department of labor update: investigation preparation › resources › documents ›...
TRANSCRIPT
LOCKTON RETIREMENT SERVICES
Department of Labor Update: Investigation Preparation Samuel A. Henson, J.D.—Senior ERISA Counsel
2
ERISA is Complex
Simple WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
3
The “DOL”
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
4
DOL Field Offices
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
5
Our Goals Today
Why would the DOL investigate you?
What can you expect?
How can you prepare?
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
6
Who Does the DOL Examine?
Single Employer
Multi-Employer
Defined Benefit
Defined Contribution
Some 403b and 457 Plans
Welfare Plans
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
7
“Audit vs. Investigation”
A DOL “examination” may be referred to as:
Audit or Investigation
Your investigator or auditor may have a different expertise:
JD, CPA, or MBA
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
8
What Causes a DOL Examination?
No DOL Investigation is Random
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
9
Four Ways to Trigger an Investigation
Annual Report Form 5500 Red Flags and Questions
Participant Complaint
Service Provider Referral
DOL Targeting Initiatives
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
10
Annual Report Red Flags
Partnership/Joint Venture Interests
Administrative Expenses
Employer Securities
Personal Property
Real Property
Real Estate
Loans
“Other”
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
11
Compliance Questions
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
12
Service Provider Referrals
ERISA Co-Fiduciary Liability:
Knowing participation or concealment
Enabling a breach to occur
No reasonable steps taken to remedy situation
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
13
DOL Targeting Initiatives
Consultant Advisor Project
Health Benefits Security Project (MEWA Fraud)
Health Disclosures and Claims Issues
Settlor Fees Project
Employee Contributions Project
Recidivism
Abandoned Plans
Apprenticeship Plans WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
14
The Investigation
Stage 1—Appointment Letter
Stage 2—On-site Investigation
Stage 3—Compliance
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
15
Stage 1—The Appointment Letter
A Few Tips:
v Audit period is three years (maximum of six)
v Photo copies only
v Request receipt
v Organize to the appointment letter
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
18
Stage 2—The On-site Investigation
A Few Tips:
v Where to conduct it
v Who should be available
v How long will it take
v ERISA Counsel
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
19
What Not To Expect . . .
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
20
What To Expect . . .
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
21
If Two Investigators Show Up . . .
Ask why?
Ask if this is a criminal investigation?
Cease voluntary cooperation.
Immediately seek counsel.
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
22
Areas of Scrutiny
Corporate Governance/Plan Administration
Disclosure
Reporting
Bonding
Funding
Investment Selection/Monitoring/Fees
Service Providers Selection/Monitoring
Participant Loans
Contribution Testing
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
What The DOL Is Really Looking For . . .
Violations
Monetary Recovery
Criminal Cases
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
24
Stage 3—Compliance
Voluntary Compliance Letter (VCL)
Response
Negotiation
Action
Closing
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
25
Potential Penalties
Civil penalty for fiduciary breach 20% of the amount recovered
The DOL may waive the penalty for financial hardship or acting in good faith
Only issue penalties for:
Civil litigation
Formal settlements
Repeat offenders
Egregious situations
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
26
The IRS’ Role
DOL will refer to the IRS.
IRS will assess an excise tax.
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
27
Learn From the Experience
Examine your administrative practices.
Incorporate the DOL’s findings.
Don’t repeat mistakes.
Document your decisions, actions, and considerations.
Improve record keeping and retention.
Learn to “investigate” yourself.
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
28
Remember
Why the DOL investigates . . .
What the process involves . . .
Prepare yourself . . .
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012
29
Questions?
Samuel A. Henson, J.D.
Senior ERISA Counsel
Lockton Retirement Services
444 W 47th St., Suite 900
Kansas City, MO 64112
Tel: 816-751-2245
Mobile: 816-876-0159
E-mail: [email protected]
WP&BC SF Spring Conference • May 17, 2012