development of a user interface for design of so2 ... · department of chemical & natural gas...

1
COMSOL Conference 2015 Boston, MA October 7 - 9 P. L. Mills Department of Chemical & Natural Gas Engineering Texas A & M University - Kingsville Kingsville, TX, USA Development of a User Interface for Design of SO 2 Oxidation Fixed - Bed Reactors A. Nagaraj Department of Environmental Engineering Texas A & M University - Kingsville Kingsville, TX, USA SO 2 Oxidation Catalysts SO 2 Oxidation Convertor Sulfuric acid (H 2 SO 4 ) is a very important commodity chemical since a nation's sulfuric acid production is a good indicator of its industrial strength. A key reaction used to manufacture H 2 SO 4 involves the gas phase oxidation of SO 2 to SO 3 over solid catalysts. Development of improved catalysts with higher activities at lower temperatures that can convert future industrial process gas streams containing SO 2 to SO 3 at higher efficiencies is a challenge of increasing importance from both an environmental and practical process perspective. Typical SO 2 converter consists of four catalyst beds operated adiabatically with intercooling between beds. The staged operation is needed due to the equilibrium limitation of the reaction. Development of a plug-flow reactor (PFR) model is important for SO 2 oxidation because the PFR is an ideal reactor and thus it produces the maximum adiabatic temperature rise and conversion. The temperature and conversion values from a PFR model can be used as a reference for a non-ideal fixed-bed catalytic model. Introduction Develop a 1-D adiabatic plug flow reactor model for SO 2 oxidation reaction for all four passes for typical operating conditions using COMSOL Reaction Engineering Lab 3.5a. Develop a graphical user interface that allows end-users to study the effect of various design parameters on reactor performance. Illustrate how COMSOL can be used to minimize the effort on setting up the problem so that more time can be allocated on understanding the interaction of various multiphysics. Objectives 2 3 3 SO2 2 P O2 SO2 SO3 SO2 O2 1 K p K 1 414 . 22 K p p p - 1 p p k SO p r SO 2 Oxidation Kinetics: (Collina et al, 1971) 2 2 2 SO 0, t b SO SO GY M r X z Pmix b SO SO GC ) H (- r z T 2 2 Mass Balance * : Energy Balance * : T = 420 to 590 o C The 1-D adiabatic plug flow reactor model originally simulated using COMSOL Reaction Engineering Lab 3.5a was successfully recreated using COMSOL Application Builder. This allows end-users of the model simulation to study the effect of various system parameters on reactor performance as part of reactor design analysis. This application reduces the complexity involved in the COMSOL reactor model setup by end-users while also allowing flexibility in adding additional advanced features to the App as these are developed. 1 - D Adiabatic Plug Flow Reactor + Reference: Azizollah Nodehi, Mohammad Ali Mousavian.Chemical Engineering Technology, 2006. 29(1): p. 84-90. Transport - Kinetics Model Momentum Balance * : p b c g p 2 3 b b Re ) 1 ( 150 75 . 1 - 1 z P g d G Reaction Engineering Lab Model Model Setup Results COMSOL Application Results User Interface Model Application Results Panel Tabs Input Gas Temperature, SO 2 Conversion, Species Molar Ratio and Reaction Rate Profiles Reactor Bed Temperature Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result Reactant Conversions Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result Species Molar Ratios Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result Reaction Rate Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result Conclusions SO 2 O 2 SO 3 SO 2 Reactor Reactor Model SO 2 Conversion O 2 Conversion SO 2 Conversion O 2 Conversion Changing concentration A “plug” Direction of Axial Flow Next Volume Segment SO 3 O 2 SO 2 SO 3 O 2 SO 2 Excerpt from the Proceedings of the 2015 COMSOL Conference in Boston

Upload: others

Post on 29-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Development of a User Interface for Design of SO2 ... · Department of Chemical & Natural Gas Engineering Texas A & M University - Kingsville Kingsville, TX, USA Development of a

COMSOL Conference 2015Boston, MA October 7-9

P. L. Mills Department of Chemical & Natural Gas Engineering

Texas A & M University - Kingsville

Kingsville, TX, USA

Development of a User Interface for Designof SO2 Oxidation Fixed-Bed Reactors

A. NagarajDepartment of Environmental Engineering

Texas A & M University - Kingsville

Kingsville, TX, USA

SO2 Oxidation Catalysts SO2 Oxidation Convertor

Sulfuric acid (H2SO4) is a very important commodity chemical since a nation's sulfuric acid

production is a good indicator of its industrial strength. A key reaction used to manufacture

H2SO4 involves the gas phase oxidation of SO2 to SO3 over solid catalysts. Development of

improved catalysts with higher activities at lower temperatures that can convert future

industrial process gas streams containing SO2 to SO3 at higher efficiencies is a challenge of

increasing importance from both an environmental and practical process perspective. Typical

SO2 converter consists of four catalyst beds operated adiabatically with intercooling between

beds. The staged operation is needed due to the equilibrium limitation of the reaction.

Development of a plug-flow reactor (PFR) model is important for SO2 oxidation because the

PFR is an ideal reactor and thus it produces the maximum adiabatic temperature rise and

conversion. The temperature and conversion values from a PFR model can be used as a

reference for a non-ideal fixed-bed catalytic model.

Introduction

•Develop a 1-D adiabatic plug flow reactor model for SO2 oxidation reaction for all four passes

for typical operating conditions using COMSOL Reaction Engineering Lab 3.5a.

•Develop a graphical user interface that allows end-users to study the effect of various designparameters on reactor performance.

• Illustrate how COMSOL can be used to minimize the effort on setting up the problem so that

more time can be allocated on understanding the interaction of various multiphysics.

Objectives

233SO22

PO2SO2

SO3SO2O21

K p K 1414.22

K p p

p - 1 p p k

SOpr

SO2 Oxidation

Kinetics:

(Collina et al, 1971)

2

22

SO0,

tbSOSO

GY

Mr

X

z

Pmix

bSOSO

GC

)H(-r

z

T22

Mass Balance*:

Energy Balance*:

T = 420 to 590oC

• The 1-D adiabatic plug flow reactor model originally simulated using COMSOL Reaction Engineering Lab 3.5a was

successfully recreated using COMSOL Application Builder. This allows end-users of the model simulation to study

the effect of various system parameters on reactor performance as part of reactor design analysis.

• This application reduces the complexity involved in the COMSOL reactor model setup by end-users while also

allowing flexibility in adding additional advanced features to the App as these are developed.

1-D Adiabatic Plug Flow Reactor

+

Reference: Azizollah Nodehi, Mohammad Ali Mousavian.Chemical Engineering Technology,

2006. 29(1): p. 84-90.

Transport - Kinetics Model

Momentum Balance*:

p

b

cgp

2

3b

b

Re

)1(15075.1

-1

z

P

gd

G

Reaction Engineering Lab Model

Model Setup Results

COMSOL Application Results

User Interface Model Application

Results Panel

Tabs

Input

Gas Temperature, SO2 Conversion, Species Molar Ratio

and Reaction Rate Profiles

Reactor Bed Temperature

Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result

Reactant Conversions

Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result

Species Molar Ratios

Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result

Reaction Rate

Rxn Engg Lab Result COMSOL App Result

Conclusions

SO2

O2

SO3

SO2

Reactor

Reactor

ModelSO2 Conversion

O2 Conversion

SO2 Conversion

O2 Conversion

Changing concentrationA “plug”

Direction of

Axial Flow

Next Volume Segment

SO3

O2

SO2

SO3

O2

SO2

Excerpt from the Proceedings of the 2015 COMSOL Conference in Boston