bs i ou zzi <; esv l 9 ; > 8 2 # f j1 - j Yl --91 J e s91 jr jl v 11

- J Yl 4 J91 J s jr ss9l j s; ¢@E: v 9u1 !

91 ? _8sYI J f u a! i #: su ! +

;; Si)! i 1i;! s, $ W#YI-lkiLI S JJl; Of 4! bl i s1+z

4wj J 9JjE' J 998 98+ 3' - > ): 4.' jlv

41 + . o >521 @$J sP91 ;L1 jlAl 1 a >! * 9JS1 >- Wa_,, M_Si; ( 8 f )*_s - U vrJJI vslP b! Li ! a o\YI S

lkt >) S (< kSl v- ;lz )) 09 .> > ;1 ;l >-; .-; [ fiH"1+ ] 4>

jl,sl < . t*ve ; <3z <S1 1L! ; ( a,^s e Jv s W! ̂ 91 ;

ouz J! a-t--z ^ ( v 's >) S! ( 1s ,, S- 5 jJ:

_<\1 > Ca bi 3! 9-YYJ 3! , W! ( o^GLll <;M1 )) s; * s ;El W i i kvj jl Hl ? oYl oJlJl Si . l olS 1 SY

z ! o ¢ pl 3 j^ll OiZ ;i S )): >Ii * t-s! ;1 q1 >,! . J<yl

1 3 ! ; a,S1 ,! s191 \1 jm, 9 S! >59 >

t ,>6A1 o Di SLi 9 1? bl J 91-L M C @> f + ! ! . ,;;1 J 4 J ,rl , \ 1 ta;l Ej ol! o .

jlj # ,;r4! ;fir.;.\1 iiJY l;JI lJnil 4g 1 S 4 g\3 _32

£ Y

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

il Ha (Ss )s , # ,> e 91 _L H aa WS SS (8O) sz JA- 1

iH8 412)\ 1! zi ,,5 Z s A' cz! ows 1! 5Az Jf 83!, ' z! o; 1! zi 1! ozYs ' ss9' si ' s8 < >' 9, +' + ' o' 1! ¢> ' >i',

: Xu>

O\ 2>NZ J . ;j ,sj, +, ,sj

My 1! A)t +'>! > JS' ak' ' >, ; vi Ji sv o;N wA iA ; 98 ey 1! At ,i 68

-- ,;18 i,! S _s\ O.s JA Ji S\j

W J #' i.- -§; f '3! ;' E °99 ;3y o' -,

* +' 1!-mY', ,Yz : e w>, > 2¢s Ju z +- +, t $, .u t H j su 9' ,i ' aS 1! Jv}' t. ^ 9' ' +'

" ) teX

j, ' ji J,; ' ey 1! s $' 448 Ji 2 ,

MYS t>! a A 5 g¢>iz ov a!; is8! +8 H 9'L! 1! -

J Fz CY l! A- Sz o\ Si sz X tSy P! _LS Sj , bYz r!\ a! ;-W! i;;; ? W an f .,L

* o+:

> ; >>! sA - Ji , e Jj >! ! <2al EL; t5; i? U Sil ME P! ; g ? S99

* u! u ri 8 58 a N-8

.8 1! ;5n'l oX \ s; ji ,j ,8 8 vs; J jx jj 9 ;

Sz +> 8 _ULY1 ws, v _ - l a qy si 3! : ql+zz ,

*>898,,ill A s Y

J SiSx > zi v; i f _Sz _o b; We _tZ @g

) <i i3 / ; oiL > 4 1! obYtj is,xi j _ tv X-

uS _k ( Sz isi ) ; L;^j > @U- J; S! J; _o J\

r

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

;'v'-s', ' JHi ; , s , : S, a sj , jj , \v J P;\u\ Ji Li, ai! . @sS LkL1 $JJ > \A X

d a ' * s _P\ + \_42 (F;Vvo i

J ?E S Gi >L. 8 a! bY; j%Ys!; Ul_X8: u6C UN ir-o > tfentLh -- \;; ; ;A i,5>898 ? )!jz 0+ s 61 s

i2N! >! Us a; ? tziy ob a ss S si; 9 4us U i;e ,\ ,\ Jeoi ; = zU Ju\! ' \ a -SL i -

. islubY\! j9YZ UL g) e f v

s+8 jo : 448 _ 8

?+S!; s\8JfJi?J4l!PlUsy

8!= ;8 ? 8JX J >; ( B8JAi! ) S JW j; ZY NSYI s >, ,3

C °8Js 58 \J- s2N ({ t;4- >} j! i 41_21 t8 jj _>j38

J&f a! . J8 z Zu- ,> C SWYI ;1 ji; s aS- tz

; u\J;:ll { -r; ? Z 41libi \ S >) a 41_X1 ji f_ _$\L;38

wf28! SWY OL. !; @Ms D%;>;8! SWYI OSL. i 8j! ̂ e) a;Ls ! Jw aLJz e5AJ < ,,Suj38 > j! 1. ( ' )z @Mz

;L;YI! ff;l J8j! J A! i SI9! .s J$ E! o8Jl i rEl

,b (< + (>; s-u1 , 9 u:!! t<Jz J 9

;1X H °JJH ej J£98 18! . ( '^ )g )SL! Z i dllj

1 J? 91 J 'V11 ;_=18 o; isiwl W.kSS ¢1 J11 J oi OsaJz iJil JS 3 ;r iAll Ji iS g .}1S 9= .k<l8 Iz Cg! . 1>1\! av S lb; ^ A\ _Y L ? v; W8Sz Q ry ? v J

-- Y - - Q 41

i st 4 9p >J)i > 48 % > LY p *i Wi : J 1s;e j28 lz Jt JJi S

: fikii; JZj 4a:L\ (>1 iiL;>:8 ..i

. zjfii UlLl\! oM r! lS stbs

.+: S t, it, +, Y! 9,t ? 9 Y S #

* W!\

*o>c <j! oJ w Y! i$;; Y S LG8J 98 S #8

'5 ). JSY8! ffaJ a:11! lcilJ =91! ^8JiJz #l

£ £

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

* ' _Ht ; 5 S 1 Dj 2 t >J_ 4- g ,>\ *! * Ps 3L J; Oloz s .kJu Zz J @s oSjS

- sit At t! - 18 aJ a,>11 u a s a r(8 8 3 *'._,IJ tv X

sSt oJa 8ui i;rs o8Sz J a;it J82$6 J\J8 zzu ey s1!

; MJ <51 svi36 Jj os,iJs o : ,#s v :,zJ

,-> ! i ;>8 S! oJuYs; ,YsJ jWYs e3 91>!

JzY' ,! ; ,$! ; St Y! a ,> Y - Mz

* ,, u

aW} - J s, R sA \?S z O198 Of i!

AsA S! a i--Sds-! WX > sl s &*8!

; w\! ¢<!-+-Jo5s ¢s Jul tv > w OU , Y! {S S-{X CK S J J

Jz A;; ,+16 H!; th18 atMi 4 , siJz >151 ,5;11 * ( Y ). j>\

; {+MJ 98 ;! oJ ,; AjJ p ¢< a i^t 8 , f DJ;8! ; ss W Y! o Y S J ?A 9 S Mi rN f

( o ). {t 0M Q i sit At ? z )N! w ¢

iil ,vsWY8! i 3XYl ? {S w U;it Ot Di! Hz si

tk iSm W ,} a ass > oS} i : ;-Y1 : rA8! ;>s ff!; w S 5 Y we-;1U- t^;>g1 ,9ic t^;sH

4; - i ; ss, 45 Dj M c>pls tS-j3! j 9t 98! * 9

,< 3! W! J98 J<i ? . ^ -58 ? XY, 1,Y' ayl - Y L;

- Js a tys 8iZ v>! S 4JX1 J > t^LlJv; 91 " ,;

§ C § M Mu' O' iSj Ms Os ri v b191 a t GS1 L ,

tX S a+8! uAz H aSt tz Q Di v Of 9+8! cHi1!

ill o E 91 vJS H ZLill i)! + YHv <;e t si 3! X,\ o\9i ? o S Os i Si bY8! jaYb i jl -tl b\ J

? ) - - ( t ps ) J% * ̂ A* ^w*u* iw,+ | a5 i s - -

98 43 9 8 4S ) > ( ,,J8 ) qlSS ; ( wILJt J 9 ) 91 _ 19 i6 S! i ( +$ St J! J3jz a

£°

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

-

v * ( W\ Lyl My, e 1 > 1 J s: 9 91

4gJ1! ,22+31 31 r\9\ + XY- 5 i>: 61 , J S Li

; Ss >9 o'r uL J °-- 4 J > Je . ^98,

4 5 -4Xs 48

Lu, e Jr j! i J\St Ss > 81 U w1 OC ? wS z<, . EbYs, )IY\!; Ju i! ' ost

H Y, i 4L J; s Y G52s w;s r\98 : Mi HH ; ueWs! suUEs!; L@\! jj 9: wY$! i o9S v

J L1 i +Uj S: i P 1 M A: \\!

oum > JM1 e < 4 : Kj - . <% C _ < g

H: SB! ' < Hs 9 HAz 9 M?\ ) - jI

5i ,3 + ss sH, : JU 4 ; 6! +J9 M2i i! * a \!uS 8 !; As J Ji rsis J e .,sAs

YS JAs } s 9 9 Y 8! g

J ,8! tlLc , 8 >L Jr 8 JU S 8 pU!

Jr ^X\! \! 498! °uUYcs C!

(Y8) Mj

u U Ju ? JA \! o\s s ;s Jr 83!

- UtSs Z_b \!,,i , ;\ Js ' &,2-! °Ju!! v a a ' S a

-- -48 ? aa01S1\ 4*s;} S 9 \a8!; %J\ ? \Js 9 2 48

,i Y )ss + 3! bLLs JY ; , Ox'ti as L)s 0 ,3 Ji

Jz Jj > (( JYYs! ,JXs 3 J-U-! , >) 4o JJE

* +\ JJ 4\ - \v!

J;S; s\Sz H r& TJJ- 9s1 J 4\ J - J9l 9 Ji S; s

it S!; 498@ ? 4\ J onuJj S JHi! s ;

; ; ' a

96 M bl; 9b J 9 0> J\ s8; )-!U\ 3! *; J 48- a

* 4+ S! S98 s A1 <;<! ; :,$ <;< Y AlJ MS ,,; : j.g"Y _ Y

9 jj A W ; S: tsSYs z Wj Xn 41 < t3! v > J! f Ji s ,< ,< 4a; >5i iJYS Ml, Y

£n

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

c - S

; Hl s it v 44.SL txjY a <1 wj Ma j;s ' ! z 1 ;19;; sX 4198 s JX SY ?, . jl;Yz v 9

¢ i ! * )!>8! 8 2vl ; d1 ,9 5 ^! ; taL1 y} ¢k e e 1X; ! zUt!! j;YI uH 23 u8 9 K ,e wfw

? 3 s jSYI J3 )1 1 . i >3 9;Y'

t 198 \Ss! tr i5jj- ,98 -J;1 J<!; i M8

,l-wn-;YI JjS M: oWL! \! Js J J JUjG a j

> JJY1 w)jWX loi . tLYS w)jl! JI+Yl w)jlj Ji; ( tt )J+8 w5jU!

-J>S^cH iR *_J591 ? SS e >1 , ? tS

\J+! US1 ? lHi iAs W1 Jl a i 1J; ulkiYI! <2lll

X - Jz - ( 1,9\ ? UJ! Xi ) UR 1;!; ( 'St °' )

* ovE5 S¢L! a: J S! . ck1 1 ss, J; 91 ? uS Y 1J= w: 8 s; i > S ; a Jw a ,, \-J-;Ys, J1>>v

Djti WA JjWz 1 fiklb <3! * JYI JjW LYI 9;L>11 ? il

-u JS 1 ! tX=- S; tu)t J! ,^ 452 J+ll

-JJXs J ! _ Ha1 , >8 ¢ <^^ - t ! ;tWnJ <;< <_W¢< Sl >$ a! . {bJSt. . Al E58 Ck X3 JYI O S > ° 51 P EbYS w)1 Jjill ;r! i iiSpl oX ClLill JJ;Lf;\

< J s t * , waJ jUs < e t;;s 2 ;;:<! 9;Li1

45iL\! JYSs sA1 JC i 91 Ow s+1 ? : az L . <;I*J;t

Xs ob J < ( tr )e>;8JI Jv^2_i O u;! a8 ;Ek JX jz eL1 ;58 tjl! o= 9 ; @8S s 1J J j%Yt 1H S>1 \1 mi S ; 1

SY J .\ JS f; ojll SS > ? ( tt )i.;:95: ,,8 J ; 98 ^_cSX - _l S: f

c ,:58 JHi . -< )JA 3 wi < R -iAl oiz < l

St.= , Mts: 43 #\ \ss J kJ pZ AY ei 2:;i . 4FU iXllLYI

; w)\91 jbXc! ̂ =\JJ > Jil <y!; w5!>8! r\ 2 \ Wk S ; ; o;$ ; ,? a 59 u g3!; jbucYZ is JJ y j. s

tJ :Z! * S #! sU >-"- S!S t \! obYI! 91 ,< i i c iEl £V

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

2t \ 4

X *s r .R *4 4 n . J 8 n

.r e v

* ty S <

rS _ _ .n q

1. - > Q P*' _ Ml. *

-

* v *-) *;

_

_ I 4 n

23 a t *-3t s 4

_

_ _ *t q

.r

y *r J '3 .n M_ J v I

'm. .t I _*

.e

.n 'ms *r

_ , _W t - 3- 4 le 4

_

w V] t_

to | q.-nt-^ )s _ 5 X

*_ _ v

*; ! . J 5

^ t- *s

&_ t

$] t . j. . t _ h

J .4

) _/ W _ w <

3 f)

*ns ) 1^

.) - t3s

_

,> .# ) .

. < _ ,.

.

{\ . d_ . t |

S .ns '3 v ** b

St \

t3' t s z

t' \ J s

n- v _ t

^ . f

_ w ._\

J _s

_ r

j .n 1 _F

3 .

_

r .

J t

- s - * -k } - % b- > 3

- . *

$- 3 J * t . 5 * t t g | w\7 *>

_

.

_ R _ *8 _

F 7s

n As t) *ns R _

J *, ,7 j .)t .. .Q' )

b b j _ .Q -

-* 7s -

j H > .

_

J n 3 %, -

. } A

q nE 1 . > j j

a,%B C .,) n - ,? D . v .Q *) 1, X v

A

*n *ns

-% - b , - >

.)

q -

J

*ns

-

- ls

'S A b _st

.e

, >

.Q'

.e _

'S < *r >

_ _

_

.t .e

; -

uSi*'

' * %

.q

t n

.r '3 _ _

3 17n *ns |

,1

. JX <

r s J- t

J

#1 *. _

#. ) n. t

.s

_/ v

.n t _ * *

1^ .s

..s

-

_ A J

_

._,

.q

, J

_*

_ )

X

<

-

*s

-

\

.q

.)

to

-

- *gg -

o

.r

.

|

l

5 > - J

*

.

>- z- -

Q le *E te

*%t *0 .t '

3 . . r

w . :' :' q

:3 -* e ;Q 4

'

*n. R 9 t%8 \q) _

_

_ | X _

_ j - ta t v

n 5 n

_ 3

.R *4 nt v l4-

'Y 3

_*

J _:t' $

tQ t . .r

-

-

t *n

-

-

-

dJ

t

%} *4

* * tZ .n d

:

Sh

J ':,

* *

. -

J

- F > -

l l l l * - * - u - u -

) v 2- A

*t t

.n, 3 q sH.

3 .) ) n- w * ' A .e A, v

=

<' 8 _ *u . Q.

-

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

s sJ s ,,#J| ;Yz Q ol,^lz A tU [ *9% ]

f wxoj ,! . vl*YIJ 91 oS > aX; os 91 J i 4t^> - oL;W} Js i 9< °> Y 4 31 ( Yv )... S y iS >111 o! . <1 tA J! i5>.9- 9 &@% *9> * ;JS '_Gs |+ 4 * Q J98 +

i5+% > >;|v% 9 4-,|! 98-4+ ;9 .s

; i>;l i 4,-;J UY28 UY28 0bj ; Jz e ;S ) J > . JYS

;;^58 Q j j- 49 091JisS Al J JXs 8+ s SY >

z ; tz * ;^ _1z ; e 0s b aS i ^ ^ ; e b 3! ; 9

Jr {wl i5i v z ;JYS @u} tLLY} F AJI ? t91 1 i,s Di lJ 9

SY>Jz e5Sz 1! ,/98 4,>8 e5P18 ,,* : ;JYb ^18 G; * i%,v1

; acXl Q I5Yl LIz i J$> 4f S ,= <>01 48JI 3! L;a51 b!

z oSi * ilGi . J%YI :11 Xi Ji s ¢211 QoliL8z JL;Yl <

, ,

z ,;L y;1 tYl Q 8 # isS ;1 t t;

* gM\# M W S \ Q goSF s? 1

Y /,91 AJ @;919 9 g 4,521 X,21 J1 s * a!

,;1; ,1> . *YI 0 ;z. , lai, ,& Je i ?YI J Ep > 4 5E J § S A)9 9 > i 49 3%YI 91 ,LS! Q 9

X5 SJ98 >- W 4;1 3! A @G) J! JA A f ? - ; £ Q > EPU- ;; 45> 02WZ ;JZ E PHl , 115 j 024 OJ )YI 4'! JYjYI 8| v Ji! ;Jz ;i s oJI}l o>J Q ,gl_; f ; ,18 o <:

idY26 J>Yz 3! ssJi Di zY Sl 3>^6 Yz . z88 yegl; * ;^ ..i!

4z! Q JJL; J ; ss A: 8 81,21 ; L J eJ I jlSo 9 i

f ,>f 61 ozyUl i ,,Ji ,;1 . olJ xYZ Jt S:$

xj s! ve- 8 o$s' o s J - 8 ? Yx s 4j%Nz >$ J \ , ,

v v s lJMz sz M rl;l Z Q t- i>1J_^J- $,6 of jWYz tlyi ,;e >; icy z 0s Sls + * 1 y

* 9i oL ac;ll H Q)8 X, . DSz j%! ? WYI OW1! ' +$ £5

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

i ( tz ,(z ¢<, st ,i 298 z ao tYx > ;1vS b - ! g 83! > ,+ a 98 ,A, lt: 9 a ¢<s } v SYs:

* u18! u!Sx d > ,5Se WT &. jV;N8 iz ;ysS Ot;9

G t;8! Ht; <? ^- > , ; Oal JA ( Ji;X ) JYI ? ; oJ$! 11 i S A Zs G St; Ls S;; Y ,X 1b!

il w i Wi J Y ,S ( +: ) 4U Si i ou\ 9 -!

S o sj y ?; ¢8!28 > S SYJ \>S SS 9! i Has

i jYJ t\e e Ji Y! W\i ,s ? >>! 4 W & W W! ; Esffli > asJ ;s! jF N Zi Z ; s, 2 ! J ! A ! O ! - uJs Ji S; 4. , ? s s yi f

)( -y 4 X- ,+\ JY ,fis ? ii Jsl ! } Je

( t )(( ¢<s t-\ ,> J\! ,y,! j%N 9ji fi 4 J! v_S\JA i ¢@\ JA Ji i >L u6 i a s98 tLNS 4>!

uyX w>U ev ? jj\! i \ i;6e:+ \ J 9 4> a! *

^ -^ ,° J\ <j%v#\ t;\ >J1 lii giJ! i #1 ><::s, jbsEs S;,yJ i 3 t M j ( r ) jba i ,L ' Myl i us ' 1 sJ L v

i J>ys e z *p18! i Wi: ? Mi 21 s; Z sj as

! t;L. ffi-S fi! ;, A si! OD S >;i bs! ; OJlsS (rt ) pb

,tJL 4i Sz 3! @>A1 921 > $^ ^ Ji gY, , ,: > > ou! ̂9-! oi 9 5n - - 4i iz >t-

. il

_LI <>* >j 4 <_X_ ? l4 a; 4J1a18 _\4 j$NS t\es ? Mo ? Az b. Ss >-W > J-! i HA ? ;J J\

9Z: Wi - U\j 91 O! ' WLu 9 J _g1

_YY, is JUX oW: jY i 1 W S Ji A oX L SX LL>! C,: X,> lc :\! i a ,+ SYwIz f,!; 0,

oJl;6 0 98 4!? ! . >N JJ,;\ ,^ K H > i {u.

>\ ,598\ySy;ss w2i \ -8W19J4 'S-

O .

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

* aX } A! ty Z: OS: a!S v a\9 !

t>! ! - JJ dYJ a rn S b J 9 si: 91 z! 3! 9P_2l Sj Jb! . g! 5j 9 ;S - !98 ? 9> 9

>Y: ,,>u (S i!; 4;; YS: SS i A a, i Ki Jf . s\! C,>!i i? S S\e S: \\!

,z,28 ,+ sYz r

l JHi vU; CzJJ! > >z sa Ji . X Ji, . ,5,> j o,4 ,_,byl ! i On4 jayz iZ,0 O\Sl 1 bA\!

0,,lz l > >, j<sl ,j , v4 s X: > J!i, ^,sl: > ,i

yr ? Xi J Zl Jlk- > t,SYs As \.iS 98 ;

eS^! i ( rr )isJ18 JlJSSl <;,^ tJUl l > ;Gpl <=^ ! . >: ,iNl <S r

Ju!s _Ij! (( l OMz J Az )) v A\! i X i j,>Ll! o Wl ieX W i i;s,ul i<l ulSk ; >3 tE^_j {LW

_lLEl tl>j <9 <ro C jU i 5 9 << jlXl - <;ro 0Qp S jj ;^ 9 * >! ;Li! ,,! Jbi! i !! t;;!! i t

o ,5ill 98 31 ;,5,ul 9 Sil, i 8,Jl o s b! ,f,k

WJ\ W)i 9Y 2 AJ1! . ( r£ )(( */5 a58 i9JZ JAJ- )) J ws WS

;;l,- O>8JJz d nazlj i d_lJ i,5iJz _;\ i1! ,yr ? )lSl J C9

1! - Xi pz Az Ji i i a.eas j__;,5tJ i j*\ ! i 9 Ju! Sz ;Lyz oub l J @U! ? our J \

Jebi tHi <;,^ <9Ls i {XJEl 0Q_ G Sl <;¢ vae ,ci 0/ JJy iZJ:

XT->LS(H-S!z!9sOJ).u\\?

> 2 < J\ a; ijNJ (< N +38 >! J Jl gS2! i ilL

* ,l! J8 b! <_bx i ._tAbEl ,_ul <;, ,.! i ,z,ql ,i ? < ,,;, , <z |;! < ipl i 9;Xyl Ji i iLSiz 4- 9 S ,: l-> ,3 w ,i ,+

P S M! ) al S l \ sl, Ji i s\, tySl H S J!>l 99- M i 9 i W sil A! i ( J\Ss a s\, J s ;J;L1 o LJ -- | v ,8,ql lj klY, b! lA 9! t 0 S: 2Jz- tiSJ i JsSl ? ysr *t Ju! f fiJjJi J i8 4_8Q28 <X! ,<_ S , l v! i td a; nall j8 9 5gX ;1lJ 5g;\ w;rX ) s Jpz ,+,ul als, ,JiJl < , l > ,3 ,,

O 8

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

MySl ta! }ui o\oQ,t\ A Att\, t,J1 o7j>,t\ J zlu f vlt JHi ; wo i ( U\ 819 )-s!Sz J- 31 +X- LEyJ oK - XS k Ij:

r _o * i ( jXYI <19 ) ou .S18 Os _o NYlll H&t ,, S f

5ntlul _zz _Y>' °uL' 3! -, - _;,> _ j,>l i -; r vS =\! * 'a\! X.';\ °Hs .8 '!! i

t ; 45,&1l S ,u18 o 1!@>3il ''<!-'+

4 4 s! ̂.,\+\\ 4 -o od18 0\<\\ WkE P!: 5Li t>Y a 9

5 r8 is; v>8 ; v i i 3 45v¢8 _S 59J! JS v ;> , ( 4 \ SL _uz J A: ,;tJz t I>Yz _t1

* twe ; ,>- i3 _bY: _U!8

A,, a4w\\ _S%\ _ '9i + 3

d a S So Or! . X\Al a^Nz WA- ,5J8 _U!U2Yz ! JS H atz: * i ; Le S1 _IQ. ,,J ? M,-

.51 J Y': li! Di;s Uz aSU- iS; _,s s xW ,SYs ,9

. 4 S At\\

: ; >-,r: ;1ss o - : 8+ss . 88> i J i roj ': d- 4; ,@U: . £ £ £ 8 ? oub t ̂ £ ar: ;nYz 0Jr; ^£: :;Ys

;LYZ H oo ;a-\ C \ Xj OL > -YI - ps J j, 2-J > ;L;Ns 0ur J ;; f d 4 ^18! 4-S\! 3 jEs su ._18 J \\ jEl _L 21! i W ,9 , a, _ ie18 ,lboWz w! i,,°

: 3,Ys

( \ ) , ,,4 X! Az Qi , 5>S i! N-iJ d v 1! 4>i 0l;\ J H ,jA 5 dl >

( A 4 ) > sXj! u C

I ;nYs o - ]

dsP + J Aj alS ia L L -r oi 089 ;218 wj98 \ oO 4 i d > > +e fla dd C 4;J > 5+ - t;J ovj

< H J jcls Wi az Oiz ,5,-!;-,t, js ._L.,- ,5i ;+ at 9' >! X isA ^/9 < S! . <'

0Y

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

91 t>!--- S 1V, ' <; $gz 91 ? 4 SSYI a;l - - >

:;L;YI l>,>_ ,3 _fi4 ,3

* 40 isti i! NiJ = o

* i;w91 <ui _iJ >1 si= j _ S J s = 91 tu!

* ( * <.g> e5Jf3J b;c ? 4o, = s;

'l; j J;l; . lsl 1 . 3 ; ,< j91 Al i - ji! ;.-^lLi

e5+ oix e S li! ls! + tlJYI ¢" ipl oiLl Ji ro+ll d-1-

DS1 C rj Ji C"S v Gi v ' s1 a A b! 3! ' oS Y

; ,Ycl; i;rS iA_Ll _ t;JL D i5i _ Z jJJl _l elL a;1 ,59;_11 t4 ^1d . ^ J!- Gjo3!J>,i' JHyJi; oHyJi; ^J; 4,J,

PJ L J D 3! si i i r rall _191

_L e jail J Auyl ,ji SJ . s191 L A X s1 + ; > ? vi Ji td1*<t > 9 - : pz <yzn1z 2!u;! zial 91 ouMJ; , our ? oj¢S s i s1 J O r191 oz : J=.. ; S ? J v ,S-4! ; ( O ? JI 3 ) JJl o ( 41 n.."1! Jw _g11 ,5 6 ) Jj! ) _91 o b > > tse Lj o Mj b: oj"

( ). ( 4> e

fikE ) sst98 J98 ^ t y z 1" v o; s 5g,i5' 4J! r s!

_zYl , 9-! > <5+ fJ i ( FJI Jz1 959 i§+ > <5s1 ,,S1, B Jikl ,;? t ,gt 1v! . ; ^ >11 J- -1 "1z , 18 ,

<si 3! J8J.>Yl ;¢ J; <56 A >; tiLI lX lAi; i JA >! aS' W re 91 -8N M Xj t98 >uf ̂ X

£ " ! i - J9YI _t ;, .>A. ; fil ? ei o G z

als Xi " W>! _8Y ,

J! Lf i J Y A,91 d! ,ui ,,,,-- -ll JiLI . , | t y .g,

uo > uz1 ? sa !.v.}' J= isll JiAl aA

or

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

@U tH YS , i U ? ,\ i ,l e l JA- > ,;e i, ;S > sS 21 aws #; ( z o B s ) XYL JZ \9S J Yj 1 aj liS; i;.. S Z Y1 Yj; ;y

; SN1 8 i ..!l j! ( ry 3 g ( Ss 4vz ) J tati i ( r: ) ou-f? S-G, ji

a s >\\+A\v!.1'JXtaS

S"o ,iA j\S'!; -z>888J1>1> J> JAi lz i 2zlxl ,<11 1v sx @,, . oxi ,; L --t4 9

. Yl5is ob J \+ a28 ;\ \ 8! 91 4Sl 98 ffUs 91 ! j! ' sA' 9' 1- & e bs ? Ss Y, i ;>Ys bU- )ayl jL, O! ' ,zy ^ @898

. LY1, ,>hU {8s

j5Xl o ; /u91 W! A 8 8 i 9sowi5 JSz rW

4tvA blaag i Js ;r--i)! 5! i Ja1! jS ijl >= ¢= S; !8 i J<8!

J sM O Y Hs: ZivEl aJ<! ? F w - ^18 as J

S' i,;18 J ; iJYJ M 3-H;Ms i> rk! $ >; osG8! 5)Js

* <'! si S H j<) 3! _Ls Jo ,, , Z 0L; + s- . jX 9 J+1 J; vs<fi5z JSz a e5S rL>8 >!

Ji18 3 Z J#8! 928 4 ) 8 * + ' 4 o isS 88 J ) _1 oV *JISaX 4 i *_> Ji; ( sJXs A ,zYs ) o A oz v! . ( J;z Ji . 1 ; JH,18 _a8! i & 2¢:, :t , ril pl ? os! ^^ ^

* ,+ f! i jS

\9 ; 98 J WA\' _W98 oV M ;9 9 9S j>\ 9!

? ¢<j 98 -u< ? 44$< S 8#li ; i;l1 wk ; t t ;N k> 8 X- e3

; r<,J" 9' As ; . ! , s :,) <? su- _s, UY28 - N 9 -s,!, °;X!, ,, ,

0X9' tw _ 8

s S0t. S S o191 3 _J8 ivis ,;58 - b! JYs s5!

Op ,, ) LJY oS OJ)! W FLXYI oJJ e3 +Y ? {n,54

S Wz -8vLs Q ( _t0 _N; ) JS: wJ1 ;w > i

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

9k! ;1! J 1 tJ U Sj J 1! '? o - J

J Y1 r;s J J8 + tj s u ol! 4, > 8 C ,s FW ' M o - J _;S S _LY1 H _8 sJi, J> 4J ;S bS,; ;LYI -oum O ;S O Xi Jlsl o-J

- $

So. ) zI Jw JljYI , ' 91 _Sg1 Jw-bY' a

* ( Y, Z _,<s

olJ Wi }c )191 J _ si 4r 9S;} i)z! e5 tz bL 8 c bij . ,4- 8 i 1n J! _g1

v1+ ? S! v1 sA1 S v

8 1 JliEl c ot s1 ,1 1 J sa,

1 ;L^: 1 1,+ UG f ;1 - 4191 91 wJ a

iil - J ;2, 1 1 ,)3 Us gS! i a 9! *

49 s ,3 # Y , wsi_S l ,, - L ,, - '" s -

? ,^891 J _R _,, J ! 4191 91 Ss si i ^.,3.

_ _ s

.898 _Lyl @S y! i 191 O! i ( ^L, J ) 191

As! s UX A1 1 Uk J

->sx i oulil JljEl ,9 3! A1 J 9

Q Xj SY; wi ej UW ,gj ,,. U , - ,j Us j

pl nr4>! i ̂ ^ -all iJ;l _li EP?>1 tS; LU J i ill Y * <o;8 1 Q ao > s

..,. a f aLLL @S M! ; Ni r 591 JuJi! 9 @ : ( £° ? *;! re ip ? ) 4q;Yz 18 / Jli t a ySl S 98 t;t / J is5JWl < ...: Je @ . ^! ;ot Jl; ;+ s t -18 >

.1 t;J;_tb ( £Y sX° JJi J! £° Uo ;>1 ) >t;Jz WJz

-. ^! a +- Y ;r ! 2J; / J k_4 t;; / t; ? of Zj X,!yl \ i iP 0v! iSz i:H

*-. _Ni

t;; / Jl; _ i 1 U; ( £ 5-41> 15 £Y 3 ) Uz l o o

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

i;e ! f, JS u! a a- JG

*G-: zE

8z/2Stw\z( °8 ?J!£5?)898iW:

e ub M , A: M c e a s z I JG

... : Js Nz 9 91 ,zj s: a/JGsz/Jstwlu-(Os ?)8_stivl:

...: Ys SYI W3 M8 <_

:> rv / >v oLJ: 4YX

a 3JYz 98 98 +8 ? ,LYz 98 J S W!; zz!! * 98 e JSN\! i ( (( 3!YI \ 98 ? >> ) a ! a_91! 191 Js: 1H S1X- W Ji S >1 Ji ,§SI ! . sSYI ! )YI r i 9'IjEl 91 9 JU

S! i 6S1 +1 > o w! i SYI WY 9'I jEl 91 91 ? 4

_$ +j ;l + 9M 6 z! ' X'ItYl I JHl ;

: ,,5 <>1 Je . : ir4

- - s 9'1 1 $ f ? of! a ! e s!) S! o ,3 'S ,3!; ow1!! Jlo >3 LS + y

( rz ) Ckl w1

o- X Ppi! G5A: )Jz Ps ? ? ! Ji J91 a!

C t01 e3 >Ji1 J +1 Xbj ,3 Lc i CSYI 49i S tJt;! ;t, 11! _J: -1

- -! 5J;1 _GL_i it^:;- a le Y! . vL;YI! 9oU tuSt 4tiLl

J! S! i d! 22l L sr G521 MYI Jv! i iSJL;ll L;11 <;H i_88l 4>>

Gg SE,<.:11! SSSYI <;H >5 > S ? ! 3! U+ LIJ

1 1 w)i G5AJI a oflj ir4 1! !10 e5jJI ti > ( rt )>ly fL-i g 5 g 5

; ¢<S1 vs ,3yl +-> - X11,>1- J !S!J!

5 ; 11 <;e tu s\ $! ' Ow s s 9 &! @\J98 St-J 5t! H il o ! <e <v21 5aj8! J 4i f i Sz! CSYI 19 .

,! , S ,! ; 'u1 51 A1 s! 3 ̂ ='1 > Z83 98 0n

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

0_Rs o_RS o! . O\J98 sz ozjzy J sAz a - U)s

>;,Y mAz ;4 oJW! r ? w s<s ow5 j! 425 a MAz gs

? f Ni CS- Ji Az ? A H i oU'Lz Mz L1 s! s

SSz az J ;; S + >

i,< ;L128 iv1JYz J 9 4 9 ? j f Nz 9

e;4:! * Mz iz 828 4S. s sJ; Wy8! vJyz %18 eSi u-tiLz JSl J Si 491 Jo sU rj a zi >

Sz 1! :8A1 Wj ¢Jz s Xy g8 fuz 1v )i v JJ, JJ s- i X^58 ooJ . E5v18 8J! +8! C J AJI vswo 4i > i 91>1! > t i ? + al c::,1 sj . ,,YI d; OU! v <:e Jf S 1! 1 4,Wi R >

su^ @ 91< + J iX. 6; UW1 Wio-<l 1J; Xd18 a Jjy ;96 8 n1 )J$!; @L1 j!: 4;98 U1lj _i f 9JX )9 a W! rI Ja Sz * ^ )LJ > 9eb 9yy 'l, f +1

a1 ,9 ,A1 e5<1 fAl F! ' c19 o ? zjWl Aj

, \ g

oJ;L 91 F s j! az 8 91< )JX 21 J Y

4,> st.£1; e 1 4W1 1 1 b!

i-, 1>1 Cti kij; iAl ,;bl ? = Ni A Y

4SYLj . Z&1 Wo S1 aH - 9141 ufl t!l; J tiAui t_£1 eLi Ou Wi ClA sj Al ? flwi j i )SYI l b

4J> WJ 4JR C5158 A! C 9Sx fl<YI ov ?! <- !

3 >- o91 ovj ;.-U59l 4ij _fi ? S S J A! W ;LiCA-i Lifi.1.M!iaL1fAlJsX1WX1lC ° + Jw1! J3jy 51SJ . 4-> isj JL^;YI <e1 iLL 4Rn

b! 8rSl 5 15! ; 45v11 tEYIJ o11! J>\ < <e, a1 o U lis lA; vxz L; <yJ ? GJJj;

u1 1J;1 ,, Cui :1A1 ,; s! o i ? y 1 * S 4S98 40i! i_ Ni i-ry 91J;\ ? &@1 fAl J k! S J

Jlji ,, J;J! e51 i 91 s L.YI j oWi j! - u es iJI ufiLI dlJ) oSJ :1 L>i 1bJ ; fi lbs zL ,3 YI

fS ,# sI,¢JI ois ;2 I3;! . 4,JIj ,U1 1 iro tA 4 1J

ov

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

\ ; < - . ^ sY oN8 9s! s t;J! z

{s >OLYsfSiAJ_>f_Ss)S!

Y + 42i ( p! OaSJ91 A) >! ) v

R f a! e S!98!;1S\!{l^- jis 4$X!; >L H sSs _\Ss

Ls J\n <:?j! . s o s As a Oz Az ? A 9 ! ;>i 3! °lu98! $ ! 31 °X ?+8 > >%;

> is J1n t2> > L, p\ 9<Ns ,, Q bu >x_o % OA fi!; ( £* >

9 _sYz Jt; L>8 H W5:18 jo16 ,;1s Li S i _L;YI J>

z S: tNJ << H v+s 45j u aSu1 !91 ,3 ̂>>i u 1! <r?} ui ;\91 ^*,Ji CA ssS a ss SE > LW

jY JSs ! t owYs >3 ¢1 1Xa18 3 pb;8 Jbc ,4s, 5s 9: _ ut!

$tlal!zvsaz9\9+>sW$tl!Jw &! XHx J A1 a! i 5z 448 3s Zi >3 ,^ ^ 1; < Si5! i _ fY i:98 !) C > s xY f f- ! ; /g! ^ <3^ Q

. _9t 9 ouWl uf a 1! >8 99 ztX 91 w

O\J98 ss oSj\y J sA1.^ o 9H1 Ls - >!

a! * fifi <y8y! Oi;\ y\y u 4az y\y! o%:Ns r8y

°v ;'\ U > i! \ ° +i 9! ) 5AS ^ i,i s 4ZgJ LLYX .s>LJs ji S i u18 j > _lvd 1s ,< WJ Ji *:)A Di ;;\ ? asls

L J;8 as >; S! 91 8o ); ; 9s sS >>Ys Z 8 js

,& 5J418 alXl ;18 <S 45>V ,+ >! J ( 4; ;\ ?+ . 9 f @'t- S i _Ni

wHi.e 098 i.^;

. b * bs

8 tis ( Y 8 ) _N1 {>\

4in-Ni a )898 4b1!-Ni H 9891

* M . s

>, v88 1 J sYz ¢sui M yi J a jz s ;iY1 a 8 rs,Nt *

oh

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

* ( r )Gflyy : fs . ( o £ ) @X18 j!

* ( v \) Ns

* (A) tA JM * ( 8 5 ) N

* ( \\ ) @)l jH

.( £ r X) Nz

* ( r )Celyy : N * ( ° £ ) @98 l

* ( n ) N

* ( A ) JM

* ( 5 ) N

JJy

.( \°) jUl

* ( v l ) N-s

*( 8A) JM

* ( 8 5 ) N-l

*(Y ) jH * ( Y ' ) N-s

* ' TY ' j! . ( TV T£ ) N

. ( To ) JM

. ( r tn ) Nz

oj a W1 C,yjy . ( rv_rt ) c8) °,4 a ssj9!

* ( TA ) N-l

* X1 * ( 'r) Nz

* js

.

A- sN-l

*( '^) JM

* * -

l ob Q aL)

* ( aS l J Wi,

s us ; 4 58 1,28 t 1 ;YI rsui , 91 a rsi . 4u,i

4 A' oFS f y ;bj **

i;! is

: 6Jill +18

6S Ht

( oL- . ?) @u 9g!

o ) oP a , @1 M?

( ;L

MJ r iL.i a ) {A1 ,

* ( OUb iL.i On4 24

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

JI! ,,i H ,1o * ( Y-A: £* rA? ) J1 . ( £._rz ) a1

* ( o- r:£* ) Ni * ( £Y ) i * ( £ A n £ * ) 98 ( £t ) $

* (V A:£t ) N . ( A_V:£Y ) 91

4c-liLI sULl_

- - 19 -

" ,,;,11 1 s i_fS

Jut i.+ 1 )

N1 3! +$ °J;! ( lr

H J1 U CU\sz > ss- - SS Orlj$ f -I W 91 S blw J : sA1 ,,!l X ; o ; SYI 91 3! {1<YI 4 _, X3 , I(6U CUT {YI J1 i JN J 4 6XB ESS ) 43lJ91 Sl ? / 5 * -JUT EJ1 ,$ SS Ss s 1 s oA1 oV J sA1 rs-; ( 1 3! 3; u898 J ov s gj a X3 SYI EA ¢C- G siJ MO D-; ol;ll * isvX Ni ? y 8At t CJi- ¢Sz Q 9y li 3! i Q ,sYz z *

8918 <;¢ {< ? s $18 Jj @918 oSS l;ilwl f M+ zr°zJi E: j ,> Jt) Jt ivilZ oz JJ4 . ,YZ J418 ? 8;< OA; A; W! J9^*J; ?.218 ° CY Jw CIA J )

J {sz l tJ s w1 is i;e sjz l sSl a^^ ;-,8j18 _)fAJ ( Caz S H SAS HZ 3 ;;JZ 0 vsJ * U! °JW, s 4*W1 e3 .- s i;<<lz ooSlZ j129; Gs C,litl ? s it:18

; ,46T OV JJS ,5JX8 ;5i v Jl=9 jl)> eJ;?) Cl8 s S[ X> ^lS

> z 1z s>Yz a - * ,jJ . 18 3! i8

: JXl 4; 4*88

i§J408 " ; ;Jz 3! l pJz 4 *f>JYz nLr J rlmiYz +z

f J^-t f fik; &sz <16 * : ,; 8 * . ,3 J

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

sx , °J>ix o s : ;8 ? 91 ;>1 b1 9^ f ' z bA &sz

A 9 J ( j2* J tJ J ? 4 9 1 > /

f > $

3' ? C' f ; ¢'8 J1

*[ro/v oL.ls^*] zU.l 98M

, ) t8, 5f J us1 ? 4 8 J - Js 48118 J )s" 1

uJW ? iuf n)s; w ,5Ji )68 j1 ( 4"> °2Jj 2sofJ N} :e J" Wf = Wi i;ls . 1-o J1 Jn 8 ? t;u;;8 i, q5AJ

f f

Q s - zu l9 Sl ,,ii8 9 vl al ?J u 4N 4> J1 XS : 4S *98 > @^W SS H

* ( ol+" N"l oJL ) {by l 8

* O8 98 Z )8< Y

. 02JJ ts Q J.J.8 ;z48 r

DIJgJlJ ,18 H 8Jx t

. 0 Q Jdf ;> o

: <La18 p , a;s is ,5, ^ ,3 sf . ss {, i> or 4f ,>8 J 8 ,^f ;>. of: qs,A

* zl H {s J 8 . .3 f ;>vJ .Y ClJ8 ; 91 8 H 8< 4jlp Ol_Z wJ^ Q >f Js > 91 t

fi9N , j l Xal jJy oJA}l

* Hs es s:>iNS LE18 oJAJS * SsJ i.|w8Ss > {s aSs 0JSs

0SJ ip ,df (> of As ws " FlJs ,3 r

> s JYJf , , 91 t

Q Jf ;> ,As z ": FIJz Q W ^ o

. 0

f 3 F A1 >

;l . 4N J1 S ? s )^E Siw u8As ast- J! 4">Nb ; >s 8Ns a suzJ * f Jy As @6 aiJJ " <9

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

r S S .' tel.. te'; oz

r ' e n

l F ts s R * G G- t = X ^- i , : r t

v W w \ C i

! 0 6 ( t k ,6 ,^ V W

8 t ^ S Z Y f z-W * _ \

J .tT tN WEtYeR st.X; i

k ; Stu.

< bE ,; $ z Wt G - t L 1' °E Z

-

t X.t W

i. R- i-^ G b - ot -

.Mt4.W r t -

t ' ' st o t b - = t- > .c*-

atct- ce^- tct-

trt tttq >* t ttt tt ><t .: G . (Y t O t\bS

E R s t W tz

e .g .e t (t F t C^t,.

* * i

n - A. D

-

L , ( c

?- ,e - b

t t^9 'L <_ G -

.

t .c*. 'S - Sr

_ t^.h %,. C' t. sL E .F - E W .t' z t.

.. b C_ , tcr- th X

.

.e -t C |,r . t t_ * _ X .F W

-

t. e G

tCt. at b-

t

*. t * | + * n -

tt sb R W * C_

* C 't E Y W

X X f ,, W > %W b

K-^'% 8 -t , ,4 Rb,4

t b t ^ tt ̂ t b tt b t ^ A. t ^

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

a5 Xj 2 ? >; iL1 1v 3 <,;sX1 uY i2- * , ,;nsi ? * OG' Hl _$ <.;1u91 iZg1 i3 oJJeJll vfc zv5

J - =t_a- >.s SJs:; o&l ! t s Lls 4__ ii f t _yi 5

. il oJWL ClJi^JU bYL BLI ;!c

oJ 3, - 11 ,3 _;; , . _,Ji *,j ,> Z AJI l;:iYI 5H- Ni W!9 AJ1 J *!91 ?E 3!; 5>1 - J W)H su s

oJ ll 4 e5 AJI ji ,+ . (< _! 1 )) J J ̂ -! ; _ 21 oJ Wl 9 Ai! . 9jl-! es ¢a i ;%11 , ove>JI >1 oJ 3 ++! SU

ill ob jD- Lc! . %YSI J-H11 ,3 4 UL _yi *j 1 j!jiJl ob Jlb *- -l; wi; W lu W !; 4£JI ;J 3! = @

! . SY¢I Ju;11 ,3 >A? E;< _, f i 491 H1 8jJl W3 ; JI e3 *jlJ olXl oJbYI ,oH J> j>J; _ JJi c 17- e

^<:1 + ? >;i! ei ,>, 1 oS jA ji XY ji _ jf

w - 11 <^ JSi SJiJ!; *)1! JUl jilw +!9 ipl < 21 si

- z s t. S i<! ;31 8 ! ,3 o S t;aJ1 3! : oll ob 3 J+-

a v i v>&iLI i,Ja:; t;-i la;i > : Jw- <_i! .- ,5> 3!

' _u1! W>)41 bI C Wsep I! i sp XYI *! Gs E;e ollgf) <; s i Si * ki i;e k 'ts ,,, jJI i i! ,5S jsj

g ' g g 9e1sb1S1 * ;191JC!A' !21+9

-Jf °> ; 1! a ; jA 1! L <;e i&- ; ¢i

( £ Y ) , S S - jYI 1 J _i *j o > sA1 a,i si1 9H1 ej !

i SJ i X)1 >5v>YI 4PJI ? esi 3 o S11 ois J> (1 ¢ti ou 3 51s, - gG OU- }1 S- ' 191 1 J W 1;< S J ji S jr j!,

*i <rk;- AJ!; iJz ob ,3 ,FA; 9! . 4 y _^! JL! e * WS ' 9 Sz 1,N' \, _Ni > Dy\! Uaz

+ P JJY ; Jf ijs e5Az ^ ijs iJL eSil 9<28 ¢^ ,,-18 <> .si i (< El >) J; Ja <.;ltl8! i JiJ 8! {BY¢I! ;18

lSi; dllif f! ; yxill ,LJl Suk ,,8 8 ;,, bf S %! . jlS

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

i M\.; .- IiG i ,OYI.4 e 191 1 9 A1 v ? 9 S 1b!

I-!10 > i )YI ? v C A! i CUI J ;s- s >

WH- I;t;JS YI<sX Ol X4I- s

DSl J>! A J!YI Nl : 99M ,3 11 , E;H K r1S ZI1II L)

:bj 1,

i 91! 2! zi1 C98 d

* [ £:r ] > 9 A; : JT; 5ill [ 88:r] <98 >3 ia a

, , $

SLS JYl A; ,aY * [ s£:r ] ;-, ,5 ,

z <;,dil ?,YI ,5! i SA1 <?

rj aLJu C 1 ; r4--^;Y 51<i rrf u1 i j

[ n a O:r ]

! + J i_ iz16

@LL As wi 9

. J fi Jr ;s

... 9L ozs

jAl 1Jv aS1 SAL J oziJ o_iJ i e11211 l jrbj

21a1 1s i,,21 JL

. J+1

is v1 ,XYI M wi s JA1 a of S 1 S , S IS! z2) e11 JXYI 1! obYL i 4S oj? ;4 J$91! OW1 i 9

JiJI >y aLJ8! SLll H! S J11 e5-ES jJI i M)YI X3 HL11 lt i 3! (( ,+1 1 > a 1JA1 s, > 991 >, > (( ,+1 J i (( ;L1 )! (( M)YI 5JA ) H e5-J1S . ( (( JP11z11 8J*b u;;YI ob ;< ! (( eSv-YI s J z ;LJ pl ) H (( 11 sJ (( SJLl

)J j1 E;< J < t;21 osl X3 ]NJI 9 ,,5:11 f Jill i f s ' $

bJ * e5A1 ^ e3 52 * ; i 5g1 oJJjl = ; Y N1 oJJj 3 L Yl {>YI alu jYI ¢! s uL;YI a8,iiJ8! LSLI ;LeY ; P Jo

JJYI j!/X! Jj e3 AJI oijlv 3 5JjJI _PJ

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

w-fis 3tfi

: @X1 j! W! ;.;$ of wiu s S

* 9 s o.89\,

[ A:£ ]

>! ' $ 1! f i,5a5

Y elli; yW1 5of sf w1 . o;Y suf ,,,

[ A/A:o ]

wxojYs *, s 8,; Jal i J1JJ1 > odl ,J11!

Ow 1 J 1A1 991 * [ 8 :° ] af 1! Jj,O 5,- >& i;,;tJ1 ,Mf ,4

;1 Ns , 8 i ,^; x, ,i

* iLrJWI °.s ) H

[8r/8TO]

,; i L -r-QJ .; s 4Y

[ 8 ^ o ] . z)t fi = s ol>!

: @U1 A!

e5+., C,ju ,?\ W¢s

)So Y siX i az > wi

* 4 's es Y,

i, ;l i;e ;l Jr si1 aULI 4 ejj i 1 4

ijlW2JI 4 v5^

;1 H- 528

f\ ! 4

i1 ? vIj R .

... Ong

Cf. J * "! > si1 M * i5J1>

£818Y Ol ck

nf C J! > o1 41 ors ozj8y s-, , z ,

ou S > 6J1 H J jLil! Jj sE Yj i sAX a J )N ?

* 5A1 M <rLYI O ,+; 5,;11 ,3 ;S S

- 4Dt- - *f ipX *_s>;YI vk1 OW I s 9 N98 YS

Ji _f oJkJI ol^! i 1L JJi X )f i 5;11! 45JJpJt 1JUZ 3

>4- #; UJJI ogl 3 w).; ,>SEl wi 45i i J>fJ t-31! tg:

XY 4! ;! ^ A1 {SkS dffl1 MI Y1 RX f E;v! i )8<YS

{91 1 S w1 . ,< 1 2! S91 1; OX Jj SWBY S

4i + _< i! 1 4 1 > o,<51! o,lJlL 4 yi 4S! @S SSl!

, ;g51 1 N 4iJ 4li S ;? ;i5ve

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

C i 8X1 J sx J cu! . i sa' i-ni W!-f 'i!! esX8 e 4,W8 J X Ess J _g1 js i oWl o z;-

* 8 J! >5A1 S! 4t a

: i--f X

* aS wN si si ? g ' g

jU ws Ha Js [ £:\ ] ,5.St i oX A! '

i>? ^ 5 [ 5 A:\ ] a-; ? S! v si R

[ \\ a] t \ R

9 v oJ - I oj wAj 9

usJ \ 1 Yi ?; >

e -o!JL o=u\!; a,

SJv [ yr_>t:n]

\ - 's Ji \SS iSe i;;;

><,?sE,i*>i? v iS!4t oUl 4 ? Ji vL

[ tr Xt:\ ] t ci a Ji: : i!

a - iri, J,; S: [ £ V ] . 58

Jz C ,21 > S

* CL! ?W sS . _898 [ 0:S ]

: -fs

9 L -Apti i bis

H ji .- XIc sy i sL1

J oj Y i ! Jj _o

* 9 s S Y! -

> i;F? usow-f 9

? 9! ' ?; ? 15! 9 MYX \ i a o +1y'S e I j- + S

45;c lf} Ji i ws 9 j-! ? w: 9 tLy

! w5;

{S, ty:;: * Sd---\ il

- < \j> t1 ji

*-* W

£8|8S O: ri

CCS 3M si: i tL1 CYI e 91 1 J sv: a [ 8t S] vX,; A a S jsi Jr o ls -|! i a r R! o a jLYs ^ S A, ; Y! e y ? v y

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

i-* L a fi ,jS v >lz [ AA - AV:v ] v - -) Fi

v > oW R jJjW zjuJ v $U1

[ t*:v]

[ 8 l:v ] * $bl Oy e X

4 = $> uS oi 1; Jx 8u! Ja 5A ^ oi ,z ;<!

i 3! *< .Y i,!; Nz t= u > 4W!

! ,YI / W 0^ 8 , - Yz 1 o1 9! i 5AZ N1 3! 9! 8

Sysi s iSos

: ,x1 , >s : JM Jli J@ " J+- a 3! J98 lk bu c i<

8 > + °>= iJ > Jzji o! J^-l . 44 J- 4! > iz Ji ;1 1z , 598 o! Jw ci + ag J>18

[r_8:A] tiSz t t t I v oUz Ck

zW! e3 S.- aii v ; Az 3 oW! a (sAz Xi J-40 a)L J f X-i iX i Wli j98 1 OSz Us USz Ni i. - i e5,Wz Ni zjz bJ o ,&1 ,,Jdi zjz _ ,_1 iSf

wz o

fi Mi i,

: Js, i Ss ; s

. wz buYz ,>

:fHY*XJ';uo!

C<S1 °98 >sJ . mz s l.A qsilz . <S- YJ Jz

[ o_8:R ] .

a i,^ ,OjYz tsSt

[ 1:5 ] Wi JAw H- i dA- s l ,pYz

[ v:5 ] cSz >

1Y

: i Ju S o' ^ 8z oi ei @! ' U. > Sz [ lS ] H- G5s . W Di A Y,

9! f !, + J cS A\ siz ^, . oWl

Xiz ? * o! WSs . J ;b zZ! ls>oSt

as oJYz F G528 ?,

J8 si i. ;, o s93 Siz ^ f i L898

Li ,< R sHi ?

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

, oul! 8jl 51 >U1 . @f [ A q ] * Al Sai ¢s 5's 91 J . s s

LW1! 9g1! 91 CS +\ 91 > ? v J

[ 5 5 ] * -+1 q Jj! _8! 11 oi ol _, ,+ Y fX 9> > w

[ \':q] . Y .1! J P! ij

jli. ! olJi Y! ,,> ,4 liJA

[ AA A ] * Z i s

J '- e! °, 29 lil £ t / 8 t olJ' ri

[ 8Y A] . 9 lisU ; olaall _f1 ;< <P- 91 oJlvil! oJlill! aQjeJI :11 aJS fi-4 - _LI s 31; , ,5 jU1 ,5,X1 _ yi i;e sL <5ill LI! 1! z . 18 ̂

N i _.f1 ,:51 i ( ir ) - I 1 3 gj XJf ;1- ; ol alz

,;JI I ,v, i 41,qll ,,\ ? SJ! o S! SA1 a S S, * a1 S! 3! A! i SS Se s 91 ji S i tu1 C;YI H

91 u1 r191 J f r;1 1 J ,4J1! J-1 L1 _>!

C YI ;? ,TYI ;91 liZ D! C 8pJl D! S! 1AZ W3 8 + Y! i Sl;,f

W4! . ST51 H1 ; ? <;JI C YI ? J!YI ;91! <re11

JE11 XA ,AS ;\;8YI 0 ;? ZYI ,

[ AV 5 ] * *__ s ^5>!ve u&! oUL 95 si1 S\z

[ AA q ] . jl? ,,Sz * - l;! ljlv >! Si, ,i Y ,>.- 1 J Si zi !!

[ 80:8*] . Ss

[ 8 1: ) ] > ! '< f S SJ\S X <r-,; W)!!

- 91! t96 ib 98 >3 uz 49! ;; Ibil ; J3!; l;l , s

>3 N-Y Sli j! iJ! ! <y S w_ >s1 4)- <S f LtJ i \L_Yl

(( ! J,=- S ,fj w , Az ! ! fL J 5 + ): ,! ti

(J) N i > 0 4:.o J jlil! <Y1 O 911 ;19 Mi r19 aJ Y-i i;e , 8 ' sA1 a J A! S1 )YI 1 s . ! Ms J 1! o 1! i w1 ¢Y8! t+1 sr

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

UXs r1J_ i yt a! A1 a a \ 4 o Di A

ou+8 ,! S ;;q5J;8 > 9 of ,j N l:<JJ i ous s ov ov s as is Ot oD DY ? Zi v aL, !8 1 As Si ,,Ns . >Y1 -S s \! ' ! N- 8 N- $ 6

, s > ; 0 s i jW b zY t fi Ns Of o N U; z: 8 01> M f > S ^J; 9! : a z Ot A sAz a s ,,> S )Jt Pz An,

;suz Xi N-Y <jj Y1 c- 8

* u8rY Y! zz A.o Y jl ' - Us xY _ 8 . 4oS oLY1 , w os _ U s > otrY 9u Q Nz -C

. Xi, osrY8, ws 1! o98 *F

: a s1 ,s, Y

.*u as iviOf SUiY 8

. w j1 tAX \S1! aYs ? sA1 _

? O\};N\, 4 4-,! 4 wZ 9 C

, 41 ia (> 11 991 > 4Js r=! oLss

91 s1 C s g i!, . A1 ^ J oWl )Js ? ob 4 s Js ? oil y8< Jv J; Xil ? Ss ) >

;-2;j 4Juill vl<8 wo Q r898 ° ,, 1! Ji sJ; Wb <5A a 6jYL H ,528 +t N 9 . \ y898 e 591 a Rf z

SX1J o sl 43 i) JI n; Ns D tJ 4J k,oz iJ + if 2s SA * S >s \j g <t_ 2L\ ! ;8 91 ,428! t898 :<OYs 3 4u1 p fW S > i 8<N 9 W Jf , of w s: N LcJ . ,ss: ;BJ \<N: <sr >f w Jils

{898 °> 1! z-y28 ;$! {li&t °u ? is>Jl 43%Ns sJI JR 9 oy alt f f > ,iJ 4JW 3 ws ,- gal,; ,<Ns u HSl! ;\ZHJ8! ;L18 J; ,Jf ! of + . o-sy of <;, sx O<s

i tY 4o1 ut2! J$85 iJ; Jf & > 8 2 4J9:! o\Jll ;;< >5 4 <no 0)) 0+ Q; > J ; di n5a2 oJt e .X1 o>Nb 8v

: J;: ! M: :YX

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

i;< 8 ;Si;C-is ' StZ zfSl > X JY J H 3 9 >\ m> o} * < C K;ts ss JX

- S - W J jik Ji w s j98 J \

e J s8! <8 * 8 wt +} <, 21 - 8

* > , > + j >-y1 ? - * O HX wrM * un\! \\\ ! ? 4-J!

? \s \ > Li LiS 4ss Lj A Ws ?,Y}

! ivavvE % k oi! (+si w)Y Si

Ow! Ju\ si zY A ? \S a ! Cui! e

>) JE J<e; C!S a e a\> S98 I Y. jb98jWi.iS\!i.,\xUs 9>J

,^ S:\, J$L oS a-f t df JeL ' k MS

,,, f ,,,<; ,p,,, (9s Jk . J,si > [ ° - :rX ]

-0s1 ,? o . asi Jf zjs; y MA > s \+ bs >\ S

cL Ulz ? 0\aL i+ i9; °?! °2!! MS J b%\ ? 0\S Js a t-W) °)i 9 4>\ P ;2a; w\ eSQ98 J! k! SYX

Lt yt i\! CuSl dSi S; 4 ;!

,5J;l , S__ s_t, Ji A ? A 8 si: wY M! i 91 Si

> i Suz 0o o ,? ,s a S . JLYs <;e 9 56 fu Ss jus Ss N\ ? z\S S ;S S C! ; r >b

, - Ss o 1 a.WL o, e '6 sA s S s S SA} a}

* <598 28JS u s 98 oS8 9!; lL28 oS >3 ;sAx Zi 9 4 C\A Ni S o tti.-18 4WX °v 1 ki 1; -f i 31 A} jl l C> j (( LW ,} tAX C 9 CH S \ > \ C ? Y tW

b jY;_ >5J;\a!Ni\ ji=Y2!.<8+Ys!

< 31 . P S y +! i i z o<;\ 888 v8

jSi vS J 4\ AYI <S ,! Wv o9VS ?! v.

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

>U1 tXyl _ Y

, s!; 45,x1 , e i5998 - ! J Ji-L} z

*YV 8 toSi J sx ji a Jj 9!; 1 1 48> J wYz \S _

g ¢ ¢

>3 'S isAy J1 J Js A1 ,S<X5 a . 0X$, Jo i$! Ss J {lwi )i ) sA1 31 L 1 !L H

i_; 4> t1JX J o , S\ fi s991 \ 31 $ s^- S!; ( \;<

w $1 >1 ( ?L )! ' Al ! Al ( ) j ,} y Zj Jr X C; ( <1JYs ? ) i avb <3 >'\9; 98 os i

6 8 Si vi ( £ 3 )+( \Ss e l! '19l a

* 8 > j1< 1 1 >8- z ;@\\ a 4j > ; uYl \b a H Jr si1 ^ 4\' J sH98 P Ji v

w_WJ iXl%Yt MYJJI + <M18 C JotJS 43 ? i)f ;. 3t a;Jt 9s1 e: + %; 9 sjl;\ <\ ¢i Jg 41 6; il<t28 i1+ ;c \ w>8J198! 9jtjj 1t 4; o 6 J 9> Yi 4 6o J

; {t de- Y1 i;? +o 45A9t 1 * >;1jX 45 t SX sz rsy 31 otb

iLll y _ ̂ ,! ; ,, - yL MYJJZ u;>$ J J>r Y$! ; + \! } a 45oRll! * 45JAJs o 45jJs-:)1 > MYJJl tL1-

4gsLs J 2X;58 \ gts ( £V , : ,5 < ? y 4 As ;=l

a 4 * a,Ys! ; Jfi s al \JuS S! ) w)\ oum ? [ > ] <96! ( W > 32-! 4 i 6+ lAl! i 4a1 ¢ JI Q sH9 9 ; JA > ; >Ji Ss ss \v tN-' ? : Lyl O!; tsyl U e ok S!: > >L {5j! ( oS R ws 1JuS S ) + 9 > 4 z t%! > j;c 2 <) f 4--; 4.;5 ; . ,> ,J, ut ¢ . wp ,Ys, ) Js

a;b;\ ljl; ¢<J \ ? i51 f ( ¢,)s X j;! 4>

Y Ms 4S > d;)t 4:_;C ; S9! 4 P f

, j _, 31 96 Y! L S' > ?; >

-+-a8 J-u 31 vS S*,¢ Ji ) 45JuS + &5ff!

] r J 5,<1 J > ( ,;1 ,>l z 1o Jl ) 1>1!; 91 M Q \ ( 9 jt ) Jm *

. [ D1

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

' ir! .s ou: cn-8J a: j! i t@8 tit : Js

jL! . ir! 9 i5W:, i r! > A8! i r! > ,Y8,

w J=, S t;:: JH ar f M! > A

s !JS S! ) M E- ;} v JS LZ \, +

,y ,_,t,t,-! < _,28-s 2!! (( 4sYz (

r!Y j>!,va; DU\;bkSY!^ .va

> 0,>sJ; - Jz ! >! ; gj ?; - Y, ^ Y

... oRlJS o,SS 9 ;JYSs i? iSz NiL\! o>;\

£ * A £ *A|r olgl8

,> N i R je\ )) e5,> 98 - S! siz Ss a t98 8

Jw 4o e3 e5998 oJ AiJ ; a; t i w ; zJs 3! 8 8 S! i_g38 ju! i J\Sz J 32 az Cs ?-Waz -S! a

8 *\xug_\ Ai - h L W \api i ;LEZ ¢<!; iu!\^JS J Coplz \v sH98 C\\ 38vYz S s S

e} s >! YYJ i 4> t yJ ; ( £^ )wz >< ° 6!;+ JK tc g; 1; /tz 8v tt; ;st;. Jts a 9!

JvAo Jg5s ;e t j >s + G59 ;8 w)i ej! vi )i is&-! sJiz i ;,4 ,- _>z ; Ji! ; 5JJ, alz ;,4, ; j8 .L! Y, Ls 3! ̂ Y

4 i_J$Jb 3!! ̂Lz ¢! #8 )) 3! Jq Sz S! 5Ji- 9-; ;i8

' j\ i?! > Y! ii;\ *! es Sb- _;iLZ 8 ,^ Jjj bG i (( 4;, o

e5jj is 3! J ! siz i548 >> a S- Y 419zJ _s,As : J ; ,5v;z S; ;,4 aj K >1z zw ; ^1z ;,4 >1z a

Jjj 40J i: i C jb YJ C\s > L 9 9! - $s _sz ?! l1 ;A Jj ej Zy _ . _Ls i t$S a! ^ - L A S!Uz \ a as \v ? yij . Jlsi i;r4 i/S! i 98 a1 tK > 6

; U SL8! Jj ;t_hlz r!- &5 t lSj J)8 9 ^- . LJZ i;,4 40 jz j:;Yz _>kw--8 juz t!} > 4g!

A £ /r MIAS;Iz

. tAs i;,4 tj (, \ ), Ji ̂ i A98 oSj Xz Ss!

: ^:;Jj ,J\ i;,4 j asj ' JYSZ 8JA * 98 J

VY

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

t M ,z, i J9l a tj w S i s .@

li Y J i Y XJi Ju1 k Q ... sy Y ,, jL1 k Q b; _ 3; J 8 < _ ;az 9 $t- 9 J+j yj i U1

ts!tt, ,)t > 4 yla 5Ai1 > v; A; * (( {LEl rsJ 4,t_

S S H bs 9 ? g tyz 1v S!S > Q1 \ Ob zb . J8jYI 1 a (, J>l ,, ji s>X1 cS wH

- > t= u1 + ; Gj v 3! sJ ,W1! 1! oYI

> 4_; U g e e jj ty1 1 a JAl Jf 83lJ ; 29l

> ^a,- ,3 J< ! ;_ t ̂y ; 5E * 1 a < < Ji vz 9 ; j !

@; $1 %91 ? LU) > 3! '' cbYl >), YYSI as, J Ju Jf o ;1 ;JW D!,! i 4,! 4,& ;1Jj S j!,! i 91 i59

. 9 Y S 3!

L5YI > , i 9,U1 J {I xd- y 3! i -A; D1S1 a s __t_1 J >1 Xj s! . oWZ z Hy y r !

; (( + a1 ,i 1JL A! i H as os OJi 1vv1 9 t) sp1

t?t;l . ^ - 4! zJj i ^ ; 91 998 ! 1 oS J

J 1> l;;aas k W

> )L Zlc 3! zi ;MLI ,, L+!; ¢y sly1 : J v ixi l<6 d! KJ ¢+! Ji H cj S! i;H H eJ s iXi ;; ty st SL 91 F S i! s S +s Ci '>i p' - oL; us Ji a-i ! y

E 4 T z X S; ,g,-i , ! li + , Ai Ci , jf ; $ s < , ,L;18 ¢Jisl , oS1 3! ! ,5;1y s ;, =- K1 Jli ( ;Ji sY ¢J Cy; 8 ;- + JL

A C/ % M1a;18

zlC 3! S s 1v g J< ' +1 Ni M 1 1 Dr!

;1_; -J I ̂ ^- YI Q wti l ia v! . ( £5 )! 4W: ? #_ oJ Wl (y f

Lc . i+ . e591 i \ 4 {% S > g tS }) 9 i J

8 8 ill iZJ ,_ iL8! ¢t; J ,Sa w9; JW v 4 5! Jfl b) ^- -' ill l0i Jt28 Q lXj tf;>! oAll Jlfi ,;R ;1 YI ,3

vr

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

§ C ^ , . X t.;

|r W - R V

\t f t \ s. 4 t ;

! t' ' S 8' S W-s dAS e X tt' X

X t w- \ 2 ts .X.

t K 9,X, i. Y 'Ale cb (_ ts C . | .g i,

* f d , (jb ez e

t 2$ z t < 8 r

W E E G S S ! )

< W F t R f it X t trb

t

We- ' *F

* ,; S Wf S

-

( -KS- G- K{/\ Ws

cL & od tW - E

sLi tA t - We q t

s. k t Gt -

> tr 6 t t ( >'f' tr L

R t t l t t. t. e

) a; W a h

_t, ,< _ t

< _r # _

drS [, <.

-to tt ¢

W dri-s WW

e k % * S t E: L. C S X _

E *F t % V >s

> e F tr F .W. f. > d v .e ,&.

W.R X,E

*F W g %, S f

W :.t t W W .f .C F ' t E R

tct- i- t-r < t; -

r. b. ,^ '} tc 9 '

c - tX G G - rb >- p -

G aft ss'

A- Lf - O k

f. _ z

> , b- '- -

a- Cb - W 'C,.

*C. WL .;

k ,9 *t' - F t^-r

>X.. t t- f. <.. < W

e (*

C; r C WJ *

° h- sC *1 s

S <_ : *r < _

t .t _ S t - 9 d WW C;

'^*c * - t

hvStu D

F ; t r trb C

i - -

> sh _ G

b- p- e w

v

e. .t. f '

* t<!

tC _

-

t . N.' _ S tE . W .t ;: W

_ ,

.. v (. .§ 2 \

X 'I

I s . .S b. r _

\t- t-

t- h sS! e _,.

- r v

F u. i- r f

q 9it R I 2

-

E s.-

-

.

.

¢ bJ .- B-

- (*

:t

t * v

.

e 9 * t- i - ^

s - -

L st

l

-

C 'u. X ^-

oW

?

,. i _

8 . W -

.

W. k . -

i, L * C

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

-; Z Xj, i 91 W xi Jlpz i

* _ kb C 8 ' 91

oA\/Y os

s , s s

,,L4>! J U 98! i s>91 s SL i AL C 8 N J W!

V=:Lz > siz >Ut A- XY $, i Jlpz A sA 8 o;1 XYSI * J9s 8 sH e jJa;)8 ,fs i Je ;z sS -s ji

,+ >3 J<Xz , _oLz zY wuz a21 5,yz JiJ

ZYz ,rz ? oJr *3 4 J;\ 1 S OJ-4J- >3 i5+\ uY, Cr * ( _8=! i. ^ ! O\ si ) zu i: a i, i o8JU siz oK - : ( Ot )

* . i_k zY a_ Z L

rvalr oS

i zz ¢ ; ; .^fizz + 0H z uz gz 0S! Sz s - \ 1--18 Xz Xz 0%! i M; Ou 6 ^! J,;8 1 % isuX ,5,pz S X a <;<! < ,38 ,, ,3 -t- >St l izi igi ie<! .-Ni Z i 1 L Wi 9 ( X Y o Ss i sH98 A O%Sz J Ni W s Sz Jl+1 ,,a§< 8 - Wz J - uEz tz ji ,+8 8 ? jj > 5 o!; az ,; dlli, ; uz a >^ 3! s- Y ( 8rJ 'ut 8 * 9)L wi O !; u898 J P -n

; 2vz Cu;8 ? tY28 S- J 5998 ! 9 98 uz SsXs a, t^>'S 16 s; Az J98 >8, J XYSz _8,8 > J s Di a Y

;>1 0 J ;1 ^- Nz e Sz \ 9 oLiu j! L 91 9 JH J SJ EJ! i;e >Lz 4 11Lz , L ovijlz

dJs S\ iLd Jl I I i- ar Ij Ji S

J i: s Js L \ > 3 liffl 91 vit

s 8 s! s, 9,jy cfflE J

oA\/Y Mu

vo

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

W jJ J "- J @Qz H es -A. - Ai O- A)t Di SN 2

ss @898 sz ;8j > l2 a ; ,5l 4> ;u! Q

JJi e3 aJ<> Ji J%,;% ,> ,rz JJ> X i ¢ i, 18 0J; i;+ owt1 ,3 aW> $sis>9zY!; >:J,:?aj,3u; 0Jy WY Js; gj X e >,; o i ;oJz l; Ju s! * a>8Jf 3

( ot )D ;: 6S a |! i s 4

;j;\

S a, Si P $s MA: z! 4- mu: f 83!

i i Y t;sz Js i - W: s S y j j s | f j f SJ ; ,tD tt , zvi vl_M: ob !1.-, a;! . ;JuJz + ;J!W dJ: + a ; J: s: 0, - t ! ; 48 JR ? >: ! 3! ib: o

- LiiJu ;_IYJ iso. : s 40 -o a: . \, ? oJ, * asl! 4o

YYSL Jv98 ! S v Ji ,j S aS! ' |A: o!

Wzj J ? ; sL J #: |JA: r ; o; Ji i 4@>Yz J> >= > $\ y IJ,¢ J:J fWhS ) sji3! .

- f -

; ,,: >3: ,3 a, ; , s ;< aJ ; :,: - 3 W! rj

J Ji 1e--s;! * J: ,pUt Jy8J; tuJ: Jlb! 298 isi; i;J8! S:!

4J; -N fYM ! i 4 AJ 98 J°! 3 J;- N k>;l a < !

°98 i)898 ;; Ji JiJ m! 3! i JsS: , 3 ,>: , t r- es6 Ji v16

> Y S: g: Wyis s! i z .j a j > f

@ . <8!; AN: 0+ s; og; sSi Ai J w:sJ Ss IW .|]Uz yy t}: t;;,- y 4,t, YYJ

; C, j%sL i :,08 ,3 , ,! 85;18 i ^ ^^ 3! );; s- - , > f )'!

g_! lSj Jj (1 ;>i J_AJ- ;J )JJ @lj28 2;J: s! J i Ji

* s ,; l! H | )a3!s ,9 t;! tAJ> H > YJ Z -°ti t-r S1a. >; ) S Xb4J! Lc ;re 3! t;); 3$> 8 LHi S. i ( r ) W5 JAAJ Z. Js 4Y G3 J5! i ( 5, ki, i b, ? l . r OL Ji vi # ,_,#> : J)AJ . ),- ,3 O\,> Jf * 98 J ;e | JH tIbal: i Jo i °| ,r° Z ] a S JS : ? s S > ,r-' Ji rli: f * g w; i ? Ni S C98 MJ '

V1

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

iS° . 49 2%Nz tY28 sJ i jz 98 *61 a %+" 8 -l

* JX8 J1 s5s" us28 J#8 J! otz;58 o iz Q i a 8 Ef Jlj sz u61 e C,Al J1 Az Cz tz u > r8 Q A Cusz J1 C28 l Of aiJ . -Cu9 Z U vs J1 A 48 >s UYwl8 {*;8 ft_l i;vx*+ ,, , ^ 8 P

s o W Oz s A a OlSz Oz @, Cliz aW Q iJ$y Of

Ps is<8 S a lvJ s olSz JF1 C); ltv> Ai PS ijiAz

S J H l> SJ . tYz lb o; Ho; O" Sz OWAL

z N"l | lj,_ zj Oll *61 Q lp zjr ij . u lrYZ . ^ oN , * P tz j1 p Y-! +l > JX z sj s 48 > ij; 1- P a;11 4r 998 Q y tSZ Bb J98 J1 4Wz Q 9 Y, 98 ,; tYS > w8 s 08 Y, 98 >8 Q MYSz >

Jzjs . 0z p 18 il; ns *> /J oS 8 iL 4"8 eN1 ;< J JJ9"

898 <l 4 O8J$y 91 9 ;. 4Sz >8J28 > O6.3k bU;l O8

*' Sz s sz w J1 j sz sl, Q tySz M s s ( or

Jt />Yz 4 Jz vlo < usY1 zz of ;8- tugl 0us,6 98 * 91 Cr Jz j

4 ^;18 ,,; 4"8> 2^ 98 JJ Z .^8 4Jjj * ,XYz 1 9 y ,28 < ; &Xz ,l 4"Gs

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

s zj fi - ; y . z l;u;; ;)1 1,sl J> 6,;;, oJ,>1 aus1 ,5, _ 8 ' zj yi rl; liv J8rl ;iudlj wtY1, ioul j os1 aii - 1 ! J* Q

. rov M s 85A1 s lJ! 1 s ;921

uo l | J1 4bf ; ;9W1 ° tW J; Q 9; 1 1 t1 t

. 8 A^£ * IJll vSl s iiJi a I s YI ,#JI bJL:1

* Cr 4 ? v M p1 /1NJ Jr Si 1 CJ>1 = >i- r

8 sVt * 4>1 WYI * ;9Wt * 6p1 19l 4 1 91 * 41 1 - £

* ( 8JI i48 )

sJ t-1JJ ,;s J1 t, Ss ,;s >T , J> ;J I+JA 11 ;;JWl >- o Jean Leveque O.C.D., Job et son Dieu: Essai d 'exSgese et de theologie biblique, Paris, J.Gabalda, 1970.

. ( 0 ,X0 ) T ; ,;s ;-- rvl IJI oz ? o 41< ;# SI+JI ozJ OiA 21 o11 {>i ; --11, ,91 ;,+T ,l! Q ;SJJI .SJi >> -

Jng isb isSti; -^ - < Jla> JJJJ liJ J>Jv! Sl; A! S>=C ;JAYI oz > f82, slxl Ju > . z ;wl | o1 9 ,>2l tn zj4Y,8 +aJI 1,

* $) J;4 'aW Q *_Y ;> *-1,! SJ ( \A1Y ) wNi wS Q

> l;l . o s ,lll s ;,zlall s bljll ¢ } bUt1 s ,fSJI ie>JI JS _ v qS ll WI *_ 8SL:ll ,;s IJI Jlyi 41 f Q e 41 J;ll J-i a 5f Q *p1

. vo:s ;L1 sJ,: ,0sl 91 Ox;; , . .$-, AlJ ,s1 -tF Jr J

, ,;I ,1,, ;,^X;11 s jWc! au"." b19l p st qf#i5' f ' @91 J . lo vo Y 9>j 81£ M * \51^

g;1 sc j s z oli:D i - JI XYI Jw I ,>} - J?CJ O@} 4,§JS ;J; OI,- 5

. tE,o Jo s ol*%ll ;*I;;i Q s -

Jo s 8 5£ s iVlI J8v s Js s JJYI ;*l s JzJI JiJI ;i>J s ,gf!WI zlc OlJ _ 8 .

. \A5_ \AX

. ssv M * r C,' . i,A,^11 oLII ZL, ;,L;11 * i,;91 1a11 ,Ic * il s J) i;e1 _ 8 8 . £ _ rr,fs; ; aLJs * Q l. Jl#l J'tJ _J1,J;*_ <=I_ \Y . sse,fs; sAve; oJJI 1X; ;,aWI; tZt3) * i$1s; ,)- sr I;S;JI 1; ee; J'lbS .0ej j 9jtiYS O.f) J!98 ,bs * ij;>t X sc iisls i 4,§vA;t-ill _ 8 £

. . X . ,,a,^11

* _ * X u isptsil *JpIJu.;;l u JlJr u fi9;iS t) j JijtiNS Oo*) ,98 8 MlYll 1_8 - 91 vc$)l Q jUl /%S;JI JLYI ) u zi et _ _ 8 o

tot,,0; 8 ̂r;; ,u11 WA; ;,21; ;8jYs .kots 4 .).ps Xio ; , * s

VA

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

. rsoO . z vl^: 1 ;JYI J,> ) * Ojflj OU} ,_ 81

. 8 . rO i rC . a rk; 0A1- 8 v

, ; , .,; 1,ml ,1,; ;,21 . ,9: ,eT ; azMz ¢is ,; abi . ,p5,91_ 8^

. \8Y?

. Yo u TC s/<| s *p1_ \5

- . Y _ ̂<,fs; 8 r; 1,jl ,1,; ;,^wl; , T . a-JA1 9 .k;t; >t1 _ T .

iA I o @t11 g o M: p:11 to j b1>^ <r1J_ Y

s 8 A° t s WI . ;sWI, 0 jJl )vXi dl jLyl -

. \ve?

JlYI Djl;: law of economy . 4AY*I aslJl ,, ol;, ,illl HjW , J> <I)_ TY

David Crystal, A Dictionary of Linguistib and; J9ill Djl;: law of redundanceJ Phonetics, Oxford, Basil Blackwdl, 2nd edition, 1986.

osJil }; rs J9i S; 49l wSl Q ;,^;JI 0z ^_z ij u ;,keS- sX^s l;,ljt S _ sr

4vvy b1 S ? ;s1 ob - . \558 iJJoI ,1, s;sWI sdo A )s j

*- @A1 )91 KL; }L rw *N t;Xt;l f s JJIJYI ;s w;c j%Y*I ;9S 4 ,¢ * r G . oi; ,f;l U1 s1 * , . a8JU ¢9 ,§ ob5j s pI 1) _ T t

. srs _ 8 T M

T Xul *> . oryl jWc! j ysJ os Q . { olgl jWl Q 1 ) . ,aG91_ to

- ; va .(;SU1 41) ,,1 ,1, .;<WI .¢s J9j

. Y vrt,fs s ,#1_ to

. ts0 _ ts t,fs; rC; Obi; ,4JXI _ sy

* Yn M u {D198 iWl Q 1) *Q;,11_ tA

. tyfifs i ,Sll- T

* ;:; 5^r ; awl iWl; 8 8z 4 ;J>; OJa rKl ; @z u 4x-- r. . T\8Gff

; ;,^w ;; . ;,^w; ,s Hi a;-, ;: r; aN 1 Ht . ,s,& ,^w _ r

* tA<Gff * \ 5YN

. 8 £<fio s 8 5£ s 1A1 * ;<liJI s 1 ) s jW;yl finj s qleAl XWIsc _ rY

. r.AM; b9z j%*! j a2t; ;91 _ rr

* r.A,fs * <e<18 bs31 § ,g,g-- ;t *91z ., ul a1* t _ r£

. oM . rC . Db521; /) jl_ ro

. l; ? Si;ll_ rE

50,,o . rC * ObjbJ * ifLf;ll _ rY

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

. srXtO . 5A0 . as ,1, . ;swl . ijdl , . ,@nz < .95 ;H1 _ ra , 8 ^,0 . J;t . ,5JYI ,;,* J,YI ;A . ,"48oJz 98 iS s z ,,s, , X,1M ) > J1^ _ r

. \n X,0,;SSs_ t.

"Le livre de lob", traduction oecumEnique de la Bible, P=is, Editions du Cerf, _ t 8 1982, pp. 991A996.

lean L*veque, Job et son Dieu, p. 122. Jo - 11 8z _ * X

S1 1z, . ;8 ,.ll .1 . . i e z l,;-^(, ) ;,L; - 11 liA Q fikL;; l;ii 9 91 ?_ tr

4Nz Q s os1 ;Jr Q >-i s1 i 19l Q ;1 ;^ r >- Y {; J j ) * ( slJI lil )

William Whedbee, "The Comedy of Job", Semeia: An E^perimental Journal 1) _ t t for Biblical Criticism, 7, 1977, pp 1-39 .

. T\oa . \E . o-l s 991_ t0

4i ,sl $ 1 s % J1t 98 0,;_1 u 42 Otl Q JS 4b ,s9j1 1>_ tn . Ore Q s,S,.j Qj Ai) s oT Q ;l

,;l .ffi1 ,1, . ;<w . z\ , s-t wS; > ,> Jsl .k- .R O8)- t t . vir-T<T o . \1Y s-J:i;11

.;toS8 ; tZ <} .S JYz ,;, .)t.:SJZ 4_-w *)>l 4. Q ;l @l Jfl_ za

;, kssl ,)>1 J;zj ,> 4^ &12nSi W ,>-ux ) { 1 ) ssAXl r i----8 >

. r C . wil - Jz; z lci z .)^98 , * 4. - N ¢^ll , Q ;> > ;,a, , . £ *^ o

, ( ljLI iafJJI ) s liL s ;sI;Jl, OJ,> t1 s Sl) oUz Q OlA Olb X, _ £ 5

TATo; TC; { opl r@ ? G ) Q * 85A

. £Y _ £Y-* \5A; ;lJbI 1 1J; oJ,>; _;l J-z j o * 4Hl _ o

-; sC,; owyz; >p1 _ O

. i P;l _ O Y

Lucien Goldmann, Pour une sociologie du roman, Paris, G^llimard, }964,p. 353. _ or

.

sp blot

^Y8) *-##) st 9fi#Ls S8, ,.;! Hjtj . v Szj Zi S! vjt f W! 4-i ut

. 8) Mj j W) ol) jZbj tj H

. or ,L

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

ity, g, @ gi, o ., ,1t <h , 9 9 4 iij 4 < @. ^) ! 4 j * l z. Se * bjjbj

. At:eWYI

s@,*) Vi o\.;;lj 2; i;, 4 b l-^^<i 4 . ^1 <J; sTj s1 sT 4) Jtu 5! wnT

* ig>-is>tj b b t) <

.^t_^r :iu.;Y

8 { lz . ol Ji 4) iStU ^! @ fi u °t;*) t;!; S Yj 4 , b*L ,;) ws}E ,;Y J ,s ) S tJ < +) ai 4 a

wsji 4! 1z -ieuo

tt _ t M

. 8 A^t * LJYI J>1 Q @A1 @1 ,1, >*l #8 6S1 #1 , @=1 w@1

Traduction cumenique de la Bible, comprenant l'Ancien et le Nouveau Testament, traduits

sur les textes originaux hebreu et grec, Paris, Editions du Cerf, 1982.

Job: The Soncino Boolcs of theBible, Hebrew text and English translation. With introduction

and Commentary. Editor Rev. Dr. A. Cohen, London, The Soncino Press, 1978.

tRsJ tt 418 r^fifi° ;e 5 vc 8 A as iv , o891 p; j ouss rW i As . AY o j1 5 t3 ?

s ,F, . 991 w) j 9,ys of J 9,98 s M oSl, Ay,

* @%*1 ,^LI ,os 48 i>21 iNd 1 ,# iN iN sp *^ >1 I LSi_ 8

5JYs 1 ;,1 ; i ,S1 ,w1; css J8<Ys v s1 Wi J>;X1 wS-+ , . s1 o1 >;1 . O1 - 4pG1

This content downloaded from 213.181.237.46 on Fri, 21 Mar 2014 15:55:12 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions