design of an early warning flood level...

32
DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL INDICATOR (RESEARCH PAPER) DENNISE B. ALFARO GENETTE S. SOLIS KENNETH ROWEL REYES CAVITE NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL DIVISION OF CAVITE CITY REGION 4A- CALABARZON AN OFFICIAL ENTRY TO THE REGIONAL SCIENCE FAIR 2012 TEAM CATEGORY (APPLIED SCIENCE) CLUSTER 1 OCTOBER 2013

Upload: buidiep

Post on 27-Feb-2018

224 views

Category:

Documents


7 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL INDICATOR

(RESEARCH PAPER)

DENNISE B. ALFARO GENETTE S. SOLIS

KENNETH ROWEL REYES

CAVITE NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL DIVISION OF CAVITE CITY REGION 4A- CALABARZON

AN OFFICIAL ENTRY TO THE REGIONAL SCIENCE FAIR 2012

TEAM CATEGORY (APPLIED SCIENCE) CLUSTER 1

OCTOBER 2013

Page 2: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT i

INTRODUCTION 1

Background of the Study 1

Statement of the Problem 2

Significance of the Study 3

Scope and Limitations 4

Review of Literature 4

METHODOLOGY 8

Creation of the Base Part 8

Creation of the Siren System 9

Initial Testing of the Device 10

Testing of the Device on Actual Flood. 10

Testing the Buzzing Sound. 11

Development of a Flood Warning Guide. 11

Comparison of the Created Device to Commercially Available Flood Alarm

11

Data Analysis 12

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 14

Specification, Installation and Operation of the Flood Warning Device 14

Functionality of the Flood Warning Device 16

Buzzing Sound of the Flood Warning Device 18

Development of a Flood Warning Guide 19

Comparison of the Created Device to Commercially Available Flood Alarm

21

CONCLUSIONS 24

REFERENCES 26

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 29

Page 3: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

i

ALFARO, DENNISE B., GENETTE S. SOLIS AND KENNETH ROWEL REYES. Design of an Early Warning Flood Level Indicator. Research Paper for the Regional Science and Technology Fair (Cluster 1, Applied Science). October 2013. Cavite National High School, Cavite City, Region IVA- CALABARZON.

ABSTRACT

Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood water

level is the primary aim of the study. The device was developed using inexpensive and simple in structure materials. In order to provide early detection of water level rise, three different alarm systems were incorporated in the improvised equipment that detects 4-in, 8-in and 12-in increase in water level. Pilot testing of the device was done at flood prone areas of Cavite National High School. Test results from the prototype system showed that the flood alarm device achieved the design requirements. Also, the siren sound of the device can be heard up to 35 m away from the flood alarm. Using the increase in flood level measured, inside and outside the school, a flood warning system was developed as a guide for students, teachers and employees during flood events in the school vicinity.

Improvised flood alarm device is comparable to commercially available devices

in terms of providing real-time flood level alerts and sensitivity to water. This early warning flood indicator is one way of saving properties and keeping individuals safe during flood disasters. The simplicity and practicality of the equipment designed was considered for future replication and modification by household, school and barangay community frequently affected by coastal floods.

Page 4: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

INTRODUCTION

Background of the Study

Flood events are a part of nature which is caused by natural and human activities

such as heavy rainfall, coastal flooding, deforestation, poor farming, poor water

management, and population pressure. These causes the disasters which later on may

harm, if not, kill people especially if they are unaware of it beforehand. Bongolan et al.

(2010) stated that 80% of Metro Manila was covered in waters during rainy seasons that

in some parts were nearly two meters deep, considering that it is compared to a normal

August worth of rain which dumps on the city in 48 hours.

Cavite City is recurrently affected by flood because of heavy rainfall during

August and September with minimal rains on June, July and October. Due to widespread

flooding, Cavite was placed under a state of calamity last August 2013 with reports of

death and missing people (Mangosing and Sabillo, 2013). Schools, especially Cavite

National High School is more frequently dumped with flood water because it is located in

a low land area and because of this, classes are always interrupted if not, suspended.

Flood forecasting and warning is a prerequisite for successful mitigation of flood

damage. Also, preventive measures should be taken to reduce possible adverse effects of

floods on aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems, such as water and soil pollution. Its

effectiveness depends on the level of preparedness and correct response. The responsible

Page 5: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

2

authorities should provide timely and reliable flood warning, flood forecasting and

information (The Association of State Floodplain Managers, 2003).

Flood alarms are often used by people in detecting the level of water during rainy

seasons. Most of the flood alarms available in the market commend high price and

complex usage. To address such problem with the lack of early warning device for floods

in the community, this study is conducted to create a scrap-made flood alarm that is

cheaper and effective compared to the commercially introduced ones. The main

consideration is the simplicity of the device wherein anyone can simply use and

manipulate it.

Statement of the Problem

After conducting this study, it is expected that an early warning device that can

detect increase in flood water level rise will be developed. Furthermore, this study aims:

1. to create a flood alarm device from scrap materials;

2. to test the functionality of the device;

3. to determine how far the buzzing sound of the alarm reach;

4. to develop a flood warning system that can be used by the school in the future;

and

5. to compare the created flood alarm from existing commercial flood alarms.

Page 6: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

3

Significance of the Study

The use of flood alarm during rainy seasons is of great help in determining the

level of flood water and informing people of various levels of water in different land

areas. The created flood alarm can be used by the different members of the society:

Household. Families can build their own flood alarm for them to determine if

flood water is high enough to enter their houses.

Flood-prone areas. Areas that is usually damaged by flood can produce their own

alarm in order to develop their awareness especially if they already need to evacuate and

secure their protection.

School. Schools can build their own flood alarms in order for the students,

teachers and others to know if the flood water in their school is high for them to have a

suspension of classes.

Hydrologists. This study will be used as additional information about the

development of scrap-made flood alarm to be widely used in our country.

Page 7: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

4

Scope and Limitations

The study focuses on the creation of an alarm system for detecting increase in

flood water level. The sound produced by the device in the study is only limited to its

maximum range when tested.

The effectiveness of the device was assessed through placing it on flood prone

area in Cavite National High School. The device has three alarm systems that alarms

when the set level of water is reached such as 4-in, 8-in and 12-in. The study was

conducted from July until September 2013 at Cavite National High School, Cavite City.

Review of Literature

In most places, rainfall is likely to occur irregularly and in widely different

amounts from one time to another. As a result, the streams which carry the surface runoff

fluctuate greatly in the amount of water they carry. Thus, floods can be expected to occur

at intervals as a normal part of the cycle (Ramsey and Burckley, 1966).

McDaniel (2012) stated that floods are the second-most widespread natural

disaster on Earth. It happens when water overflows or soaks land that is normally dry.

There are few places on Earth where people don’t need to be concerned about flooding.

Generally, floods take hours or even days to develop, giving residents time to prepare

or evacuate. Sometimes, floods develop quickly and with little warning.

Page 8: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

5

Flooding may result from the volume of water within a body of water, such as

a river or lake, which overflows or breaks levees, with the result that some of the water

escapes its usual boundaries, or may be due to accumulation of rainwater on saturated

ground in an area flood. It can also arise from abnormal heavy precipitation, dam failures,

rapid snow melts, river blockages (Mwape, 2009).

Impacts of Flood Events. Floods are among the most dramatic forms of

interaction between man and its environment. They are always associated with heavy

loses of life and property, misery hardship disease and at times, famine. There are two

main causes of flood which are natural and man-made.

Some examples of natural causes are heavy rainfall and overflowing of river

banks which usually results to perennial flooding. Also, heavy rainfall accompanied by

flooding cannot only cause tremendous damage to buildings and homes, but also kill

woody and herbaceous plants (Devalsam, 2011).

Lu (2012) opined that significant amount of topsoil were removed from a large

area of farm land. Whereas some parts of the landscape have lost significant amounts of

topsoil both due to sheet erosion as rain falls on wet soils and heavy flooding. However,

the removal of topsoil is always a loss to agricultural productivity for topsoil is that part

of the soil horizon having higher level of organic matter and nutrients which generally

Page 9: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

6

has better structure. Some effects of flood caused by natural causes depend on rainfall

duration, heights of water level, topography, and use of flood plains.

The most significant impact of flooding arises from man-made causes like

urbanization because it involves deforestation, land use changes, temperature

modification of soil’s physical properties and structures and the exposure of bare soil

surfaces especially of construction sites all of which bring about changes in the

morphological and hydrological state of water (Khalekuzzaman, 2004).

Usage of Flood Alarm Systems. Among all natural disasters in the world, flooding

constitutes the most costly and prevalent. Simonovic (2012) opined that there are a lot of

strategies and methods nowadays used in addressing flood hazards and disasters. Flood

Alarm Systems or Flood Warning Systems (FWS) have been introduced in many

countries to minimize life and chattel losses by warning people in flood prone areas to

evacuate and protect their property, albeit some damage still occurs (Goodwin, 2012).

Molino (2002) stated that sirens are designed to provide a very rapid alert to

potentially threatened populations. They are currently the only reliable means of alerting

outdoor populations. Some sirens are used in making an effective FWS.

Furthermore, a local flood warning system helps in increasing lead time for

watches and warnings at locations subject to flood risk. The information can be used to

predict whether a flood is about to occur, when it will arrive, and how severe it will be.

Page 10: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

7

Organizations and individuals are given notice by the system so they can protect

themselves and their property.

Floods impact on both individuals and communities and have social, economic,

and environmental punishment. The consequences of floods, both negative and positive,

vary greatly depending on the location and scope of flooding, and the susceptibility and

value of the natural and constructed environments they affect. Floods can also traumatize

victims and their families for long periods of time. The loss of loved ones has deep

impacts, especially on children. Displacement from one's home, loss of property and

disruption to business and social affairs can cause continuing stress. For some people the

psychological impacts can be long lasting.

Page 11: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

8

METHODOLOGY

The procedures in creating and testing of the flood alarm device are as follows:

Creation of the Base Part. A base for the device was created using a used pail

covered with cement for additional weight. Three holes similar to the form of a five peso

coin was drilled on the base of the created cemented pail. A glue stick was used to attach

a 12-inch high wood vertically at the styro ball. Three styro ball sensors was created and

installed inside the base part of the device. It will serve as the improvised sensor for the

increase in flood water. Figure 1 shows the diagrammatical sketch of the device.

(a) (b)

Figure 1. Base part of the flood alarm device. (a) diagrammatical sketch of the base with the styro ball installed inside (b) actual base part of the flood alarm device.

Page 12: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

9

Creation of the Siren System. Three siren systems was created and attached on the

created base part of the device. The siren system will respond to the three different flood

water rise—4-inch, 8-inch and 12-inch. In creating the siren system, a 12-inch high PVC

pipe with 0.75 in diameter was housed inside a 3-in (diameter) PVC pipe which is 12

inches in height by cementing it. This will assure the wood’s passageway towards hitting

the button of the siren. The siren is connected to the pipe by means of its wires with its

button attached inside the hole made on the center top cover of the PVC pipe. The same

procedure was performed in creating the other two sirens with varying height of pipes

such as four and eight inches. The three siren systems were connected to a speaker which

is operated by eight 1.5-volts double A batteries attached on top of the PVC pipe.

(a) (b) Figure 2. Siren system of the flood alarm device. (a) diagrammatical sketch of the base

with the styro ball installed inside (b) actual base part of the flood alarm device.

Page 13: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

10

Initial Testing of the Device. The created flood alarm parts was assembled by

attaching the siren system on top of the cemented base part. Initial testing for the

functionality of the device was carried out under controlled condition. The assembled

device was placed inside a larger water container. Using running water from the faucet,

effectivity of the device in alarming at three different identified water levels was

determined.

Testing of the Device on Actual Flood. Once the three alarms are functioning at

the three different water levels during the initial testing, the device is now ready for

testing in the field. Actual testing of the device was done at Cavite National High School.

The device was installed outside the school vicinity reported to have the highest flood

water rise for the past few weeks. Aside from the identified location for the device

installation, three flood prone areas inside the school was determined.

Once the flood alarm device buzzed the first warning, 4-in water rise outside the

school, the increase in water level on the identified flood prone areas inside the school

was measured using a 12-in ruler. The same procedure was performed once the alarm

buzzed the second alarm (8-in water rise outside the school) and the third alarm (12-in

water rise outside the school). This testing was carried out three times at different dates.

The obtained measurements for the increase in flood water inside the school was used as

a reference in creating the flood warning system or guide for students, teachers and

school employees.

Page 14: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

11

Testing the Buzzing Sound. The buzzing sound of the device was assessed using

the following scale:

Verbal description Score

Not Heard (NH) = 1 Slightly Heard (SH) = 2 Faintly Heard (FH) = 3 Loudly Heard (LH) = 4

Three individuals assessed the buzzing sound of the device at three different

distances of the device from the respondents such as 15 m, 25 m, 35 m and 45 m.

Development of a Flood Warning Guide. A guide on the usage of the flood

warning system was developed for the use of the students, teachers and employees of the

school. The guide will introduce the users to the background of the flood alarm device

such as its purpose and usage. Using the data obtained from the actual testing, a flood

warning system guide was created including the following:

1. Flood condition outside the school

2. Flood condition inside the school

3. Appropriate student, teacher and employee response

Comparison of the Created Device to Commercially Available Flood Alarm.

Using the specifications of commercial flood detecting device published online, the

Page 15: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

12

created device was compared. Three main factors were considered such as real-time

water level alerts, power source and cost.

Data Analysis. Qualitative data obtained during the testing of the buzzing sound

was transformed and converted into a quantitative distribution. Mean was used for all the

obtained data in the three trials performed. Figure 3 summarizes the steps involved in

conducting the study.

Page 16: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

13

Figure 3. Summary of the procedures involved in the creation and testing of the flood

alarm device.

(a) Test for the Buzzing Sound (b) Development of a Flood Warning Guide (c) Comparison of the Created Device to

Commercially Available Flood Alarm (d) Data Analysis

(1) Creation of the base and siren system

(2) Assembling the device (3) Initial testing

(4) Actual testing of the device Chief E. Martin St.

Two-Storey Bldg.

Side of Science Bldg.

Quadrangle

Page 17: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

14

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Specification, Installation and Operation of the Flood Warning Device

The completed flood alarm device is composed of two parts—body and siren

system. The body is made of cemented pail with holes at the bottom for the entry of

water. Inside the body are three improvised sensors made of styro balls with wooden

sticks directly passing through the siren system. After several modifications done to the

body base of the device, it was observed that the greater the number of holes, the faster

the detection of flood water rise. From a single passageway of water, it was increased

into four. Table 1 summarizes the specification, installation and operation of the created

equipment. Figure 4 shows the complete form of the flood alarm device.

Table 1. Specification, installation and operation of the flood warning device.

Specifications

Body- cemented pail (16 in diameter and 12.5 in height)

Improvised sensor- styro ball (11 in circumference) with 12-in wooden stick Siren System- (a) three alarm systems housed in three PVC pipes (3-in diameter) of varying heights such as 4 in, 8 in and 12 in; (b) speaker; and (c) power source with eight 1.5-volts double A batteries

Installation The body and the siren system are installed outdoors. The speaker of the alarm may be installed indoors.

Operation

During heavy rain, once the styro sensor increased by 4 inches in height from the ground, indicative of 4-in water level rise, first buzzing sound will alarm due to the wood stick attached to the ball touching the button of the siren system. The same process happens as the other styro sensors increases by 8-in and 12-in, respectively, due to water level rise.

Page 18: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

15

Figure 4. Completed flood alarm device compared to the blueprint. (a) Speaker (b) Three siren systems for three different flood water levels (4 in, 8 in and 12 in). A button is attached on top of each pillar that will trigger the alarming sound. (c) Base part with four entry holes for water and inside are styro balls that serve as the improvised water level sensor.

(a)

(b)

(c)

Page 19: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

16

Functionality of the Flood Warning Device

The pilot testing of the device inside a large water container and running water

from the faucet showed that the created flood alarm device gives signal in varying rise in

water level. The three warning systems installed functioned properly.

On September 7, 2013, the device was installed near the school gate at Chief E.

Martin Street, Caridad, Cavite City wherein the highest flood water rise was observed for

the past few weeks. Three other flood prone areas inside the school were also determined

such as: (1) quadrangle in front of Gabaldon Building; (2) side of the Science Building;

and (3) entrance of the Two-Storey Building. Figure 5 is the map of the school including

the location where the device was installed and the flood prone areas monitored.

Figure 5. Map of Cavite National High School. Areas in red are the identified flood-prone areas. (a) Location of the flood warning device (b) Quadrangle in front of Gabaldon Building (c) Side of Science Building (d) Front of Two-storey Building.

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Page 20: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

17

Once the flood alarm device signaled the 4-inch water level rise outside the school, the

increase in height of the flood water in the three flood-prone areas inside the school were

measured. The same procedure was done when the alarm signaled the 8-inch and 12-inch

water level rise. The testing of the device was repeated on September 12 and September

15. Results are summarized in Table 2.

Table 2. Flood water levels inside and outside the school.

Flood Alarm Signal

Flood water level

outside the

school (in)

Flood water level inside the school (in)

Gabaldon Building Side of Science Building Two-Storey Building

1 2 3 Ave 1 2 3 Ave 1 2 3 Ave

1 4.00 2.50 2.60 2.80 2.63 1.00 1.20 1.25 1.15 1.20 1.20 1.50 1.30

2 8.00 3.70 4.40 4.40 4.17 1.50 2.70 2.90 2.37 1.50 2.50 3.40 2.47

3 12.00 4.80 5.90 7.80 6.17 3.30 5.20 6.60 5.03 4.35 4.25 4.90 4.50

Note: Trial 1- September 7, 2013; Trial 2- September 12, 2013; and Trial 3- September 15, 2013

From the testing done, the device responded based from its specifications. The

amount of rainfall, during the above date of testing, is enough to increase the water level

in the testing site up to 12 inches. The increase in water level outside the school has a

corresponding increase in water level on the flood-prone areas identified inside the

school. The highest recorded increase in water level inside the school was at the

Quadrangle in front of the Gabaldon Building last September 15, 2013 (7.80 inches high).

In the average, increase in water level on the side of Science Building (5.03 inches high)

and entrance of the Two-Storey Building (4.50 inches high) is lower compared to that in

Page 21: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

18

the Gabaldon Building (6.17 inches high). This recorded increase in the water level inside

the school is highly dependent on the amount of rainfall during the testing date.

Buzzing Sound of the Flood Warning Device

Three individuals went on various experimental ranges to test the buzzing sound

of the alarm. The buzzing sound results of the device were as follows: (SH= Slightly

Heard, FH= Faintly Heard, LH= Loudly Heard and NH= Not Heard). The verbal

description was given the following scores:

Verbal description Score

Not Heard (NH) = 1

Slightly Heard (SH) = 2

Faintly Heard (FH) = 3

Loudly Heard (LH) = 4

After getting the average of the three ratings for every experimental range, the

score was then translated using the following scale:

Scale Interpretation

3.25-4.00 = Loudly Heard 2.50-3.24 = Faintly Heard 1.75-2.49 = Slightly Heard 1.00-2.49 = Not Heard

The obtained scores were tallied and shown in Table 3.

Page 22: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

19

Table 3. Buzzing sound scale of the flood alarm system.

Distance of the respondent from the flood warning device

(m)

Buzzing sound rating of the respondents

Description 1 2 3 Average

15 4 4 4 4.00 Loudly Heard

25 4 3 4 3.67 Loudly Heard

35 3 3 1 2.33 Slightly Heard

45 1 1 1 1.00 Not Heard

On a distance of 15 m away from the alarm system, the average result is 4 which

mean that it is loudly heard. 25 m away has an average result of 3.67 which can also be

classified as loudly heard. 35 m away has an average result of 2.33 which is slightly

heard and 45 m away which has an average result of 1 which is not heard.

The buzzing sound of an alarm can be loudly heard if one is near the testing area.

In opposite, the chance of hearing its sound lessens because the distance is far from the

testing area (Association of State Floodplain Managers, 2003).

Development of a Flood Warning Guide

Using the data obtained from the testing done, a flood warning guide was

developed. Figure 6 shows the proposed warning system that will serve as a guide for

students, teachers and employees during heavy rains.

Page 23: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

Figure 6. Proposed flood warning systems for the students, teachers and employees during flood events. It includes description of the condition outside the school, inside the school and possible response for the flood scenario.

Page 24: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

21

The warning system is composed of two parts. The first part describes the water level

condition outside and inside the school while the second part provides possible actions

for the individuals inside the school.

The flood warning system suggests that as soon as the flood alarm device buzzed

on the first level, Chief E. Martin Street is already covered with water which is 4-in high.

Students are suggested not to pass by the gate on that street and use instead the Main

Gate along Garcia Street. However, students heading to their MAPEH classes at Montano

Hall Stadium should pass by Chief E. Martin. Students should be cautious on passing by

the flood area. On the other hand, condition of the water level inside the school is

described for every level of flood alarm signal. Suggested routes that the students,

teachers and employees may pass by are detailed. It must also taken into consideration

that the guide created is not providing information on amount of rainfall during the day.

Thus, the speed of increase in water level may vary according to how heavy or intense

the rain is.

Comparison of the Created Device to Commercially Available Flood Alarm

The created device was compared to commercial flood alarms available online.

Table 4 summarizes the key features of the created device and commercially available

device online.

Page 25: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

22

Table 4. Features of the created flood alarm device in comparison to commercial flood alarm.

Parameters Commercial Flood Alarm Improvised Flood Alarm

Provides real-time water level alerts yes yes

Sensitivity to water very sensitive

(once the water touches the alarm)

sensitive (once the wood touches the

button)

Buzzing sound beep siren

Controllable water level rise yes yes

Number of water level that can be detected one three

Power Source 3v battery 8 double a ( 1.5 volts) batteries

Cost 923 PhP – 7,000 PhP

(depending on the quality/ size of the device)

250 PhP

Source: ABUS Security Check Germany (http://www. philippines.rs-online.com/)

Both of the flood alarm devices compared provides real-time water level alerts.

Commercial flood warning device operates through an electronic sensor installed inside

which is very sensitive to water even in little amount. On the other hand, the improvised

flood warning device operates through a manually operated sensor using a styro ball

responding to the increase in water level. It is essential for a flood warning device to have

an effective way of informing the user of the water level in the testing sites. The

improvised flood warning device has this feature and the sound varies for every increase

in height of water in the testing site. Desired water level that the device can be detected

can be predetermined in the commercial device by adjusting its settings. On the other

Page 26: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

23

hand, the height that the improvised device can detect may be set by adjusting the length

of the PVC pipes and the wooden stick attached to the styro ball.

In terms of power source, commercial and improvised devices are both battery-

operated. It is a suggestion to include a solar panel to the flood warning device so that it

will be having a use during non-rainy days as energy storage. One disadvantage of this

device is its size. It is necessary that a strategic location should be identified for the

installation of it. Also, this device is only suggested to be used in areas wherein coastal

floods are the major cause of the increase in water level. This device is not yet tested in

areas wherein flashfloods happen wherein there is a stronger current and different water

type.

The major lead of the improvised device against the commercially available is its

cost. The cost of the device was spent on the siren however there are still options of using

the switches in electric fans as a connector for the three siren systems of the device. The

cost of creating this improvised flood warning device is less than half of the cost of the

commercial waning system.

As a summary, the improvised flood alarm device has the necessary features of an

effective early flood warning device which is of low cost and can easily be created by

common household.

Page 27: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

24

CONCLUSIONS

An early warning device that can detect increase in flood water level was created

using scrap materials. The flood warning device is designed to be an intelligent

equipment which is capable of providing real-time water level alerts such as 4-inch, 8-

inch and 12-inch increase in water height through a siren system. Functionality of the

device was tested at flood-prone areas in Cavite National High School, Cavite City. From

the testing done, the device responded based from its specifications. The amount of

rainfall, during the date of testing, is enough to increase the water level in the testing site

up to 12 inches. The increase in water level outside the school has a corresponding

increase in water level on the flood-prone areas identified inside the school. The highest

recorded increase in water level inside the school was at the Quadrangle in front of the

Gabaldon Building which is 7.80 inches high. In the average, increase in water level on

the side of Science Building (5.03 inches high) and entrance of the Two-Storey Building

(4.50 inches high) is lower compared to that in the Gabaldon Building (6.17 inches high).

This recorded increase in the water level inside the school is highly dependent on the

amount of rainfall during the testing date.

Since the device works through a siren system, strength of the buzzing sound

produced by the device was assessed. Based from the ratings done by three respondents,

the buzzing sound can be heard up to 35 m away from the device. It is suggested that

using a larger speaker unit for the siren system can increase the range of the buzzing

sound.

Page 28: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

25

Using the measurements obtained from the three trials of testing of the device

under actual flood condition, a flood warning system was designed. This flood warning

system will serve as a guide for the students, teachers and employees in cases that the

flood alarm device will signal first, second and third warning. The flood warning guide

includes description of the water level outside and inside of the school and suggested

response that the individuals may perform during the flood warning events.

The developed device was compared to commercially available flood alarm. The

improvised flood alarm device has the necessary features of an effective early flood

warning device such as real-time water level alerts, sensitivity to water level increase and

adjustable water level alert. The major lead of this device is its low cost.

One can improve the device by incorporating a wireless sensor network which

uses GPRS or SMS whenever flood water is rising. The locale can improve the device by

making it higher and larger so that whenever a huge flood occurs in the whole barangay

is conversant that the flood water level is rising.

Page 29: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

26

REFERENCES

BONGOLAN, V.P., F.C. BALLESTEROS, J.A.M. BANTING, A.M.Q. OLAES AND

C.R. AQUINO. 2010. Metaheuristics in flood disaster management and risk

assessment. Presented at 8th National Conference on Information Technology

Education. 20-23, October 2010.

DEVALSAM E, I., J. E. ATU,C. OKO, I. EKWOK. 2011. Flood and its impact on

farmland in Itigi, Abi Local Government Area, Cross river State, Nigeria.

International Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences 1(9): 98-104.

GOODWIN, R. AND S. KEODUANGSINE. 2012. An appropriate flood warning system

in the context of developing countries. International Journal of Innovation,

Management and Technology 3(3): 213-216.

KHALEQUZZAMAN M. D. 2009. Flood control in Bangladesh through best

management practices. Department of Geology and Physics Journal 3(7): 1-

13.

LU, J. AND K. WHITEHOUSE. 2007. Flash flooding: Exploiting the capture effects for

rapid flooding in wireless sensor networks. Department of Computer Science,

University of Virgina Journal 1(1): 1-9.

Page 30: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

27

MANGOSING, F. AND K.A. SABILLO. 2013. 5 province, key cities, other areas under

state of calamity- NDRRMC. < http://www.inquirer.net/philippine-election-

2013/ articles/ 471315> date accessed 28 August 2013.

MCDANIEL, M., E. SPROUT, D. BOUDREAU AND A. TURGEON. 2012. Flood.

<http://education.nationalgeographic.com> date accessed 17 August 2013.

MOLINO, B. 2002. Bells and whistles, belts and braces: designing an integrated flood

warning system for the Hawkesbury Nepean Valley. < http://www.ses.nsw.

gov.au/content/documents/pdf/research-papers/42898/Bells_and_whistles_

belts_and_braces_part_1.pdf> date accessed 17 August 2013.

MWAPE Y. P., 2009. An impact of floods on the socio-economic livelihoods of people:

A case study of Sikaunzwe community in Kazungula District of Zambia.

University of the Free State Faculty of Natural and Agricultural Sciences

Journal 1(1): 1-87.

NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION. 2012. Flood

Warning Systems Manual. NOAA’s National Weather Service 1(1): 1-21.

PREVENTION WEB. 2010. Philippines - Disaster Statistics.

<http://www.preventionweb.net> date accessed 17 August 2013.

Page 31: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

28

RAMSEY, W. AND R. BURCKLEY. 1966. Modern Earth Science. Quezon City: KEN

Inc.

SARUKKALIGE, R. AND MA, J. S. 2011. Urban Flood Control and Management - An

Integrated Approach. World Academy of Science, Engineering and

Technology. 1(3): 2036-2040.

SHIRKE, Y. KAWITKAR, R. AND BALAN, S. 2012. Fuzzy Based Flood Control

System with Prediction Using ANN for a Physical Hydraulic Model. ARPN

Journal of Science and Technology 2(4): 292-296.

SIMONOVIC, S.P.. 1999. Decision support systems for flood control management in the

Red River Basin.Canadian Water Resources Journal 24(3): 203-223.

THE ASSOCIATION OF STATE FLOODPLAIN MANAGERS. 2003. Best Practices

on Flood Prevention, Protection and Mitigation. <

http://www.floods.org/PDF/Intl_BestPractices_ EU_2004.pdf > date accessed

05 July 2013.

Page 32: DESIGN OF AN EARLY WARNING FLOOD LEVEL …teacherplant.weebly.com/uploads/5/0/9/1/50912219/_5__research... · Development of an early warning device that can detect increase in flood

29

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

We, the researchers, would like to articulate our deepest appreciation to all

individuals who helped us for the conduct of this study and the completion of this paper.

First and foremost, to the Creator who guided us throughout the completion of

this study. Second, to our parents who supported us financially and understood our tight

and hectic schedule in order to finish this study. Third, to our Research educator Mr.

Joald G. Calpo who has the outlook and the substance of a genius. He continually and

convincingly conveyed a spirit of adventure with regards to research and an enthusiasm

with regards to teaching. Without his supervision and persistent help, this study would

not be a success. Fourth, to all science teachers who gave and provided us ideas towards

the progress and development of our study. Lastly, our classmates and friends who

offered a helping hand during our most stressful times.